Latest / Human Interest Story / An Irishman's Suspicion
Transcript
- riverside copy of an irishman's suspicion human interest story: New Year's Day 1942 in Johnson County, Iowa, was one for the books. A blizzard had begun dumping almost two feet of snow on the state, followed by record breaking cold and bitter winds. Wartime rationing had begun after the United States was drawn into World War II after a sneak attack on Pearl Harbor on December 7, 1941. And a body was discovered on the property of my great aunt Loretta and her husband, Joe Barry. This is episode two in my human interest story An Irishman's Suspicion. By 1942, my family had been farming land in Johnson County, Iowa for 80 years. Loretta's grandfather, John, was part of the Irish labor force that helped build the Mississippi and Missouri Railroads that led to the establishment of Tanktown, which later became Oxford, Iowa. John used the money saved from working the railroad to purchase farmland in Oxford, where he and his wife Mary raised their nine children, including Loretta's dad. Loretta was the oldest of five and only daughter born to James and Nellie Mahoney Kennedy on September 5th, 1893. Loretta lived at home with her parents and was listed as either having no occupation or as being a servant from the respected 1920 and 1930 censuses. Iowa Public Marriage Records listed her as having married Joseph Leo Barry, also of Oxford, on April 19th, 1938. Joe Barry was the oldest of seven children. Born March 13, 1894, in Oxford to James and Margaret Folk Berry. Like Loretta, Joe grew up on a farm outside of Oxford and was listed as a laborer or farmhand in the census records of 1920 and 1930. After they married, Joe and Loretta lived on their own farm south of Oxford and raised hogs and cattle. They had a local hired hand that lived with them off and on, named Eddie B. Schmidt. On or about Friday, December 26, 1941, Eddie Schmidt disappeared. Or at least he stopped showing up around the farm. Loretta and Joe thought he'd gone to visit family for the holidays. One week later, on New Year's Day, Joe discovered Eddie's mangled corpse in the barn. It was a gruesome sight, according to the county attorney Edward Wright, who wrote about it in his memoir some 40 years later. The coroner, Dr. George P. Callahan, listed his death as a heart attack with a question mark. In an article in the Cedar Rapids Gazette from February 9th, 1942, Sheriff Preston Cozer said the decision had been based on the fact that Eddie had been complaining of heart trouble prior to his death. And the body had been so badly mangled by the livestock, it was difficult to tell if he had died of natural causes or unnatural causes. Two days later, his funeral was held at Barnstore Funeral Home in Oxford on the morning of January 3, 1942. Eddie was the second youngest of the late Henry and Martha Schmidt. Left to mourn him were five brothers and two sisters. He'd never been married. And spent most of his working life as a farmhand in the Oxford area. A few weeks later, Eddie's brother Carl contacted the Johnson County prosecutor to say that the family was dissatisfied by the claim of natural causes and demanded further investigation. So the county attorney decided to look further into Eddie's death. Five weeks after Eddie's body was discovered, on Thursday, February 4, 1942, investigators set by Edward Wright. knocked on the door of Loretta and Joe Barry. A search ensued, and according to the Criminal Investigation Division for the state of Iowa, the house was in such disarray that they thought some sort of tussle could have happened. In one corner of the kitchen there was a cock, and when the agents pulled back the blanket that covered it, they discovered a large stain which was perceived to be blood on the mattress. In the driveway leading up to the corn crib, they found a large amount of what a junior investigator thought to be blood. However, the other investigators disagreed. I'd mentioned earlier that there had been a blizzard around the time that Joe discovered Eddie's body in the barn on New Year's Day. Between Christmas Day 1941 and the day the criminal investigation division showed up at the berry farm, the region had experienced a historic blizzard and perilous Arctic deep freeze. A total of 20 inches of snow had fallen, at least a foot of that in Johnson County, and coupled with high winds. Temperatures had a daytime high of negative six degrees Fahrenheit with a nighttime low of negative twenty degrees Fahrenheit. Would a large amount of blood from Eddie B. Schmidt have been found in the driveway to the corn crib after a month of all that precipitation? Based on the records available, it was never tested to determine if it was actual blood, nor was the cot in the kitchen. The investigators arrested the berries that day and, quote, unceremoniously whisked them away, end quote, to a jail in Sigourney, Iowa, according to Rait's memoir. Sigourney, Iowa is 50 miles southwest of Oxford in Keokuk County, and it's not clear why they were taken there and not to the much larger, much closer Iowa City. Edward Waite wrote that the quote, officials at the time were unfamiliar with the term due process, and of course they never heard of the Miranda decision. And I'm afraid we violated a lot of the rules pertaining to civil rights when they interrogated the two persons who were held in jail, but without any information filed or warrants of arrest. End quote. They put Joe and Loretta together in a cell that was bugged with a listening device, hoping to overhear something incriminating. Coroner, Dr. Callahan, aggressively interrogated them according to rate. Yes, the coroner. Loretta and Joe seemed to be in a state of shock. And didn't provide anything usable to their jailers. At some point, a family member or a neighbor contacted defense lawyer A. C. Cahill, who sent one of his partners with a writ of habeas corpus, and the couple were transported north to Iowa City to appear before a judge. It wasn't until just after midnight on Saturday that they were able to locate a judge, and they were officially charged with first degree murder. Judge T. Fairchild refused bail to the couple. So who was Eddie B. Schmidt? Eddie's parents, Henry and Martha, were immigrants from Germany and arrived in Iowa around eighteen sixty three, first settling in the nearby German enclave of Homestead. They had nine children, Eddie being the second youngest, born on september twenty sixth, eighteen eighty nine. His younger brother, Glenn, died january ninth, nineteen two from diphtheria, according to the state of Iowa death records. Had this highly contagious bacterial disease also infected Eddie at the time when he was twelve years old, he could have suffered some long term effects, which can include damage to the heart. His mother passed away a few years later in 1906 at the age of 57, when Eddie was 16 years old. The oldest of the Schmidt siblings, Julius, was a traveling salesman and almost 20 years old when Eddie was born. John Schmidt followed, a livestock trader, and then Carl was born. In 1875, the one who raised the alarm on Eddie's demise. Anna Schmidt, born in 1878, was married to a railroad engineer. Next was Fred Schmidt, born in 1880, then Molly, followed by William, who was a superintendent of a steel mill in Des Moines. Fred Schmidt, who was the proprietor of a local bar in the town of Oxford called the Rockfront Tavern at 125 South Augusta Avenue, hosted big band live music from around the country. Until at least 1942. Its opening made the front page news of the Johnson County Democrat on July 19, 1934. Link and his Wanderers Orchestra was booked to play the opening on the second floor ballroom, and Jean Hanlon, tap dancer superb, would join in on the performance. As a side note, Fred Schmidt's daughter-in-law Vilda Saxton-Schmidt was the first cousin once removed to county prosecutor Edward Wright. Small towns. Eddie lived and worked as a farm laborer his entire life in the Oxford area, except for a stint in the Iowa National Guard during World War I, guarding the border between Mexico and the United States in Brownsville, Texas from potential raids from Pancho Villa. After World War I, Eddie returned to Oxford and worked in the area as a farmhand, generally residing with the family where he worked. In the 1925 Iowa Census, Eddie lived with and worked for an elderly couple. John German and his wife Catherine. In the 1930 census, Eddie resided with James and Nellie Kennedy and their daughter Loretta. Eddie remained living with the Kennedys for the next decade. Loretta eventually moved out of her parents' house when she married Joe Barry in 1938, and they set up their home on that farm southeast of Oxford. She was 44 when she married, practically one foot in the grave when it comes to settling down at that time. This was also Joe's first marriage, according to the marriage certificate filed with the state. Why didn't Loretta and Joe marry sooner? They'd both been a part of the Oxford community their entire lives. Members of the same parish, both of Irish extraction, in a small town where even at the local cemetery, the Protestants had a section separate from the Catholics until the late twentieth century. I hate hearing this phrase in genealogy. But this is or could be something we'll never know. It sounds so final. But unless we one day uncover a diary, Loretta wrote, we will indeed probably never know why they married so late. Sometime after the 1940 federal census was submitted, Eddie joined the Berries to help with the farm work. And according to everyone who knew all three of them, they all like to drink too much. This was noted in Edward Reit's memoir when the investigators spoke to the neighbors. This is also something I'd personally heard. Joe and Loretta were said to host poker parties at their house, and there was rumored to be unseemly behavior by those who attended. The original thinking around Eddie's death, that he had too much to drink, wandered out to the barn, had a heart attack, and died of that or exposure during the violent weather. Then the Schmidt family reached out to the county attorney, and Loretta and Joe's drinking habits became evidence before the grand jury. The supposedly ransacked household that the investigators found five weeks after Eddie's funeral seemed to speak more toward Loretta's housekeeping or lack thereof. Who commits a crime and then leaves the scene intact for over a month? Given the local talk that both berries like to drink too much could speak to something much more clinical with their behavior. Depression. Alcoholism. And then to move a bachelor farmhand who also liked to tiple into that situation and start hosting whiskey-laden parties seems like a terrible idea all around. Loretta and Joe sat in jail for a week before they were granted bail on February 14, 1942, at $12,500 each. That's approximately $250,000 each in 2026 dollars. Edward Wright wrote that he appeared before Judge Gaffney and broke down what had happened, and the state agents asked him to file a county attorney's information. That would have sent them to trial without a grand jury indictment. Judge Gaffney said, Quote, Ed, all you have here is an Irishman's suspicion and you'd better go a little slow. End quote. The grand jury was finally convened months later in early May 1942. Edward Wright called all the witnesses that they had interviewed and they made an elaborate record of what they had and what they did not have. Then, Edward Wright, county attorney, told the grand jury that in his opinion, they didn't have enough evidence to convict. But If more evidence were disclosed in the future, they could submit to another grand jury. And after five days of deliberation, the grand jury declined to return an indictment. He read a statement as follows The grand jury has given patient, impartial, and intelligent consideration to the testimony of the many witnesses exhibits in documentary evidence and the problems in connection therewith. Consideration of the public policy and fairness to all interested parties as well as the laws of the state of Iowa forbid the publication of the evidence. The judgment of the grand jury has been exercised in its report to the court. This report has been approved by the court, and the case must now be considered closed. What a complete waste of time. The investigators arrested the berries first and then they tried to find evidence to support the supposed crime. While the evidence and testimony that the grand jury were viewed was sealed, the newspaper reporting created fuel for lurid small town gossip. The photos on the front page of the local newspaper show Joe and Loretta covering their faces with their hands, hunched in their seats in the courtroom, the embodiment of shame and fear. The reporting on the convening of the grand jury, a full two months away, sounded like guilt was a foregone conclusion. And another side note, Loretta's name was misspelled throughout the entire reporting. Really has nothing to do with the case, but it's something that has been irritating throughout the research. The accusation and absolution of Joseph and Loretta Barry for the murder of Eddie B. Schmidt took its toll on the couple. Shortly before their exoneration by the grand jury, a notice in the Iowa City Press Citizens shows a transfer of property from Joe and Loretta to his brother James. They lost their farm and homestead. At least twice after that, Joe was arrested for drunk driving, as reported in the local papers. The first was September of 1943 when he was fined $150, about $3,000 in 2026, and 10 days in jail. Loretta was also arrested with him and fined $25. Although I don't know how a passenger in the seat of a car can be arrested for intoxication when the driver is being charged for OWI. In November of 1945, he was arrested for driving without headlights at night and being intoxicated. He pled guilty and was fined $500. or $10,000 in 2026. Joe and Loretta were living in Iowa City by that time. He was working for the University of Iowa hospitals as a janitor. She was a maid at the Van Meter Hotel. The small town of Oxford, where the rest of the Barry, Schmidt, and Kennedy families resided just 20 miles to the west, life moved on. World War II continued to rage, and the local headlines pivoted to news of local men and women who were called to the fight. Eddie's older brother Julius died just two weeks after the indictment was dropped. His brother Fred closed the Rockfront Tavern within a few years. Joe's father died about the time he and Loretta were transferring their land and home to his brother James R. Berry. Members of the three families crossed paths at St. Mary's Catholic Church, at the shops in town. They belonged to the ladies' auxiliary, and their children sat next to each other in the country schools. Loretta passed away in a nursing home in 1970 at the age of seventy six. Joe died three years later, also in a nursing home at the age of eighty. They're buried next to each other in Oxford Cemetery, on the Catholic side. Loretta wasn't mentioned much in family stories after that, except on the occasion of her association with the tragic death of Eddie B. Schmidt. And they didn't cut her any slack. She was guilty by association. Alcoholism was considered a moral weakness during that time period, and those who suffered from the disease were blamed for their condition. Unless there is a dust-covered box somewhere in a storage facility with the evidence presented in this case to the grand jury in May of 1942, that is all that is publicly available on the death of Eddie B. Schmidt and the exoneration of Joe and Loretta Barry. Were the couple complicit in Eddie's death? I honestly don't know. What I do know is that out of the 27,888 days of Loretta's life, this is all that she is remembered for. In my family. And that makes me sad. It's also tragic to think of the life of Eddie, as simple as it seemed on paper, came to a gruesome end in a freezing barn. And Joe Barry, who wrestled with an addiction to alcohol so severe that he lost his farm, his home, and lived out the rest of his life with the shock and horror of finding his hired hand and his friend dead in his barn surrounded by livestock. Imagine being defined in a family history by an incident that you had no control over. Every kindness that you extended, every tear that you ever dried was forgotten. Loretta went on with the next 28 years of her life after Eddie B. Schmidt's death and the accusations that followed. She and her husband's drinking problem didn't subside. The arrests that followed support that. Her family's frustration with her addiction was actualized by isolation and emotional banishment. In researching the information for the story, I was in touch with genealogist Kathleen Brandt from A3 Genealogy. Her team exhaustively searched sources, including contacting the law firms associated with A. C. Cahill, the Barrie's Defense Attorney, and the Johnson County Sheriff's Office, as well as the Johnson County Historical Society, the University of Iowa Law Library, and the Iowa Bar Association. Edward Reid's daughter graciously provided the few pages of his memoir. That revisited his perspective. Without his thoughts on the case, there was very little evidence on what happened other than a handful of newspaper articles and family lore. Before I read those comments, my assumption was that there was evidence of guilt, and that their ties to the community and through the upstanding reputation of their families had been given a pass. Now it seems to be the opposite. We should keep an open mind when it comes to stories of our infamous ancestors. That's it for today's human interest story.