Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / The Art of Impasse-Breaking in Mediation
Transcript
- 0:03I am Jeff Kravitz. I am the co -chair of the
- 0:06Beverly Hills Bar Association's ADR section.
- 0:11And we are thrilled today to be hosting Mr. David
- 0:15Hoffman. He is the John H. Watson, Jr. lecturer
- 0:20and law at the Harvard Law School, where he teaches
- 0:23three classes, most notably with the topic of
- 0:27mediation. He is an attorney. a mediator, an
- 0:32arbitrator, and founding member of the Boston
- 0:35Law Group collaborative, where he handles family,
- 0:39business, and employment, and other disputes.
- 0:42He is the past chair of the ABA committee on
- 0:46ADR, and is a distinguished fellow of the International
- 0:50Association affiliated with ADR. It is with that
- 0:55abbreviated introduction that I introduce David,
- 0:59a graduate of the Harvard Law School, magna cum
- 1:02laude. Thank you, sir, for joining us here today.
- 1:05You have the floor. Thank you. Pleasure to be
- 1:08here. Thank you for the lovely introduction.
- 1:11And I see there are about 100 people in the Zoom
- 1:15room. And I do know that some people watch this
- 1:19on recording, as I often listen to continuing
- 1:23education programs. So welcome, everybody, to
- 1:27this Zoom space. As you may know, you do have
- 1:30the opportunity to put questions in the Q &A,
- 1:34if you have any, and I'll try to get to the questions
- 1:38before the hour is over. I usually start with
- 1:42New Yorker cartoons because I find that they
- 1:46are a nice window into some of the things that
- 1:50frame our talk, such as thinking outside the
- 1:53box. So I'm going to be presenting some ideas
- 1:57that might feel like they're a little bit outside
- 1:59the box. And we in the mediation world, that's
- 2:05one of the superpowers that we aspire to is thinking
- 2:10outside the box, not only in terms of solutions,
- 2:13but also in terms of process. One other cartoon
- 2:17is about beginner's mind. So whenever we are
- 2:21learning something new, We aspire to the Buddhist
- 2:25concept of beginner's mind clearing out, or at
- 2:28least asking the judgy parts of our minds to
- 2:32take a step back and create some spaciousness.
- 2:36And as you may know from the materials in preparation
- 2:41for today's talk, I recently published a book
- 2:44with the American Bar Association called The
- 2:47Art of Impasse Breaking and Mediation. And so
- 2:49I'm going to be sharing the material. with you
- 2:52today that is in the book. The book's available
- 2:57through the ABA and otherwise. Also, we're putting
- 3:03in the chat, Suzanne is helping us with that,
- 3:09and in the materials for this course, an excerpt
- 3:13from the book that you can have for free as part
- 3:16of this event. The agenda is that I want to talk
- 3:22about some process interventions, some substantive
- 3:24interventions to break impasse, and then open
- 3:28the floor for Q &A. Before doing that, however,
- 3:32I want to share with you two things that are
- 3:35not in the book. One of them is a story, mediation
- 3:41story. It'll probably be in the second edition
- 3:44of the book whenever that happens. And I'm also
- 3:48going to give you a quick case example, because
- 3:51I think we can refer back to this case as I proceed
- 3:54through this one hour presentation. So let me
- 3:59start with a story. And the story is often referred
- 4:03to as the 18th camel. Some of you may know the
- 4:07story. It appears in Bill Urie's book Getting
- 4:11Past No. He also did a TED Talk in which he talked
- 4:14about it. And the story goes back to the 18th
- 4:18century. I'll give you the source for it in a
- 4:21minute. But let's start with what is the story
- 4:23of the 18th camel? Well, it has to do with an
- 4:26inheritance dispute. The parents died, their
- 4:30adult children, there were three adult children,
- 4:33inherited from their parents. The will says that
- 4:38the oldest of the three gets half the estate,
- 4:41and the middle child gets a third of the estate,
- 4:44and the youngest gets one ninth of the estate.
- 4:47The problem, their estate consists of 17 camels.
- 4:52And if you try to divide 17 camels in half or
- 4:55a third or ninth, that just doesn't work. So
- 4:58the solution is, of course, they hire a mediator.
- 5:03So the mediator arrives riding her own camel
- 5:07and she decides to donate her camel to the estate.
- 5:11So now the three siblings have 18 camels and
- 5:14the math works just great because the My slides
- 5:19just went completely berserk there. I'm not sure
- 5:22why. I think I have an overly sensitive touch
- 5:25pad or something. I got near the touch pad with
- 5:29my thumb and it went crazy. So they hire a mediator.
- 5:32The oldest now gets nine camels. Half of 18 is
- 5:35nine and middle child gets a third, which is
- 5:38six. And the youngest gets one ninth, which is
- 5:42two camels. Now, if you add up nine and six and
- 5:44two, you get 17 camels. And so... the three siblings,
- 5:51returned the mediator's camel to her, and everybody
- 5:55was happy. Now, if you're mathematically inclined,
- 5:59you might go to ChatGPT, as I did, to create
- 6:03a pie chart to see what the heck is going on
- 6:06with the 18th camel story. And what's going on
- 6:09is that if you divide up an estate, the whole
- 6:13circle is the estate, and give out a half and
- 6:18a third and a ninth, you haven't given out the
- 6:20whole estate. There's one 18th, about 5 .6 %
- 6:24of the estate that's not allocated under the
- 6:26will. And so the mediator figured out that if
- 6:30this surplus, this excess, that unallocated amount
- 6:34was allocated proportionally, the oldest child,
- 6:39instead of getting 50 % of the estate, would
- 6:41get 52 .9%. the middle child would get instead
- 6:46of a third 35 .3 percent and the youngest instead
- 6:49of getting 11 .1 percent would get 11 .8. So
- 6:52now all of the surplus has been distributed and
- 6:56there's a camel left over. So the story of the
- 7:0018th camel You can read about it in Wikipedia.
- 7:05The source, originally, the original source is
- 7:07Mullah Mohammed Mahdi Narraki, who was an Iranian
- 7:11philosopher of the 18th century. Or you can click
- 7:14on Bill Urie's TED Talk called The Walk from
- 7:18an ODS. And by the way, as you may know, the
- 7:23recording of this presentation will be available
- 7:26to you. So if you're worried about taking notes
- 7:28on all of this, you don't need to worry. So the
- 7:35essence of the story of the 18th camel is when
- 7:39mediators come along, One of our tasks is to
- 7:42see if we can identify some surplus value. And
- 7:46it may be the reduction of transaction costs.
- 7:48It may be an apology or some other kind of emotional
- 7:52exchange. It might be figuring out that there's
- 7:54an absent stakeholder and we need to enlarge
- 7:59the number of people. We'll get to that topic
- 8:01in just a moment. But I said I would share with
- 8:03you a case study, and I will. So this was from
- 8:06about a week and a half ago. a very simple case,
- 8:13not a terribly high stakes case, an employment
- 8:17termination of a chief financial officer. Now
- 8:21I've changed the identifying information to protect
- 8:24everyone's confidentiality. The CFO was terminated
- 8:28and the company that terminated him said they
- 8:32did it for cause and therefore they didn't need
- 8:35to pay him severance. But the CFO said that their
- 8:39claim, the employer's claim of cause was bogus.
- 8:43And he loyered up, filed a suit with a make whole
- 8:48demand of $321 ,000. And the company claiming
- 8:53that the CFO had been negligent in his duties
- 8:57filed a counterclaim. So they were seeking money
- 9:00and we had a pre -mediation Zoom call with the
- 9:04lawyers. Mediation begins at 9 .30 in the morning.
- 9:08And even though the plaintiff wanted to stick
- 9:10with their 321 number as their demand, by having
- 9:14a meeting among counsel, we determined they really
- 9:17needed to come up with a number that wasn't their
- 9:19grand slam home run number, but instead a lower
- 9:23number than that. And they proposed 250 and the
- 9:27defendant said, we'll drop our counterclaim and
- 9:30we'll pay $25 ,000. But they saw the plaintiff's
- 9:36case as being really bogus because they had very,
- 9:40very abundant evidence of the CFO's negligence,
- 9:46or so they said. And frankly, there wasn't that
- 9:49much debate about whether the CFO did a good
- 9:52job or not. That wasn't really the crux. The
- 9:54crux is whether they had crossed their t's and
- 9:56dotted their i's in terminating him for cause.
- 9:59And there was a good argument that they had failed
- 10:01to do that. So that's where the case rested.
- 10:05But the lawyers looked at these numbers and said,
- 10:07this is We've got a big distance to travel. And
- 10:11so plaintiff's counsel, I mentioned the possibility
- 10:14of range bargaining, and plaintiff's counsel
- 10:16thought that was a good idea and said they'd
- 10:19be willing to drop from 250 to 175 if the defendant
- 10:24would come up to 100. And you can imagine the
- 10:27defendant wasn't willing to do that. They proposed
- 10:30their own range, which is they would come up
- 10:32from 25 to 40 if the defendant, if the plaintiff
- 10:36would come down to 120 ,000. Now, very often
- 10:40in mediations that I'm involved in, this range
- 10:43bargaining will continue right to the end. And
- 10:46what's happening is the bookends are getting
- 10:48closer, even though no one has accepted the other
- 10:50side's range. But in this case, the plaintiff
- 10:54decided to go back to a number, fixed number,
- 10:58and said, well, we'll come down from 175 to 160.
- 11:04And the defendant made what I thought was a non
- 11:07-trivial jump from 40 to 70. And so now the bookends
- 11:11are getting closer, but the party started hitting
- 11:14the brakes. So now, and you'll see in a moment,
- 11:19we're going to reach a point of impasse because
- 11:21there's a move of 15 ,000 by the plaintiff and
- 11:24then a movement of 10 ,000 by the defendant and
- 11:28then a move of 7 ,500 by the plaintiff and then
- 11:31a move of $5 ,000 by the defendant. And so now
- 11:36we have a significant settlement gap, 52 ,500.
- 11:42But each side is hitting the brakes. And it doesn't
- 11:45look like the trajectory of these ever -reducing
- 11:51proposals, those lines are not going to cross.
- 11:54And so at that point, the plaintiff suggested,
- 11:58how about a mediator's proposal? And I had told
- 12:00them that I'm willing to do it if that's what
- 12:02they think would be, if we all agree that that
- 12:05would be expedient. And the defendant said, sure,
- 12:09let's do that. Now, those of you who have a calculator
- 12:12handy can probably guess what my mediator's proposal
- 12:16was. I would say in most cases where I'm doing
- 12:20a mediator's proposal, it's not smack dab in
- 12:22the middle. First of all, I want to gauge what
- 12:27constraints each side is under. And here there
- 12:33were several, which I'll explain in a minute.
- 12:38But what I concluded in this case was that each
- 12:41side had reached a point of resistance. For example,
- 12:46the defendant said, we will never get to $100
- 12:48,000. And the plaintiff told me, this is all
- 12:52privately, said, we'll never go below $120 ,000.
- 12:56So I knew that there was a very significant gap.
- 12:58Each side was dug in. And I made a proposal.
- 13:01privately to each side. That's how the process
- 13:03works. $112 ,250. And with it, I provided a case
- 13:11evaluation as to what I saw as the risk factors
- 13:15for each side in going forward to trial. And
- 13:18the ground rules for media's proposal are that
- 13:20each side responds privately and confidentially.
- 13:23And I don't report the response unless they have
- 13:26two yeses. And in this case, they did have two
- 13:29yeses. And so by 8 .30 in the evening, we had
- 13:32written up a memorandum of understanding and
- 13:34signed it. Now, I mentioned that there were constraints.
- 13:37Well, The defendant felt like they didn't want
- 13:40to pay any money at all because when they fired
- 13:44the CFO, they did it exactly according to instructions
- 13:47from their previous law firm. And they felt that
- 13:51if they were going to have to pay a settlement
- 13:53to get out of this case, their law firm should
- 13:56pick up the tab. And so in the middle of the
- 13:58mediation, I'm on a speakerphone with the defendant
- 14:03and the defendant's CEO. And she was talking
- 14:11with the lawyer representing her former law firm,
- 14:14her company's former law firm, and trying to
- 14:18round up some money from them. So we had a stakeholder
- 14:22on the defendant's side and the the insurer for
- 14:26the defendant's previous law firm. And on the
- 14:29plaintiff's side, we had a plaintiff's lawyer
- 14:31who was on a pure contingency. So he had a vested
- 14:35interest and the plaintiff had used a litigation
- 14:37funding firm to keep him going while he was pursuing
- 14:41the litigation. So we had approximately seven
- 14:44stakeholders in the case. And so that constrained
- 14:48this process a good deal and It meant that when
- 14:56we reached this point of impasse, we had a very
- 14:59delicate question of how much movement would
- 15:02each side accept. And I concluded that I should
- 15:06find the exact midpoint. And in this particular
- 15:09case, that worked. What you see here in gray
- 15:14or the times when I met, I had joint sessions
- 15:17with just the lawyers. I had only one joint session
- 15:20with the parties. There was no love lost here.
- 15:23The CEO didn't want to be in the same room with
- 15:25the terminated CFO. And I don't think he wanted
- 15:28to be in the same room with her. We did have
- 15:32one joint session at the very beginning, 18 separate
- 15:35caucus shuttle diplomacy sessions and four joint
- 15:40sessions with both attorneys together in my office.
- 15:44And I have found over the years, this is one
- 15:47of the most useful impasse breaking techniques.
- 15:51If the parties... If you don't think that a joint
- 15:53session with all hands on deck, all parties,
- 15:56all lawyers is going to be productive, and in
- 15:59many cases, it's not, having a meeting at least
- 16:02with the lawyers turns out to be quite useful.
- 16:05Now, here's my secret sauce. I bring to in -person
- 16:09mediations. Most of my mediations are on Zoom.
- 16:12But when I meet in person, as I did in this case,
- 16:15I bring my dog Bella. because even though the
- 16:19parties may dislike each other, nobody dislikes
- 16:23a golden retriever in my experience. And so long
- 16:25as I check in advance to make sure that there
- 16:28are no dog allergies or dog phobias, and I haven't
- 16:32had that yet, I bring Bella along and I have
- 16:38to say Bella's batting average is extraordinary.
- 16:43She's batting a thousand. Every single case,
- 16:47in which I've brought Bella to the mediation.
- 16:50And I only got her, right? She's a rescue from
- 16:53Serbia. I got her during the pandemic. And so
- 16:57I've only had her for a few years. But not only
- 17:01has she settled every single case that she's
- 17:03attended, but she works pro bono. if you catch
- 17:08my drift. So we always bring treats, people give
- 17:11her treats, and the oxytocin is flowing in both
- 17:13directions. I think that helps us settle the
- 17:15case. So with that as an introduction, the 18th
- 17:19camel, the case study, let's dive into some specific
- 17:24impasse breaking techniques in addition to the
- 17:27ones that I just mentioned in the case study.
- 17:30And the premise for this discussion is that The
- 17:36mediator has already done the basics. The mediator
- 17:39has heard the party's respective accounts of
- 17:41what happened, has explored their feelings about
- 17:43what happened, has elicited their underlying
- 17:45interests, has brainstormed options. And by the
- 17:50way, in the talk that follows, This is not just
- 17:53for mediators, it's also for lawyers who use
- 17:56mediation. So if you're counsel in a mediation,
- 18:00you want to make sure that the mediator has at
- 18:02least done all of these basics, including considering
- 18:06what's the alternative to a negotiated agreement
- 18:08and getting to yes, the book getting to yes,
- 18:12this is often described as BATNA, your best alternative
- 18:14to a negotiated agreement. In litigation matters,
- 18:19which are the majority of what I mediate, not
- 18:22mediate some other kinds of cases too, business,
- 18:27family cases. But usually in my cases, you're
- 18:33going to court if you don't settle. And therefore,
- 18:35the malatna, the most likely alternative to a
- 18:38negotiated agreement, is what's relevant. So
- 18:41all that's happened. and the parties are stuck.
- 18:45Now what? So the first thing to do, of course,
- 18:48is to diagnose the settlement barriers. Why hasn't
- 18:50the case settled? Is it some psychological or
- 18:53cognitive or emotional barrier? What is it? Well,
- 18:58it might be missing information. For example,
- 19:01in the case study I mentioned, we didn't know
- 19:05whether the plaintiff would be able to persuade
- 19:07the litigation funding firm to take a haircut.
- 19:13And sometime, I had one case recently where a
- 19:17couple, a married couple who owned a business
- 19:19together, didn't know what their tax liabilities
- 19:24were gonna be for the previous year and they
- 19:25had a very complicated business. And that was
- 19:28a missing piece of information. So we had to
- 19:31hit the pause button in the mediation until we
- 19:33could fill in that puzzle piece. It might be
- 19:37missing people. I've had cases where a critical
- 19:40stakeholder was absent. And I'll give you an
- 19:44example from a family case where a couple was
- 19:48trying to stay together and the husband, it was
- 19:51heterosexual marriage, the husband said, well,
- 19:54the real problem here is that my mother -in -law
- 19:56is bad mouthing me all the time to my wife. And
- 20:01so I asked the wife, Do you think your mom would
- 20:05be willing to participate in the mediation? She
- 20:07said, yeah, probably, but I don't need to be
- 20:10here. It's between them. So I said, husband,
- 20:13how about. a mediation session with just you
- 20:16and your mother -in -law. And he said, great.
- 20:19And so we found out that there's a particular
- 20:22bagel shop in Newton, Massachusetts that she
- 20:26particularly liked. And so we had our mediation
- 20:28session at the bagel shop. The bagels were terrific.
- 20:32And the mother -in -law and her son -in -law
- 20:36buried the hatchet. And the couple remains married,
- 20:39so far as I know. So we always have to do an
- 20:43assessment. even in commercial, whether it's
- 20:46commercial case, family case, are there some
- 20:48stakeholders who are missing? Let's say everybody
- 20:51is on deck, so to speak, everybody is in the
- 20:55mediation room, but there are some who don't
- 20:58get along very well with each other. In one of
- 21:06my commercial cases involving an ESOP, an employee
- 21:10stock ownership plan, the senior lawyers involved
- 21:15in the case couldn't stand each other. They didn't
- 21:17want to be in the same room. And the junior lawyers
- 21:19didn't really have enough gravitas or authority
- 21:22to settle the case. But each side had hired an
- 21:25expert witness who was very experienced, and
- 21:28the two experts knew each other. And at a certain
- 21:31point, it became clear that the two experts were
- 21:34going to be able to figure out a solution more
- 21:37readily than anybody else. So I always look if
- 21:40there's an impasse to see, are there certain
- 21:43people who could have a more productive conversation
- 21:46than others? I mentioned Bella. She could be
- 21:51one to change the players and bring Bella in.
- 21:55She has a web page on the Boston Law Collaborative
- 21:58website where we talk about not only her willingness
- 22:00to work pro bono, but also some articles about
- 22:04dog -assisted mediation. It's a whole thing.
- 22:07What about partial settlements? So the parties
- 22:10are an impasse, but there's some low -hanging
- 22:13fruit. Rating it up sometimes gives people hope.
- 22:18And so I find that coming up with a partial agreement
- 22:22often works. I don't know if you can hear in
- 22:24the background, but Bella is barking right now
- 22:27because she's guarding our house from, I think,
- 22:30a UPS driver. Sometimes the parties... could
- 22:35benefit from considering some other process,
- 22:39maybe arbitrating a portion of the case, or maybe
- 22:44litigating, bifurcating the case in some way
- 22:47and litigating part of it, or using some case
- 22:50evaluation, which we'll talk about in a moment.
- 22:53I found that when the parties reach an impasse,
- 22:56sometimes it's helpful to take a step back and
- 23:00hear where the parties have come from. I remember
- 23:04one case in which there was a whistleblower who
- 23:07had been terminated and the company thought that
- 23:11the ethical issues he raised were not genuine,
- 23:18not a real source of concern, but he kept filing
- 23:21these ethics issues with this company. And so
- 23:25I asked him because... we were really at a standstill
- 23:28in a negotiation. I asked him to tell me the
- 23:31story of his service in the Army. I saw on his
- 23:34resume he had been in the Army for 20 years and
- 23:36then he retired and went into the corporate world.
- 23:40And he told me this very moving story about how
- 23:44in the Army, he was very proud of his Army service,
- 23:47he loved being in the Army, that everybody turned
- 23:50square corners. because you had to, your life
- 23:53depended on it. You had to rely on people to
- 23:55follow the rules and follow the chain of command
- 23:58and so forth. And as he was waxing poetic about
- 24:03his military service, I saw the light bulb go
- 24:08on over his head. And he said to me, you know,
- 24:11I think I wound up in the wrong place. He said,
- 24:14you know, in the corporate world, it seems like
- 24:15anything goes. I really liked being in the military
- 24:19much better. And so whether it's stories that
- 24:23parties share with each other, and I have found
- 24:25that that's often very useful, or just stories
- 24:28they tell the mediator, when people feel deeply
- 24:31heard and seen and understood by our paying careful
- 24:36attention to their stories, it can sometimes
- 24:38unlock a an impasse because people are now emotionally
- 24:45better prepared. to settle the case. So, and
- 24:52if you can get the, even the lawyers may have
- 24:56humanizing stories to share. And one other kind
- 25:00of story, which is really powerful in my experience,
- 25:03is the mediator telling stories of settlements.
- 25:05So if you've had a case similar to the one that's
- 25:07in front of you, but you're uncomfortable making
- 25:09a proposal, you're not sure how it will be received,
- 25:13sometimes, explaining how you've seen other people
- 25:17resolve a similar case can provide with the social
- 25:22psychologists called social proof. In other words,
- 25:24other people have done this, maybe it makes sense
- 25:27for you to do it. Identifying possible trades.
- 25:32One side might have a concern about immediate
- 25:35money, the other might have a concern about long
- 25:38-term security, and they may be able to work
- 25:41out a deal that has certain contingent features
- 25:45in it. If you're dividing a marital estate, maybe
- 25:51one of the spouses doesn't want the private equities
- 25:56because they're kind of risky and wants the more
- 26:01secure stocks and bonds. And the other party
- 26:04really values the private equities because they
- 26:07have a lot of potential. And so in that kind
- 26:11of situation, both sides can be made better off.
- 26:14Instead of dividing the assets right down the
- 26:16middle, we give each party what they actually
- 26:21prefer. Metaphor is a really useful tool. Jose
- 26:27Ortega y Gossett said the metaphor is the most
- 26:30powerful tool known to humankind. And what you
- 26:34see on the screen is the image of a rear view
- 26:37mirror and a windshield in a car. And I sometimes
- 26:39say to people, you know, in mediation, I often
- 26:43say this early on, It's like driving a car in
- 26:48terms of how we relate to the past. You wouldn't
- 26:50wanna drive a car with no rear view mirror. So
- 26:52we are gonna spend some time talking about the
- 26:54past. But if the rear view mirror was as big
- 26:58as the windshield, we never get anywhere. So
- 27:00our main focus is gonna be the windshield, namely
- 27:04the future. Another metaphor when people get
- 27:08frustrated is whitewater rafting. It may feel
- 27:11like we're in the middle of turbulence right
- 27:14now, but there are smoother passages. And if
- 27:17you stay in the boat, your river guide has been
- 27:21down this river before, and I think we can get
- 27:24this done. And in divorce cases, when the parties
- 27:28are squabbling about the kids, I sometimes use
- 27:33the metaphor of parents being the co -pilots
- 27:36in the plane. So you want to keep the cockpit
- 27:39door closed. You don't want them overhearing
- 27:41conversations on the intercom. So you make sure
- 27:44the intercom's turned off. And just give them
- 27:46reassuring messages. And remember, the pilot
- 27:49and the co -pilot have to agree on the destination
- 27:52if the plane is going to be landed successfully.
- 27:56Food is often a great way to break an impasse.
- 28:00And I have found that getting the parties together
- 28:03for a meal, if we're stuck, it's very helpful
- 28:07to have a ground rule that says we're not going
- 28:09to talk about the case, talk about anything else
- 28:11under the sun. And that ritual of eating together
- 28:15can sometimes help us resolve a case. When you're
- 28:18really stuck, remember what Mahatma Gandhi said.
- 28:23Speak only when it improves upon the silence.
- 28:27Sometimes mediators need to just say, well, we
- 28:29seem to have reached an impasse. I wonder where
- 28:33we might go from here. And then just be comfortable
- 28:36sitting with the silence and see what people
- 28:39say. Taking a break can distract people from
- 28:46how frustrated they are with the other side.
- 28:49Eric Galton, who's a mediator in Texas, tells
- 28:51a great story of a CEO in a case, mediation case,
- 28:56being really stuck and with permission of everybody.
- 28:59Eric asked the CEO if he'd like to take a walk
- 29:02around the lake in Austin, Texas, where Eric
- 29:05practices. CEO said, sure. And they talked about
- 29:09everything under the sun. Not that much about
- 29:13the case. They came back and they settled the
- 29:15case. Sometimes you need to step out of the fire
- 29:19in order to douse the fire. Apology can be a
- 29:25hugely powerful impasse breaking technique. But
- 29:29the question is how to tee up an apology. And
- 29:31what I've found is that often asking the question,
- 29:34if you could roll back the videotape, is there
- 29:37something you would do differently? So for example,
- 29:39in the case study I shared earlier, the company
- 29:43probably would have been willing to say, wouldn't
- 29:46have made a difference to the plaintiff as it
- 29:48happens, but could have said, yes. We wish that
- 29:51we had handled the termination differently. Those
- 29:54kinds of statements can be made in a mediation
- 29:57if confidentiality and privilege are protected
- 30:00because they'll be inadmissible. But even with
- 30:03those protections, people are often very uncomfortable
- 30:07apologizing. However, if you can tee up a mutual
- 30:10apology, for example, the CEO could have, CFO
- 30:13could have said, you know, I wish I had handled
- 30:15some of my responsibilities differently than
- 30:18I did. I can sometimes tee up that mutual apology
- 30:23by asking each side if they'd be willing to share
- 30:27that with the other side if the other side is
- 30:30also willing to apologize. Case evaluation. Now,
- 30:35in the case study, I mentioned that I did case
- 30:37evaluation. The reason I did it was the defendant
- 30:40wanted to be able to take that case evaluation
- 30:43to their old law firm and to the old law firm's
- 30:47malpractice carrier. and counsel for the old
- 30:52law firm and say, we paid $112 ,250, and that
- 30:58was a reasonable settlement. So they want to
- 31:01protect their right to collect on their malpractice
- 31:04policy, the law firm's malpractice policy by
- 31:11refuting the argument that they overpaid to settle
- 31:15the case. That's not why case evaluation is usually
- 31:19used. Usually it's used to help the parties and
- 31:23the lawyers get a better sense of what's likely
- 31:25to happen if the case goes to trial. And when
- 31:28I do case evaluation, not always, but some of
- 31:31the time, I use a decision tree of the kind that
- 31:34you see here where you measure, where you predict
- 31:38what's the likely outcome of particular uncertainties
- 31:42in the case. This is an insurance case in which
- 31:45the potential recovery was $31 million. But because
- 31:50there was a 50 -50 issue of timely notice, There
- 31:55was also a big issue, a 90 -10 issue in my judgment
- 31:58about whether an exclusion applied and also an
- 32:02issue about how the damages would be valued.
- 32:06This was a case where there was a manufacturer
- 32:10who suffered a loss because of theft. If you
- 32:15roll back all these uncertainties, the litigation,
- 32:18the settlement value of the case was $822 ,000.
- 32:22So these kinds of decision trees help the case
- 32:26evaluator explain the reason for their judgment,
- 32:31their prediction of what a court might do. Now,
- 32:34case evaluation is often done by retired judges.
- 32:36So if you're a mediator or if you're a lawyer
- 32:39in a mediation, you might want to bring in an
- 32:41outside person. But often, the parties want the
- 32:45mediator's case evaluation. By the way, the American
- 32:50Bar Association recently issued formal opinion
- 32:52518, which says that it's okay for a mediator
- 32:57to offer an opinion about what a tribunal is
- 32:59likely to do. If you're a lawyer and therefore
- 33:05subject to the rules of legal ethics, you should
- 33:08not state or imply that a settlement is in a
- 33:10party's best interest, because that's up to their
- 33:12lawyer to give advice about. Now, your mileage
- 33:16may vary in other states. I don't know about
- 33:19California, but in Florida, there's a court rule
- 33:23that says the mediator should not offer case
- 33:26evaluation. So in that case, you might hire someone
- 33:29outside the mediation, like a retired judge.
- 33:32The use of hypothetical proposals. So I often
- 33:37will ask one side, if I can get the plaintiff
- 33:43down to 100, do you think that your side would
- 33:47come up to 100? And the answer might be yes or
- 33:50might be no, but it's useful to find out. I'm
- 33:53not asking them their bottom line. I'm asking
- 33:56them a question about a possibility. Or I might
- 34:03ask the plaintiff, if I can get the defendant
- 34:09up to $100 ,000, do you think you would be willing
- 34:13to settle? Now, I actually did ask questions
- 34:15like that in my case study case, and both sides
- 34:19said no. Well, that's okay. That's useful data.
- 34:24But sometimes the answer is yes, and then the
- 34:27mediator has information that can help settle
- 34:29the case. In Massachusetts, we had a judge named
- 34:35Joseph Toro, a great judge, passed away not too
- 34:39long ago. He was in the federal district court.
- 34:42And I watched him do this. I learned this technique
- 34:45from him. He would ask each side to write down
- 34:48on a piece of paper their absolute last best
- 34:52offer and provide it to the judge confidentially.
- 34:56And he would do this even in a bench trial situation
- 35:01and of course also in jury trials. And after
- 35:05he looked at each side's confidential last best
- 35:09offer, he would then tell them whether they should,
- 35:12you know, we should schedule a trial or instead
- 35:15go out in the hall and see if you can settle
- 35:16it. I have found that when I use this technique,
- 35:21after writing down the last best offer, the lawyers
- 35:23will very often say something like the following,
- 35:26I'll show you mine if you show me yours. And
- 35:30when they open up those pieces of paper, now
- 35:32the bookends have moved very dramatically closer
- 35:36together. And now we get to Amir's proposal.
- 35:43So I want to... dwell on this for a minute because
- 35:47it's a very useful technique, not only in international
- 35:51diplomacy, as you can see with President Carter
- 35:54after the Camp David talks, but it's extremely
- 35:56useful in commercial and even family and employment
- 36:05and other kinds of. cases. So as a definition,
- 36:09case evaluation is a prediction of what the court
- 36:11will do. Mediator's proposal is a prediction
- 36:14of what the parties will do. And the ground rules,
- 36:17and I'm guessing many people, if not most in
- 36:20the Zoom room, are familiar with these ground
- 36:23rules, but I think it's worth mentioning them.
- 36:28The mediator, first of all, all parties must
- 36:31want the mediator's proposal. And as a mediator,
- 36:36I asked the parties what else should be in it.
- 36:38So for example, in the mediator's proposal that
- 36:41I made in the case study, there were bullet points
- 36:45for non -disparagement, confidentiality of the
- 36:48settlement terms. There was already in the employment
- 36:51agreement a durable obligation of non -solicitation
- 36:55and non -disclosure. of proprietary information.
- 37:00There was going to be a stipulation of dismissal
- 37:03without prejudice and no admission of liability.
- 37:05Those were the non -monetary terms. Oh, and also
- 37:08that the tax treatment would be ordinary income,
- 37:12except the money going directly to counsel. So
- 37:16all of that was settled. All I had to do was
- 37:19fill in the blank, which was the number. So I
- 37:23make the same proposal in this case. I did it
- 37:25in writing I printed it out brought it into both
- 37:27rooms And I asked the parties not to respond
- 37:30right away while I was in the room I wanted them
- 37:32to have a chance to talk about it because when
- 37:35I went in the other room I wanted to be able
- 37:37to say I don't know how the other side is going
- 37:41to respond And after each side's ready, they
- 37:44send me a text message, and I come back into
- 37:46the conference room. They've had a chance to
- 37:49think about it. When I come back, they tell me
- 37:52either yes or no. And sometimes they come back
- 37:56and they say, no, but. That's still a no. Although
- 38:02the but, if they say no, but, we would be willing
- 38:05to do x. very useful information, I'm going to
- 38:09keep that to myself. So I report if there are
- 38:12two yeses. Now, what I've found is that in 80
- 38:16% of the cases that I do, there are two yeses.
- 38:22In 10 % of the cases, there's a yes and a no.
- 38:25And in another 10%, It's getting lower nowadays.
- 38:30It might be closer to 5%. But in 5 % to 10%,
- 38:33there are two no's. Those are the cases that
- 38:36are really hard to settle. The ones where there's
- 38:38a yes and a no, those cases almost always settle
- 38:41because the party that said yes is usually willing
- 38:44to disclose that. So I won't... Well, okay, I
- 38:50will give you a sample case for media's proposal.
- 38:52Plaintiff has demanded $6 .5 million. The defendant
- 38:56is offered $250 ,000. And by the end of the day,
- 39:00the parties are stuck at $2 million and $1 million.
- 39:04And they want a mediator's proposal. So I show
- 39:08them these slides, actually, and I did in the
- 39:13case study I mentioned earlier. And what the
- 39:15slides do is they illustrate how does a mediator
- 39:19decide. what the proposal is. So I explained
- 39:23that I know 100 % certainty that the plaintiff
- 39:28would settle at $2 million and I know with 100
- 39:31% certainty that the defendant would be willing
- 39:33to settle at $1 million. I also know that there's
- 39:36zero chance that the defendant would settle at
- 39:41$2 million and zero percent chance that the plaintiff
- 39:44would settle at $1 million. So between the polls
- 39:47of $1 million here and $2 million here, Where
- 39:50do these lines of resistance cross? Where is
- 39:54the spot where if you go to the left or you go
- 39:57to the right, you're reducing the overall chance
- 40:00of a settlement? And the answer to that question
- 40:03might be smack dab in the middle, as it was in
- 40:06the case study, but it's not always. It might
- 40:08be over here closer to the defendant. It might
- 40:11be over here closer to the plaintiff. We just
- 40:13don't know. And indeed, there might be no zone
- 40:16of possible agreement at all. So I show people
- 40:20these slides and say this is how I do it. I try
- 40:24to discern where's the crossover point and in
- 40:28this hypothetical case, let's say I proposed
- 40:30$1 .4 million, I thought that's where the lines
- 40:33cross and let's say the case settled. So we're
- 40:41in the homestretch here and then I'm gonna open
- 40:43the floor for Q &A. So range bargaining, I illustrated
- 40:47that earlier with the case study. It's basically
- 40:49parties proposing a range instead of a number.
- 40:53Contingencies can be our friend, Plan A or Plan
- 40:58B. And that could happen in the case of an earn
- 41:05out. For example, let's say the... the CFO, actually
- 41:10the CFO had some stock in the company and we
- 41:13didn't actually negotiate any resolution of that.
- 41:16He left with stock in hand, but we could have
- 41:20had a contingency that would have involved some
- 41:23profit sharing or earn out based on the shares
- 41:27and he would have relinquished the shares. If
- 41:30there's concern about liability, For example,
- 41:35if the company is afraid they're going to get
- 41:37sued for some of the mistakes the CFO made, there
- 41:40could be indemnification. That would be a contingency.
- 41:43There could be tax sharing if there's uncertainty
- 41:46as to how a settlement will be taxed. Sometimes
- 41:49in cases where property or a business is being
- 41:52purchase, there might be an inspection or financing
- 41:55contingency or an appraisal contingency. Or if
- 41:59somebody wants to buy back the business or real
- 42:01estate, there might be a right of first refusal.
- 42:05Dual or multiple offers. So this is one of my
- 42:07favorites actually. Let's say the plaintiff coming
- 42:15in in my case study at 250 ,000 is concerned
- 42:19that the defendant will experience sticker shock.
- 42:23What the plaintiff can do is say, I'll tell you
- 42:25what, if you accept 250 as a settlement, that's
- 42:28fine. But if not, we're willing to share in the
- 42:32cost of an external case evaluation, retired
- 42:35judge, because we believe that the fair and reasonable
- 42:40value of the case is 250. And generally, the
- 42:44other side rejects the both prongs of the dual
- 42:48offer, either 250 or case evaluation, but it
- 42:53adds credibility for one side or the other to
- 42:57say we're willing to do either one, non -binding
- 43:01case evaluation or our number. Sometimes when
- 43:05Both parties want a piece of real estate or other
- 43:08belongings. An auction can be useful. And it
- 43:12could either be an internal auction or the property
- 43:15or business can be put on the market. When it's
- 43:17put on the market, you're going to get higher
- 43:19value, usually. In an internal auction, you've
- 43:23protected confidentiality and privacy, but maybe
- 43:27limited the amount of money available for the
- 43:30purpose of the purchase. And then there's this
- 43:34really cool technique. If anyone in the Zoom
- 43:37room does matrimonial work, maybe you even use
- 43:42this. It's called the adjusted winner auction.
- 43:45So each side, each spouse picks out, you list
- 43:50the items and each side has a bidding sheet.
- 43:53And they do this privately, separately. And let's
- 43:58say there's a piano. and painting and some other
- 44:02items. And so spouse A really values the piano
- 44:06and is willing to pay 5 ,000 for it. Spouse B
- 44:09doesn't really care that much about the piano,
- 44:11but knows that it has some value. So they put
- 44:14on their bidding sheet 2 ,000. And I've had cases
- 44:17where they had 20, 30, 40 items. in the adjusted
- 44:21winner auction sheet. And the cool thing about
- 44:24the process is that the higher bidder gets the
- 44:28item, but gets it at the average of the two prices.
- 44:33So spouse A, who wants the piano, is getting
- 44:36it for $3 ,500, and they think they got a deal.
- 44:39Whereas spouse B is going to get half the value
- 44:42of that $3 ,500, which is more than they thought
- 44:46they would get because they thought the piano
- 44:48was only worth $2 ,000. Joint experts and appraisals.
- 44:53So when the parties are stuck at impasse over
- 44:56the value of a business real estate or other
- 44:59property, often we talk about getting a non -binding
- 45:03appraisal, but there are disadvantages to that
- 45:07because people want finality. So I've come up
- 45:09with this three appraisal protocol, three -step
- 45:11protocol that has worked every time. And the
- 45:17way it works is the parties jointly hire an appraiser,
- 45:21and they agree in advance they're not going to
- 45:23privately lobby the appraiser. All communications
- 45:25will be in writing, no ex parte communications.
- 45:29And after they get this non -binding joint appraisal,
- 45:32they negotiate, and maybe they agree on the value.
- 45:35But if they don't, they jointly hire a second
- 45:38appraiser. and then they negotiate and see if
- 45:41they can arrive at a value. And if they can't,
- 45:46then they go to step three where they jointly
- 45:48hire a third appraiser and then they're done
- 45:51because they've signed an agreement that the
- 45:55value of the property will be the average of
- 45:58the three and they're bound by it. And I've only
- 46:02had one case where the parties ever got to step
- 46:04three, because for the most part, they don't
- 46:07want the decision taken out of their hands. Also,
- 46:11we have a provision that says if any one of the
- 46:13three appraisals is an outlier, meaning, let's
- 46:16say, more than 15 % different from the average
- 46:18of the other two, we ignore the outlier, average
- 46:21the other two, and that's binding. And because
- 46:24it's mathematically possible that there are two
- 46:26outliers, the parties will reject the appraisal
- 46:32that's more of an outlier than the other and
- 46:35average the other two. So there are many other
- 46:40parts of this book. You will have in your materials
- 46:44the heart of the book, but these are some of
- 46:47the other parts, the ones I listed on the screen.
- 46:51And with that, I'm going to stop the screen share
- 46:53because we have about 13 minutes and I want to
- 46:58open the floor for any questions. I'm going to
- 47:02look in the chat and see if there are any more.
- 47:07Suzanne, if you have any questions, please let
- 47:11me know. Yeah, so we do have some questions in
- 47:14the Q &A. One is mentioning another mediator
- 47:17who thinks that mediator proposals are problematic
- 47:20because they necessarily favor one side and demonstrate
- 47:23bias. There was an article on that that other
- 47:27speaker wrote. What do you think on that? Does
- 47:29AB 518 prohibit mediators proposals? Yeah, I
- 47:35know the article. Jeff Kitchhaven and Jeff is
- 47:39a good friend and I have enormous respect for
- 47:42Jeff. I disagree with him about this and there's
- 47:45a lot if anyone wants to Google. ABA formal opinion
- 47:49518 and put Jeff's name in there, you'll find
- 47:53that there's a robust discussion online. And
- 47:58I think there's nothing, first of all, there's
- 48:01nothing unethical about doing case evaluation.
- 48:04And if you say to the parties in advance, you
- 48:08ask them, do you want a mediator's proposal?
- 48:10And they say, yes. Then what you say to them
- 48:14is, okay, media's proposal is different from
- 48:17case evaluation. I'm not predicting what the
- 48:19court will do. I'm predicting where the point
- 48:21of resistance and settlement is for each side,
- 48:24because I've had private discussions with each
- 48:26side. And I could be wrong. It happens. But I'm
- 48:33going to give you my best guess of where there's
- 48:35a zone of possible agreement. And it might be
- 48:37over here. It might be over here. It might be
- 48:41in the middle. And I'm not going to tell you.
- 48:44because the ABA opinion says lawyer mediators
- 48:47shouldn't tell you that it's in your best interest.
- 48:49So I'm not going to tell you that. I'm simply
- 48:51going to tell you where I think the two sides
- 48:55might be willing to settle, whether I think it's
- 48:58in your best interest or not. And if it works,
- 49:02then my prediction was accurate. If it didn't
- 49:04work, then let's go back to the bargaining table
- 49:06and see if we can get this done. So, Jeff, if
- 49:12you're out there listening, I welcome the chance
- 49:15to talk with you about this sometime. And whoever
- 49:21asked the question, thank you. Great question.
- 49:25All right, you have another question here. Do
- 49:27you think it is appropriate for parties to characterize
- 49:29a settlement as ordinary income, essentially
- 49:32giving them a tax win, which may or may not be
- 49:34appropriate? Okay. Usually my agreements have
- 49:38no characterization and no tax advice. However,
- 49:41the party can characterize how they want without
- 49:43the defendant's assistance. Well, that's an interesting
- 49:47point. I think that the question arises, it arises
- 49:57a lot in the employment arena, because everybody's
- 50:01got the IRS and the Department of or the State
- 50:03Department of Revenue, or the Labor Department,
- 50:06you know, potentially looking over their shoulder.
- 50:09And so I think the important thing is that both
- 50:12sides are, you know, in agreement about the characterization
- 50:18so they're not creating audit risk for each side.
- 50:22I don't think there's anything unethical. In
- 50:24fact, I think it's quite a sound practice for
- 50:27the parties to talk about that. And in my experience,
- 50:31I can't think of a single case where the parties
- 50:34didn't reach agreement on that point. And it
- 50:40may be part of the question that you just read,
- 50:44Suzanne, that the parties, it's not my job as
- 50:51a mediator to police how the parties characterize
- 50:55settlement money. And I'm not a tax expert and
- 50:59it's not my place to give them advice about how
- 51:02the IRS or State Department of Revenue might...
- 51:04might look at it. My job is simply to help people
- 51:09not only resolve the present conflict, but hopefully
- 51:11avoid future issues. And that's why I have that
- 51:15discussion with them. And every now and then,
- 51:18there's a tax issue so complicated that it's
- 51:21worth bringing in an outside opinion about it,
- 51:25where each side might get their own tax opinion.
- 51:31And I guess there's a related question. If I
- 51:34know, if someone tells me, well, I'm not going
- 51:38to report this income, am I colluding in some
- 51:42way by keeping confidential what, let's say the
- 51:46party, this has never happened to me, but let's
- 51:52say the party said, yeah, I know this is taxable
- 51:54income, taxable under either ordinary income
- 51:57or some other. heading, but I'm not planning
- 52:00to pay taxes on it. I would be very uncomfortable
- 52:03writing up the agreement under those circumstances
- 52:07because it would feel like I'm colluding in in
- 52:10tax fraud. So I might you know, withdraw at that
- 52:14point, although my withdrawal may be inconsequential
- 52:16because maybe the parties have now figured out
- 52:19how to settle this on their own. So sorry to
- 52:22give such a long -winded answer to a very straightforward
- 52:26question, but it seemed to me like there were
- 52:28several elements in it. Great, thank you. And
- 52:33let's see, I have one in the adjusted execution.
- 52:37What happens when both bid the same amount? Ah,
- 52:42okay, so there is a, with confidential last offers,
- 52:52there are three possibilities. There's a gap,
- 52:56they pick the same number, or their numbers actually
- 53:00overlap. And so what I usually tell people in
- 53:04advance is if their numbers overlap, I'm going
- 53:06to recommend, you know, a settlement at the average
- 53:10of the two numbers. That's only happened once
- 53:13in my memory and I've been mediating now for
- 53:1934 years. Usually there's a gap. If the parties...
- 53:25pick the same number, that's easy. I just report
- 53:27that we have a settlement. But Suzanne, I'm not
- 53:30sure if the question I answered is precisely
- 53:33the one that was being asked. Can you read that
- 53:35one more time? Yeah, of course. In the adjusted
- 53:39execution, what happens when both bid the same
- 53:42amount? The adjusted winner auction. I answered
- 53:46a question that wasn't even asked. So in the
- 53:49adjusted winner auction, we have a protocol that
- 53:58their bid needs to be either an odd number or
- 54:01an even number. So even if it's like... $5 ,001
- 54:05and the other person offers $5 ,000 or something
- 54:08like that. By saying that it has to be either
- 54:10an odd number or an even number, you never get
- 54:12a tie. Great. Thank you. And let's see. Christopher
- 54:20Daniels is asking, what do you do when the impasse
- 54:23on a settlement, in this case business litigation,
- 54:26is not the monetary terms, but non -monetary
- 54:31terms where the plaintiff is insisting on non
- 54:34-monetary terms that it could not get at trial?
- 54:39Great question. So, you know, that is the case
- 54:44in a significant number of of commercial mediations.
- 54:51And it may be, for example, release from a non
- 54:56-compete agreement or the imposition of a non
- 55:02-compete agreement. And neither of those is going
- 55:06to be available at trial. So now we have a business
- 55:09negotiation going on. What are the interests
- 55:11here? How can those interests be met? And we
- 55:17look at uh you know various contingencies and
- 55:21so forth and if there's truly an impasse then
- 55:24part of the analysis is okay well let's say we
- 55:26don't have an agreement what is going to happen
- 55:28and sometimes that you know gets the creative
- 55:32juices flowing because the non -agreement alternative
- 55:36doesn't look so great um but but i also just
- 55:40want to acknowledge that there's some cases that
- 55:43don't settle for a reason because there's a good
- 55:47faith disagreement about the value of the case.
- 55:51Or there may be certain constraints that the
- 55:57parties can't do anything about. It may be a
- 56:00bet the company case where settlement just isn't
- 56:05possible because the one side doesn't have enough
- 56:08money to satisfy the other side. And so they
- 56:14have to go to trial. But I think the important
- 56:18thing is the mediator meeting separately with
- 56:22each side can explore very thoughtfully options
- 56:25and alternatives. Options are what's available
- 56:28at the table. Alternatives are what's available
- 56:32away from the table, namely in court or if it's
- 56:36a commercial transaction, is there some other
- 56:39party that they could do the deal with? I want
- 56:43to say one more point on this, which is that
- 56:47there's a great metaphor that Bob Mnuchin and
- 56:52his co -authors came up with in the book, Beyond
- 56:56Winning. And it's the idea of bargaining at two
- 56:58different tables. And in mediation, this happens
- 57:01all the time. One table is the table of expected
- 57:04value. What's going to happen in court if we
- 57:06don't settle? And lawyers are very ready to argue.
- 57:10and discuss at that table. The other table is
- 57:14the table of interest -based bargaining. How
- 57:17can we make both sides better off? And sometimes
- 57:21people get very frustrated at the table of expected
- 57:24value because they disagree about the case evaluation.
- 57:31So they go to the interest -based table. And
- 57:34if they get frustrated there because they haven't
- 57:36come up with an interest -based option that works
- 57:41for everybody, they go back and forth. And over
- 57:44time, after exploring the disagreement here and
- 57:48the challenges here, they decide, you know what?
- 57:51I think we're going to have to move off of our
- 57:56positions. to come up with a solution. So part
- 58:01of my job as a mediator is to sort of normalize
- 58:04the fact that there are two, often at least two,
- 58:07sometimes more than two conversations. I guess
- 58:09there's a third table where people talk about
- 58:12if there are emotions in the case, is there some
- 58:17kind of emotional exchange, some kind of relationship
- 58:21repair, or just the storytelling or apology that
- 58:26might help people at that third table. So I see
- 58:31we have a minute, but I'm willing to go beyond
- 58:33if there are more questions. Suzanne, is there
- 58:37anything else in the Q &A? You have a few questions,
- 58:40actually. We have about three or so. Let's see.
- 58:44So John is asking, on any settlement, the tax
- 58:47man is a silent partner. And I'm guessing Prosecutors
- 58:52want, no, P's want W -2 payroll payment as low
- 58:56as possible, and D's want a reasonable value
- 58:59to avoid tax issues when P's do not have the
- 59:03funds to pay their taxes on April 15th. Plaintiff.
- 59:08Defendant. Silly. Okay. Yeah, we're okay. Yeah,
- 59:12there's a lot, in my, the cases where I'm the
- 59:15mediator. There are often discussions about this,
- 59:19and the tax laws have changed a bit. This is
- 59:22mentioned in the book, The Art of Impasse Breaking,
- 59:25to make it harder to, in employment cases, to
- 59:31allocate part of the settlement to non -wage
- 59:37income. But it's not impossible. And what often
- 59:42happens is the defendants, the employers in those
- 59:46cases, want an indemnification from the plaintiff
- 59:51because if the IRS or the State Department of
- 59:55Revenue comes around saying to the employer,
- 59:59you didn't, you characterized this settlement
- 1:00:03in a way that's not supportable and you're going
- 1:00:06to owes some social security or other funds,
- 1:00:14the plaintiff will often provide that indemnification
- 1:00:17in exchange for a characterization of the allocation.
- 1:00:23between ordinary income and 1099 income. But
- 1:00:28many employment plaintiffs are not willing to
- 1:00:30provide such an indemnification. And so, as I
- 1:00:34mentioned earlier, I've had cases where we bring
- 1:00:35in an outside tax expert, and often that's quite
- 1:00:38useful in figuring out what is a reasonable,
- 1:00:43defensible position to take on allocation for
- 1:00:47tax purposes. Thank you so much. And let's see,
- 1:00:52I have another one from Erica asking, how do
- 1:00:55you assist the parties in settling a matter when
- 1:00:57one lawyer on the or the other's behavior is
- 1:01:00creating the obstacle to settlement and the lawyer
- 1:01:03doesn't appear to be open to discussion about
- 1:01:05his or her behavior? I've certainly have had
- 1:01:10situations where that's the case. And I mentioned
- 1:01:14earlier, sometimes changing the players and figuring
- 1:01:16out who can have a productive conversation. But
- 1:01:20one of the things that I do when I'm dealing
- 1:01:24with, it could be a party, or it could be a lawyer
- 1:01:27who's being very difficult, I say, well, okay,
- 1:01:31I get you strongly held views. What's your proposal?
- 1:01:34They tell me their proposal. I say, well, what
- 1:01:36do you think the chances are the other side will
- 1:01:38respond to that proposal as opposed to leaving
- 1:01:41the negotiation? And very often, I find that
- 1:01:44they are making a realistic determination of
- 1:01:48how the other side might react. And if it's,
- 1:01:53well, I think there's a... good chance the other
- 1:01:55side will walk, then okay, well, maybe a different
- 1:01:59proposal would be useful. Or sometimes they're
- 1:02:01overly optimistic and I say, well, here's my
- 1:02:03prediction. I think with that proposal that you
- 1:02:06want to make, they're going to experience that
- 1:02:09as, I think there's better than 50 -50 % chance
- 1:02:14they'll walk. That's my hunch. I don't know because
- 1:02:18we haven't presented that yet. So basically what
- 1:02:22I try to do is to get them in off the ledge,
- 1:02:25so to speak, by doing some reality testing about
- 1:02:30how the other side might react to what they want
- 1:02:34to do. Great. So it looks like we just have one
- 1:02:39question here. Any suggestions for when the impasse
- 1:02:43is emotional, non -rational, in addition to the
- 1:02:46ones you've mentioned? or when the parties can't
- 1:02:49seem to agree on non -economic facts in a way
- 1:02:52that interferes with reaching agreement. Yeah,
- 1:02:56so I think part of our job as mediators is to
- 1:03:00bring all the tools of psychology that we can
- 1:03:07learn about to bear on the situation. And that
- 1:03:13doesn't mean we're providing psychotherapy. We're
- 1:03:15clearly not doing that. But what I have found
- 1:03:20is that sometimes I can tee up an emotional exchange
- 1:03:27that will be useful. And sometimes I can help
- 1:03:30people manage their own strong feelings of ambivalence
- 1:03:36about settlement. And I'll tell one quick story
- 1:03:38of each of those two kinds of emotional situations.
- 1:03:44So the first one. involves an uncle and his niece.
- 1:03:52The uncle had just lost his sister to cancer,
- 1:03:59and that's the niece's mother. So they were both
- 1:04:04grieving, but this case came to me about three
- 1:04:07years after the sister, the mother, had died.
- 1:04:13And the uncle, who was a lawyer, had badly mismanaged
- 1:04:18his sister's estate. It had taken three years
- 1:04:22for the niece to finally get his attention. And
- 1:04:26the way she got his attention was by filing a
- 1:04:28lawsuit to get him to complete the estate. And
- 1:04:32he apologized right at the beginning for how
- 1:04:35badly he'd handled the estate. But the apology
- 1:04:37didn't really move the needle. Bargaining back
- 1:04:42and forth getting some numbers on the table,
- 1:04:44we finally got a settlement. But what the uncle
- 1:04:48really wanted beyond figuring out a financial
- 1:04:51settlement was he wanted forgiveness and he wanted
- 1:04:56to be family again. And so with permission of
- 1:04:59the lawyers, I met with just the uncle and the
- 1:05:02niece in my office. And there was one other thing
- 1:05:06he wanted. which was he wanted the niece to agree
- 1:05:10that she wouldn't report him to the board of
- 1:05:14bar receivers because having his license was
- 1:05:18critical to his making a living and supporting
- 1:05:20his family. But you can't put in an agreement,
- 1:05:24an enforceable agreement, a provision that says
- 1:05:26that you won't go to a public official and report
- 1:05:29misconduct by a lawyer. So that never became
- 1:05:35part of the negotiation, even though the other
- 1:05:37side, the niece's side knew that's what the uncle
- 1:05:41wanted. And so in my office, the uncle said to
- 1:05:46the niece, I'm really glad we figured out the
- 1:05:49money solution. But he said, what really matters
- 1:05:51to me most is can we be family again, celebrate
- 1:05:56holidays together. And what I really want to
- 1:06:00know is if you're willing to And he was just
- 1:06:03about to say the word forgive. And the niece
- 1:06:06held up her hand like this. And I thought, oh
- 1:06:08dear, this is not going to go well. And she said,
- 1:06:14I've already forgiven you. In my heart, I've
- 1:06:18already forgiven you. And he got very teary.
- 1:06:21And she got very teary. And they gave each other
- 1:06:24a hug. And so then they each gave me a hug. And
- 1:06:29she said, and by the way, I'm not going to report
- 1:06:32you to the Board of Barber Sears." And he was
- 1:06:35so relieved and he gave her another hug. So those
- 1:06:41kinds of non -monetary and in some cases, non
- 1:06:47-negotiable terms can make a huge difference.
- 1:06:50Now, the second and last case I want to mention.
- 1:06:55involved a woman who was a manager, a high -level
- 1:06:58manager in a company who was laid off, and she
- 1:07:03claimed sex discrimination. She had a very good
- 1:07:05lawyer. She had a very good argument of sex discrimination
- 1:07:09because the company replaced her with a man and
- 1:07:12gave them the same job duties, but just changed
- 1:07:16the title. So she had a pretty good case, but
- 1:07:19it would have taken years. And she was the primary
- 1:07:22earner in her family. And so I sat with her at
- 1:07:25the end of the day, there was $250 ,000 on the
- 1:07:28table, and she was really struggling internally,
- 1:07:32emotionally, with whether to take a quarter of
- 1:07:34a million dollars and move on or fight the good
- 1:07:38fight for women's rights and women's equality.
- 1:07:42And she felt very strongly about both of those
- 1:07:44things. So I sat with her and I said, you know,
- 1:07:50I mentioned that I've been studying the internal
- 1:07:54family systems model. And in that model, it posits
- 1:07:57that we all have different parts, internal parts
- 1:08:01of us. And it sounds like there's a part of you
- 1:08:05that wants to fight the good fight to make sure
- 1:08:09that other women aren't subjected to sex discrimination.
- 1:08:12And she said, yes, very much so. And I said,
- 1:08:16and also a part of you is very concerned about
- 1:08:18making a living. because you're the primary earner
- 1:08:21in her family, and you need to be able to make
- 1:08:23your mortgage payments. And she said, absolutely.
- 1:08:26I said, in this IFS model, there's this idea
- 1:08:31that we all have a mediator inside us, what we
- 1:08:35call self -energy. And that mediator can listen
- 1:08:39to these two different parts and mediate a resolution
- 1:08:44that you can accept and maybe even embrace as
- 1:08:49a reasonable resolution. I wonder if you can
- 1:08:53feel that internal mediator in you. And she paused
- 1:08:59and I could see she was really consulting her
- 1:09:03internal mediator. And then she looked up and
- 1:09:07she said, I know I need to settle this and move
- 1:09:11on. And And with that, we reached a resolution
- 1:09:17of the case. And I was meeting with just her
- 1:09:21and her lawyer. And she stood up, and her lawyer
- 1:09:25stood up. They gave each other a hug. And so
- 1:09:27there are a lot of, and when mediations end on
- 1:09:30a very happy note, there's often hugging involved,
- 1:09:34sometimes tears. I would say most cases aren't
- 1:09:39emotional in quite that way. But in every case,
- 1:09:42Every case that I've been involved in, psychology,
- 1:09:46emotion is part of the mix. And part of my job
- 1:09:50is to be attentive to not only the words, but
- 1:09:55the music. Not only what people are saying, but
- 1:09:58what are the feelings behind what they're saying.
- 1:10:00And so with that, I think we're gonna bring...
- 1:10:04Suzanne, are there any other questions? Because
- 1:10:06if not, we'll bring today's session to an end.
- 1:10:08We actually have one last question. It was, have
- 1:10:11you ever used AI as a tool to assist in resolving
- 1:10:14impasses? Great question, very timely question.
- 1:10:18So I've started using AI to look at option generation,
- 1:10:23but I've not yet introduced it into the mediation
- 1:10:26room. I'm not sure that the... lawyers and the
- 1:10:29parties that I work with would be entirely comfortable
- 1:10:32with that as a tool. And of course, there's concern
- 1:10:36about when you put in the question, when you
- 1:10:39put in the facts of a case, have you properly
- 1:10:42disguised the information so that you're protecting
- 1:10:46the confidentiality of all concerned. So I have
- 1:10:50no doubt that the time will come when we'll be
- 1:10:53using it. And in fact, in my book, there are
- 1:10:5760 impasse breaking techniques listed. And one
- 1:11:03of the 60 is using AI for option generation,
- 1:11:07because it's certainly something we ought to
- 1:11:09be thinking about as a possibility. And I don't
- 1:11:12think it'll be long before we're using it on
- 1:11:15a regular basis. Great, thank you. So that looks
- 1:11:20like that's the last of the questions today.
- 1:11:22Thank you so much, Mr. Hoppen, for an excellent
- 1:11:25presentation, and thank you so much to our audience
- 1:11:27today. Have a great day, everybody. Thank you.