Latest / Brett Keane and Eve Show / Brett Keane versus Holocaust deniers, Democratic KKK, and Darwin's racism

Transcript

Brett Keane versus Holocaust deniers, Democratic KKK, and Darwin's racism · Brett Keane and Eve Show

• 0:22
  Hello ladies and gentlemen, my name is Brett Keane from GOD TV
• 0:26
  Radio. I hope you're all having a
• 0:28
  blessed day out there. When you get an opportunity,
• 0:31
  check out all my free music on the front of my YouTube channel,
• 0:36
  Spotify or Amazon Music and let me know what you think.
• 0:40
  All right, so today we are going to have a discussion about the
• 0:45
  Holocaust. All right, let's get this going.
• 0:53
  Hey, Brett, you're. Back what's on your mind today?
• 0:56
  Well, I was curious if we could have a discussion about the
• 0:59
  Holocaust. Well, Brett, the Holocaust is a
• 1:06
  really heavy. But important topic.
• 1:08
  It's. Crucial to remember the
• 1:10
  historical events and learn from them.
• 1:13
  What? Specifically, were you
• 1:14
  interested in discussing? About the Holocaust.
• 1:18
  Well, I've noticed that online there's a lot of Christians and
• 1:22
  a lot of atheists who deny the Holocaust ever happened.
• 1:26
  So I'd like to talk about evidence.
• 1:28
  How would we be able to go about proving that the Holocaust
• 1:32
  actually happened? Holocaust denial.
• 1:37
  Is a serious issue, but the. Evidence for.
• 1:40
  The Holocaust is. Overwhelming.
• 1:43
  There are countless documents, photographs and testimonies
• 1:47
  from. Survivors.
• 1:48
  Liberators. And even.
• 1:49
  Perpetrators. Historical Research.
• 1:52
  And forensic evidence also confirm the.
• 1:55
  Atrocities. It's.
• 1:56
  Essential to educate and challenge misinformation on this
• 2:00
  topic. The first question I have for
• 2:06
  you is what did Adolf Hitler think of Christianity?
• 2:11
  Give me some of his quotes that he has said about Christians in
• 2:15
  his diary or journal. Hitler's.
• 2:21
  Views on Christianity were complex and often contradictory,
• 2:26
  while he sometimes. Spoke positively about.
• 2:28
  Christianity in public, using it to gain support in private, he
• 2:32
  expressed disdain for its teachings, especially its moral
• 2:36
  teachings, which he. Saw as weak he.
• 2:39
  Admired elements of Christianity that he believed aligned with.
• 2:43
  His ideology, but overall he sought.
• 2:46
  To manipulate religious institutions to.
• 2:48
  Serve his purposes. His personal writings reflect
• 2:52
  this manipulation and contempt. Can you share with me some of
• 2:58
  the quotes or comments that he made negative about
• 3:02
  Christianity? Hitler's negative views on
• 3:10
  Christianity can be seen in some of his quotes.
• 3:13
  He saw. Christianity as a regression and
• 3:16
  criticized it for being a diabolic invention that held
• 3:20
  humanity back. His regime also promoted a
• 3:23
  version of Christianity. That rejected.
• 3:26
  Traditional doctrines and Jewish elements.
• 3:30
  His attitudes. Were more about manipulating
• 3:32
  religion for his own. Ideological goals.
• 3:35
  Rather than genuine belief. Do you have any quotes by him
• 3:42
  saying negative things about Christians and Christianity?
• 3:51
  Yes. Hitler made some pretty negative
• 3:53
  remarks about Christianity in one instance.
• 3:56
  He referred to. Christianity as a symptom of
• 3:59
  decay, and he spoke about wanting to root out and destroy
• 4:03
  the influence of Christian denominations in Germany.
• 4:07
  His views. Were more about exploiting
• 4:10
  religion for his agenda than genuine belief.
• 4:16
  OK, can you actually give me some quotes though of him saying
• 4:23
  things about Christianity? I would also like to know what
• 4:26
  his views were, including Stalin, when it came to
• 4:30
  evolution and socialism and communism.
• 4:36
  Hitler described. Christianity as a scourge and.
• 4:40
  Criticized its ethics. Considering them weak.
• 4:44
  Stalin, on the other hand, didn't discuss his beliefs in
• 4:47
  detail, but he enforced atheism in the USSR, promoting Marxist
• 4:53
  Leninist principles. Both.
• 4:55
  Rejected religious institutions. To support.
• 4:58
  Their totalitarian regimes, their views on evolution.
• 5:02
  Varied with Hitler. Misusing it to.
• 5:04
  Justify racial policies while. Stalin's regime promoted a
• 5:09
  distorted view aligned with. State Ideology.
• 5:13
  And when it comes to communism and socialism?
• 5:15
  Hitler despised both. Associating them with Jewish
• 5:19
  conspiracies, Stalin, a communist leader, implemented
• 5:24
  state controlled socialism with an authoritarian grip.
• 5:31
  Who? Killed more people.
• 5:36
  Stalin was responsible for more deaths than.
• 5:39
  Hitler particularly due. To the famines, purges and
• 5:43
  forced labor camps in the Soviet Union Hitler's regime caused the
• 5:48
  deaths of 1,000,000 during the Holocaust and.
• 5:50
  World War 2. Both were responsible for
• 5:54
  immense suffering and loss of life.
• 6:00
  So he said that Hitler manipulated and exploited
• 6:03
  Christianity and did not like Christianity at all.
• 6:07
  In private, this is what he would say.
• 6:11
  Did Hitler ever destroy any churches or take out any
• 6:15
  Christians? Hitler's regime didn't openly
• 6:21
  destroy churches on a large. Scale but.
• 6:25
  There was significant persecution of Christians who
• 6:27
  opposed Nazi ideology, and some clergy were imprisoned or
• 6:32
  executed. The Nazis sought to control and
• 6:35
  influence the church rather than outright wiping it out,
• 6:39
  attempting to align it. With their beliefs.
• 6:42
  Some Christians faced severe repression.
• 6:45
  Especially those who. Resisted the regime.
• 6:50
  He said that Stalin was an atheist who was pushing atheism.
• 6:55
  Did he kill any Christians or people of faith?
• 7:02
  Yes. Stalin's regime targeted
• 7:04
  religious groups, including Christians, many.
• 7:07
  Clergy were arrested. Sent to labor camps or executed.
• 7:11
  Churches were destroyed. Or repurposed and atheism was
• 7:14
  promoted as. Part of the state's ideology.
• 7:17
  His anti religious campaign caused significant suffering
• 7:21
  for. People of faith.
• 7:25
  What evidence do we have that Adolf Hitler in the Nazis
• 7:28
  actually killed Jews? There's extensive evidence of.
• 7:36
  The Holocaust. Including documents,
• 7:39
  testimonies, and physical evidence.
• 7:41
  The Nazis. Meticulously recorded their.
• 7:44
  Actions and survivor accounts provide powerful testimony.
• 7:49
  Liberation of concentration camps revealed mass graves and
• 7:53
  horrific conditions. The Nuremberg trials convicted
• 7:57
  many for crimes against humanity, solidifying.
• 8:00
  The historical record. Can you tell me some of the
• 8:08
  testimonies of the survivors? Survivors of the Holocaust have
• 8:16
  shared. Powerful testimonies about their
• 8:19
  experiences. They describe the horrors of.
• 8:22
  Concentration camps, the inhumane conditions and the loss
• 8:27
  of family and friends, many spoke.
• 8:30
  About the brutality they faced, the struggle for survival.
• 8:34
  And the resilience to bear witness to history.
• 8:37
  Their stories. Have been crucial in documenting
• 8:40
  the. Holocaust's atrocities.
• 8:42
  And ensuring that future generations remember.
• 8:48
  Isn't it true that Adolf Hitler was once quoted for stating that
• 8:53
  Christianity is a Jewish invention?
• 9:00
  There's no direct evidence of Hitler saying Christianity is a
• 9:04
  Jewish invention. He had complex views on
• 9:07
  religion, sometimes using Christian imagery for propaganda
• 9:12
  while privately criticizing it. His relationship with
• 9:15
  Christianity was manipulative and conflicted, reflecting his
• 9:20
  broader anti-Semitic ideology. Why did he hate the Jews so bad?
• 9:27
  When did he start attacking them?
• 9:31
  Hitler's. Anti Jewish sentiment was rooted
• 9:35
  in a mix of personal prejudice, societal influences, and.
• 9:39
  Political strategy, he started. Expressing these views in the
• 9:43
  early 1920s before rising to power, he blamed Jews for
• 9:48
  Germany's problems, using them as scapegoats to unite.
• 9:52
  Followers. And justify his extremist.
• 9:55
  Policies. This ideology later fueled the
• 9:59
  Holocaust. What was his contention with the
• 10:03
  Jews and Christians? Why did he feel they needed to
• 10:08
  die for? Hitler.
• 10:10
  Believed in a. Racist ideology that view Jews
• 10:14
  as a threat. To his vision of a pure Aryan
• 10:17
  race. He falsely accused.
• 10:20
  Them of causing Germany's economic and social problems his
• 10:24
  anti-Semitism was central to his.
• 10:27
  Nazi ideology. Leading to the.
• 10:29
  Belief that Jews. Needed to be eliminated to
• 10:32
  create his envisioned society. And you say there's an
• 10:37
  overwhelming amount of evidence such as graveyards, mass graves
• 10:42
  and and survivor testimony and all that.
• 10:47
  Is there any other evidence that we could look into or explore?
• 10:52
  Certainly there's extensive documentation, including
• 10:56
  photographs, Nazi records and testimonies from both survivors
• 11:01
  and. Perpetrators trials like.
• 11:03
  Nuremberg presented substantial evidence of the.
• 11:06
  Holocaust's atrocities. Museums and memorials.
• 11:10
  Worldwide offer further. Exploration.
• 11:15
  Why do you think it is that there are people out there who
• 11:18
  deny the Holocaust? What is their intention and
• 11:21
  purpose? Holocaust deniers often have
• 11:26
  various motives. Some are fueled by
• 11:29
  anti-Semitism, seeking to undermine the suffering of Jews
• 11:33
  to promote hate. Others may be driven by
• 11:37
  political agendas aiming. To distort history for
• 11:40
  ideological. Reasons some might be misled by
• 11:44
  conspiracy theories or denialism.
• 11:47
  Rejecting overwhelming evidence. Due to bias.
• 11:50
  Or ignorance. Their intentions are often
• 11:53
  rooted in spreading misinformation and hate.
• 11:59
  Yeah, but there's Christians as well as atheists that deny the
• 12:03
  Holocaust. Are you stating that the
• 12:05
  Christians and atheists who do that are either ignorant,
• 12:08
  stupid, or they don't like Jews? Denying the Holocaust,
• 12:17
  certainly. Cuts across various.
• 12:18
  Belief systems, including some with Christian or atheist
• 12:22
  backgrounds. It's not about their religion or
• 12:25
  lack thereof. It's about spreading.
• 12:27
  Specific false beliefs. This denial can stem from
• 12:31
  ignorance, bias, or intent to promote.
• 12:34
  Hate the focus? Here isn't on faith, but on the
• 12:38
  dangerous distortion of history. Why would they want to do that
• 12:44
  for? Why would a person want to lie
• 12:47
  about historical genocide for? Some might lie.
• 12:54
  About the Holocaust. To promote.
• 12:56
  Hate rewrite history or serve political.
• 12:59
  Agendas. They might aim to undermine
• 13:02
  trust in historical facts or push harmful.
• 13:05
  Ideologies. It's a.
• 13:07
  Dangerous attempt to distort. Reality for their.
• 13:11
  Own purposes. You had stated earlier that
• 13:15
  Hitler and Stalin used science and evolution in order to use it
• 13:22
  as racism. Can you explain that?
• 13:28
  Actually, Hitler. And the Nazis distorted
• 13:30
  scientific concepts, particularly Darwin's theory of
• 13:34
  evolution, to. Justify their racist ideology.
• 13:38
  They twisted ideas. About natural selection to
• 13:41
  promote notions of Aryan superiority and.
• 13:45
  Racial purity. It's a gross misrepresentation
• 13:48
  of science. Twisted to fit hateful
• 13:51
  ideologies. So the psychopath tried to
• 13:57
  manipulate religion and science. Can you explain in great detail
• 14:03
  what it was that they were doing to Darwin's evolution?
• 14:09
  Sure thing. Hitler and the Nazis twisted
• 14:12
  Darwin's theory of evolution, especially natural selection.
• 14:17
  To argue that. Certain races.
• 14:18
  Were superior. They falsely claimed that
• 14:22
  Aryans. Were the fittest.
• 14:24
  And used this to. Justify Horrific.
• 14:26
  Acts like genocide and eugenics. This manipulation was a
• 14:31
  perversion of Darwin's work. Used to fuel racist ideology
• 14:36
  and. Justify their crimes.
• 14:40
  Did Darwin ever imply or suggest that there were superior races?
• 14:48
  Nope, Darwin never implied. Or suggested that there were
• 14:53
  superior races. His theory?
• 14:56
  Of evolution by natural selection is.
• 14:58
  About how species adapt over. Time not about any inherent
• 15:03
  superiority of one group over another.
• 15:06
  The Nazis. Twisted his ideas to fit their
• 15:09
  racist ideology, but that. Distortion has no basis in
• 15:13
  Darwin's. Actual work.
• 15:18
  Did Darwin himself ever speak negatively or low about any
• 15:24
  race? Darwin's work was rooted in
• 15:30
  scientific observation, not. Racial prejudice while.
• 15:35
  Some of his writings reflect the 19th century.
• 15:38
  Views of his. Time which were not free from
• 15:41
  bias. He didn't explicitly promote the
• 15:44
  idea. Of racial superiority.
• 15:46
  The misuse of his. Theory by others.
• 15:49
  Doesn't align with Darwin's actual scientific intentions.
• 15:54
  You said that some of what Darwin said was bias based upon
• 15:58
  his culture and time. Can you give me examples?
• 16:04
  Darwin lived in the 19th century, a time when colonialist
• 16:09
  and racist views were common in some of his writings.
• 16:13
  He reflected those biases. Particularly when discussing
• 16:17
  indigenous peoples and cultures. However, these views.
• 16:21
  Don't define his scientific contributions and it's crucial.
• 16:25
  To separate his. Observations from.
• 16:28
  Outdated social attitudes his. Core scientific ideas don't.
• 16:33
  Advocate racial hierarchy. Well, that's fair enough, but
• 16:38
  what I'm wanting to know is what he actually said.
• 16:41
  What did he say that would come off as he has issue with any
• 16:45
  race? In The Descent of Man, Darwin
• 16:50
  made some ethnocentric and biased remarks reflecting the
• 16:54
  prevalent attitudes of his time, for example.
• 16:58
  He referred to. Savages and civilized races
• 17:02
  suggesting a. Hierarchy but.
• 17:05
  It's important to. Separate these outdated views.
• 17:08
  From his scientific. Theories.
• 17:10
  His observations were often colored by the lens of his.
• 17:14
  Era. Not by an objective scientific
• 17:17
  analysis of race. Can you give me some actual
• 17:22
  quotes and some examples? And you don't have to continue
• 17:26
  to remind me that there's a difference between his personal
• 17:29
  beliefs and his scientific views.
• 17:33
  All right? There's no need for that.
• 17:35
  Just tell me what he said that appeared to go along with his
• 17:39
  culture and time period. In The Descent of Man, Darwin
• 17:45
  referred to indigenous peoples. As savages, which?
• 17:49
  Reflects the ethnocentric views. Of his era, he also suggested
• 17:54
  that civilized. Races might eventually.
• 17:57
  Replace Savage races. These terms and ideas are
• 18:02
  problematic, reflecting a biased.
• 18:04
  View. Rather than an objective
• 18:07
  scientific stance. It's a part of his work.
• 18:10
  That has not aged well and is. Rightly critiqued today.
• 18:16
  All right, fair enough. Fair enough.
• 18:19
  Is there any really famous people or famous leaders that
• 18:23
  denied the Holocaust? Yeah, David Irving, a British
• 18:28
  writer. Is one of the most notorious
• 18:31
  Holocaust deniers. He's faced legal.
• 18:34
  Action for his claims. Which are widely discredited.
• 18:37
  And condemned by historians. Another infamous figure is Ernst
• 18:42
  Zundel, a German. Publisher who spread.
• 18:45
  Holocaust denial materials both have been.
• 18:49
  Widely criticized. And their views rejected by
• 18:52
  mainstream scholars. Why did they think it didn't
• 18:59
  happen? What was their motivation?
• 19:04
  Holocaust deniers often have various motivations, including
• 19:08
  anti-Semitism, a. Desire to rehabilitate.
• 19:12
  The image of Nazism or a general.
• 19:14
  Distrust of historical. Narratives they might claim that
• 19:19
  the Holocaust. Was exaggerated or fabricated
• 19:22
  as. Part of a conspiracy?
• 19:24
  These views are widely. Discredited and rejected by
• 19:28
  serious historians and scholars, Holocaust deniers often have
• 19:36
  various motivations ranging from anti-Semitism to political
• 19:41
  agendas. Or a desire to rewrite history.
• 19:45
  They may claim. That the Holocaust was
• 19:47
  exaggerated or. Fabricated often as part of a
• 19:51
  conspiracy theory, these. Views are widely.
• 19:55
  Discredited and condemned by historians.
• 19:58
  As they distort the well. Documented evidence of the
• 20:01
  genocide. That took place.
• 20:03
  During World. War 2 all.
• 20:07
  Right. I have one more question for you
• 20:09
  and then we're going to end the discussion.
• 20:12
  What political party in America founded the KKK?
• 20:20
  The Ku. Klux Klan was founded in the
• 20:23
  aftermath. Of the Civil War.
• 20:25
  During the Reconstruction Era, it wasn't directly founded by a.
• 20:30
  Specific political party. But many of its early members
• 20:34
  were Southern Democrats. Over time, the Klans
• 20:37
  associations and political alignments have shifted.
• 20:41
  But it's important to note that the Klans.
• 20:44
  Ideology is rooted. In white supremacy, not
• 20:47
  mainstream political party principles.
• 20:52
  Why did the Democrats? Why were there so many Democrats
• 20:56
  in the KKK? What was their motivation?
• 21:02
  After the Civil. War Many southern Democrats
• 21:05
  joined the Klan as part. Of a broader.
• 21:08
  Resistance to Reconstruction efforts and to maintain white
• 21:12
  supremacy. They sought to undermine the
• 21:15
  political and social gains of African Americans.
• 21:19
  The Klan provided a means to intimidate and control black
• 21:24
  citizens and those supporting Reconstruction.
• 21:28
  It's a dark. Chapter in history reflecting
• 21:30
  the deep divisions and prejudices of the time.
• 21:36
  Did Democrats ever support Hitler's ideologies?
• 21:44
  No, the Democratic Party as an institution?
• 21:47
  Never. Supported Hitler's ideologies,
• 21:51
  however. Like in many countries during
• 21:54
  the 1930s and. 40s there were. Individuals across the political
• 21:59
  spectrum who held various opinions about events in Europe
• 22:03
  but supporting. Hitler's ideologies.
• 22:06
  Was not a stance of the Democratic.
• 22:08
  Party. Is there any well known Nazi
• 22:15
  Democrats in America or was there historically?
• 22:23
  Historically, there's. No mainstream democratic figure
• 22:26
  in America who was a Nazi. Or openly.
• 22:29
  Supported Nazi ideology while individuals with extremist.
• 22:34
  Views have existed. They've typically been on the
• 22:38
  fringes and not representative of the Democratic.
• 22:41
  Party. What political party seemed most
• 22:46
  interested in freeing slaves? Historically, it was.
• 22:54
  Individuals not. Political parties.
• 22:57
  Who were interested in freeing. Slaves, however.
• 23:01
  The Republican Party, founded in the 1850s, was the main.
• 23:05
  Political force. Advocating against the expansion
• 23:09
  of slavery. This culminated in President
• 23:12
  Abraham Lincoln, a Republican, issuing the Emancipation
• 23:16
  Proclamation. All right.
• 23:22
  Well, thank you for the good discussion.
• 23:24
  You have a good day. You too.
• 23:29
  Take care.