Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Alex Acosta And His Epstein Interview With OIG Inspectors (Part 14)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome to another episode of the
- 0:03Epstein Chronicles. In this episode, we're going to dive right
- 0:06back in and pick up where we left off with
- 0:09alex Acosta's interview with the OIG inspectors. Question. All right,
- 0:14so we have a draft from redacted, a working draft
- 0:17on September tenth, with a small rewrite from you. There
- 0:21is an Exhibit seventeen series indication that of the kind
- 0:25of activity that redacted was going through to come up
- 0:28with the federal plea. But eventually she and the defense
- 0:31attorney who is most actively working on this, Jay Lefkowitz,
- 0:35turned back to the NPA, and if you look at
- 0:37seventeen D, just to make the sort of staffing clear,
- 0:40you know, of course redacted as left redacted is going
- 0:43on vacation as of September fifteenth, and so redacted Lorie
- 0:47has helped finalize. So the finalizing of the NPA, the
- 0:51final version of which is in Exhibit twenty two, falls
- 0:54to redacted with redacted right answer yes, question okay, and
- 0:59redacted puts you on notice in eighteen B. In that process,
- 1:05this email in eighteen B is sort of a follow
- 1:07on to eighteen A. Do you see it comes one
- 1:10minute after your email in eighteen A. It's a response
- 1:13from her to you only, in which she makes note
- 1:16that the defense tried to reopen all the loopholes that
- 1:19I had sown shut. Answer yes, question, so it's fair
- 1:23to say that you're kind of you're on notice that
- 1:26they're being difficult. Answer that's fair question, okay, in the
- 1:31course of that being difficult. Nineteen A is an email
- 1:34to you from redacted on September eighteenth, in which he
- 1:37represents that or explains that the defense is that things
- 1:41are kind of falling apart with the negotiations, and she
- 1:44fears the deal is going to fall apart completely. Mister Todd,
- 1:49should we take a quick break here? You're losing your voice? Redacted.
- 1:52I'm fine, mister Todd. You could probably use a minute.
- 1:55Redact it all right, We'll take a break. They come
- 1:59back from their break, and the questions are back on
- 2:03question back on the record. Looking at Exhibit nineteen C,
- 2:06you say you write to redacted regarding whether you're available
- 2:10to at the time when she's going to be hashing
- 2:12out language. You advise her that I don't think I
- 2:15should be part of negotiations. I'd rather leave that to
- 2:19you if that's okay. Answer yes. Question, why did you
- 2:23say that to her? Answer? Because she was the line
- 2:26lawyer involved, and I thought, I think it's important for
- 2:30US attorneys to absent truly exceptional circumstances to not get
- 2:34involved in those sort of negotiations. You can meet like
- 2:37I did in September, reaffirm the position of the office
- 2:41back your AUSA, but ultimately, I think your trial lawyer
- 2:44needs discretion to do their job. Question At this point,
- 2:48of course, we know redacted is on vacation and you
- 2:52were aware, were you not? That Redacted LORI was about
- 2:55to DeCamp for Washington. In other words, he left at
- 2:59the end of September to become the chief of staff
- 3:01and principal Deputy Assistant Attorney General for who headed the
- 3:06Criminal Division. Okay, so it was really just the two
- 3:09of them at this point and with nobody apparently involved
- 3:11between them, And you answer so fair. But when you
- 3:17say just the two of them, redacted is an incredibly
- 3:20experienced lawyer. So to say just the two of them
- 3:23is not to take not should not imply that there
- 3:26was experience on the table. Question. I certainly in no
- 3:30way intended to suggest that answer fair enough question. Looking
- 3:35at nineteen d in which Redacted is on page two,
- 3:39looking at the latest draft from redacted meaning redacted, and
- 3:44this is in the throes of negotiating the NPA. Redacted
- 3:48is essentially telling you that he agrees with Redacted's observations
- 3:52that the Defense are just up to all kinds of
- 3:54nonsense in the deal and constantly changing their terms and
- 3:58just not apparently negotiating or dealing with these warring drafts
- 4:02with the drafting process in good faith. Again, that's my characterization,
- 4:08but Redacted says that to you in this email. I
- 4:11suggest we simply tell him redacted that his counteroffer is
- 4:15rejected and that we intend to move forward with our case. Right.
- 4:19And then your response is interesting. You say to him,
- 4:22why don't we just why don't we just call him?
- 4:25Tell them one, you agree and then change things. Answer you,
- 4:30being redacted agrees and changes things. Question correct. Tell him
- 4:35you agree, meaning redacted agree. Answer no, question I see.
- 4:41Tell him she gets cut off or he gets cut
- 4:44off by acosta. Tell him you Redacted agree and you
- 4:47change things. Question I see. Answer that is not acceptable
- 4:52to us and is in bad faith. Stop it, or
- 4:55we'll just indict and then try to work it out. Question, So,
- 4:59if is to try to work it out? If the
- 5:01numbers one and two are what you should tell, what
- 5:04redacted should tell redacted? Is number three something redacted should
- 5:08tell redacted? Or what you're telling redacted try to work
- 5:12it out? Answer? It's what I'm talking and telling. Question Okay,
- 5:16so just to be clear, you say tell them, meaning
- 5:19you redacted tell Jay number one and number two. But
- 5:22number three is then what you're instructing redacted to do?
- 5:26I'm just trying to understand. Answer yes, So my understanding
- 5:30of this is there being difficult. Hey, this isn't the
- 5:33first time that an attorney agrees to something and then
- 5:36goes back and tries to pull a fast one. So
- 5:39tell them you're onto this that they need to stop
- 5:42it or will indict. But then what we'll try, you know,
- 5:46redacted should try to work it out. Question Okay, answer,
- 5:50but they need to stop this tactic. Question did you
- 5:53really think that was going to be effective with this defense? Answer?
- 5:57I don't know. You know, I think one of the
- 6:00hard things with this is if it was right on
- 6:02September sixth, it remained right, irrespective of really I think
- 6:06I say sorry, I know it's a pain. This negotiation
- 6:10was a pain. But if it was the right position,
- 6:12the fact that you've got annoying council on the other
- 6:15side doesn't make it any less of a right position.
- 6:18You tell them to stop being annoying, You try to
- 6:20work it out, and if not, then you indict. Question
- 6:24is that is that consistent with your sort of view
- 6:26of doing business, being even and working it out? Answer? Yeah,
- 6:30that's our position. It's not a bluff, it's what we want.
- 6:34You work it out. People yell and scream on the
- 6:36other side, you work it out. If not with them,
- 6:38then we indict. Question what would have been the tipping
- 6:41point for you? What would have caused you to say, Okay,
- 6:44I agree with you redacted, I agree with you. Let's
- 6:47indict answer. So it's really difficult to speculate, but I
- 6:50think the tipping point would have been a failure to
- 6:52reach it was pretty clear jail time registration restitution. Once
- 6:57we move from twenty four to eighteen months. That was
- 7:00a give and take. But ultimately, if they came back
- 7:03and said we can't agree to these terms, then we indict.
- 7:06Question all right, question, it seemed like your troops were
- 7:10telling you we've reached the end of our rope where
- 7:12you really just want to go forward and indict answer
- 7:15right question, and you are coming back with tell them
- 7:18again that the defense is being difficult, but I want
- 7:21you to work it out. Does that tell your troops basically,
- 7:25that's where your priority is. You want them to go
- 7:27out get this resolution, and if they have to give
- 7:30up stuff, it's okay, it's really okay, but you want
- 7:33this resolution answer. So it's not if you have to
- 7:36give up stuff. I'm not telling them to give up stuff.
- 7:39I'm not telling them to negotiate things away. But I
- 7:42think the dynamic, from my perspective, is incredibly So there's
- 7:47a tactic that council sometimes take where they negotiate and
- 7:51when they try to come back and renegotiate, and that is,
- 7:54to my thinking, one of the most annoying tactics that
- 7:57you can have, and it creates a lot of frustrating
- 8:00And what I'm trying to say is, look, they might
- 8:02be frustrating folks, but if this had been worked out.
- 8:06Looking at this, we thought we had an agreement, and
- 8:09then they change things. And I'm saying, look, if you
- 8:12thought you had an agreement. Tell them you had an agreement.
- 8:15Don't let them change things. I understand it's frustrating to you,
- 8:19but if it was right two weeks ago, the fact
- 8:21that they're frustrating attorneys doesn't change the underlying legal analysis.
- 8:26The attorney's behavior doesn't inform the rightness or wrongness of
- 8:30a certain disposition to a point question. What's the point answer?
- 8:36So I think after and now I'm calling it an NPA,
- 8:39I was personally very frustrated with the failure to report
- 8:43on October twentieth, and I had envisioned that entire collateral attack.
- 8:47I think I would have looked at this very differently.
- 8:50Question in what respect answer to the extent that this
- 8:54was going back to, for example, the public corruption prosecution
- 8:58that we had. One of the values it was to
- 9:00have public figures stand up and say I did this
- 9:03and plead. One of the values was, you know, avoiding
- 9:07a long and messy legal process. And so when you
- 9:09put all of that together, you know, this is why
- 9:12I say it's not quite This was the factor that
- 9:15we'd consider that it's all of this put together and
- 9:18in something that could have been very positive for the
- 9:21victims and for sending a signal as it dragged on,
- 9:24became exhausting and negative for the victims. It put us
- 9:28in a position of what do we do with notification?
- 9:31It put us in a position of a lot of
- 9:33appeals to Washington. It put us in the position of
- 9:36having to deal with complicated legal issues that actually got
- 9:40more messy in terms of how a federal twenty two
- 9:43fifty five or late to a state charge. And had
- 9:46all of that been known, I do think this would
- 9:49have proceeded differently. Question differently in what way? Answer? So
- 9:55if I had factored all of that, Like, I can't
- 9:57predict it what I would have done, but I think
- 9:59if if I had known all of that, this could
- 10:01have proceeded very differently. I was very frustrated with the
- 10:05October to June time period. Question. So, if you had
- 10:09been back in the timeframe in early September looking at
- 10:12this with I don't know what Harry Potter character is it,
- 10:16but whoever can see into the future and anticipated or
- 10:20foresaw what would happen, would you have simply said, look,
- 10:23we're not going to go the state route, We'll go
- 10:25to the federal route. Answer quite possibly. Question all right, answer,
- 10:30and let me sort of say, we'll probably get into it,
- 10:33but at some point I do think the post versus
- 10:36the pre signature time period was different for any number
- 10:39of reasons, and we'll probably want to talk about that question.
- 10:43All right, we will, But now I'd like to turn
- 10:45to some of the terms of the NPA, because you
- 10:48did make Let me make sure that this is correct.
- 10:53Somebody pipes in you skip this one question? Oh yeah,
- 10:56before that, thank you. My colleague reminds me. Nineteen is
- 11:00an exhibit that has an exchange between you and redacted
- 11:04Laurie about at the time when the Plea Agreement, the
- 11:07Federal Plea Agreement was still in play, and the issue
- 11:09is whether you should sign it, and you didn't want
- 11:12to because you never do. But you say at the bottom,
- 11:14we should only go forward if the trial team supports
- 11:17and signs this agreement. What did you mean by that?
- 11:22The first part of that answer. So what I meant
- 11:25by that was I got something that is the document
- 11:28was unusual. So my signature appearing on this document is not,
- 11:32in and of itself unusual. Question and this would have
- 11:36been the Plea Agreement, not the Federal Plea Agreement not
- 11:39or was I thinking about the NPA. Answer this was
- 11:42about the NPA. Question okay, answer right, and so the
- 11:47NPA had my signature. Now, the NPA is almost too generous,
- 11:52so that in and of itself is not indicative of something,
- 11:56but it does raise my concern. Is this something that
- 11:59ultimately the trial team does not feel comfortable with? And
- 12:03if it's something they don't feel comfortable with, then they
- 12:06should speak up and let me know because we shouldn't
- 12:08go forward with it. Question and did you ever have
- 12:11a conversation or a discussion about that issue other than
- 12:14mentioning it? Answer no, not to my recollection, I would
- 12:18assume based on this that Redacted would read it and
- 12:22would take my word for it and say, look, if
- 12:25you think you're going in the wrong direction, Alex, you
- 12:27know I think you're going in the wrong direction, or
- 12:30I'm uncomfortable with it. Question did you ever have a
- 12:33direct conversation with redacted about wanting her to sign the
- 12:36agreement as opposed to yourself? Answer? I did not. This
- 12:40was my first communication with redacted, and I really meant
- 12:43that if at the end of the day my team
- 12:45isn't comfortable, then you shouldn't go forward. Question you never
- 12:49recall hearing from redacted that she was not comfortable moving
- 12:52forward with the plea agreement question the NPA answer, I
- 12:57did not hear. I don't recall hearing from redacted that
- 13:00she was not comfortable. I know that at various points
- 13:02she became frustrated. At various points she became frustrated. But
- 13:07they were negotiating this. If at some point they did
- 13:10not they thought that this was a mistake or wrong
- 13:13or unjust, I would think that they would have told
- 13:15me question, what would you have done? Answer? Sit down
- 13:19and really have a serious conversation about where this is going,
- 13:23and sit down and hear them out again, even at
- 13:26this late phase, I would I would think that that's
- 13:29what I would have done. All right, folks, we're gonna
- 13:32wrap up right here, and in the next episode, we're
- 13:34gonna pick up where we left off. All of the
- 13:37information that goes with this episode can be found in
- 13:40the description box.