Latest / The Buckeye Weekly Podcast / Who Needs To Have The Biggest Game To Ensure An Ohio State Win Over Michigan?
Transcript
- 0:02Hello, everybody, Welcome to the Buckeye Weekly Podcast. I am Tony Gerdaman
- 0:07here as always with Tom or Tom. How's it going? Oh? I'm
- 0:16out of things to say this week, Tony, how's it going with you?
- 0:24Thanks for joining us. Next, there have been a lot of shows,
- 0:29and I think I'm out of emotions and independent thoughts at this point.
- 0:33So sorry, We're just gonna have to talk football, not not anything else.
- 0:38Let's start with the easy when Tony from at Isaac McIntyre, how do
- 0:41the Buckeyes win this game? Tony, they score more points? Next up?
- 0:45All right? Boom number two? Yeah, boom, there's one.
- 0:48Yeah, I mean, how do they win this game? I mean,
- 0:51it's really trite to say they win the turnover battle, but I think they
- 0:55just need to. I don't think they need to win the turnover battle,
- 0:58but I think they need to not lose to turnover battle. You need to
- 1:00not give Michigan short field. They need to play, you know, disciplined
- 1:06on defense. If they don't give up big plays on defense, you know,
- 1:11no no plays over, no runs over twenty yards, and no passes
- 1:17over thirty yards. And that's all I tell you. In Ohio State doesn't
- 1:21turn the ball over. How are you percentage chance if those that's all you
- 1:26know, what percentage chance you're giving Ohio State to win that game? Oh,
- 1:30I'd put that around sixty five percent or so for me. Whenever I
- 1:34think about this game and the years were Michigan didn't have that great of an
- 1:40offense, they would still find a way to concoct a big play, to
- 1:44draw up a big play, And if they're not able to do that one
- 1:48here, then yeah, I definitely like Ohio State's chances. I was just
- 1:52on a news station time on television. If you must no, and we're
- 2:01talking about running the ball to win the game, do you see either of
- 2:06these teams if you rush for less than four yards per carry? I feel
- 2:13like normally you won't win this game. But also I could see both teams
- 2:16rushing for under four yards per carrying this game. Therefore somebody must win.
- 2:24Yeah, But if they both teams rush for under four yards of carry,
- 2:29that means either you're getting a defensive score or a special team score or something
- 2:34like that that maybe decides the game, or you got to win it with
- 2:38your passing attack. And if it's winning with your passing attack, I think
- 2:42I'm putting my money in Ohio State. Just Michigan's wide receivers are good colts,
- 2:47and Loveland is a very good tight end. But Marvin Harrison plays for
- 2:53Ohio State, and I'm like a book a plays for Ohio State. And
- 2:57I don't know that JJ McCarthy is meaningfully ahead of Kyle McCord right now.
- 3:01Both of those guys kind of dealing with some injury stuff, So you know,
- 3:06I think they're both maybe a little bit limited. McCarthy maybe a little
- 3:08bit more than McCord, just because his injury is a little more recent.
- 3:13I think if both teams, if Ohio State holds Michigan under four yards rushing
- 3:19and Ohio State doesn't turn the ball over, I think that's another one where
- 3:22I think I might even say greater than sixty five percent chance of Ohio State
- 3:27winning that game. If those are the only two things you tell me,
- 3:30yeah, because it does feel like Michigan will need to run the ball in
- 3:34this one, because they have not been fantastic throwing the ball, and so
- 3:38if they're not able to run the ball and they put it all on JJ
- 3:40McCarthy, and I'm pretty sure, as we said, before that, we
- 3:44said maybe these exact same words last year heading into this game, make JJ
- 3:47McCarthy beat you. I'm not saying they need to do that this time.
- 3:52I'm just saying that if they're not able to run the ball, then things
- 3:54are going to get a lot more difficult for JJ McCarthy. And he may
- 3:58still be able to do what he did, but he also had help last
- 4:01year with down of Edwards down in the fourth quarter making those big runs.
- 4:06Yeah, and that was three long passes earlier in the games on one mistackle
- 4:12and a couple of busted coverages, and then two long runs at the very
- 4:15end of the game when Ohio State was kind of in desperation mode and you
- 4:17had just a couple bad run fits and you're playing cover zero and then that
- 4:21turns what should be a six yard gain into a sixty five or seventy five
- 4:26yard gain. So, I you know, I don't think I'm expecting Michigan
- 4:30to put up, you know, five big plays against Ohiostio Hioes States only
- 4:34give it up one play of forty yards or more all season long. That
- 4:38was the fumble Rouskie at Rutgers. So that took kind of a trick play
- 4:41to do it on a fourth and one situation. I don't think Michigan can
- 4:45bank on big plays again this year. So you know, if they can't
- 4:48run the ball, I think that's a big problem for them potentially next up
- 4:54from at zero HST, so like OHST but with a zero. If I
- 5:00told you Trayvon Henderson, Marv or J. T. Twoey Molowell had their
- 5:03best game as a Buckeye next week this week, which would you give me
- 5:06which would give you the most confidence in a Buckeye win. I'm going with
- 5:11Travon Henderson. That was the question. The listeners thought, going with Travion
- 5:15Henderson, although I think Tony that might also be my answer. Tom,
- 5:20I think we might be three for three on that one, because we've seen
- 5:25you. You you can see a wide receiver catch twelve passes for two hundred
- 5:28and ten yards and that's because of a desperation need to throw the ball because
- 5:34you're trailing my three touchdowns or whatever. So you just you can have a
- 5:38big game as a wide receiver and it not really impact the the win loss.
- 5:43Tom. I will also say we saw J. T. Twoe Molo.
- 5:46I'll have the game of his life last year against Penn State, and
- 5:50that was a game I've seen need in twenty eight points in the fourth quarter
- 5:56to win that. So we saw an incredible game from J. T.
- 6:00Twee mullow out in that one, and yet you still needed much more to
- 6:04happen to win that game. So I think if you see Travon Henderson have
- 6:10the game of his life, then that to me is the one that you
- 6:15will take right now. And again, let's not forget the best game of
- 6:19Travion Henderson's Buckeye career was two hundred and seventy seven yards rushing against Tulsa.
- 6:25So if we're gonna use that measurement, then if if Travion Henderson rushes for
- 6:30two hundred and seventy eight yards, then you've got to like Ohio States chances.
- 6:34But even if it's Tom What's what's the the minimum number of rushing yards
- 6:40or Trevion Henderson where you feel like that guarantees a win or eighty percent chance
- 6:46of winning? Is it like one hundred and sixty hundred and fifty yards somewhere
- 6:49in there? I mean, yeah, somewhere, yeah, somewhere in that
- 6:55like one seventy five range. Give or take if he's only if Travon Henderson
- 7:00runs for over two hundred yards, unless you have like a nineteen ninety nine
- 7:05Jonathan Wells situation where he runs for seventy six yards and gets tackled at the
- 7:10one or whatever and then they somehow get stuffed and miss a field goal.
- 7:14I mean, if you're you have to assume you're running for two hundred yards,
- 7:16you have to assume you're running for a couple of touchdowns in there.
- 7:20So, okay, there's fourteen points, and then if Travon Henderson's running for
- 7:27two hundred yards, Michigan cannot let themselves get run over like that. So
- 7:30then you have to bring your safeties up. You've got to try and control
- 7:34the run. You got to try and get Ohio State, you know,
- 7:39to do something else. And that's when then you involve, you know,
- 7:42and that's when it maybe does turn into Marvin Harrison's greatest game as well.
- 7:46That's that's I think the absolute best case scenario for Ohio State fans is Travon
- 7:50Henderson runs for two hundred seven yards and then that opens think up. That's
- 7:56that's where Ohio State wins this by four touchdowns. If Travion Anderson runs for
- 8:00two hundred yards, I'm certainly not expecting that. If Blake Coreham runs for
- 8:03two hundred yards, Michigan's probably winning this game by three or four touchdowns.
- 8:09If Blake Koram and Trayvan Henderson both run for two hundred yards, well,
- 8:13Tony, we will have watched a hell of a football game. I don't
- 8:16know anything more than that, but man, it will have been a hell
- 8:20of a football Well. Who is more likely to rush for two hundred yards
- 8:24in this one? Because there's one running game that is trending up and another
- 8:30running game that is just trending I don't want to say down, but it's
- 8:33not going up, and that would be Michigan. So if you're asking me,
- 8:37and I guess I'm the one asking me. If I'm asking me,
- 8:39who is more likely to rush for two hundred yards in this one, I'm
- 8:43gonna choose Trayvon Henderson. We know that Michigan's run defense is pretty darn good,
- 8:50so rushing for two hundred yards obviously isn't likely to happen. But the
- 8:56way he is playing right now, his explosion, he has explosion. Blake
- 9:00or doesn't have the same thing that he had last year, and not that
- 9:03he would go seventy yards untouched, but he would go forty five yards and
- 9:09get tracked down. He'd go fifty two yards and get tracked down. He's
- 9:13not doing that this year. Travian Henderson has more big plays than Blake Korum,
- 9:16and Henderson has missed three games. To give you an idea of the
- 9:20different levels of explosion. So I think, if if you're going to if
- 9:24one of these guys is bound to do it, or if I'm picking one
- 9:28guy who could or would or over the other, I'm taking Henderson, Tom
- 9:33would you take who's more likely to rush for one hundred in this one?
- 9:39I think more likely to rush for one hundred. I think I would probably
- 9:43say Quorum, because I think if one of these guys is going to get
- 9:48twenty five carries, it's going to be Korum. I don't think Travian Henderson's
- 9:52getting twenty five carries, and you know I'm not. Maybe you get a
- 9:58scenario where Travia Henderson runs, you know, he has a sixty yarder,
- 10:01and then he also has ten runs for four and a half yards or whatever
- 10:07a carry. Something like that. I could see that I just I think
- 10:11you're Travon Henderson. If he doesn't hit a long one, is probably not
- 10:15going to hit one hundred yards. And I think there's a real possibility he
- 10:18doesn't hit a long one. So I think just in terms of Michigan,
- 10:24is probably going to be more consistently willing to stick with the run even if
- 10:28it's not really really really working. Like we have seen Ryan Day kind of
- 10:33get the itchy trigger finger a little bit sometimes where Okay, the runs not
- 10:37you know, the run's working, and yeah, you get I know I
- 10:39have to stay with the run, but I'm just going to pass this one
- 10:41time and then kind of gets going on that. So I think more likely
- 10:46to run for two hundred yards Travon Henderson, Moreland likely to run for one
- 10:50hundred yards. I'm gonna say, Blake Corn. There's so much to be
- 10:54thankful for. Family, friends, food at NFL football all week long.
- 10:58Draftkick Sports Book is keeping your thing thanks Giving a week full of action.
- 11:01New customers can bet just five bucks on the NFL Action to score one hundred
- 11:03and fifty instantly in bonus bets. No matter your appetite, there's something for
- 11:07you. Money aliones parlays props, live bets, and so much more.
- 11:09You name it and they've got it. So download the DraftKings Sportsbook app now
- 11:11and use code huddle up. New customers con bet five on the NFL Thanksgiving
- 11:15Action to score one hundred fifty instantly in bonus bets only on DraftKings sports Book
- 11:18and official sports betting partner of the NFL with code huddle up. The Crown
- 11:22is yours. Gambling problem called twenty hundred gambler in New York call eight seven
- 11:24seven eight Hope n Y or text Hope n Y four six seven three sixty
- 11:28nine West Virginia. Visit www dot twenty hundred gambler dot net. Please play
- 11:31responsibly. In Connecticut, help is available for problem gambling called eight at eight
- 11:35seven eight nine seven to seven seven seven or visit CCPG dot org on behalf
- 11:39of Boothill, casino and Resort. Kansas must be twenty one or older in
- 11:41most eligible states, but age varies by jurisdiction. See DraftKings dot com slash
- 11:45Sportsbook for details and state specific responsible gambling resources. Eligibility and deposit restrictions apply.
- 11:48Bonus bets expire one hundred and sixty eight hours after issuance terms at sportsbook
- 11:52dot DraftKings dot com slash football terms. All right, Next up from Hank
- 12:00Scorpio, is this the biggest or most anticipated version of the game in history?
- 12:07Tom? I think it's going to be incredibly difficult to beat the two
- 12:11thousand and six game, number one versus number two, and that game was
- 12:16anticipated before Beauchamp Beckler's passing on Friday made it even bigger. You've got the
- 12:22HBO film crew. They're doing a documentary about that game. Not that we
- 12:28necessarily knew it at that point, but there's just a lot going on that
- 12:31week, that game, and then it lived up to the hype. Although
- 12:37the score was closer than the game was down the stretch. You know,
- 12:39it was forty two thirty one until Michigan scored at the end there and then
- 12:46got a two point conversion. So the forty two to thirty nine looks fantastic.
- 12:50Number one versus number two. Everything lives up to the hype. How
- 12:54can this game? This is a much this is this is definitely still big.
- 13:00It's playoffs, it's division title, Tom. We can't lose that.
- 13:03I mean, the two thousand and six game was not for a Division title.
- 13:05This is actually for something, and in fact, this is the opportunity
- 13:11to then go play Iowa. I mean those are stakes Tom that the two
- 13:20thousand and six team has never played for, the nineteen sixty nine team,
- 13:22the sixty eight team, they never got to play for these stakes. But
- 13:28everything going on around Michigan right now, what this game means for Ohio State,
- 13:31what this game means for Michigan. I would argue that the stakes of
- 13:37everything around the situation makes this bigger because there's just more going on right now.
- 13:46Well, there's certainly more going on right now. I think you might
- 13:48fall into a little bit of an issue with this game not being in the
- 13:54spot on the schedule or with the proximity to the national champion that some of
- 14:00the past ones have have had. No is this the nineteen sixty nine game
- 14:05pre dates both of us. But if Ohio State had won the nineteen sixty
- 14:09nine game up in Ann Arbor, they're national champions period, full stop,
- 14:13end of story. There was no additional game to win. There was not
- 14:16a championship game and a semi final and a Big Ten championship game to win.
- 14:20It was if Ohio State wins in Ann Arbor. They are national champions
- 14:24for the second year of the row because back then the Big Ten had what
- 14:26was called the no repeat rule, which meant if you went to the Rose
- 14:28Bowl the previous year, you could not go to the Rose Bowl again.
- 14:31So Ohio State had won the national championship in nineteen sixty eight, they had
- 14:35gone unbeaten into ann Arbor in nineteen sixty nine, that was going to be
- 14:39the last game of the season, period, full stop, end of story.
- 14:41And if they had won, they were number one and they were going
- 14:43to win the national championship again. So that coupled with bo Schimbeck was first
- 14:48year. I'm sure that was a pretty hyped thing back then. I'm sure
- 14:52it was just blowing up Twitter in nineteen sixty nine. Yes, But you
- 14:56know, so that's a sort of factor here that obviously predates us. It's
- 15:01really not one we're capable of discussing super intelligently. Nineteen ninety seven, that
- 15:05was a really big one up in inn Arboro, ohiosed at Michigan both top
- 15:09four. Ohio State had lost to Penn State earlier in the year, but
- 15:13that was it Michigan unbeaten. That was a pretty hyped game that got a
- 15:18lot of attention. That wasn't a really good game. Michigan jumped out to
- 15:22a twenty to nothing lead, ohiost it came back Michigan. Boy, you
- 15:26look at the box score of that game, Michigan I think was like forty
- 15:28two rushes for forty two yards or something like that. Like Michigan did nothing
- 15:31in that game. Ohio State turned it over a couple times. Charles Woodson's
- 15:35back of Punton, that's all she wrote. And Michigan shared the National Championship
- 15:39with Nebraska that year two thousand and two. That has to be in the
- 15:43conversation. That's another one where you know nineteen ninety seven that got Michigan into
- 15:48the Rose Bowl and then winning the Rose Bowl got them a shriff the National
- 15:52Championshi two thousand and two, the BCS had already started, so that win
- 15:56got Ohio State into the Fiesta Bowl, the National Championship game against Miami.
- 16:00Still remember probably Brent Musburger screaming about going to play for all the tostitos.
- 16:06That one was another, I mean, really hyped game because that one is
- 16:10sort of similar narratively to this one where Michigan had that long run of dominance
- 16:14against Ohio State ten too and one over thirteen year span. Jim Tressel goes
- 16:18up there in two thousand and one and upsets Michigan, and then two thousand
- 16:22and two it was okay, you know, is Ohio State going to continue
- 16:26this and make this a little bit of a trend or is this going to
- 16:27be Michigan you know, gets things back on track as the world usually works.
- 16:33Plus you had the BCS thing and the National Championship on the line there
- 16:36two thousand and six. You talked about twenty sixteen that was a top three
- 16:40matchup that I mean went to overtime. And you know, I think some
- 16:44of these games, the two thousand and six game, twenty sixteen game,
- 16:48suffer a little bit in memory based on what happened after those games. Two
- 16:51thousand and six, Michigan loses the Rose Bowl after losing to Ohio State.
- 16:55They lose the Rose Bowl to the USC. Ohio State loses the National Championship
- 16:57game to Florida. Twenty sixteen, Ohio State loses in the semi final to
- 17:03Clemson. So I think, you know, some of those games looking back
- 17:07now don't feel as big as they would have if those teams had advanced and
- 17:10won the national championships, it's not part of that kind of like a big
- 17:14picture kind of story. Last year obviously kind of the same thing, you
- 17:19know, didn't end up being that kind of a big picture story. So
- 17:22where this one falls historically might depend somewhat on what happens after the game.
- 17:30Well, and what happens after the game is kind of why I think it
- 17:34is so important and could be really see changing for one program and altering the
- 17:44history for Ohio State perhaps as well, if they can go ahead and get
- 17:48this one, because the narratives that can then be latched onto as as like
- 17:55a life preserver basically for the last couple of years, Whereas if Ohio State
- 17:59loses one, then the thing that you wanted to latch onto the counter Stallion's
- 18:04thing over the past two years, like that's no longer and it's not.
- 18:07It's got some holes in it, and more than just the one that a
- 18:11life preserver may have, So there's some difficulty in just fitting that narrative into
- 18:18your own reality. But if Michigan loses this one, then this becomes We're
- 18:25already seeing the pre backlash from some folks on the Michigan side, saying that
- 18:30this is going to be the story that comes out of this. If Michigan
- 18:33loses, it's that the last two wins were tainted. Meanwhile, that's that
- 18:37is going to happen, and that the thing is you can't This is why
- 18:45you why Michigan needs to win, because that is going to happen, and
- 18:48they can't prove that it's not true. And so there's just people will run
- 18:53with it. People will That's that's the label that Michigan is going to be
- 18:56given. So this is something that is it's a big game, but it's
- 19:03bigger than just this game. And so that's why there's so much surrounding this
- 19:08that it's there's the game, there's the legacies, there's the past two games.
- 19:15There's more than just this game. And by the way, this game
- 19:18is also extremely important. It's it's two versus three, just like last year's
- 19:25was. But if Ohio State makes that kick against Georgia, that Michigan game
- 19:30last year doesn't necessarily doesn't mean nearly as much. And also, Tom I
- 19:36think I think Marcus Hartman wrote about this this week at Dayton Daily News,
- 19:40how this is going to be the last game like this for Ohio State and
- 19:44Michigan and Ryan Day. Somebody asked Ryan Day about that, not about Marxist
- 19:48peace, I'm coming. Let's not pull up Marcus too much here, but
- 19:52ask him about the next games will be different because of the playoff, because
- 19:56it could be the first of two meetings, could be the first three meetings.
- 20:00And he said, it's not going to be any different because everybody's going
- 20:03to want to win, want to win each of those games, no matter
- 20:07when they are or where they are and who they are. You're you're never
- 20:10going to give your best, give anything other than your best in this game.
- 20:15So just a ton to go into this game. And yet for the
- 20:21people who are in each one, they're all the biggest and nothing is bigger
- 20:23than the one you're in right there, right now. Well, I mean,
- 20:26Michigan talks about themselves. It's a two time defending Big Ten champions.
- 20:30They kind of feel like they are defending those last two Big Ten championships this
- 20:33weekend in a lot of ways, because you know, if they lose,
- 20:37I mean, this is you know, yeah, it's sort of in a
- 20:40lot of people's minds. No one's mind is going to be changed. Everyone
- 20:42has already probably made up their minds in terms of what this game means,
- 20:45and it does or it doesn't mean anything about the previous two years. It
- 20:48does kind of in a weird way, might impact sort of the how severe
- 20:55this is viewed. As if Ohio State goes in and beats Michigan by fourteen
- 21:00to seventeen points in a game where this is the best team that Michigan has
- 21:03had over the last three years and Ohio State is you know, they're good
- 21:07in some areas and not as good in other areas, and it's on the
- 21:11road, and Michigan has won the last two by three scores, and if
- 21:15Ohio State goes in there and beats them by two three scores, like,
- 21:17oh boy, that's you know, that's not great for this year's team.
- 21:19But also, you know, you can have Michigan people saying, well,
- 21:23this doesn't mean anything but the previous years. The vast majority of people are
- 21:26not going to agree with that sentiment. And if you've if there is a
- 21:30widespread view that this, you know, people at the NC double A are
- 21:34not going to necessarily agree with that sentiment. So if there is a widespread
- 21:37view that, hey, this materially impacted multiple years and potentially denied Ohio State
- 21:44teams a chance to play for a championship or swung the results of conference championships.
- 21:48That's not going to be good when you get to the punishment phase if
- 21:51and when they get to the punishment phase with the NC double A. So
- 21:53when we say there's a lot on the line this weekend, we mean it
- 21:57real quickly, telling you let's hit the one from at Jimmy four six zero
- 22:02two, three to one, five to one, three to one. What
- 22:04is the artillery shell sound at the Woody when you're doing shows from there?
- 22:10Well, there are a number of sounds, and as I'm trying to think
- 22:12through my head, my first initial thought was that it was the Monarch machine,
- 22:15but I don't know that that's actually loud. I think it's the it's
- 22:19the blocking sleds that some guys will be hitting at times. It's the softball
- 22:23going on against the wall to get into the gloves. Is it anything that
- 22:29the chairs are being put away and thrown onto carts like there's trust me.
- 22:33We've tried to complain about the noise of the athletes doing their things and the
- 22:37workers doing their jobs. Nobody wants to hear from us, So I apologize
- 22:41on behalf of them for doing their jobs in a loud manner. But it's
- 22:48not the Australians drag racing and doing donuts in the parking lot. That is
- 22:51a different noise. No, that is a very different loud, screeching noise.
- 22:56It is not the truck backing up to us as we were talking about
- 23:00a former Ohio State offensive lineman and who did not have a particularly great performance
- 23:03at a pro day. This show has a long and storied history of let's
- 23:11just call it sonic excellence. Perhaps somehow we always find a way to the
- 23:18tornado siren, somehow always goes off. We can be recording at Tuesday at
- 23:22two in the afternoon, It's like, why are they setting off the tornado
- 23:25the new non Wednesday tornado sirens? How often is there a train going by
- 23:29wherever we're recording? Why are we constantly under flight pass of airplane airplanes?
- 23:34No matter where we are recording from. How many Gators can Ohio State Football
- 23:38possibly have in their facility? And the answer is it doesn't matter. There's
- 23:44always something. I think my favorite was we were recording in what late November
- 23:48early December. At one point in like a car outside of the way.
- 23:52This is several years ago before did the's on a YouTube show and there was
- 23:56someone either mowing or with a leaf blower, and it's like, it's December.
- 23:59There has not been a leaf or a piece of grass growing, a
- 24:02blade of grass growing in this area for six months like this. That was
- 24:07the one where I was like, all right, we are clearly on the
- 24:08Truman Show now, like there's no other explanation. Mine that stuck with me
- 24:15real quick. As we recorded somewhere in the Big the Big Lobby and the
- 24:18Trophy Lobby went to the side room where there is just like a strip of
- 24:22a like a carpet a rug, and they decided at that point as we're
- 24:27recording, you know what, let's vacuum this, and they brought into vacuum.
- 24:32It's like we we we came inside to get away from the outside outside
- 24:37noise and then boom, time to do some housework. So that that will
- 24:41do it for this episode. Again, please like this video if you have
- 24:45not yet done so, we would appreciate that. If you're listening to it
- 24:47on a podcast, ahead and give us a five star. Writing or interview.
- 24:49Find us at bucket huddle dot com check us out. The game is
- 24:53just days away. I know we are all looking forward to it, and
- 24:56so that will do it for this episode. Thank you all for tuning in,
- 25:00and we'll talk to you guys later