Latest / Deep Thoughts About Stupid Sh*t: A Pop-Culture Comedy Podcast / Deep Thoughts about Gender in Pop Culture: Tools for Feminist Analysis (BONUS)
Transcript
- 0:00Emily Guy Birken: This is Emily Guy-Burken and you are listening to Deep Thoughts About Stupid Shit, because pop culture is still culture, and shouldn't you know what's in your head?
- 0:09Emily Guy Birken: In today's bonus episode, I will be talking about feminist analysis of pop culture with my sister, tracy Guy-Dekker, and with you.
- 0:19Emily Guy Birken: Let's dive in.
- 0:25Tracie Guy-Decker: Have you ever had something you love dismissed because it's just pop culture, what others might deem stupid shit?
- 0:32Tracie Guy-Decker: You know matters, you know it's worth talking and thinking about, and so do we Come over, think with us as we delve into our deep thoughts about stupid shit.
- 0:46Emily Guy Birken: Tracy, we have already kind of talked about a couple of common feminist analyses of pop culture and so we realized it would probably be a good idea to have a bonus episode where we kind of dig into these things.
- 0:59Emily Guy Birken: So if in the future we want to reference something like the Becdel test or Mary Sue, we can refer people back to this.
- 1:06Emily Guy Birken: Why don't you get us started with an explanation of the Becdel test?
- 1:11Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah, I'd love to Thanks.
- 1:14Tracie Guy-Decker: So the Becdel test named after Alison Becdel, who actually I don't know if you know this, emily, but she and I are both alumni of the same undergraduate institution.
- 1:21Tracie Guy-Decker: I did not.
- 1:23Tracie Guy-Decker: Yes, alison is an OB and in fact this test that bears her name was in some ways in her mind, just like a throwaway moment in her comic strip Dyches to Watch Out For Back in the mid-80s I believe it was in 1985 was the strip when it first went.
- 1:42Tracie Guy-Decker: So the test is, we asked ourselves about a piece of pop culture literature.
- 1:47Tracie Guy-Decker: Are there at least two female characters?
- 1:50Tracie Guy-Decker: Do they both have names?
- 1:52Tracie Guy-Decker: Do they talk to one another and is the topic of their conversation something other than boys or men?
- 1:59Tracie Guy-Decker: And it's funny because Becdel, outside of the specific like comic book fandom that she has, is known exclusively for this feminist test, in some ways to her chagrin.
- 2:15Tracie Guy-Decker: I recently read an article, an interview with her.
- 2:18Tracie Guy-Decker: She's written all kinds like plays and musicals have been made out of her graphic novels, like she has this like big career as a creator.
- 2:27Tracie Guy-Decker: And so she was reading this interview with her where the interviewer was like I think we need to talk about the Becdel test and she was like oh, do we have to?
- 2:35Tracie Guy-Decker: So I think that's that's.
- 2:38Tracie Guy-Decker: I don't know what I'm going with this, but I think it's pretty interesting that this actually really useful kind of short hand threshold to ask if something crosses that has been so useful.
- 2:52Tracie Guy-Decker: She sort of it was just like a throwaway that she she was just trying to make a joke in her Dikes to Watch Out For comic book in the 80s, so I think that's really interesting.
- 3:02Tracie Guy-Decker: So and the test is super useful.
- 3:05Tracie Guy-Decker: You and I talk about it most episodes of Deep Thoughts, I think because unfortunately so much of the literature, movies, tv shows that we consume do not pass the Becdel test and it is a really, really low bar.
- 3:24Emily Guy Birken: I have was trying to think about the movies that I loved as a child, the ones that I watched over and over again, if any of them passed the Becdel test.
- 3:33Emily Guy Birken: Star Wars, does not know.
- 3:36Emily Guy Birken: The Princess Bride does not know.
- 3:39Emily Guy Birken: Ghostbusters, no, does not.
- 3:42Emily Guy Birken: Let's see back to the future, I think does not.
- 3:46Emily Guy Birken: There might be an interaction between Lorraine and her mother yeah, In back in 1955.
- 3:53Emily Guy Birken: And Lorraine does have friends in 1955, but I think they're talking about I don't think, yeah, they're talking about boys, or they don't talk, they're just like presents.
- 4:03Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah.
- 4:03Emily Guy Birken: Yeah, the Neverending Story does not pass the Becdel test.
- 4:06Emily Guy Birken: So you know so much of the culture that I, you know, soaked in as as a little baby, future feminist, did not pass this very low bar, which I think goes to show how rare it is to have a film with two female characters, who are named, who talk to each other about something other than men, which is kind of horrifying.
- 4:33Emily Guy Birken: But also goes to show how ingrained, first of all, how many screenwriters are men and how ingrained the, just the generalized misogyny is in our culture.
- 4:45Tracie Guy-Decker: And even the even female storytellers.
- 4:47Tracie Guy-Decker: Right Like this is these are the models we've been given is the hero's journey.
- 4:53Tracie Guy-Decker: It's not the heroine's yes, so yes, which maybe we'll talk about it in another bonus episode sometime.
- 4:58Emily Guy Birken: Yes, which is interesting because we just learned about something called, I think, the Virgin's Promise, which is the feminine like archetype of what the hero's journey is, and it was interesting to me because that tends to be the types of stories I tell in my fiction and I have been told that I don't have enough conflict right Because it doesn't follow the hero's journey.
- 5:22Emily Guy Birken: So the other feminist analysis that we have mentioned before I think we talked about it in our very first episode is the idea of Mary Sue.
- 5:29Emily Guy Birken: That is a term that was coined kind of as a joke by Paula Smith in 1973.
- 5:35Emily Guy Birken: Paula Smith was the editor of Star Trek fanzine, which I delight in.
- 5:42Emily Guy Birken: The fact that there were fanzines back when you had to put it in an envelope and put a stamp on it to receive it, like that's amazing to me and I think it's just how dedicated fandom can be and how there's something kind of wonderful about that.
- 6:00Tracie Guy-Decker: I just had a really sacrilegious thought that, like all of Midrash, which is a Jewish form of Torah, interpretation like Midrash is biblical fan fiction.
- 6:13Emily Guy Birken: I think you're correct.
- 6:14Emily Guy Birken: Well, I mean, so much of any fiction is fan fiction.
- 6:20Emily Guy Birken: Yeah, honestly.
- 6:22Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah, I mean, as I said to you recently in a text, I think a large portion of Western art history is fan art of the Bible or Greek myth.
- 6:33Emily Guy Birken: Yeah, yes, yes, oh gosh.
- 6:36Emily Guy Birken: I'm just now thinking about we're still doing it.
- 6:38Emily Guy Birken: I've been thinking lately about how Marvel movies and like superheroes are Greek gods, yeah, or Norse gods, or Norse gods, and there is so much fan fiction around that.
- 6:54Emily Guy Birken: That is both literal fan fiction, like people are just writing stuff because they want to, but then also like the all the different interpretations that you get of like there's so many different Spider-Man movies yeah, there's.
- 7:05Emily Guy Birken: You know, even when it is green lit by the studio, it is still a type of fan fiction.
- 7:11Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah, even within the canon it's fan fiction of a sort.
- 7:13Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah, I totally distracted you with that Quite all right, so you were talking about Mary.
- 7:19Tracie Guy-Decker: Sue and fan zines of Star Trek.
- 7:22Tracie Guy-Decker: Fan zines of the 1970s.
- 7:24Emily Guy Birken: Yes, so many of the fan fiction writers at the time and I think this is still probably true were young women, and Paula Smith was kind of poking fun at the fact that the young women writing these, this fan fiction, would often kind of self insert into the stories in a way that can feel a little, I want to say, ridiculous.
- 7:45Emily Guy Birken: But it is not in service to the story, it's not in service to the characters.
- 7:48Tracie Guy-Decker: Right, it's wish fulfillment for the author as opposed to the integrity of the story.
- 7:52Emily Guy Birken: Yes, so so her 1973 parody, which was called a Trekkie's Tale, she had literally Lieutenant Mary Sue, who joins the the enterprise after graduating from a Starfleet Academy and immediately finds Captain Kirk enamored of her, is everything she touches is perfect, like her, her.
- 8:17Emily Guy Birken: Her reasoning is eminently logical, according to Spock, I mean.
- 8:19Emily Guy Birken: And so that is really what Mary Sue analysis is supposed to be.
- 8:24Emily Guy Birken: When it is a character that does not serve the story, that's is like kind of just magically good at everything, it is clearly some sort of self-insert.
- 8:33Emily Guy Birken: And, as we talked about in the Twilight episode, the problem with the term Mary Sue is that it is used in a very gendered way.
- 8:40Emily Guy Birken: Anytime there is a female character who is competent, or anytime there's a female character who could be seen as a self-insert, there's the accusation of oh, she's just a Mary Sue.
- 8:50Tracie Guy-Decker: It's not just accusation, it's like a dismissal that there is no validity or worthiness to this entire fiction because that character is Mary Sue.
- 9:01Tracie Guy-Decker: Yes yes, it's a way to dismiss female authored pieces.
- 9:06Emily Guy Birken: Well, I haven't seen it because I'm not a huge fan of the Marvel Cinematic Universe.
- 9:10Emily Guy Birken: Not that I don't think they're well-made movies.
- 9:13Emily Guy Birken: I am just resentful of something that requires me to see, like what 30, 40 movies.
- 9:18Tracie Guy-Decker: Totally commitment-phobic about it, me too.
- 9:21Tracie Guy-Decker: So I have like a couple of like the little franchises, like I've watched the Guardians of the Galaxy franchise, I've watched the Black Panther franchise, but like the bigger picture, like I'm with you, I am totally commitment-phobic about that whole universe.
- 10:02Emily Guy Birken: As I understand it, the Captain Marvel movie which is, I think, brie Larson so it's Captain Marvel is a woman that constantly people were saying like, oh, she's a Mary Sue.
- 10:14Emily Guy Birken: And I don't have any sense of whether or not this is a good movie, because that started before it even came out and, for instance, my older son decided he wanted to watch all the Marvel movies by himself, but he was looking on Rotten Tomatoes to see which ones were worth watching, cause, you know, some of them are not as good as others, and he's like, oh, I'm going to skip that one cause it's got really bad reviews.
- 10:34Emily Guy Birken: I was like don't pay attention to that, cause a lot of that is backlash from people who hadn't even seen it.
- 10:40Emily Guy Birken: Just the fact that it's a female led superhero movie is frightening to people for some reason.
- 10:46Emily Guy Birken: So I do find the concept of Mary Sue, even though it is used in such a gendered way and can be just pure misogyny.
- 10:55Emily Guy Birken: It is helpful to have a term for it rather than saying I feel like they were writing something to satisfy themselves rather than actually paying attention to what the characters would really do and what would serve the story in a satisfying way for the audience.
- 11:14Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah, I feel like you'd have two words to say that.
- 11:16Tracie Guy-Decker: Yes, it is interesting though, as we talked about in Twilight, like self inserting is something that male authors have been doing for as long as there have been male authors, and so I just want to say again out loud that a self insert can also serve the story.
- 11:34Tracie Guy-Decker: It doesn't have to be the scenario you just described, where there's something that feels inauthentic and satisfying because of the self insert.
- 11:44Tracie Guy-Decker: Self insert can be totally satisfying and authentic to the story for the reader or viewer.
- 11:53Emily Guy Birken: If done well, it can also bring the reader or viewer along Right so that they also feel like the hero.
- 12:03Tracie Guy-Decker: Right, because if the reader or viewer shares any characteristics, or whether it's demographic or psychographic with you, the author who's written your film in, it's easier for them to identify than with that character.
- 12:16Tracie Guy-Decker: So, yeah, I think that's worth noting and like the joke that you told me when we talked about this during our Twilight episode.
- 12:23Tracie Guy-Decker: What do you call a male, mary Sue, a protagonist?
- 12:28Emily Guy Birken: So that, actually that kind of brings me to the next analysis that I wanted to talk about, which is I think it's a relatively recently coined one called Born Sexy Yesterday.
- 12:41Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah, I had never heard of this when you.
- 12:43Tracie Guy-Decker: I mean, I knew exactly what it meant, but I had never heard it said that way when you first brought it up to me.
- 12:48Tracie Guy-Decker: So let's hear it.
- 12:50Emily Guy Birken: As far as I can tell, it was coined by Jonathan Macintosh of the Pop Culture Detective Agency and there's a video he put out explaining it, which I believe is how I first heard of it.
- 13:01Emily Guy Birken: So it starts based on the 1950 film that was remade in 1993 called Born Yesterday, where it's this ditzy Vegas showgirl that two men decide to kind of teach and she actually turns out to be brilliant.
- 13:18Emily Guy Birken: She just had never gotten an education before.
- 13:21Emily Guy Birken: It's kind of a Pygmalion story, I think.
- 13:22Emily Guy Birken: But this trope is that there is, and Macintosh was specifically looking in the sci-fi and fantasy genre and he recognizes there are older roots to this that are kind of racist and colonialist because it's about women from outside of the white Western culture that men encounter.
- 13:45Emily Guy Birken: Oh interesting, but specifically in sci-fi and fantasy, because there's a way to magic a woman into being what she is, is physically a woman, sexualized as a woman, and has some sort of major, impressive capability that is usually masculine-coded, like she is an excellent fighter or she does coding or something Super strong.
- 14:12Emily Guy Birken: Yes, lelu, lelu, fifth element, that is the best example of this.
- 14:20Emily Guy Birken: But because she was born yesterday, she has no understanding of, a how attractive she is to other people, b how the world works or, c what can be expected of people.
- 14:37Emily Guy Birken: The reason why I wanted to go talk about this next is because my family does a family movie night once a week and recently we watched the Fifth Element together as a family and I've always been very conflicted about this movie because it is fun.
- 14:53Emily Guy Birken: It is a fun movie.
- 14:55Emily Guy Birken: It is so problematic and even as a 19-year-old or 18-year-old, when it came out and watching it in the theater, I was just like this is not OK, because we've got that born-sexy yesterday trope with Lelu.
- 15:08Emily Guy Birken: They keep talking about how she is a perfect being and if they were talking about her mental capacity, her wisdom, her ability to take in new information, her ability to fight, her empathy for other creatures, that would be one thing, but it is always said when she is naked.
- 15:30Emily Guy Birken: And so the idea that Mila Jovovich, who was, I think, 20 at the time, is what female perfection is and that's not.
- 15:42Emily Guy Birken: I mean she's gorgeous, I mean, yes, absolutely, but it's very, very gross.
- 15:46Emily Guy Birken: And then, meanwhile, bruce Willis, who plays Corbin Dallas, is I looked it up, he was close to 40.
- 15:53Emily Guy Birken: And I was just thinking about this as we were talking about Mary Sue.
- 15:58Emily Guy Birken: Corbin Dallas is very much a self-insert for Luc Besong, because he is good at everything, like everything he touches he's good at.
- 16:07Emily Guy Birken: He is clearly, you know, inserted in there as a like oh I'm, I'm going to be the perfect man for this perfect woman.
- 16:20Emily Guy Birken: When he's just a guy, you know, and that's part of the born sexy yesterday Trope is that, because she has no knowledge of the world like the first man she meets, is so impressive to her.
- 16:35Tracie Guy-Decker: And it's you know, I'm realizing.
- 16:36Tracie Guy-Decker: We recently recorded our Wonder Woman episode and in, at least in Linda Carter version, like there's a, there's an element of that for Wonder Woman, because she enters the our world from Paradise Island and she has this sort of naive wisdom Like that's part of the trope of this.
- 16:53Tracie Guy-Decker: Is it like a naive wisdom Like why would you do that, why would you fight people?
- 16:57Tracie Guy-Decker: Like questioning sort of fundamental pieces of human society.
- 17:02Emily Guy Birken: I love that you brought that up, because Macintosh describes born sexy yesterday as profoundly naive yet unimaginably wise.
- 17:10Emily Guy Birken: Yep, yeah, and that's it.
- 17:13Tracie Guy-Decker: And Wonder Woman definitely is that in the Linda Carter version anyway.
- 17:17Emily Guy Birken: Even the Gal Gadot 2017 one.
- 17:18Emily Guy Birken: I'm just thinking of when she sees the baby and and the way she reacts to the world in 1941, I think, and that, to me, is a similar aspect of it.
- 17:35Emily Guy Birken: So the thing that that, in watching the fifth element, again this time and Luke Basson wrote that when he was 16, like he didn't make it until he was in his 40s, but he wrote the story when he was 16.
- 17:47Emily Guy Birken: That actually makes a lot of sense.
- 17:49Emily Guy Birken: Oh, yeah, he has written this character who's supposed to be like, so strong and like beyond human comprehension in terms of complexity and ability and all of that, and yet she needs the help of some random cab driver to be able to handle things.
- 18:10Emily Guy Birken: And it's like no, no, you're either one or the other.
- 18:16Emily Guy Birken: Yeah, and I'm not saying that, like strong people can't be vulnerable, but just the way her vulnerability is written is entirely a male fantasy, because her vulnerability is fixed by his mouth.
- 18:34Tracie Guy-Decker: Well, yeah, I mean, that's like a you know Snow White Cinderella, like, oh my God, yeah, okay, all right, cool.
- 18:42Tracie Guy-Decker: So so now we have Bexeltas, mary Sue, born sexy yesterday with their naive wisdom.
- 18:50Tracie Guy-Decker: What else you got on your list?
- 18:52Emily Guy Birken: Okay, so this one I love just because I love the name of it.
- 18:56Emily Guy Birken: And then I didn't know, until I was doing a little research for this, exactly what she meant.
- 19:01Emily Guy Birken: But the sexy lamp analysis, which was coined by Kelly Sue DeConnick and based on the Bexeltas.
- 19:10Emily Guy Birken: And what she said is and I think she was in a science fiction fantasy convention and I think she was talking about books rather than film, but it's useful in any of them.
- 19:21Emily Guy Birken: She says if your female character could be replaced by the sexy lamp from a Christmas story, like the leg lamp, the leg lamp, the leg delay.
- 19:32Emily Guy Birken: Yeah, and it doesn't change the plot in any way.
- 19:35Emily Guy Birken: Then you need to rewrite your story.
- 19:39Tracie Guy-Decker: That's actually a really fun and like quippy way to talk about women as prizes, right.
- 19:45Emily Guy Birken: Like.
- 19:46Tracie Guy-Decker: I don't know why.
- 19:46Tracie Guy-Decker: The first thing that comes to my mind is the legend of Zelda.
- 19:48Emily Guy Birken: But the game that's played when we were kids.
- 19:50Emily Guy Birken: It's a speech.
- 19:51Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah, like Zelda was just the prize, princess Peach is just the prize.
- 19:56Tracie Guy-Decker: She's not actually anything else, so she could very easily just be a sexy lamp or a literal trophy, because that's all she is.
- 20:04Emily Guy Birken: Yes, yeah well, this is on my mind because I've been working on this fiction project.
- 20:08Emily Guy Birken: I loved the story of Orpheus and Eurydice growing up.
- 20:12Emily Guy Birken: For our listeners who aren't familiar with it, this is the Greek myth.
- 20:14Emily Guy Birken: Orpheus was a musician who was like, gifted by the gods with the most gorgeous voice.
- 20:19Emily Guy Birken: He fell in love with a wood nymph named Eurydice.
- 20:22Emily Guy Birken: She is bitten by a snake on their wedding day and dies.
- 20:26Emily Guy Birken: He sings about his heartbreak and goes into the underworld, is able to convince Hades and his Queen Persephone to let Eurydice be alive again, but they tell him that he has to walk back to the upper world with her behind him and never look back.
- 20:40Emily Guy Birken: Until they are back in the sunlight and, depending on the version of the story you know, she trips and cries out and he looks back without thinking, or he gets sunlight far before she does, without thinking, he turns back.
- 20:50Emily Guy Birken: But long story short, he looks back and she's gone from him forever.
- 20:54Emily Guy Birken: And then after that, he keeps singing his despair and he's torn apart by I Can never remember their name but he's torn apart by a bunch of women who are like why won't you sleep with us?
- 21:02Emily Guy Birken: You're singing, is pretty.
- 21:03Emily Guy Birken: And then his head keeps singing down the river.
- 21:06Emily Guy Birken: Anyway, as much as I love that story, my, my little romantic heart, just just, oh man who would go to the ends of the earth and beyond.
- 21:15Emily Guy Birken: I love that as, as I got older, I like Eurydice could be replaced by a sexy lamp.
- 21:21Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah, like she does not have any agency cuz.
- 21:26Tracie Guy-Decker: Even at the end, when he loses her, it's because of his action, not hers.
- 21:29Emily Guy Birken: Yes, not because of hers.
- 21:31Emily Guy Birken: I find it very useful to look at things with that and, like you know, actually imagine the the lamp from Christmas story in it, because that helps me recognize, like, why I have some like moments of like I really like this, but about things that are, you know, that make my romantic heart Otherwise sing.
- 21:52Emily Guy Birken: The fiction that I'm working on is I'm updating the story as a young adult novel From Eurydice's point of view, where she makes the choice to get bitten by the snake and she makes the choice not to leave with them because Orpheus is a toxic asshole, instead of it being a romantic story.
- 22:10Emily Guy Birken: And and I think that that you know, the idea of women as prize is is another aspect that Happens way too often and is so unexamined.
- 22:22Emily Guy Birken: The other common thing that we see is the manic pixie dream girl.
- 22:27Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah, talk to me about that.
- 22:29Emily Guy Birken: Yeah, so that term was coined by, I think, a movie reviewer, but he's a media expert named Nathan Rabin, in 2005, after seeing the movie Elizabeth Town with Kirsten Dunst.
- 22:42Emily Guy Birken: I have, like I remember when that movie came out.
- 22:46Emily Guy Birken: I know it has a Orlando blue minute.
- 22:48Emily Guy Birken: I never saw it and the only reason I even remember that it exists is because I know that this guy coined manic pixie dream girl from this.
- 22:54Emily Guy Birken: But the manic pixie dream girl is the woman who is available, quirky, and her entire job is to Get the uptake guy to stop being so uptight.
- 23:08Emily Guy Birken: And so she doesn't have a Real arc of her own, she doesn't have personality of her own, she's just a series of quirks and it's really all about like she's adorable and she makes him realize that life is worth living or realize that he doesn't want the high-powered job or whatever it is Natalie Portman in.
- 23:31Emily Guy Birken: Garden State, exactly like Natalie Portman.
- 23:34Emily Guy Birken: Garden State.
- 23:34Emily Guy Birken: That is exactly the example that I was gonna use.
- 23:37Emily Guy Birken: So you know, we meet her and she says have you heard the shins?
- 23:41Emily Guy Birken: It's gonna change your life.
- 23:42Emily Guy Birken: And like, has shares the earbuds with them and like human beings don't act like that.
- 23:46Emily Guy Birken: And it's a, it's a kind of cuteness that is so open and non-threatening and undemanding.
- 23:57Emily Guy Birken: That is, again, not giving women the fullness of a real inner life.
- 24:07Emily Guy Birken: Now Nathan Rabin has come to regret having coined that term.
- 24:11Emily Guy Birken: Oh really, and I have not been able to dig into it as much as I'd like.
- 24:15Emily Guy Birken: I think he regrets it because, like Mary Sue, it's used in a sexist way.
- 24:20Emily Guy Birken: So any female character is like oh, she's just a manic pixie dream girl, but it's.
- 24:26Emily Guy Birken: It's another one that's very helpful term to use in recognizing and it has a lot of overlap in it with the born sexy yesterday because so, like one of the examples of born sexy yesterday is splash, and Madison is very much a manic pixie dream girl, and splash so because she gets him to break out of the prison he's put himself in with, with the world that he lives in.
- 24:53Tracie Guy-Decker: It seems to me that, born sexy yesterday, the stakes tend to be higher, mm-hmm, both for the, the woman, and like just the story, at least the examples that we're talking about, the splash and and and the fifth element where the stakes To Madison are actually pretty high, versus, like, portman's character in Garden State.
- 25:15Emily Guy Birken: I Mean it's ultimately just a love, not just a love story.
- 25:19Emily Guy Birken: It's a love story.
- 25:20Tracie Guy-Decker: Her this, but the stakes of the her relationship with the Zach Ramf character character are just their romance.
- 25:28Emily Guy Birken: Yes, exactly.
- 25:29Tracie Guy-Decker: It's like the world is not ending.
- 25:31Tracie Guy-Decker: She's not gonna be like shipped off to a you know research facility and studied like like Madison.
- 25:37Emily Guy Birken: Yeah, I think that's a good analysis, because every time I've heard the manic pixie dream girl described, it's generally in realistic fiction.
- 25:46Emily Guy Birken: Mm-hmm rather than in like sci-fi, fantasy or something where there there are higher stakes.
- 25:52Tracie Guy-Decker: I think it's an interesting kind of Concepts to play with when thinking about like okay, well, what would it take to move this character out of magic to pixie dream girl, into a fully fledged human woman who has agency?
- 26:08Tracie Guy-Decker: What would it take in the story?
- 26:10Tracie Guy-Decker: For that to happen.
- 26:11Tracie Guy-Decker: I feel like that's it like kind of an interesting Concept to have, so that we can ask that question, mm-hmm.
- 26:18Emily Guy Birken: So so the subversion of this trope that I latch on to is From a movie called Liberty Heights Starring Adrienne Brody, that came out in 1999.
- 26:28Emily Guy Birken: It's set in the 1950s.
- 26:29Emily Guy Birken: It's set in Baltimore, about a Jewish neighborhood and these interrelated stories.
- 26:35Emily Guy Birken: So the Adrienne Brody character is absolutely in love with this Blonde young woman who is dating someone else who is not Jewish, and so there's there's some angst about the fact that he's interested in this woman, is not Jewish, and he just pines for her.
- 26:53Emily Guy Birken: And there gets to be a point where she breaks up with her boyfriend at a party when Adrienne Brody is, and the boyfriend says something along the lines of like, good luck with that one, and so he takes her home and she suggests they go to a motel or something and she has a complete and utter breakdown and a lot of the lovely mental health issues that she did not let people see, and so he had gone from, like you know, really pining for this woman who was this kind of unattainable, gorgeous object to seeing her fully, and I don't remember exactly how it ends.
- 27:30Emily Guy Birken: I mean, she ends up crying there and like and having basically a breakdown and he's like I don't this, what is this?
- 27:37Emily Guy Birken: What is this?
- 27:38Emily Guy Birken: I don't understand and I feel like that's a really good subversion of a trope that hadn't even described yet.
- 27:46Emily Guy Birken: You know it came out six years before the trope was it was was first described.
- 27:49Emily Guy Birken: But I think about that over and over and over again because that character still doesn't have a full story.
- 27:56Emily Guy Birken: Like we just see that Adrian Brody's character's bubble is burst.
- 28:00Emily Guy Birken: But we get to see that there is more to this than just what you see on the surface of this, like adorable, gorgeous, charming, quirky woman who seems to have all the answers.
- 28:16Tracie Guy-Decker: So just from your description.
- 28:18Tracie Guy-Decker: It's a little it feels like sticky in a bad way to me and so far is like, because she's fully human, she's no longer worthy of affection, of pining Like I haven't seen it.
- 28:33Tracie Guy-Decker: So I'm just reacting to what you said.
- 28:35Emily Guy Birken: Yeah, fair analysis, but it felt a little bit more like not that she wasn't deserving, it was that this was not what he thought was happening.
- 28:44Emily Guy Birken: So like he had built up this idea in his head and then he's hit with reality and it was more than he could handle, Like he was not in a position to be able to help her through whatever this breakdown was Because she was a sexy wham, but it turns out she was actually a human being.
- 29:02Emily Guy Birken: Yes, yes, so like you don't think highly of him after this, but it's not like you know.
- 29:08Emily Guy Birken: Oh, you're not worth my time, it's more like I'm over my head.
- 29:11Emily Guy Birken: That has stuck with me.
- 29:14Emily Guy Birken: I saw that movie 20 years ago and that moment is one of like two or three that I can remember from the entire film.
- 29:21Emily Guy Birken: So I know you've got a hard stop.
- 29:25Emily Guy Birken: So I want to talk about one more analysis that I find very helpful.
- 29:30Emily Guy Birken: Okay, let's hear it.
- 29:32Emily Guy Birken: It's called Fridging Women or Refrigerating Women, gail Simone, who is, believe it, novelist.
- 29:38Emily Guy Birken: She coined that term in 1994, specifically because of a Green Lantern comic book, where the Green Lantern, kyle Rainer, comes home to find his girlfriend, alexandra DeWitt, killed and stuffed in the refrigerator, and that event is his inciting incident to take revenge and go off into all of this.
- 30:05Tracie Guy-Decker: So this trope is that sort of backstory that the dead wife and kids and or kids were the reason that we're now seeing this.
- 30:14Tracie Guy-Decker: That's a very common trope, very common.
- 30:19Emily Guy Birken: Especially in a superhero.
- 30:21Tracie Guy-Decker: That's very common superhero backstories.
- 30:24Emily Guy Birken: It again reduces.
- 30:25Emily Guy Birken: Instead of women being a sexy object, it's just an inciting incident object, basically Like, okay, how are we going to get him to go on a rampage?
- 30:33Emily Guy Birken: All right, let's kill off his wife.
- 30:35Emily Guy Birken: And it's related to me, to one of my like.
- 30:40Emily Guy Birken: One of the things that drives me really nuts in books is when an author wants to show how scary a bad guy is and they want to raise the stakes so they info dump a huge amount of backstory of a character you've never met before, who's just about to die, and that is, I think, kind of a hack writing technique as a way to raise stakes.
- 31:02Emily Guy Birken: And this reminds me of that, because it's instead of like organically finding a way for this character to feel broken and feel the need to go off and do all these things, just like, oh, wham bam.
- 31:16Emily Guy Birken: Thank you, ma'am.
- 31:17Emily Guy Birken: We're going to refrigerate someone he cares about, and if it were something that only happened occasionally, that would be fine.
- 31:24Emily Guy Birken: But, for instance, I really like the Deadpool movies, but the second Deadpool movie refrigerated Vanessa, his girlfriend, and it's partially because his girlfriend needs to not be in the film for him to be Deadpool, because otherwise he'd just be happy and be weighed, whatever his last name is.
- 31:41Emily Guy Birken: That is really frustrating, because it's like why can't you come up with a better way to do that?
- 31:47Emily Guy Birken: Why do they have to be unhappy first of all to do these things?
- 31:51Emily Guy Birken: Or why can't you find a different way to make them unhappy?
- 31:54Emily Guy Birken: Or why does it have to be a death Right?
- 31:58Emily Guy Birken: You know, why can't she have the agency to like be seduced to the dark side?
- 32:05Tracie Guy-Decker: Or, you know, I don't know anything, or just like take a really good job in California and not take it with her.
- 32:10Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah, yeah, no, I think it comes up a lot Like just you're saying it.
- 32:16Tracie Guy-Decker: I'm thinking about both sort of fantasy, sci-fi, like superhero stuff, but also like Russell Crowe's gladiator refrigerated his wife.
- 32:28Emily Guy Birken: Matt Max.
- 32:29Tracie Guy-Decker: Yeah, like I think it's.
- 32:32Tracie Guy-Decker: I mean that one's a science fiction, but it feels like a very, very common Well.
- 32:37Emily Guy Birken: John Wick.
- 32:38Emily Guy Birken: I don't know if you've seen any of the John Wick movies.
- 32:40Tracie Guy-Decker: No, I haven't.
- 32:41Tracie Guy-Decker: It's a little bit different there.
- 32:43Emily Guy Birken: Yeah, his wife dies like he retires from being an assassin.
- 32:47Emily Guy Birken: His wife dies of natural causes and so she knew she was dying and so she arranged for him to get a puppy, like the day after her funeral, and someone kills the puppy.
- 33:01Tracie Guy-Decker: Oh, ok, but so it's like a step removed it's just like refrigerated with a bi-proxy yeah, yeah, no.
- 33:09Tracie Guy-Decker: And like a lot of like villains, although I'm thinking about Shang-Chi and the Seven Rings.
- 33:16Emily Guy Birken: I have a few of them the Ten Rings and the Ten.
- 33:18Tracie Guy-Decker: Rings and there's like.
- 33:21Tracie Guy-Decker: The death of the wife is the inciting incident, but she has a lot more, although it sounds like Vanessa did too.
- 33:27Emily Guy Birken: Yeah, Vanessa is a great character.
- 33:29Tracie Guy-Decker: Like there is.
- 33:29Tracie Guy-Decker: The wife actually has very much of a full like character.
- 33:35Tracie Guy-Decker: Well, I don't know if she has a full characterization, but she does have agency and exists.
- 33:41Emily Guy Birken: Kingpin's wife in Spider-Man.
- 33:43Tracie Guy-Decker: Into the Spider-Verse.
- 33:45Emily Guy Birken: She has agency because she's she's running away from him because she's horrified by who she's married to, yeah, and so the?
- 33:53Emily Guy Birken: So that's not exactly refrigerating, refrigerating, it's not exactly that.
- 33:59Emily Guy Birken: Yeah, actually I would say it's probably not because she is missing as a direct result of his actions.
- 34:06Tracie Guy-Decker: Well, except doesn't he bring her?
- 34:08Emily Guy Birken: back and she doesn't want it.
- 34:10Emily Guy Birken: He brings her back and the same thing happens because when he brings her back he's.
- 34:14Emily Guy Birken: He's still trying to hurt Spider-Man.
- 34:17Tracie Guy-Decker: I OK, I, my recollection was that she had died and then he brings up and she rejects him when she's a zombie.
- 34:23Tracie Guy-Decker: Not, but OK.
- 34:25Emily Guy Birken: No, no, no, no, it's, it's what he's using.
- 34:26Tracie Guy-Decker: The the other alternate universes.
- 34:29Emily Guy Birken: The alternate universe machine to bring an alternate universe version of her, and it's so.
- 34:34Emily Guy Birken: That's like that's a great subversion of this, like it gives us a good background.
- 34:37Emily Guy Birken: I actually really like Kingpin as a as a villain, because there is something very sympathetic about him just wanting the people he loved best in the world back, even though he was a horrible human being, and the single mindedness with which he was pursuing it was comprehensible as someone who is grieving and doesn't care who he hurts, because he's always been a sociopath, but he was able to hide it with his wife and child, and so like I think that's really really well done, whereas when you have, you know, some of these fridging, it's just like, ok, we've got that out of the way, now we know why he's he's doing the crap he's doing.
- 35:16Emily Guy Birken: It's similar to how I hate the romantic comedies that start with one character's like sister or brother-in-law or something dying and so they end up having to take in the kids, like that's.
- 35:30Emily Guy Birken: I feel like that's a similar refrigeratoring Moment, because it's like you are manipulating these characters in a way that is unnatural, just so that you can get two people who don't like each other having to raise a kid together or whatever it is, and that is it's bad storytelling is why it bothers me.
- 35:51Emily Guy Birken: But it's also like I truly believe that we owe something to our characters and that's why it bothers me when when they do the info dump one of minor characters about to die, like that character deserved better, like they do.
- 36:05Emily Guy Birken: We owe something to our characters, you know they don't exist without us and so we, if we're gonna make them suffer, it needs to be in service of something greater than just a story shortcut.
- 36:16Emily Guy Birken: So I mean, I do tend to anthropomorphize fiction.
- 36:19Emily Guy Birken: Oh, so that's quite a lot of deep thoughts.
- 36:25Emily Guy Birken: I wouldn't call it stupid shit, but it's a lot of deep thoughts.
- 36:28Emily Guy Birken: No, do you want to try to synthesize stuff for us?
- 36:32Tracie Guy-Decker: Sure, okay.
- 36:33Tracie Guy-Decker: So today we were talking about some tropes that we see and you grouped these, emily, specifically around gender.
- 36:41Tracie Guy-Decker: So I hope that we'll be able to do additional bonus episodes around other tropes or archetypes.
- 36:46Tracie Guy-Decker: For instance, we briefly touched on the hero's journey in the purge.
- 36:49Tracie Guy-Decker: It's promised today.
- 36:50Tracie Guy-Decker: Let's let's dig into those again in the future.
- 36:52Emily Guy Birken: And we've talked a little bit about like the magical negro trope and so talking about like tropes surrounding race and other yes, communities could really interesting, because I think it would also be really Fascinating to talk about like the gay best friend tropes.
- 37:05Tracie Guy-Decker: absolutely thing yeah so we will get to those in future bonus episodes Stay tuned.
- 37:09Tracie Guy-Decker: But for now we talked about the bec del test, which gives us sort of a quick and dirty like litmus test around Female representation in a piece of, in a piece of pop culture.
- 37:23Tracie Guy-Decker: We talked about the born sexy yesterday.
- 37:27Tracie Guy-Decker: Lelu from the fifth element is a an epitome of that.
- 37:31Tracie Guy-Decker: She's the poster child.
- 37:32Tracie Guy-Decker: But we're seeing it, we we saw it in other like clearly, another including including one one Mm-hmm.
- 37:38Tracie Guy-Decker: There was the manic pixie dream girl, who is a collection of quirks to be romanticized and draw our hero out of his shell.
- 37:49Tracie Guy-Decker: Mm-hmm, we talked about the refrigerated woman, who is the Dead wife or girlfriend from the backstory of our hero, or anti hero or villain, who is the so-called explanation or inciting incident for their behavior.
- 38:05Tracie Guy-Decker: And the one that I missed is Mary Sue, who is a self-insert of the author, and when we talked about it it was important for us to name that.
- 38:15Tracie Guy-Decker: There's nothing inherently wrong with the self-insert.
- 38:18Tracie Guy-Decker: What makes it actually this is true, I think, of all of these Mm-hmm.
- 38:22Tracie Guy-Decker: What makes it problematic is when it is done without Care for either the character or the integrity of the story.
- 38:33Tracie Guy-Decker: Mm-hmm, both of those things are important and when one or both of them are ignored, it feels False, inauthentic and then reifies Sexism in these cases.
- 38:46Emily Guy Birken: Yes, yes one other that you missed was the sexy lamp.
- 38:49Tracie Guy-Decker: Oh, Of course.
- 38:51Tracie Guy-Decker: How could I miss the sexy lamp If your, if the female character could be replaced with a sexy lamp, and nothing changes about the story.
- 38:59Tracie Guy-Decker: She is not a fully formed character and you should do some rewrites.
- 39:07Emily Guy Birken: Well, this has been so much fun.
- 39:09Emily Guy Birken: I I'm really excited to be doing these bonus episodes and I will see you next time.
- 39:15Emily Guy Birken: Sounds great.
- 39:17Tracie Guy-Decker: Hey there, tracy, here.
- 39:18Tracie Guy-Decker: Just a quick note to say I hope you enjoyed this first bonus episode of deep thoughts about stupid shit.
- 39:24Tracie Guy-Decker: It will not be our last Moving forward bonus episodes will exclusively be for patrons.
- 39:31Tracie Guy-Decker: We will do bonus episodes about tropes and analyses like this one, and also about somewhat more obscure pieces of pop culture, like the monster at the end of this book Featuring lovable furry old Grover.
- 39:45Tracie Guy-Decker: Head on over to our patreon link in the show notes if you're interested in getting all the bonus content.
- 39:50Tracie Guy-Decker: Thanks for listening.
- 39:53Tracie Guy-Decker: Our theme music is professor umlaut by Kevin MacLeod from in compateccom.
- 39:57Tracie Guy-Decker: Find full music credits in the show notes.
- 40:00Tracie Guy-Decker: Deep thoughts is a labor of love, but that doesn't make it free to produce.
- 40:05Tracie Guy-Decker: You can help keep us overthinking.
- 40:07Tracie Guy-Decker: Support us through our patreon with a link in the show notes.
- 40:10Tracie Guy-Decker: Leave a positive review so others can find us and share the show with your people.
- 40:16Tracie Guy-Decker: Until next time, remember Pop culture is still culture, and shouldn't you know what's in your head?