Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / Nico Slobinsky: Comparisons to atrocities are hurtful and harmful
Transcript
- 0:02Check podcasts. Hey folks, my name is Mohameir and this is Van Color,
- 0:20British Columbia's bonafide culture and politics TV talk show. Tonight, we'll look
- 0:25at the state of discourse and debate BC Green's leader Sonia. First to know,
- 0:29we'll be here to discuss why she was brought to tears in the BC
- 0:32legislature last week. But first, when we discuss difficult topics, current events,
- 0:38or polarizing political figures, are we too cavalier or casual in invoking historical
- 0:43atrocities? An aspiring BC political candidate recently had to resign after liking a Twitter
- 0:49post comparing doctor Bonnie Henry to a Nazi doctor. A few years ago,
- 0:54a BC mayor found themselves in hot water after comparing gun owners to Holocaust victims.
- 1:00Earlier this year, a video surface of Alberta's premier comparing vaccinated Albertons to
- 1:04Hitler supporters. Why do people, even those who know better, keep doing
- 1:10this? Joining us to discuss is the vice president of the Center for Israel
- 1:14and Jewish Affairs. He is Nico Slabinski. Thank you for having me.
- 1:19Nico, Hello and Shalom. Nice to have you here. Thank you for
- 1:22having me. Thank you. Now you're familiar with Godwin's law, the idea
- 1:26that a longer conversation continues online, eventually someone will call the other person hitler
- 1:33or a Nazi. And I feel like it's funny on one end, because
- 1:37you and I are both online we've seen this play out. But it is
- 1:40troubling on the other because why do we have this weird tendency to get into
- 1:45an argument with someone and then immediately go to like the worst possible comparison.
- 1:49Right, That is a really good question. I would say that for anyone
- 1:53that is having those kinds of conversations online, my suggestion is just don't have
- 1:57them right at the same time. Why does that happen? It's something that
- 2:02I've been asking myself for a very long time. I understand that it's natural
- 2:07for people to compare things. We have all done it. I guess that
- 2:09in some respects, you could say we're all guilty of the same thing.
- 2:14Right. Comparing things makes it easy for us to categorize one thing or another
- 2:19because it's not this or it's that, because we have a measured measuring tool
- 2:23to compare it to something. What troubles me is that a lot of its
- 2:28comparisons tend to be anchored in comparisons to genocide kind of has eight recognized genocide,
- 2:35and depending on the day of the month, you could go and scroll
- 2:38online and you will find these comparisons on any of them. I can speak
- 2:44to you about our own experience, which is what we see a lot of
- 2:46its comparisons to Holocaust. And let's get into that, because again, as
- 2:51you said, it is kind of a human tendency to compare and contrast things.
- 2:54But when we are talking about things like atrocities or just things that are
- 3:00very sensitive to certain communities, why should we second guess ourselves or refrain from
- 3:06using these type of comparisons or analogies, whether it's you know, comparing things
- 3:09to the Holocaust or any other you know, tragedy or atrocity particular to Holocaust
- 3:15comparisons. What you are doing when you do that, you are diminishing the
- 3:22historical record of the Holocaust. And in many cases, particularly here in Vancouver
- 3:27and in many cities across North America, we have survival populations that are still
- 3:30living with us Holocaust survivals themselves and their descendants. And when we are comparing
- 3:36actual day news or events to the Holocaust and the historical record of the Holocaust.
- 3:42When you are doing that, you're also also forcing these people to relieve
- 3:46through their trauma, right, and that is something that is very hurtful and
- 3:50unfortunately. We saw a lot of this during COVID nineteen and the pandemic.
- 3:53Right Like we saw you know, anti vax protesters putting on you know,
- 3:59Star of David like things on their on their shirts or jackets, so that
- 4:02was causing a lot of harm to your community. We did see this a
- 4:05lot through the pandemic. We saw this fueling rise of anti semitism during the
- 4:11pandemic. Also, these comparisons actually fuel bigotry or antisemitis. You know what,
- 4:15I always say that while words are free, they're not free of consequence.
- 4:20And during the pandemic what we saw is exactly what you described. We
- 4:23saw, for example, public health orders or vaccine mandates being compared to Jews
- 4:30having to words the start of David, the yellow Star of David during the
- 4:32Holocaust. Now, the start of David was made to be worn by Jews
- 4:36in order to identify them, to classify them as others, and then to
- 4:42send them to extermination camps. Let me be clear whether or not you agree
- 4:45with vaccine mandates or with public health orders those who are designed to preserve life
- 4:50and saved life. Right, those are two very differy different things that should
- 4:55never be compared. It almost feels like even if you are compared, you
- 5:00know, one atrocity with another atrocity, we just shouldn't do that anyways,
- 5:04right, Like we should talk about things independently without the need for you know,
- 5:10drawing on another community's experience. I would agree to that. I would
- 5:15say that, you know, if you want to compare something, you don't
- 5:16need a measuring tool to do that. Something can be bad for what it
- 5:20is, or you can be right on your own merits. You don't need
- 5:24to compare to something else to prove your case. And my advice to everybody
- 5:28doing that is like, there's something that just don't do it. Don't compare
- 5:31anything to genocide. Right. You do not want to cause people to relieve
- 5:36through their trauma of their genocide, whether it is the Holocaust or one of
- 5:41the other seven genocides recognized by the Government of Canada. You do not want
- 5:45to put survivors under descendants through that experience again and again and again. You
- 5:49do not want to chipen the memories and the historical record of that traumatic event,
- 5:57and we need to learn from that history, so we do not repeat
- 6:00that history. And the further away we go from the actual historical event,
- 6:04in this case, the Holocaust is now. You know, we're talking about
- 6:08seventy eight years ago. Although there are still survivors that are a lot,
- 6:12they are still with us, it's not that long ago, and we have
- 6:15the responsibility right to carry that education and that memory in a way that serves
- 6:20generations of British Columbians to come. Is the larger problem that we're just too
- 6:26cavalier and too casual with words and terminology in general. Because I've talked to
- 6:30some of my black friends and they also don't like when people use the term
- 6:34slave or invoke slavery in a very casual way. And I never thought about
- 6:40it until they brought it up right. It was that conversation that helped me
- 6:43realize that, yeah, that is invoking a very painful memory for a lot
- 6:46of people, or certainly a painful history for a lot of people. So
- 6:50is the larger problem that we're just not conscious of the words that we're actually
- 6:55using. That perhaps is the case in many situations. You know, I
- 6:58recognized that language changes and evolves over time, and that I think it's an
- 7:02important recognition that we need to be mindful of. I think that in some
- 7:06ways language has changed and evolved for the better. You know, if you
- 7:10take the example of how do we speak to you about certain you know,
- 7:13minorities like the LGBTQ or the neurodiverse populations, I think that, uh,
- 7:18the evolvo language has served us for the better. M Absolutely, we talk
- 7:24much better about those things today than we did in the past, all right,
- 7:27and in some other cases we don't. And this is where what you
- 7:30and I are discussion comes into play, and where we need to be more
- 7:32careful about the impact that our words have, because they're not free and they
- 7:39do carry consequences. Absolutely, Nico, this was a pleasure. Thank you
- 7:43for this conversation. I think it's important and I hope that all of the
- 7:46viewers watching this right now do consider the language that they use, the comparisons
- 7:50that they make. So thank you so much for your time tonight. Thank
- 7:53you for having me more folks. He is the vice president of the Center
- 7:58for Israel and Jewish Affairs. Is Nico Slovinski now after some business, BC
- 8:03Greens leader Sonia First to Know will be here to discuss why you, as
- 8:05a British Columbian, should be concerned by what happened last week in the BC
- 8:11legislature. That's up next