Latest / Stage Talks with Bellingcat / "Detecting Stolen Art" with Arthur Brand
Transcript
- 0:04You're listening to a stage talk titled Detecting
- 0:07Stolen Art. This week we're joined by art detective
- 0:10Arthur Brans. He, alongside law enforcement,
- 0:13uncovered more than 200 stolen artworks over
- 0:16his career, from a stolen Picasso to statues
- 0:19owned by Hitler, that disappeared after the war.
- 0:22He was able to find them. And, he says, anyone
- 0:25would be able to do what he does. In this stage
- 0:28talk he explains how open sources are crucial
- 0:30to his work, and he shares valuable resources
- 0:33for those who are curious about the world of
- 0:36art crime themselves. This talk was hosted by
- 0:39me, Merel Zut, on Thursday the 31st of July 2025,
- 0:43in the Bellingcat Discord server. Hello everyone,
- 0:54welcome back to our stage talks. Today we're
- 0:58speaking to an art detective which I think might
- 1:01be one of the coolest job titles there is. Artur
- 1:05Brandt has recovered over 200 stolen artworks
- 1:08throughout his career. These include famous paintings
- 1:11once thought lost from Dalí's to Picasso's. He
- 1:14uses an array of different techniques to uncover
- 1:17where these pieces may have ended up. from going
- 1:19undercover on the black market to more traditional
- 1:22open source methods. Arthur also works alongside
- 1:25law enforcement in their pursuit of the thieves
- 1:27providing expertise and guidance. Despite years
- 1:30of experience he still maintains that this role
- 1:32is something anyone could be doing and therefore
- 1:35Arthur will talk us through his methods using
- 1:37a real case he worked on and he'll explain how
- 1:40open sources played an important role in solving
- 1:43the mysteries. If you have any questions while
- 1:45he speaks please put them in the chat. And if
- 1:47you don't want me to share your username, make
- 1:50sure to share this as well in your questions
- 1:52so I leave your name out. And due to the complexity
- 1:55and volume of Arthur's work in the Q &A section,
- 1:58Arthur will only be answering questions on specific
- 2:01cases that he has already mentioned in the talk.
- 2:03We don't unfortunately have time to dig into
- 2:05all his work. If you want to learn about other
- 2:07cases not mentioned, you can read Arthur's book
- 2:10on Hitler's Horses, which we'll put a link for
- 2:14in the chat, or you can follow him on social
- 2:15media. Of course, we will have time to dive into
- 2:17how and why Artur does what he does. And with
- 2:21that in mind, please, Arthur, if you want to
- 2:23go ahead and share your story and your work,
- 2:27you can go ahead now. Okay. Well, everybody,
- 2:32thank you for joining. My name is Arthur Brand,
- 2:35called Art Detective. It's not really a title.
- 2:38You cannot go to university to become an art
- 2:41detective. It's just... the title that they gave
- 2:45me. I'm working very close with police forces
- 2:50all over the world to track down stolen art or
- 2:54fake art. And the topic that I chose for today
- 2:57is a recent case that I cracked together with
- 3:00the police. It was this year and I chose this
- 3:04one because it has a lot of juicy details, but
- 3:08also we cracked it through the use of open sources,
- 3:11which means that you could do the same. So let's
- 3:16start with this case. You see now for the people
- 3:20who are watching now, you see now a small painting
- 3:24on screen and it started with this. This is a
- 3:28news article. You see a small painting. It says
- 3:33After 40 years, this painting is first to be
- 3:36seen again for the public. It was a Dutch museum
- 3:39who was publishing or was exhibiting this particular
- 3:43work. And it was made by Pieter Bruegel, a very
- 3:47important, famous Dutch painter. And to describe
- 3:52the painting for the people who are listening
- 3:54and not watching, you see a peasant woman in
- 3:58a summer landscape. She's wearing two things,
- 4:01a bucket of water in one hand, And a pair of
- 4:06tongs with drawing pieces of charcoal in the
- 4:10other hand. And that's an old Dutch proverb which
- 4:13says, don't trust anybody with water in one hand
- 4:17and fire in the other hand. So this painting,
- 4:20a very important painting from Pieter Bruegel,
- 4:22as said in the newspaper, was first shown after
- 4:2540 years. There was this man, John Brosius, he
- 4:29works for a Dutch magazine called Find. And he
- 4:32wanted to write an article about this particular
- 4:34painting. So he started searching for more information
- 4:37with the title, but he couldn't find anything
- 4:39on the internet, which is not that strange because
- 4:42many of the paintings from the 16th, 17th, 18th
- 4:45century do not have a name. They were just painted.
- 4:49So the names were put on later. So he couldn't
- 4:52find anything on the internet, but he didn't
- 4:55give up. So he did a reverse image search with
- 4:59this picture from this newspaper. But as you
- 5:04can see, the painting is shot from the side.
- 5:08You cannot see it very well. So that didn't work
- 5:11either. So most people would have given up at
- 5:15this moment, but John Brosey has walked that
- 5:17extra mile. So he edited the picture and you
- 5:21can see that here. He turned it up and then he
- 5:23put it again through Google images. That's a
- 5:25good lesson. You never should give up, you know.
- 5:27Try everything to get what you want to do. And
- 5:30when he put this image to Google search, he got
- 5:33a hit. And he watched the painting and he thought,
- 5:35well, this probably is the same painting. It's
- 5:38a woman carrying embers and it looks quite similar.
- 5:42So he started reading through Google Translate.
- 5:45And the story that he read was quite explosive.
- 5:49The story said that this painting, woman carrying
- 5:52embers, was in the possession of a museum in
- 5:55Gdansk in Poland in World War II in 1944. You
- 6:00know, in World War II, there was a lot of stolen
- 6:03art, et cetera. We all know these stories. So
- 6:06he got interested. He thought, how can it be
- 6:08that a painting that was in 1944 in a museum
- 6:11in Poland can now be on exhibition in a Dutch
- 6:15museum? The Dutch museum got it from a Dutch
- 6:17family. It was in the possession of a Dutch family
- 6:20who had lent it out to this museum. So he thought,
- 6:23how can that be? But when he read more about
- 6:28the article, he found out that there were more
- 6:30disturbing things. In 1974, on April 24, a cleaning
- 6:35lady was working in this museum in Poland, in
- 6:39the room where this painting of Bruegel was hanging
- 6:42on the wall. And in a moment of inattention,
- 6:44she knocks the Bruegel from the wall. The glass
- 6:48panel protecting this painting shatters into
- 6:51countless pieces on the floor. And you can imagine
- 6:54the cleaning lady was shaking. She thought, oh
- 6:57my God, we are talking about 1974, Poland was
- 7:00communist country. So she thought, oh my God,
- 7:04this is so bad news. So she called the curator.
- 7:07The curator stepped in and she and the curator
- 7:10both feared for their job. In communist Poland,
- 7:13you could go to prison for destroying cultural
- 7:15heritage. The curator leans forward to the floor.
- 7:19With trembling hands, he picks up the painting.
- 7:22And to his great surprise, the painting feels
- 7:24like thin paper. And then he looks better and
- 7:29he sees that instead of a painting, he has reproduction
- 7:33in his hands, cut from a magazine. And then,
- 7:37of course, the penny drops. The painting had
- 7:39been stolen weeks or months before and had been
- 7:42replaced by a copy from a magazine, of course,
- 7:46to mask a theft. So the cleaning lady, of course,
- 7:49was relieved. She thought, my God, I just uncovered
- 7:52a theft, but at least I didn't destroy the painting.
- 7:55But the story gets darker. Of course, the police
- 7:58starts investigating in 1974, the Polish police,
- 8:02this theft, and then somebody calls in, and that's
- 8:05Romwald Werner. Here you see a picture of Romwald
- 8:08Werner. Romwald Werner was working for the state
- 8:12in the port of Gdansk. And after the theft, he
- 8:16read about it in the newspaper, he called the
- 8:18police and he said, I'm working in a port here,
- 8:21but there are some people in this port smuggling
- 8:25stolen art abroad. You must understand that in
- 8:31communist Poland 74, you know who dared to steal
- 8:34a painting and who had the connections to smuggle
- 8:38them abroad. So, Ronald Werner thought that maybe
- 8:42the Secret Service was involved. So, he called
- 8:44the police and the police ordered him in for
- 8:47questioning. Ten minutes before he would enter
- 8:51the police station, some people nearby, employees
- 8:54from a cemetery, heard somebody screaming. They
- 8:58went outside and they saw somebody waving. screaming
- 9:03he was full of flames somebody had put petrol
- 9:05over him and he was standing there he fell down
- 9:09and he died and that person was Romuald Werner.
- 9:14So it appears according to this article that
- 9:16some people didn't want him to go to the police
- 9:19to tell about this theft. The Secret Service
- 9:23then closed the case Which is strange, of course,
- 9:26you know, it gave more suspicion to the idea
- 9:29that the secret service was involved in the theft
- 9:32of the Bruegel. So Brozius, the Dutch guy who
- 9:38was reading this article to Google translate,
- 9:42you know, he was shocked. He thought, oh my God,
- 9:44this painting was in the war. It was in Poland
- 9:47until 1974. Then it was stolen. Somebody got
- 9:51murdered. So he was quite shocked. But the article
- 9:55said one more thing, that Bruegel painted six
- 10:00similar paintings of a woman carrying embers.
- 10:06So Brozis was not sure that the painting that
- 10:09was now shown in the Netherlands was the same
- 10:11painting that was being talked about in the article.
- 10:15So he thought, well, let's contact the Dutch
- 10:18Museum, who is now exhibiting this painting.
- 10:22So he wrote them an email, but he got no response.
- 10:25And he thought, well, sure they have read this
- 10:28email and they probably figured out that these
- 10:32two are not the same. Probably the one in the
- 10:35Netherlands is one of the other five similar
- 10:38paintings. But little did he know that nobody
- 10:41read his email because the person who shoot was
- 10:44on sick leave. So normally here the story ends.
- 10:49Nobody would have discovered this. But here is
- 10:51a lesson make yourself known. In the last 15
- 10:55years, I have done a lot of interviews. I have
- 10:58my own series on Dutch television. People think
- 11:00I'm an expert. So I always give the message that
- 11:06you can contact me if you have questions. Luckily
- 11:09for me, Brocers, after half a year, he remembered
- 11:14this case and he thought, well, I know this artifact.
- 11:17Let's give him a call. You never know. So Brooches
- 11:21called me and told me the story and I was intrigued
- 11:23of course, you know, World War II, Bruchel, that's
- 11:26not a, you know, it's quite a big name, a murder,
- 11:30probably involvement of the secret service. So
- 11:33I started to read about this story and I of course
- 11:38also thought that the museum had read this email
- 11:40and that most likely the Bruchel in the Netherlands
- 11:44was not identical, was not the same one that
- 11:47had been stolen in Poland, but one of the five
- 11:49others. Roses could not find the five others,
- 11:52so I started looking for the five others. There
- 11:55are a lot of websites where you can find art.
- 12:00One of them is the RKD, which is a huge archive
- 12:04with hundreds of thousands of paintings. So it
- 12:08took me three days, but finally I got the other
- 12:11five identical ones. This is one of them. As
- 12:16you can see, this is also a woman carrying ambus.
- 12:20It's almost identical to the one that was stolen
- 12:23in Poland, but you can see it's not a summer
- 12:26landscape, but a winter landscape. I found all
- 12:28the other five and I was now sure, comparing
- 12:33them all together, that the one in Poland, stolen
- 12:36in Poland in 1974, was indeed the same one that
- 12:41was now in the Netherlands. What did I do? I
- 12:46called the police because, you know, this painting
- 12:49was stolen in 1974 in Poland. I also found that
- 12:53it was, this is this picture. You can see it.
- 12:55This is the list of Poland's most wanted pieces
- 12:59of art. And on the bottom left, you can see woman
- 13:03carrying embers of Bruegel. So, it was a very
- 13:07important painting for Poland, national heritage.
- 13:10So, I called the police and the police checked
- 13:13my findings and they went to the Dutch Museum
- 13:16to secure the painting. Well, you would think
- 13:20that the story ends here. It was stolen, it was
- 13:24secured by the Dutch police, but in my field,
- 13:28in tracking stolen art, there was always a new
- 13:31twist. Because the first question was, Could
- 13:35Poland claim the painting? If the Dutch owners
- 13:39could prove that they had bought the painting
- 13:4230, 40, 50 years ago in good faith, according
- 13:48to Dutch law, there would be a problem because
- 13:50there is something called statute of limitations.
- 13:53That means that certain crimes after a certain
- 13:55period of time, cannot be prosecuted anymore.
- 13:59That means that when you steal something in the
- 14:02Netherlands after 12 years, you cannot prosecute
- 14:05the thieves anymore. And as the theft had occurred
- 14:09in 74, the statute of limitations both in the
- 14:13Netherlands and Poland about theft had expired.
- 14:18But of course, there was the murder of Ronald
- 14:21Werner, most likely linked to this case, to this
- 14:25theft. So there was a chance, you know, because
- 14:28normally murder doesn't reach the statute of
- 14:30limitations, but unfortunately in Poland it expires
- 14:34after 30 years. So you would think, well, we
- 14:39have a problem here because legally the owners
- 14:42in the Netherlands would keep his stolen painting.
- 14:47But I did some more research, of course, using
- 14:49Google Translate because I don't speak Polish.
- 14:53And then I found something Interesting because
- 14:56Poland has a special law and that says that all
- 15:00crimes committed during the communist era in
- 15:04Poland, which ended in 1989, never expire. So
- 15:11this would mean that Poland could reclaim the
- 15:16painting. It belonged to them, although it had
- 15:18been expired according to normal law. because
- 15:21of this special Polish law, it had not been expired.
- 15:26But I said in my field of work, there was always
- 15:31a new surprise because I was triggered by the
- 15:34fact that, as I told before, that the museum
- 15:38in Poland had bought the painting, had acquired
- 15:41this painting in 1944 during World War II. And
- 15:46we all know World War II, millions of artworks
- 15:49have been stolen mostly from Jews. So there could
- 15:54be something tricky there. And we did some more
- 15:57research and to our big surprise we found out
- 16:00that the painting indeed before the war had been
- 16:04in the possession in the collection of a Dutch
- 16:06family. Of course it's not the same Dutch family
- 16:09who was now in possession. But before the war
- 16:11between 1932 and 1941 the painting had been in
- 16:16Holland. owned by a Dutch family. And here you
- 16:20can see a picture when this painting by Brugge
- 16:24was in their collection in 1941. We did some
- 16:29more research, open sources. All this open source
- 16:32is what we did. And we found that there was This
- 16:37was also a big surprise that indeed this family
- 16:40had claimed that their entire collection had
- 16:43been not stolen, but they had sold it to the
- 16:46Germans in 1941, but they said it was under pressure.
- 16:51You know, if the Germans, the Nazis came to you
- 16:53and said, we want this painting, we offer you
- 16:55this amount of money, you hardly could say no,
- 16:57you know, because if you would say no, you would
- 16:59be in big problems. After the war, the family
- 17:04went to the Dutch state and said our whole collection,
- 17:07including a Bruegel was sold best to the Germans,
- 17:12but it had not been done voluntarily. And this,
- 17:17of course, would mean that the painting, although
- 17:20it was stolen in 1974 in Poland, it had stolen
- 17:24before in 1941 by the Germans. So in that case,
- 17:28the painting should not go back to Poland. but
- 17:31to the family in the Netherlands. So we did some
- 17:35more research also on open sources and we found
- 17:40the website of the Dutch Restitution Commission.
- 17:43In the Netherlands, we have a restitution commission.
- 17:47It's a state institution. And they had looks
- 17:5110, 15 years ago into the case of this Dutch
- 17:54family who had lost or what sold their entire
- 17:56collection, including the Brugel. to the Nazis
- 18:00and the Dutch state denied the claim. They said
- 18:05look you sold it to the Nazis but we have found
- 18:08no proof that it was not voluntarily. Which means
- 18:13that this Dutch family could not reclaim anything
- 18:17of the collection in the future. So case closed
- 18:22you would say because The Dutch family could
- 18:25not reclaim the painting, which means it should
- 18:27go back to Poland. But another problem came up.
- 18:36As said, the Dutch state had said that the Dutch
- 18:41family had sold it voluntarily to the Nazis.
- 18:46brought it to Reichsmarschall Goering. You see
- 18:49his picture. He is standing next to Hitler watching
- 18:51art. Goering was a real art lover. And Goering
- 18:57then transported this painting in 1944 to the
- 19:01Museum in Rysdansk in Poland, what we have read
- 19:04before. At that time, that museum was owned by
- 19:08the Nazis. So the Dutch state had concluded that
- 19:12the Nazis had bought this painting legally. And
- 19:16this could mean, I know it sounds strange, but
- 19:20that the Nazis were the legal owners because
- 19:24they had paid for it. Of course, the Nazis do
- 19:27not exist anymore. But if you do a little bit
- 19:30more research, also through open sources, you
- 19:32will find that the current German government
- 19:35is the legal successor of the Third Reich. And
- 19:39that means two things. They had to pay compensations
- 19:42to the victims of the Nazis, mostly Jews, of
- 19:44course. But on the other hand, everything that
- 19:47was legally owned by the Nazis should go back
- 19:51to the current German state. I know it sounds
- 19:54crazy, but that's just the way it is. But I'm
- 19:58sure that in this case, you know, I cannot think
- 20:01that the German state will claim this painting,
- 20:04you know, it would be a scandal, of course. So
- 20:07my guess is that this painting, which is still
- 20:10in the Netherlands, will eventually go back to
- 20:13Poland. to dance to the museum there. And I said
- 20:16it's considered there as cultural heritage. It's
- 20:19one of the most important paintings from that
- 20:22museum. So it's still open what will be decided.
- 20:27But if you want to follow this story more, you
- 20:28can follow my socials. But of course, you can
- 20:32also read press articles about it. There has
- 20:34been press articles in many languages about this
- 20:38story. I told this story to show you that these
- 20:42stories have A lot of juicy details, you know.
- 20:45Well, murder is not really juicy, but you know
- 20:48what I mean. World War II, the Nazis, a Dutch
- 20:52family, a mass theft, the cleaning lady who accidentally
- 20:57kicks off this painting from the wall. Everything
- 21:02is in it. And if you give it time and you have
- 21:05the skills and you are determined to follow up
- 21:09on such stories, you know, you could do what
- 21:13we did in this story. So this was my case for
- 21:17today and now I go back to Merel for the questions.
- 21:22Thank you Arthur. It's a fascinating story and
- 21:25I think there are some questions coming in from
- 21:27the chat right now. The first question is very
- 21:30straightforward. Is the painting still on the
- 21:32display now and I'm curious also where? Yes,
- 21:36the painting is still in the museum in the Netherlands.
- 21:38It has been secured by the Dutch police. And
- 21:42well, as you have heard from my story, it's a
- 21:45very complicated legal issue. The Dutch family
- 21:49who sold the collection As they said under Dures,
- 21:54not voluntarily, they might appeal the Dutch
- 21:57decision from 10, 15 years ago that their collection
- 22:00was not seized by the Germans. So that can happen.
- 22:03The Dutch family, who's the current owner of
- 22:05the painting, could say, look, it might not have
- 22:09reached the statute of limitations in Poland
- 22:11because of that special Polish law, but according
- 22:14to Dutch law, we are the owners. So there are
- 22:18still a lot, maybe even Germany will reclaim
- 22:21the painting. So there is still a lot to do.
- 22:24I drove the police and I who did this together.
- 22:28I heard from the prosecutor that we drive her
- 22:30nuts because, you know, it's such a complicated
- 22:33story. So at the moment it's still in the Dutch
- 22:35Museum. But my guess is that eventually it will
- 22:38go back to Poland. And I think it belongs there.
- 22:43Cyber 4 and 6Pi. asked in the chat how important
- 22:48was it that you essentially lived in the same
- 22:50areas as the artwork or that you know about Dutch
- 22:54law perhaps? Well not at all. I'm a little bit
- 22:59older than I think most of the people in the
- 23:01public. I'm still from from an era that there
- 23:04was no internet. But in these days, you know,
- 23:08you can find anything everywhere around the world.
- 23:11And with Google Translate or other means for
- 23:16translating other languages, you can find anything
- 23:21everywhere in the world. I found pieces in South
- 23:24America. I found pieces in South Korea. So in
- 23:29this case, you know, this John Brosius this guy
- 23:33who started his investigation, he just was interested
- 23:37by this painting, you know, a very important
- 23:39painting that turned up after 40 years. He didn't
- 23:43suspect anything. When I would have read this
- 23:46article, I would because, you know, most paintings
- 23:49are not hidden for 40 years. Of course, in some
- 23:52cases, yes, because a family owes a painting
- 23:55and they sell it after 40, 50 years. But normally
- 23:58it's known where important paintings are. So
- 24:02if you read something about a painting in a small
- 24:04newspaper that a painting resurfaced after 40
- 24:07years, well, it might trigger you to get interested,
- 24:10you know, and then you start searching for it.
- 24:13And I think that of 50 % of all the cases that
- 24:16I cracked, I used open sources. And people always
- 24:22think that I have some special talent. I don't.
- 24:25is just using your, you should be determined.
- 24:30Of course, you should build up a network of people.
- 24:32Well, we are here at Bellingcat, that's already
- 24:35a network, but you know, everyone could have
- 24:39found this painting. I think that's exactly the
- 24:43type of mindset that a lot of people in this
- 24:45server and at Bellingcat are following. And that's
- 24:49also why I see some people asking in the chat,
- 24:52and maybe you could talk first a bit about How
- 24:55do you start with an investigation? Because you
- 24:58said, you explained you tried to get your name
- 25:00out there, people come to you with clues and
- 25:04information. Is that how you usually start or
- 25:07do you also sometimes just stumble upon something
- 25:09on the internet and start digging into there?
- 25:12Well, both. I of course know the wet flags, you
- 25:15know, sometimes I read something about something
- 25:18and I think, well, this sounds tricky. But in
- 25:21most cases, not in most cases, but in some cases
- 25:23I'm being called even by students, art history,
- 25:28you know, from the United States who tell me,
- 25:30look, I have an uncle who called me because he
- 25:33thinks I'm an expert, I'm studying art and he
- 25:35has a problem with a certain painting which might
- 25:38have a shady history. And then he contacts me.
- 25:43If people, if you are out there on the internet,
- 25:47you know, it's like Bellingcat. They are doing
- 25:49the same. If people know that you exist, people
- 25:52from your surroundings might come to you with
- 25:55questions. So that could be the first link. But
- 25:58if you start, there are entire websites like
- 26:01lostart .de, which has thousands of black and
- 26:06white pictures of paintings stolen during World
- 26:09War Two. And they are still missing. And I know
- 26:13of some people who are like me, you know, we
- 26:17don't have any other hobby than searching stolen
- 26:20art. And they go from picture to picture and
- 26:23do reverse image search. And once in a while,
- 26:27they come up with a story of a painting, a painting
- 26:30that might have been stolen by the Nazis in Poland,
- 26:33and turns up somewhere in the Netherlands or
- 26:35in Japan. So there is so much there out there,
- 26:39so many venues where you can start, you can read
- 26:43about it. And I think, you know, who doesn't
- 26:46love art, who doesn't love history, the stories,
- 26:50and who doesn't love crime stories? So this comes
- 26:55all together here, you know. I have other paintings
- 26:59now, we are working on that, paintings that had
- 27:02been in the hands of Adolf Hitler, for example.
- 27:06So, you know, these stories are so great. It's
- 27:10about the beauty of art and the bad things of
- 27:13crime. And I think, you know, if you're determined,
- 27:16if you can make this your hobby, if you have
- 27:18a few hours to... to kill in the weekend, you
- 27:22know, it's such a fascinating world. And there
- 27:25is still so much to find out, you know, I said
- 27:29www .lostart .de, you can find hundreds of thousands
- 27:34of paintings which have been lost, but I think
- 27:38half of them are still out there. And with reverse
- 27:42image search, Maybe someone in the public is
- 27:46going to do that tonight, and maybe in two or
- 27:49three days, he or she finds a painting stolen
- 27:52from a museum, let's say in France, and he or
- 27:57she finds them now in the collection of an American
- 28:00museum. We have done that. And the feeling when
- 28:04you have this hit, it's the best feeling you
- 28:08can get. You spoke a bit about some red flags
- 28:12and telltale signs that you look for when you
- 28:15think, hey, this is a fishy story. AlpIntel asks
- 28:19in the chat, what would be telltale signs and
- 28:22tools to preliminarily, sorry, that word I struggle
- 28:27with, detect forgeries. So they mentioned UV
- 28:31lights, radio code, GEMMAs, spectrometers. Can
- 28:35you tell anything about these? Feltail signs.
- 28:39Yeah. Yeah. Forgeries are very spectacular. Some
- 28:43people say, I say that too, that 30%, three zero
- 28:48of all the art which you can find on the internet
- 28:52or at auction houses or at museums is fake or
- 28:56misattributed. 30%. Of course, if you go to an
- 29:01auction house with a good name like Sotheby's
- 29:03or Christie's, It's not 30%, it's less, but in
- 29:07other auction houses, it's more than 30%. So
- 29:1030 % of all the art on the market is fake. And
- 29:14there are a lot of ways to find out. You have,
- 29:18of course, technical ways. You can go to a laboratorium
- 29:21and to check certain technical stuff. I'm not
- 29:25an expert in that. but that doesn't hold me back.
- 29:29I was once called by a person who said, Arthur,
- 29:32can you help me find out if a certain piece of
- 29:35art that I own is a fake? And I said, sure. And
- 29:39she said, it was a woman, she said, but how can
- 29:42you know? I didn't even tell you which piece
- 29:45of art it is. How can you be an expert in everything,
- 29:49you know, because you have paintings, you have
- 29:51statues, you have everything. And she said, So
- 29:54you know a lot of experts. And I said, yeah,
- 29:56yeah, I do know, but that's not the way I work.
- 29:58And she said, but how do you work? I said, well,
- 30:01what I always do is when somebody offers me a
- 30:04painting, I do some research and try to find
- 30:07out who has faked these paintings in the past.
- 30:10I'm now doing this work for 15 or 20 years. So
- 30:13in my red book, I have like a hundred forges
- 30:16with a telephone number, and I just give them
- 30:19a call. You know, that's how I start. So I call.
- 30:21If there was a Giacometti popping up on the market,
- 30:24there was a very famous Giacometti forger who
- 30:26was sentenced in Germany to four years in jail.
- 30:30I have his email address. So I sent him a picture
- 30:33and I say, Robert, his name is Robert Dreesen,
- 30:36a very famous forger. Is this piece real? I cannot
- 30:40ask him, did you fake it or did you force it
- 30:42because then he would incriminate himself. But
- 30:45if I ask him, is this piece real? And he sends
- 30:48back, no. I know that the piece is fake and that
- 30:53he made it. So there are a lot of ways to find
- 30:55out if a piece is fake. Read about forges, see
- 30:59what the techniques are. You can always go to
- 31:02a laboratory and ask them to test it, but there
- 31:04are so many red flags that can pop up. Many fakes
- 31:09that are now on the market, they always have
- 31:12the story that it was, when you turn the painting,
- 31:17You see always a fake stamp of the Nazis. They
- 31:23have to come up the forges with an explanation
- 31:25that this new fake, which they say that it's
- 31:29a very old master, that it has not been on the
- 31:32market, has not been seen for 40, 50 years. That's
- 31:35of course normal because it was fake yesterday,
- 31:38but they have to make up a story that it was
- 31:41hidden somewhere. In these days, you see a lot
- 31:44of these paintings with a fake German Nazi stamp
- 31:49on the back. So if you Google a little bit, you
- 31:51see, oh my God, there are more of these pieces
- 31:54on the market. Other pieces that show up have
- 31:57strange provenances. A provenance is the history
- 32:00of ownership of a painting. If a painting has
- 32:03been faked, of course, it's just a week on the
- 32:07market. So it was not in the hands 40 years ago
- 32:10of someone. a big collector. So what they always
- 32:13say is it was in the possession of General Franco
- 32:18or Mussolini or Ceausescu. So they always come
- 32:21up with these stories. So, and if you read books
- 32:24about forgeries and there are many on it, one
- 32:27of them is from Noah Charney from Arca. You also
- 32:30should follow Arca. They are very good in this.
- 32:34You will see the tricks and you will see the
- 32:37red flags. And I think that detecting forgeries
- 32:41is even more interesting than trying to find
- 32:45stolen art. Thank you. I have another question
- 32:50in the chat from Chris, who asks, of the 25 objects
- 32:54you helped to return to the National Archives
- 32:56of the Netherlands, which one had the most impact
- 32:58on you and why? Three weeks ago, I recovered
- 33:01together with the Dutch police. I always work
- 33:03with the police. Every step I do, I do with the
- 33:05police. That's an important lesson because if
- 33:08you go hunting for criminals or for stolen art,
- 33:11you are civilian, you know, and you have to follow
- 33:15the law. So it's always good to have very good
- 33:17relations with your local police force. You inform
- 33:21them what you're going to do, et cetera. But
- 33:23in this case, with the stuff stolen from the
- 33:26Dutch National Archives, It was in somebody's
- 33:30cellar and this person was more or less dying.
- 33:36So family members were searching the cellar and
- 33:39they discovered an old box with old paper works
- 33:43and they thought, well, it might be stolen. And
- 33:46what you see in most cases is that people do
- 33:49not want to get involved, especially when they
- 33:51are innocent. So then they destroy these pieces
- 33:55of art. I always give the message out, before
- 34:00you destroy stolen art, give me or somebody else
- 34:04at ARCA or whatever, give us a call, let's discuss
- 34:08it. Maybe there's a way out for you to bring
- 34:11it back. And in this case that happened and it
- 34:15turned out that in this box, there were some
- 34:18pieces that were declared world heritage by UNESCO,
- 34:22the VOC, the Dutch East India companies. the
- 34:25first multinational in the world. And in this
- 34:29box was, for example, the first meeting of the
- 34:34Dutch East India Company. A famous logo, the
- 34:39first company logo in the world was designed
- 34:42in the book that I found in that box. There was
- 34:47a ship lock of Michiel de Ruyter. Michiel de
- 34:50Ruyter is one of the most famous admirals in
- 34:52history. He was a hero in the Netherlands. He
- 34:54saved the Netherlands many times, but he's also
- 34:57still considered one of the... biggest admirals
- 35:00in history. And then I opened this box and I
- 35:03see the first journal of this man describing
- 35:06his travels to South America and that he had
- 35:12to fight the Spanish in Spain with his ship.
- 35:16So that's the fun thing of this, whether you
- 35:19recover a painting, whether you recover a statue
- 35:22or a box with 17th century ship logs. the first
- 35:29meeting of the Dutch East India Company. You
- 35:31know, it's like stepping into Treasure Island.
- 35:34And I think, thinking about it now, I think that's
- 35:37the most interesting thing in this field of work.
- 35:40Every painting you start researching, like this
- 35:44painting by Bruegel, we started to look for this
- 35:47Bruegel. Was it stolen or not? You learn so much.
- 35:50You learn something about communist Poland. You
- 35:53learn about secret services who killed. for stealing
- 35:58art. You find things about the Nazis. How did
- 36:03they work? And in the end, you learn more about
- 36:06Bruegel. So every story is like a book on itself.
- 36:12Yeah, that's fascinating. I had the same experience
- 36:14when recently we were working on the, we made
- 36:17some art crime challenges on our website together
- 36:21with Linda from ARCA. And it's so fascinating
- 36:24how much comes together in this work with the
- 36:28crime story of it, but also the historic art
- 36:32and art history information that you learn along
- 36:35the way. So it's very interesting. If you start
- 36:38searching for stolen art on lost art or whatever,
- 36:43and if you feel insecure, you can always ask
- 36:45Linda from ARCA or myself or other experts. You
- 36:49just send them an email and you say, look, I'm
- 36:52new in this field, but Could it be that I just
- 36:56discovered that this painting stolen by Goering
- 36:58is now in that museum? They look quite similar.
- 37:01You know, there are people out there like Linda
- 37:04and myself and some others. You can always approach
- 37:06them. Don't feel ashamed, you know, give it a
- 37:09shot. Could you maybe share some of your favorite
- 37:12open source research tools that people in this
- 37:16server could use to get started in this themselves?
- 37:19Yes, well, first of all, you have there is the
- 37:22Interpol. app of Stolen Art. You can download
- 37:25it when you see a painting you can. just make
- 37:28a picture and this app then shows immediately
- 37:31whether this painting or statue shows up in the
- 37:35Paul Stolen database of art. That's one. I said
- 37:38we have the lostart .de which I use a lot, which
- 37:43is fascinating. So you have these kind of websites
- 37:49where there are hundreds of thousands of pieces
- 37:52of art that had been stolen mostly by the Nazis
- 37:55and that are still not recovered. So it's an
- 37:59endless sea of stolen art, you know, and not
- 38:03that many people are searching for it. You know,
- 38:06you have Linda, you have myself, you have some
- 38:08police forces, but that's about it. So there
- 38:11are maybe 200 people in the world looking for
- 38:14200 ,000 or more. pieces of stolen art. So you
- 38:19can use the app of Interpol. You can follow stories
- 38:22that I put out on my social media. ARCA has a
- 38:26lot of... They do summer courses. They have a
- 38:29blog. You know, it all starts with being fascinated
- 38:33by these stories. And if you follow people like
- 38:36us, you will come across certain websites which
- 38:40can bring you further. I started 20 years ago
- 38:44and... I could hardly distinguish a Van Gogh
- 38:48from a Rembrandt, you know? Well, this is a bit
- 38:50exaggerated, but look where I am now. And that's,
- 38:53I think, because if you feel passionate about
- 38:56something and you can end up where I am, you
- 39:01know, give it a shot and feel passionate. And
- 39:04who is not passionate about art, these stories
- 39:07which I just told about this Polish, this Bruegel,
- 39:12you know? who doesn't like these stories, you
- 39:15know, and it's out there for everyone. George
- 39:18in the chat is asking, you've been doing this
- 39:21work for over 15 years now. How did you see art
- 39:24crime evolve since then? Have you noticed any
- 39:26emerging trends in the field of art crime? Yes,
- 39:31of course, we have now internet, we have a lot
- 39:34of places where people can easily sell now stolen
- 39:38art. You have the dark web, but In many countries
- 39:42in the world, we have a problem that the soil
- 39:47is full of treasures which still have not been
- 39:50unearthed from the Romans, the Greeks, et cetera.
- 39:53And of course, an archaeologist should dig them
- 39:57up. But in many countries, you have people with
- 40:00metal detectors roaring around and finding these
- 40:04pieces, maybe gold, silver, and they sell them
- 40:08on the black market. in the old days it was difficult
- 40:11you had to find an art dealer but these days
- 40:13you can you can put them out on ebay or wherever
- 40:16you know so that's that's a big problem the police
- 40:19is very focused on that so that has changed and
- 40:23what you also see is that in the last 10 -15
- 40:26years in many pieces of the world where these
- 40:30people are walking around with metal detectors
- 40:33these grave robbers the credit of our civilization
- 40:38was in the Middle East. So there is where you
- 40:41can find the most. Unfortunately, in many of
- 40:45these countries, there is not a stable government
- 40:47anymore. And we have seen that certain terrorist
- 40:51groups took over this world of illicit antiquities.
- 40:58So we have seen cases in which people linked
- 41:01to groups like Al -Qaeda or ISIS have been caught
- 41:05selling art, stolen art on the Western market.
- 41:10So that has changed. And what also has changed
- 41:13is that there was more awareness. In the old
- 41:16days, nobody was that interested, you know, but
- 41:20in these days, you see that many countries in
- 41:22South America, in Africa, they say, look, these
- 41:26pieces once were stolen from us, we want them
- 41:29back. For many countries, to have these treasures
- 41:32back, which were once stolen from their countries,
- 41:37it gives them pride. It should not be that all
- 41:42these pieces that were illegally found by gravediggers
- 41:46were smuggled to the West Air and are now here
- 41:48in collections or in museums. So what you see
- 41:51is many countries now have stepped in, China,
- 41:57countries in Africa, countries in South America.
- 42:00So these are the things that have changed. Alp
- 42:05Intel asks about your connection and your work
- 42:08together with law enforcement. How did you first
- 42:12link up with law enforcement officials and how
- 42:15does an OSINT investigator or an investigator
- 42:18like yourself complement law enforcement in this
- 42:21field? Well, it starts... a little bit strange,
- 42:25you know, you start to find stolen art and then
- 42:28you have to call the police. And then the police
- 42:31says, look, who are you? And I said, well, you
- 42:33know, I just came from the university. It's my
- 42:37hobby. And then they say, well, we have a problem
- 42:40because in most countries, the art squad is very
- 42:43limited. In most countries, Stolen art is not
- 42:47a priority. Priorities are terrorism, drugs,
- 42:51et cetera. But there is always in any country
- 42:54one, two, three people who are working on art.
- 42:58So you get to know them, you start working with
- 43:01them because they have not enough people to do
- 43:04all the things that they should do. In the beginning,
- 43:08you know, if you or I or anybody else starts
- 43:11working in this field and you find something,
- 43:14the police, of course, is a little bit suspicious.
- 43:16Who is this man or woman? But in the years, you
- 43:21know, after 10, after a couple of years, you
- 43:25earn that trust. And in the end, I'm now working
- 43:28at this very moment now with five different police
- 43:33forces all over Europe in cases involving their
- 43:37countries. and I've been very closely working
- 43:40together with the German police in the past and
- 43:43still I'm working with them almost on a daily
- 43:45basis with the Dutch police, with the Spanish
- 43:47police. So they do like it when there are people
- 43:52like also Linda from ARCA and myself, people
- 43:56who are They always think we are a little bit
- 43:59crazy, you know, because they at least earn money
- 44:01with it. We are doing this more or less like
- 44:05a hobby, but they know some police officers,
- 44:10you know, they enter this field and after five
- 44:12years they are being replaced. And people like
- 44:15Linda and myself are keeping sitting there, you
- 44:18know, and keeping keep going. What you see is
- 44:22that many of these police forces are very happy.
- 44:27They have said about me in many interviews, we
- 44:29are glad we have Arthur Brandt here in the Netherlands
- 44:31who is monitoring everything with us and every
- 44:35steps he does, he does in consultation with us.
- 44:39So you have to have good relations with the police
- 44:42and you have to earn that trust, but sooner or
- 44:46later you will get that trust, if you behave
- 44:48of course. Okay, I want to remind everyone in
- 44:51listening in that we only have 10 more minutes,
- 44:54so please if you have any more questions, this
- 44:56is the time. I was wondering, can you talk a
- 45:01bit about the time frame? Does it get more difficult
- 45:03to look into art pieces that have been missing
- 45:06for a long, long time? Or does that time frame
- 45:11not really matter and is it dependent on other
- 45:13circumstances? The older the better, because...
- 45:17You know, there have been cases that have been
- 45:21closed 30, 20, 40 years ago. Nobody is searching
- 45:25for them anymore. So most cases I do, the statute
- 45:30of limitations have reached. The best cases are
- 45:35cases that are 10, 20, 30 years old because the
- 45:39police is not investigating anymore. Most people
- 45:42have forgotten about it. So, like this piece,
- 45:45you know, we talked about the Bruegel. It was
- 45:47stolen in 74. It was almost forgotten in Poland
- 45:51until four years ago. They did a big documentary
- 45:54about it on Polish television. So, can you imagine
- 45:58how Poland felt when the news broke there that
- 46:01the painting stolen in 1974 just resurfaced in
- 46:06the Netherlands? I think the older the stories
- 46:11are, the better it is. Sometimes when something
- 46:15gets stolen 50 years ago, people are hiding it
- 46:18and then they die. And then a son or daughter
- 46:23finds it on a seller, like the Dutch East India
- 46:27Company stuff that I recovered, and they try
- 46:31to sell it maybe on the market. And if you look
- 46:34for certain pieces, I think that the best Cases
- 46:38are the cases that are more than 10 years old.
- 46:42And it's also very cool, of course, to crack
- 46:45a case that people have been trying to crack
- 46:47for 50 years and nobody cracks it and then you
- 46:52crack it. So I think those are the coolest cases.
- 46:55So even two years ago, there was Madonna, the
- 47:00famous singer, she was posing for magazine, Vogue,
- 47:05I think it was. She was posing in front of a
- 47:07painting and some people in France, a mayor was
- 47:11watching it and he recognized this painting.
- 47:14He thought, oh my God, this looks like the painting
- 47:17that was stolen during World War I in 1918 from
- 47:22our little town. So even if you look in magazines
- 47:28like Vogue, you know, you can crack a case that's
- 47:31over 100 years old. Alina in the chat asks if
- 47:37AI tools have changed the detection of forged
- 47:39or solenoid art, if you use those in your work.
- 47:43I think that they will. I'm not that much into
- 47:49artificial intelligence yet, but I do think that
- 47:52it will change a lot. They are now trying to
- 47:56train artificial intelligence in detecting forgeries.
- 48:01The problem with detecting forgeries is that
- 48:04in many cases, it only comes down to some experts
- 48:08saying, this painting is fake. But then somebody
- 48:12else said, no, no, this is not a fake. And they
- 48:15are now training artificial intelligence to do
- 48:19a better job. And I think in five, 10 years,
- 48:25artificial intelligence might be better in detecting
- 48:28fakes than... all the experts that we have had
- 48:32until now. But I still think that even then artificial
- 48:36intelligence will never be as good as the best
- 48:40forges. And if you talk about those cold cases
- 48:44and that the colder the case, it actually gets
- 48:47easier to solve. Do you ever stop looking or
- 48:52is it more that you pause and then might come
- 48:55back to it later? Yeah. It might be my character,
- 49:01but I always keep on trying to find a case. I
- 49:05have here behind on my wall, I have like 40 cases
- 49:08with leads. Some leads dried up 20 years ago,
- 49:15but there is always a chance that people die
- 49:19and children go to the cellar and find stuff.
- 49:25people die and maybe their brother or their mother.
- 49:29I get calls from people who tell me, look, from
- 49:32an old woman who is from a couple of weeks ago.
- 49:35And she said, well, my son died and my son was
- 49:38a criminal. And I know that he stole a certain
- 49:41painting and I don't want to die with this secret.
- 49:44I recovered Hitler's horses, Hitler's most famous
- 49:47statues. They were gone since 50, 75 years. And
- 49:54together with a good friend of mine from the
- 49:56German police, we managed to recover them. You
- 49:59know, it made headlines all over the world. I
- 50:01wrote a book about it. So if that's possible,
- 50:05if you can find Hitler's favorite statues of
- 50:10three meters high back after 75 years, everything
- 50:14is possible. Cool. There's lots to work with
- 50:17for the people in the server, I think. And we
- 50:21have another question for from George who asks,
- 50:24do you have any suggestions for regulatory improvements
- 50:26that can be implemented on a national or international
- 50:29level, which could help with some of the challenges
- 50:31that crimes against art present? Well, it's difficult
- 50:35to know. I always say on Monday, art was invented.
- 50:39On Tuesday, the first art was stolen. And on
- 50:42Wednesday, the first art was forged. It has always
- 50:45been there. In many cases, we are talking about
- 50:48a lot of money, you know. pieces of art, which
- 50:52are worth millions. If you manage to fake a Picasso
- 50:56and you can set it for 10 million, it's quite
- 50:58a sum of money. So what I think is what we see
- 51:06in most countries, as I told before, police is
- 51:09not really so much interested. There are other
- 51:13forms of crime. So the police could use the help
- 51:17of people like me, like Linda, but also of the
- 51:22public who is now listening. They need us. They
- 51:26need people who help them search for these paintings.
- 51:31It's a very big market, the criminal art market.
- 51:34We're talking here about maybe six to eight billion.
- 51:38It's quite a big market. And we have a few hundred
- 51:40police officers around the globe who are working
- 51:43on it. It's a very big business. And what we
- 51:48see is that many of them never get caught. If
- 51:52they get caught, it's very hard for the police
- 51:54to prove that a certain piece was illegally excavated
- 51:58in Italy, for example. So it's a field where
- 52:03criminals in the last decades had free game.
- 52:10And some of them get caught. But with today's
- 52:15internet, it also gets easier for people like
- 52:18me, but also from people who want to start today,
- 52:22to track down stolen art. And I said with artificial
- 52:25intelligence, it might be helpful, but I think
- 52:31our theft and art forgery, unfortunately will
- 52:35never stop. I said it has always been there,
- 52:37and as soon as there is a lot of money involved,
- 52:42Even the biggest auction houses like Christie's
- 52:45and Sotheby's have been victim of forgeries,
- 52:48you know, and the best experts in the world are
- 52:51working there. So it's very hard to cover it
- 52:57all. I can imagine. And just to give people a
- 53:02bit of guidance as a last question, I think almost,
- 53:06do you see any patterns in cases that you've
- 53:10covered. Do you see repeatable steps that thieves
- 53:13take to evade law enforcement? Or is every case
- 53:16unique? Every case is unique, but never forget,
- 53:21most people think that the art world is about
- 53:23beauty. Well, it isn't. It's about money. And
- 53:29if it's about money, people are capable of everything.
- 53:34Respected auction houses, respected art dealers,
- 53:39Some of them, not all of course, have been caught
- 53:43red handed because if there's so much money at
- 53:46stake, people do things that they shouldn't do.
- 53:50So be aware always, we are talking here about
- 53:52a big market, big reputations, a lot of money
- 53:57at stake and people do very, very strange things
- 54:00for money. And we see that all the time in the
- 54:04art world. museums of big names, the biggest
- 54:09museums in the world, they have bought pieces
- 54:11of which they knew or could have known that they
- 54:15were not legally acquired. And that's because,
- 54:19you know, they wanted to have these pieces. So
- 54:22be aware that you are working in a field of high
- 54:26egos, a lot of money and some bad people. That
- 54:32sounds fun. And just to get Pio's excitement,
- 54:35do you have any recommended reading for people
- 54:37that want to get into this field and learn a
- 54:39bit more about the world of art crime? Yes, follow
- 54:43ARCA. They have a blog. You can follow me on
- 54:46social media. There are books out there. I already
- 54:49mentioned Noah Charney. He's a professor who
- 54:51does a lot of research about art crime. He has
- 54:54written a lot of books about it. There are many
- 54:56books out there. Well, follow me on social media
- 55:02and follow Arka. That's a good start, you know.
- 55:05There's much more. And I know Linda is listening
- 55:08probably, so that's a good way to start, you
- 55:13know. Arka and myself and some books. There are
- 55:16many books out there. Amazing. Linda was definitely
- 55:20listening and putting all kinds of helpful resources
- 55:23in the chat as well. And we'll make sure to list
- 55:25everything in our show notes as well in the version
- 55:29that is going to be recorded, that was recorded,
- 55:32and that we'll share on a podcast platform. So
- 55:35you can find all these resources back. And I've
- 55:38also seen a lot of people talk about the ArtCrime
- 55:42server we have here on our Discord server. In
- 55:44that channel, people have been discussing this
- 55:46topic for quite some time. And this is also the
- 55:49place to discuss and help each other find find
- 55:54out more about this fascinating world. And this
- 55:56was a great introduction, Arthur. Thank you very
- 55:58much for giving some insights in your work and
- 56:02for all the tips for the people that want to
- 56:03get started with this. And thanks, everyone,
- 56:06for listening in and for all your questions.
- 56:10I'll end the recording here and the recording
- 56:13will appear on your streaming platforms in the
- 56:15coming days. And in two weeks, we'll be back
- 56:18with a new stage talk. So make sure to tune in.
- 56:21Thank you for listening to the stage talk. If
- 56:25you'd like to catch a stage talk live where you
- 56:28can ask the guest questions, join the Bellingcat
- 56:30Discord server by visiting www .discord .gg slash
- 56:37Bellingcat. The music you've heard is titled
- 56:40Dawn by Newer Self and is courtesy of Artlist.