Latest / The Vegan Report / Winning Europe, One Victory at A Time. With José Luis Murillo | Ep. 106
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, my name is Ryan and welcome to
- 0:04The Vegan Report. Today we travel to Europe,
- 0:08where there is a fierce political fight taking
- 0:10place for the animals. And to address this topic,
- 0:15I have with me José Luis Morillo, the General
- 0:19Director of Animal Welfare Observatory. Lois
- 0:23and I discussed how Animal Welfare Observatory
- 0:26was able to make it a nationwide policy to have
- 0:31cameras in Spanish slaughterhouses and their
- 0:35plans to make it happen everywhere else in Europe.
- 0:39The clash his organization has with big ag lobbyists,
- 0:43how his team convinced corporations that animal
- 0:47welfare reforms were lucrative, if there is hope
- 0:51for animal rights activists to get between animal
- 0:54and plant farmers, and much much more. Lewis
- 0:58described the Animal Welfare Observatory as the
- 1:02organization that this movement needs. It's an
- 1:04organization that is making a huge impact. They
- 1:08were recognized for their work by animal charity
- 1:11evaluators. I warmly invite you to connect with
- 1:15them. Link in the episode notes. Follow or subscribe
- 1:19to the show for more conversations with the passionate
- 1:23people behind your favorite organizations. Share
- 1:27the episode with the vegans you know and help
- 1:30shed light on the meaningful work of the Animal
- 1:33Welfare Observatory. Leave a good review, any
- 1:37gesture of support is appreciated. Thank you.
- 1:41So as a noise breaker question, and it's a question
- 1:45I've asked the other charities on the list of
- 1:4910 recommended charities from animal charity
- 1:53evaluators, how did you find yourself on that
- 1:57list? Well, that's a great question because I
- 2:01think we are the rookies on that list. We are
- 2:04the first timers. And that's a huge compliment
- 2:08for us because It's kind of a recognition to
- 2:12our work since we started out in 2018. Up until
- 2:16this point, well, they have been searching, doing
- 2:20the research on everything, anything and everything
- 2:23that we did in the past and what we are working
- 2:27on at the moment. And they thought that we have
- 2:31a lot of potential. So we agree. Yes, they do
- 2:37have quite a... difficult. It's a complete evaluation
- 2:43process. It takes time and it can be difficult
- 2:47for the organization to provide all of what they
- 2:51need in order to evaluate your case. That's right.
- 2:56And it's not only coming from us, really. It's
- 3:00coming from them checking and trying to compare
- 3:04with the media outlets, echoing our work and
- 3:07so on. to make sure that everything is on point.
- 3:13So for us, it took, I think, a couple of months,
- 3:17at least. But once they got everything and they
- 3:22started their evaluation progress, it was really,
- 3:27really interesting for us to see that they were
- 3:30so into it and so into our work, not only because
- 3:35we are representing something that in Spain is
- 3:39not so common as a corporate outreach, but also
- 3:42the institutional outreach and trying to convince
- 3:46politicians and try to turn everything into laws
- 3:51and so on. It's not so common, but we are one
- 3:56of the few NGOs doing it and we got lucky that
- 4:00we have a successful run. And I have many questions
- 4:03about that. But first, the focus of your work
- 4:07is Europe. Now, most of my audience is made up
- 4:13of Americans and North Americans. So what should
- 4:17we tell them about the state of animal welfare
- 4:21in Europe? Well, we believe we are setting the
- 4:27standard, really, for the rest of the markets.
- 4:32At the same time, we are dragging because we
- 4:36expect the European Commission to publish a revision
- 4:40of the entire animal welfare legislation for
- 4:44farm animals in 2023. And we are in 2026, and
- 4:50it's not happening at the pace that was promised
- 4:55by the Commission. So at the moment, we are pushing.
- 4:58We are pushing mainly for the transfer proposal.
- 5:01And our goal and our main priority at the moment
- 5:06is stopping all live animal transport, because
- 5:12it's very important for the whole industry to
- 5:17make the transition to meat and carcasses only.
- 5:20And then pushing, of course, for the regulation
- 5:24that will be the most important for us, that
- 5:28is the one banning all cages. from farming. So
- 5:32these are two wins that we thought that we could
- 5:38be cheering and having a toast on them in 2024.
- 5:46But we are pushing because the commission is
- 5:49taking a side. Are there any European countries
- 5:53that are doing better? And are there countries
- 5:57that are doing worse? Sure, there are countries
- 6:01like Denmark that have implemented some of these
- 6:06measures without waiting for the EU institutions
- 6:08to finalize the regulation. And then there are
- 6:14some others like Spain that is kind of in position
- 6:18to trigger the domino effect. If we make it here,
- 6:23we can... be the ones that spawn that domino
- 6:29effecting throughout Europe and that's our goal
- 6:32really. That's the role we're playing at the
- 6:34moment. Yes. It's funny that you mentioned Denmark
- 6:37because I'm also going to have a conversation
- 6:40with the Denmark Vegetarian Association. I think
- 6:44they were also part of that. They're also rookies
- 6:48on that list of 10 recommended charities. Okay.
- 6:54I feel like there's lots of politics behind your
- 6:58work. Now, how do you go about creating those
- 7:04relationships with politicians and political
- 7:07institutions? Well, sometimes we are seen as
- 7:12very few of the organizations that contact politicians
- 7:17directly to request meetings and go about the
- 7:22technical details. because sometimes NGOs are
- 7:26seeing like the big statements and then not the
- 7:33detailed ones. So it's funny enough for us to
- 7:37find out that politicians are into discussing
- 7:40these issues with us because they are not doing
- 7:43this. They are doing this with the industry,
- 7:45but not with us. And having our way with them,
- 7:48it's all about knowing your material, what you're
- 7:52working with. and knowing nuances at a regional
- 7:56level or local level so you can leverage on this
- 8:00because otherwise they will think that you don't
- 8:02really know what you're talking about so we have
- 8:05to provide a lot of information with the research
- 8:08and investigations and of course a lot of data
- 8:13that is backed by the institutions themselves
- 8:17we are always crossing all this data to come
- 8:20up with some new solution. Interesting. I think
- 8:24in the domain of politics, people tend to picture
- 8:29voters as left -wing, right -wing, but most voters
- 8:33are not voting at all. They are apolitical. They
- 8:38have divorced themselves from politics entirely
- 8:41and are not aware of who is the representative
- 8:46on the European Parliament. Canadian Parliament
- 8:51or whatever, and they don't know what's happening
- 8:55on the political front. Is it, you know, with
- 9:00those politicians, are they informed about animal
- 9:04welfare? Do they know when you start talking
- 9:09with them, are they aware of what's happening
- 9:12on the land? No, not always. Not most of the
- 9:18time, because when we show some images from investigations
- 9:22or research that either we or our colleagues
- 9:26or fellow NGOs from colleges that we were part
- 9:32of are digging up, well, they are really impacted
- 9:38by them. And this shows that there is a lot of
- 9:46work to do with that kind of public pushing,
- 9:53because from our side, well, we do know what's
- 9:58going on, but they are kind of... I don't know,
- 10:08they are narrow -minded, because they are always
- 10:10looking at things... from their own perspective
- 10:13meaning an office or the institution themselves
- 10:16and they are not with their feet on the ground
- 10:19most of the time. So whenever they see something
- 10:23that they read in a paper come true in form of
- 10:27images of animals suffering a lot and with very
- 10:33cruel ways that they believe that weren't happening
- 10:37or it wasn't so much of a deal. For them, they
- 10:42become a deal. And for us, it's very interesting
- 10:46to see that animal welfare is not always tied
- 10:50to, I don't know, ecology, you know? Because
- 10:57sometimes you find that governments like Italy,
- 11:01you know, Andrea Meloni, they just pass a law
- 11:08on male chick cooling to ban. So this is very
- 11:13important because that's something that you will
- 11:15expect from a most progressive party in government
- 11:19like the one there is in Spain and it's not the
- 11:24case. You can always find these kind of situations
- 11:28in which unexpected measures come from unexpected
- 11:34government. See, that gives me hope. you know,
- 11:39the fact that, you know, it's not that they take
- 11:42the side of being against animal welfare, it's
- 11:45just they're ignorant about it. I talked about
- 11:49that voting block that is just divorced from
- 11:53politics. And, you know, I think if we look at
- 11:58the animal rights community, many of them are
- 12:01not interested in political activism. How do
- 12:04we change that? How do we get people engaged
- 12:07in what's happening politically? Well, it's always
- 12:11very difficult because they tend to think, at
- 12:14least at the moment, that everything is part
- 12:17of a scenario in which everybody plays a role,
- 12:21but it's not so real as they want us to believe.
- 12:28But at the same time, we started out kind of
- 12:32doing something that was pioneering really in
- 12:38and all throughout the EU, that all the slaughterhouses
- 12:43in Spain have cameras on them. So this is something
- 12:50that we accomplished by convincing politicians.
- 12:54And that wasn't a part of corporate outreach.
- 13:00We are always doing some outreach with companies,
- 13:06not only on the grocery industry, but also with
- 13:09the producers, with the farmers themselves. But
- 13:12this one, it was all about convincing the politicians
- 13:16that we should place cameras inside all the slaughterhouses
- 13:22to check if the standards for animal welfare
- 13:27for all the animals since they arrived to the
- 13:31slaughterhouse. until the other slaughter were
- 13:35met, the requirements and the standards. So for
- 13:39us, this was very important because we did it
- 13:43through convincing politicians, but not only
- 13:46politicians. We need a public campaign on this.
- 13:50So we put a lot of effort on showing the people
- 13:57what was going on. on the slaughterhouses in
- 14:01Spain and then it became a law and it became
- 14:06enforced that was very important for us. And
- 14:10now we are kind of the example that all the EU
- 14:15countries are looking at and pointing at because
- 14:19the slaughter regulation was one of the ones
- 14:22that got delayed from the European Commission.
- 14:25and we just wanted to make the Spanish case an
- 14:29European case. Yes, and that's an amazing win.
- 14:36But do you meet any kind of, you know, adversity
- 14:43in that work in terms of politics? And now I'm
- 14:47thinking about the lobbies, the different, you
- 14:51know, big ag lobbies. Do you meet those people?
- 14:54Uh, do you clash with them? Uh, what it's like,
- 14:57what is the dynamic like? Well, now we have to
- 15:01deal with them as well, because we see them getting
- 15:04away with, uh, with some politicians that are
- 15:09peak. So we need to talk to them as well, not
- 15:13only to the politicians, but the analysts from
- 15:15the industry as well. And that's how we started
- 15:19our round, our industry approach really. around
- 15:23contacts with companies and so on, because we
- 15:29saw that they were key as well. So we need to
- 15:32convince them as well. And we need to convince
- 15:35them through not only this is an ethical issue,
- 15:39but also this is a profitable issue. And we had
- 15:44to identify, we had to do a lot of research to
- 15:47identify which animal welfare measures were profitable
- 15:51for the industry. in order to sell them these
- 15:55measures and then make them push for them as
- 15:58well. So it was a hell of a work, but it's paying
- 16:03off because at the moment we are trying to get
- 16:06out of this blocking situation that we're experiencing
- 16:10at EU level by coming to terms with the industry
- 16:15on some animal welfare measures that they implemented
- 16:18themselves. without waiting for a law to push
- 16:24them. So we are trying to make those best practices
- 16:30a law and then, well, make them not only a law
- 16:36in Spain, but a regulation throughout the EU.
- 16:40Well, that's really interesting because I've
- 16:44had the CEO of the Humane League and he said
- 16:47You know, they're pushing those animal welfare,
- 16:50um, you know, reforms, um, on corporations with
- 16:56the hidden agenda of, uh, diminishing their margin
- 17:00of revenues. Uh, but you're saying that you're
- 17:03trying to convince them by, uh, you know, selling
- 17:08the idea that they will increase their margins
- 17:11of profit. Um, so how do we square that? Um,
- 17:18That's a great question, really. Well, we have
- 17:21an example of this. We did some research and
- 17:25we found out that in 2020, the Spanish pork industry,
- 17:31the Spanish pork sector was in a bit of a rush
- 17:36because China experienced a problem with the
- 17:41pork population with an outbreak that caused
- 17:46It diminished by half. So countries like China
- 17:52needed millions of peaks from overnight almost.
- 18:00So they stepped in by transitioning to meeting
- 18:05carcasses. So no peak was going. alive, you know,
- 18:15through all these, well, I don't know how many
- 18:19miles are there from Spain to China, about half
- 18:23of the world apart, you know. And it was very
- 18:27interesting for us to see that they made a bundle
- 18:30out of it. They made a bundle out of an animal
- 18:36welfare measure that is stopping live animal
- 18:41transport and transition to meeting carcasses.
- 18:44And then we saw that they founded themselves
- 18:47without subsidies. So if you are willing to do
- 18:52this, that is, well, for us, it's important because
- 18:57it means animal welfare, improvements. But if
- 19:01you're doing this, it's because you're seeking
- 19:04profit, because you're a machine of making profit.
- 19:10So We studied the numbers that they provided
- 19:15throughout their annual reports and so on. And
- 19:19we saw that animal welfare can be profitable
- 19:22for the companies. And then we have to sell a
- 19:27pack of measures that is, okay, we are doing
- 19:31the transition to meat and carcasses, no animal
- 19:36transport, okay. no life animal transport, but
- 19:41then you have to do all these other methods that
- 19:44are not so profitable, but comes with the other
- 19:48one because otherwise we will campaign on you,
- 19:52of course. We will launch campaigns on you are
- 19:56doing just for the shake of profitability and
- 19:59not for the animal work. That is our goal really.
- 20:04I see it. The strategy is very nuanced. um what
- 20:11do you make then of the whole debate that is
- 20:14you know this tension in the vegan animal rights
- 20:18community of you know should we take a more animal
- 20:22welfareist approach versus a more abolitionist
- 20:25approach um do you feel it is a productive debate
- 20:30um do you you know um feel more inclined to support
- 20:37one way versus the other? Well, I'm a vegan,
- 20:42so this is my part on the argument. I believe
- 20:47it's a good argument. I believe it's a good discussion
- 20:50that we should have. And having it shows that
- 20:56also everybody gets to play a part on the upper
- 21:01strategy and all strategies can be combined.
- 21:04I believe veganism is one way to look at things
- 21:08that makes the movement go forward. But also
- 21:12the work that we are doing, that it's not strictly
- 21:15towards veganism as the ultimate goal, but just
- 21:19avoid cruelty and avoid animal suffering altogether.
- 21:25But I believe that we are making the movement
- 21:31go forward as well with what we're doing. Because
- 21:34otherwise, You tend to think that big changes
- 21:40can be achieved overnight, and that's not it.
- 21:43We have to take into account that animals are
- 21:46suffering nowadays. And what should we do about
- 21:49them? Well, these measures that we are talking
- 21:52about are taking care of them at the real time,
- 21:57at the moment. So it's kind of OK. We can dream
- 22:02of long -term measures. as well as implementing
- 22:06shorter terms measures that really goes into
- 22:10that direction as well. I'm sorry, I'm not aware
- 22:15of that. But is there any animal party in in
- 22:20Europe that is campaigning to elect politicians?
- 22:26Yeah. Yeah, they are small parties. Some of them
- 22:30have a member of the European Parliament, at
- 22:36the European Parliament. Some of them have members
- 22:38of parliaments, of the national parliaments.
- 22:41In Spain, it's a case of not having, at any institution,
- 22:48a member of PACMA, that is the one in Spain.
- 22:53But, of course, the ones that are there at the
- 22:58European Parliament are the ones that always
- 23:02push for any question, any measure that we want
- 23:08the politicians to start a debate on, they are
- 23:13the ones stable in them. So yeah, that was my
- 23:16next question. Do you find their presence helpful?
- 23:20Do you work with them in collaboration with them
- 23:23to push forward your agenda? Sure. We believe
- 23:27they are an important part of the puzzle because
- 23:30they accomplish their own role as well. So for
- 23:35me, it's kind of separate arms for the same strategy,
- 23:41and they all combine. They all work for the greater
- 23:46goal. So we welcome them and we usefully work
- 23:53with them. Let's go back to the corporations.
- 23:57I guess one more question I had about your approach
- 24:03towards those corporations is what is your perception
- 24:07of the employees at those corporations? Because
- 24:12they're humans and I want to believe that they
- 24:17care about animals, yet they are responsible
- 24:21of all this carnage. And so how do you work with
- 24:27them? How do you... dialogue with them, knowing
- 24:31that they are the people behind all of that destruction
- 24:36and blood. Sometimes they are veterinarians as
- 24:40well. So it's all the more amazing to see them
- 24:45on that side of the table. But at the same time,
- 24:50we know that they are kind of working inside
- 24:54a a control environment that they had and they
- 24:59stepped in because they inherited that environment
- 25:03from previous leaders or something or somebody
- 25:07that was in place before them. So I believe they
- 25:12are trying to, I don't know if just becoming
- 25:17early adopters would be the goal for them because
- 25:23some of them Can adopt these measures just because
- 25:28they are going to happen anyways So we might
- 25:31as well take that margin profit and that part
- 25:34of the because they are always speaking now on
- 25:37these terms really are sometimes on this does
- 25:39but I Believe it's important for us to to know
- 25:45that they are playing a role within their own
- 25:48set of circumstances And we have to somehow give
- 25:55them the possibility to make all these animal
- 25:59welfare measures a reality because that would
- 26:02be a relief for them as well. Maybe they are
- 26:06struggling with this conundrum of having animal
- 26:12welfare on one side and profits on the other.
- 26:15Some of them, I think they will be very pleased
- 26:20to get those together. And if we provide that
- 26:24research and development that shows that it's
- 26:29feasible for them, it's a treat because they
- 26:34are not saying no, they're not reluctant to speak
- 26:38with us or explore any possibility with us. Although
- 26:45it takes time because it's like a monolith, you
- 26:47know, it's too large for them to just test something
- 26:54that is not being properly measured and properly
- 26:58worked. So they are kind of in the middle of
- 27:03something that I believe they want to change,
- 27:07but little by little. And we want the bigger
- 27:09changes, of course. And we want it now. Well,
- 27:15it's good that they're ready to work with you.
- 27:20But I feel like our community is more hesitant
- 27:26to approach them, to approach people with whom
- 27:29we disagree this much and build something with
- 27:34them. And I think it's the same thing with environmentalists
- 27:39who don't want to talk with executives from big
- 27:43oil. They demonize them and they're not ready
- 27:48to work with them in any capacity. What do you
- 27:53make of that hesitation? How do we go? How do
- 27:56we get over it in order to make some progress?
- 28:01Well, I believe it's okay really for most activists
- 28:06to hold a strong position because for me, I expect
- 28:12that from them. I expect somebody to fulfill
- 28:16that role and it's them. the ones that have that
- 28:21part on the whole scenario. But for me, it's
- 28:26all about being the organization that the movement
- 28:29needs, not the ones that we would love to be.
- 28:35And we saw that this is feasible and this might
- 28:39help millions of animals as we have over the
- 28:43years. So we need to push forward. for this and
- 28:48at the same time, we're okay with activists pushing
- 28:53for more because this way we are coming with
- 28:56even better solutions because we are pushed as
- 29:00well. Not becoming part of it, but you know,
- 29:05being ahead of it. Yes, there is momentum and
- 29:08I love that line. It's such a badass line. Where
- 29:12the organization that this movement needs. Not
- 29:15the one that we would love to be. That's amazing.
- 29:21Okay, I want to quickly talk about world politics
- 29:27and what's happening with the tariffs, with Trump
- 29:33who is making lots of news. Is that, you know,
- 29:39is it affecting in any way your work and what's
- 29:43happening on the animal welfare front? I believe
- 29:47some of this blocking that we experience in throughout
- 29:53the EU, it's mainly because of the tariff in
- 29:56Trump, but it's also because the European market
- 30:01is trying to close itself and try to to work
- 30:05within the countries that are part of the EU.
- 30:09So at the moment, we are experiencing something
- 30:12that is a bit of a drastic change because of
- 30:16it. But at the same time, we believe it's for
- 30:21the better because we need to push for the mirror
- 30:24clauses to become a reality. sad that the Mercosur
- 30:31agreement got through and we celebrate that.
- 30:33Now it's kind of in the European Court of Justice
- 30:37to make sure that it's okay at European law level.
- 30:44But at the moment, we believe these changes might
- 30:47allow us to Not only increase our standards,
- 30:52but also increase the rest of the world standards.
- 30:55If they want to resume their cooperation with
- 30:58the UN and with their market, because we have
- 31:02these measures implemented and we want the rest
- 31:05of the world to have it implemented as well.
- 31:08Animal welfare wise. Interesting. Yes, we often
- 31:13here in North America, we often take the European
- 31:16Union as an example. The standards are always
- 31:20higher. The products are always healthier. There
- 31:24are less pesticides, less additives, less this
- 31:29and that, and it's more ethical. There is this
- 31:34influence factor. I do feel it here. It is brought
- 31:41up again and again in public conversations. Yeah,
- 31:45we call it the Brussels effect. And it's pretty
- 31:51interesting because we know that by expecting
- 31:57the same from the rest of the countries, we can
- 31:59do so much more. And that's mainly our argument
- 32:03to push for these mirror clauses on any treaty,
- 32:08any agreement, because otherwise... Imagine that
- 32:15we pass this regulation and we ban all cages
- 32:21on farming. Well, we're banning them from the
- 32:25EU. But if we are dealing with Eastern European
- 32:30countries that are not implementing these measures,
- 32:34we are just changing the cages from one place
- 32:36to the other. But it would be kind of importing
- 32:41chicken from... cages somewhere else. And that's
- 32:45not what we want. Another situation that is making,
- 32:52you know, global news. Well, I think I'm affected
- 32:56by that because my native language is French.
- 32:59And so I'm just, you know, getting that news.
- 33:02But it's the situation of, you know, friends
- 33:06and the farmers there. They're protesting. They're
- 33:11very vocal. What's happening there? Why are they
- 33:16so agitated? Well, first thing, I believe it's
- 33:22kind of what these controls and this, um, uh,
- 33:29bureaucracy that they always complaining because
- 33:31let's face it, you is about bureaucracy most
- 33:35of the time. That's not related to animal welfare.
- 33:38It's related to anything and everything throughout
- 33:42all the countries in the EU. And France is not
- 33:45an exception. But I think it's really interesting
- 33:48to see them running with tractors on the streets,
- 33:53demanding the European Green Deal to be taken
- 33:58down a couple of years ago. And now it's the
- 34:02Mercosur agreement that they want to take down.
- 34:06And that's Strong change really that's a big
- 34:10change if you want to to see the spectrum and
- 34:14how it's shifting because They were complaining
- 34:17about this Bureaucracy and all these controls
- 34:21and all of these You know, it's always it's it's
- 34:26the same thing. But at the same time they found
- 34:29out that maybe This kind of liberal agreement
- 34:38on Mercosur is not it either. And they are kind
- 34:44of seeing both sides of the argument. Now they
- 34:48have to make a stand. And that's very interesting
- 34:51for the interests within the European Union,
- 34:55because, of course, the farmers represent a huge
- 35:00portion of the economy. That's for sure. At the
- 35:07same time, they were the ones calling for everything
- 35:11to be slower and not only the animal welfare
- 35:16reform, but also anything that was green. And
- 35:21now they are seeing that our standards are something
- 35:25that makes them different and maybe they want
- 35:28to uphold them. So it's kind of a very interesting
- 35:33change to see. Can we create any kind of meaningful
- 35:38division between animal farmers and plant farmers?
- 35:44And my first instinct is to think, no, since
- 35:47the biggest clients of plant farmers are the
- 35:51animal farmers. But is there a way to get between
- 35:56the two and say, hey, what you're doing as a
- 36:01plant farmer is much better for the environment.
- 36:04And we're all with you. Our problem is with the
- 36:08animal farmers. Yeah, well, you're right. They're
- 36:12intertwined most of the time, even at well, some
- 36:19organizations that represent the interests of
- 36:23agriculture represent the interests of both sectors.
- 36:28So this is very difficult because you cannot
- 36:34separate them so easily by trying to meet representatives
- 36:41from one of the sectors because you're getting
- 36:44the one that represent all of them. So it's very
- 36:48important for us to show that not only, of course,
- 36:54agriculture and even cell -based protein, of
- 36:59course. our move forward and the way to go at
- 37:03the moment. But also, to say the least, I think
- 37:11that these kind of tensions have been seen in
- 37:18the protests because the agriculture sector was
- 37:22not always following the farmers with the tractors.
- 37:26And that's a gap that It's been broadened. It's
- 37:32broadened, but for the moment, we need a bit
- 37:36more work to try to sit down with the agriculture
- 37:43sector and say, hey, we want to root in your
- 37:47favor. We want to root for you, but we don't
- 37:51want that your biggest client, that is the farmers,
- 37:56get in the way. So it's very difficult to stepping
- 38:00that because that's the middle of something that
- 38:02it's kind of the big pie for them. That's really
- 38:08interesting. And the fact that they're not showing
- 38:11up at protests, you know, as a unified front,
- 38:14it's in a small hope. Okay, I want to get back
- 38:19to the work of your organization. You mentioned
- 38:23earlier in the conversation, one of your big
- 38:27victory, which was, you know, putting cameras
- 38:30in slaughterhouses all across Spain. I want to
- 38:33know more of your victories. Well, we have been
- 38:39working with companies to, well, first thinking
- 38:45about laying hands. We needed to step in and
- 38:51really make them fulfill some agreements because
- 38:56Spain was a mess. We started out in 2018 and
- 39:04that was kind of 90 % of laying hands in small
- 39:10cages for all their lives and they could barely
- 39:15move. So it was very important to get some supermarket
- 39:21chain, I believe six out of the 10 biggest supermarket
- 39:27chains in Spain. reached agreements with us.
- 39:34And this impacted the numbers, the figures dropped
- 39:39from this 90 % in 2018, 2016, 2018 to now we
- 39:47are at 65 % in 10 years or less. So that's a
- 39:54huge accomplishment that we are not responsible
- 39:58because there are other NGOs working on this
- 40:02as well. But we pushed so hard with this and
- 40:05we reached these agreements with the companies
- 40:09that were key, really. And then, of course, we
- 40:13did the same with the supermarket companies to
- 40:18adopt cage -free commitments for broiler chicken
- 40:22as well and higher standards. Now, at the moment,
- 40:27we are now focusing on, especially, fish. Because,
- 40:33let's face it, there are not too many people
- 40:35focusing on fish at the moment. And this is very
- 40:40interesting, because each time you talk about
- 40:42aquatic animals, it's like a large group, but
- 40:47you're not taking into account a lot of aquatic
- 40:52animals. very different aquatic animals. And
- 40:56this is important because each breed behaves
- 41:00differently and have different needs and so on.
- 41:04So it's important for us to join the work that
- 41:11institutions like the European Food Safety Authority
- 41:15is doing because they are coming up with reports
- 41:20and some researchers on this. that allowed us
- 41:25to say to the aquaculture sector in the meetings
- 41:29that these animals are sentient beings as well
- 41:33and they suffer because that was something that
- 41:35they weren't admitting up until a couple of years
- 41:42ago. So it's very important for us to keep working
- 41:45on this because there are millions of animals
- 41:50that are suffering at the moment. and we need
- 41:52to step in and keep working because, well, at
- 41:59the moment what we are doing is, of course, not
- 42:03only shifting to more humane ways of slaughtering
- 42:08flesh, but also make sure that the stunning previous
- 42:13slaughtering is efficient because that's a huge
- 42:18debate that is within the, well, not only the
- 42:22industry, but also people from the European Food
- 42:27Safety Authority as well. They are always going
- 42:31back and forth because it's very important that
- 42:36these new tools for stunning are proven right
- 42:42because at the moment they are kind of showing
- 42:47some results that are not convincing. Yeah, that's
- 42:53a big one. And I took the resolution to talk
- 42:56more about aquatic life on this podcast because
- 43:00I've been avoiding the topic unconsciously. It's
- 43:06just a bias in the animal charity evaluators.
- 43:16description of your organization. There is a
- 43:20mention of shrimp welfare initiative. Can you
- 43:23tell us more about that initiative and shrimps
- 43:28in general? Sure. We're not focusing on this.
- 43:322026 will be a great year for our investigation
- 43:35on shrimp because we are coming up with these
- 43:40proven methods of styling to be effective. And
- 43:44that's one of our main goals, to make sure that
- 43:48any slaughter is properly executed. We are very
- 43:54sorry to use these terms, but this is how it
- 43:58goes. And we need to step in and make sure that
- 44:01these animals suffer as little as possible or
- 44:04not suffering at all. But at the moment, we are
- 44:08talking about eye -stalk ablation. You know,
- 44:11it's kind of... taking almost their eyes out.
- 44:15And that's something that it's being refuted,
- 44:21not only by experts, but also by people from
- 44:24the food industry that it's not making any difference
- 44:28to the taste or anything like that. So why don't
- 44:33we stop doing this to the animals? And we are
- 44:37focusing on this mainly. I believe 2026 will
- 44:41be a huge progress for shrimp welfare. Yeah,
- 44:47I've heard about that kind of operation. Is it
- 44:52like someone who's in charge of taking one shrimp
- 44:57at a time and removing their eyes? Is that it?
- 45:02You can say that. All the more disgusting and
- 45:09thinking about animals being treated like this.
- 45:12It's like, well, magic building, really. So for
- 45:17us, we need to take that away because it's not
- 45:23making anything. It's kind of something that
- 45:26we are encountering that the industry keeps doing,
- 45:30but they don't have a real reason for keep doing
- 45:33this. That's crazy. At the same time, I'm not
- 45:41that shocked because I remember being in high
- 45:46school and we had science teachers who would
- 45:48teach that fish and shrimps and all of that did
- 45:52not feel any pain, that scientifically they were
- 45:57just like plants. So what can you expect from
- 46:01people? What about the workers in slaughterhouses
- 46:08or the ones doing the dirty job of removing the
- 46:11ice and all of that? I know that in North America
- 46:16it's mostly immigrants, poor. We've even found
- 46:22children in some slaughterhouses. Some investigations
- 46:26uncovered that. Anyway, so people from vulnerable
- 46:31populations, disadvantaged. populations. Is it
- 46:34the same thing in Europe? It's kind of the same,
- 46:37but also we have to take into account that it's
- 46:41something like Christmas on steroids because
- 46:47in Spain during Christmas it's kind of a tradition
- 46:52to throw a crustacean on boiling water alive.
- 46:57So it's something that they did in the past because
- 47:02they thought it would preserve the taste. It
- 47:06would taste better and the meat would be a little
- 47:10bit more fluffy or something like that. And also
- 47:13rigid, if you feel the crustacean prior to throwing
- 47:18into boiling water. But at the moment we are
- 47:23very, very, very... into stopping this because
- 47:28each Christmas is like a massacre for the crustaceans.
- 47:32And they haven't on display on any supermarket.
- 47:36They have this aquarium with all these crustaceans
- 47:41floating around and waiting to be killed in the
- 47:45most cruel way. And this is something that we
- 47:50are trying to work on because it's a tradition
- 47:55but it's dying out really. It's not so much a
- 48:02thing of today. So we have this light of hope
- 48:07that we can put an end to it slowly but surely.
- 48:12That's great to hear. And going back to my question,
- 48:20you often talk to the workers, the office workers,
- 48:25the corporations, but they're not the ones doing
- 48:27the dirty work. Do we have a profile in mind
- 48:31of who is doing the dirty work of slaughtering
- 48:34the animals and all of that? Is it mostly just
- 48:37like in America, immigrants and illegals and
- 48:43so on? We believe so, because it's kind of a
- 48:47work that nobody wants to do, really. we have
- 48:52been profiling this and encountering. Sometimes,
- 48:57sorry, immigrants, sometimes there are people
- 49:00that had some family business around this issue
- 49:06and they just inherited it because they don't
- 49:10think it's cruel. They have been exposed to it
- 49:16throughout all their lives, so they're fine with
- 49:19this. But We believe that we can open their eyes
- 49:25on this because it's really, if you take a step
- 49:29back and look at it, it makes no sense at all.
- 49:33It's kind of making cruel ways of raising animals
- 49:43for food that are not even needed for the purpose.
- 49:49What about then the different maybe fights that
- 49:54you have led and that you were not very satisfied
- 50:00with the results? I think it's part of the game.
- 50:06Some efforts are more fruitful than others. So
- 50:11yeah. Well, for us, it was really a bummer to
- 50:17see that the EU legislation was pushed further
- 50:22in the timeline because at the moment Spain was
- 50:26the one holding these rotatory presidents of
- 50:30the EU, you know, and the ministry officials
- 50:33were telling us that they booked all the rooms
- 50:38for the presentation of these regulations. So
- 50:42it was a thing that was going to happen in 2024.
- 50:49And they received a call from the European Commission
- 50:52holding all operations in no time and they have
- 50:57to pay a lot. They complained that they had to
- 51:00pay a lot for those venues that they reserved
- 51:03for the publishing of these proposals because
- 51:08there was this one that would be very important,
- 51:12banning all cages from the farming sector and
- 51:15the other one on transport. of course, but also
- 51:19there was one on labeling and putting an end
- 51:24to this overwhelming strange situation that we
- 51:30have on labeling in Europe because animal welfare
- 51:33labeling is kind of each company coming up with
- 51:37their own animal welfare label and with their
- 51:39own standards and they are the ones looking at
- 51:42it. to see if they meet the standards or not,
- 51:46but not the administration. So it's kind of,
- 51:50it's backed by thin air. Really, it's not something
- 51:55that you can really check and see if they are
- 52:01accomplishing really. They are delivering or
- 52:03not, we don't know. So having a public and regulated
- 52:10animal welfare label for all the year, that was
- 52:15something that we were really expecting. And
- 52:19also there was one on the slaughterhouses that
- 52:22would replicate what we did in Spain. So having
- 52:26them delayed was a huge bummer for us because
- 52:30we thought that we were getting them in 2024.
- 52:35Ursula von der Leyen, the president of the European
- 52:37Commission, said that this would be delivered
- 52:41in 2022. So we were two years behind schedule,
- 52:48but now they are kind of in limbo because they
- 52:56are not even delivering a date for the release
- 53:00of any of these measures. Only transport that
- 53:03is now at the European Parliament, they are working
- 53:08on the amendments and at the council as well.
- 53:11And the one on farming that will be banning the
- 53:16cages, that's coming along as well, but slower
- 53:20than transport. The other two, they're not even
- 53:25talking about them. So it's really hard for us
- 53:29to see this happening. And what explains that
- 53:33delay? Because is it coming from the lobbies?
- 53:37Because if I was a... person, you know, lobbying
- 53:41for big ag, if I can't get my way, well, the
- 53:45best thing I could I can get is at least a delay
- 53:48in implementing those measures. So is it coming
- 53:52from them? Where is it coming from, you know,
- 53:55this push to delay everything? We believe so.
- 53:59We believe so because we saw as primary situations
- 54:05that spawn this delay. not only the European
- 54:09elections of 2024, because the spectrum shifted
- 54:15through all these parties that were rooting for
- 54:19more, well, how to say this? Okay, let's put
- 54:29it this way. All these parties that were backing
- 54:33the farmers that were protesting, with their
- 54:36tractors on the streets. So it was kind of European
- 54:39elections on one side and the tractors rallying
- 54:45throughout Brussels and all the European capitals
- 54:49at the same time. That was something that really
- 54:53made the new European Commission look into what
- 54:59the previous ones have done and said, hey, let's
- 55:03stop this for a minute. because otherwise it
- 55:06would be very difficult for the European Commission
- 55:08to meet the demands that the farmers were rooting
- 55:14for. And that was to see them so permeable to
- 55:20the farmers, to see the Commission so permeable
- 55:22to farmers was a setback. But at the same time,
- 55:30now that we look at the farmers rallying against
- 55:33the Mercosur agreement, we see that we have a
- 55:37chance at the moment to push for the full proposals
- 55:42to be delivered and to speed things up. But it
- 55:47remains to be seen, really. Just a word about
- 55:53the labeling situation. It must be very frustrating
- 55:57to have that double standard of like the industry,
- 56:03the animal products, they can label their products
- 56:07the way they want. I mentioned on another episode
- 56:13how they do some bad advertisements. They just
- 56:18lie about their environmental impact. Now you're
- 56:21talking about how they mislabel things as humane
- 56:25and cage -free and so on. At the same time, plant
- 56:30-based products are not allowed to use words
- 56:34like milk to sell their soy -based milk. So that
- 56:41double standard must be very frustrating for
- 56:43you. Sure. We were impacted by the European Commission
- 56:49and the European Parliament stating that you
- 56:53cannot say that a veggie burger is a burger.
- 57:00So it's strange because this shows how permeable
- 57:05they are to the interests of the food industry,
- 57:09right? And at the same time, we thought that,
- 57:15well, okay, it's one way to look at things, but
- 57:19if we are getting the proposal on enabling, it
- 57:24would be all sorted out, but... then nothing
- 57:27happened with the labeling proposal because what
- 57:31they were discussing regarding the labeling proposal
- 57:35was that maybe labeling shouldn't be mandatory
- 57:39at all. So it would be kind of labeling that
- 57:44if you want, that would be great, but we won't
- 57:49force you to improve your animal welfare standards
- 57:54or nothing like this. So, it was very strange
- 57:59because it was the one law that our minister,
- 58:06the Spanish agriculture minister was most interested
- 58:10about, but I don't know if they didn't push for
- 58:15it or they found out that some countries throughout
- 58:21the EU didn't want this to be a thing because
- 58:24I'm not speaking only about the Spanish supermarkets.
- 58:28It's all EU, really. And some of the bigger countries
- 58:35were kind of pushing against it. I don't know
- 58:39why. Maybe they have their own systems implemented
- 58:43and they didn't want to lose them to a label
- 58:48that is not mandatory. I don't know. That's fascinating,
- 58:52and I'm so glad that you exist doing this complicated
- 58:56work. Oh my gosh. You need to persevere in that
- 59:00line of work. I feel like it's a key quality
- 59:04here. Maybe before we stop the recording, a few
- 59:10words about the staff at your organization, your
- 59:14colleagues. Do you have any special... you know,
- 59:19office tradition, uh, that, you know, brings
- 59:22the mood up, uh, with every everyone. Well, we,
- 59:30we need to, to, um, I believe because I'm the
- 59:34new guy, you know, I arrived, uh, in October.
- 59:38So it's all about the team. The wins are all
- 59:41about the team accomplish accomplishing all that
- 59:45we discussed and For me, we should work on more
- 59:49retreats, you know, not only once a year, because
- 59:53we have a blast in the last retreat that we had
- 59:58and getting together because this organization
- 1:00:01has no office, really. We are, everybody is working
- 1:00:06online. So we need to find ways to meet each
- 1:00:11other and not only in small groups, but the whole
- 1:00:15team, 25 people. And I'm trying to get the retreats
- 1:00:25twice a year or three times a year. That would
- 1:00:28be great, not only because of Team Morgan, because
- 1:00:31I love to be around them. I agree that it's important
- 1:00:37for team cohesion and happy people who are more
- 1:00:42successful or more productive too. than, you
- 1:00:46know, depressed people. Anyway, Jose, this was
- 1:00:51a wonderful conversation. I learned a lot. Did
- 1:00:55you have anything more to add before we stop
- 1:00:59the conversation? Well, it's all about fulfilling
- 1:01:03our own roles and they are all combined, really.
- 1:01:07That's what I have in mind. Amazing. I completely
- 1:01:12agree. Jose, this has been a pleasure. and an
- 1:01:16honor. Thank you so much for all the good work
- 1:01:18you're doing and your team is doing. Thank you
- 1:01:22so much for your contribution and thank you for
- 1:01:25having accepted my invitation. Thank you for
- 1:01:27having me, Ryan. It's been a pleasure really.
- 1:01:30Thank you everyone for listening. I kindly invite
- 1:01:33you to share this podcast with the vegans you
- 1:01:36know. Let's encourage more people to take action.
- 1:01:40Again, thank you so much for caring and I will
- 1:01:43see you next Tuesday. for a new episode.