Latest / Coffee and Crime with Mom / The Interview That Broke Him… | The Lauren Giddings & Stephen McDaniel Case
Transcript
- Nicholle: June 30th, 2011. In Macon, Georgia, police are called to Barrister Hall Apartments, building close to Mercer University's Law School. And at first, everyone is looking for a missing woman. 27-year-old Lauren Giddest. She just graduated from Mercer Law. She was studying for the bar exam, ⁓ she was supposed to be starting the next chapter of her life. But Lauren had not been answering calls. ⁓ friends were getting worried. And then investigators found something outside the apartment complex. A trash bin. And inside, evidence that Lauren had not simply disappeared. She had been murdered. News crews arrived and students gathered. Neighbors stood nearby trying to understand what happened. One those neighbors was Stephen McDaniel. He was also a Mercer Law graduate, and he lived near Lauren. And when the reporter interviewed him on camera, he acted like a concerned friend until the reporter told him remains had been found. Stephen's face changed, his voice changed, and suddenly the man giving an interview about a missing neighbor looked like someone realizing the investigation had just turned toward him. Zalle: Welcome back to Coffee and Carn with Mom, I'm Zale. Nicholle: And I'm Nicole, Mom, and today we're covering the murder of Lauren Giddings. A case that is terrifying, not because the killer was a stranger, but because he was right next door. ⁓ I mean the was locked when everyone got here. And we we just don't know where she is. ⁓ What about ⁓ the like the parking lot area? I they've been doing a lot of I think that's where they have recovered ⁓ the body or they recovered from there. ⁓ Ali. ⁓ Had heard had you seen anything there? ⁓ so on these Thursday episodes we decided we won't do ⁓ the coffee moment. These are supposed be shorter episodes, but they're kinda like a special thing. Zalle: Yeah. Yeah, and they have been kinda lengthy, so we're working on trying to make sure we get them down as far as length goes. Nicholle: Yes. Yes. Kinda across the board after editing that last one. Yes. But we're we're learning. Yeah, we're learning. Zalle: Yeah, we tend to ramble and then editing is impossible. Yeah. Yes. today's case is the Lauren Giddings case and it was crazy because it it really ⁓ shines light on the fact that don't know ⁓ people like you think you people. You just ⁓ know what they show you. Nicholle: Right. That's right, you know the masks they show you. and this case we're talking about Lauren Giddings, who was twenty-seven years old. She was from Laurel, Maryland, and she had recently graduated from Mercer University's Walter F. George School of Law in Macon, Georgia. ⁓ Friends described as smart, driven, kind, and full of life. She had worked hard to get through law school. You can hear your baby. Zalle: Wow, wow, Nicholle: Okay. She had worked hard to get through law school, and in the summer of 2011, ⁓ she was studying for the Georgia Bar This should have been a proud season in her life. She had finished law school and she was preparing for her future. She had every reason to believe life was moving forward. Zalle: And baby, I don't know. You know, everybody's not Kim K who could just pass the bar. R right surprisingly. Nicholle: The bar. ⁓ do you think she really passed the bar? Zalle: That's why I said what I said. Okay? Tis was the joke. Nicholle: Sorry. I was shocked. I I was stunned by the fact that she passed the bar. I guess I got stupid for a second. That was the point. Zalle: Yeah. She passed the bar. Okay. Yeah. But that is hard to to finish law school and passing the bar, getting through it. I know it's law degrees, ⁓ medical including nursing, that are like super hard. So that's always awesome. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. ⁓ yeah. Mm-hmm. Zalle: But Okay. Lauren lived at Hall apartments, which was popular with Mercer Law students because it was close to campus. One of her neighbors was Steven McDaniel. Steven had also graduated from Mercer Law at first He seemed like another quiet student in the building, but investigators would later uncover evidence that Steven's interest in Laura had become obsessive and disturbing, and that is exactly what I'd be saying when I say you you don't know peoples, know, yeah. Nicholle: Yeah, so Lauren was last known alive ⁓ late June twenty fifth in the early morning hours of June twenty sixth of two thousand and eleven. And after that her friends couldn't reach her. That was immediately concerning because Lauren was responsible. She was preparing for the bar exam. She was not someone who would just vanish without warning. When people checked her apartment, things felt wrong. Her belongings were still there, she had not packed up and left, and there was no normal explanation for why she was missing. Zalle: Which is weird. I mean, most people going through law school don't just go missing. Nicholle: No, you put all that work in. Now you're studying for the bar exam. That seems like that would be all you could focus on. Zalle: Yeah, I just I've done years of this. I finally finished school. Now all I need is to pass this exam so I could be a practicing lawyer. That's it. Yeah. I mean, I'm sure the stress was like insane, but to just disappear, no. No. And so there was another detail that makes this case even more disturbing ⁓ Because Nicholle: Yes, this test. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Right, right. Zalle: had reportedly been concerned before about the that someone had entered her apartment or tampered with things around her home. I know that's terrifying. Because I know when I see stuff, like if I come home and I don't remember stuff being moved, I'd be like, Somebody was here. So but I just have like anxiety and I Nicholle: ⁓ my gosh. Right. Zalle: makes it up in my head. But to actually feel like that's really happening, I'm sure. Horrifying. Nicholle: I've had that happen like I walk into a room and I'm like, Something isn't right. Zalle: Something right, at the time that may have seemed a strange feeling or a small warning sign, but after investigators learned what had happened, those fears looked very different, Nicholle: ⁓ June 30th, 2011, investigators found Lauren's remains in a trash bin ⁓ outside the complex. From that moment, this was no longer a missing person's case. it was homicide investigation. The scene was horrifying for Lauren's friends, classmates, and family. And this was not a random place. This was where she lived, where law students walked every day and where neighbors knew each other. And one of those neighbors was about to become the center of the case. Zalle: And I just need to know why. You decided to put her in a trash bin outside the apartment complex. You didn't take her nowhere. This is where both of you reside. Nicholle: Right. And this is not a dumpster. This is not like what you have in normal apartments. This is like the trash can that you have to wheel up to your garage with the the lid that just you you put next to your house if you have a house. So it's not a huge dumpster and it's just on the side of the building. Zalle: No. ⁓ yes. Mm-hmm. Yeah. So I mean that stood out. But Stephen McDaniel was nearby when media outlets were covering Lauren's disappearance. He gave an interview where he talked about Lauren. He appeared emotional and concerned, but then the reporter told him that remains had been found in Baby. That was the moment, okay, because it became one of the most replayed true crime clips connected to this case. You liter it's literally like Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: His soul was like ⁓ Yeah. Nicholle: Yeah, yeah. And it's it looks like they a movie about this, his reaction was ⁓ the theatrical version of it. And you'll This is from the local news in his area. Zalle: Yeah. So we're gonna show you guys. Yeah. The actual news clip. Nicholle: ⁓ Zalle: ⁓ After that clip, it is hard not to pause because knowing what we know now, it feels like we are watching someone's mask clip in real time, which is literally what happened. Like I said, his soul just Nicholle: It's crazy. But we also want to be careful here, as hard as it is. A strange reaction alone does not prove guilt. People react differently to trauma. We can't always say how people will react. What matters is what investigators found after that, and what they found was much bigger than one strange interview. Zalle: I mean, I guess that is like p it it yes, that's true. But also I'm trying to think, like looking at his reaction, could it be because at first if it wasn't he wasn't the killer, which he actually was, and it was just like we're hearing that we found a body, could that have been a like natural reaction? Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Right. When you watch it, you see that even the reporter's reaction is like trying to comfort him. We don't know what it is. We we don't, they don't know for sure. You know, she's trying to cover, she's trying to make it better for him. So clearly her response to it wasn't that he seemed guilty right off. Zalle: Yeah. Guilty, but like shocked. it could be a a natural ⁓ reaction ⁓ if not your brain go to the fact that whoever you're looking for could be dead and now somebody says they're dead. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Right. Yeah, it could be that, definitely. So Stephen McDaniel was questioned by police and at first he was not publicly known as the killer, but investigators began uncovering evidence that tied him to Lauren and to the crime. According to arrest warrant reporting, police found keys connected to the apartment complex that included a key to Lauren's apartment and a key that could unlock doors in the complex. That mattered because there were not obvious signs that Lauren let a stranger inside. Zalle: And then she was saying somebody was there and the fact that it's not just Lawrence Key shows that he probably was doing this to other people and she was just his main fascination. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Right. Mm-hmm. Zalle: Police also found ⁓ hacksaw packaging in Steven's apartment. hacksaw was later found in the storage area at the apartment complex. And testing connected that saw to Lauren through DNA evidence. And that was a major turning point. Cause this was no longer just about odd behavior. Investigators had physical evidence. And who just has a hacksaw? Living in an apartment complex. Nicholle: Who I mean, I'm not even sure I wasn't even sure what a hacksaw was. And yes, why would you need it in an it's not like you have a farm or you live on a ranch or even you have a house with a lot of trees. No. He's in dorms basically. Zalle: Basically. Student living. Nicholle: Right. And as investigators looked deeper, they found evidence that Stephen had been watching Lauren. Reporters described digital evidence including photos and videos connected to Lauren. And this is where the case becomes especially chilling because Lauren was not just randomly attacked. ⁓ The suggested that she had been observed before her murder. ⁓ Zalle: Okay, so this to me just feels like ⁓ it was stalking gone wrong, is what it it seems like. Like he she was obsession and I'm sh at some point he tried to make some kind of advance and it didn't go how he wanted to, and then this is what happened. Yeah. Nicholle: Mm. Right. Mm-hmm. He did. Yes, that's that's what happened. they say that he ⁓ actually asked her out the time that they met. And she said, No, you know, but I would like to remain friends trying to be courteous, you know, because he was kind of an odd kid. ⁓ And it seems like from on she would tell her friends that he made her feel creepy when he was around. So ⁓ he was definitely obsessed with Zalle: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, and that changes how we understand the case because this is not a sudden argument. This is not a burgl burglary that went wrong. This was a case where investigators believe Steven had access, opportunity, and a fixation. And Lauren was living her life studying, preparing for her future, and someone nearby was quietly watching her and plotting on her because there are weirdos everywhere. Yeah. Nicholle: Yes, it that's scary. Yeah, it's very scary. And in April of twenty fourteen, about a week before his trial was scheduled to begin, Stephen McDaniel pled guilty to malice murder. a part of the plea, he gave a written statement. Prosecutors said Stephen admitted he entered Lauren's apartment around four thirty in the morning using a master key. He said he watched her for a while while she slept. When Lauren woke up, he killed her. Later he returned and attempted to hide what he had done. So she woke up in the middle of him being in her apartment. They ⁓ they were saying that. He possibly had been in her apartment before. And this time she woke up. And of course she recognized him and he killed her. so he returned and attempted to hide what he had done. We're not going to describe that part in graphic detail. ⁓ but investigators said Lauren's remains were separated and disposed of in different locations. And they have a I do have a picture what it looked like. Zalle: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Nicholle: when they went into his apartment. It's horrible. It's horrible. Zalle: my goodness. That's just devastating because men really don't realize, like, I mean, obviously it's not all men, but women are literally fighting for their lives every day, ⁓ unbeknownst to us, that there's people out here like this that just have whatever fascination and it's our fault that you can't get your rocks off and now we have to suffer. Yeah. Nicholle: Yes, I know me. And we have right, and we have to be aware. Right. We always have to be aware. There's no way I would go outside and move around with both of my AirPods in my ears. Something that simple. I need to be able to hear, even if I'm by myself, I need to be able to hear somebody's coming up behind me. And that is how women and that's just very basic. Like I'm not afraid when I go outside, but I have to be aware. We always have to be aware. Zalle: Never. Yeah. Yes. I am terrified. Like when I have to go places with the boys, you should see me getting everybody in the car by myself. It's always like, Everybody hurry up, get in the car. Everybody get in. I'm looking, trying to buckle the boys in. I'm turning around looking behind me. Because you know, people are they do crazy crazy things and now nowadays they just snatch people in broad daylight. So I don't put anything past anybody. No. No. So but that plea meant that Lauren's family did not have to sit through a full trial. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Right. They will take advantage of the situation. No, no. You can't. Zalle: Thankfully. But it also meant that the public never heard every piece of evidence presented in court the way they would have during a trial, which for people like us who want to know the information, or even if you know the family did want to know, then that's unfortunate. But still the Nicholle: Yes. Us who wanna know all the details, yeah. Felt that one coming. Including burglary and sex exploit Okay. part of the plea agreement, prosecutors dismissed charges, ⁓ including burglary and sexual exploitation of children charges came out of the broader investigation. They should never, ever, ever, ⁓ ever, ⁓ ever dismiss charges. ⁓ Of sexual exploitation of children. Zalle: Let me tell you, they fucked up when they let me figure out I don't need a degree, no kind of experience, I don't need a recommendation, I don't need none of that shit to be a congresswoman. Cause I'm about to be a congresswoman, I'm about to switch some shit up. It's no way in hell that y'all are like, yeah, ⁓ we'll throw that shit out. Cause he played. Nicholle: No. Well, because you charged him with it because you saw or found something out. You can't just that okay, never mind. I know he's gonna be in prison for hopefully his whole life. Maybe if you didn't drop those charges, cause what you why he wanted them to drop him, because he was gonna go in prison and get his ass taken from him on a nightly basis and his ass probably killed behind fucking with kids. Zalle: Right. It's evidence. Because it was gonna be associated with them children, yeah. Which it should have happened. I don't feel like they should ever dismiss any of that shit. The rest of that, the burglary, cool, cool, cool. The children shit, hell no, that shit should stick with your ass every time. Every time. Every time. You should not be able to get away with that. Sorry. Nicholle: Get on him. No. Mm-hmm. Yep. No, once I have once they have evidence enough that they charged him with it, unless they find out 100% that there was some mistake, I I don't know, I don't know what it could be, but unless you have a hundred percent evidence that he did not do it, you never drop those charges. That's why these people are doing this shit. Zalle: Under the jail. Ev everybody charged with any kind of yep, everybody charged with any kind of crime against children, sexual crimes against children, we should throw their ass in a dungeon like old days, down there with the dragons and gargoyles and shit. Put them down there under there, like we four, five, six layers under the ground and lock that shit up and leave them there. Fend for yourself. Nicholle: I say my position is listen to the song Fertilizer. That's how I feel. That's all I'm gonna say on that. Lauren's family gave a powerful statement in court. They made it clear that Stephen may have taken Lauren's life, but he did not erase who she was. Lauren was more than the crime. She was a daughter and a friend, a law student graduate, a young woman with the future. Zalle: And that is important because cases like this can become known for the killer, the creepy interview, the strange behavior, the evidence. But Lauren is the person who should be remembered because she did not choose for this weirdo to come bust in her apartment and watch her sleep in the middle of the night and infringe on all of her privacy and all of her rights and murder her f because he got caught. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Right. Where she should feel the safest in her own home. Zalle: The safest. Yes. Yes. That it's insane. But she had worked so hard to build a future and that future was stolen from for selfish reasons. Nothing. Nicholle: For nothing. For nothing. And one of the scariest parts of this case is proximity. Stephen was not some unknown person miles away. He was close. He lived nearby. He had gone to the same law school, which is crazy. He understood legal language and police procedure enough to think carefully about what he said. Zalle: Yes, and sh it sounded like it was somebody that she at least tried to be friendly with. So even though I'm not you're not my cup of tea, I'm not gonna treat you no kind of way. I'm not ugly to you. And that makes it even worse. I mean not that it would have been okay the other way around. Nicholle: Nice to yes. Because that because that shows his mindset. How dare her turn me down? You know, like he's he gives he gives off incel. Like he he's by himself and it's everybody else's fault that he's by himself. Zalle: Yeah. Yeah. And that makes the case even more unsettling. Because we often think of danger as something obvious, someone suspicious, someone who stands out, but sometimes danger is quiet. Sometimes it is someone people barely notice and that happens a lot. Nicholle: A lot more than we care to think about. And this case also shows why stalking and voyeuristic behavior should be taken seriously. Those behaviors are not harmless, they are about control, access, and violation. And in Lauren's case, investigators believe that behavior escalated into murder. Zalle: A lot. Mm-hmm. No. Nicholle: Okay, so we're gonna go to the closing exactly because that's just telling us about a video that I don't know if I'm gonna put there. Zalle: Okay. Nicholle: Lauren Giddings should have been stepping into her legal career. She should have been taking her bar exam, celebrating with her friends, celebrating with her friends and planning for her future. No, I'm gonna do it over. She should have been taking the bar exam, celebrating with friends and planning her future. And instead, her life was taken by someone who lived close enough to watch her and had access to the place where she should have been safe. Zalle: Her case is remembered because of the interview clip, but it should also be remembered as a warning about obsession stalking and the way quiet warning signs can become serious because if somebody is around you and they're giving you the ick, I mean a lot of the times people just like, ⁓ you're being a ass or whatever the case is. But no, if you fe you like this person being around them, they genuinely make my skin crawl like something isn't right, then y'all need to pay attention to that. And if you Nicholle: Right. You always need to pay attention to to Zalle: Yes. And if ⁓ you feel that way, they shouldn't always be around you. Like they shouldn't have the and obviously he was right there. He was close, like a neighbor, so she really didn't have that choice. But those in her life should listen. Nicholle: That's right. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Right. And I think that we, especially as women, tend to discount those feelings. We're like, ⁓ we're being extra. People tell us we're emotional. We're being extra. We have those intuitions and those feelings that to protect ourselves. So we have to learn to listen to them. Because Lauren was loved and she mattered and her story deserved to be told with care. Zalle: Mm-hmm. Nicholle: Thank you for listening to Coffee and Crime with Mom. Lock your doors, trust your instincts, and we'll see you next time. Zalle: Yes, and watch out for the weirdos.