Latest / Dark Murder: True Crime Cases / Episode 41
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the podcast where we discuss anything and everything criminal. I'm your
- 0:04host Jordan Lee. On today's episode, we are going to delve into the
- 0:08puppy sitter case. Beloved by family. Born in January nineteen eighty three,
- 0:13Holly Peranen grew up in a family that loved her dearly. By age ten
- 0:16and nineteen ninety three, she resided in Grafton, Massachusetts. Holly dreamed of
- 0:21becoming a marine biologist, coming at a time after she just finished fourth grade.
- 0:25In the summer of that year, the family was on a vacation at
- 0:28Quackum Quaysite Pond, better known as South Pond, about twenty eight miles from
- 0:32home. The grandparents owned a summer cottage in this rural area, which was
- 0:36a perfect recreational destination for Holly and her father, Richard, as well as
- 0:40her two younger brothers, seven year old Andy and five year old Zachary,
- 0:44who all went on the vacation that started in early August. Quiet vacation turning
- 0:48into a disaster. August fifth, nineteen ninety three, was the second day
- 0:51of the Pieranen's vacation at South Pond. The morning started quietly, but with
- 0:56lots of fun. Richard pieran And took his children out for a boat ride
- 0:59to go swimming. They were already back inside the cottage by noon, but
- 1:03Holly and Zachary were already on the go again, heading out to a neighbor's
- 1:06house where the children expected to see some newborn Collie puppies. They had to
- 1:10walk along allan road to reach the gates to the neighbor's garden, where they
- 1:14waited for the neighbors to let the puppies outside, but witness saw both children
- 1:18standing there, and it was the last reported sighting of Holly from someone aside
- 1:22from her younger brother, because he did leave her at some point, which
- 1:25must have been someone after twelve pm. For what reason Zachary left his sister
- 1:29is unknown, but he went back to the cottage back there peering and asked
- 1:33him where Holly was, and after stating that she was still at the neighbor's
- 1:36garden, Zachary and Andy were sent to pick up Holly for lunch. They
- 1:40returned some time later, but without Holly. Holly's been taken. When the
- 1:42two boys arrived at the spot they expected their sister to be, she wasn't
- 1:47there. The only thing left of her was one of her shoes. They
- 1:49searched for her, but couldn't find her, and only came back to the
- 1:53vacation home with the shoe that was left. Zachary and Andy showed their father
- 1:57peering in the shoe and Andy said, Holly's been taken, but pierin and
- 2:00immediately left to search for his daughter himself. Without a trace of her,
- 2:04he immediately dialed nine one one, and it only took minutes until a search
- 2:07for the young girl started. For several days, police, firefighters, volunteers,
- 2:12and boy scouts looked for the ten year old Holly without any success.
- 2:15It took many more months until she would be found, but not the way
- 2:19anyone hoped for. Assaulted and murdered. It was a late October day,
- 2:23the twenty third. More than two months had passed since Holly pieran And disappeared,
- 2:27but this day would hold drastic changes for the investigation into her case.
- 2:30Hunters with a bunch of dogs were heading into a forest in Brimfield, Massachusetts.
- 2:35This is where they found the bones and skull of a human. A
- 2:38T shirt, dungarees, and a lone shoe were found near the body,
- 2:42which was positively identified to belong to the missing ten year old Holly Pierane.
- 2:46Everything that an autopsy could conclude was that she had been assaulted and murdered,
- 2:50but the cause of death couldn't be determined anymore. This terrible finding rose the
- 2:53question everyone asked who did this? Many suspects and scary moments. It was
- 2:58clear for many that this was a crime of opportunity, that someone must have
- 3:01seen Holly watching the puppies and got a horrible thought that led the person to
- 3:06abduct and kill her. In fact, there has been a strange encounter made
- 3:08by two sixteen year old girls on the day that Holly vanished, not far
- 3:13from where the ten year old was. Two cousins were walking along Allan Street
- 3:16at noon to head towards a mailbox when a light colored pickup truck drove by
- 3:20and slowed to walking speed right next to the girls. The driver, a
- 3:23middle aged white man, looked at them in a menacing way that frightened them
- 3:27so much to turn around and go back to the house where their fathers were
- 3:30busy packing things for vacation. In fact, the encounter must have been so
- 3:34scary for one of the girls to believe the man in the pickup was going
- 3:37to jump out and grab one of us. The truck meanwhile continued down the
- 3:40street, but returned only to scare the girls another time. The man would
- 3:44drive by one last time before never returning. It's likely that he had to
- 3:47pass the spot where Holly was did he possibly kidnap her? While that question
- 3:52can't be answered right now, there are two actual persons of interest in the
- 3:55case. One of them was David Pulliett, who worked for a juvenile detention
- 4:00center and had been a veteran during the Vietnam War. Items found at the
- 4:02crime scene seemed to have tied Pulliat to the area at the time the murder
- 4:05of Holly must have happened. Whatever these items were as a mystery, and
- 4:10Pulliat died in two thousand and three before any evidence could be held against him.
- 4:14Another person of interest is Randy Stanger. He lived close to the place
- 4:17where Holly's body was eventually found. Additionally, based on flashbacks Zachary had years
- 4:23after Holly's murder, a sketch was drawn of a man Zachary claimed to have
- 4:26seen during his flashbacks. The end result of the sketch had strong similarities to
- 4:30Stanger. He was also indirectly connected to Holly through his brother Rodney, a
- 4:33different tragedy. Rodney Stanger has long been the prime suspect in the murder of
- 4:39Molly bish who was murdered seven years after Holly's death. She was just sixteen
- 4:44years old when she was abducted and killed. The corpse of her was found
- 4:46in a wood some time later. What makes her murder especially chilling is the
- 4:49fact that Molly wrote a letter to Holly's family after she vanished. At that
- 4:54time, Molly was as old as the missing girl. In her letter,
- 4:57she noted, I am very sorry. I wish I could make it up
- 5:00to you. Holly is a very pretty girl. She is almost as tall
- 5:02as me. I wish I knew Holly. I hope they found her.
- 5:05What now? Twenty nine years have passed since Holly peering and disappeared, and
- 5:10the twenty ninth anniversary of the discovery of her corpse is also not far anymore.
- 5:15Despite suspects, her case is unsolved, but everyone keeps on hoping that
- 5:18justice has served. One day not far anymore. In twenty twenty, there
- 5:21has been an update in the case. A grave was exhumed in connection to
- 5:25Holly's murder. Not much information was disclosed to the public, except for the
- 5:29fact that the body belonged to a man. According to Boston twenty five,
- 5:32how much significance this head for Holly's case hasn't been answered yet, as there
- 5:36have been no more updates ever since. Still, the support for Holly is
- 5:40big. A Facebook page with the name Justice for Holly peering and keeps on
- 5:44actively updating about her case. That's all for this episode. Please don't forget
- 5:47to like and subscribe so you never miss an episode. If you'd like to
- 5:51support the channel, you can go to patty reON www dot patty reON dot
- 5:57com, forward slash Forever Haunted podcast dot com. By joining our pad rhon,
- 6:01you will get access to bonus episodes monthly, as well as a free
- 6:04book of creepy stories. Once a month, I will draw names from the
- 6:08pad rons and select winners for free bookmarks as well as signed paperback copies of
- 6:13creepy stories. So don't forget to sign up. It only costs two dollars.
- 6:16Thanks for tuning into today's darkness. I hope to see you on the
- 6:19next chilling episode.