Latest / Gabriel Ellis, PhD | The Curious Mind Podcast / Therapy Recording Sessions - "Anna", part 4/6
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Cure is mind podcast and the fourth part of
- 0:03my therapy recording sessions. This is the second part of the
- 0:08second session with my client Anna.
- 0:10And in this episode, she will continue to reflect on her
- 0:13family situation and in particular, the theme of
- 0:17exclusion. Who is in the family, who is
- 0:21outside of the family and what are possible implications for
- 0:26how to get back into the family. Okay, could you point it out a
- 0:32bit more or just reflect on it? What do you need from them?
- 0:36Why are you the one that needs something from what they can go?
- 0:42All right. I would love for them to to
- 0:46share with me a little more like like things and that they're
- 0:51dealing with because like you know for a while I didn't even
- 0:54know my brother had a girlfriend in total, you know like stuff
- 0:58like that. Why is that important?
- 1:04Because it was such a big deal for him to get a girlfriend and,
- 1:07you know, we were trying. So for so many years, you're in
- 1:09the find somebody and then he did and then really like you
- 1:12didn't share that with me at all and I found out just by chance,
- 1:16right? Yeah.
- 1:18And it's like I'm not really part of the family.
- 1:24If I don't know those things you know.
- 1:27And and um I think I would just, I would just like to have those
- 1:33those fun talks that we used to have that.
- 1:36That would be really nice. It brings me back to the to the
- 1:45question that I have, when it's always at the back of my mind,
- 1:48what is family to you? Because I understand there is
- 1:52something like family that was in the past.
- 1:54It was the close connections that you had the fact that they
- 1:58trusted you, that you trusted them.
- 2:02So, this was there. And it was at a time when you
- 2:05were still living in the u.s., when you were younger before,
- 2:08you get married before you were pregnant.
- 2:11So what this is, I mean, almost two decades ago, it has been a
- 2:17while so right now, it's not real.
- 2:21Is this need for family. A need to go back to a place or
- 2:26a time when you felt happy with them.
- 2:30What is the present you need that you have?
- 2:33Yeah. Or is it all melancholic?
- 2:36You know that just wish we could have those fun times again?
- 2:40Yeah. Maybe it's a bit event that they
- 2:43can just being very nostalgic, you know, I don't know.
- 2:50I never thought of like what what their their purpose in my
- 2:55life would be, you know, it's just we always assume like okay,
- 3:00you have a brother and sister or siblings, whatever family is
- 3:04family, right? And that's what I was taught.
- 3:07Like, no matter what your you have to be family.
- 3:12My family is kind of very, very close to the point where they
- 3:18don't accept Outsiders. You know, so people who married
- 3:21into my family were never treated like fully as part of
- 3:26the family. There's a lot of deep stuff with
- 3:31that and you know, even my father who has been with my mom,
- 3:36since they were teenagers, it took him a long time to be fully
- 3:41accepted in my mom's side of the family, just bizarre, because
- 3:45they grew up in the same area, whatever.
- 3:48And And so we always had this thing like, you know, they're
- 3:54not really part of us. Yes.
- 3:57It's now maybe I'm feeling like, oh no, I'm like, I've been
- 4:03kicked out like the, you know, the in-laws and boyfriend's
- 4:06girlfriend's. I'm like in that category So
- 4:11that there's a theme on or we can say maybe a tool of
- 4:14inclusion and exclusion that conclusion has to be earned
- 4:20somehow. Yeah yeah and for some reason
- 4:24you fell out of favor and yeah the inclusion anymore.
- 4:29Does that sound right? Definitely like it's, it's so
- 4:34deep, like, my mom will will only tell me a few things about
- 4:38my sister, not everything, you know, and she'll be like, know
- 4:44it, she'll brush it off. And she won't reveal certain
- 4:48things or whatever, and it's not like, she doesn't want to
- 4:51gossip. It's not like it going into
- 4:53gossip territory, or - it's just more.
- 4:55Like, what's happening with her lie?
- 4:57Can we tell me it? Does she need help or something?
- 5:01And Like, you know, I'm not in the situation.
- 5:07What's up reveals? At least two things.
- 5:10So far that we had in our conversation, which I would like
- 5:14to bring two more to the surface to see what you're up against.
- 5:20There's the one thing that we had more in the beginning, which
- 5:23is a family policy of not talking about conflicts, not
- 5:32maybe Express needs and demands. So overtly, But this avoidance
- 5:40theme, right? There's one thing and that can
- 5:44be already challenging enough to break because you're in the
- 5:48position now where you don't want things to just continue.
- 5:51So you want to make a change, right?
- 5:53And order to make this change probably necessary that you open
- 5:57up. More of look guys have been
- 6:01disappointed by the past, I would like us to be closer
- 6:03together again. In short to say something that
- 6:08usually is not said in your family, so that's one thing.
- 6:10And then now we have another theme emerging where your family
- 6:15has apparently of a way of including and excluding people.
- 6:21Which as you said can be quite powerful.
- 6:25And so far that in-laws of the is kind of have to struggle to
- 6:30be regarding insiders. And you have been, you know, we
- 6:37can put a drastically excommunicated.
- 6:40Yeah, right. So there's no communication with
- 6:44you from their side. And so additionally to kind of
- 6:49introduce yourself as a new person, the person that you are
- 6:52now and not the cutie but you have been regarded as when you
- 6:56were young. So to introduce yourself as a
- 6:59new person with new needs and to overcome this exclusion that
- 7:04somehow more or less consciously has taken place, these are
- 7:08powerful obstacles. These are obstacles that I mean
- 7:13I know very little of your family just from your
- 7:16descriptions but if I look at other families this has
- 7:19potential to go over generations and I was like your grandfather
- 7:24disappointed, my grandmother and this is why we never regarded
- 7:30families do that. I'm not saying yeah, there's
- 7:33necessarily but these kind of stories, these kind of Dynamics.
- 7:37They do have the power to continue.
- 7:40You for such a long time. So, when you reach out to your
- 7:44siblings, I think it's good to keep in mind that there are
- 7:49those several additional unconscious layers in their
- 7:53minds that they have to overcome in order to be close to you
- 7:58again. Okay.
- 7:59Yeah, it goes General because it goes deep, doesn't it
- 8:03generational thing? Yes, it's like, it's like being
- 8:08in a clan or like, A cult. Or something with my family
- 8:14sometimes. Yeah, I call it very clannish.
- 8:21So let's reflect a little bit on.
- 8:24Let's say you're reaching out to a sibling, right?
- 8:26And we keep in mind that there are those kind of instinctual
- 8:30obstacles for them to reconnect with you.
- 8:33Again, a consequence of this would be for me that you would
- 8:38have to make it really attractive and interesting and
- 8:43palatable to connect with them again.
- 8:47Sorry for them to connect with you again.
- 8:50How would you, how would you package this the whole thing,
- 8:54what are some of your ideas is to brainstorm?
- 8:58What you could try so that they would be interested in that?
- 9:05I was thinking that like I started with thinking with my
- 9:08sister yesterday like for us to just share more just pictures,
- 9:14you know just privately because I know she doesn't like to Post
- 9:17online which is fine. I respect that but like I don't
- 9:21know like what my niece is look like.
- 9:24And I told her like even if you know because they're growing up
- 9:28so quickly and I don't get to see them so much.
- 9:33She's so maybe if I just start sending her more short videos or
- 9:39pictures to show her. Hey like this.
- 9:42This is something that we can do together because we're both
- 9:45mother's, we can Bond over that, you know, that you're not alone,
- 9:50being a worried mom or whatever our children are, the same age,
- 9:54by the way, we were both pregnant the same year.
- 9:59And so there's a connection with that and we can go off of that
- 10:04you know? Yes that's a possibility.
- 10:08I it seems to me that this would be driven by your initiative.
- 10:13Yeah. And maybe this is kind of an
- 10:15investment that you want to make for your own sake because you
- 10:19will get something out of it, which is eventually to belong.
- 10:22So I think this is one kind of set of strategies which is kind
- 10:26of too casually lower them. Two more contact?
- 10:32Yes. None conflictual, right.
- 10:38What is what would be a more open more direct approach?
- 10:44How would that look like when you express your need stronger?
- 10:47When you express your disappointment of the past
- 10:51stronger, and so on? How would that look?
- 10:54I guess, you know, in terms of mice with my sister, it's just a
- 10:59simple conversation because I think with her, I can
- 11:03communicate that openly. I think with her, it's there.
- 11:10But with my brother, I don't know.
- 11:14I don't know if we're just so different that and we just have
- 11:18such different Lifestyles that might be like, I don't even know
- 11:22if he would care. Listen.
- 11:27Okay, let's let's think about a contact with your sister then,
- 11:29so that seems more realistic can.
- 11:33So you can imagine to have an open conversation like that with
- 11:37her with were several instances in the past.
- 11:40Where was disappointed, I realized that more and more now
- 11:44I'm sorry that I was more open in the past myself.
- 11:48All these kind of more explicit kind of bits of inside To give
- 11:55how would that ferret? You think, how would you react
- 11:58to that? I think she would be open to it.
- 12:02She's you know, she's one of those.
- 12:03She's a very good listener. It's someone like she wouldn't
- 12:09be judgmental. Is she someone who like my
- 12:13brothers clothes with her? Like, you know, she she can be
- 12:17close to both of us. She's, she knows how to handle
- 12:22people and and to be the rock, I think I, you know, the torch got
- 12:29put on to her. Mmm.
- 12:32Yeah, definitely. She was more involved with Mom
- 12:37and Dad and having children of her own also, like, you know,
- 12:43elevated her place in the family.
- 12:45Because things were centered around her her daughters and so
- 12:51she has more like control in that way but she and maybe she's
- 12:56not happy that she got put in that position, you know.
- 13:01I think that it's stressful for her.
- 13:03She has a lot of stress that she deals with And sometimes I feel
- 13:09guilty about it. Yeah.
- 13:13Like I abandoned her. Yes, right.
- 13:18But I mean, we have this position for a long time.
- 13:22Do you think that you got the worst part of the bargain that
- 13:27the stress and the post 20s is more to Bear than yeah dress
- 13:32that you had. Yeah, I think so because, you
- 13:37know, Mom and Dad now are getting older and they had to
- 13:42sell their plays may moved in with my brother and there's more
- 13:46like a we got to take care of Mom and Dad now.
- 13:50Yeah. And whereas before it was like
- 13:53Mom and Dad were there for for us to go and stay with them and
- 13:58we can like rely on them. But now the roles have reversed
- 14:01and there's so much pressure put on her.
- 14:04Then care of two kids working, full time, dealing with her
- 14:08marriage issues, taken care of family that she's never had
- 14:13like, earlier. I was mentioning that she
- 14:15doesn't have a life outside of my family.
- 14:17That's enough. That's not her fault though.
- 14:19Like, she is not allowed to. And, and here I am, I can I have
- 14:26more freedom You know, in my life.
- 14:30Now that I don't have a crazy marriage and I can, you know,
- 14:37things generally in my personal life or quite good, I can go do
- 14:43some traveling if I wanted. I can, you know, go have a fun
- 14:46night out. She can't, she doesn't, she
- 14:49doesn't get that. Yes.
- 14:52I feel so bad but that's even a third layer, right?
- 14:58That might make it difficult for them.
- 15:00And it's like, oh, she has didn't know much, but she's
- 15:04fine. Don't worry, we have no right to
- 15:08take care of. Yeah.
- 15:11So You know, they, I always hear comments like, oh, it's nice
- 15:17that you get to go to Berlin. Oh, that's, you know.
- 15:22Where's who's watching your kid? Like and I have a different life
- 15:27Arrangement here where I can do those things.
- 15:32It doesn't mean that my life is perfect and I'm completely happy
- 15:35and satisfied all the time, you know?
- 15:38But for them, it looks like Mall.
- 15:41She's, she's living it up and we have to work a lot, and we have
- 15:47to take care of family stuff and I just take a train, you know.
- 15:53Yes. So it's cookie like she
- 15:56chickened out. and we have the responsibility and that might be
- 16:03a source of resentment resentment that they might be
- 16:08more or less aware of Yeah, for sure.
- 16:18I feel that. I feel like, yeah, they probably
- 16:23resent me. They like, I think they, they
- 16:27don't want to address that, and they will hide that, because
- 16:31that's not something we're supposed to feel because we're
- 16:36family and family is thicker than blood, right?
- 16:39Yeah, but it manifest in other ways.
- 16:42Ways. You know, and that's why I'm
- 16:46saying like maybe it would be healthier if they just got it
- 16:49out and just hold me like, hey, I'm not happy that.
- 16:54You did that. Okay, but from their point of
- 16:58view, let's say the event and the let it out, right?
- 17:01And there will be a more open discussion about this What were
- 17:06you going to say? Look, if you want any contact,
- 17:09you have to move back and support us with Mom and Dad.
- 17:13If you don't want to do this fine but then don't count on us
- 17:19to be the family that you wish to have because you left us with
- 17:23them. Yeah.
- 17:25So that might be, you know, this would be a kind of a worse
- 17:27scenario of how such a conversation would go but what
- 17:31I'm trying to say is an open conversation would not
- 17:33necessarily the conflict because then they would say, okay, you
- 17:36want to change things, come back.
- 17:39Mmm. Yeah.
- 17:42And that is certainly not what you would like to do.
- 17:46No. No but at least I would know, at
- 17:50least it would be clear, right? Because I wouldn't I went love
- 17:58that situation a situation. I went you know be happy after
- 18:01that conversation but at least I'd have a little more peace
- 18:04with it like well at least I know where where the boundaries
- 18:07are whereas now it's like I really don't know and I'm in no
- 18:13man's land with with who I am. This family, can you imagine to
- 18:20we're still thinking in possible conversations?
- 18:23Could you imagine to from your site to just apologize for that
- 18:27without even knowing if they have such a conscious
- 18:31resentment? I think I've come to a place
- 18:35where I would feel comfortable doing that.
- 18:37I think earlier, I was like, you know, like how I put I couldn't,
- 18:43I would have been angry, like, you know, don't you know what?
- 18:46I'm dealing with but now because I have a more peace and clarity
- 18:51about myself here. Yeah, I can completely empathize
- 18:57with them and say, I understand like, It wasn't fair, you know,
- 19:04it will but it, but at the same time, it wasn't intentional, it
- 19:07wasn't personal. You know, I wasn't trying to be
- 19:12a bad person to you. I mean, I know constellations of
- 19:18such families that live in different locations where the
- 19:26one in your position might take over some responsibilities in
- 19:30order. To, you know, unburden, the
- 19:33family of, for example, I want to take care of some counting
- 19:37stuff or some, hellish Insurance health insurance stuff or
- 19:42something that can be contributed from from the
- 19:45distance, which would be not only a substantial help for your
- 19:51siblings in that case. But with be just can could not
- 19:56be ignored as a gesture. We're kind of your effort to to,
- 20:01to put something in would just unmistakably show.
- 20:05Look, I want to get involved. I am living here.
- 20:08Not moving back, but I'm doing. If there's something that I can
- 20:12do from here, I will take this extra load, just an order to
- 20:16show you that I care. Yeah, that might be a
- 20:20possibility. yeah, I would I would be open to that, you know,
- 20:26like You know, my parents are not too thrilled about my
- 20:32brother's girlfriend or whatever and stuff.
- 20:35And I always said, I can talk to my brother, you know, like they
- 20:40want me to talk to him. Do you want me to ask him some
- 20:42things, because I'm a neutral person in this situation?
- 20:45I don't know so much, but I can be there, but I need to be a
- 20:51little more. I need to put more pressure on
- 20:54my brother to, like, talk to me because he's There's nothing
- 20:59coming from his side. So but let me ask you because we
- 21:05have spoken mostly about your siblings now.
- 21:07And my understanding was from the beginning in the middle of
- 21:10our conversation, that your priority would be to like, to
- 21:15reconnect with your siblings because this is for you, the
- 21:18future of your family. So if I took that kind of aspect
- 21:23more seriously than Then it would be detrimental to have an
- 21:28antagonizing conversation with your brother in the sense of
- 21:32look, monk your girlfriend because that would certainly
- 21:35yeah those are to you right right.
- 21:39I know I don't want to do that. Like I and I tell them listen if
- 21:44he's happy and he's happy, you know, it's his choices like I
- 21:47don't want to Judge him on it. Yeah, I don't want to antagonize
- 21:55it. Okay, so recapitulating
- 22:00capitulating a little bit and trying to build an ark kind of
- 22:05for our conversation. For me, the guiding question was
- 22:09as who would you approach your siblings or family when you
- 22:15start a new phase of seriously trying to reconnect with them?
- 22:19And I think we talked about many bits and pieces there Do I
- 22:24connect with them as the strong sibling, or the one in need?
- 22:30The one who has something to offer the one who is willing to
- 22:33apologize for, you know, unfairness that you might have
- 22:37created about wanting it. The one who is addressing, more
- 22:42the siblings and prioritizing your future with them, or also
- 22:47trying to connect with your rings.
- 22:51And in that sense to help out with yours, siblings, when they
- 22:54have certain needs and these I think are questions that are
- 22:58worth kind of thinking over and ruminating brainstorming over
- 23:04because I sense that there's a lot of kind of undifferentiated
- 23:10feel when it comes to your approach to the family and this
- 23:16can end up in a mess. I don't know if it would but I
- 23:20know from examples again that it might be so that especially in a
- 23:25family where it was kind of it seems to have been built in that
- 23:30it's it's not very differentiated and not very
- 23:34clear what the sets of needs and Tires are of each individual
- 23:39family member. It would make sense that you
- 23:42introduced that for yourself, where you go against the grain
- 23:45of the family, Dynamic and ask yourself explicit questions.
- 23:51What is my attitude towards my brother?
- 23:54What is my attitude towards my sister?
- 23:56What can she be, what can I be for them?
- 23:59What can I do? Right, and my parents, of
- 24:03course, as well, at the beginning, just to introduce
- 24:07this kind of differentiated way of thinking into my thought
- 24:10world, not in order to come to full conclusions and answers and
- 24:15a strategy. But just to get used to this way
- 24:18of thinking of explicitness, at least in my mind.
- 24:23And this certainly something that I would suggest and I would
- 24:27be interested to know what kind of further ideas you would get
- 24:30to when you reflect for it over it in the next week.
- 24:34But I also would be interested in how you see things now and if
- 24:38you see marriage in this approach, okay I would I
- 24:44probably would need time to like even write it down on paper
- 24:48because it's how I yes awesome things and just It's a good way
- 24:54to think. Like how like What is my role
- 24:59for them? What do I want from them?
- 25:01What do I think that they want from me?
- 25:04Because I can't be sure but what I can offer.
- 25:09Yeah. There's that I definitely never
- 25:12thought about it. It's just, it's just implanted
- 25:15in me all their brother and sister and therefore, it's that,
- 25:19you know, and it definitely changed our Dynamics have really
- 25:25changed Through The Years. So maybe we need to To
- 25:28re-examine that. Figure it out, at least.
- 25:32This is what I was suggest to you, because if I think the
- 25:35other way, if you didn't, develop a kind of clearer
- 25:40perspective for yourself, then I think the tendency would be that
- 25:45you have to that. You could join the family
- 25:48Dynamics again on terms of the family Dynamics.
- 25:53Basically, if you want to go back, you play by our rules.
- 25:56Again, the rules of avoidance, the rules of being nice, the
- 26:01rule of maybe being cute again on that rule.
- 26:05This I would feel is the danger if you think.
- 26:08Okay let me just try and somehow feel my way into it without a
- 26:12more explicit approach and that I don't know it can go well but
- 26:18I you know, I would have my concerns and I would certainly I
- 26:22like you to be more grounded and you approach that you don't lose
- 26:26yourself in a progressive way that you have to become, you
- 26:32know, one again if you want to be a yeah, right.
- 26:37This would be my concern from looking from the outside.
- 26:42Now, it's real, these are topics.
- 26:46Like I said, I never addressed before especially with my
- 26:49family. So it's I've no idea how they'll
- 26:53respond to it because we've never been in this situation
- 26:56like ever when you reflected in the next week.
- 27:00Don't think about them because that this is two three steps
- 27:04away. Yeah for me it would be more
- 27:06important or is he a bigger potential in the way that you
- 27:10think the way that you reflect On your siblings, the family
- 27:13Dynamic. And so on its, I don't see any
- 27:16kind of a direct way to how to communicate it to them, but
- 27:19first of all, you know, like you said, I haven't thought about it
- 27:22in these terms just for yourself.
- 27:24Does it give me something? Does it, does it Advance my way
- 27:28of reflecting on myself and the family?
- 27:32When I start to be more explicit in my own thinking?
- 27:37And then it might still be the result that when it comes to
- 27:42dealing with your sister and brother, kind of the kind in
- 27:45explicit approach might still be the more valuable but but still
- 27:49you would be grounded in a more explicit.
- 27:51Respect of yourself. Yeah.
- 27:54Yeah, it's good point. Okay.
- 27:58Okay, I will think of those things.
- 28:00I would make there is no harm and it's it has the potential I
- 28:05think to change up the terms, the terms and conditions of how
- 28:10to engage with them. Oh yeah.
- 28:14Like my my little homework. Like right.
- 28:19Who am I to my siblings? That's, that's kind of a task.
- 28:23It's a little bit artificial. I think it kind of just The
- 28:27Catalyst for future. Yeah, okay.
- 28:32Alright, I'll add, we'll try that.
- 28:34Please join us next time for the beginning of the third, and last
- 28:39session that I have with my client Anna, where we will
- 28:43summarize the journey that she has had so far her insights, and
- 28:48her understanding of the therapeutic process in general.
- 28:27The Catalyst for future. Yeah, okay.
- 28:32Alright, I'll add, we'll try that.
- 28:34Please join us next time for the beginning of the third, and last
- 28:39session that I have with my client Anna, where we will
- 28:43summarize the journey that she has had so far her insights, and
- 28:48her understanding of the therapeutic process in general.