Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / The High-Mileage Renault Zoe: A Reliability Review
Transcript
- 0:00You might remember seeing a picture I put up online not long
- 0:02back. Little electric car, a Renault
- 0:05Zoe looking a bit sorry for itself on a recovery truck.
- 0:08Yes, I saw. That and if you saw it, you were
- 0:10probably thinking, OK, what's the story there?
- 0:14Well, today we're going deep. We're tackling a really direct
- 0:16question. Knowing everything now, would I
- 0:20buy another high mileage Renault Zoe and.
- 0:23The answer is. It's a hard no, a definite no,
- 0:26And stick with us because we're going to unpack exactly why.
- 0:29And that's really our mission today in this deep dive, isn't
- 0:32it? We want to pull out the key bits
- 0:34of information, the really crucial stuff about Runno Zowe
- 0:37reliability, especially those older, higher mileage ones.
- 0:40Yeah, and figure out what that actually means for you if you're
- 0:42maybe looking at buying one of these early, quite popular EV's
- 0:45on the second hand market. We need to go beyond just the
- 0:48one story. Absolutely.
- 0:50I mean the Zowe, it was one of the first EV's lots of people
- 0:52saw regularly, wasn't it? Felt like a proper usable
- 0:55electric car right from the start.
- 0:57For me, and I think for many others, it was that first real
- 1:01taste of of driving electric day-to-day.
- 1:04Quite groundbreaking at the time.
- 1:05Exactly, and that's why we need to look closely.
- 1:07We're going to weigh up the good and the bad using the real world
- 1:10experiences and the technical details from the sources we've
- 1:14got right. The aim is to give you a clear,
- 1:16honest picture of what you can genuinely expect as these
- 1:19pioneering EVs get older. It's about understanding the
- 1:22reality of, you know, long term EV ownership.
- 1:25OK, so let's get into it. We have to rewind to that
- 1:28moment, the day this particular Zoe decided well enough was
- 1:31enough after being pretty reliable for its age.
- 1:34It just completely let me down. Just driving along normal speeds
- 1:38and boom, total loss of power. Felt like it just dropped into
- 1:41neutral completely dead. Oh wow.
- 1:43Nothing. Well, weirdly I try to jump back
- 1:45just on the off chance and it actually sprang back to life,
- 1:48but only for about maybe 200 meters.
- 1:52Just enough to give me this tiny sliver of hope before it died
- 1:55again. The worst kind of hope.
- 1:57Exactly. So there I was, side of the
- 2:00road, waiting for the AA to winch it onto the truck and take
- 2:03it off to my usual garage. And this wasn't a low mileage
- 2:06car failing, was it? Right.
- 2:07What was the mileage when this happened?
- 2:09It was at 114,000 miles. OK, 114,000, which, you know,
- 2:14that's a decent innings for any car, electric or otherwise, but
- 2:18it's definitely the sort of mileage where underlying
- 2:20weaknesses, if they exist, start to show themselves.
- 2:23For sure. And look, thanks to some proper
- 2:25digging by the garage, we now know precisely what went wrong.
- 2:28And interestingly, it wasn't the battery, it wasn't the onboard
- 2:32charger or the General Electronics.
- 2:34So what was it? It was the main event, the motor
- 2:36and the reduction gearbox unit itself.
- 2:38The whole thing just failed. OK, so the drivetrain and do we
- 2:41know why it failed? What was the specific point of
- 2:44failure? Yes, and this is the crucial
- 2:46bit, right? It turns out the original
- 2:48bearing, the one right off the top of the motor, that was the
- 2:51root cause, it'll become really badly scored, just ground itself
- 2:55down. A bearing failure seems simple
- 2:57enough. Well.
- 2:59Yes and no, because that initial failure set off a kind of chain
- 3:02reaction inside the unit, the actual motor shaft spindle, you
- 3:06know, the bit that spins inside the bearing.
- 3:09Because the bearing failed, the shaft started to wear unevenly
- 3:12and actually got bigger in places.
- 3:14Deformed. Bigger.
- 3:15How does that happen? Just to the uneven forces and
- 3:18friction, it effectively mushroomed slightly and this
- 3:21meant there was suddenly a huge amount of play, unwanted
- 3:24movement in the bottom bearing of the motor too.
- 3:27I see SO 1 failed bearing caused problems elsewhere.
- 3:31It wasn't isolated. Exactly.
- 3:32A cascade failure. And the really critical
- 3:35consequence of all that extra movement, all that wobble was
- 3:38that the copper windings inside the motor, they started
- 3:43physically hitting the motor case.
- 3:45They're rubbing against it. You can actually see the marks.
- 3:47And because they're rubbing, it caused the motor to short out.
- 3:50Game over. So the motor essentially drops
- 3:53slightly because the bearings wore out.
- 3:55Pretty much just enough for those windings to make contact
- 3:58where they absolutely shouldn't. It really shows how precise
- 4:02these electric motors are. You know a tiny bit of wear in a
- 4:06seemingly small part like a bearing can lead to complete
- 4:10failure. Right.
- 4:11And this is where it gets really frustrating from a repair
- 4:13perspective. My garage they did the obvious
- 4:16thing, tried to order a new top bearing.
- 4:18Makes sense. Standard procedure.
- 4:20Except Renault will not sell you the bearing.
- 4:23Just the bearing on its own. Nope.
- 4:25It's not available as a separate part from them.
- 4:27Can you believe that? So the garage had to go on this
- 4:30sort of global hunt. They eventually found and
- 4:33ordered a replacement bearing from the United States.
- 4:36From the US for a Renault part, yeah.
- 4:39Interestingly, it actually turned up quite quickly, but.
- 4:41The fact they had to go to such lengths, look this bearing,
- 4:44especially after 114,000 miles handling all the torque from an
- 4:48electric motor, it should be a serviceable part.
- 4:52It absolutely should. You'd think so, like a wheel
- 4:54bearing or something. Exactly, it should be something
- 4:56you can replace as part of maintenance or when it fails.
- 5:00But Renault's approach, their policy seems to be Nope, you
- 5:03have to replace the entire motor unit.
- 5:05Which costs? How much we're talking what, 7
- 5:09or 8000 lbs potentially just for the unit before Labor, yeah.
- 5:13Compared to, I don't know, maybe 50 or £100 for the bearing
- 5:17itself. It's madness.
- 5:19It's completely disproportionate and it wasn't even
- 5:21straightforward after getting the US bearing.
- 5:24Remember how this shaft had worn?
- 5:25Yes, the deformation. So the garage had to take the
- 5:28shaft to a local engineering place, they machined it smooth
- 5:31again, put a custom collar on it and then fitted the new top
- 5:35bearing. Proper job.
- 5:36Sounds like a lot of skilled work.
- 5:37It was, but here's the real gut punch.
- 5:40Even with all that effort, the new top bearing fitted perfectly
- 5:44the wear and the other bearing? The bottom.
- 5:46One still causing problems. Yeah, it meant the motor was
- 5:49still shorting out on the windings.
- 5:52So all that work, all that ingenuity, basically for
- 5:55nothing. We were back to square 17 grand
- 5:57for a motor because a bearing failed.
- 5:59It's like like demolishing your house because a light bulb
- 6:03blows. It really throws that whole
- 6:05green image into question, doesn't it?
- 6:07If things aren't designed to be repaired, just replaced
- 6:09wholesale, and this, you know, this connects to something
- 6:12bigger. This isn't just a Zoe problem
- 6:15though, it's a really clear example.
- 6:17It feels like part of a wider trend in the industry, doesn't
- 6:20it? Both combustion engines and EVs.
- 6:22You mean designing things that are hard to fix?
- 6:24Precisely where maybe the priority is selling new units,
- 6:27new cars, rather than insuring components can be repaired
- 6:30affordably for the long haul. It makes you question if new
- 6:34always means better or more sustainable.
- 6:36Yeah, it reminds me a bit of like the issues with the Ford
- 6:39EcoBoost wet belts or some of those Peugeot Citroen engines
- 6:44where a design choice leads to huge repair bills down the line
- 6:47because a small part isn't easily serviceable.
- 6:50Exactly that kind of thing. The Ford Eco boom as some call
- 6:53it This Zoe motor issue where simple bearing isn't sold
- 6:56separately. It feels like the same sort of
- 6:59thinking. It shifts the cost and the
- 7:01headache entirely on to the owner.
- 7:03So it's not just a faulty part, it's almost a design philosophy
- 7:06issue. I think that's fair to say.
- 7:08And for you listening, the key take away here is when you're
- 7:11looking at any car, especially with newer tech like EVs, don't
- 7:15just ask does it work now? Ask how is it fixed when
- 7:20something does go wrong. Is component repair even
- 7:23possible or are you locked into replacing massive expensive
- 7:26assemblies? Asking that question upfront, as
- 7:29we've seen here, could save you a fortune later on.
- 7:32It forces us to think about the total cost of ownership, not
- 7:35just the sticker price or the fuel savings.
- 7:37So after all that drama with the bearings and the machining,
- 7:40yeah, what actually happened? How did we get the Zoe running
- 7:43again? Right, the solution.
- 7:45Well, huge credit to my garage again.
- 7:47They kept searching and eventually managed to source a
- 7:49complete used Z50 motor and reduction gearbox unit.
- 7:53Ah, a second hand unit. Yeah, this one came out of a
- 7:56much newer 22 plate Zoe that had only done 22,000 miles, so low
- 8:01mileage relatively speaking. Makes sense?
- 8:03They just swapped the whole unit over, fitted the replacement
- 8:06assembly, changed the oil in the reduction gearbox while they
- 8:10were at it and honestly, the result's been brilliant.
- 8:13Good news, finally, and that really shows.
- 8:16Sometimes sourcing a good used assembly is the only practical
- 8:20way forward when the manufacturer won't support
- 8:23component repair. Yeah, good independent garages
- 8:26are lifesavers. Totally.
- 8:28The car is now whisper quiet, silky smooth.
- 8:31The garage reckons it should easily do another 8090, maybe
- 8:35even 100,000 miles. Wow.
- 8:37And my mom is actually using it now mainly for short local
- 8:39trips, probably doing only about 2500 miles a year.
- 8:43So for that kind of use, it's absolutely spot on.
- 8:45She loved it. That's quick and it proves a
- 8:46point, doesn't it? The rest of the car, the battery
- 8:48seems fine, the electronics are good, the onboard charger works
- 8:50perfectly. It was purely that Z50 motor
- 8:53design that couldn't handle the higher mileage because of that
- 8:55bearing issue. So the warning really stands.
- 8:59If you are looking at an older electric car, especially a
- 9:03Renault Zoe with the Z50 motor and high miles, you have to
- 9:07factor in this potential motor failure.
- 9:09Be aware of it. Definitely, but it's not all
- 9:11doom and gloom with Zoe reliability, is it?
- 9:13Let's broaden out a bit. There are other known weak
- 9:16spots, but thankfully they're usually much less serious.
- 9:19OK, good. Like what?
- 9:21Well the front suspension is 1 area.
- 9:23Owners often mention specifically the drop links.
- 9:27Yes, I've heard about knocking noises from the front.
- 9:29Exactly, the drop links connect the anti roll bar to the
- 9:32suspension struts and on the Zoe they seem a bit well, undersized
- 9:38or maybe made of materials that just don't quite cope with the
- 9:40forces over time so they. Wear out quickly.
- 9:43Yeah, faster than you might expect, leading to that knocking
- 9:46or sometimes squeaking sound, especially over bumps.
- 9:49Is that a big fix? No, thankfully that's the good
- 9:52news here. Drop links are pretty cheap
- 9:54parts, and they usually very easy to replace.
- 9:57Maybe an hour's labor. So while it might be annoying if
- 10:00they go every say, 30,000 miles, it's really more of a routine
- 10:04maintenance thing than a major red flag.
- 10:06OK, so annoying but not a deal breaker like the motor.
- 10:09That's reassuring. Definitely not a deal breaker.
- 10:12Another suspension point to be aware of, though maybe less
- 10:15common, is the ball joints on the lower suspension arms.
- 10:19If they become loose, you can also get knocking, sometimes
- 10:21even when you're steering. It can make the front end feel a
- 10:24bit vague, a bit imprecise. Is that specific to the Zoe?
- 10:27Not really, no. That's a wear and tear item on
- 10:30many cars as they get older. The fix usually involve
- 10:33replacing the entire lower suspension arm as the ball joint
- 10:36is often integrated OK. Accessing one of the bolts can
- 10:39apparently be a bit fiddly because of the front subframe
- 10:41design, making the job slightly longer than it perhaps should
- 10:45be. Again, it's not a catastrophic
- 10:47failure, just something to be aware of.
- 10:48Might need doing on an older car.
- 10:50So general advice is just be kind to the suspension.
- 10:54Pretty much a bit of mechanical sympathy, as they say.
- 10:57Slow down for speed bumps, avoid slamming into potholes if you
- 11:00can safely do so. It helps prolong the life of all
- 11:03these components on any car really.
- 11:06Makes sense now, you mentioned earlier that not all Zoe's are
- 11:09the same and this is really important, isn't it?
- 11:11The whole drivetrain variant thing.
- 11:13Absolutely crucial. This is key information if
- 11:16you're shopping for a used Zoe. The potential issues, the
- 11:20performance, even how you charge it can differ quite a bit
- 11:23depending on which drivetrain it has.
- 11:25OK, break it down for us. What are the main types?
- 11:28So there are two main families. When the Zoe first came out, it
- 11:31mainly used a drivetrain sourced from a company called
- 11:34Continental Motor Electronics. The lot.
- 11:37OK, Continental. Then after a couple of years,
- 11:39Renault introduced their own in house designed drivetrain.
- 11:43They claimed it was a bit more efficient, gave a little more
- 11:45range. The Renault one, did that
- 11:46replace the continental one straight away?
- 11:48No, and this is important. For several years they actually
- 11:51sold both types side by side. So you as a buyer had a choice.
- 11:56Did you want this slightly better range of the Renault
- 11:58motor or the faster AT charging capability of the Continental 1?
- 12:03Faster charging on the continental.
- 12:05Interesting. So you can't just tell by the
- 12:06year of the car then? Not reliably, no, especially
- 12:09during those overlap years. But there are ways to tell them
- 12:12apart. Right.
- 12:14How? OK.
- 12:14Three main ways. First, the model designation
- 12:18cars with the Continental motor have model codes starting with Q
- 12:22like Q210 or later was called the Q90.
- 12:24Q for continental makes sense. Well, actually oh, the Q
- 12:27supposedly stood for quick charge because those models
- 12:30could charge faster on AC. OK, So what about the Renault
- 12:33ones? Those have model codes starting
- 12:35with R like R240R90R110 the later R135.
- 12:39R for Renault or or R for? RR apparently stood for Rapid
- 12:42charge, which is confusing because they actually charge
- 12:44slower on AC than the Q models. Hang on, Q for quick charge is
- 12:47fast AC, R for rapid charges slower AC.
- 12:51That's typically Renault naming, isn't it?
- 12:53It is a bit baffling, but that's the second way to tell the AC
- 12:56charging speed. If a Zoe can take 33 kilowatts
- 12:59on an AC charger, it's got the Continental Q drivetrain.
- 13:03If its maximum AC speed is 22 kilowatts, it's got the Renault
- 13:06R drivetrain. OK.
- 13:07Q is 43 kilowac, R is 22 kilowac.
- 13:12Got it. That's much clearer than the
- 13:13names and the third way. Pop the bonnet and look in the
- 13:16top left corner as you face the car.
- 13:18They look physically different. How so?
- 13:20If you see a kind of circular black plastic housing there,
- 13:24that's the Renault in house drivetrain.
- 13:26If instead you see a more rectangular aluminum metal box
- 13:30in that spot, that's the Continental drivetrain.
- 13:32Plastic circle for Renault, metal box for Continental.
- 13:34Easy enough. Yeah, it's linked to the cooling
- 13:36to the Continental motor is water cooled, hence the metal
- 13:39casing, while the Renault one is air cooled.
- 13:42So knowing these differences, the QR codes, the AC charting
- 13:45speeds or just looking under the bonnet is really vital.
- 13:48It helps you understand exactly what version of the Zoe you're
- 13:50looking at. That is super helpful so you can
- 13:52do your homework before buying. Precisely because it might
- 13:55influence reliability, performance, and just how
- 13:59practical the car is for your charting situation.
- 14:02Well, that feels like quite a journey we've taken with the Zoe
- 14:04today, from seeing it on that recovery track to digging into
- 14:09why that Z50 motor failed. Unearthing that unserviceable
- 14:13bearing issue. Yeah.
- 14:14And then looking at the suspension quirks and finally
- 14:17getting our heads around those Q&R model differences, it's
- 14:20clear there's more to these early EVs than meets the eye.
- 14:24Absolutely. And the main point, the real
- 14:26insight to take away from all this is that specifically for
- 14:29those high mileage Z50 Renault zones, the ones with the Renault
- 14:32R motor, that motor is a potential weak spot because of
- 14:35those bearings. Right, even if the battery and
- 14:37everything else is holding up OK.
- 14:38Exactly. That motor is the potential
- 14:41Achilles heel you need to be aware of, and knowing whether
- 14:43you're looking at AQ model or an R model is just fundamental
- 14:46homework for any potential buyer in the used market.
- 14:49So, thinking bigger picture then what does this whole saga tell
- 14:52us? Well, it makes you think,
- 14:53doesn't it? If a major part like an electric
- 14:56motor is designed in a way that forces a hugely expensive full
- 15:00replacement instead of a much cheaper component repair, what
- 15:05does that really mean for the long term sustainability and the
- 15:09true cost of owning these first generation EVs?
- 15:11Yeah, good question. And maybe how should that shape
- 15:15what you look for, what questions you ask when you're
- 15:18considering future EVs that come onto the market?
- 15:21It's definitely food for thought about repairability and true
- 15:24long term value. Definitely something to Mull
- 15:26over. Well, we hope this deep dive has
- 15:29been useful for you. Yeah, hopefully informative.
- 15:31If you found it helpful, please do hit that like button and
- 15:34maybe subscribe to the channel for more insights like this.
- 15:37We want to keep you informed on the stuff that really matters.
- 15:39Thanks for. Joining us.
- 15:40We'll catch you on the next deep dive.