Latest / Janoub Podcast / Nobody Is Voiceless: Afghanistan, Live from Kabul, with Ali Latifi
Transcript
- Sherif Mansour: Hello, hello. Welcome everyone to Janoub Podcast. This is our first live interview and I am honored AML: no. Sherif Mansour: to have my guest Ali Latifi from Kabul live with us today. Welcome Ali. I want to AML: Thank you. Thank you for having me. Sherif Mansour: give you a chance to introduce yourself, but let me start by saying this episode was not part of my plan for this season. And I think it's an opportunity that I use that as a chance to learn. I had said I want to work on and focus on Global South. moving from Gaza to Ethiopia, Sudan, Yemen. And Ali graciously got in touch with me and told me, why don't we talk about Afghanistan? And that was a sign of ignorance on my part because the more and more I researched and the more and more I talked to Ali. I realized this was a great fit. Ali is Afghan-American, born in Kabul, raised in Little Kabul, California. He chose to return and report in Afghanistan in 2013. And right now, he is the editor of the Asia Desk at the New Humanitarian. Ali, welcome again, and please introduce yourself. to our listeners. AML: thank you. I'm Ali Latifi. I'm a journalist based in Kabul. I mean, you kind of said everything. so yeah, I mean that that's basically it. I grew up in California. I came back to Afghanistan for the first time in 2011 when I was working in Doha for Al Jazeera. and then in twenty thirteen I basically moved back full time. Sherif Mansour: Why did you choose to go back if you don't mind me asking? And also, what interested you in being a journalist? I saw that your grandfather was a journalist. Is that the reason? AML: yeah, you you really did your research. yeah, the that that's all definitely a part of it. I I always liked to write, even even as a kid. and then to be honest, you know, when I was in undergrad at UC Santa Cruz in California, and even after that, I tried a few different things and none of them really worked out. And I think the the thing is when when you're innately drawn to something, it just plays out in your life. I tried to get involved in politics, that definitely didn't work out. I tried to get involved in the entertainment in the independent entertainment industry in LA, that also didn't work out. And then by the time I started grad school at the American University in DC, it kind of became obvious that like what I want to do is is be a journalist. And that was also at the time when, because it was like around 2009, that was also at the time when Al Jazeera English was like really rising up, when it was getting a lot of attention. And when I saw that it was possible for people that look like us, you know, that that come from these parts of the world, to have a role in the media, because I think Unfortunately, so much of the media to this day is still, even with all of these claims of representation and diversity and so on, it's still very white, it's still very Western. And even when, you know, there are a few brown and black faces sprinkled in, it's always of a very specific mindset, right? It's always of very specific mind view, of a sp very specific world view. Th there's very little room for it's different thought, right? and Al Jazeera at the time was an example of that. And that was something that kind of I think it gave it gave me a a sense of hope and courage that like, okay, it's possible. and it's it's, you know, it's definitely been a slog since then because obviously when you when you're kind of like going against the current of the industry, it makes things more difficult, but at the same time, I think you have to stay true to what you believe in and also what you see. Sherif Mansour: You also mentioned similar things in the past about who is voiceless. No one is voiceless. And who is a worthy victim when covering the news and also commenting on how the Western media and international media cover Afghanistan or lack thereof. Can give me recent examples? of when that happened, why. AML: I I think it happens all first of all, like this idea of voiceless. I don't think anybody is born inherently voiceless. Obviously, we all have a voice. Even if you cannot speak, you can still find ways to communicate, especially in the world today, right? There's there's so many ways to make yourself known and make yourself heard, but there are systems at play that try and minimize that voice or that. overlook that voice. Like if someone is voiceless, that's not by accident. You know, certain systems had to take had to be established, certain events had to take place, certain policies had to be made, to make someone quote unquote voiceless. You know? obviously Gaza is a great example of that. because you know it It's about who you speak to, how you speak about people, and whether or not you even like bother to see the people where you are. Before this, I I was doing some some research and I realized that there was a headline by big, big US un US paper that said something like, I traveled along one of Afghanistan's most dangerous roads. This was in twenty sixteen. And the road was from the city of Kabul to the city of Jalalabad, which is about a three-hour trip to the east. had probably thousands, tens of thousands of Avons were making that trip every single day. For day trips, for picnics, for work, for for anything. Like it's it's such it's like going from LA to San Diego. You know, it's it's like the most dangerous thing about it is that, you know, you're you're going on these curved mountains and hills and that's, you know, people aren't driving properly. But In terms of actual war and violence, there was almost none along that road by especially by 2016. But because you know, this journalist had probably never been on that road, had never even thought to go he like he thought it was a such a big deal that my god, I'm going on the Kabul Jalabod road. But it's it would like to to say that it was I mean, literally it's it's the equivalent of going from LA to San Diego. Because it's that routine for people in this country. It's been that routine for decades. but I don't even think you have to look at Gaza or Afghanistan. I was saying earlier to you that you know, when I'm at the gym, I listened to these different podcasts, and one of them is from another major US paper, and they were cover covering the protests in France. And In the intro of the podcast episode, the journalist who worked for the paper, clearly someone from the United States, said, in all the years I've lived in France, I think it was like 10 years, I've never seen anything like this. And I'm listening to the podcast, it's 20 minutes, 30 minutes. And I'm like, okay, eventually, I felt like Jeff Goldblum in in Jurassic Park, right? I was like, eventually there's gonna be French people Sherif Mansour: I'm AML: in your podcast about France, right? Nothing. And I'm like this guy, he Sherif Mansour: Yeah. AML: lives in Paris, right? he the like the the protests are in Paris and Marseille. it's not, you're not talking about some provincial village. You're talk so all he had to do was go downstairs from his apartment to the boulangerie or to a cafe or to speak to a shop owner or or a high school student or a university student or someone who supported Marine Lapen or someone who repe supported emmanuel Macron, you know, but like nothing. Nothing. And my thinking, like I I was shocked just listening to it because I was like, how is it that you are talking about France? You're talking about Paris and you couldn't get two French people in your 20 minute podcast Sherif Mansour: you AML: to expla like because he was talking about shopkeepers. You couldn't get two you couldn't go downstairs to the boulangerie. And so if you Sherif Mansour: you AML: Do that, if you can do that to Paris, what hope does someone in Dhaka or Beirut or Bogota have? You know, and like I've been I've been a journalist, I've been an editor, I've been a podcast host, I've been a TV correspondent. So I understand how these things work, and I I just I was shocked that nobody in the entire process in the production of that episode thought, you don't want to have two French people speak? And again, this is what I'm saying is if if if if you if you can do that in Paris. Sherif Mansour: Mm-hmm. AML: And I'm not saying that they were that they were necessarily racist against the French or anything like that, but I think it was just such an oversight. Didn't even bother to think let me have an actual Parisian or an actual French person, speaking. And no, I don't think anybody would ever dare to call the French voiceless the way that they would someone in Nairobi. Right? Or Cairo. Sherif Mansour: Yeah. AML: And so if you like I said, if you do that to to someone in Par to people in Paris, like I s what hope do you have for people in Kandar or Hira? Sherif Mansour: So let's focus on that a little bit. I think one of the, I think stories of Afghanistan that I became more familiar with is how much displacement of Afghanis have recently happened because of the war in Iran, the tensions with Pakistan, millions of people forced back. AML: Look at it Sherif Mansour: I know you cover. humanitarian issues, but give us a little bit of sense on this crisis, the displacement crisis, what it means for Afghani. AML: It's it's like it's it's the same anti-refugee, anti-immigrant bias you would find in the United States, you would find in India, you would find in you know, almost any in in Bangladesh, you would find in any other country. It's very similar rhetoric coming from the Pakistani and Irani side. And they are both using sort of the same excuses. Iran currently has the excuse of the war, but even prior to the war For instance, last year, last summer, when Israel was attacking Iran for I believe it was about a period of 11 days, there were a lot of false reports saying that, and this this is what was crazy about it, saying that that there are Avghan spies for Israel. Afghanistan has never recognized Israel. Afghanistan has never had relations with Israel. There's not an Avghan person on earth who would, I mean, there are a few, but you know That's a different story, who would ally themselves with Israel. Even during the US occupation under the former Western-backed Islamic Republic, you could not get into Afghanistan if you had an Israeli stamp on your passport. Even during the US occupation, both the Karzai and Ghani administration sent aid to Gaza at different times, which which I thought was great and ironic. But you know, so it it was just this ridiculous sort of claim. But even before then there has been anti you know, the Iranian public has unfortunately been known for for decades for for being hostile, abusive, xenophobic towards Afghans and Afghan refugees. And the government was just using that as an excuse to sort of, you know, play up on that sentiment. And in twenty twenty-three, the Pakistani government made this claim that there are there's insecurity, that there are economic problems in Pakistan due in large part according to them to the presence of so many Afghan refugees. And so they began a process of what they said would be kicking out all illegal people in the country. And that was just coded language for kicking out everyone from Afghanistan. And since then we have seen different rounds of those deportations. And what we've seen is that it has slowly gotten to the point where even people who had proper identification documents, either from the UN or from the Pakistani government, were being kicked out. I met people in, I think by that point it was in Torcham in Ningarha province. Like they showed me what's called an Afghan citizen card. They're like, look, we had these and now they're useless. and so it's what I think what's most important to understand about it is that these sorts of anti immigrant, anti-refugee sentiments, they're unbelievably common all over the world. And and they prey upon or they they sort of utilize the same rhetoric, right? The the the same rhetoric, the same Tone, the same sentiments. It's it you you could track it, you know, whether you're talking about the way you know, certain South American countries talk about refugees from other countries. The same thing. The way Bangladeshis talk about people coming from Myanmar. It's all, you know, the way I mean I I lived in Turkey for a while, the way the Turks talk about. Arabs and Avrons. It's all very similar. You know, they want to change the demographics of the country. They want to, I mean, that's what I found so ironic about the the Turkish argument is that in a country of 80 million people, they think that a few million Avron and Arab refugees are gonna magically, you know, change the demographics of one of the most nationalistic populations on earth. Like let's be honest. It's a very nationalist society. Sherif Mansour: Yeah. AML: but people bought into that. Friends of mine bought it, they they said it to me to my face. so these things are unfortunately very powerful. last year I was at a conference in Chennai, Thailand that was all about refugees from the Asian continent. and there were quite a few journalists from Pakistan there, and I was shocked at you know how much they were talking about. The situation of Afghan refugees and how much they were saying, we feel so sorry for your people and so on. And then as soon as the argument came to the claim coming from the government in Islamabad that Afghanistan is supporting armed groups that are attacking Pakistan, which is a claim that dates back to even the former government, the former Western Back government, the tone shifted. Everyone looked at me like, yeah. and again, because it's this idea that you are creating an enemy and it's a very easy thing to do, whether you're calling them bad hombres or in Urdu you call them namakharam, it's the same concept. and and it's a lot of the same tone. Sherif Mansour: You discussed also a little bit kind of where you think engagement should be and who is punished by lack of engagement. You said that punishing or trying to punishing the Taliban by not engaging with them ended with everyone else punished, but not the Taliban. How do you suggest? We continue to do so and especially as they continue their like gender apartheid, their shunning of women, including from journalism, but also high schools, which for five years now Afghani women, Afghani young women have not been able to have a secondary education. AML: well, women are working as journalists. so they're not they have more difficulty working as journalists because there are more restrictions on them. Like they have cover their face with face masks and things like that, but they are still able to work. And that is a good example of what engagement can look like, is is capitalizing on the things that are still possible and supporting the things that are still possible. Because, you know, everyone and rightfully, constantly brings up the issue of women. Well, women are still able to run private businesses, but what they lack is funding. So if you are a country that wants to support Avalon women, or you are an organization that wants to support Avalon women, great, for right now, you can still support them as entrepreneurs. But if you automatically say nothing is possible for an Avron woman, if you have Meryl Streep sitting next to two former Western-backed government officials who had shady reputations, anyways, to begin with, saying that a dog and a cat have more freedom than an Avon woman. You know, so Meryl Streep, you know, a close ally, a close friend of Harvey Weinstein, who has never stepped foot in Afghanistan, saying this at the United Nations. Has a big impact, right? It disempowers Avon women, it takes agency from them and it's inaccurate. It's disrespectful to them. So what you need to do is Sherif Mansour: Hmm. AML: to figure out what is possible and work on that. And additionally, when you, for instance, when you place restrictions on the banking system, that affects Avron men, that affects Avron women. That impacts the level of investment, which in turn impacts the amount of unemployment in the country. And again, for instance, private businesses are still able to hire women. Private businesses can't function without investment and support. Especially in a country where the economy was so inflated by this artificial aid that was coming in for 20 years, and people were being given all of these inflated salaries, and you know, all of these businesses were being open to support the logistics of the occupation. And suddenly all of that goes away. Right, you have you have you have this fictitious economy. Sherif Mansour: Well I feel like that also drives to the point about you also made about how Afghanis never tasted independence. Now that the US AML: Yeah. Sherif Mansour: have left and Taliban is back in power, what does independence AML: Well this is Sherif Mansour: look like and being not in a proxy war? Because this has been like a recurring theme. At least in this podcast, yeah. AML: Well, this is the thing, right? So i i it's a theme on your podcast. It's unfortunately a theme for much of the world. You know, when when I was an undergrad, I I was in this class, I for I forget what it was called, but the central argument was, is the nation state relevant? Is it still relevant? Right? Because they were like, We have the EU, we have the UN, we have multinational corporations, we have, you know, international NGOs. you know, does the nation state still matter? And I remember I I I I I raised my hand and I said, it matters if you don't have one. It matters if you're Kashmiri. It matters it matters if you're Baluchi. It matters if you're Palestinian. And it matters if you're Afghan. Because if you don't have real sovereignty over your country, then you're really not independent. And the one thing one of So I I always say, you know, occupation of the land is one thing, right? That's awful in itself. But occupation of the mind, that's even worse. And that takes so much longer to take away. And the one thing, you know, it failed at bringing democracy to Afghanistan, but the one thing that the Western occupation was very good at was bringing capitalism to Afghanistan and setting really unrealistic expectations for people. that you know this the that that this artificial economy that was propped up by this occupation I mean know people who work for the government they're like, my salary is only this much, but the World Bank tops it up by this much. The UN tops it up by this much. That's not sustainable. Right? or immediately after the Taliban returned to power, I did a story about small businesses and the impact on them. And I went to this little bodega right by my apartment. And he said, Listen, you come in here and you buy some water, you buy some rice, you buy, you know, whatever. I don't make much money off of you. I make money off of all of those offices in your building. But all of those offices, what did they do? They provided visas for foreign foreigners, they provided cars for them, they acted as travel agents for them, they sowed the tailor the tailoring shops sold suits for them. All of it, he said, all of that was reliant on. The economy of the occupation. Right? It created these entire industries that yes kept tens of thousands of people employed, but they were not sustainable. Sherif Mansour: you AML: for 20 years, for 20 years, the United States spent more than the Marshall Plan. they spent billions and billions of dollars in Afghanistan, and still to this day, we don't have 24 hour electricity. I remember I was talking to an advisor of former president Ashrav Ghani. And she said, she asked him, she said, she said, Why don't we have more factories in Afghanistan? Why aren't you building factories? Why aren't you putting people to work? And he said, Find me electricity and I will build you a factory. Right. Th this all all if you if you rely on your neighbors in Central Asia for electricity, to this day, how independent are you really? Sherif Mansour: I want to ask, usually I want to end in half an hour and I want to take a lot of your time. But my last question is usually for my guests about what keeps them hopeful, what kind of resilience they see in their country, especially by women and women leadership, their effort. And I want to give you a chance as well to ask me any question. Or if you think there was a question I should have asked that I haven't you can answer it AML: Well, if if we're talking about what what makes me hopeful for women in Afghanistan is that They haven't given in. They still, you know, d a a couple like a week or so ago, I was speaking to a British journalist and she was saying, is it true that no women go outside, no women work? And and I laughed and I said, I just came out of this mall where there's a a language course, right? On on the fifth floor. And I'm like, there were all these girls going to that language course. And yes, you know, it it costs a lot of money, and you know, they're they're They're well-to-do young girls, but the fact that they still they've been they they're not able to go to official government run schools, but the fact that they're using whatever disposable income their families still have to continue to try and educate themselves, the fact that there are still women on television and on the radio who, despite having to cover their faces, still report and still do their job, despite even the fact that, They're just women walking on the streets, going out on their own, running basic errands, you know. Dressing I mean Avon women have all have always dressed very, you know, conservatively traditionally and all of that. But like obviously the Taliban's expectation is much more strict. but but but still, you know, dressing for the most part how they want and taking a risk in doing all of that, but still doing it. You know, in in 2023 there there were these huge earthquakes in Heyrod in the west of the country. and I was interviewing this team of female doctors and health workers who came from Kabul on their own to Herat to help treat everyone, but especially the women. They didn't have a Mahram, they didn't have a man with them, you know, but they they went on their own and because they wanted to help. and overall, that is what gives me hope is that, you know, over the last five years, I've really seen. the Avon people support each other and stand up for each other. whether that was the you know, closing of universities to girls and seeing male university students in Ningarhar and Pandad and in other provinces standing up and saying, you know, we don't accept this, seeing fathers in Paktio province marching with their daughters after their schools were briefly opened and then re-reclosed. that was something, those kinds of things are something that gave me hope. And then also after these natural disasters, seeing the Avon people come together and support their their their country their their fellow Avons in any way possible. I mean, after the earthquakes in Herat, I was I was in Ningarhar because it was the same time that the expulsions from Pakistan were starting. And I was in a government office waiting for an accreditation, and there were these young boys there. And I said, What are you guys doing here? Why it's a media office, why are you here? And they said, we're gonna set up tents across the city at the different roundabouts to collect money for the earthquake victims in Heyrock. And then if if I remember correctly, it was it was last year, there were there were these again big earthquakes in Conar province, and all of the roads were blocked. By by debris and rubble, and it was very hard to get to the actual disaster sites in the initial days. And at a certain point, we were we were in this random corner going up the hills, up the mountains. and there was this boy there just sitting there on a chair. And we stopped him, we're like, what are you doing here? And he said, you know, the only way to get up there is to walk, like three hours, four hours, whatever it is. And I have, he was like 20-something, and I have a heart condition, so I can't do that. So what I'm doing is I'm sitting here and I'm collecting money for the victims. And my friends, whenever they come back down, I hand them the money and then, you know, they buy what they need in the city and they go back up. so so those are the things that that that still give me hope. The fact that the Avon people, despite the way the media plays it, have not surrendered, have not given in. Sherif Mansour: Thank you Ali. Ali Latifi, our host today from Kabul. I wish you the best, of luck and AML: Thank you. Sherif Mansour: stay safe. And hopefully there'll be another chance and we talk. But I've learned a lot and I hope everyone who's watching today or later will learn as much. Thank you again. AML: Thank you so much. Sherif Mansour: Rarific