Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Car Dealership Negotiation Avoidance Strategy
Transcript
- 0:09OK, let's dive right in. If you're thinking about buying
- 0:13a car new or used from a dealer, tip well, our sources are pretty
- 0:17clear on one thing. Yeah.
- 0:19That the whole process, it feels designed to play on your
- 0:23anxiety, right? That uncertainty everyone feels
- 0:25when walking onto the lot. Exactly.
- 0:27And that's what we're getting into today, the sort of secrets
- 0:31of the sales floor, the psychological games, the
- 0:34financial traps they set. That's the plan.
- 0:37We want to arm you with some, you know, insider knowledge.
- 0:40We've pulled together insights from a former car salesman, plus
- 0:43warnings from consumer experts. Because making a 5 figure
- 0:46purchase that's huge. You definitely don't want buyers
- 0:49or more sitting in later. Absolutely not.
- 0:52So we're going to break down the three big ways dealerships try
- 0:55to, well, maximize their profit, often at your expense, starting
- 0:59from minute. One right that first moment you
- 1:01meet the salesperson because they're not actually trying to
- 1:03sell you the car immediately, are they?
- 1:04It's something else. Not really, no.
- 1:06Step 1 is what we're calling the emotional lure.
- 1:10They want to create a feeling of psychological ownership, get you
- 1:13connected to that vehicle. How do they do that?
- 1:15Like what are the specific things they do?
- 1:17It's often subtle stuff, but it's deliberate.
- 1:19They'll push for that test drive right away, go on, take it for a
- 1:22spin. Then they have you adjust the
- 1:24seat just so. Fix the mirrors, maybe sync your
- 1:27phone to the Bluetooth, play your music.
- 1:29Oh yeah, I've had them do that. Flip back the sunroof.
- 1:32Exactly. All these little things, they're
- 1:34building excitement that that new car smell euphoria makes the
- 1:38car feel like it's already yours.
- 1:40And the danger there is what your brain switches gears.
- 1:44Pretty much that emotional high starts to override the logical
- 1:48part of your brain. You know, the part that
- 1:50carefully set your budget and decided on a target price.
- 1:53Suddenly that number seems flexible.
- 1:56Totally flexible. It's like one source.
- 1:58Use this analogy of a dog during a thunderstorm.
- 2:01Logic goes out the window. Fear, or in this case signalman,
- 2:04takes over. So that physical experience, the
- 2:07driving, the features, it's actually kind of recognized
- 2:09against your careful planning. It really is which highlights
- 2:13how crucial preparation is before you even get in the car.
- 2:16OK, so how do you fight that? How do you keep your cool when
- 2:18you're genuinely excited about a car?
- 2:21Awareness is key. Just knowing they're trying to
- 2:24evoke that feeling helps you stay grounded.
- 2:27Recognize the excitement, acknowledge it, but don't let it
- 2:30drive the decision. And maybe give yourself some
- 2:32space. Definitely the number one rule
- 2:34from like every expert we looked at.
- 2:36Do not buy a car, especially a big 5 figure purchase, the same
- 2:41day you first drive it. Just don't go home.
- 2:44Sleep on it. Exactly.
- 2:46Let that initial excitement fade.
- 2:47Look at the numbers again when you're calm and rational.
- 2:50That makes a lot of sense. OK, so you resist the emotional
- 2:53pull. You come back inside, sit down
- 2:55at the desk. What's next?
- 2:57They shift gears Right. Big time.
- 2:59They move from the feel good stuff straight to the numbers.
- 3:02But, and this is critical, they focus on a specific type of
- 3:05number. This leads us to pitfall #2 the
- 3:08payment illusion. The monthly payment track.
- 3:11Precisely, they almost always try to negotiate based on what
- 3:15you can afford monthly rather than the total price of the car.
- 3:18Why do they prefer that? Seems counterintuitive.
- 3:20Well, it works brilliantly for them for two main reasons.
- 3:23First, a monthly payment, say $500 sounds way less scary and
- 3:27much more affordable than you know a a $42,000 sticker price.
- 3:32Yeah, relatable. You think?
- 3:33OK, I can swing $500 a month. Right.
- 3:35It distracts you from the total cost, making it easier to accept
- 3:39a higher overall price without even realizing it sometimes.
- 3:42And the second reason. It muddies the water.
- 3:45It makes it really hard to see the underlying factors clearly,
- 3:48like the actual interest rate you're paying or the total
- 3:51length of the loan. All that gets hidden behind the
- 3:53affordable monthly number. And that's where people get
- 3:55stung later on. We saw that example, right?
- 3:57Just $100 difference in the monthly payment.
- 3:59Yeah, Over a typical six year loan, an extra $100 a month is
- 4:03$7200 more you're paying. Wow, not 6072 hundred.
- 4:07That's huge. It adds up incredibly fast.
- 4:09We even saw a case where a buyer saved $4200 just by refusing to
- 4:13talk monthly payments and focusing only on the total
- 4:16price. That was a $70 difference per
- 4:18month. So the strategy here is
- 4:21basically you have to control the conversation, force them
- 4:24back to the big number. Absolutely.
- 4:26You need to be really firm right up front the moment they ask.
- 4:29So what kind of monthly payment are you looking for?
- 4:32You shut it down. What do you say?
- 4:33Something direct like look, I'm not talking payments right now,
- 4:36let's just focus on the out the door price for the car.
- 4:39And that out the door price that includes everything, taxes,
- 4:42fees, the lot. Yes, exactly.
- 4:44The total amount you'd need to write a check for to drive that
- 4:47car off the property. Get that number agreed upon
- 4:50first. It includes the vehicle price
- 4:52plus all the necessary taxes and dealer fees, even the
- 4:56questionable fluff fees. Better to see those early.
- 5:00OK, so get the total price nailed down first.
- 5:03That stops them hiding extra costs in the payment calculation
- 5:06later. Correct.
- 5:06You negotiate the value, not just the monthly affordability.
- 5:10All right, so let's say you've done that.
- 5:12You resisted the emotional test drive pressure.
- 5:15You negotiated a great out the door price.
- 5:18You're feeling pretty good. Maybe shake hands thinking
- 5:20you've won. Big sigh of relief.
- 5:23But then they say, OK, great, let's just step into the finance
- 5:26office to wrap up the paperwork. And this, this is another major
- 5:29danger zone, isn't it? This is probably the most
- 5:32dangerous point for most buyers. We're calling it the finance
- 5:35office trap because even really tough negotiators often lose
- 5:39everything they just saved in this final stage.
- 5:41Why? What?
- 5:42Happens. Your guard is completely down.
- 5:45You're mentally tired from the negotiation.
- 5:47You think the hard part is over, you just want the keys.
- 5:50The whole process is kind of designed to wear you down before
- 5:52this meeting. And the person you meet in
- 5:54there, the finance manager, they're not just processing
- 5:56forms. Oh, definitely not.
- 5:58These are often former top salespeople.
- 6:01They are experts at selling, but they specialize in selling
- 6:04things you can't see or touch intangible products.
- 6:08Like what? Primarily 2 things, the interest
- 6:10rate on your loan and optional add on products.
- 6:13Those are huge profit centers. OK, let's break that down.
- 6:16The interest rate, how do they make money there?
- 6:18Simple markup. The dealership might get
- 6:20approved to lend you money from a bank at say 3%, but they might
- 6:25present the paperwork to you showing 4%.
- 6:27And that extra 1%? Go straight to the dealership
- 6:30often padding the finance managers Commission and that 1%
- 6:33difference on a standard car loan could easily cost you over
- 6:37$700.00 maybe more over the life of the loan.
- 6:40Wow, just for not catching that markup and you're probably tired
- 6:44and just want to sign. Exactly.
- 6:46And the second profit area is those add-ons, extended
- 6:49warranties, GAP Insurance, paint protection, tire protection,
- 6:54rust proofing, the list goes on. Are those things bad or just
- 6:58overpriced? Often drastically overpriced
- 7:01compared to what you could get elsewhere, these products have
- 7:03huge markups. Remember that story about the
- 7:05guy who negotiated a razor thin deal on the car itself?
- 7:08Yeah, the dealer only made like $100 profit on the actual
- 7:10vehicle. He must have felt great.
- 7:12He did until he got into the finance office exhausted, guard
- 7:15down. He ended up buying thousands of
- 7:17dollars in high markup warranty and GAP Insurance, and he
- 7:20accepted an interest rate that was higher than he probably
- 7:22qualified for. Oh man, so he lost all his
- 7:25savings. Lost about $4500 more than he
- 7:27saved. All that tough negotiation on
- 7:29the car price totally wiped out in the last 45 minutes.
- 7:32OK, this is scary. So knowing this trap exists,
- 7:36what's the defense? How do you protect yourself in
- 7:38the finance office? Preparation again is everything.
- 7:42The absolute best defense is to walk in already holding the
- 7:46money, figuratively speaking. Meaning get pre approved for
- 7:50your car loan before you can go to the dealership, go to your
- 7:53own bank or even better a local credit union.
- 7:57Get that approval letter in hand.
- 7:58How does that help, specifically in the finance office?
- 8:01Two massive ways. First, it gives you leverage.
- 8:04You have a backup offer. Second, it gives you a benchmark
- 8:07interest rate. If your credit union offers you
- 8:093.5% and the dealer comes back with 4.5 percent, you know
- 8:13immediately they're trying to mark it up.
- 8:15So. You can say no thanks.
- 8:16My credit union gave me 3.5%. Can you beat that?
- 8:19Precisely. You force them to compete with
- 8:21your rate, or you walk away and use your own financing.
- 8:24It puts you in control. OK, that handles the interest
- 8:26rate. What about all those add on
- 8:27products they push? The warranties, the GOP
- 8:30insurance? Same principle, knowledge is
- 8:32power. First rule, Never discuss the
- 8:35cost of these items as a small addition to your monthly
- 8:39payment. Always ask for the total price.
- 8:42How much does that warranty cost in total?
- 8:44Why? Is the total price so important?
- 8:46Because $15 extra a month sounds trivial, but when they tell you
- 8:50the warranty cost $2500 total, suddenly you pause and think
- 8:55right And 2nd, do your homework beforehand.
- 8:58Know what these things should cost or if you even need them.
- 9:01GP insurance for example. Check with your auto insurer.
- 9:04Some, like State Farm, might offer it very cheaply or even
- 9:07include it. Credit unions often sell GAP for
- 9:10a few $100. Where is the dealer might
- 9:12charge? 800 a $1000 easily.
- 9:14Same with extended warranties. You can almost always buy them
- 9:17cheaper outside the dealership, sometimes even from the
- 9:19manufacturer directly or from your credit union.
- 9:22Knowing the fair price makes you immune to the inflated
- 9:25dealership quote. So basically walk in pre
- 9:28approved for financing and know the outside market price for any
- 9:31add-ons you might actually want. That's the core defense Control
- 9:34the money, know the value. OK, let's pull this all
- 9:36together. It sounds like success boils
- 9:38down to preparation and sticking to a clear plan controlling the
- 9:42process. It really does.
- 9:44Foundational power comes from prep.
- 9:46You absolutely need to know 3 numbers before you go.
- 9:49One, what's the fair market price for the car you want?
- 9:52Use Edmonds TrueCar sites like that.
- 9:55Two, what's your current car worth as a trade in?
- 9:58Get quotes beforehand. 3 What is your absolute maximum walkaway
- 10:03price? If you don't have that line in
- 10:05the sand, you're likely to overspend.
- 10:07And then structure the negotiation itself.
- 10:10Don't let them mix everything together.
- 10:11Critically important negotiate in sequence.
- 10:14Step one, agree on the price of the new car that out the door
- 10:17number only after that settled. Step 2.
- 10:20Negotiate the value of your trade in separately.
- 10:23Exactly, keep them distinct. If they try to combine them
- 10:25asking about your trade in while you're still talking new car
- 10:28price, just politely refuse. Say you'll discuss the trade in
- 10:31later. And Step 3 is financing, which
- 10:33you've hopefully prearranged. Right, new car price, then trade
- 10:36in value, then financing. Each is its own deal.
- 10:39There was also a quick point about credit checks.
- 10:41Oh yeah, important detail. Don't let them run your credit.
- 10:46Do what's called a hard pull until you are very, very close
- 10:50to actually making the deal and signing papers.
- 10:52Why wait? Because multiple hard credit
- 10:55inquiries in a short period can actually lower your credit score
- 10:58a bit, especially if you end up shopping at several dealerships
- 11:01and they all pull your credit. Wait until you're serious about
- 11:04that specific deal. Got it.
- 11:06OK, finally, the ultimate trump card, the thing that cost
- 11:10nothing, that gives you immense power.
- 11:12The power to walk away. Seriously, if the numbers aren't
- 11:15right, if you feel pressured, if anything feels off, just stand
- 11:19up, thank them for their time, and leave.
- 11:21Does that actually work? Won't they just let you go?
- 11:23Sometimes, yeah, but very often is, especially if you timed your
- 11:26visit near the end of the month or year when they're chasing
- 11:28sales quotas. Quotas and bonuses.
- 11:31Exactly. Your phone might ring before you
- 11:34even get home with a suddenly much better offer.
- 11:36Your willingness to walk proves you're serious and not just
- 11:39playing games. It's your strongest leverage.
- 11:42And you mentioned negotiating via e-mail as an alternative.
- 11:46Yeah, that's a great advanced tactic. e-mail multiple
- 11:48dealerships with the exact car you want.
- 11:50Ask for their best out the door price.
- 11:53Let them bid against each other. It takes all the face to face
- 11:55pressure and emotional games out of the equation.
- 11:58So pulling it all together, buying a car isn't just
- 12:00shopping, it's a strategic negotiation against a system
- 12:04designed to maximize their profit using, frankly,
- 12:07psychology and financial complexity.
- 12:10It sums it up well. Decades of practice have gone
- 12:12into refining their process, your confidence, your success.
- 12:16It comes directly from doing your homework, knowing the
- 12:19numbers, securing your own financing, controlling the
- 12:22sequence of the negotiation and always, always being ready to
- 12:25walk away. It really hits home how easy it
- 12:28is to lose thousands of dollars right at the finish line, even
- 12:31after you thought you'd won, just because you let your guard
- 12:34down for a moment in that finance office.
- 12:37It's a real eye opener. And it makes you think, if we
- 12:40need this level of research, strategy and vigilance for
- 12:43buying something like a car, which just loses value over
- 12:47time, maybe we should think about how carefully we approach
- 12:51other huge financial decisions in life, You know, like buying a
- 12:54house or planning for retirement.
- 12:56That's a really powerful point. It definitely puts things in
- 12:58perspective. We genuinely hope this deep dive
- 13:01has given you some practical tools and maybe saves you some
- 13:05real money on your next vehicle purchase.
- 13:07Could be hundreds, could easily be thousands.
- 13:09Absolutely. Thank you so much for tuning in
- 13:11and joining us for this session. If you found this insight
- 13:13helpful, please do hit that follow button on the channel.
- 13:16That way you won't miss our next deep dive.