Latest / Automotive State of The Union / AI Car Brokers, Pricing Transparency, and the End of Arbitrage with Scott Painter
Transcript
- 0:00Good morning. It's Friday, October 16th. It's the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul Jay Daly. That's Kyle Mounts here.
- 0:06Today we have a very special guest, someone that's never been on the show, CEO of TrueCar, Scott Painter. We're gonna chat with him a little bit. [upbeat music] Yeah, this is gonna be really cool.
- 0:16Obviously Scott's, uh, kind of been around since his time originally at TrueCar as he, as he got that off the ground. And coming back, we've already seen, uh, some changes that he's made in the market.
- 0:27And whenever you think about, like, our time with any third-party marketplace and their executive team and their purview on the industry, you know, there's just so much to be had from the macro data, the, the, the knowledge of what, what they have.
- 0:42So I'm excited about this conversation. I, I do think that... So, I mean, Scott, obviously he's come back. He's really revamped the organization.
- 0:47He's made them profitable for the first time in a really long time, which is one of, one of the reasons he wanted to take it private, to make some decisions that he could make. Um,
- 0:56I think that the third party mentality, third parties naturally, naturally spend all of their time focusing on what consumers are asking for and how to give them what they're asking for.
- 1:08Like, in dealerships, we do that as well. However, dealers are also focused on operational logistics and inventory, all these things that they need to be.
- 1:17And third parties, I think, can provide us some insight into what customers are saying on a regular database, 'cause they have all this data. I mean, Scott's a West Coaster.
- 1:25Um, speak- I mean, speaking of the West Coast, can I segue into- Look, yeah, yeah. You gotta-... ASOTU Con West?... segue into it. Yes. Uh, speaking of the West Coast... Oh, where's my button? Oh, no. Ah. Segway. Time.
- 1:36[upbeat music] Yeah. ASOTU Con West is coming in hot. Make sure- It's coming. We, we've been talking about this. Here we go. Talk about having some people in this room together, all in one room, all for one day.
- 1:48We made it fly in, fly out friendly so that you can come to this. We understand multi-day events are a big ask. You can come into this.
- 1:55You can hang out with Jack Hollis, Vic Keller, uh, Alex Lawrence with EVauto, Ed Roberts, Steve Greenfield, and all these other experts together one day to talk about, um, affordability, used EVs, mobile service.
- 2:08We're gonna give you all the info. How to deploy AI effectively inside your business with people who are and have. You could ask all your questions.
- 2:15Steve Greenfield's gonna deliver a new keynote called The Profitability Stack. Jack Hollis is gonna talk about leadership. Vic Keller's gonna talk about how you get a team aligned. He should know.
- 2:24He was a direct report to Warren Buffett. And we're gonna have a- Yeah... a nice little tidy welcome rece- or closing reception at the LA Motoring Club, which is right across the street from the venue. Yeah.
- 2:33Hey, thanks to, uh, Plugg, Mia, Kirby. If you're not aware of what they're doing in the industry, reach out to them. Uh, they have thrown down with us and said yes to a first-time event. Thanks for them, uh- Yes...
- 2:45supporting what we're doing. And, and you can hear from them, meet them in person. Yeah. And that reception at the end, sponsored by Dealer DMV. Hey, there you go. It's gonna make sure we have a nice wrap on the day.
- 2:54All right. Enough about us. So if you've waited before... Enough about, enough about us. We hope you enjoy this inver- uh, inver- this inver- what am I gonna say? This conversation that we had with Scott Painter.
- 3:04Scott, thank you so much for giving us some time today. A lot going on, uh, in your neck of the woods, and, uh, a lot to talk about probably. You know, I think it's a really, uh, transformational time in auto retail.
- 3:16Um, we've obviously got so many external things going on, both with the economy, interest rates, which hugely affect, uh, auto sales. And, you know, the cyclicality of the car business
- 3:28is really about the mix shift between new and used cars. Um, you've got, um, you know, external factors like interest rates, of course, and affordability that really force people to seek value.
- 3:40And so, uh, we're, we're, we're looking at right now a real rotation towards used cars. Um, new cars are struggling.
- 3:48Um, I think, uh, you know, you're very aware, True- TrueCar is a new car auto buying platform, and really our particular value proposition about, is about helping eligible members of our affinity partners to save time and money when buying a new car.
- 4:02Um, all of our franchise car dealers that are on the program, and we've got a little over two-thirds of all franchise car dealers on the TrueCar platform today. But these stores also, also sell used cars.
- 4:12So, you know, the used cars is, is certainly a part of the equation.
- 4:16A lot of people who come to TrueCar are, you know, looking for a new car, obviously, but then they also shift to a used car because they just need to look for- Start working those payments out.
- 4:25Are you seeing the shopping behavior, uh, i- in the broad data really focus on the payment, the affordability, or is that more of a de- derivative thing, or is it where people are starting their journey?
- 4:37Well, I think that's a really important question because, and most people who sell cars as a frontline car salesman know consumers tend to be price shoppers, but payment buyers.
- 4:47So the big trick for any marketplace and any service that's really gonna help people actually get through a transaction is bridging that shopping experience where they're looking for a good deal, and that good deal is usually something we can communicate based on price.
- 5:03But it really comes down to if you're gonna get the car, you're gonna ultimately buy a monthly payment. Mm-hmm. And there's four transactions that occur when you buy a car.
- 5:12It's the car, it's the trade in, it's the financing, and the insurance. All four need to be handled. So what we're really building at TrueCar is a much more contiguous experience.
- 5:23But one of the cool things about TrueCar that's very unique is that we allow you to have an option logic configuration experience, so you can configure a new car any way that the manufacturers will build it.
- 5:33We find that a lot of customers tend to come in either upper funnel, where they're looking for product information and general pricing. Um, I think there's three layers of
- 5:43sort of comprehension that we really see customers moving through. One is some people don't even know what a new car costs. So just educating them as to what is the MSRP for the car.
- 5:54And, you know, the difference between a base model Toyota Highlander and a luxed out Toyota Highlander- Substantial. Yeah... I mean, y- you go from 36,000 To 63,000.
- 6:05So you might just be shopping in the wrong aisle of the grocery store. [laughs] Yeah. Sure. You know, just helping people to make product decisions.
- 6:12And you know what, I, I'll give you another really easy example, but in Los Angeles, you don't really need four-wheel drive if you're driving an SUV.
- 6:20[laughs] Um, but most people have no idea that four-wheel drive, just on its surface, is a 4 or $5,000 option for almost all vehicles.
- 6:28And so when somebody is looking for a car, to be able to give them that information and they go, "Oh, shit, I can actually go and, and ch- you know, focus on the exact car that I really need," as opposed to thinking I need to get the moonroof and the leather and the nav.
- 6:44You know, almost all cars today have CarPlay. So for example, you don't need some super tricked out BMW nav system y- if you've got it on your phone and, uh- Yeah. You just need it to sync up and, and feel good.
- 6:57You know, you, you bring up a point about pricing, and I think, uh, it merits the conversation that so many people are having.
- 7:03You're having it a little bit more, uh, precisely [laughs] in California right now, but the FTC's recent enforcement activity, everyone's gotta look at pricing, look at transparency a different way, uh, regarding the new requirements, new disclosures.
- 7:15What is your overall view on what's happening and what the dealers need to be doing- Uh... to make sure that they don't end up on the wrong side of this? Well, SB 766 actually went into effect October 1st in California.
- 7:25It's called the CARS Act. It's a, it's a pretty offensive piece of legislation to car dealers. It actually stands for Combating Auto Retail Scams. It, which is- Oh my goodness... a pejorative title, right? [laughs] Oh.
- 7:38Um- Wow... so I, I, I think we, we, we feel empathetically very aligned with our dealers in that there, there's no presumption that people are getting taken advantage of.
- 7:47But the legislation was written in such an offensive way that I think just starting out, if I'm a car dealer, I'm gonna say, you know, look, I, I, I'm not a bad guy.
- 7:55Um, but at the heart of this legislative initiative is clarity, and everything that we do at TrueCar is about providing clarity. So that first layer is what does a thing cost?
- 8:07But what we believe is that greater transparency, greater detail, gives you an informed consumer who's ready to buy. And- Yeah...
- 8:17I think part of that, and, you know, your, your question about financing and payment, we do have to conflate auto shopping with auto finance in a way that allows you to shop for cars based on monthly payment.
- 8:29Because if it's about affordability, which is right now the byproduct of what's happening in the world- Mm-hmm...
- 8:34higher interest rates, higher oil costs, I mean, all of these things are leading consumers to focus so clearly on, on monthly payment. You know, the average interest rate in America today is going up.
- 8:46The average loan term is going up. One of the biggest tricks at a car dealership to get the monthly payment down is just to extend the term- Extend the term. Sure...
- 8:54which, you know, puts people in sort of- Well, we cov- we covered this week that 58, 58 point something percent of all loans right now are in negative equity. That, that's a huge problem.
- 9:04I mean, that's almost sort of the automotive equivalent of The Big Short. Um- Yeah... you have got also an average car payment today, average, over $770.
- 9:14You know, the average new car is, according to Cox, a little over $50,000, $51,000. So- Mm-hmm... you know, certainly inflation is, um, you know, hitting consumers. And this is also what we see in terms of the mix shift.
- 9:26I mean, consumers are really moving from luxury and premium to more mainstream vehicles. They're looking from bigger cars to smaller, more fuel efficient vehicles. They're looking from new to used.
- 9:37But I think the bigger thing that we're seeing is they're, they're actually just staying in the market longer. They're saying, "Yeah, I'm, I'm educated, but I'm gonna wait."
- 9:46And that doesn't really help the industry at all. So there's a lot of forces, I think, that are challenging to auto retail that, um, are consistent with clarity.
- 9:56And what the CARS Act really, um, does require is that the confusion around pricing gets eliminated. And it's not just that, you know, California has the CARS Act. A lot of states tend to follow what California does.
- 10:09Yes. But there's been a lot of FTC enforcement of clarity in advertising- For sure... going on around the country. Um, you know, there was a vacate of, uh, a ruling, uh, last February which rolled back some of that.
- 10:22But the FTC is still enforcing this. 95 dealerships were notified that their- Mm-hmm... pricing practices are just not forthcoming.
- 10:29And so the good news about TrueCar is that all the dealers on our platform were compliant, are compliant, and will be compliant.
- 10:36Because part of our belief about what a consumer needs in order to make a confident decision is not just a compelling price, but clarity around what is the price. Scott, um, uh, question.
- 10:48You know, a little over a year ago, the data, uh, in retail auto was looking like about 1.7% of all, overall, uh, referral traffic to dealer websites was from AI. That, uh, that stat is getting close to 4% now.
- 11:01So even though not large, it's doubled.
- 11:03Um, from shopping behavior to, uh, to, uh, people negotiating, uh, cars, w- leveraging AI, uh, all the way to dealers leveraging AI in their showrooms and in their, and in their communications practices, where are you seeing the future of retail auto?
- 11:19Especially when it comes, uh, to shopping behavior and, and dealers interacting with customers, whether it be through TrueCar's platform or through, uh, the, the, the tools that they wanna leverage.
- 11:31Well, first of all, um, I think the market is going through a massive transformation right now, and AI is really the, the big thing. Um, let's fast-forward to what the big fear is.
- 11:41The big fear from a car dealer is that they're gonna be reverse auctioned at scale by comp- by a computer. Mm.
- 11:49And if a computer is reaching out to multiple dealers, in some cases dozens or maybe even hundreds, and pinging those dealers for lowest price and beginning the negotiation- Mm-hmm...
- 12:03um, I think a dealer, rightfully so, is gonna have to be worried about sort of that race to the bottom. Um, that this is- Sure And, and I'll, I'll just sort of speak to it as it relates to TrueCar.
- 12:15All, all of these companies have an origin story. The TrueCar origin story started with when I got out of West Point, I went to Cal Berkeley, and I started helping friends buy cars.
- 12:25And I learned the car business from the brokering side of the table. And I understood how auto retail sales work and how to work with a dealership to, to really tap into their fleet sales department.
- 12:37But when you're talking to a customer who is using a broker, their guard is down. They're basically saying, "Help me to make a good decision." And it is not car sales. It is order taking.
- 12:49Um, my mom still introduces me as a car salesman. Um, you know, a- and I'm like- [laughs]... "Mom, we, we, we don't, we don't, we don't sell cars at all."
- 12:56[laughs] Um, you know, cars are a wonder- Like, I, I have this long, lifelong love a- love affair with cars. I could tell you where I was at in my life by what I was driving. I love going in and getting a car.
- 13:07But it really starts with the information asymmetry that most people fear when going into a car buying situation. They're just not as qualified as a dealership.
- 13:16And it doesn't matter whether you're a first time car buyer, elderly, um, digitally challenged, a credit, you know, sort of criminal.
- 13:26The, the, you know- [laughs] What- whatever your challenge is, your disadvantage, those things are real fears going into a situation where you're dealing with a professional salesman that does this every day with lots of different customers.
- 13:36And so I think that, um, recognizing that agentic AI is basically going to scale auto brokering- Mm... poses a different question for the future of successful auto retail.
- 13:53And again, this is where new cars and used cars are different, because used car value is something you infer. New car prices- Yes... are very, very objective and binary things. Yeah, it's stationed.
- 14:05A new car comes off an assembly line. It's a commodity. It's produced en masse. And so, you know, every new car that has a build code has an MSRP. Yeah, right. No two used cars are the same.
- 14:16Yeah, but two new cars are the same. And- Exactly...
- 14:19you know, we still see there's a massive difference between what people pay for the same identically configured new car, sometimes even at the same dealership on the same day.
- 14:28So the ability to help consumers in an agentic way get to that outcome also means you have to build the technology in a way that helps preserve the dealer's front and back end. You know, this is really why we've seen
- 14:42large consolidators become very powerful, because the larger the group, like AutoNation, for example, the more back-end gross they get because they have power with the manufacturers.
- 14:53And the back-end gross refers to all the things that are not published for consumers to see. Um, the front-end gross is, what does a dealer make versus invoice? Sure.
- 15:02And so, um, obviously, dealers want to preserve as much front-end gross as they can, and the bigger dealers are gonna have more back-end gross to play with, and so they can be more competitive.
- 15:11So I, I think there's a couple of things that are gonna be true. I do think there's gonna be more consolidation in new car auto retail.
- 15:19I think you're gonna see more dealerships going to these larger groups, and it's gonna be harder and harder for the single-point family store to be competitive, because they just don't have the benefit of consol- you know, sort of consolidated economics across a group of stores and efficient management, advertising, brand, all of those things.
- 15:38So there's gonna be additional consolidation. I'll, I'll give you a really interesting prediction. At some point, the arbitrage around what people pay for a new car is going to be over.
- 15:52And what I mean by that is nobody is gonna overpay and nobody is gonna underpay. We're gonna get to a point where transparency, efficiency, and whether it's AI-driven or it's just smart- Yeah...
- 16:06dealers hugging the cactus early- Yeah... and sort of doing the hard thing, I think that, um, there's no question that transparency and information is here. The ability to look through all this data chaos- Yeah...
- 16:18and understand, you know, what is the thing really costing, this, this ability to, you know, deconstruct a very confusing price- Yeah... different pay. I, I think that could, I think that could be good for everybody.
- 16:31And we see this over and over again, time and time historically. When technology goes deeper in any industry, it brings market efficiency and pricing efficiency, which is what you just described. Yeah.
- 16:40Scott, so much going on. We'll be certain to have you on again. Thank you so much for giving us some time- Yeah... jumping on and, uh, sharing with our audience today. You bet. Thanks for having me.
- 16:48Good to see you guys again. [upbeat music]