Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Why Credit Unions Could Lose Big in Washington’s Regulatory Reset with John McKechnie
Transcript
- 0:00Treichel: Hey everyone, this is Mark Trico with another episode with Flying Colors.
- 0:03I'm excited to be here with John Ney MC, John Ney, LLC, formerly of NCA,
- 0:09formerly of cuna and credit union.
- 0:12Guru.
- 0:12He knows a lot about what is going on in, in Washington, DC
- 0:17a guru, how would get a guru.
- 0:18I put that on my business
- 0:19McKechnie: cards now.
- 0:20Treichel: That's a technical term.
- 0:22John it's great to have you back on the show today.
- 0:25McKechnie: And
- 0:26Treichel: we're recording this right before GAC we'll both be there.
- 0:31I believe that I will be publishing this.
- 0:34I'll be publishing this before GAC.
- 0:36Maybe I'll do it on the weekend so that the regular listeners when they're
- 0:40flying in can listen to with flying colors and the wisdom that we're going
- 0:44to share with the listeners today.
- 0:45So I just set the bar real high.
- 0:48So Mark, there is
- 0:50McKechnie: no shortage of stuff to talk about.
- 0:52You're right.
- 0:53You alluded to that.
- 0:55It's.
- 0:57Uncertainty is the word of the day for everybody, not just not
- 1:01just for Washington generally, but also credit unions.
- 1:04We have just an enormous amount of issues that are yet to be resolved.
- 1:10Clearly the recent changes where the Trump administration has
- 1:14made some pronouncements about certain independent agencies, N.
- 1:18C.
- 1:19U.
- 1:19A.
- 1:19included Although he hasn't, the media coverage has been a bit misleading
- 1:23from our perspective, because they don't mention NCUA, and, I think we
- 1:27both know that NCUA in the pecking order of the federal regulatory
- 1:31universe, NCUA does not rate as high as some other banking agencies.
- 1:37But nonetheless, there's just a sense that the deck is being reshuffled right now
- 1:41and I think writing should be concerned.
- 1:44The executive order that came out where the president asserts more control over.
- 1:50That's one issue, and I think it's yet to be seen how much of
- 1:55a real change that's going to be.
- 1:57The thing I'm much more focused on and much more concerned about is
- 2:02the consolidation of regulators.
- 2:05That could be significant, and I think every scenario I play out in my head,
- 2:10it ends up negative for credit unions.
- 2:13And I'll tell you why.
- 2:14Treichel: Yeah.
- 2:14So walk through that.
- 2:15So you're talking, there's discussions out there.
- 2:19That it was that Scott has been asked to to look at the
- 2:23possibility of consolidation.
- 2:25Can you walk through what it is you've heard relative to that, that initiative
- 2:30and then why you're viewing it as a possible losing game and more than 1 way.
- 2:37McKechnie: Since the election, there has been an undercurrent of buzz
- 2:42among people on Capitol Hill and among people who were, at the time,
- 2:46about to enter the administration.
- 2:47Now they're in the administration, but there was always an undercurrent
- 2:51of, We're going to look at possible consolidation of the regulators.
- 2:54We're going to look at merging agencies.
- 2:56We're going to look at restructuring.
- 2:57Whatever terminology they used, you got a sense that they wanted
- 3:01to look at the financial regulatory landscape and make it simpler.
- 3:05And I think the idea If the Trump people were on the call, they say it's
- 3:09going to be a more efficient and a more cost effective way to do things.
- 3:13And so yes, there's been this, like I said, an undercurrent that broke out into
- 3:17the open last week where the wall street journal and Bloomberg and other major
- 3:23media began to cover the possibility based on their conversations on Capitol
- 3:28Hill, that that the administration wanted to roll FDIC and OCC into a treasury,
- 3:36a new department within the treasury.
- 3:39And that's with the Wall Street Journal article.
- 3:40They specified OCC and FDIC, and that's it.
- 3:44That's all they said.
- 3:45I happen to be, I think by good fortune I was on Capitol Hill the night
- 3:50before that article appeared, and I saw one of Senator Tim Scott's staff.
- 3:54Senator Scott is the chairman of the Senate Banking Committee.
- 3:58And his staff talked more expansively about that.
- 4:01That's all they said.
- 4:02FDIC, OCC, they mentioned CFPB, they mentioned the bank supervisory element
- 4:11of the Fed, the Federal Reserve has a bank supervisor in it, and they would
- 4:16peel that out, but this person who knows I, he knows I work in the credit union
- 4:19world, he also knows I used to work at NCUA, and he said, don't think that NCUA
- 4:24and the credit union regulator would escape that just because Most of the
- 4:28talk is centered on the bank regulators.
- 4:32And
- 4:33Treichel: Yeah.
- 4:33Just because they don't say the wave will take NCUA.
- 4:36If it takes every other banking regulator the fact that NCUA is not mentioned is
- 4:41an afterthought of the existence of NCUA.
- 4:44It's not a, we're going to keep them separate.
- 4:46McKechnie: That's right.
- 4:46And it's not necessarily meant to be insulting or denigrate us, although,
- 4:50and sometimes being small means we're out of the way and not thought of.
- 4:53But in this case, as you, you allude to, you're going to have a combination.
- 4:59You're going to have a bringing together of similar functions.
- 5:02And again I'm just genuinely worried and very negative about that for
- 5:08the, a couple simple reasons.
- 5:10One, if we lose the share insurance fund, the share insurance fund, the credit
- 5:14unions have maintained, nurtured, paid into, kept and the industry and the
- 5:19agency have both created a very stable.
- 5:21Financial backstop for people who deposit their money in credit unions.
- 5:26That would be brought into the FDIC system and I don't think
- 5:29it would be to our benefit.
- 5:30The bank dominated FD deposit insurance fund would most likely just take
- 5:36our money and put into something that's much more suitable for the
- 5:39banking industry and not for us.
- 5:42People who will run that are used to regulating.
- 5:45And supervising the banking industry.
- 5:48I think it's gonna be a no brainer that our share insurance
- 5:50fund gets sucked in there.
- 5:52And secondly, and I think you probably can speak to this better
- 5:56than I can the actual supervision and regulation of credit unions.
- 6:02You have an NC way that, I know the industry has ups and downs
- 6:05with our regulators as it should, any kind of healthy relationship
- 6:09between an industry and a regulator.
- 6:12Means that you're going to have sometimes some hiccups, but generally
- 6:16people know that NCUA is run by credit is a regular that, that
- 6:21looks at credit units as distinct.
- 6:24unique cooperative financial institutions.
- 6:27I don't think you're going to have any of that mentality in
- 6:29a bank dominated regulator.
- 6:31Treichel: Yeah I would agree with that.
- 6:33Plus the power players at the new agency are going to be from the bank
- 6:37side, not from the credit union side.
- 6:39At the beginning it's, again presuming this happens, right?
- 6:42This is a, this is the worst case scenario of everybody's woven together sometime.
- 6:47Probably with the vote to do it within the first two years before midterms.
- 6:51And if it goes down this path, but you talk about the exam side of it I recall
- 6:57the number was either 30 or 35% and that's the, if you looked at pick a number
- 7:02of $3 billion credit union versus a $3 billion bank or a $5 billion credit union
- 7:08versus a $5 billion bank, NCUA spends.
- 7:12Between 30 to 35 percent less hours examining that institution.
- 7:18So you're all other things being the same because under Doge and under the
- 7:25right sizing of government, there may be less of a footprint ultimately.
- 7:30Once that dust settles the burden of being a bank, as far as how frequently
- 7:35the, how many hours the examiner spend there is about 135 hours for
- 7:40every hundred hours that NCOA spends.
- 7:43And that means 35 percent more questions 35 percent more analysis.
- 7:49More burden onto the backs of the credit unions.
- 7:52If indeed that number was to stay the same and everybody was rolled together.
- 7:56McKechnie: Sure, and then certain regulations that don't pertain
- 7:59to credit unions may come to pertain to for instance, CRA.
- 8:02Correct.
- 8:03Some of the bank secrecy provisions that are more, more
- 8:06esoteric could be applied to us.
- 8:08I just think.
- 8:10In the new, this brave new world, there's going to be a matrix of
- 8:13how to examine institutions, and that's going to be a bank matrix.
- 8:16It's not going to have any, it's not going to have any accounting
- 8:19for the uniqueness of credit unions, the cooperative not for profit
- 8:22structure, the member ownership, etc.
- 8:25I just I think this could be the practical end of what we know as
- 8:28credit unions, if it comes to pass.
- 8:30Now, You raise an interesting point a second ago.
- 8:32You said if it happens, there's going to be there's certain things the president
- 8:37can do with a stroke of a pen, but there's a lot of other things that have
- 8:40to be changed in the law on Capitol Hill.
- 8:43And I think that there's going to be at least an opportunity for
- 8:46credit unions to make our case.
- 8:48To our friends on the hill that this is not a good idea that do what you will to
- 8:53the banks If you want to homogenize their system if you want to homogenize their
- 8:57regulatory structure Go ahead, but credit unions are not banks and they shouldn't
- 9:02be regulated or insured like that I will also make an interesting point I talked
- 9:08to Senator Scott's people who, again, the Chairman of the Banking Committee has
- 9:12apparently, although it's not official, but he's, the word is he's been tasked
- 9:16with coming up with some legislative blueprints and by the administration.
- 9:21And I said to the guy what I just said to you, which is, we're not banks and,
- 9:24the banks may say we're banks, they're simply not taxed, and I disagree with
- 9:29that but he did concede a good point, or at least I hope it was a good point
- 9:33that, credit union just treats its members as members and not customers.
- 9:38And he said that's it.
- 9:39He's he thought for a second.
- 9:40I could tell it got the wheels turning just something as basic as that.
- 9:44We have members.
- 9:45We don't have customers and, from that point forward, I think
- 9:48we can at least make a case.
- 9:50If Congress wants to do this, it's going to be a mistake that they're
- 9:53going to regret because it's going to really deprive the consumer marketplace.
- 9:57Treichel: And one of the, there's many strengths of the credit union
- 10:01industry, the credit union movement, whatever you want to call it, that
- 10:03member side of it is part of it.
- 10:06The ability to bring so many people to Washington, D.
- 10:10C.
- 10:10to hike the hill is a, is another part of it.
- 10:13And that's coming up.
- 10:15We're recording this.
- 10:1710 days, nine days, a certain number, a week and a half away
- 10:20from when GAC is kicking off.
- 10:23I'm sure that's probably some of the things that those folks that are going
- 10:27to be visiting the Dems and the Ds and the Rs are going to be saying,
- 10:32Hey, don't sweep us up in this.
- 10:34We are different making this a really this GAC, and perhaps the
- 10:38next one as important of a couple of.
- 10:41of visits to Washington D.
- 10:43C.
- 10:43as the movement might ever have.
- 10:44McKechnie: That's a good point, and I will re emphasize something I've been
- 10:48saying for many years, and that is that the best advocates credit unions
- 10:51have are not those of us who wander around Capitol Hill or at the agency.
- 10:56The best advocates we have are the credit union people who come to town like you
- 10:59just described, and members of Congress want to hear from them, and they want
- 11:03to hear their stories from back home.
- 11:05They want to hear what impact credit unions make on their communities, and I
- 11:09think in this case, Our people will have an opportunity to make a very compelling
- 11:14case for why we need a distinct regulator.
- 11:16And I think they're going to make a strong case on the tax argument.
- 11:21Treichel: So let's look at a matrix.
- 11:24It's NCOAs rolled into another regulator and credit unions are
- 11:29taxed on this axis and this axis is they're, they aren't, and they aren't.
- 11:36So the, what are the odds of.
- 11:39I described those axes wrong, but what are the, so one combination is
- 11:42they're taxed and they're rolled in.
- 11:44Another one is they're not taxed and they're not rolled in.
- 11:48And one of them is one of those things happens and the other doesn't vice versa.
- 11:52So how do you see what is it lawn sausage?
- 11:56The, do you see some negotiate people are saying, no, we shouldn't be rolled in.
- 12:01We shouldn't be taxed.
- 12:02And then the closer you get to, to the final act is one of those things happens.
- 12:08And one of those things doesn't.
- 12:10McKechnie: For one thing, the law and sausages comment is terrific.
- 12:14People misattribute that to Mark Twain.
- 12:16You didn't.
- 12:16But some people do.
- 12:17Everybody if they wanna make a quote, they usually attribute it
- 12:20to either Mark Twain or Yogi Berra.
- 12:22And in this case it's not Mark Twain, it's actually Bismark
- 12:25who said laws and sausages.
- 12:26Okay.
- 12:27Or things you don't want to be watch made.
- 12:29It's, look, I think we're gonna win on.
- 12:32I feel very confident about the tax issue even though I think
- 12:35there is real danger up ahead.
- 12:37I think that the tax arguments that credit unions can bring to Washington,
- 12:42once Congress focuses on it, they're going to realize it's just not worth
- 12:46really stirring up a political hornet's nest with the credit union system.
- 12:51I think we've got not only economic substantive arguments, which is that
- 12:55we benefit consumers every day In the way we serve them and we help
- 12:59them I think we help the entire marketplace by being in the marketplace.
- 13:03I think we help drive bank behavior in a better direction But besides
- 13:08that I think we also have a political case to make there's an average
- 13:11of about 250 20, 000 credit union members in every congressional
- 13:15district in the United States.
- 13:16We can sit across the desk from a congressman and say, look, if
- 13:20you eliminate the credit union tax exemption, you're going to raise taxes on
- 13:24essentially 220, 000 of your constituents.
- 13:27And that's a pretty daunting thing to put in front of them,
- 13:30especially with Republicans.
- 13:31And I've been very upfront in saying with a lot of Republicans on the Hill.
- 13:35People send Republicans to Congress to cut people's taxes.
- 13:39They don't send them here to raise taxes, and that's exactly what
- 13:42you're going to be doing if you do something to our tax exemption.
- 13:45So let's just start with that, that even though there's nothing on paper quite
- 13:49yet with the tax reform, I think in the between now and the end of March, there is
- 13:54going to be at least a draft legislation.
- 13:57Our goal is to try to keep creditors out of it.
- 14:00The banks are trying hard to Put us in it.
- 14:03And I will also unfortunately mention that the ones, the two issues I have heard
- 14:10where the banks appear to have gotten some traction with members of Congress
- 14:15are on the credit unions purchasing banks.
- 14:19And also some of the stadium naming rights issues, and I don't say either
- 14:24of them with any great pleasure because I think there's they're both defensible
- 14:27activities, but I can just tell that since last fall, a lot of lawmakers
- 14:33and their staffs who have generally been friendly to credit unions.
- 14:37Have expressed some concerns and misgivings about that So we're gonna have
- 14:40to make sure we try extra hard at this gac And other times to make the case as
- 14:45to why those are not Reasons why they should do something to our tax exemption
- 14:50Again, I feel i'm a cautiously optimistic person on this I feel like when we bring
- 14:57our people to washington and make our case good things are going to happen.
- 15:02But this is a tricky environment and I think the fact that you
- 15:04have A broad tax reform on the table has made it more dangerous.
- 15:08We heard a lot of people in the hill say that while they may not
- 15:12necessarily favor our tax exemption, or I'm sorry, they may not favor
- 15:15doing something to our tax exemption.
- 15:18They've all cautioned us to be very vigilant because they're in the words
- 15:22of 1 of our best friends, they're taking a 360 degree view of the tax code.
- 15:27Everything potentially could be on the table.
- 15:30Treichel: And when they do that final countdown, they have to try
- 15:35and get it as balanced as they can.
- 15:36There's numbers involved.
- 15:38And if they can look at it and say, this will save us X and it helps us
- 15:42do these other things we want to do.
- 15:44And you haven't slowed that role.
- 15:47That's where it can get real problematic there.
- 15:49McKechnie: We, you have to be very basic and just Being, yeah, it was the Woody
- 15:54Allen theory of lobby just, showing up is 90 percent of it and we just have to
- 15:58get our people here and I feel and also let's not think of this as an episode
- 16:03where you come to Washington, you check the box, you go back home, we need to stay
- 16:06engaged throughout and I'm not even saying just through the middle of the year.
- 16:13I think that a tax bill could be resolved Before the summer, but that doesn't
- 16:18mean we can go back in the woodwork.
- 16:19If we win, we just have to constantly be engaged and involved.
- 16:23That's been my mantra ever since I worked for CUNA back in the late 80s.
- 16:26It's just a political involvement is not an episode.
- 16:29It's a process.
- 16:31Treichel: The I can't not say this with a reference to Yogi Bear.
- 16:36I wrote, I wrote down my favorite Yogi ism, which is
- 16:39that nobody goes there anymore.
- 16:41Nobody goes there anymore.
- 16:43It's
- 16:43McKechnie: too crowded.
- 16:43It's too crowded.
- 16:44Yeah.
- 16:46But he also says prediction, predictions are hard, especially about the future.
- 16:50And so you asked me about what's going to happen with all those
- 16:53different possible outcomes.
- 16:55Yeah, and I will say I'm nervous about the legislative
- 16:58horse trading that could go on.
- 17:00I think.
- 17:01One senior congressional staffer in the last week said something about how the
- 17:07banking trades, one of the bank trades, is trying to shop an idea that we don't
- 17:11tax all credit unions, but just what they call the big mega credit unions.
- 17:15And I guess they're trying to come up with an asset threshold of
- 17:19credit unions over which they're taxed, under which they're not.
- 17:23That, that concerns me.
- 17:24I don't know.
- 17:25I don't.
- 17:26I don't think that's going to get traction, but we have to make sure it
- 17:28doesn't, but that kind of stuff that goes on in the back rooms and the legislative
- 17:34process, we have to worry about that.
- 17:37And again, the other ingredient we're stirring into the pot is is that
- 17:41consolidation issue we talked about?
- 17:43What if somebody dangles out the possibility of keeping
- 17:46the regulator independent in exchange for something else?
- 17:49I don't know what I don't know, but.
- 17:52These are all concerning possibilities.
- 17:55And again, it's, but we've, we as a movement have been preparing for many
- 18:00years for these kind of situations.
- 18:02Credit unions have invested a lot of time and effort and money into this.
- 18:06This is why we've done it all.
- 18:07Let's get, but we have to now use it, get to work.
- 18:10Treichel: Dust off the play to play book and update it.
- 18:13And and keep the playbook out.
- 18:14Like you said don't put it back and keep singing that mantra.
- 18:18When you talk about, what's big whatever the word was you used, it
- 18:23wasn't big, but let's only text.
- 18:25McKechnie: They call them mega credit,
- 18:27Treichel: So when they look, if they go, okay let's figure out what mega is.
- 18:32You, sometimes you try and not create new definitions, right?
- 18:36So would it, you, when someone says, what might somebody say is mega, the
- 18:40first threshold could be 15 billion.
- 18:42Those that report to ones that's an NCAA internal.
- 18:45The second could be the 10 billion CFPB bright line, CFPB is not
- 18:51something anybody's quoting right now in the, in this administration.
- 18:54So maybe the 10 falls away.
- 18:56So then maybe it falls to what NCAA calls as complex, which
- 18:59is 500 million and above.
- 19:00A higher number you don't want any of them tax, but a lesser number is better.
- 19:05But once they start, they get into the discussion of
- 19:08that's what we're going to do.
- 19:09Then they got to come up with a number and somebody's going to
- 19:11fall on the wrong side of that.
- 19:12Somebody's going to fall on the right side of it.
- 19:14And there are credit unions that have tried to stay below
- 19:1710 billion, avoid CFPB, tried to stay below 15 to avoid ones.
- 19:23They'll be doing the same if there's some, artificial number that it becomes.
- 19:28Is determined as Megan.
- 19:29You're right
- 19:29McKechnie: on all those counts.
- 19:30You make now.
- 19:31I've spent a career reminding Congress that a credit union.
- 19:36That's a 100Million is no different than a credit union.
- 19:40That's 100Billion and that the structure and how they're the member ownership
- 19:45and how they relate to their members.
- 19:47That's the important thing to think about.
- 19:48So I'm not going to get into a size discussion with anybody.
- 19:51Yeah, you don't
- 19:51Treichel: want to go there.
- 19:52It's just a wrong.
- 19:52Yeah.
- 19:53Yeah.
- 19:53Yeah.
- 19:53McKechnie: So I'm very adamant about that.
- 19:55But I would be remiss if I didn't tell your listeners that the banks
- 19:59are trying to start that discussion and we need to be aware of that.
- 20:03Like I said I'm guardedly optimistic.
- 20:05I know what crediting people are capable of.
- 20:07I re, I was at CUNA back during the famous HR 1151 which was over 25 years ago now.
- 20:13But that's, that was a great victory for all of us.
- 20:16I was on Capitol Hill as a very junior staffer back in 1986 when
- 20:21the last real challenge to the credit union tax exemption occurred.
- 20:25Credit unions actually were put into the tax bill.
- 20:28You had this grand bargain between Ronald Reagan and Democratic House Ways and
- 20:32Means Committee Chairman Dan Rostenkowski.
- 20:35That was for a few weeks we were in a tax bill.
- 20:38You may not, a lot of our people may not remember this, but credit unions
- 20:42really had to fight heck to get out of it and mounted a pretty good
- 20:45grassroots campaign, if I can remember being on the other side of the desk.
- 20:49But, this is something that matters to credit unions and I think we're
- 20:52going to rise to that occasion.
- 20:54Treichel: Yeah, I think if it's if it becomes about effort, I think credit
- 20:57unions will rise to the occasion, but it's challenging and choppy waters right now.
- 21:02Any other D.
- 21:03C.
- 21:04Things that you can think of.
- 21:05We talked a little bit about some of the orders.
- 21:07N.
- 21:07C.
- 21:07A.
- 21:08Has a hiring freeze.
- 21:09Every agency has a hiring freeze.
- 21:11They're looking at the size of their.
- 21:13Their workforce that's going to create, create some exam challenges.
- 21:17What happens in these times you talked about bank purchases,
- 21:20triggering challenges on Capitol Hill.
- 21:23What happens when you have a hiring freeze is the exams become the only thing that.
- 21:27Matters.
- 21:28So anything that's not exam gets pushed past longer.
- 21:31So merger decisions, field membership decisions any anything not meat
- 21:36and potatoes relative to the safety and sound is getting the exam done
- 21:40is what they're gonna have to be looking at doing rolling forward.
- 21:44McKechnie: You're right about that.
- 21:45I, you remind me CFPB, of course, has been in the news a lot, and it should, it has
- 21:50been in the news for its entire existence.
- 21:52It's a very controversial entity.
- 21:54I think it's overstated when some people say that CFPB is going to completely be
- 21:59done away with, because it's in statute.
- 22:01It's in the law.
- 22:02That can't happen without a change in the law.
- 22:05But I, what I do think is going to happen under the Trump administration
- 22:08is that agency is not only going to become smaller, but I think it's become
- 22:13less aggressive towards regulating conduct in the financial marketplace.
- 22:19And I think it's going to be also become much more focused on fraud.
- 22:23And abusive consumers, which I think that's healthy.
- 22:26I think it's hard for me I can't imagine even some of the most strident critics
- 22:31of cfpb to say we don't need to police that of course We need to police that
- 22:35and maybe if cfpb becomes more Of an enforcement type agency and less of a
- 22:41marketplace police officer, maybe that will take some of the heat away from CFPB.
- 22:46I'd love to see CFPB eventually become a five member commission where you have
- 22:51a mixture of Democrats and Republicans.
- 22:54I think you'd have a little bit less of a lightning rod there and a little bit
- 22:58of less of a controversial approach.
- 23:00Even the prior director Rohit Chopra.
- 23:05He was a.
- 23:06A pleasant guy to talk to and I think he was an earnest guy,
- 23:09but boy he stirred up a lot of controversy with a lot of his actions.
- 23:13And I think he knew he was, he was a deliberately provocative
- 23:16person in those ways.
- 23:18And I'd like to see a less inflammatory CFPB somewhere in the future where we have
- 23:25it as a more sober and staid consumer.
- 23:30And really something that can help the consumer when there are
- 23:32problems, but not dictating to a consumer what they can or can't buy.
- 23:37Treichel: Yeah, I'll vote for that.
- 23:39And what was it recently?
- 23:41I learned, or if I knew it before I'd forgotten it, that they
- 23:46basically turn the spigot off.
- 23:48From the Fed, right?
- 23:49They said, we don't we have enough cash.
- 23:50We don't need any more cash to conduct our essential business.
- 23:55And that is decided by 1 person who is the director of CFPB, as opposed
- 24:01to it being discussed with a vote of 5 that have both these and ours on
- 24:07McKechnie: it.
- 24:08You got to remember that when CFPB was envisioned by a law professor
- 24:12at Harvard named Elizabeth Warren, she wanted it to be insulated from
- 24:16the congressional funding process.
- 24:18And, she thought that would mean it stays away from any kind of political pressures.
- 24:22But as you say, now that if you have a director in there who wants to do
- 24:26what you just described, they did it.
- 24:28They turned off the Fed Fund.
- 24:30The Federal Reserve, under the law, is obligated to give whatever CFPB wants up
- 24:36to, I think, 12 percent of the Fed budget.
- 24:38And CFPB's new director said, we don't need the money anymore.
- 24:43I think the outcome there may have reminded some of the CFPB's defenders
- 24:47on Capitol Hill, like Senator Warren, that maybe we do need to
- 24:50get it into the regular process.
- 24:52And that might safeguards funding in the future.
- 24:55Treichel: That makes sense.
- 24:57Yeah the approach that she thought would keep it away from scrutiny
- 25:02actually made it more subject to it.
- 25:05So
- 25:05McKechnie: yeah.
- 25:05Somebody is playing 3d chess.
- 25:10Treichel: Well, which goes to the, I said this to somebody recently, Debbie mass
- 25:15was a board member left and came back.
- 25:17Rodney hood was a board member left and came back.
- 25:20When they came back, they understood the game much better.
- 25:24Not only did they learn things while they were gone, they had learned
- 25:27things when they were there, right?
- 25:28And we talked, I mentioned the mid, midterms, the presidents
- 25:33typically have a two year window.
- 25:35If they have control Trump does to get things done, but they came in knowing
- 25:41what they wanted to get done knowing where they had been told you can't do
- 25:46that before and figured out there's got to be a way and put bright minds
- 25:52on it and are taking an anvil to some things that last time they thought
- 25:58they couldn't touch that's my idea.
- 26:00McKechnie: That's an excellent analysis.
- 26:02I think that the administration this time is much more.
- 26:05They've learned from mistakes in the past.
- 26:08They made assumptions about the bureaucracy that
- 26:10didn't turn out to be true.
- 26:11And there were, I hope I don't get people on one side of the political
- 26:14aisle, but angry at me, but I think they found out That some of the career
- 26:19folks here in Washington were really hostile to what Trump tried to do.
- 26:24And so they, in the first term, so they tried to stop it.
- 26:27This time Trump is addressing that by getting rid of some of those people.
- 26:31And I know it's painful.
- 26:32And it's a messy situation.
- 26:34And I think you also have the overlay of the COVID.
- 26:37Stay at home telework in the backdrop.
- 26:40Treichel: Yeah.
- 26:40Yeah, the perfect
- 26:41McKechnie: storm.
- 26:42Treichel: Yeah, it's
- 26:42McKechnie: every right.
- 26:42Everything is now coming together.
- 26:44And this is an exciting time.
- 26:46I would I'm not going to lie.
- 26:47I like the excitement and the exhilaration.
- 26:50I know it's painful in some ways to go through this.
- 26:53But, I got into government affairs and politics when I was just out
- 26:57of college because I liked the.
- 26:59The thrill of it all.
- 27:00This, you and I were colleagues at NCA during the financial crisis in 2008 2009.
- 27:06And while it was a nerve wracking time, it was also very,
- 27:10it was fascinating every day.
- 27:12If
- 27:13Treichel: you're an adrenaline junkie, you live for some of this.
- 27:16stuff.
- 27:17A lot of regulators, a lot of people that that like Washington D.
- 27:21C.
- 27:21Like you and I are do like that adrenaline.
- 27:24So it is exciting times.
- 27:26The dust will settle and then we'll figure it out.
- 27:29McKechnie: We will.
- 27:30Next time we'll know more.
- 27:31Treichel: Next time we'll know more.
- 27:32So john, thanks so much.
- 27:34I will see you at GAC and listeners come see John and I we can, if you
- 27:41wanna talk about this or anything else.
- 27:42John, I wanna thank you so much for Thank you being available on short notice here.
- 27:46McKechnie: Always great seeing you.
- 27:47Take care.
- 27:48Treichel: Yep.
- 27:48And listeners, I want to thank you for listening.
- 27:50As always, this is Mark TriCal signing off with flying colors.