Latest / The Vegan Report / Breaking Down Border Walls. With Myles Traphagen | Ep. 41
Transcript
- 0:00We're going to build the walls★
- 0:18Build that wall! Build that wall! Build that wall!
- 0:22Build that wall!
- 0:23Build that wall! builds Gangplank
- 0:25Build that wall! x3
- 0:26Welcome to The Vegan Report.
- 0:34My name is Ryan and today we are talking about border walls, and more specifically the southern
- 0:40border wall separating the United States from Mexico.
- 0:45As the US election are approaching, it feels like the question of the southern border has
- 0:50become front and center of the political debate.
- 0:54We hear a lot of talks about immigrants and immigration policies, but what we never hear
- 0:59about are the animals.
- 1:01And does it affect their lives when, you know, you build a fence stretching hundreds of kilometers
- 1:08or miles across their habitats?
- 1:11To discuss this topic, I have with me Miles Trafigen.
- 1:15He is the Borderlands Program Coordinator for Wide Lens Network.
- 1:20He's a researcher, a conservationist, and overall someone who has taught a lot about
- 1:26the border from an environmental perspective.
- 1:29So Miles, welcome to the show.
- 1:31Thank you so much for being here.
- 1:33Yeah, thank you for having me.
- 1:34I'm glad that you're taking interest in such an important topic that I think is under the
- 1:39radar for a lot of people.
- 1:41So my first question for you is about, you know, how can we locate the border wall?
- 1:49So can you first describe the border wall in terms of where it is located?
- 1:55Are we talking about also, you know, a wall or more of a fence?
- 2:00How long is it with kind of, you know, environments and habitats and territories?
- 2:06Is it crossing?
- 2:08So I'll let you answer the question.
- 2:10Well, those are very good questions you're asking.
- 2:14The border wall is kind of a generic term that has been used to describe border barriers
- 2:21and infrastructure along the US-Mexico border, most of it being built in the last 15 years.
- 2:29I'll start with very basics.
- 2:32When they first started marking the border, it was just using concrete or steel obelisks,
- 2:38just markers that they would place along the border going from the Rio Grande River to
- 2:44the Pacific Ocean in California.
- 2:47And these were all in line of sight of each other.
- 2:50So there's 268 of these monuments.
- 2:53And theoretically, if you're standing at one, you should be able to look left or right and
- 2:58see if you're on the borderline.
- 3:01So that was sort of the first method of marking the borders, you know, a kinder, gentler way
- 3:07of doing things.
- 3:08And then we had barbed wire fence that came along when cattle arrived.
- 3:12And that was the main barrier in most places.
- 3:16But then beginning around the mid-2000s, they started building more stout barriers.
- 3:24And these range from vehicle barriers, which look like what they call Norman defencing,
- 3:30like the landing craft deterrent structure, as you saw on the beaches at Omaha Beach in
- 3:36France during World War II.
- 3:38And those are very recognizable.
- 3:41And these were repurposed from old railroad tracks.
- 3:45But then we entered the era of border walls.
- 3:49And this is where they built steel structures that range from 18 feet tall to 30 feet tall.
- 3:57So we're looking between, you know, five and nine meters.
- 4:01And the gaps between the beams, the steel beams that they are constructed of are only
- 4:08about 10 centimeters.
- 4:10And so that's not very much room for something to get through.
- 4:15During the Trump administration, they built over 600 kilometers, actually about 700 kilometers
- 4:23of border wall in the states of California, Arizona, New Mexico, and to a lesser extent
- 4:32in Texas.
- 4:35There's some subtle differences between the states, specifically Texas, on how and where
- 4:40they can build border walls, depending on how the land is owned.
- 4:43But Arizona, New Mexico, and California, we really took a bad hit here when the Trump
- 4:50administration was around.
- 4:53And there were border walls built prior to that under the Bush administration and to
- 4:59a small number for the Obama administration.
- 5:02Now these border walls, like I said, they're the ones that they built after 2017, are 30
- 5:10feet tall.
- 5:11That's, you know, almost 10 meters tall.
- 5:14And this is a lethal distance for somebody to fall.
- 5:20And so, you know, border barriers have an effect upon humans and wildlife, a huge health
- 5:31effect.
- 5:33In the hospitals in San Diego, they're seeing more people injured by falling off the border
- 5:38wall than they do gunshot wounds.
- 5:41And in America, that is saying something because we get a lot of gunshot wounds here.
- 5:45And not to joke about such a grave topic, but it's very significant.
- 5:53But the impact that the border wall is having on wildlife is profound.
- 6:00And it's a difficult thing to measure because we don't really have good baseline data to
- 6:05go off.
- 6:06That's kind of a different scientific topic I can expand upon.
- 6:10But in essence, here you have this border barrier that is crossing the continent and
- 6:17in places where there happens to be very high biodiversity and a lot of natural migration
- 6:24corridors that have existed for thousands of years.
- 6:27So the way that the topography is laid out in the Western states, North America is the
- 6:34basin and range topography, where basically you have north-south trending mountain ranges
- 6:40interspersed with valleys between them.
- 6:43And so these narrow pinch points between the US and Mexico, what happens is it enables
- 6:52animals to migrate north or south according to changing conditions.
- 6:57And of course, these changing conditions have been going on for thousands of years, but
- 7:01they happen seasonally and more recently in the context of climate change, we're seeing
- 7:07a lot more animal dispersal in order to follow things like rainfall and if you're a predator,
- 7:13prey availability.
- 7:14So there's really no worse place that you could place a border wall and no worse design
- 7:21than to put one running east and west across this part of the continent because you are
- 7:27essentially fragmenting and altering the evolutionary history of North America.
- 7:34Can you bring us to that place?
- 7:38You talked about New Mexico, Arizona, and Texas.
- 7:43If I go there and I've never been to the southern border, what does it feel like?
- 7:50What's the weather like?
- 7:51What's the topography like?
- 7:54Because I imagine like a desert, like a barren lands, and you're talking about migration.
- 8:03So can you bring us to that place and talk about what you see when you travel there?
- 8:10Well, that's an excellent question, Ryan.
- 8:12I'm really glad that you asked that because I think the impression is that we live in
- 8:18a desert wasteland here and nothing could be further from the truth.
- 8:24And borderlands are an incredibly diverse place.
- 8:27They have elevations ranging from sea level up to 3,000 meters.
- 8:33And so you could be anywhere along this point of the 2,000 mile long border and you could
- 8:38find yourself in a variety of different habitats.
- 8:42This ranges from pine trees, conifer trees, junipers, and pinions, and grasslands, just
- 8:50like you would find up in Manitoba, Ontario.
- 8:55These are short grass prairie grasslands.
- 8:58So you get that element, but you also get some of the deserts.
- 9:04But contrary to popular belief, deserts are very high in biodiversity.
- 9:08And where we are here in the southwest is one of the most biodiverse places on the continent,
- 9:14especially when it comes to reptiles and amphibians and pollinators and native bees.
- 9:23There's a great degree of inhabitants.
- 9:25And what also makes it unique is that since this is the meeting ground of the temperate
- 9:32zones and the tropic zones, where you've got the temperate zones coming down from the north,
- 9:37the Rocky Mountains essentially reaching their southern terminus where they meet the Sierra
- 9:42Madre, which is the big mountain range on the spine of Mexico, that has the tropical
- 9:48element.
- 9:49And so it creates this melting pot, this meeting ground of great diversity of plants and animals.
- 10:00The most iconic representatives would be the black bear, which people associate with northern
- 10:07temperate zones.
- 10:08But then we also have the jaguar in the borderlands.
- 10:13We've had nine jaguars occur over the last 25 years here in Arizona and New Mexico.
- 10:20And this is the iconic apex predator of the tropics, ranging all the way down to Argentina.
- 10:29And so it reaches its northern extent up here.
- 10:33So I like to say that this is the land where the jaguar and the black bear share the same
- 10:38trail.
- 10:39Oh my gosh, that's incredible.
- 10:42This is the first time I'm hearing this.
- 10:44Is it because the fact that it is the first time I'm hearing this?
- 10:48Is it because, you know, are there a lot of documentaries out there about this zone?
- 10:57Lots of reports.
- 10:58You know, I don't remember, you know, watching anything about this zone, this part of the
- 11:06world.
- 11:07It's just my personal bias, but tell me.
- 11:11I don't think it's your personal bias.
- 11:13I think it's the media bias.
- 11:16There's always a recurring story that happens along the border and it comes along in the
- 11:21election seasons.
- 11:24And much like when you hear about it's hurricane season.
- 11:27And so in the southeastern US, places like Florida, they start talking about hurricanes
- 11:32in June and we can expect this to happen.
- 11:35This is essentially what happens before every big election.
- 11:39It becomes immigrant abuse season and it becomes, you know, basically a very, it's a very racist
- 11:47approach towards the border.
- 11:49You know, when you hear terms like invasion, when we're clearly not being invaded, there's
- 11:54people just simply walking across trying to find a better way of life.
- 11:58Yeah, this is, so the way the media portrays the border is very much as a desert space,
- 12:10as a place of desperation, of chaos.
- 12:16When the reality is that 99% of the borderlands, if you were just plopped down there like a
- 12:23transporter beam from Star Trek, you would probably be alone in the wilderness, in, you
- 12:31know, standing beneath an oak tree or maybe a pine tree if you're lucky to be enough higher
- 12:37or in grasslands or you might be in the saguaro cactus deserts, like you think of, people
- 12:42think of the Arizona desert.
- 12:44And so what happens is in some of these places that happen to be big population centers like
- 12:49Yuma, El Paso, these are in some of the desert places, it's an easy place for the media to
- 12:57access and to get their photo ops.
- 13:00And this happens frequently.
- 13:02Every few weeks there's a delegation of mostly Republicans from Republican Party here in
- 13:10the US from the border states of Nebraska, Illinois, Oklahoma, and I joke about that
- 13:16being border states because those are not border states, but everybody from around the
- 13:21country seems to have an interest in what's going on down here.
- 13:26And they come down to get their photo ops, you know, say that we're being invaded, that
- 13:30you know, whatever administration's in power is not doing enough about this.
- 13:34And so it's really become a political football.
- 13:38And the reality of the border is so misunderstood.
- 13:47You know, along with the diversity of habitats, vegetation communities, wildlife and plants,
- 13:55it's also an incredibly diverse place for human culture.
- 14:01It's an area of extreme mixing and blending where you find a lot of dynamic energy.
- 14:09And there's been a great food tradition that's come out of the borderlands.
- 14:14And you know, I would say a good majority of Americans take part in some sort of, you
- 14:21know, Mexican food at some point, probably almost weekly.
- 14:27It's become, you know, almost daily ingrained with, you know, burritos and tacos and enchiladas
- 14:33and you know, all these things, avocados, you know, all these things that North Americans
- 14:37have grown to love in recent years.
- 14:41And that's a result of, you know, humans occupying this space, this very dynamic space where,
- 14:51you know, you've got the American Anglo influence from the North with the Latin American influence
- 14:58from the South.
- 15:00And then the mixing ground of all these great food traditions, you know, from an ethnobotanical
- 15:06perspective, it's fascinating because, you know, Mexico is the land where chili peppers
- 15:12come from and tomatoes and avocados and some of the tastiest foods in the planet happen
- 15:19to come from this part of the world in Mesoamerica, the Aztec and Mayan traditions.
- 15:24So that's an element of the borderlands that is something that's very positive, you know,
- 15:33it's a place where, you know, a lot of people like to be and it's spurred a lot of innovation
- 15:40and experimentation with food and culture and just about every facet of our life here
- 15:49in the borderlands.
- 15:50And I just wish that that aspect of the border was cherished more and really viewed in a
- 15:57more positive light.
- 15:59LR I'm glad you brought up the topic of food.
- 16:03And yeah, we owe a lot of our legumes and recipes to Southern American culture, including,
- 16:13I think, potatoes, watermelons, even tomatoes are native from, you know, South America,
- 16:21if I'm not mistaken.
- 16:23But you said that, you know, the real border, the kind of border we're talking about right
- 16:30now, you know, it's started during the 2000 era.
- 16:35And before that, you know, there was a more gentle approach to, I guess, marking the border.
- 16:41What I want to know is the people who decided to build that wall, have they, you know, taught
- 16:48about wildlife?
- 16:51Was it even a footnote in the way, you know, they, they thought about, oh, now we're going
- 16:57to build the wall.
- 16:59It's going to impact this and that.
- 17:02Was there even a study around that before they built that wall?
- 17:06LR No, there wasn't.
- 17:08And there's a very specific reason for this.
- 17:11There was a law that was enacted in 2005 called the Real ID Act of 2005.
- 17:17And that sounds fairly benign.
- 17:19Okay, well, we're all supposed to carry identification.
- 17:22But there was a clause in that law that said that the Secretary of Homeland Security has
- 17:29the authority and power to waive all laws for the construction of border barriers.
- 17:35And this includes the Endangered Species Act, the Clean Air Act, the Clean Water Act, the
- 17:42Rivers and Protection Act, the Wilderness Act, Bald Eagle, Golden Eagle Protection.
- 17:47And the list goes on to about 70 different laws that they have the authority to waive.
- 17:53And so because of this, we were not able to do environmental studies to try to assess
- 18:00the impact of the border wall on wildlife, on water, on the ecosystem.
- 18:08So they essentially can just do what they want to do.
- 18:12And that's exactly what they did is they don't really have to notify anybody except to put
- 18:17it in the US Federal Register saying, we're going to build a border wall here and we are
- 18:22waiving all of these laws.
- 18:25And that is a very scary thing and it set a horrible precedent around the world because
- 18:34this is the erosion of democracy.
- 18:37How can an unelected politically appointed official, which is who the Secretary of Homeland
- 18:43Security is, how do they have the authority to waive laws that both houses of Congress
- 18:49have passed and whatever sitting president signed them into law and then it withstood
- 18:55decades of judicial review and challenges at the Supreme Court?
- 18:59How does that person have the power to do that?
- 19:03Unchecked power.
- 19:05This is something that people should be scared of because it's starting to proliferate around
- 19:10the world.
- 19:11There are now nearly 70 countries in the world that have border walls and they are following
- 19:19the same playbook where in Poland and Belarus, they built a border wall two years ago, a
- 19:27200 kilometer long border wall between Poland and Belarus right through the Białowice Unesco
- 19:35Biosphere Reserve.
- 19:37So there's bison there, there's wolves, brown bears, and they waived all the laws to construct
- 19:44that.
- 19:47In Slovenia, they're putting up border barriers and once again, they did the same thing saying
- 19:51that, oh, in order to put these up, we need to bypass all the laws.
- 19:56And unfortunately, that's something that I believe that the United States exported to
- 20:03a lot of places who are taking advantage of this autocratic power that really should not
- 20:14exist in a true functioning democracy.
- 20:17But why are we building those walls?
- 20:20Because when I think about a wall, I think about the Great China wall.
- 20:29It's something from the medieval era.
- 20:31It's something from the time of our ancestors and times of conflict and lords waging wars
- 20:41between themselves and things like that.
- 20:45So what's the function of that wall?
- 20:49What is it contributing to our society, to our countries?
- 20:58I think it's really taken a step backwards in our evolution.
- 21:04And this makes me think of the rock band Devo.
- 21:11It stands for devolution.
- 21:14And the members of the band thought that at some point in the late 60s, early 70s, we
- 21:18had reached a pinnacle of human evolution.
- 21:22But after the Kent State shootings, and I believe it was 71, they saw us devolving.
- 21:29And that's what I believe is happening with these border walls, is that we are trying
- 21:38to approach 21st century problems, socioeconomic and climate problems with a very medieval
- 21:48base solution.
- 21:51I mean, we are past the days of where there's a group down there with torches that say,
- 21:56now we storm the castle, and they're trying to clamor up the walls and they're pouring
- 22:01oil on them and everything.
- 22:02It's just, I don't think we're living in those days right now, at least right here.
- 22:09People are coming to this continent for a variety of reasons, but I'll tell you the
- 22:18common three that I have seen over the years as I've worked there and talked to people
- 22:24and helped transport them to airports and buses if they're seeking asylum.
- 22:30It's that one, they are fleeing climate change.
- 22:34And two, a lot of people in the Northern hemispheres, we are not seeing the climate change effects
- 22:43as acutely as they are in some parts of the world that are more prone to drought or disturbance
- 22:53or weather phenomenons.
- 22:57We're slightly more buffered here, except when you go further North and getting up into
- 23:02Alaska in the Northern latitudes, they're seeing that as well.
- 23:07But people are fleeing climate change because they have been in places where they've seen
- 23:12multiple hurricanes, they've seen droughts and wildfires.
- 23:19And then the second reason they're also fleeing is because of violence and persecution.
- 23:25And there's a lot of instability out there, global instability, but also inter-country
- 23:33instability in terms of a lot of gang violence and narco-cartel violence.
- 23:40A lot of these communities in the small villages, the mountain areas of Central America are being
- 23:46terrorized by very organized gangs, organized crimes.
- 23:55And then the other reason that they're also escaping is resource depletion to where it's
- 24:03becoming more difficult to grow your crops and make a good living with an unstable climate,
- 24:11with an unpredictable climate.
- 24:13But on top of that, they are also a victim of global macroeconomics.
- 24:19And coffee is a perfect example of this.
- 24:23There was a period where a lot of farmers in the coffee growing regions were doing pretty
- 24:28well.
- 24:29Well, now there's been a huge explosion of coffee over the last three decades, and it's
- 24:34essentially overplanted and also very subject to climatic fluctuations in its production.
- 24:42So here these people have to compete with a global commodity, just like oil, and they
- 24:49are essentially powerless.
- 24:51They take the price that they're getting.
- 24:53And so these people are victims of global trade agreements such as NAFTA, such as GATT.
- 25:01They've all been affected by this because these global trade agreements, they benefited
- 25:06the big corporations quite well, and especially agri-industry, meaning agricultural, industrial
- 25:14agriculture, with large companies such as Cargill, Archer, Daniels, Midland, these very
- 25:24Cone Agri.
- 25:26They own a significant portion of the agricultural market, and it's based upon a lot of commodities
- 25:36such as corn and wheat, beans, that now are traded on the global scale.
- 25:43But these people need these on a daily basis, and they have no power of controlling their
- 25:50own pricing.
- 25:51And so they get squeezed.
- 25:53And so what's happening as a result of this?
- 25:57It's thermodynamics, is we have energy that's moving from one place to another.
- 26:01And if you could call money energy, then essentially they don't have very much.
- 26:08They don't have very many resources there, and so they're moving this direction.
- 26:12So when you look at this, and we're putting up border walls, this is just the most absurd
- 26:20thing you can do.
- 26:23And it causes a very cynical reaction in me because I would like to think that people
- 26:29in our governments are at least semi-intelligent and are thinking about problems and want to
- 26:36be problem solvers.
- 26:39And we are simply not solving any problems.
- 26:41There seems to be no effort to really provide solutions to these issues that are only going
- 26:49to be increasing every year.
- 26:51So we are starting to see climate change in action that's arriving at our southern doorstep.
- 27:00And the United States always frames it as we have a problem with the southern border.
- 27:05It's our problem.
- 27:06It's like, no, don't put that on yourself.
- 27:09Claim this responsibility for it.
- 27:11This is a global crisis is what we're seeing.
- 27:14It is manifesting at the border because of borders being places where just things get
- 27:20compressed, where we're seeing people from dozens of countries all around the world.
- 27:25I've counted 17 countries so far and people I've encountered over the last probably two
- 27:30or three years.
- 27:32So these people are not just coming to America for the healthcare.
- 27:37Definitely not.
- 27:39But they're coming for very good reasons.
- 27:43And that common thread of why they're coming, it's across the same for people I've met
- 27:50from Syria, from people I've met from Ukraine, from Ethiopia, Sudan, Mali, Burkina Faso.
- 28:00I mean, it's just incredible that the people I encounter and the places that they come
- 28:05from and that's never appreciated in the media.
- 28:12And the media and the government is not doing a good job of being analytical and introspective
- 28:19on why are the people coming here.
- 28:24Why is never a question that you'll hear in any stories about the border.
- 28:33I think you, I never heard such a good explanation of why is it a problem right now?
- 28:40Why are we hearing so much noise about it in the media?
- 28:47I want to get back to the wildlife aspect of it because I feel like, first of all, I
- 28:54feel like it's such a great story to tell.
- 28:58The impact of the border wall on wildlife.
- 29:02Why are we not having more conversations around that?
- 29:06Why aren't reporters and journalists interested in the fate of wildlife species around the
- 29:15border?
- 29:16It's not that there are none that are not covering this.
- 29:23There was a documentary that was produced about three years ago called American Scar.
- 29:30And so I was part of that production.
- 29:32And in fact, we were just in Mexico City for a screening a couple of weeks ago for that.
- 29:36So it's still having an impact.
- 29:39That discusses wildlife.
- 29:42But there's a couple other documentaries that I just finished shooting recently that will
- 29:50be coming out this summer.
- 29:52And these will specifically be focused on wildlife and such as nature divided or border
- 29:59wildlife effects.
- 30:03Back in 2021, we did a story map and story maps of these GIS products that it's basically
- 30:12like kind of a scrolling story with multimedia in it.
- 30:16And I actually see this a lot of websites now for news as they're starting to use the
- 30:20story format.
- 30:21I think it's a pretty good medium.
- 30:22But we did one on where the border wall was built and it has interactive maps in it.
- 30:28And I'll send you a link to that so that people can find that in the comment section.
- 30:34But that lays out the structure of the border and what it's affecting.
- 30:41And what it's really affecting are the large mammals.
- 30:48And I had mentioned the jaguar, which is a very charismatic species from the tropics.
- 30:58It's the third largest cat in the world, spotted cats.
- 31:02But the ones that I'm really concerned about are the common everyday animals that you see.
- 31:09Like if you and I did a trip down to the border today, we would definitely see deer, probably
- 31:14two species, white-tailed deer, mule deer.
- 31:16And then there's also the javelina, which is like a wild pig native to this area.
- 31:21That's like a new world pig.
- 31:24They're very common.
- 31:26There's an animal called coadamundi, which is kind of like a ring-tailed cat raccoon.
- 31:32That's another tropical species.
- 31:34And there's a pronghorn antelope, which range all the way up into your area, into Canada.
- 31:42And there's black bear, mountain lion, bobcats, and desert bighorn sheep.
- 31:50All of these animals are very affected by the border wall because in a place that's
- 31:56dry and even though it may not be desert in a lot of the borderlands, it's still a very
- 32:01arid place where rainfall is very infrequent in space and time, meaning that you may have
- 32:08a year where not much rain falls or you may have all of it falling in one day or in one
- 32:16place and not another.
- 32:18So these animals have adapted over thousands of years to find these water sources, find
- 32:26these food sources, find the places for shelter when different seasons come around.
- 32:33Now they have this barrier that's running hundreds of miles across the land.
- 32:40And what do they do when they encounter this if they needed to get to their water source
- 32:45that's maybe one kilometer north or south of where they are?
- 32:48Now they have to walk potentially 100 kilometers to the end of this wall or find a gap in it
- 32:56and get through.
- 32:57So I think that the border wall is probably killing a lot of animals that we're not even
- 33:04seeing that we're not even aware of because animals are out of sight, out of mind.
- 33:12They don't call up on a cell phone and say, hey, I'm lost out here.
- 33:15I'm hungry.
- 33:16Can you help?
- 33:18Which is the case with humans.
- 33:20We know that in the Arizona area just over the last 10, 15 years, there's been documented
- 33:29five, 6,000 people who've died in the desert here.
- 33:34Organizations such as No More Deaths documents these and finds these locations and has created
- 33:41maps for those and has put little memorials out there and also tried to identify the remains
- 33:46using forensics and DNA.
- 33:50So if this is happening for humans, if we're seeing five, 6,000 humans that we know of
- 33:57perishing dry horrible deaths of starvation and suffering, I'm sure that the same is true
- 34:05for animals.
- 34:06But we just don't see that because an animal may walk off into the bushes and pass away
- 34:14and then its remains are scavenged by something.
- 34:19And so we don't see that.
- 34:20And so I'm very concerned about all the common everyday animals that we have not had the
- 34:26opportunity to monitor because of the nature of the way border barriers are built.
- 34:34And this goes back to what I mentioned earlier with the Real ID Act of 2005, where since
- 34:39they were able to waive all these laws, they just build the barriers.
- 34:43Now any other giant public works project like a dam or a freeway, it would go through environmental
- 34:49reviews.
- 34:50There would be biological opinions.
- 34:51There would be public comment periods.
- 34:53There would be alternatives presented to minimize impacts and expense.
- 34:59But that's not the case with border walls.
- 35:01And so we were not able to put in any baseline studies to see like, okay, we know how many
- 35:09animals, how many deer are in this area.
- 35:11We know how many mountain lions are here.
- 35:13Now what's going to happen if we build a border barrier?
- 35:16What happens to their home ranges, their distributions, their habitats?
- 35:22There's just so much that we don't know.
- 35:25And that's what makes it really difficult is when you know in some places that wildlife
- 35:32are having a hard time.
- 35:34And we have trail cameras and videos.
- 35:37We're monitoring this in numerous locations along the border with long-term research projects
- 35:41that we've set up recently.
- 35:46But that's going to take a long time to get those results.
- 35:50And I think that even with scientific data, the data are, they turn into numbers at some
- 35:59point.
- 36:00And what happens is you lose the fact that there's a real animal with a beating heart
- 36:08and hopes and desires, I'm sure.
- 36:15What's happening out there?
- 36:18And if we see that, oh, wildlife numbers have declined in the context of border walls, what
- 36:24does that mean, decline?
- 36:26That means probably big die-offs of animals along the borderlands.
- 36:32And we simply don't know how that's going to affect the ecosystem at large if that happens.
- 36:39And like you said, with a horrifying death, having this border and you know there is water
- 36:45just across it and you just can't reach it and you have to go through the desert and
- 36:52the hot weather.
- 36:53So you talked about mammals.
- 36:55What about reptiles?
- 36:57What about insects?
- 36:59Is it also affecting, you know, is it affecting every species out there or is it limited to
- 37:06certain categories of animals?
- 37:09I think it's probably having an effect on almost everything.
- 37:14It's obvious that some things can pass through the border wall.
- 37:17I've seen several snakes, rattlesnakes and other ones crawling through the border fence.
- 37:24So they're not having an issue, but desert tortoises can't make it through there because
- 37:31you know, that's a hard shell.
- 37:32The border wall is only four inches slash 10 centimeters wide.
- 37:39And so two years ago I had an encounter where we encountered a pretty large female desert
- 37:44tortoise and she was right on the border road next to the border wall and happened to be
- 37:52with the documentary film crew and so that will be in this documentary, The Border Wildlife.
- 37:58But you see the plight that this animal is in.
- 38:03It's had this barrier placed across a place where it's lived for decades.
- 38:11Desert tortoises can live to 60, 80 years old.
- 38:14And so they form their lives around these known locations of food, shelter, water.
- 38:25So they are being affected, the desert tortoises are.
- 38:30And also there's a lot of birds and butterflies that are impacted by this because even though
- 38:36they fly, many of them don't fly that high.
- 38:39They may fly three, four meters maximum.
- 38:44And I've observed this along the border wall.
- 38:46I've seen butterflies, big giant flocks of butterflies come up to the wall and not pass
- 38:54through.
- 38:55And I think it might be something to do with the temperature of the wall during the daytime
- 38:59it heats up or it could just be that there's a disruption of airflow.
- 39:06You know, I don't know.
- 39:09But unfortunately they have installed high intensity lighting in many places along the
- 39:17border.
- 39:18This is like stadium lighting.
- 39:19And so in most places they have not turned this on yet.
- 39:23And we're very concerned about this because that could have a huge impact upon bird and
- 39:30bat migration.
- 39:34You know, these animals they use visual navigation, they use sonar navigation.
- 39:42So the presence of high intensity lighting could really disrupt that.
- 39:46It's also could have a huge impact upon native insects and pollinators.
- 39:54In the San Bernardino Valley of southeastern Arizona, there was a paper published about
- 40:00three years ago that identified there were 500 species of native bees that occurred in
- 40:06this one area, the highest of all North America, the highest diversity.
- 40:12These are a lot of solitary bees.
- 40:15So there are these ground dwelling bees that just live by themselves.
- 40:20And a lot of people don't think about this.
- 40:22When we think about bees, everybody thinks there's one bee, you know, but it turns out
- 40:26there's thousands of bees, you know.
- 40:28And the Western North America has a lot.
- 40:30And so if you turn on high intensity lighting, the effect that's going to have on the insect
- 40:37fauna, and then the avian fauna and the bats is going to be tremendous.
- 40:44And so we're putting out all of these structures and technology and border militarization type
- 40:52of tools without really doing the work to determine what kind of impact are they going
- 41:00to have.
- 41:01So things will be impacted all across the border and including plants.
- 41:07We're seeing a huge influx of non-native invasive plant species occur along the border because
- 41:13you had this road hundreds of miles long that has been disturbed and all of that heavy equipment,
- 41:23you know, giant pieces of caterpillar construction gear and trucks and thousands of people from
- 41:29all around the whole country spreading all these seeds.
- 41:35And so we're seeing weird plants pop up now, you know, invasives that we have not seen
- 41:41in other places, you know, range expansions of invasive species we've seen in Arizona,
- 41:47but we had not seen them in New Mexico yet.
- 41:50They hadn't made it there, but now they're making their way there.
- 41:53So anytime you get a change in the plant community, that's going to have a ripple effect because
- 41:59a lot of plants, all plants have some sort of mutualisms or symbiotic relationships or
- 42:08something that is going to some species is going to rely upon that plant for its sustenance
- 42:14and wellbeing and pollination.
- 42:17So you know, it remains to be seen what's going to be the final outcome here, but there's
- 42:24out of doubt we are seeing tremendous effects across the ecosystem now due to the border
- 42:30wall.
- 42:31LR You mentioned, well, we talked about water sources and you mentioned rivers.
- 42:36What about aquatic life then?
- 42:38CB Oh, aquatic life is definitely impacted.
- 42:41Where I first started my career in the Southwest was at San Bernardino National Wildlife Refuge.
- 42:46And that's near the Arizona New Mexico state line.
- 42:50And it's right on the international border, the refuge is.
- 42:54And that refuge was established for native fish.
- 42:57That is the headwaters of the Rio Yaqui River basin.
- 43:02And so there's eight species of endemic fish to that small refuge.
- 43:08We're talking a place of only about 1000 hectares, harbored eight different species of native
- 43:13fish.
- 43:14The Yaqui top minnow, the Yaqui chub, the beautiful shiner, or the Mexican stone roller,
- 43:19and then the only catfish native to the Western North America, the Yaqui catfish.
- 43:26Those were impacted tremendously by border wall construction.
- 43:30Because it turns out that some of the portions of the streams where a lot of the population
- 43:36lived was right on the border, right where it crossed, where the deepest ponds.
- 43:42There was tremendous amount of material that was discharged into these streams, making
- 43:49the water quality terrible.
- 43:52In addition, they pumped billions of gallons of groundwater to mix the concrete to build
- 44:00the border wall.
- 44:01And so there are places where they drilled wells and pumped the water and all the surrounding
- 44:06wells went dry, and including the natural artesian wells that flow naturally at the
- 44:13San Bernardino refuge, those went dry.
- 44:15And they had to, in an emergency, install solar powered submersible pumps that are still
- 44:22there to this day to keep the water flow to these ponds where the native fish are.
- 44:28So ironically, this was all occurring during COVID, most of the construction.
- 44:33And right at that point, the refuge went on a ventilator when they had to install all
- 44:39of these solar powered pumps and the water has still not returned to its natural flow.
- 44:45So the aquatic resources has been tremendously affected.
- 44:50And other places where rivers cross the border, like the San Pedro River, like the Santa Cruz
- 44:55River, which are small rivers by Eastern standards, but the major drainage is here, those have
- 45:02been walled off and they put fences across them.
- 45:07And these have blown out with floods every year since they built the border wall.
- 45:12And so it's so naive to think that you can just stop a river.
- 45:17It just doesn't work that way with nature.
- 45:20Nature will win.
- 45:21And every time one of these walls gets knocked over by the latest big flash flood that comes
- 45:26through this area, it's just sort of a ray of hope that eventually nature will reclaim
- 45:33what is hers.
- 45:36But I wish we could do it a little bit quicker.
- 45:40Let's run some scenarios and tell me how pertinent it is to what we're talking about.
- 45:47What about if there are storms or changes in the weather in terms of seasons?
- 45:59How does having this big wall impact wildlife in this context?
- 46:09A lot of migration routes are learned.
- 46:13But everything is this magic instinct in wildlife ecology.
- 46:19It's well known that birds such as whooping cranes, sandhill cranes, they learn their
- 46:26migration routes from their elders.
- 46:29And even in Europe, in places between the former Iron Curtain, the Eastern Bloc countries,
- 46:39the Russians built a fence, the longest fence at that time in the world.
- 46:45I think it's nearly 2,000 kilometers long, not as high as the one here.
- 46:51It was more of a fence with a lot of razor wire on it.
- 46:56But when that was removed, they started removing this in the 90s, 2000s, the 90s in a lot of
- 47:05these places.
- 47:06They took the walls down, wrapped up all the barbed wire, got rid of it.
- 47:11Interesting thing was observed.
- 47:14Collared animals, meaning ones that had GPS satellite collars for research.
- 47:18And these were bears and wolves and lynx and other large caribou.
- 47:27They followed the same routes of the walls.
- 47:31And they were not migrating across these.
- 47:34Even though no physical barrier existed anymore, these animals had gone through several generations
- 47:41of learning this is the route to go.
- 47:44And they continue to follow these routes even though the border barrier has been removed.
- 47:51And right there, that tells me something that we've got a data point that demonstrates an
- 47:57impact, a decades long effect from this border barrier.
- 48:03This is an effect that we are now able to observe because the wall is gone and we've
- 48:07got research technology, things that we can measure things very accurately, animal movements.
- 48:17So there's definitely things that we are not seeing here on the US Mexico border because
- 48:24we don't have the time, meaning the time to observe these effects.
- 48:32We don't have a good handle on who's being affected by this.
- 48:37So migration routes and animal movements will undoubtedly be affected in ways that we have
- 48:49not been able to predict because of those movement corridors that might be changing
- 48:58and different at different times of the year.
- 49:01Maybe in December, an ocelot or a javelina goes this area.
- 49:09In August, they go this route.
- 49:14So measuring the complexity of animal movements along any region is complex, but even more
- 49:22so in places like the Southwest and the borderlands where rainfall is infrequent.
- 49:29And like I said, it's really patchy in space and time.
- 49:33And so the movements and migrations of animals are a little bit more sporadic and random
- 49:41versus a classic case like the Serengeti where the wildebeest make that migration.
- 49:47They all go through that one space.
- 49:49The Nile crocodiles are waiting for them.
- 49:51We don't have that type of migration routes here.
- 49:56They're more dispersed, they're more invisible.
- 50:00So this is an uncontrolled experiment is what this is.
- 50:06We're going to see things happen that we've probably never seen before.
- 50:11Second scenario, I mentioned storms.
- 50:15I guess there will be pollutants.
- 50:20You talked about the concrete in the water, but this wall will get damaged.
- 50:26What will be the effect of those pollutants?
- 50:28And then what about the increased human presence?
- 50:33The people that will be dispatched to again and again repair that wall, repair the holes
- 50:39in the wall and do maintenance on the wall.
- 50:43Oh yeah.
- 50:44As we speak, there are probably hundreds of people working on the wall right now doing
- 50:48maintenance.
- 50:49And in some places it has fallen down or at risk of being fallen down.
- 50:56There's a lot of what they call head cutting, which is a process of erosion or streams cut
- 51:01back into their banks.
- 51:04And you see this in places where there's a lot of gullies.
- 51:08And a gully is just a steep sided eroded piece of land.
- 51:13The Grand Canyon and those places that people know of in the Southwestern United States,
- 51:20that's an extreme example of gullying of an erosion.
- 51:23Basically the Grand Canyon is one big gully that keeps on cutting back into itself.
- 51:27Well, that's essentially been happening in many places on the border.
- 51:30And so when you get soil erosion, ultimately that soil goes into streams and that affects
- 51:36the water quality.
- 51:38And then when the soil erodes, well, nobody wants to lose soil.
- 51:42That's the foundation of basically most life on earth combined with water and sunlight.
- 51:50Yeah, we are seeing a lot of damage to the land and continual maintenance of the border
- 52:00that's required.
- 52:01And with that comes, like you said, increased human presence.
- 52:05There's a lot of traffic, a lot of truck traffic, heavy equipment.
- 52:08Of course, animals get hit on the road.
- 52:10I find roadkill constantly.
- 52:13And then there's the increased border patrol presence.
- 52:18And now you've got vehicles occupying an area basically 24-7 and driving these roads.
- 52:29And the effect of them on animals is quite significant.
- 52:33In fact, for my master's research, I studied the white-sided jackrabbit, which is a rare
- 52:37species of hare that lives in the southwest corner of the state of New Mexico and in Chihuahua.
- 52:44And this hare is nocturnal, comes out about 10 o'clock at night, goes back in before the
- 52:49sun comes up.
- 52:50I guess it was called the vampire hare.
- 52:53But at that time of night, they haven't been subject to very much roadkill because of the
- 53:02rural area that they live in.
- 53:04However, now with the increase of patrol roads on the border and border walls, now you have
- 53:12border patrol trucks driving around all night long in a habitat space and time that there
- 53:19didn't used to be that.
- 53:21And so I documented the decline of the white-sided jackrabbit, about 50%, part of which is due
- 53:28to habitat change, due to climate variables.
- 53:32However, there were locations, the signal came out pretty strong that there's a roadkill
- 53:39effect here.
- 53:40And very early on in the study, I began documenting what vehicles I was seeing.
- 53:47Was this border patrol vehicle or non-border patrol?
- 53:50And it was 99% border patrol vehicle.
- 53:53So there's a measurable impact that border security and border militarization has had
- 53:59upon animals.
- 54:03Last scenario, you talked about that, the turtle.
- 54:08Oh, the tortoise.
- 54:10Yeah.
- 54:11Yeah.
- 54:12Sorry.
- 54:13You know, sometimes I just lose my English abilities and my mastery of English.
- 54:18Anyway, you found that big, beautiful creature and you did nothing.
- 54:26You know, you helped her.
- 54:28I guess you documented her presence, which is the right thing to do because now I'm imagining,
- 54:35you know, all those people who are now present around the border wall area, if they had encountered
- 54:44like a rare animal or something like that, like the creature you described, I feel like
- 54:51they would have just picked up the creature and brought it home or something like that.
- 54:55So last scenario, what is the impact of the border wall on wildlife trafficking?
- 55:03One thing it does is it brings more people to an area.
- 55:07And this is the classic case with logging and mining, you know, oil production roads
- 55:15is that you have roadless areas and now they build a road in order to go in to extract
- 55:21the materials or whatever they're going to do there.
- 55:25And for the first time, you have a traffic highway that people can go into and out of
- 55:31quickly.
- 55:32They have mobility there.
- 55:33They have the advantage of fossil fuel vehicles.
- 55:37And so now you're bringing in a population of humans to a place that they didn't exist
- 55:43or they were in very small numbers and only on foot.
- 55:48And so the ironic effect of the border wall is that now there is increased migration in
- 55:56places that were formerly wilderness areas because the United States government went
- 56:01and created the infrastructure and mobility to get in and out of those areas.
- 56:06So now it's become even easier for the drug cartels, which have largely switched to human
- 56:11trafficking in the last two years because it's more profitable and less risky.
- 56:19Now they have routes to take people through.
- 56:23They can take them through the wilderness areas to the south of the border in Mexico.
- 56:28And then they get to the border wall and they put a 31 foot ladder on top of the 30 foot
- 56:34border wall and the people go to the other side.
- 56:37And now they've got a highway that they can utilize.
- 56:44And so this is the same for drug smuggling, all of this thing, although the majority of
- 56:48drugs are coming through the port of entry.
- 56:52So there's a snowball effect that's occurring is that the more you add onto the infrastructure,
- 57:03the more you actually increase the presence of humans and you create better conditions
- 57:10and habitat for them to exploit.
- 57:13And ultimately, the wildlife is going to suffer.
- 57:18And noise pollution is a big part of that too.
- 57:22That can't be overlooked.
- 57:23I would say that in a lot of places where I see a lot of heavy human traffic, I'm not
- 57:30seeing very many animals.
- 57:32And that's kind of an obvious effect.
- 57:34They're kind of scared away.
- 57:36This was observed all around the planet during COVID is that there was an influx of wildlife
- 57:42into urban areas.
- 57:44A lot of urban parks in India saw large increases of leopards and even elephants coming in at
- 57:51night in spaces because the quarantine had taken effect and the humans went back into
- 57:57their boxes and all the urban areas that still had trees and landscapes got recolonized quickly
- 58:06by the animals.
- 58:07So that's another data point.
- 58:09If they can be recolonized that quickly, then they can be depopulated that quickly as well.
- 58:15LR That's crazy, Miles.
- 58:18I'm astonished.
- 58:20I did not realize before this conversation how large, how the problem was that complex
- 58:29and that large scale.
- 58:33So you're working day and night researching, documenting what's happening.
- 58:40First of all, is it safe, the work you're doing?
- 58:43Because I guess you're bothering a lot of people and agendas and you talked about those
- 58:50gangs trafficking people.
- 58:55Hopefully you never had to encounter some of those violent criminals.
- 59:00So this is my first question.
- 59:04How is it being in the forefront of talking about this issue and doing something about
- 59:10it?
- 59:11So during border wall construction when it was active between 2017 and 2021, I was monitoring
- 59:19the actual activities.
- 59:20And so I would go to these construction zones and I would fly my drone, I would take photographs.
- 59:26They had security teams, heavily armed, just like you'd expect in America.
- 59:34These firms out of Texas and they come around like, what are you doing here?
- 59:37And this is a place where I've worked for over 20 years.
- 59:40And my question would be like, what are you doing here?
- 59:43So I encountered a lot of hostility during that period.
- 59:47I've had encounters with cartel and those aspects over the years.
- 59:56Nothing terrible, nothing horribly violent, but there's an element of risk.
- 1:00:05I would say that the borderlands are safe, no more dangerous than other places, but you
- 1:00:12can't overlook the fact that anytime you are at a border area anywhere, there's going to
- 1:00:18be a heightened sense of awareness.
- 1:00:24They talk about things like conditions, like condition green, everything's cool.
- 1:00:28It's a Sunday afternoon, you're not working, you're in the park, you're having some wine
- 1:00:32in a baguette and some brie or something like that, then you have condition yellow and red
- 1:00:37and then black and it's that gradient.
- 1:00:40And so when I'm working in the borderlands, I would say that I'm definitely on like a
- 1:00:45condition yellow, a very relaxed one, but just you have to keep track of your surroundings
- 1:00:51and be aware of where you are and know the terrain.
- 1:00:57It's funny because people don't often know what is dangerous and what isn't.
- 1:01:04And this is kind of a classic case if you travel somewhere in the world and if you just
- 1:01:08went into some big city, ignorance is bliss.
- 1:01:13Sometimes you might be in a very dangerous place, but you don't know it because you were
- 1:01:17never told that it was a dangerous place.
- 1:01:20And so I think that there are some places on the border that are more dangerous than
- 1:01:25people perceive and other ones that are less dangerous.
- 1:01:28But it's like anywhere and it definitely has its degree of risk involved.
- 1:01:35And what can we do to support your work to do something about this issue?
- 1:01:42I think that learning about border walls and how and why they're being constructed is just
- 1:01:51the first step of awareness is to realize that what they can waive these laws.
- 1:01:56And this runs so deep.
- 1:01:57I was with a congressman one time down at the border and she said, well, why don't we just
- 1:02:05use the Endangered Species Act to stop this?
- 1:02:09And I just said, whoa, wait a minute, you were a member of Congress and you weren't
- 1:02:12aware of the law that you passed here?
- 1:02:16They were part of that voting block and they weren't even aware of it.
- 1:02:21So just educating oneself, but keep track of the organizations such as Wildlands Network,
- 1:02:30Sky Island Alliance.
- 1:02:31We do work along the border here.
- 1:02:33No More Deaths, the Samaritans.
- 1:02:37There's a lot of groups that do human and animal aid along the border.
- 1:02:44And so keep track of what's going on with those projects.
- 1:02:51We have a combined study with Sky Island Alliance.
- 1:02:53We have a border wildlife study.
- 1:02:55We've got hundreds of cameras along the border.
- 1:02:57We're trying to track movements of animals.
- 1:03:02Donations are always, of course, extremely helpful.
- 1:03:06Trail cameras cost around 200 to $250, but that's what I like to say, that's the entry
- 1:03:11points there.
- 1:03:12Because once you do that, then it's the maintenance of going there to take the SD card out of
- 1:03:17it.
- 1:03:18And then you got to put the SD card in the computer and look at 5,000 pictures of whatever
- 1:03:22and catalog all that.
- 1:03:24And so one camera really costs $1,000 a year because of just all the work that goes into
- 1:03:31it.
- 1:03:33So I often donate to a lot of small organizations, $50 or something, just because I know that
- 1:03:41they've got to buy batteries for this camera or something like that.
- 1:03:44So that's helpful.
- 1:03:46And also the political process.
- 1:03:50This is all about politics.
- 1:03:52And so for people who say, I don't like to get involved with politics, well, at some
- 1:03:56point you better get involved because the levers and machines of bad politics have hit
- 1:04:04the borderlands ground zero, like a ton of bricks.
- 1:04:09And we've seen so much damage and destruction along the border.
- 1:04:14And I don't want to see any more suffering continue.
- 1:04:19There's got to be a better way of doing this.
- 1:04:22Before we end this recording quickly, I heard about projects of building another wall, but
- 1:04:28this time on the northern border with Canada.
- 1:04:34Does it have any, is it realistic?
- 1:04:38Is it just rumors of something or are people really considering doing that?
- 1:04:44I have not heard any real consideration of that.
- 1:04:48However, I would like to, and I don't mean this in a mean way.
- 1:04:57Let's get down to the root of why the southern border gets picked on.
- 1:05:01It's racism.
- 1:05:03It's what I call the fear of the little brown people is essentially what's happening in
- 1:05:09America.
- 1:05:13And the perception, like when we started out this interview, that it's a desert wasteland,
- 1:05:20what's there to conserve, there must be no wildlife there.
- 1:05:25The northern border is entirely different.
- 1:05:29It's demographic makeup.
- 1:05:31If you said the secretary of Homeland security has determined that in order to secure the
- 1:05:37border, we are building a border wall across Niagara Falls.
- 1:05:42So we're going to be dynamite blasting this here to build the border wall.
- 1:05:47People in that area would say, no, you can't do that.
- 1:05:51It's just like, oh, no, yes, we can.
- 1:05:53Really?
- 1:05:54Yeah.
- 1:05:55The Real ID Act of 2005 does that.
- 1:05:57If they wanted to drain the boundary waters of all of its water and divert that and build
- 1:06:02a wall through that, they could.
- 1:06:04If they wanted to blast through the mountains of Glacier National Park, Waterton Peace Park
- 1:06:11that straddles the border in Western Canada and the state of Montana, they can do that.
- 1:06:18They can build a border wall through there.
- 1:06:20I guarantee you that the constituency of those places of towns like Buffalo, towns like Niagara,
- 1:06:27Vermont, and Quebec, if they were going to be blowing up the mountains to build a border
- 1:06:36wall through national parks and reserves and provincial parks, I think people would just
- 1:06:43go crazy.
- 1:06:47Because there's more population there, there's also a better political constituency, meaning
- 1:06:53that they're engaged more with their politicians where here in the borderlands, the politicians
- 1:06:59have left the people behind.
- 1:07:03There's not a lot of people living in these rural places on the border, and the people
- 1:07:07that are there are poor, many of them undocumented, so they don't have a voice.
- 1:07:11The people in the borderlands are almost like the animals.
- 1:07:14They have a very diminished voice.
- 1:07:19People on the US-Canadian border have a much larger voice, Vancouver, Seattle, those places.
- 1:07:28If they started talking about a border wall there, I would be happy because it would expose
- 1:07:34this horrible law that we have in the books.
- 1:07:37Maybe people might want to reconsider and say, I didn't know that we could do that,
- 1:07:41so let's look at this and maybe tweak this and get rid of that one.
- 1:07:47But I'll keep you informed if I hear about anything happening at the border there.
- 1:07:52If we do nothing, what happens to the southern region?
- 1:07:58If we do nothing.
- 1:08:02Well people are coming here, they're going to come to the United States, Canada, no matter
- 1:08:11what, whether there's a border wall.
- 1:08:14When I encounter these piles of trash that are often blamed on the immigrants, but the
- 1:08:19reality is that when the border patrol gets them, they make them empty out all of their
- 1:08:22backpacks and pockets.
- 1:08:24I see plane tickets from Ethiopia.
- 1:08:27I see plane ticket stubs from Sudan, and then buses all along the way through South America
- 1:08:35and Mexico.
- 1:08:37Do you really think that a family that's coming from halfway around the world is going to
- 1:08:41arrive and then they get to this nine meter border wall, which is very significant and
- 1:08:46imposing and just go, oh man, I didn't realize there was a wall here.
- 1:08:50I guess we're going back.
- 1:08:52It's just stupid to think that it's going to be that way.
- 1:08:56So let's solve one of the problems of our time and facilitate and manage migration because
- 1:09:08migration has been occurring since the first bowl of primordial soup was served.
- 1:09:15It's happened everywhere with every species from bacteria to bats, and it's going to happen
- 1:09:22forever.
- 1:09:24It's just the nature of life is to migrate.
- 1:09:27So unless we start learning how to deal with that, we're only going to be throwing these
- 1:09:31destructive measures up on our borders and dividing everyone as opposed to, let's invite
- 1:09:39everyone to the table and solve the problem together.
- 1:09:42Miles, this has been such a pleasant and educated conversation.
- 1:09:48People will find links to how to donate and also to the map you talked about in the description
- 1:09:54below.
- 1:09:55Thank you so much.
- 1:09:57Thank you for your work.
- 1:09:59Thank you for everything you're doing.
- 1:10:02And thank you for having taken the time to answer my questions.
- 1:10:05Merci beaucoup.
- 1:10:06I appreciate it.
- 1:10:08Thank you everyone for listening.
- 1:10:11I kindly invite you to share this podcast with the vegans you know.
- 1:10:16Let's encourage more people to take action.
- 1:10:19Again, thank you so much for caring, and I will see you next Tuesday for a new episode.