Latest / The Academic Boardroom Podcast / The Sensory Blueprint: Navigating Metabolic Narratives with Dr. Paule Valery Joseph
Transcript
- What is the minimum amount of an odor that is necessary for someone to identify or perceive something. So there are specific tools one of them we have what we call sniffing sticks. You can think about them as, marker that has audience inside. And you you smell it. And there's a protocol by which you give individuals. one of the things that happens is like at least when Alzheimer's and Parkinson's disease, we know that, you know, the sense of smell begins to be affected. At least, 15 years before any memory symptoms occur. So I think we have a vital sign hiding in plain sight. [Theme Music] Welcome to the table. You tuned in to the academic boardroom with doctor J and doctor E, pull up a chair. Higher learning, higher stakes. Welcome back to The Academic Boardroom where we sit down with powerbrokers shaping the future of education. I'm your host Dr. Eli Joseph and joining me is my colleague and partner in crime, Dr. Janice Gassam Asare. Today we are pleased to welcome Dr. Paule Joseph, a nurse scientist who serves as a co-director of the National Smell and Taste Center at the National Institutes of Health. As a senior investigator, Dr. Joseph leads interdisciplinary research at the intersection of sensory science and metabolic health. Her work integrates genomics and neuroimaging to develop chemo sensory biomarkers for conditions ranging from alcohol use disorder to Alzheimer's disease. Her honors, which is pretty stacked, includes the election to the National Academy of Medicine, a Guggenheim Fellowship selection as a Lasker Clinical Research Scholar, selection as a TED fellow, and designation as a Presidential Leadership Scholar. Dr. Joseph, welcome to the boardroom. Welcome. She is just that girl, as the kids say. So I'm really curious about your background and your journey because we hear, you know, Dr. Eli provided all of your accolades. It seems like you're so accomplished. You have such a vast resume. But I want to know where it all started. And and a little bit more about your academic journey. What made you study what you wanted to study, and how did you get into the work that you're doing now? Well, first of all, thank you both for having me here in the boardroom. I'm very excited. This is I'm being really looking forward to this conversation. So how did my career study? That's when I get sometimes often. You know, it's so I trained as a nurse and as a nurse practitioner. Actually, I started my career studying in community college. So I went to a community college in the Bronx, hosts community college there. I became a licensed practical nurse. During those times where you can do become a licensed practical nurse while you were getting your your and, you know, but even during the time that I was in the community college, I knew I wanted to to to do more. And I knew that the next step was to get my bachelor's degree and just having the aspirations of more. So I went to College of New Rochelle, got my Bachelor's in nursing, and of course, I thought that I was going to just keep working and then not go to school for a little while, but and then I went and became a family nurse practitioner. And while I was doing my NP degree, you know, I got involved in collaborating with some of the faculty members during my grad school program, and that gave me an opportunity to to see the possibilities, winning research and just writing in general. So, you know, having those mentors that sometimes see something in you that you might not see in yourself. And they were really encouraging me to just go ahead and go for my PhD right away. And I said, okay, let me, let me, let me do that. So I applied for the PhD program and went to Penn. When the idea that I would do a PhD somewhere around obesity. Right. I was working in New York City, you know, at both a Montana hospital and Cornell, which is really nearby where you guys are and, you know, working with patients that had weight loss surgery. And one of the things that often the patients will tell me was that, you know, food didn't taste the same after surgery and I didn't know better. So I thought it was just, you know, the anesthesia or something like that. And, you know, little one, I will get to learn that we had taste receptors in the gut. And as they having these surgeries, these changes that are happening that could potentially be, you know, one of the reasons why they are exhibited in these symptoms. But even before that, you know, as when I started very early on in my career, started working with patients in also in nursing homes. And, you know, any nurse that works in a nursing home will tell you, you know, the way that we give patients sometimes medication is, you know, we crush it and mix it in applesauce. And, you know, many of the patients will just spit it right back at me. And so, you know, and it was it was mainly because, you know, it just didn't taste good. But during that time, I didn't necessarily have the background and training that I have today. Knowing that, you know, your sense of taste changes as you age and, you know, and that might be one of the reasons why, you know, this was happening when patients. I became really curious, you know, around taste and smell and how important they are for our health and well-being, how they change one disease. And that's how I ended up doing this work. I remember as far as your work, it's it's once again, it's pretty diverse and stacked. And I always ask myself, you know, this and I'm most curious as well. We normally focus on what we see and what we can feel, but we rarely can. You know, we overestimate or underestimate what we smell and what we taste. Did you feel like, you know, you knew that coming in through your studies and your work, that this is something that I know I can I can make a, a, a stamp on this type of work. Or did you just stumble upon it while you were studying and while you were working as a nurse? Yeah, that's a great question. You know? Okay. Hindsight is always 20-20. You know, as I, I told you, like these scenarios about working with the patients and noticing these things. And, you know, one of the things I like to always say is that, you know, nursing is observation before its intervention. So, you know, we listen to the patients, we see what's happening. And I would say that, you know, looking back, those interactions sort of inform the a lot of of what I became interested in doing. But, you know, you said something very key, which is like, you know, in this audio obsessed and visually obsessed culture, we don't really think about our taste, our sense of taste and smell. But if we look across how we interact in society, right, we interact with food, right? Like you want your food to smell good, to taste good. And so I think like there's some there's two reasons why smell and taste have often been ignored, and especially in traditional medicine, but just in general. And one of them is culturally, you know, taste and smell have often been quoted as, you know, the territory of chefs and perfumers, right? Not really clinicians. You know, there are the senses for pleasure, not the senses that are related to pathology. So but technically, until the last few decades, we did not have much validated tools to be able to measure this. So, you know, in the early 1990s that has started to shift clinically. But I think like one of the one of the biggest issues here has been one that is like culturally, we just don't think too much about it. Right? I mean, we think about it when it's bad, when you know your garbage smells bad. Okay. I need to take things out. You have. Right. Something's been rotten in the fridge, but, but also in the context of, like, you know, there's a lot of socio political connotations when it comes to smell, and that's something that we also don't discuss, right? Like the language that we attach to whatever smells good. It doesn't smell good. So yeah, there's so much to talk about this. you know, as far as your lab, you said you smell and taste alcohol use disorders, obesity and early neurodegeneration, What does it look like when you are under the microscope and you're doing, you know, chemo sensation? What does it look like in terms of what you're diagnosing or what do you see? I want to I want to tap into the brain of, you know, a neuroscientist like you. You know, I mean, so my lab does both like human research. I like to think of my life as a clinical and translational research lab. So meaning that, you know, we focus on humans, we want to understand what is happening to the individuals. And I'm going to give you an example like for example, let's go back to COVID. Nobody wants to talk about COVID, but let's take three seconds to talk about COVID. You know, during COVID, one of the things that happened is like, you know, that we had tens of millions of people that lose their sense of smell overnight. And they told us that, you know, things just didn't taste the same. And it started to affect, like their appetite, their intimacy. There's there will be safety issues, right, from either gas leaks or spoiled food, you know, so this is a huge effect on quality of life. So we want to understand, how much does, for example, diseases like COVID or other conditions like obesity or even addiction impacts the senses, right? We often focus on pain. If you go to a hospital, you've been asked how much is your pain from 0 to 10 or and you know, most people will have an answer, but we never really measure, smell or taste, right? So when we ask about, you know, how much people have recovered, we really don't have a baseline for that. So what we do is try to we do psychophysical measures. So the specific measures that have been developed where we can identify, okay, can people identify their specific orders. And that would be smell identification. You know, what is the threshold. What is the minimum amount of an odor that is necessary for someone to identify or perceive something. So there are specific tools that, you know, one of them and I wish I had maybe hopefully by the end of this, I look around and look for it. But we have what we call sniffing sticks. You can think about them as, you know, like a marker that has audience inside. And you you smell it. And there's a protocol by which you give individuals. So we have patients come in to the clinic. We do a battery of tests for them, whether it's olfactory tests, case tests, but we also do a lot of quality of life measurements. We ask them a number of times, we do a lot of biological markers to really understand what is the underlying cause of these changes that they might be perceiving, or is there are changes that are happening with these conditions. So you mentioned near the generation. So one of the things that happens is like at least when Alzheimer's and Parkinson's disease, we know that, you know, the sense of smell begins to be affected. At least, you know, 15 years before any memory symptoms occur. So I think we have a vital sign hiding in plain sight. And we have not really been doing much about it, especially because, as I told you, we don't measure it. And speaking of markers, it's a weird this is a weird confession of mine, but markers are my one of my weirdest I love I love the smell of markers. That's interesting. It takes you back to to kindergarten of preschool. Yeah. Yeah, it's. And I also have a question now, I see now that you said that you think that smelling something bring back memories of the past or trying. Okay, so there's a there's a correlation. There's a relationship between what you smell today and what brings, you know, in terms of your memory. And probably even taste. Right. I think there's such a deep connection between maybe something your parent used to make and just the taste brings you back. The smell brings you back. Right. I had a question for you, Dr. Joseph, because I think it's interesting. You've done work around obesity research, and I feel, as you were saying, that I was just thinking of people who maybe trying to lose weight. You know, there's so many people on GLP ones and people who want to lose weight. And I know that I feel like there's a connection between, you know, it's hard to lose weight because we want to eat the foods that taste good and that smell good, but is there a way to like, kind of bio hack your brain to eat things that are healthier but that, you know, just because of how they smell? And not necessarily. I don't know if I'm making sense in what I'm saying, but like, I know I have a friend who is trying to lose weight. He's Mexican and he hired a trainer, and he was telling me it was really hard because he likes the taste of Mexican food. And the trainer was like, oh, just eat this and eat this and eat this. And it's like, but it's not the same. The smell isn't the same, the taste isn't the same. And so I'm thinking from like an obesity perspective, people who are trying to lose weight, if there's a way to kind of bio hack their brains, to make them smell something and think that it actually tastes good, even if it doesn't work, it's not maybe a traditional food that they're used to. Is there any research? I'm just curious about that. Yeah, I think you just wrote my next research question. Yes. You know, I mean, we can think about this, right? Like, I mean, you you have a little one, right? Like we one of the things that they tell you earlier on is like early exposure to different foods, right? Like, how do you how did you create a diverse palette. Right. Is by exposing that palette to different things, like if we always only eating, you know, processed foods or, you know, too much sweet, like when you get something better, it's going to be very difficult for you. So, so that there's like ways to sort of modulate your sensory system. And the other thing that that, that I wanted to add is because you you mentioned that sort of in passing by just for the audience. Yes. A lot of what we call taste is actually smell. So we need both of them to be able to perceive flavor. And that's an very important thing. So normally we say something tastes good, but we are describing really if you don't have the ability to smell, you wouldn't be able to perceive that flavor. So that that's that's very important as well, especially just to clarify for the audience. But you can you know, our taste buds are like regenerating, you know, very often. Right. So yes, there's decline that happens when aging, but there's also regeneration that occurs. It's very there's a lot of plasticity. And this is why, you know, this idea of sort of, you know, introducing different foods early. Now you just brought something to mind. So last week I was at a, at a conference that was put together by the Culinary Institute of America together with Stanford University. You know, which is food is life, food is health. And it was the first time I was at a conference where we had chefs, researchers, clinicians. It was it was really I was mind blown. But one of the things that was brought up is one, you mentioned it suddenly, which is this prescription of food, right? We you know, the trainer is prescribing this particular food. But, you know, how do we actually consider this cultural component? Right? Because what is taste good to me from, you know, coming from Venezuela might not taste as good to my Mexican husband. Right? So we we need to also take that into consideration. And when it comes to our sense of taste and in particular, you know, and it's also exposure, right? You have people who are born in areas where they, they eat a lot of spicy foods and, you know, they it tastes good for them. It smells good to them. And you have others that cannot tolerate it at all. So, you know, I just wanted to sort of put those two, those two concepts together because I think they're very important that even in the work that we do. Going back to Eli's point in terms of like, how do we do this work, what are the things that we're interested in understanding? We interested in understanding this individual variability is, you know, why do we eat what we eat? Why you know, how our sensory system impacts the decisions that we make when we have something in front of us when it comes to food. But we also need to take into consideration, you know, socioeconomic diversity that happens, right? Like sometimes exposure is not just exposure, because, you know, I don't want to eat something, but it's also, you know, food deserts. That's all you have, right? So there's a lot of things to tease out here. So yeah I hope that helps. Yeah. The food deserts part makes me think about there's this content creator and what he does is he he walks around New York City, he waits outside of McDonald's, and he's trying to get people to eat healthier. So he offers them a free meal if they decide not to eat at McDonald's. And he takes them to a healthier place, and the amount of people that seem like they're addicted to McDonald's and they're like, no, the food doesn't. I don't like the taste of healthy food is so fascinating to me because I'm like, I do think it touches on the point that you made where people don't have exposure to things. So the smell and maybe even the look of it is like salmon. You know, if you're not somebody maybe who eats salmon regularly, it might not be something. The smell and the look doesn't appeal to you. But it's it's fascinating because now I'm thinking about how big of a role early exposure plays, like somebody who's never had caviar might look at it and just be like, oh, what is you know, it's just not something that their palate has, has gotten used to. So, you know. Yeah. So I think you brought up such a good point. No, no. Great. I just didn't want to lose this train of thought because your chance reminded me of something as well. So talking about early exposure. So they there was a study that was done by, one of like one of my mentors of the Julie Mainland with the Chemical Sciences Center very early on and where they gave, I want to say was, I want to say onions or carrot juice, I will I will get the detail of that particular study. But early to the prime and mothers. Right. And then they follow the kids afterwards. So they really just kind of showing what early exposure have in utero and how that developmentally also impacts our taste perception. Right. And so there's ways that we can change this. But we do need to, you know, at the end of the day, it's like it's going to be a lot of access and education. And that's why I think that this particular conference where we're having this discussion about, you know, food as, as medicine, you know, considering the food is health and food is life. Yes. And how do we get more people exposed to very healthy options? How do we make food varying Tyson to healthy food enticing, you know, to kids and others. And yeah, so there's there's a lot of very interesting questions here. Whole program of research. I'm always I'm always intrigued that some of the foods that that are healthy, they smell bad, but they can taste good and some foods and it goes the other way around where some foods that, you know, they they smell good, but they can taste nasty as well. I wonder if that's something that can also, you know, because we say that the mind can play tricks on us as well in terms of what we similar, what we what we taste and what we eat as well. I wonder if that's if that, if that's, you know, a not not true statement, but it's a correlation or some form of a positive relationship of the, you. Know, you know, like that. Do you mean like it smells good but taste good or. Yeah, smell it smells good. Taste bad. And foods that that smell bad but tastes good. Like durian. Like durian, for example. Yeah. Like durian is. 00:23:09:01 - 00:23:09:22 Dr. Janice Gassam Asare Like. It's so durian. Is this Asian fruit that, you know, for the most part is it smells pretty bad. So is this like, it's this food that has this little spiky things? When you go. In my mind, I'm thinking, I know what. Yeah, yeah. So it's South Asian. It's like. Is it yellow? It's yellow. Yellow. Okay, I know exactly it. You know, and it's very infamous for it's just really pungent order. You know, often these most people compare it to like sulfur, onions, sewage. It's really like the smell is very interesting. But despite the smell, it's creamy sweet. It has this complex flavor. You know, I remember my first time trying it. I was like, oh, like, I, I couldn't pass that that smell, but, you know, like, then once I did, it was just delicious. He has like notes of vanilla caramel almond is super nutritious. Honestly. It's like it's delicious. But it goes back to what Eli said. Just this. The smell of it might stop you from really trying something new. So I think that there's a there's a lot to say here in terms of options regarding food. I read this book years ago because, Dr. Joseph, you don't know this about me, but I have a really, really bad sweet tooth. So I am like, Cinnabon is like my favorite thing in the whole world, and I'm always trying to figure out ways to not eat sweets because I just, I love sweets, and I read this book about food scientists, how they engineer the taste of of these items to have just the right amount of salt, salt, just the right amount of sugar, and how they do make it addictive for people because of the combinations. And it's just you taste something and you're like, this is heaven. And in the book it talks about how when you walk into a mall, because I feel like there's Cinnabon at every mall you walk in, you smell the Cinnabon for miles and miles and miles away, you can be on a different side of the mall and you smell. The smell is what really brings you in. So I don't see these companies being incentivized to, because the smell is what draws you in and makes you want to eat something. So I don't see how, you know if someone had something that wasn't healthy, you want the smell to draw people in. So I think it's difficult. I'm thinking from like an obesity standpoint, what what makes people want to eat something, maybe, is that combination of the smell that's bringing them in, and then they take the taste. And so I'm just thinking from that standpoint, I don't see why, as a company, I would be incentivized to make it smell bad because people wouldn't want to eat. People want it because they smell it. It smells good. Yeah. But I think that, you know, good, delicious food also smells good, right. Like so. So I think it just goes back to, you know, I want to put a big plug for like sort of like education, right. Like how do you know. Just, you know, green leaves, vegetables for the most part is they taste better right. They taste better. But you can make a combination of, of salads that are just so delicious that you don't even perceive the, the bitterness on it. Right? So I mean, I'm just thinking about let's go to what's your favorite holiday win food. Got it. Christmas. Christmas I love Thanksgiving. Yeah I got to go in Christmas because it's my birthday. So but I like things but like, you know, I mean I would go with Thanksgiving for Janice. Right? Not my favorite holiday because there's too much food and there's too much smells going on. But think about it like the food, for the most part that you're cooking is pretty healthy, right? Hopefully. So you know then. But it smells good. So it's I think it's more of like, you know, how do we create spaces where they are healthy foods that also are delicious and that sort of appeal to our sensory system. Right. So yeah. So there's a lot of things here. And I don't know if I have like a little a chance to just add something because we we talked a little bit about memory. So I'm since we're talking about the holidays and our favorite holidays bring a lot of memories and most of it is attached to food. You know, the sense of smell is the only sense in the human body that bypasses the thalamus. So it goes straight from the olfactory bulb into the limbic system, so into the amygdala and the internal cortex. So that's why a single whiff of and off like your, you know, that favorite food that you might have, might take you back to your grandmother's kitchen? You know, when a force sort of visual memory, like, where maybe a visual memory really rarely has. So it is it is the same, like anatomy. That explains why smell loss is the least early signal that we have for assignments and Parkinson's. But, I think that that was just, like, sort of important to just kind of bring back why smell is so powerful, right? It's like it's just really attached to a lot of memories, good memories and also bad memories, because we can just make it all sound good. Right? So you can think about patients that might have PTSD. I had a patient at one point where that fought in the war and just couldn't really be around certain orders because it would bring them back to that particular period of time. Right. So there is a lot to think about smell. So going back to your question earlier, it's like we just completely ignore it. Like we just don't think too much about it. Now I want to talk about the Guggenheim Fellowship. Yeah. That's know like switching gears. Yeah, the Guggenheim Fellowship, I believe they were taking you to write. They take it to Oaxaca and you're basically studying indigenous foods. I wanted you to talk about that experience. And, you know, that study. And also, how does that connect to what you're working on in terms of what you know, whether it's your book, research papers? I want to talk about that for for a second. No, I you know, first of all, I'm just very grateful to to the Guggenheim Foundation for, for believing in this project that I'm about to share with you. So the Guggenheim project, I developed it to really understand it's more about chemo sensory traditions that have been refined over thousands of years that have never really appeared in US nutrition databases. So in what I'm working, when when one of my colleagues and also TED fellows, Germán Santillán, who is this mistake chocolatier, you know, who is an expert on cacao. And of course, being from Venezuela, I am so excited because I love chocolate. So you know who's really going to be? We're going to be looking at how cacao processing and ritual food practices shape or factory experience as well, and metabolic health. So, you know, one of the things that that we don't really think too much about is these indigenous practices that have happened when cacao, when coffee and, and how all of that have maybe changed how they, you know, climate change might be affecting our soil and therefore affecting the taste of, you know, our favorite things like cacao. So I was really interested in taking this anthropological approach. I am not an anthropologist. So we know one of the things that it gives you is the opportunity to do something, expand your research, or expand a question around your area of research that what are you going to learn a new skill? So for me, it was very, very important to do this sort of like immerse myself in the community, immerse myself in this indigenous communities. So I'll do what. But I'm also going to be doing Guatemala. So like doing what? What am I, India as well? Just, you know, kind of like the one of the centers for a lot of, of, you know, things regarding smell. So this really connects to the book for which I just got a contract for when hay House. So I'm very excited to share that with you. Congratulations. Do you know when it will be coming out, or do you have an approximate release date? I think I think my release date is going to be end of 2027. If and if I'm if I'm not mistaken. So we just happened. So you guys this is like fresh. And exclusive. You know. So you know that at its core, the argument is that smell and taste of food are not just about life accessories. They're more they're important. They're medicine that humans have been refining since before language was written. You know, when I trace olfactory ritual across China, Mesoamerica, Egypt, Mesopotamia and Rome, you know, you can see how different civilizations understood something about, you know, about smell around taste. And these are the things that, you know, some a different dimension from what I do in the lab, but it still ties into the work. And yeah, so I'm really excited to sort of mix science, the science of smell and taste when the story and kind of sort of bring, you know, to the public why, you know, again, why this is important and how why is has been so important across generations and across, you know, different communities around the world. I since we're talking about, you know, centuries of tradition here and we fast forward to today and we talk about AI, artificial intelligence. Right. We are going into ChatGPT or Google Gemini or Cloud or meta AI to basically self-diagnosis with what's going on. If something is wrong with our stomach or something smells bad, we go to chat to figure out what's going on. Do you think first I want to get your thoughts on on, you know, whether AI is doing a disservice or is it a beneficial application for us? And if AI is starting to tell us what to eat? How do you make sure that it respects our cultural traditions? Oh, that's a that's a that's a fascinating question. You know, I guess when I think about AI, I think about I think about statistics and large language models and all algorithms. Right? So what we put into it is what we it's going to be literally spit out to us. And I'm just thinking I think AI could be helpful. You know, but we need to think about ways to democratize AI. Not everybody has access. And and even when we have access, is everyone unrepresented, right. So I think that those are the questions that I see a lot of people in the community sort of gravel in, in. And if we think about move that into your point about food, you know, I'm not even sure if like there are recipes from my indigenous communities in here, right. Like, I don't know, I have not even looked. But I think it it goes back to, you know, for me as a scientist to stop and ask those questions. You know, if I'm going to be using this platform, I'm is the group is my question going to be comprehensive? And I think this is why, you know, thinking about anthropological research, right. Going into that community, going to talk to the people, kind of getting the the the sauce is extremely important. And to keep that in mind as we move our research and our questions through this artificial intelligence sort of world. So I don't think AI is bad, it's just how we use it. And, you know, we we use an AI for a very long time. Right? If you had any big data set and you had to do some analysis, you needed a large language model to help you sort of make sense of that data. So I think it's just sort of language is very important. And how we, how we categorizing these different things is also something we need to think about. I have another question when it comes when it. Comes to when it comes to the, you know, speaking of large language models and AI, and we think of spreadsheets, right? Spreadsheets are the things that we typically use Excel spreadsheets I want to and this is more so if it's technical question for you, I want to get your, you know, your insights on what is one thing that spreadsheets can tell us that doctors in patients or what is one thing that they can tell us in terms of, you know, whether it's color coded or character, you know, characteristic traits that, you know, that may lead to some certain study that may be cited from certain studies. But what is one thing a spreadsheet can never tell a doctor about a patient's health? I think the emotion, you know, there I think that I go back, you know, as a nurse, I have the honor and privilege of being when people from, you know, birth to death sometimes. Right. Like many nurses do, we sit when the patient's we hear their stories. And I think one of the things that I often say is that even when we look at those spreadsheets, we cannot forget the human behind the data. Right there are there is a human being behind every number. There's an emotion, there's a family. There is. There's a complex individual. Right. That, behind that particular data point. And, and I think that this goes back to the core of what we do, which is spend time with patients, you know, hear the stories. That's why, you know, one of the the most privileged thing we can have as clinicians is sitting down and hearing, you know, how is your symptoms going? What is happening? Are you even taking your medication? Can you actually afford your medication? Right. If we don't spend time asking those questions or listening to the challenges, or maybe not even challenges, maybe everything is fine when it comes to access to their meds. But maybe there's another challenge when in the family dynamics, right, that might be impacting that person. So even when we look at this at the spreadsheets, we always have to remember the human and the soul behind that data. As far as you know, your research and what you do, which is remarkable. I want to fast forward to next year, in two years. Right. Let's say, you know, listener who's listening to this podcast episode, right? And they're intrigued with what you're doing, and they read your book. That's that's bound to come out soon. What is one idea or one key takeaway that a reader or a listener would, would take away from not only your body of work, but the research that you have done behind, you know, sensory and and taste. I will say that one message would be, you know, to pay attention to your sense of smell, pay attention to the way maybe food is changing in terms of taste, right? Not to dismiss these senses just because we take them for granted as we go on the our day to day, you know, they are they tell us a lot. They're like a window into our brains and it's they're so important. So next time that you are sitting at a restaurant or around the table, just take an extra second and and smell that coffee, right? That tea, smell that food. Take time when you're cooking, you know, you're taking the spices out of the cabinet. Don't just throw you just you just know it's it's onion powder. But, you know, just don't just take the on just take a chance to say, okay, does it even smell like onion powder? Just the intentionality behind just stopping. You know, we often say stop and the roses sounds cliche, but really, truly stop and smell because you start noticing these changes. And just to give you like just a super quick example, you know, we often told, don't go back and read the comments on your on your, on your talk. So on, on, you know, on social media and things like that. But you know, I actually do the opposite. I go back and, you know, especially for my Ted talk and my Ted talk, I, I go back and read people's comments because I think they're very insightful. And, you know, whether they're, you know, like most of most of them are positive, but their stories there and the story has been the same, like, you know, as I shared about my mother in law, who started cooking with more salt than more sugar, and how we discovered that she was having this, you know, frontotemporal dementia later on. You know, I see comments from from people that said, you know, now that I think about it, my my mother, my grandmother, when, you know, I noticed those changes to but I just attributed it to old age, I didn't know. Right. So people were already noticing, right? What, what just what I just told you they were not the same, these changes. They just didn't have the language and and the knowledge to know that these changes were actually real. And they were telling us a lot more about ourselves and our body. So that would be my message. Just, you know, pay attention and and, you know, hopefully in a couple of years we'll have smell tests in every doctor's office, just like we do pain and hearing, just like we do for our kids. Right, Jan? It's like, you know, they get a hearing test, they get a vision test. Nobody's getting their smell test done. So can we change that? And that's one of my goals. I'm so curious, with your vast amount of knowledge, do you think there's anything we can do to improve our sense of smell or our sense of taste? You did talk about this idea of slowness and taking time to, you know, most of us I know when I'm eating, I'm eating quickly because I have to do I'm not tasting the food. So the idea of being more slow and intentional. But do you think of somebody who studies this? There's anything else we can do to maybe increase our sense of taste or our sense of smell? You, Janice, do you want to become a wine connoisseur? I would love to. I know. I mean, that's a perfect example right there, right? Like, people are just not born just only with that ability to be able to master all these notes. Right? When it comes to even wines. Right. Like that's training. You need to train yourself. So even when we talk about slowing down, to savor, to to save our food, to smell our food, to to just perceive the flavor of things, it's the same, right? It's like even if you buy, even if you get a candle and you burn a candle in your house. Of course we have habituation. Our sense of smell habituate to things. That's why you need to be intentional, right? If you burn in one of those things in your house right now, you probably even forgot that I was there. So that's actually a biological mechanism behind it. But again, it's kind of we need to kind of put it in our mind and said, okay, let me, let me even if you got your flowers for Mother's Day, oh, did you stop today and actually smell them? Did you, did you actually went back and say, okay, let me see what this flower smells like today. And most people don't, right. So it's that, oh, they look so pretty. What does it smell like? You know. So I think that that's extremely important. So yes, we can do these things. And they're also very important because it also helps our cognitive our cognition. There's been some studies out in Australia showing the that correlation between, you know, cognitive, you know, cognitive health and olfaction because we really have a lot of cognitive demand. Right. You're going to have a lot of things to remember, you know, is this chicken smelling. This does the way this pepper chicken is supposed to be smelling or something else. Right. Or even your fish or something like that. So it has a lot of demand. Knowing carious. If your research is so fascinating. Now, a thought that literally popped into my head now I'm like, can a smell actually change a person's mind or persuade a person to do something? Like if you if you put on a certain scent, or if somebody I don't know has fond memories of their grandmother making chocolate chip cookies, and you are walking into a business meeting and you want to convince someone of something if you if you have a smell of chocolate, would that make them more? Now I'm like so curious about. So yeah, no, I mean I don't ask good questions, right? I mean, like, you know, you know, can you modulate behavior and the brain based on different orders? And I'm sure there's been people that have looked into this into but again, like, you know, I'd be very careful on how these things are applied. But I mean, let's let's use an example like if you're going to even if it's like a business dinner, right? There's going to be food. There's certain ambiance that gets developed because, you know, it is different, right? Like how people come in and especially if there's good food, you know, you might feel a certain way, you might make certain decisions based on on that. So I'm sure like there's something to it in terms of like the rigor of the research, I'm not necessarily certain, but I'm going to actually go look it up because this was actually a very good tart. You know, it. Was because now then people could kind of weaponize, smell and say, oh, if I want to convince someone of something and I know it's individual, everyone is different. So you'd have to know the person. And. You know, one of my one of my colleagues, Allie, looks she's out of in the UK. So she's actually she studied the politics of smell and she's going to have a book out next year. So, you know, one of the things that we talked about and this is again, the other parts of of action, right, like we am talking about in the context of health, but you cannot separate the cultural connotations that might be that might happen. Right. Like how you can make weaponize an order and attribute it to an entire community. Right. And I think I wrote I think I wrote a little bit about that recently. That is important that we that we think about that notion as well, right? That we don't necessarily attribute a certain particular order to an entire population right of and that we seen that happens over the years. And even if we go back to, and I won't go too much into details, but I'll just put this into your mind. Right. Like if we think about slavery and go back into history, I like history, right. So you can think in terms of let's go to even the Bible, right? Like biblical figures. And you know how one of the things I'm fascinated in is how orders have been described in religious texts. Right. And you can see those dimensions. Right. But often you see as well that even in when it comes to House of worship, this smells right, that right. And incense does something. So think about there's a reason why there's incense at a in, you know, in religious space places. Right. Because you will now put associate that order to a practice. Right. So when you, when I, when I smell a particular instance, it takes me into a temple, right. Or in text me into a church. Right. So there's a, there's a lot of these themes from a societal perspective as well that happens. And I think those conversations are extremely important. I know when Abercrombie and Fitch, they were known to spray some sort of scent so that every time people walked by they would associate that scent with, and I don't know if there was research on whether that influenced buyer behaviors, but I wonder, I'm sorry. I have that. As of no idea. Honestly, I didn't even know that, that example. But thanks for letting me know. Like, you know, there's so much out there that sometimes I, you know, like coming to this type of shows because I learn from the host and they tell me all kinds of stuff. And then I have a whole new research study that Janice just wrote for me, I love it. I also wanted to to ask, is there any? Because I know that there may be some correlation between the sense of smell and politics, but it can also be a correlation between the sense of smell and social commentary, right? Sometimes you can smell the person commentating on what you're doing. Right. You may ask, does, you know, does that person commenting smell good based on what he or she is saying? I wonder if that's that's possible to to study. Yeah. You know, and that's interesting. I think that, you know, especially when I talk, I talk about the politics of smell. I'm talking more in the perspective of like the social, cultural component of it. But you know, I guess I guess so, like, I, you know, like, there's people who do that. I'm not necessarily sure, but you can think about this, and this is why this is why I'm really looking forward to to Alice book and what she's going to be sharing, because I think it's going to be really interesting, you know, to have that other perspective. But there's been other anthropologists that have really describe this phenomena, right? Like, you know, even when when you go there was a globe, I think it was in the UK when the smells of the world. And I'm going to send you that, the link to it, it was it happened a few years ago, but it might be interesting to the audience members to take a look at it, and then people might choose a country and they will and they it will emit the order of that particular country. So every country was associated with a smell, and I'm pretty sure this was not French fries on something. So like but. But I think it was it just was a fascinating project. You know, that. We. It gets it gets to think of, make us think about a smell in a particular in a different way. But yeah. No, this is cool. Really cool. Questions. Guys. I have one last question. I normally asked this question in for my guest here for students or professors or academics, practitioners here who are interested in your work or who aspire to be neuroscientists here, what is one key skill that you think they should either adapt or have in order for them to be successful? You know, I would say, you know, I think about three things. First, you know, right. The work in your own voice before someone else writes, writes it down for you. I learned this the hard way. You know, when you do, when you do work that travels well, you know, it's important that you publish, that you speak about it, that you share your work, just like we're doing today. And and I'm really grateful for this opportunity because it's doing exactly that that I believe. And then also giving, giving it gives people an opportunity to sort of think about working in different ways. The other thing I would say is that find good mentors, mentors and sponsors and don't be afraid of asking people to mentor you. If you are someone you know, I did that all the time. I still do that. Or will you mentor me? Half of the time people don't say no. So, yeah, actually a lot of times people don't say no, but I think it's. Just. That's extremely important. And I will also say, you know, be generous and honest and have integrity. You know, if something doesn't work the way that you expected, it's okay. Even negative information, negative data is good data, I can tell it gives us direction and and that's important. And that also also helps a lot as we're building, you know, our reputation as scientists. And so I would I would say that those I mean often those are categorized as soft skills. But if you tell me those are hard skills, you know, we can learn the lab, we can learn some of the other things. But I think that connection with people and it's it's extremely important. And that's something that needs to be cultivated very early on and reach out to people. Just reach out. Like if you, you know, if you're a student, you are young nurse or your student that is listening to this podcast and you're hearing this podcast right now and you're thinking, can I reach out to her? The answer is yes. Right then. And there will be like the contact information. But you know, what's the worst that can happen? The worse is that if you never reached out. Wow. Well, Dr. Joseph, we appreciate you. Thank you so much for joining us and for all your insights. It was so great to meet you, and I can't wait for your book to come out. I'll let you guys know when it comes out, and then maybe I'll come back here. And. Yeah, and they will will do a whole conversation and go deeper into Eli's questions about the the fellowship and what I'm doing. But in the meantime, I will tell you, just anytime you smell a little bit of chocolate, think about me. Yeah, I love that because I love chocolate. So thank you so much. This is the academic boardroom and we are signing out right now. [Theme Music] scholar and a business minded soul. We at the academic forum. Yeah, we keeping it 100. If you're looking for the truth. Well, you finally found it. Take a seat at the head. Let the dialog flow. It's a masterclass. Five. If you did it now you know.