Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Commercial Credit Culture: What Is It and Why It Is So Important
Transcript
- 0:00We're not here just to say yes or no to loans.
- 0:02We're here to provide the right financing for that borrower.
- 0:04Hey everyone, this is Mark with a special Archive episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:10I hope you enjoy.
- 0:11Do you want to maximize your success with NCUA?
- 0:15Join Mark Treichel as he shares with you the insider's view on passing
- 0:18your exam with Flying Colors.
- 0:21The With Flying Colors podcast is sponsored by Credit Union
- 0:24Exam Solutions by Mark Treichel.
- 0:26If you would like to work directly with the Credit Union Exam Solutions
- 0:29team and receive support to optimize your results with NCUA so you save time
- 0:34and money, visit us at marktreichel.
- 0:36com to find out more.
- 0:38Hello, I'm Mark Treichel, and you are listening to With Flying Colors,
- 0:43the podcast where I interview subject matter experts to provide credit
- 0:48union leaders with tips on how you can achieve success with NCUA and also
- 0:53pass your exam with flying colors.
- 0:57Today, I'm excited to say that I'm joined by Vin Vieten to
- 1:02talk about credit culture.
- 1:03Before we jump in for folks who are just meeting you for the first time,
- 1:07could you share a little bit about who you are and your career and the
- 1:12experiences you had in that career?
- 1:15Sure, Mark.
- 1:16I am a retired senior credit specialist from the NCUA, I
- 1:23had worked there for 11 years.
- 1:25I retired last February, but prior to that, I was a commercial banker
- 1:30and senior loan officer through in New Hampshire for a lot of years.
- 1:35And then also I had the.
- 1:38good fortune to work in industry as a controller to a large
- 1:44already mixed concrete company.
- 1:47So through that I've learned an awful lot about commercial credit,
- 1:51working with borrowers, working in good times and bad times.
- 1:56And so I was a lender.
- 1:59I was actually a borrower when I worked for the concrete company.
- 2:02And I also then was a regulator.
- 2:05So I like to say I worked on all three sides of the desk and enjoyed
- 2:09each of those experiences as it gave me good perspective in the overall
- 2:12commercial lending world and process.
- 2:15Well, then I know that when you and I have been on the calls with some of my
- 2:18clients and you've walked through having been on all three sides, and that's
- 2:22not something that everybody at NCOA.
- 2:25Was able to say, and like for me, for example, I had 33 years at NCOA,
- 2:30essentially came right out of college and now out consulting in the world.
- 2:34I'm working with credit unions and adding that second leg of experience,
- 2:39but there's one thing I remember you saying in some of our discussions when
- 2:43you were at the, the concrete place.
- 2:45I remember you, there's this conversation you had with maybe
- 2:49the owner where he talked through.
- 2:51His responsibilities, like to the families that, that worked at the, at that company.
- 2:56Would you care to walk through that example here for our listeners?
- 3:00Yeah, sure.
- 3:00I'd love to, because it was, that was a very special experience because I
- 3:04was fortunate to work for an individual who, whose focus was his company, but
- 3:10his focus was on his company because he wanted to provide the best product
- 3:13and service to his customers, and he wanted to treat his employees fairly.
- 3:17So it was a great place to work and get real perspective.
- 3:20To what the value of what small business in this case, it was more
- 3:24closer to a medium sized business does for not only the community,
- 3:29their customers and their employees.
- 3:31So that was really great.
- 3:32But one day he was at one point he used to smoke and he was a
- 3:36very busy guy and to get his attention, he'd always come into my.
- 3:43Office.
- 3:43I didn't smoke.
- 3:44And he'd say, Hey, Vincent, you need a cigarette, which meant we were
- 3:46going out on the porch, which is where he'd have a cigarette and I could
- 3:50finally talk to him about all the things I wanted to talk to him about.
- 3:53So I was very excited one day.
- 3:54And as we were out there and we were watching truck.
- 3:59Let's go back and forth.
- 4:00He had 21 locations.
- 4:01So we were at the main location.
- 4:03So there were a lot of trucks going back and forth, pickup
- 4:05trucks and concrete trucks.
- 4:08And he looked at me as one of the trucks went by and he said, Hey,
- 4:11Vincent, I've got to buy groceries for 300 families every Friday.
- 4:16And boy, did that, that hit me.
- 4:18I understood that.
- 4:20But when he said it, I thought, wow, that's even a bigger responsibility
- 4:24than guaranteeing a loan.
- 4:25He's made a commitment to these people.
- 4:28If they perform certain tasks during the week, he was going to pay them.
- 4:32And there was never a problem paying them, but I realized, so what we do is lenders.
- 4:38Is very important because it even goes beyond the owner.
- 4:41It goes down to the employees and we should have fun doing our job
- 4:46lending money and enjoy doing it.
- 4:49But at the same time, realize how important it is and
- 4:52how many people it impacts.
- 4:54So that was that was just a great experience.
- 4:56Yeah, it sounds like it and it stuck with me when you've said that.
- 4:59And it's as regulators.
- 5:02And having only served as a regulator, you often can lose sight of that.
- 5:06It's what's the regulation say, how do you button everything up?
- 5:09And sometimes that by buttoning everything up, you can eliminate too many risks.
- 5:13And at the end of that equation, there are families that need to be
- 5:16fed and in the middle is the lender.
- 5:18So it's really, again, you've done all of those things, which really
- 5:21brings you a neat perspective.
- 5:22And, and so I, I'm, I'm lucky to be able to have you on so that we can
- 5:27share that here with the audience.
- 5:29So let's jump in.
- 5:30But just a quick comment, Mark, if you don't mind.
- 5:33And that's what made, I want to talk about NCOA a little bit.
- 5:36What, so I had, I had these experiences, which being an old guy, I got to go
- 5:42through plenty of good and bad times.
- 5:44I saw real estate booms and busts and businesses struggle
- 5:48and businesses be successful.
- 5:50So it was, I always appreciated the opportunity then to finish my career last
- 5:5711 years at NCOA where I could share a lot of what I'd learned over time and how
- 6:04important again, I'm repeating myself, but how important commercial lending is.
- 6:09And what we do and how it impacts other people.
- 6:12So that was a lot of fun.
- 6:13Those 11 years I had at, at the agency working directly with credit unions.
- 6:18I went out on a lot of exams and then also using experiences to regulation
- 6:23that made sense and was appropriate and also provide other guidance.
- 6:28So that was a lot of fun.
- 6:29I was, I always was so thankful.
- 6:32That I was able to finish my career by sharing all the
- 6:34things that I learned over time.
- 6:36And I was thankful and we were thankful that you were there and you're being
- 6:39modest, you did do, you mentioned the regulation and you had a heavy influence
- 6:42on the last version of the regulation.
- 6:45Uh, you also influenced NCUA by training NCUA staff on commercial landing.
- 6:50All right.
- 6:51That's a great background to let the audience know where you come
- 6:55from and the journey you've had.
- 6:57So let's, let's talk a little bit.
- 7:00about today's topic, which specifically is commercial credit culture.
- 7:05And with that, Vin, I'm just going to, I'm going to ask
- 7:07you, what is Commercial credit.
- 7:09That's a great question because I think if you asked a hundred people,
- 7:13you'd get a hundred different answers.
- 7:15It's one of those things to also to, you know, it when you see it, but
- 7:20essentially what did credit culture is your approach to providing credit
- 7:26to your customers, your members.
- 7:27I did say customer, didn't I thought I got rid of that 12 years ago.
- 7:31But for the members and it's something that starts and.
- 7:37Well, what it does is follow your institution's values and mission
- 7:44applied through the credit.
- 7:46And it's going to be how you approach the credits, what your goals are
- 7:51with the credits, what your risk tolerance is, your risk and other.
- 7:55For word for that is risk appetite, which is a whole nother discussion, although it
- 8:00overlaps very much into credit culture.
- 8:03So it's how you're going to, why you're providing commercial financing and, and
- 8:08then really how you're going to do it.
- 8:10And that's a good definition.
- 8:13So why does a credit union have a credit culture?
- 8:19I think you have a credit culture.
- 8:20So, You can provide thorough and consistent credit to your membership and,
- 8:31and, and consistence really important.
- 8:33It's if you have people out there, your people meeting lending staff
- 8:38that are just lending based on how they feel about the credit is going
- 8:43to be a hodgepodge of credit and very inconsistent service to the membership.
- 8:49It it's going to outline your whole philosophy.
- 8:51And in fact, I was thinking about it.
- 8:54And a good example I can give you about credit culture, believe it
- 8:57or not, NCOA has a credit culture.
- 9:00They do.
- 9:01And it's reflected in the new rule that was put into place in January
- 9:08of 2017, but where you're going to understand the credit culture.
- 9:13Is if you read through the preambles to the proposed rule that came out in
- 9:17July of 2015 and the, the final rule, which was February of 2016, I think,
- 9:24but the, the preamble outlines what.
- 9:28NCUA thinks how credit should be provided.
- 9:32And to say it in a nutshell, would, would credit, the credit culture at NCUA
- 9:39is obviously for the credit unions to provide safe and sound credit, but its
- 9:45approach should be fulfilling its Its mission as a credit union of providing
- 9:53thorough and accurate credit member service, meaning if you read through the
- 10:00preamble, the constant theme is you're providing credit, uh, in a, by being very
- 10:08thorough and understanding your borrower.
- 10:10And the reason you do that is so that you understand the borrower's needs and
- 10:15what that, that thoroughness requires, knowing the borrower's business, knowing
- 10:19the borrower themselves, and also Have a very good understanding of the financial
- 10:25condition and trends of the business and the member that By understanding that
- 10:33you're going to be providing financing that's appropriate for the borrower,
- 10:41meaning it will be within their, it will be properly structured based on its
- 10:45purpose and collateral, and it will be in the ability of the borrower again.
- 10:52That would then the ability to borrow be in the repayment ability of the
- 10:56borrower, and the important word there is properly structured because that will
- 11:01obviously be structured appropriately for the assets securing it and the
- 11:05needs, not just structured so that they can make the payments and, and
- 11:10if they can't make the payments on a properly structured loan, then obviously
- 11:13you need to have to take some time.
- 11:15To explain that to the borrower and how they should approach maybe future
- 11:20requests with the credit union.
- 11:22And in other words, the philosophy at NCUA is, is good customer
- 11:26borrower service so that they can provide appropriate and appropriate
- 11:31financing to safe and sound lending.
- 11:34So there's a lot there to unpack.
- 11:36And I wrote down a couple of the keywords, but you pointed the listeners
- 11:40to the preamble and just in general, I always found reading the preamble On
- 11:46any regulation, as it shows the intent of the board, it can almost be more
- 11:50revealing than actually reading the actual language of what you can and you can't do.
- 11:54Cause they'll give examples.
- 11:55Like you say, whatever regulation you're looking at or thinking about,
- 11:59whether it's commercial lending, whether it's the investment regulation,
- 12:03read the preamble, go online there.
- 12:05They're easy to find if you type in the right keywords, but you'll
- 12:08learn as much about a regulation in the preamble, as you will in the
- 12:12actual language of the regulation.
- 12:14So.
- 12:15Appropriate for the borrower.
- 12:16Sometimes borrowers will come in and be asking for things
- 12:20that they think they need.
- 12:21And it sounds like you're saying that, that when you have a good credit culture,
- 12:28you, the, the lenders, the commercial lenders can actually guide them.
- 12:33Into understanding what makes sense for them to ask for what might not make sense
- 12:40and then also having consistency across across the membership for like type
- 12:44borrowings by interpreting that, right?
- 12:47Yes, and I think and I'm speaking from, of course, these are my thoughts
- 12:53regarding providing commercial credit.
- 12:56And in the credit union world outside of banking with the credit
- 13:00union mission being to provide service to their membership.
- 13:03I think there's an added responsibility that credit unions be very complete in
- 13:11their approach in evaluating commercial credit risk with the focus being on
- 13:18the best interest of the borrower.
- 13:21You know, providing credit is really a value added service.
- 13:25Some of the requests you get are pretty straightforward.
- 13:28It's good company, good cashflow.
- 13:30They know why they needed to borrow money.
- 13:32That's great.
- 13:33Others, they can't afford what they want to do and you have to make
- 13:37sometimes a tough decision there, but take the time to explain it to
- 13:40them why they may not be able to, you're not able to approve that loan.
- 13:45But the real, you really earn your money when a borrower comes in and
- 13:48says, look, I got a good company here, but I don't have any cash.
- 13:51What's going on?
- 13:52And you take some time.
- 13:54To evaluate what's going on with that business and realize that and help
- 14:01them identify where there could be some strain in their financials that
- 14:05are impacting their cash flow or their liquidity and take that time and explain
- 14:09it to him and then structure alone.
- 14:11That's appropriate.
- 14:12To help them fix it.
- 14:13And it's always, I feel, and that's part of your credit culture, right?
- 14:17So it's really important that you take the time, especially in the credit
- 14:21union world, seeing how we're not.
- 14:22You're not out there to satisfy stockholders.
- 14:25You're out there to satisfy that person across the desk from you
- 14:28is asking to borrow some money.
- 14:30That's a great differentiation.
- 14:32The member owner sitting across from you is different than maximizing
- 14:35the bottom line in a bank.
- 14:37So, so who's responsible or who establishes the, the credit unions credit?
- 14:41It really starts at the top, and there's a few different ways of looking at this.
- 14:47In my opinion, again, these are my opinions that I think it's
- 14:50very good for institutions to have that discussion internally.
- 14:54I'll talk about that in a minute, but it really starts out at the top with
- 14:57the board, the board sets the mission statement for the institution, the values
- 15:01of the institution, and then it's the senior management along probably with the
- 15:05board, uh, senior management of lending.
- 15:09To then create that credit culture within, within the institution by sharing
- 15:16those values of the board and mission of the board in the credit process.
- 15:20And I was thinking about this and I never did this, but I think this would be a fun
- 15:23exercise for a lot of credit unions is sometime bring your credit team together,
- 15:31the commercial credit team together and sit down to them and say, ask the
- 15:34question, do we have a credit culture?
- 15:37And obviously, hopefully they're going to say yes.
- 15:40And then ask them, what is that credit culture?
- 15:43And then have a discussion around the credit culture of your institution.
- 15:46So it's clear, then help make the message clear on what your, your expectations
- 15:52are in providing safe and sound and appropriate credit to your borrower.
- 15:57Uh, in fact, I'd love to sit on one of those conversations someday too.
- 16:01I'm looking back now.
- 16:01I never did that.
- 16:02I was a senior lender in two banks and I never did that with my staff.
- 16:05And I look back now and wish that I could, cause it would
- 16:07have been a great opportunity.
- 16:10To make sure we're all on the same page as we went out looking to find
- 16:15an ad to the commercial portfolio.
- 16:19But like I said, Mark, it really starts, there's the values of the institution
- 16:24and they then they are reflected into the credit, the credit culture.
- 16:29Of the institution.
- 16:31No, that makes sense.
- 16:32And of course, I don't have the regulation in front of me, but I'm, I'm pretty
- 16:35certain that the regulation would talk about the board need needing to
- 16:39approve the policies to comply with the regulation and as part of those policies,
- 16:44credit culture could be addressed.
- 16:46In those policies or separately in procedures, I would imagine.
- 16:49Yeah.
- 16:50And it's, it, and just in, in everyday activity, it's
- 16:55permeates through, but yeah.
- 16:57And I'll be the nerd here because I was involved with writing it.
- 17:00I don't worry.
- 17:01Yeah.
- 17:01You'll find good outlines for your credit culture to be in, in part
- 17:05seven 23 three, which is the board's responsibilities and senior management
- 17:10talking about the type of lender and the experience they should have.
- 17:14And then 723.
- 17:144, that's the regulation 723, commercial MBLs and commercial loans.
- 17:21And that outlines the procedures and process because you need to have good
- 17:25systems as part of a credit culture and good processes, well defined processes.
- 17:30Again.
- 17:31So you bring that consistency, what it does also.
- 17:36Is if you've got a good credit culture, those who are not as
- 17:41experienced but need to be involved with evaluating credit risk, meaning
- 17:45the board and sometimes other senior management that are not directly.
- 17:50involved with credit.
- 17:52If you have those good processes and consistent processes in place, then they
- 17:56get trained on how they should start at least at the level they're involved.
- 18:00You'll train them in how they can better understand the risk associated with those
- 18:04credits that they become involved with.
- 18:08Sure, sure.
- 18:08Yes, you mentioned systems and training.
- 18:10Part of that is the next thing I wanted to ask you relates to how do
- 18:14you implement the credit culture?
- 18:16You're going to start by having the systems and processes in place.
- 18:20Uh, you'll also be able to reflect it.
- 18:25In the training and education you provide, there should be a lot, there
- 18:29should always be training and education involved as the industry changes and
- 18:34the approaches changes to credit.
- 18:35I know in my long career, we shifted from just straightforward debt service
- 18:41funds available to support debt service to including important balance sheet
- 18:47components in our analysis also.
- 18:49So that was a, that's.
- 18:51Shifted many years ago when the beginning of my career, but it was
- 18:54important to stay trained in that.
- 18:56But mostly it's like I said earlier that you know, when you see it and if
- 19:03there's a good credit culture in your institution, you're going to have.
- 19:08A similar approach by your entire staff in providing that credit to your borrowers.
- 19:14I'm going to go down a rabbit hole here.
- 19:16So, you know, when you see it, it's more of an art than a science is
- 19:20what jumps into my head with that.
- 19:21And if I was hearing that maybe as a credit union, I think sometimes that
- 19:27dance of knowing when you see it can be a challenging part of the examination.
- 19:31Right.
- 19:32Because NCOA is asking questions and saying you need X, Y, and Z and the credit
- 19:38unions looking and saying our credit culture is this, and then the examiner
- 19:41refers back to the regulation, which was black and white words that, that may
- 19:46or may not mean a few different things, but can you speak to, to, does what I'm
- 19:53saying make sense and fit into this?
- 19:55I guess it probably fits into every aspect of commercial lending, but the credit
- 19:58culture piece is what we're talking about.
- 20:01And so you.
- 20:02It's an art.
- 20:03And so how do you regulate an art?
- 20:05I'll tell you, I think, hopefully the, the examiners are also familiar with
- 20:10the preambles and the rule itself.
- 20:12Great comment.
- 20:13And I think this is a, that's a good question, Mark.
- 20:15I hadn't given it any thought, but as a, as an answer.
- 20:20When we wrote the rule, there was a few of us involved.
- 20:24We decided to just, and at that time, instead of just being the MBL
- 20:28rule, we added commercial lending.
- 20:31The reason we added commercial lending is because there's a
- 20:37standard, there's a standard way of providing an accepted practices.
- 20:42For commercial lending.
- 20:43So if you read through the first the rule itself, but then you read
- 20:49through the preambles, you'll see that there's nothing revolutionary
- 20:53or revelationary in in that preamble.
- 20:59It was written for basic standard accepted commercial lending practice.
- 21:03So I think if you take the time and so what's in what the expectations
- 21:09of the bar of the examiners should.
- 21:14Be that you're using accepted, reasonable practices.
- 21:20In in providing commercial credit and evaluating commercial risk.
- 21:28If the examiner is, is not seeing that, then I think that's room for a discussion
- 21:34for both you and the examiner, not immediately acquiesce to the examiner,
- 21:38but have a thorough discussion about that.
- 21:41What you're doing makes sense.
- 21:43And you're properly evaluating the risk and that by doing, and by your process.
- 21:50You're providing appropriate financing for the borrower.
- 21:52I can't stress that enough.
- 21:54Appropriate financing for the borrower.
- 21:57That's really what your job is.
- 21:59And that means financing that is paid back within the ability that's structured.
- 22:07I want to say structured against properly structured financing.
- 22:12That's paid back through and within the financial ability of the borrower.
- 22:18Now that's good advice.
- 22:19And again, going back to the art of it, there's the discussion.
- 22:23There's the discussion between the examiner who may or may not be a
- 22:27commercial lending specialist and credit unions that do a lot of
- 22:29loans, a lot of commercial lending.
- 22:32They're typically going to have some specialists that are involved who
- 22:35have higher levels of training, which can raise bar of the conversation.
- 22:39But.
- 22:40And then you've got the credit union in the middle, and then you've got the
- 22:42member and oftentimes, again, going back to that art, it's a, it's a, it's
- 22:47about the quality of the questions, the quality of the policies, the
- 22:50quality of understanding, and then having a good dialogue with NCUA and
- 22:53not being afraid to say, Hey, where does the regulation require that?
- 22:57Why, where is it that.
- 22:59It says that's an acceptable, reasonable practice because we
- 23:02believe our practice is acceptable.
- 23:05And so the credit union should confidently believe that they can push
- 23:07back, but they also, with respect, should respect the knowledge, skills,
- 23:11and abilities of the examiners.
- 23:13There have been times, you know, where we've had clients that kind of wanted
- 23:16you or I to be part of that conversation just to make sure that what was being
- 23:21communicated As a necessity is really a necessity, sometimes credit unions, right?
- 23:26Sometimes the examiners, but having a good dialogue and good communication is how it
- 23:33works well towards getting a good exam.
- 23:35And it works well toward being able to serve your members as best you can.
- 23:39Right, and I'm glad you brought that up, Mark, because it reminds
- 23:43me of my early days within where I was out on a lot of exams.
- 23:48And it was interesting as we were talking to different credit
- 23:52unions about different issues.
- 23:54I constantly get the question, where does it say that?
- 23:57And I'm thinking, what?
- 23:58I don't understand that question.
- 24:00What do you mean?
- 24:00Where does it say that?
- 24:02And we all have to get away from that, including the examiners that we're not
- 24:05going to, there's no point to document.
- 24:08What we were talking about is evaluating commercial risk.
- 24:12So it's not a matter, it's not a, It's have you properly evaluated that
- 24:19risk and each deal is going to be different and the approach from each
- 24:23lender can be a little bit different.
- 24:25In fact, one of the things that should be allowed in credit culture is if you've
- 24:30got well trained and well experienced and competent lenders, they should have
- 24:35some freedom to use their judgment.
- 24:37If they do use their judgment, they should properly document in the credit
- 24:41proposal, why they're, maybe it's an exception to policy or for whatever
- 24:47reason that this is a judgment issue, not so much supported by straight facts
- 24:53and finances and that's the thing, but getting back to, so weird as it says
- 24:58that it doesn't say it anywhere, but a good experienced commercial lender knows.
- 25:03Whether the commercial risk has been properly analyzed and and I think that's
- 25:10As we do talk to credit unions now, and it is a lot of fun to be Again,
- 25:14working with the institutions directly, I think it's important to get that
- 25:18as if you're being challenged by the examiner, be able to support what you've
- 25:25done always be able as I last night, I got asked by somebody and I said, just
- 25:31be able to support what you've done.
- 25:32That's the important thing, which is saying is reasonable, but an examiner
- 25:37following the paint by numbers.
- 25:39Is not going to be comfortable with that.
- 25:41So be able to support that you appropriately understood the risk and
- 25:46did sufficient evaluation of that risk.
- 25:49So I was going to ask you about how do you reflect it in policy?
- 25:52I think we talked a little bit about that.
- 25:54Is there anything you want to add to what we've already said about credit
- 25:57culture and reflecting that in policy?
- 25:59Yeah, I think Again, the, the, the regulation itself explains pretty much
- 26:06what you should have in policy, which, you know, and that was a good news
- 26:09again, too, when we did issue that rule, there wasn't any objection to the
- 26:13preamble or to the rule text itself.
- 26:15For the most part, we made very slight changes, just fine tune some
- 26:18things when we issued the final rule.
- 26:21So what that says is, Overall, I think the industry agrees that as the
- 26:25regulations written, it makes sense.
- 26:29And then they should frame their policy around, around, I think what's in the
- 26:35regulation, which again is overall just accepted commercial loan practice.
- 26:40And if they have some unique situations, then or borrowers or
- 26:43industries that they service to be specific in their policy to that.
- 26:47But I think overall the policy itself.
- 26:52will reflect the credit culture, what your approach should be to evaluating the
- 26:57credit and how you evaluate that credit.
- 26:59So almost every word of the policy is part of the culture you're creating.
- 27:03It is.
- 27:03Yes, I think so.
- 27:04Okay.
- 27:05Got it.
- 27:05Tell me about, uh, credit culture relative to a credit proposal.
- 27:10If there's anything you'd like to add relative to that.
- 27:13Well, the credit proposals should again, that's enough.
- 27:17There should be consistency in the credit proposal.
- 27:21So hopefully the proposal itself will reflect again,
- 27:28getting back to what I believe.
- 27:29And again, this is me.
- 27:30What I believe should be part of the culture of a credit union should be
- 27:34consistent, but at the same time, document the full understanding.
- 27:39Of what the borrower is, what they do, what the loan purpose is, why
- 27:44it's structured, however, it's structured to purchase a fixed asset.
- 27:49That's pretty straightforward.
- 27:50But if you're providing lines of credit and other types of financing,
- 27:55some kind of cash advance, you should explain why you want to do that.
- 27:58And then of course the financial.
- 28:01Analysis itself should be thorough enough so that you do understand that
- 28:05the bar, the, the, the understand the trends of the borrow and also that
- 28:09the bar, this is appropriate for what the borrow's financial capability is.
- 28:15Got it.
- 28:15Got it.
- 28:16That makes sense.
- 28:18One more specific question about credit culture, how would you describe
- 28:23credit approach and credit actions as it relates to credit culture?
- 28:29Credit culture is the approach, isn't it?
- 28:31I think that's why you're providing the credit and how
- 28:35you're providing the credit.
- 28:36And so then actions would be really, to me, credit actions.
- 28:41Are the approvals and declinations.
- 28:45And also then you would obviously, there's probably another discussion
- 28:49is if you have a troubled credit, how you're going to approach that.
- 28:54Okay.
- 28:54No, that makes sense.
- 28:55And then just a quick comment about troubled credit.
- 28:59That's again, where you earn your money, that there's a lot of
- 29:02reasons why credits deteriorate and the borrowers have problems.
- 29:07And again, in a member service focused industry.
- 29:11I think that requires special attention also to scan that and do that balancing
- 29:18act for the needs of the borrower.
- 29:20But also in the end, it's the safety and soundness of your institution
- 29:24that from everything else.
- 29:27Got it.
- 29:28Got it.
- 29:29All right.
- 29:30I've been, as we've, as you and I have had some conversations with some
- 29:33of my clients, I really enjoyed the conversations, the credit union got value.
- 29:38You know, I learned a little bit more about commercial lending that then it's
- 29:40been a while since I actually flipped loans back when I was a problem case
- 29:43officer, but I've always enjoyed that part of, of what credit unions do.
- 29:48And our discussions with clients and some of my other folks that assist
- 29:52me was really what got me thinking that I, I would want to do this
- 29:57podcast because I think there's.
- 29:59There's inside baseball, if you will, that we can share with the credit union
- 30:03community that will help credit unions.
- 30:05And by helping the credit unions, it in turn will help NCOA.
- 30:08And in this particular interest in instant more than others, it
- 30:11actually helps the members as it relates to the loans that they, I,
- 30:14I always enjoyed commercial lending.
- 30:17I wanted, I wanted the other career I would have had, had
- 30:22I not chose, Lending money.
- 30:25I don't know if I chose it, but it had happened.
- 30:27It chose you.
- 30:28Would have been a guidance counselor and a football coach because your
- 30:31influence on people and helping them.
- 30:34I think commercial lending is as good an alternative or the
- 30:37next best alternative to that.
- 30:38Because if you do the business, if you do it right.
- 30:42You're working with, again, a business that has an impact on so much of the
- 30:47local economy, the employees, the customers and everybody else that
- 30:52it's take it, do the job as more as a consultant, as opposed to an authority.
- 30:59And I think it'll be a lot of fun for everybody and you'll
- 31:02find that you're providing good sound financing to businesses.
- 31:06I said, so Vin, this was great.
- 31:08I want to thank you for being my guest today.
- 31:10I'm going to talk through a couple other things that when you and I started
- 31:13talking about having you on the show here, you've put together some other
- 31:17topics that we're going to have coming.
- 31:18And I'm going to touch on those real quick for the listener.
- 31:21So we're going to have a topic on credit proposal.
- 31:25We're going to have a topic on underwriting, a topic on regular.
- 31:29Regulatory resources, a topic on credit risk rating systems.
- 31:34And this isn't one that you put on here, but it's 1.
- 31:36I want to have is a global cash flow because I know that a lot about that.
- 31:40I know credit unions get a lot of questions about that.
- 31:43And then so 2 other things for the listeners here.
- 31:47I listened to a lot of different podcasts and one of them that I
- 31:51like quite a bit answers follow up questions to previous podcasts.
- 31:55That's something I'm hoping to be able to do.
- 31:57So if there's anything that was raised in today's podcast that you have a
- 32:03follow up question on, I'm going to give you an email address where you can
- 32:06send that to me and then we can address those as add ons to future podcasts.
- 32:13So that's, , that's number one and then number two.
- 32:15To the listeners, if you'd like to talk to me about how VIN and I can assist you
- 32:19in your credit union, you can reach out to me at CU Exam solutions@marktrico.com.
- 32:28That's the LE you know CU for Credit Union CU Exam solutions@marktrico.com.
- 32:35Or you can reach me via my website, which is www.marktrical.com.
- 32:42Alright folks, that's it for today.
- 32:44I'm Mark Treichel, and I hope you join me again next time for With Flying Colors.
- 32:52Thank you for joining us on this episode of with flying colors, subscribe on
- 32:56your favorite podcast app to hear future episodes where subject matter experts
- 33:00of all varieties will provide tips on how to achieve success with NCUA.
- 33:04If you would like to learn more about how we assist credit unions, check
- 33:07out our services at marktreichel.
- 33:09com.