Latest / Dark Murder: True Crime Cases / Episode 115
Transcript
- 0:06Dark murder, true crime cases, kill five four three, two one one.
- 0:27Welcome back. I'm your host, Jordan Lee. I'm sure you are
- 0:31all ready to dive into some dark, creepy stories, so let's get started.
- 0:37On today's episode, we are going to delve into the serial slayer known
- 0:43as the Thriller Killer, a chilling nightmare of events that led to murder.
- 0:50The nightmare begins. Rick Poccaccio awoke early on the morning of August fourteenth,
- 0:57nineteen ninety three, to take the family dog out for a walk, as
- 1:02was their routine. However, on this occasion, instead of opening the door
- 1:07and being greeted by a new day, he was horrified to see his daughter
- 1:12tricious, brutalized form, lying crumpled on the back stoop. Dropping to his
- 1:19knees, the distraught father tried to render aid, but it soon became clear
- 1:26that she was already gone. The medical examiner would determine that she had been
- 1:32stabbed at least a dozen times in what appeared to be a killing frenzy.
- 1:38Her heart, lungs, abdomen, collarbone, and back had all sustained deep
- 1:45wounds, and her left arm was broken, indicating that she had struggled fiercely
- 1:51with her attacker to no avail. Skin samples from an unknown party were found
- 1:57underneath her fingernails and preserved for evidentiary purposes. Although there were no visible signs
- 2:04of rape, a sexual component to the crime could not be ruled out.
- 2:10Detectives learned that the eighteen year old, who had only recently graduated from high
- 2:15school, had spent the last night of her life participating in a scavenger hunt
- 2:22in her hometown of Glenview, Illinois, a suburb of Chicago. From what
- 2:28they could gather, she had returned home in the early morning hours, only
- 2:34to be confronted by her killer on the back porch of the family home.
- 2:39Since no one reported hearing anything out of the ordinary, it was assumed that
- 2:45the perpetrator had stifled Tricia's screams at the onset of the blitz attack. A
- 2:53look into the victim's background turned up nothing to indicate that she had any enemies.
- 2:59Quite the contrary, an excellent student who had been her parent's pride and
- 3:05joy, Investigators were hard put to find a soul who had anything but praise
- 3:10for her Devoted to her high school sweetheart, she wasn't the type to go
- 3:16looking for trouble. Sadly, it had found her. Nonetheless, as detectives
- 3:24spoke with neighbors in an effort to eliminate suspects, one name kept coming up
- 3:30time and again, that of seventeen year old Michael Garjulo, a hothead who
- 3:37had a reputation for lashing out in anger with little or no provocation. More
- 3:43than one concerned citizen felt that he needed looking into. Conversely, they had
- 3:50also noted that he could be quite charming when it suited his needs, which
- 3:54only added to their suspicions. When investigators sat down with Guardjulo, he acknowledged
- 4:02that he knew the Paccaccios and had even hung out with Tricia's brother on occasion.
- 4:10Since DNA technology was still in its infancy at the time, the scrapings
- 4:15taken from under the victim's fingernails were of no use in either pinpointing or eliminating
- 4:21a suspect. In light of the fact that there was no proof of wrongdoing
- 4:27on the part of the neighborhood menace, he was free to go. Despite
- 4:31their best efforts, authorities couldn't track down the person responsible for Tricia's murder,
- 4:39and the case went cold. A decade would pass before a suspect would be
- 4:46identified, though he would remain free for another five years as the body count
- 4:51continued to rise. Psychopath at large. In February of twoth thousand and one,
- 5:00twenty two year old California Golden Girl Ashleigh Ellern was dividing her time between
- 5:06attending the Fashion Institute of Design and Merchandising during the day and working at a
- 5:13gentleman's club at night. While it may not have been her first choice,
- 5:19the job paid well and enabled her to afford a residence with the help of
- 5:25a roommate in the highly coveted Hollywood Hills. When she wasn't in school or
- 5:31earning a living, Ashley was spending time with her new bow, an up
- 5:38and coming actor named Ashton Kutcher. Although they had only been dating for a
- 5:45few weeks, the pair tried to spend as much time together as their schedules
- 5:50would allow. On the evening of February twenty first, the couple were planning
- 5:58a much anticipated night out when Kutcher arrived at Ashley's apartment and knocked on the
- 6:04door. She didn't answer, thinking that she might be upset with him for
- 6:10showing up late. He had gone to the side of the unit and looked
- 6:15through the window, but saw no sign of her. He did, however,
- 6:20spy a maroon colored substance spilled on the floor that he presumed to be
- 6:26wine. After coming to the conclusion that the date was off, he had
- 6:32departed without ever entering the residence. When Ashley's roommate, Jennifer De Sisto,
- 6:41arrived home on the morning of February twenty second, she was met with a
- 6:46gruesome sight. As she walked toward her room, she happened upon her friend's
- 6:51body lying just outside the bathroom door, covered in blood. Paramedics arrived on
- 7:00the scene moments later. After determining that Ashley had been dead for several hours,
- 7:06they handed the case over to the coroner. An autopsy would reveal that
- 7:13Ashley had been stabbed forty seven times, with such ferocity that the blade had
- 7:18gone through her body and exited the other side. A deep cut to her
- 7:24throat, which would have been fatal in and of itself, had nearly severed
- 7:29her head. Her hands and arms showed a number of slash marks, which
- 7:34were classified as defensive wounds. Much like Tricia Poccaccio, no evidence of rape
- 7:42could be found. When Kutcher saw news reports of Ashley's murder, he had
- 7:47immediately contacted police and offered his full cooperation. It was only after being informed
- 7:56of the grisly nature of the crime that he realized the substance he had seen
- 8:01on the rug that he thought was red wine was in actuality his girlfriend's blood.
- 8:09After eliminating Ashley's boyfriends past and present, detectives widened their circle of potential
- 8:16suspects when friends of the victim came forward with stories of a guy in the
- 8:22neighborhood who had taken an unusual interest in Ashley that bordered on obsession. Detectives
- 8:30knew that this was a lead worth exploring. Unfortunately, when authorities went looking
- 8:37for the man, who they knew only as an air conditioning technician named Mike,
- 8:43he was nowhere to be found, though they would learn through the grapevine
- 8:48that his name was Michael Kurtulo. It appeared that he had moved out of
- 8:54the area shortly after Ashley's body was discovered. Coincidentally, as detectives in Los
- 9:03Angeles worked on finding Ashley's killer, they were contacted by investigators in Illinois who
- 9:09were looking into the cold case murder of Tricia Poccaccio. It seemed that their
- 9:16one and only suspect, Michael Cardulo, had relocated to California in nineteen ninety
- 9:22eight, and they needed help finding his whereabouts. With the DNA results from
- 9:28her slaying now usable, they hoped to match him to the crime. Two
- 9:33years later, Guardulo surfaced and his DNA was compared to the samples taken from
- 9:39Tricia's body. To the delight of detectives, they proved to be a match.
- 9:46When the evidence was turned over to the Illinois States Attorney, he deemed
- 9:50it insufficient to issue an arrest warrant. Stonewalled Once again, investigators had no
- 9:58choice others than to put both murder cases on the backburner, pending further developments.
- 10:05Another brutal slaying, thirty two year old mother of four, Maria Bruno,
- 10:11was going through a rough time as two thousand and five was coming to
- 10:16a close. A native of El Salvador, she had recently separated from her
- 10:22husband, Irving needing time to herself to take stock of the situation, she
- 10:28had moved out of the home they shared and into an apartment in Almonte,
- 10:33just east of Los Angeles. After doing some research on the area. She
- 10:39had specifically chosen that location for its high safety rating. While she was getting
- 10:46settled in, Maria had left her children, all of whom were under the
- 10:50age of five, in the temporary care of their father. Even though their
- 10:58marriage was on shaky ground, the couple remained on good terms. On the
- 11:05night of December one, Maria was sound asleep when a man entered her apartment
- 11:11through the kitchen window. The attack that followed was so brutal that seasoned detectives
- 11:18were sickened by the scene. Irving Bruno had the misfortune of finding his estranged
- 11:24wife's badly mutilated body the following day after she failed to pick up the kids
- 11:31as planned. The horrific state in which she had been left was something he
- 11:37would never forget. First responders determined that Maria had died from multiple stab wounds,
- 11:46seventeen in all. They also noted that the young mother's breasts had been
- 11:52removed and that the sadist responsible for her death had placed one of her excised
- 11:58nipple across her mouth, Though the killer had been careful to cover his tracks.
- 12:05A single hospital style booty had been recovered from just outside Maria's apartment door.
- 12:11In a stroke of unexpected luck, technicians were able to extract DNA from
- 12:18the disposable shoe cover. A major snag at that point was that detectives were
- 12:26lacking a viable suspect for DNA comparison. Having cleared their persons of interest,
- 12:31including Irving, they had found themselves at a loss. Even so, they
- 12:37knew that the perpetrator would slip up sooner or later and they would take him
- 12:43off the streets for good. They would eventually be proven right, but justice
- 12:48would be a long time coming. A monster meets his match. On the
- 12:56evening of April twenty eighth, two thousand and eight, twenty six year old
- 13:01Michel Murphy was asleep in her Santa Monica home when she was jolted awake by
- 13:07a burning sensation in her arm and chest. Although she had initially believed that
- 13:13she was having a nightmare, she soon realized that a man was on top
- 13:18of her, stabbing her with a large knife. Her survival instincts taking over,
- 13:24she had put up a fight that caught her attacker completely off guard.
- 13:31In the melee that followed, she had punched gouged and kicked at the knife
- 13:37wielding maniac like a wild animal, calling upon a strength she never knew she
- 13:43had. The petite Michele, who stood at a mere five one, had
- 13:50somehow managed to throw her assailant off the mattress and on to the floor.
- 13:56Having no desire to tangle any further with this particular victim, he had uttered
- 14:01an apology before fleeing into the night. It was later determined that the perpetrator
- 14:07had accidentally cut himself during the struggle, leaving a trail of blood that started
- 14:13on the bed and led out the door. Though she had been stabbed eight
- 14:20times and was bleeding profusely, Michelle made it to the phone and called police.
- 14:26The responding officers weren't aware of it at the time, but they were
- 14:30about to break three cold cases wide open. A killer gets his just deserts.
- 14:37When detectives entered the DNA from the blood found in Michelle's bedroom into the
- 14:41CODIS database, they got a hit. The sample matched that of Michael Cargulo.
- 14:50After performing a quick location search, investigators learned that their prime suspect lived
- 14:58directly across the street from Michelle. Murphy. Gardulo was taken into custody on
- 15:05June sixth, two thousand eight. Tracing his movements since he arrived in California,
- 15:13investigators found that he relocated frequently. Tellingly, he had lived within a
- 15:18few blocks of both Ashley Ellern and Maria Bruno at the time of their murders.
- 15:26After learning that Gardulo had lived in the same apartment complex as Maria,
- 15:31detectives obtained a search warrant for his former residence. Hidden away in a storage
- 15:37area, they recovered a booty identical to the one that had been left behind
- 15:43on the night of the murder. An analysis of the DNA samples taken from
- 15:50the crime scene shoe cover, as well as the one found in his old
- 15:54apartment, revealed that they had both been worn by Garshulo. Over the course
- 16:03of their investigation, detectives discovered that Grdulo had approached Ashley one afternoon as she
- 16:11fretted over a flat tire on her car. A handyman who could fix just
- 16:15about anything, he had offered his services. Although she had been under the
- 16:22impression that he was simply being neighborly, his motives were far more sinister.
- 16:30According to those close to Ashley, Cardulo had relentlessly hounded her In the days
- 16:37and weeks following their initial encounter. They claimed that he would often sit in
- 16:41his car outside her apartment, observing her from afar. When one of her
- 16:48male friends confronted him about his intrusiveness, Gardulo had become defensive and sped away.
- 16:56Three months after his arrest, Gardula Law was formally charged with the capital
- 17:02murders of Maria Bruno and Ashley Ellerin the thirty two year old married father of
- 17:08two, whom the press alternately dubbed the Thriller Killer and the Hollywood Ripper,
- 17:15maintained that he had been wrongly accused. It would be a position from which
- 17:22he would never waver, even in the face of irrefutable evidence to the contrary.
- 17:30While incarcerated a waiting trial, Carjulo had allegedly told his jailers that the
- 17:37fact that his DNA had been found at the crime scenes didn't necessarily mean that
- 17:41he had killed the ten women involved, since he was only being charged with
- 17:48two counts of murder. His slip of the tongue led authorities to believe that
- 17:53there were other victims out there somewhere. On July seventh, twenty eleven,
- 18:00officials in Cook County, Illinois, charged Guardjulo with the first degree murder of
- 18:07Tricia Poccaccio. Although they were aware that they would have to wait in line
- 18:14until the legal proceedings and their inevitable appeals in California were over, they had
- 18:21savored the bittersweet victory that was long overdue, staring down the demon. After
- 18:30years of pre trial hearings, postponements, and legal wrangling, Carjulo finally had
- 18:37his day in court on May second, twenty nineteen. During the three month
- 18:41proceedings, Ashton Kutcher had taken the stand to recount the events of that fateful
- 18:48night eighteen years earlier. He recalled that he had phoned Ashley at eight twenty
- 18:55four pm to cement their plans. According to him, she had been upbeat
- 19:02and had shown no indications that she was in distress. A little over an
- 19:08hour later, he had phoned again to say that he was running late,
- 19:14but the call had gone to voicemail. Thinking that perhaps she was in the
- 19:18shower, he had headed out to her apartment. When he arrived at around
- 19:23ten forty five, he saw that Ashley's vehicle was parked out front. After
- 19:30knocking on the door and receiving no response, he had looked through a window
- 19:36and spotted a liquid he believed to be wine, pooled on the floor.
- 19:41With no reason to suspect that anything was amiss, he had continued on with
- 19:47his evening. Although Gargulo had been chomping at the bit to take the stand
- 19:52in his own defense, his lawyers wouldn't allow it. A while card whose
- 20:00temper was unpredictable, they believed that his testimony would do more harm than good.
- 20:10On August fifteenth, Michael Gardulo was convicted of the capital murders of Ashley
- 20:15Ellern and Maria Bruno, as well as the attempted murder of Michelle Murphy,
- 20:21the only known survivor. The penalty phase began on October seventh, with the
- 20:27now convicted killer's teenage son taking the stand to plead for his father's life.
- 20:34While the jury had sympathized with the boy, they felt compelled to recommend that
- 20:40Guardjulo be put to death. Following numerous delays, on July sixteenth, twenty
- 20:45twenty one, a judge agreed and sentenced him to die by lethal injection,
- 20:52even as he sits in San Quentin awaiting his execution date. Illinois authorities are
- 20:57working on extraditing him back to Chicago to stand trial for Tricia's murder. Aftermath,
- 21:07Tricia's parents didn't learn until two thousand and six, three years after the
- 21:12fact, that it was Grdulo's DNA under their daughter's fingernails. Even as the
- 21:18district attorney debated filing charges, no one had thought to tell the victim's family
- 21:26that they had a lead on her killer. In the end, it had
- 21:30been a homicide detective from California who would give them the news while looking into
- 21:37Gardulo as a potential suspect in the Hollywood slayings. Gardulo's motives for his shockingly
- 21:45brutal crimes are up for debate, given that he continues to deny any involvement
- 21:51in the murders. While he didn't commit rape in a traditional sense, it
- 21:57has been theorized that he received ved sexual gratification from the act of stabbing his
- 22:03victims. This scientifically recognized sadistic behavior is known as pikearism, which is defined
- 22:11as a sexual interest in penetrating the skin of another person with sharp objects.
- 22:18As for Michel Murphy, who helped take Gardulo off the streets, once and
- 22:23for all. The physical trauma was easier to overcome than the emotional anguish she
- 22:30suffered as a result of the attack. Haunted by the memory of her close
- 22:36call with death, she developed a paralyzing fear of being alone, especially after
- 22:42dark. She was also plagued by survivor's guilt, which is common among those
- 22:49who lived through an ordeal in which others have perished. While she has slowly
- 22:56regained her footing in life, it's been a long, arduous road that she
- 23:03continues to navigate to this day. If there's anything to be learned from this
- 23:08disturbing story, it is that none of us can ever really know what darkness
- 23:15lies in the hearts of others. On the surface, Michael Cargiulo had seemed
- 23:22like a friendly neighbor with the purest of intentions. Underneath the amiable facade,
- 23:29however, dwelt the soul of a killer who had kept a watchful eye on
- 23:34his victims in the days leading up to the murders. By the time that
- 23:41his true face was revealed, save for Michele, their fates were already sealed. Arsity