Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Scout Stays in Court, Porsche Bounces Back, Entrepreneurs Live Longer
Transcript
- 0:00Good morning, it is W- what day is it? It's Tuesday. Tuesday. Tuesday, October 22nd. This is the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul Jay Daly. That's Kyle Mounts here. Hey.
- 0:09Today we're talking about California swinging a big win against Scout in court. I think I'm just gonna stop it right there. Swinging a big win. That, that's been in the...
- 0:19I mean, every time we're with-- I feel like we've been talking about this, this suit, this fi- like, it feels like two years. It has, it hasn't been, no, it hasn't been two years, but it's been close. It's a lot, yeah.
- 0:30And you get a ruling, and you got a ruling. And there, there's a lot of states looking at this thing.
- 0:34Well, the- I mean, we were just in, we were obviously just in North Carolina, and they're thinking about it 'cause they got pe- they got home base there. Uh, so lots of people talking about it.
- 0:42But speaking about California, Paul- Segway. Segway. Segway into an announcement. I like that. Segway into an announcement. We are gonna be in California, in LA, on November 18th for a one-day ASOTU CON West.
- 0:57We're bringing the energy, the vibe, the speakers, the, the, the room, the, a chance to rub elbows with people that are getting the work done to the West Coast for a one-day event.
- 1:08You can fly in, fly out, get to hang out with people like Jack Hollis, former COO of Toyota. Uh, you've got Vic Keller, Berkshire Hathaway, and used to be, uh, sit right underneath Warren Buffett.
- 1:25And not just that, but today we are announcing a brand-new session all about the top three things that you should be thinking about when it comes to implementing AI strategies in your dealership.
- 1:38Uh, we're releasing a new podcast around this with Daniel Kim. Uh, you know, you may know him, uh, when he started Orbi and now is at Barnes Crossing, and Daniel Kim is a genius- He's a genius... in his own right.
- 1:52So, uh, you're gonna wanna check that out. There's gonna be three strategies. It's not just gonna be about conversational AI. We've got Mia handling that in their panel.
- 2:00But really thinking about how do you leverage the tools that you have uniquely within your dealership, uh, right now. So we've got too much to say no to this event. Yeah.
- 2:10[laughs] You can go to asotoconwest.com, check out the full agenda, check out the speakers, the timing. Um, we designed this event to be fly in, fly out. We know, uh, multiple day events are, um, always a big ask.
- 2:21We also know there's a lot of other stuff going on, so you can come to this event, you can fly in, you can fly out. Really anywhere on the western half of the country, that's possible.
- 2:30Um, if you live on the East Coast, it's still possible, but just like a longer day.
- 2:34So go to ASOTU CON West, check out it, and, uh, we really hope you join us because it's gonna be an amazing time with, uh, some of these, uh, geniuses in the room, which is really the value of any event.
- 2:44Like, who do you get to spend time with? And this one you get- Yep... to spend time with the real deal. All right, let's talk about some news. Uh, back to that lawsuit.
- 2:51A federal judge has again refused to dismiss the California New Car Dealers Association's lawsuit against Scout Motors and VW Group of America over Scout's direct-to-consumer sales plan.
- 3:01Chief Judge Cynthia, uh, Bason dis- denied motions on October 22nd, her second rejection after a similar March ruling.
- 3:09The court reaffirmed that California law bars manufacturers from competing with their own franchise dealers, even indirectly through an affiliate. The CNCDA argue Scout, wholly owned by Volkswagen, is exactly that.
- 3:20It's a, it's a strong argument. It's huge, yeah.
- 3:22The case now moves to discovery where 14, uh, while 14 California VW dealers have separately filed protests with the state's new motor vehicle board, Scout's Traveler SUV isn't even slated for serious production until 2028.
- 3:37So it's still a long way off, but no one wants to, uh, give up any ground early on. CNCDA Chief Legal Officer Anthony Bento said, quote, "Our claims stand, and we continue with discovery in the case."
- 3:49Well, here's the thing. G- great thing for auto dealers, obviously still a long way to go, uh, in, in this case. Um, it is wild to see, like, Scout originally talking about releasing vehicles this fall.
- 4:02Uh, and now production still not slated until, uh, 2028 and pushed back and pushed back. I think there's a lot that goes into that, obviously, the R&D timelines of a ne- new vehicle.
- 4:13Um, but also some of the stuff that they're dealing with across state, uh, you know, Florida, North Carolina, California, all, uh, working on, on, you know, talking with VW about, "Hey, dealers wanna be able to sell these cars."
- 4:25If it's me, and we've had an, an opportunity to talk to a couple of people at Scout, and, and I, I believe in their vision for how a customer should be able to buy a car.
- 4:33I think that the way that they could do this better is potentially work with the dealers to enhance the experience.
- 4:38If, if you've got new information, if you understand the market, if you've done the research, equip, deploy that into the dealership network, into the websites, into the i- into the protocol for how to deliver and sell these vehicles.
- 4:52This is an opportunity for collaboration at, at an all-time high scale, and dealers wanna sell these cars. It's not like they're like, "Get the car out of the market."
- 4:59It is- They just want to have access to the sales pipeline. I don't see... I, I still, I hold to the fact, I don't see how Scout is going to convince, if that's the law- Yeah...
- 5:09I mean, the really, the only- And you'd have to overturn the law in all these states... the only option is overturn the law. I mean, it seems pretty clear.
- 5:15Obviously, this judge is like, "You know, stop sending these things my way because I'm gonna reject it again." [laughs] It's like, "Oh, are you- Yep... a manufacturer of cars that these people sell?" "Yes."
- 5:24"Are, are you a wholly owned subsidiary of that manufacturer?" "Yes." It's like- Next... what are we even talking about here? Unless they- Yeah... figure out a way to spin it out, I just don't see a route.
- 5:34The law seems very, very clear, and what they're doing seems very, very clear. Yeah. So again, um, California in the fight. Uh, we'll see some of those folks down there when we're at ASOTU CON West. Yeah.
- 5:45So, uh, yeah, just getting, getting on with it. Speaking of getting on with it- They are. I mean, it's good to see a turnaround early on in an initiative.
- 5:54Porsche posted a sar- a sharp profit rebound for the first nine months of 2026, an early sign that CEO Michael Leiter's plan to shrink the company and pull back from China is working.
- 6:04Operating profit reached 1.74 billion euros, up from 40 million euros just a year ago. That- Wow... is a massive change. That's a turnaround. 40 million to 1.74 billion.
- 6:18Uh, when costs tied to their d- EV strategy, they halted that. They, um, I'm sorry. When car costs tied to the halted EV strategy crushed results, right? So they, they realized all the EV losses.
- 6:29The margin climbed to 6.9% with Q3 over 10% margin. Sales of the flagship- Wow... 911 rose 12%, the only model in the lineup to grow.
- 6:38Leaders is betting on more customization and exclusive higher margin models, trading volume for profit. With no project- production outside Europe though, Porsche is still absorbing US tariffs.
- 6:48CFO, uh, Jochen Brekner said Audi's potential Georgia plant that was announced earlier this week won't shift Porsche production since it would mean double investments when it comes to suppliers. So- Look-...
- 7:00same with the Audi domestic...
- 7:01they, they came under so much heat last year, both from, uh, y- you know, from the, everything, from their EV strategy to their marketing strategy to who they were going after as a target market, and this, this turnaround is huge.
- 7:15I, you know, the Porsche brand is just such a, like, well-loved brand by car enthusiasts. I'm glad to see them leaning in. I think it's okay to go, uh, further upmarket with more customizations. Mm-hmm.
- 7:26There's no re- there's no reason why they shouldn't desire that, uh, and, and not just think, "Hey, this car is for everybody." Um, kudos to them. Look, this is, this is a winning s- this is a strategy.
- 7:36They're winning with it. Uh, keep rolling. I mean, that, that whole K-shaped economy, like, looks like they're paying attention to that, and they're saying like- Yeah... "Okay, we're focused on the top of the K."
- 7:45That's it. That's it, and it's working. It's working. Speaking of working. Non-stop. Three segues? Segway. That was, was that three or four segues in one show? It was four. They were solid, too.
- 7:54New research suggests that starting your own business, come on now, fam, could help you live longer, especially if you chose that path.
- 8:01Stevens Institute of Technology Professor Cristiano Bellavitis and colleagues analyzed about 20 years of data on 27,501 Americas, they got that one- [laughs]... uh, aged 50 and older.
- 8:13Entrepreneurs had a 10% lower risk of premature death than lifelong employees- Hmm... even after accounting for age, income, wealth, and education. They also, listen to this, reported less depression and loneliness.
- 8:24Benefits showed up for people who started businesses out of desire, not necessity, and were great, uh, were greatest where autonomy was highest.
- 8:33Bellavitis, uh, credits autonomy and the chance to preserve, pursue meaningful work benefits, uh, he says, quote, "May have lasting effects." Okay, so I think there's a few things going on here.
- 8:45Number one, um, a certain personality type pursues entrepreneurship. For sure. Right? And they're- Yeah... typically speaking, somewhat, you have to be an optimist if you're an entrepreneur.
- 8:54You have to be, because the sta- the deck is stacked against you from the start. Right. And you generally have this level of intrinsic motivation that just gets you going.
- 9:02So I think that that accounts for some of it, like personality type.
- 9:05However, um, I think that it's so easy to get lost inside of a big company or inside of a role where you see no light of day, and I bet when you look at companies and organizations and maybe, wink, wink, industries that have upward mobility, that have a career path, that have some place to go where you work together with a team to serve other people, I'd bet that the numbers on that are actually pretty revealing as well, because those are all things that humans are created to fulfill.
- 9:35Purpose, meaning, and vision. Cultivation. Right? Like- All of that stuff... you can create that in any organization. Purpose, meaning, and vision.
- 9:42So, so I'm not, I'm, I'm saying it's not all left out there for the entrepreneurs. No.
- 9:46I'm saying it's everybody's obligation to work together, and it's the entrepreneur's obligation to try to provide as much of that as they can for the people around them.
- 9:55[upbeat music] I think we've done our work here for today. Listen- Did today... if you want to meet people that have that mentality, you really should check out asotukanwest.com. Yeah. Look at everything.
- 10:04Buy your ticket. We'll see you in just, uh, just under three weeks. [upbeat music] And lead the way. Oh, just... [upbeat music] And lead the way.
- 10:13Oh, just...