Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Spotify Financial Deep Value Analysis
Transcript
- 0:00For like a decade, Spotify was essentially the ultimate
- 0:03financial black hole. I mean, they pulled in hundreds
- 0:06of millions of users, billions of data points, and absolutely 0
- 0:11sustainable profit, right? Yeah, none at all.
- 0:14But if you look at their Q 12026 numbers, that black hole just it
- 0:18turned into an absolute cash generating juggernaut.
- 0:20It really did. We are looking at a company that
- 0:22completely reengineered its underlying business model.
- 0:25They escaped this massive industry trap all while we were,
- 0:29you know, just busy making our driving playlists.
- 0:32Exactly now really quickly to access more advanced researches,
- 0:36applications and our latest personal deep value agents.
- 0:39Welcome to explore and join Deep Values dot AIAPP Track total
- 0:45market temperature. Welcome to search and download
- 0:47iOS app buff an indicator from Apple App Store or Bubble Watch
- 0:52from Google Play. Disclaimer All analysis is based
- 0:55on publicly available sources and may be subject to revisions
- 0:58or differing interpretations. All contents from this channel
- 1:01is for research and entertainment purposes only and
- 1:04does not constitute any investment or financial advice.
- 1:07Conduct your own due diligence before making investment
- 1:09financial decisions. Don't forget to like this video.
- 1:12Much appreciated. Well said.
- 1:13OK, let's unpack this because our mission today is to help
- 1:16you, the listener, really understand Spotify's new
- 1:19business model maturity. We're going to break down their
- 1:21structural margins, how they hacked their way out of the
- 1:23music industry trap, and ultimately figure out if this
- 1:27company actually qualifies as a deep value investment today at
- 1:30$485 a share. Yeah.
- 1:32And to really understand that valuation, we have to establish
- 1:36the sheer scale of their current success.
- 1:39OK, let's look at the snapshot. So Q 1/20/26 was incredibly
- 1:43robust. Total revenue hit €4.53 billion.
- 1:47Wow. And if you adjust for constant
- 1:50currency, so removing those weird foreign exchange
- 1:52fluctuations, that's a 14% jump year over year.
- 1:55Which is massive and the user base reflects that, right, yeah,
- 1:58I mean, they're sitting at 761 million monthly active users
- 2:02it's. Staggering.
- 2:03Yeah, with 293 million of those being actual premium
- 2:06subscribers. And the revenue split between
- 2:09those two groups is heavily weighted.
- 2:11Premium brings in €4.14 billion. Which is what, like 90%?
- 2:16Yeah, 91.5% of their total revenue.
- 2:18Meanwhile, the AD Supported tier brings in just 385,000,000.
- 2:22OK, so if the free tier brings in so little comparatively, why
- 2:26keep it around? What's fascinating here is that
- 2:28the free tier is basically an engine for the premium side.
- 2:31Over 60% of their premium users actually start on the free tier,
- 2:34and it yields this incredible 38.5% percent conversion rate.
- 2:38That that conversion rate is just absurd.
- 2:40It's it's like a grocery store handing out a free sample that
- 2:45is so good, almost 4 out of 10 people immediately signed a
- 2:48lifelong contract with the bakery.
- 2:50That is a perfect analogy, and the reason that sample works so
- 2:53well is their mote. It's what the industry calls the
- 2:56taste graph. The taste graph.
- 2:57Yeah, because you have these billions of data points feeding
- 3:00their machine learning algorithms every single day.
- 3:03Right, curating the exact right playlist.
- 3:05Exactly, and that creates immensely high psychological
- 3:09switching costs for the user. I mean, people just don't want
- 3:12to lose their curated playlists and their algorithm history.
- 3:15Yeah, I definitely wouldn't want to start over on a new app, but
- 3:19but I do see a crack in the armor here looking at the
- 3:21report. Yeah.
- 3:22If user numbers are up, why did the ad supported revenue
- 3:25actually shrink by 5% year over year?
- 3:28Like how does that work? Well, you're looking at the
- 3:30cyclical vulnerability of the ad market there.
- 3:32The actual impressions they sold went up.
- 3:34Oh, so they sold more ads? Right, but broader economic
- 3:38softness completely compressed their pricing power.
- 3:42Advertisers just weren't willing to pay as much per slot.
- 3:45I see. But contrast that with the
- 3:47premium tier. That pricing power stayed
- 3:49incredibly resilient across all regions, even with the price
- 3:53hikes. OK.
- 3:53So user engagement is super high, pricing power on premium
- 3:56is solid, but that brings us to the next big piece of the
- 3:59puzzle. Right, the margins.
- 4:01Yeah, if the model is so good, why did it take a full decade
- 4:05for Spotify to achieve its current record 15.8% operating
- 4:09margin? I mean they were famous for just
- 4:12bleeding cash for years. They were, and that was due to
- 4:16the ultimate structural flaw of the music industry.
- 4:18You have this variable cost trap.
- 4:20Right, the music royalties. Exactly.
- 4:22Royalties paid to the big three labels, so Universal, Sony,
- 4:27Warner and the Merlin consortium.
- 4:29Those costs scale proportionally with revenue.
- 4:31So every time Spotify makes a dollar, the labels automatically
- 4:35take their exact. Cut every single time, which
- 4:37historically capped their gross margins at around 25%.
- 4:40They physically couldn't get more efficient.
- 4:42What if they hacked their way out of it?
- 4:43Because this Q1 report shows their gross margins hit a record
- 4:4733.0%. They found an escape route by
- 4:51strategically investing in non music, audio podcasts, podcasts,
- 4:56audiobooks and marketplace tools for artists.
- 4:58Unlike music, podcasting has fixed upfront costs.
- 5:01Right, you pay the creator once. Exactly.
- 5:04And once listener engagement crosses a certain threshold to
- 5:07cover that fixed cost, the incremental margin on the next
- 5:10listen approaches 100%. That is a massive pivot and I
- 5:14also noticed their operating expenses fell by 5%.
- 5:17Yeah. And part of that was heavily
- 5:18aided by this quirky little thing, a €49 million favorable
- 5:23variance in Swedish payroll taxes.
- 5:25Wait, really? Yeah, it's actually tied
- 5:27directly to their share price movement.
- 5:29That's that's hilarious. So the stock moves and their tax
- 5:31bill drops. Plus they run super lean now,
- 5:33right? They do post layoffs.
- 5:35They have a workforce of roughly 8524 employees.
- 5:39Earning what, like an average of $127,612?
- 5:43Yep. So they are running a very tight
- 5:45ship. OK, but here's where it gets
- 5:47really interesting for me. If Spotify is finally proving
- 5:50that this model is highly profitable, aren't the big tech
- 5:54giants just going to crush them? You mean the apples and Amazons?
- 5:58Yeah. Apple, Amazon, Alphabet with
- 6:01YouTube, they have the balance sheets to run audio streaming as
- 6:04a massive loss leader forever. Literally just to sell iPhones
- 6:08or Prime subscriptions, right? How does Spotify survive that?
- 6:11Well, that is a permanent structural risk.
- 6:13There's no denying it. It places a definitive ceiling
- 6:17on Spotify's pricing power. Because if they raise prices too
- 6:20much people just jump to Apple Music.
- 6:22Exactly. And you also have these complex
- 6:25statutory litigation risks compounding things.
- 6:28Like the audiobook thing? Right, the mechanical licensing
- 6:30collective lawsuit. Because Spotify bundled
- 6:33audiobooks into the premium tier, publishers are arguing it
- 6:36changes how music royalties should be calculated.
- 6:38Man, that sounds like a legal nightmare.
- 6:40So what's stopping Big Tech from just overwhelming them while
- 6:43they fight these battles? It comes right back to the taste
- 6:46graph. The algorithm is the only thing
- 6:48keeping Big tech at Bay. Apple has the money, but they
- 6:51don't have a decade of your specific listening data to serve
- 6:55you the perfect track on a Tuesday morning.
- 6:58OK, but still to build all that out, escaping the label trap,
- 7:02building the podcast infrastructure, fighting big
- 7:05tech that required years of just stomaching massive losses.
- 7:10Billions and losses, yeah. So how did management survive
- 7:13Wall Street's impatience? Usually if a company burns cash
- 7:16like that, activist investors just come in and clean house.
- 7:19They survived because of their very unique corporate
- 7:22governments and we saw the combination of this with the
- 7:24massive leadership shift back on January 1st, 2026, right?
- 7:28When Daniel Egg stepped down to CEO.
- 7:30Well transitioned, he became executive chairman to focus on
- 7:33long term strategy and geopolitics.
- 7:35OK. And he handed daily operations
- 7:37over to the Co CEO's. Yeah, Gustav Soderstrom and Alex
- 7:40Nordstrom, both of whom are 15 year veterans at the company.
- 7:43But the ownership structure is the crazy part because Eke and
- 7:46his Co founder Martin Lorenzen, they only own roughly 25 to 28%
- 7:50of the actual economic interest, right?
- 7:52But they hold these beneficiary certificates.
- 7:55They grant them over 70.7% of the voting power.
- 7:59It is absolute control. I mean for you listening to
- 8:04this, you have to ask yourself, having founders control over 70%
- 8:07of the vote sounds like a corporate dictatorship.
- 8:10Is that actually a good thing for regular investors?
- 8:13If we connect this to the bigger picture, it actually is top
- 8:16institutional shareholders like Bailey Gifford with their 4%
- 8:20stake and 10 cent with eight point O 9%.
- 8:23They fully support this structure.
- 8:24Really Why? Because it renders Spotify
- 8:26completely immune to hostile takeovers and activist
- 8:29investors. It allowed management to
- 8:31prioritize long term infrastructure like that
- 8:34expensive podcast pivot over short term quarterly.
- 8:37Earnings. Oh, so they could just ignore
- 8:39Wall Street screaming them we're not making a profit?
- 8:41Exactly. And now we are in the capital
- 8:44return phase. Right, the buybacks.
- 8:46Yeah, after 10 years of 0 buybacks, the April 2026 Annual
- 8:52General Meeting authorized a massive 10 million share
- 8:55buyback. That's a huge shift in
- 8:57philosophy. It is in Q1 alone they
- 8:59repurchased €306,000,000 in shares.
- 9:02They also retired €1.3 billion in exchangeable notes.
- 9:06And they still have, what, €8.8 billion in cash just sitting
- 9:09there just. Sitting in reserves.
- 9:11OK, so that brings us to the ultimate question of this
- 9:13report, the deep value paradox. Let's hear it.
- 9:16So what does this all mean? With mature management record
- 9:19margins in these massive buybacks, Is Spotify actually a
- 9:23good value today at $485 a share?
- 9:26Well if you look at traditional Benjamin Graham deep value
- 9:29metrics, it completely fails. Completely.
- 9:30I mean the PE ratio is 34 point 4X price to book is 11.4 X the
- 9:35PEG ratio is 2.45. X And it deliberately ran at a
- 9:39loss for eight of the last 10 years, so it totally fails the
- 9:41historical earnings per share test.
- 9:43Exactly, but it passes modern cash generation tests with
- 9:47flying colors. They've had ten straight years
- 9:50of positive free cash flow. They're trailing 12 month free
- 9:52cash flow is a staggering $3.5 billion.
- 9:56Wow, which is an 18.3% margin. Return on equity is 33.2%, and
- 10:01debt equity is virtually 0 at .05.
- 10:04Yeah, trying to value a modern algorithm based company using
- 10:09traditional price to book ratios.
- 10:11It's it's honestly like trying to value a software company by
- 10:14weighing its physical computer servers.
- 10:15It just doesn't make sense. That's a great way to put it.
- 10:17But let's look at the discounted cash flow scenarios you pulled
- 10:20from the report, because I want to push back on the math a bit.
- 10:22OK, let's look at the DCF. So the no growth intrinsic value
- 10:25is $188.96. Conservative with 6% growth is
- 10:30$368.90, and the nominal scenario, which assumes 15%
- 10:36decaying to 8% growth gives us an intrinsic value of $603.97.
- 10:42So at $485 today, the stock is technically below that $603.00
- 10:47nominal value, but it completely misses the required 30% margin
- 10:52of safety price, which would be $422.78.
- 10:55That's true. So is this just too risky for a
- 10:58traditional value investor? This raises an important
- 11:00question about how we define value.
- 11:02Today. We are really looking at a
- 11:04Munger esque value framework here.
- 11:07As in Charlie Munger. Exactly.
- 11:09You are paying a premium, yes, but you are paying it for an
- 11:13unassailable Moat. Because of the taste graph,
- 11:15right? And the business is hyper
- 11:18efficient. Depreciation consumes only 2% of
- 11:21their gross profit. That's nothing.
- 11:23It's basically a rounding error and their owner's earnings are
- 11:26sitting at $2.95 billion. You are paying for a compounding
- 11:32machine that doesn't need a heavy capital reinvestment just
- 11:35to survive. Wow.
- 11:37OK, so just to recap the journey here, we've watched this company
- 11:40go from a cash burning music player totally trapped by record
- 11:43labels into a highly profitable dual tiered audio monopoly.
- 11:47And it was all run by founders who played the ultimate long
- 11:50game. It really is a fascinating
- 11:51evolution. It is.
- 11:52Now before we go, just a quick reminder.
- 11:54If you want to track total market temperature for yourself,
- 11:57definitely search and download the iOS App Buffett Indicator
- 12:00from the Apple App Store or Bubble Watch from Google Play.
- 12:03And as you're doing that, I want to leave you with one final
- 12:05thought to Mull over regarding that taste graph Mote.
- 12:09Yeah, the algorithm, right. We know it's billions of data
- 12:14points that perfectly map out your preferences to serve you
- 12:17the exact right audio at the exact right moment.
- 12:20But think about what music really is.
- 12:23It's deeply emotional. If they have mapped your
- 12:26emotional state perfectly, what happens when they leverage that
- 12:29psychological mapping outside of just muse up in podcasts?
- 12:32Oh man. Right.
- 12:33What else does your Spotify algorithm know about your mental
- 12:35state that you don't even know about yourself?
- 12:37That is. That is slightly terrifying, but
- 12:40incredibly profound. Thanks for unpacking all of this
- 12:43today. Anytime.