Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Contract Drafting: Creator Partnership & Licensing Agreements
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone. Welcome to Contract Drafting,
- 0:06Creator Partnership, and Licensing Agreements.
- 0:09I'm Keith Kelly, Chair of the Entertainment Law
- 0:12Section. On behalf of the Beverly Hills Bar Association's
- 0:15Entertainment Law Section, we'd like to thank
- 0:18our generous sponsor, Lawyers Mutual Insurance
- 0:21Company. Please see the chat and written materials
- 0:24for more information about them. I'm delighted
- 0:27to introduce today's speaker, April Paredes.
- 0:30April is the co -owner and principal attorney
- 0:33at Ascent Legal. April practices business and
- 0:36entertainment law with a focus on transactional
- 0:39matters in the entertainment, media, and technology
- 0:42sectors. Her work includes rights acquisition,
- 0:46licensing and brand collaborations, advising
- 0:49producers, studios, media companies, and major
- 0:52brands entering the content creation space. She
- 0:56handles matters related to the creation, production,
- 0:59and distribution of audio visual content, including
- 1:02television, feature films, and podcasts. April
- 1:06also works closely with startups, providing legal
- 1:09services throughout their life cycle from formation
- 1:13to exit. Prior to founding Ascent Legal, she
- 1:16practiced at Shepherd Mullen. She also holds
- 1:19a master's in communication management from USC.
- 1:23Now, let's get started. Thank you, April. All
- 1:35right. Hi, everyone. Thank you, Kelly, Keith,
- 1:38for the introduction. So a large part of my day
- 1:43-to -day work involves helping clients navigate
- 1:46the influencer and content deals, both on the
- 1:48brand side and also on the creator side. So and
- 1:52seeing where these agreements tend to break down
- 1:54in practice. So today I'm going to walk through
- 1:57some of the key drafting issues that come up
- 1:59in these agreements and how to approach them
- 2:01in a way that aligns expectations and avoids
- 2:05the common pitfalls. So before we get into drafting,
- 2:09I want to start off with what actually happens
- 2:12in these seals. So we can move on to the next
- 2:16slide. Okay, so these are the common issues that
- 2:23I usually deal with in my practice. So the first
- 2:26one, competitor data. So a creator posts a branded
- 2:30content and then posts a competitor shortly thereafter
- 2:33because exclusivity wasn't really clear in the
- 2:37first place. So that's an issue that I constantly
- 2:39see. Another one is brands' overuse of content.
- 2:44So a brand that takes content and uses it in
- 2:47paid ads indefinitely because usage rights were
- 2:50never clearly defined. So that's another issue
- 2:54that on the brand side, it's good, but on the
- 2:57creator side, they're seeing their content being
- 3:00exploited in different types of platforms that
- 3:02they weren't originally agreed to. Then there's
- 3:07FTC issues. So a creator forgets to properly...
- 3:12comply with FTC disclosures and now there's a
- 3:14compliance issue. So oftentimes, depending on
- 3:17how agreements are drafted, whether you're on
- 3:21the creator side or you're on the brand side,
- 3:29it will depend who put that off to the creator
- 3:34and make sure that the creator is compliant.
- 3:37And so that comes into play as well. Another
- 3:40issue that I constantly also see is when campaigns
- 3:45don't go as planned. Let's say a creator is hired
- 3:47by a brand to work in developing a particular
- 3:51video. But then let's say that campaign never
- 3:54comes to fruition. And then what happens next,
- 3:57right? The creator already spent a lot of time
- 4:01developing this video. They have the work product,
- 4:04but then just the campaign's no longer going
- 4:07to be they're not going to proceed with the campaign
- 4:10after all. So what happens after? So those are
- 4:13like sort of things to look out for, especially
- 4:16when drafting. So here are the key points. So
- 4:19none of these are surprises. Every single one
- 4:22of these issues is preventable through drafting,
- 4:25but most agreements don't address them clearly.
- 4:28And that's where the issue comes in. I had a
- 4:30situation where a brand paid $50 ,000 for a campaign
- 4:35and the creator just posted content on behalf
- 4:39of a competitor within that same week. Because
- 4:43the exclusivity clause wasn't clearly defined,
- 4:47it just generally said no competing brands. It
- 4:53didn't have any specificity which caused issues
- 4:55in the long run. So these are some of the issues
- 4:58that I deal on a daily basis when I'm working
- 5:01on brand deals with creators. So we can move
- 5:05on to the next slide. Why creator deals are different?
- 5:11So these agreements are a little different from
- 5:13your traditional contracts. So they move fast,
- 5:16often faster than they should. And they're usually
- 5:19driven by marketing teams rather than lawyers.
- 5:22So in a traditional production, everything is
- 5:26tightly controlled. The script, the performance,
- 5:29the final edits. In creator deals, it's a bit
- 5:31different. Often the creator is given a product
- 5:34or a general campaign concept, but they're given
- 5:38a lot of leeway of what they can do and how they
- 5:41can present it. So often content creators are
- 5:44referred to as a one -man show. Basically, they
- 5:48get a product, they develop how they're going
- 5:51to present it to an audience, and they have a
- 5:54lot of freedom and flexibility in how they're
- 5:56going to portray that. And by doing that, it
- 6:00makes the content feel more authentic and effective.
- 6:03But it also creates risks if expectations are
- 6:07not clearly defined. So the contract has to do
- 6:12more work upfront. So as lawyers representing
- 6:15the creator or sometimes the brand, we have to
- 6:19make sure that everything's specifically defined,
- 6:22it's clearly written so that way we don't fall
- 6:25into the common traps. And that's why deliverables
- 6:28are so important. because they're really the
- 6:31foundation of the agreement. So let's move on
- 6:36to the next slide in terms of what we're actually
- 6:39going to cover in this presentation. So this
- 6:42presentation is not going to be a clause -by
- 6:45-clause breakdown, but it's going to cover practical
- 6:48drafting tips, common attorney mistakes, and
- 6:52real -world issues. And we'll go through 10 key
- 6:55clauses that show up in almost every creator
- 6:58agreement. So let's start with the most common
- 7:01problem. Okay, so where are the deals break?
- 7:10So we can go to the next slide. So deliverables.
- 7:17So we're going to start with the foundational
- 7:19piece of deliverables. So everything starts with
- 7:23deliverables. So you need to define what content,
- 7:28right? Whether it's a story, if it's a real,
- 7:32if it's an in -feed story, is it a video, is
- 7:35it a photo? So that's very important because
- 7:38sometimes depending on where you're going to
- 7:43be posting and what type of campaign you're running,
- 7:47it's important to make sure that the creator
- 7:49knows what they're expected to deliver, right?
- 7:53It could be a reel it could be a story that's
- 7:56going to disappear so everything has to be laid
- 7:58out also so which platform is it going to be
- 8:02a tiktok youtube and how many how many um posts
- 8:07do they have to comply with within a week is
- 8:10it two posts per week is it one post per month
- 8:13what is the arrangement and when how often are
- 8:17they expected to post So usually when I I'm on
- 8:22the creator side and then I make sure that they
- 8:27understand how many what are the expectations
- 8:30right what do they have to deliver at the end
- 8:33of the of the agreement so but being on the brand
- 8:37side it's also important in every contract to
- 8:41include the technical specs, whether raw files
- 8:46are included as part of the deliverables, whether
- 8:50drafts are part of the deliverables as well.
- 8:52So that's really important to make sure that
- 8:55it's attached as part of the contract. So usually
- 8:58when I'm representing the brand, I make sure
- 9:01that I'm adding exhibits and laying out how long
- 9:06each video is supposed to last. if they're supposed
- 9:10to comply with certain specs, what type of creative
- 9:16elements have to be included as well. So that's
- 9:20all a part of the agreement. So instead of saying
- 9:26creator will post on Instagram, it sounds very
- 9:29generic. You have to be very specific in terms
- 9:32of creator will publish two Instagram reels.
- 9:36and three Instagram stories between, let's say,
- 9:39April 1st and April 7th, right? I've seen brands
- 9:43expect five to six pieces of content while the
- 9:47creator thought they were only delivering one.
- 9:49That turns into a payment dispute immediately.
- 9:52So from a brand's side, specificity ensures you're
- 9:56getting exactly what you're paying for. From
- 9:58the creator's side, it protects against scope
- 10:01creep. which is a real thing, and it's something
- 10:04that creators struggle a lot with. And they end
- 10:08up doing a lot of different content and doing
- 10:11a lot of different additional work that wasn't
- 10:14bargained for in the beginning. So even if you
- 10:18define deliverables, then there's another trap
- 10:21as well. So you also have to look at the platforms,
- 10:25which is covered in the next slide. So platforms.
- 10:32So for example, an Instagram story, a TikTok
- 10:35video and a YouTube video post all function very
- 10:39differently. So an Instagram story disappears
- 10:42quickly. A TikTok video can continue to circulate
- 10:46and a YouTube video has a much larger lifespan.
- 10:50They also have different levels of effort and
- 10:52production value and different value to the brand.
- 10:55So what do you actually draft, right? So you
- 10:59have to specify the exact type of platform. So
- 11:02if the content's just going to be living on Instagram,
- 11:06then make sure you're establishing that type
- 11:09of platform. It clearly says in the contract
- 11:12what type of platform the creator is responsible
- 11:15for utilizing in order to present that content.
- 11:20Are they going to be using their own personal
- 11:23handle? or sometimes creators tend to have their
- 11:27own personal one and that they're developing,
- 11:29let's say, merchandise and they're collaborating
- 11:32with another brand, they'll use their own business
- 11:35one. So which handle will they be attaching to
- 11:39each of their content, right? Also addressing
- 11:42cross posting. So this is something that has
- 11:46been a real issue too. So let's say a content
- 11:49creator develops a video and then they the agreement
- 11:54is just for publishing it on Instagram but then
- 11:58it has a lot of great results, a great audience,
- 12:02so then the brand decides to use that same video
- 12:05and use it on YouTube or use it on TikTok but
- 12:09that was not originally the agreement and sometimes
- 12:11brands will do that and then as a result the
- 12:16creators are left with compensation that they
- 12:22should have actually gotten more compensation
- 12:24out of it because they're using different platforms.
- 12:27They're utilizing their posts to gain audiences
- 12:32on different types of platforms. So let's say
- 12:36a brand pays for TikTok content and then reposts
- 12:39it on YouTube ads. That's a completely different
- 12:43value and it should have been negotiated for
- 12:47upfront. So from the brand's perspective, they're
- 12:50just maximizing the content, right? But from
- 12:53the creator's perspective, that's completely
- 12:55different use and often a much higher value use.
- 13:00So if that wasn't negotiated upfront, you know
- 13:03how to dispute. So that's why it's very important
- 13:06when you are drafting these type of contracts,
- 13:10depending on which side, that you acknowledge
- 13:14the platforms that will be being utilized right
- 13:17and then how long will the content live on there
- 13:21so let me show you what this actually looks like
- 13:25in practice if we go on to the next slide so
- 13:32what you're seeing here is It's just a sample
- 13:35deliverables clause. This is how we translate
- 13:38all of those concepts into actual drafting language.
- 13:42And there are a few things I want to point out.
- 13:44So first, notice how structured this is. We're
- 13:47separating deliverables by type. Photographs,
- 13:50in -feed videos, stories. That matters because
- 13:54each of these has different type of effort, different
- 13:57value, and different expectations. Second, look
- 14:00at the level of specificity. We're defining the
- 14:05number of deliverables, the format, the platform,
- 14:08and even the duration requirements. So instead
- 14:11of saying just this creator will post content
- 14:15on social media, we're saying exactly what content,
- 14:18exactly where, and exactly how long it needs
- 14:22to live. And this might sound self -explanatory,
- 14:26but it actually triggers a lot of issues, and
- 14:29that's the cause of poor drafting. This is, from
- 14:36a legal perspective, this is something that is
- 14:38very important. So this clause defining the scope
- 14:42of performance means you can determine if there's
- 14:47a breach, you can determine if payment is owed,
- 14:50and you can avoid scope disputes entirely. So
- 14:54one thing I want to highlight specifically is
- 14:57this language around pinning content, which is
- 14:59on 3 .3, the last sentence. And on Instagram,
- 15:04creators shall pin the story's video on the profile.
- 15:09So that's a great example of how detailed these
- 15:12agreements can get. Because pinning does increase
- 15:15visibility, extends the life of the content,
- 15:18and increases value to the brand. But it also
- 15:21imposes another obligation on the creator. So
- 15:24again, if you don't specify it, you can't really
- 15:27enforce it. So that's why it's a good example
- 15:29of how specific, how granular you have to be
- 15:33to make sure that everything's accounted for,
- 15:36especially when content creators are developing
- 15:40content, they're going to launch it in connection
- 15:42with a specific campaign. You don't want to be
- 15:45stuck in these disputes. You want to be able
- 15:47to make sure that it flies smoothly. And that
- 15:53goes back to how the contract was drafted. So
- 15:57let's go to tip number three in the next slide.
- 16:04So duration. So is it perpetual or is it time
- 16:07limited? Does it need to stay pinned as we talked
- 16:10in the previous slide? So from the brand's perspective,
- 16:14the longer the content stays live, the more exposure
- 16:18and return they're going to get on a particular
- 16:21campaign. From the creator's perspective, longer
- 16:24duration means a longer ongoing obligation and
- 16:28potentially limiting their ability to refresh
- 16:30their content or work with other brands. So this
- 16:34is where alignment really matters. So if a brand
- 16:36expects content to stay up indefinitely, then
- 16:41but the creator assumed that they can take it
- 16:43down, let's say, after a few weeks of promoting
- 16:46it. That's not just understanding. That's a breach
- 16:50question. So the contract needs to answer it
- 16:54clearly. You also want to think about things
- 16:56like pinning, right, that we've talked about
- 16:59because requiring a post to be pinned requires
- 17:02visibility and adds value to the brand. affects
- 17:10how the creator creates their profile. So again,
- 17:13that needs to be explicitly negotiated and defined.
- 17:17So duration isn't just a timing issue, it's more
- 17:20a value and control issue. So if you don't define
- 17:22it clearly, it leaves both sides exposed because
- 17:27the creator might take it. down and might be
- 17:32willing to work with other types of brands. And
- 17:36then the brand that they initially engage with
- 17:40will be exposed, right? So that's why it's so
- 17:44important to ensure. draft language in the agreement
- 17:49in terms of how how long is this content going
- 17:52to last is there a time limit is it sometimes
- 17:55what creators will do when they engage in a brand
- 17:58deal is they've been hired to develop videos
- 18:03in anticipation of a product launch and let's
- 18:07say there's no duration there's no time limits
- 18:09then they might not even go in accordance to
- 18:13schedule and maybe those that promotion that
- 18:16the Creator had to present in the first place
- 18:20they're not going to be able to do so because
- 18:22it wasn't clearly defined in the first place
- 18:25and that's that would be very Impactful for the
- 18:31brand that's going to launch this product and
- 18:34hired this creator to Develop these videos in
- 18:38anticipation of this launch So that's something
- 18:42to always think about as well. So why that's
- 18:44why explicitly mentioning duration is very important.
- 18:50So if we can move on to tip number four, approval.
- 18:56So the approval section, at what point the creator
- 19:05can post whatever they believe satisfies the
- 19:08agreement. And the brand has very limited ability
- 19:12to intervene before it goes live. So approval
- 19:15isn't just a preference, right? Approval is a
- 19:19sort of control mechanism, because the last thing
- 19:21the brand wants to do is hire a content creator
- 19:24to develop a reel on TikTok and have it go live
- 19:30before they actually approved it, approved the
- 19:33quality, approved the sound, made sure that the
- 19:37product is being displayed appropriately. the
- 19:43language that they intend to use it to capture
- 19:46their audience, right? But like most things in
- 19:49these agreements, it needs structure. What should
- 19:52you include? So as the brand, you want to make
- 19:56sure that you have a clear pre -approval requirement
- 19:59before the creator goes out and posts this content.
- 20:04You want to make sure that It aligns with what
- 20:09they were supposed to do in the first place.
- 20:11There's a lot of like representing the brand.
- 20:14There's a lot of content creators that will present
- 20:16their videos, but it's poor quality. The product
- 20:20isn't even shown how it should be. It's not gonna
- 20:23appeal to the audience that they're intended
- 20:25to market. So imagine being the brand and not
- 20:30having any type of approval process. that would
- 20:33be detrimental. So that's why it's very important
- 20:36to have a clear pre -approval requirement before
- 20:38the creator can actually post. A cap on revision
- 20:44rounds. So this is more favorably for the creator
- 20:47because typically it is recommended that the
- 20:51creator just revises the content typically once
- 20:55or two, twice. But what brands tend to do is
- 21:01ask them for Unlimited revisions and from the
- 21:06brands perspective that is that creates a lot
- 21:08of flexibility on their part But from the creators
- 21:11perspective Creators don't want to work for free.
- 21:15They want to clear cap on revision rounds. So
- 21:18one or two is usually standard and They want
- 21:22to make sure that they're not Basically brands
- 21:26are not nitpicking every little thing and then
- 21:28they go back and then they're doing a lot of
- 21:31work for free It's also important to define turnaround
- 21:34times for feedback. So if there's a video that
- 21:40needs to be approved by the brand, making sure
- 21:42that the brand has X amount of days to get back
- 21:45to the creator so they can make the necessary
- 21:48edits and then they can move forward with revising
- 21:52the video. Now, depending on who you represent,
- 21:57the clauses are going to be able to look very
- 21:59differently, right? As I mentioned, pre -approval
- 22:03requirements are generally more favorable for
- 22:06the brands. They create more flexibility. If
- 22:10there's no cap on revisions, that's better for
- 22:14the brand. And it gives the brand a tighter control
- 22:19on what ultimately gets posted. So from a creator
- 22:23perspective, though, you want time limits. You
- 22:26want to make sure that you're a clear cap on
- 22:29revision rounds and define timelines so that
- 22:32way the brand can't delay the process indefinitely.
- 22:37So let's take one of my scenarios that I had
- 22:41to work with. If you don't include a revision
- 22:44cap, brands will constantly keep continuing requesting
- 22:50like edits until the content matches their exact
- 22:53vision. I've had this several times because creators
- 22:56enter into these brand deals with with no revision
- 23:01cap and so now they're working unlimited they're
- 23:07investing a lot of unlimited time for unpaid
- 23:09work and that's where disputes start because
- 23:11sometimes they'll develop a video it was in accordance
- 23:16with the specs the brand provided but let's say
- 23:20the brand decided to move in a slightly different
- 23:24direction. And now they're coming back to the
- 23:26creator and they're saying, oh, can you make
- 23:28this edit? Can you can you tighten this? Can
- 23:31you add something else? And so that that just
- 23:34becomes, you know, a constant struggle with the
- 23:38creator and the brand, because now they have
- 23:41to try to align with their vision, which wasn't
- 23:45what they envisioned in the first place. So that
- 23:47creates a lot of unnecessarily frustration on
- 23:53behalf of the creator so it's best to have everything
- 23:57delineated in the agreement that way the brands
- 24:01don't have the upper hand in terms of what revisions
- 24:04they have to endless revisions and so forth and
- 24:08we can go to the next slide slide number five
- 24:12in terms of Tip number five, payment. So payment
- 24:17terms are not just financial, they're risk allocations.
- 24:20So at minimum, you want to make sure when will
- 24:23payment be triggered, whether payment is tied
- 24:28to performance metrics, whether their kill fee
- 24:34is canceled. So oftentimes it will be hired to
- 24:38develop content for a particular campaign and
- 24:42That campaign unfortunately doesn't come out
- 24:48right. It's just in the works. It never sees
- 24:54the light. And basically, they're left with their
- 24:58content. Is the creator going to be compensated
- 25:02for the work they've done already? Or given that
- 25:05the campaign has been canceled, are they still
- 25:11able to get some sort of compensation. So those
- 25:15are questions that usually get triggered when
- 25:20you're drafting because you have to think about
- 25:21these things. If my client, let's say, was a
- 25:25content creator, they spent a lot of time, effort
- 25:27developing this video or photo, right? They should
- 25:34be compensated for the work they've done even
- 25:36though the campaign never comes to fruition.
- 25:40So now, depending on who you represent, this
- 25:44cause is going to look differently. From a brand
- 25:47favorable perspective, you want payment tied
- 25:50to milestones, right? For example, X amount upon
- 25:55delivery and then X amount upon approval and
- 26:01then the final amount upon. posting the content.
- 26:04You might also want to tie compensation to performance
- 26:07metrics like views or engagement. But from a
- 26:14creator favorable perspective, you want guaranteed
- 26:18payment. Content creators have made, are now
- 26:22living, they've made their livelihood off of
- 26:25posting content and making videos and that's
- 26:28their full -time job. So for them, it's not going
- 26:32to be favorable to enter into a brand deal in
- 26:36developing content and not getting paid for it
- 26:40just because a campaign never took effect or
- 26:45was canceled, right? So from a creator's council,
- 26:51you want to make sure that payment is guaranteed,
- 26:55often triggered upon signing or upon delivery,
- 26:59and you want protection for your client in case
- 27:03the campaign doesn't move forward. Let's say
- 27:06it was canceled, you still want to ensure that
- 27:08your client, the content creator, is compensated.
- 27:12Because the worst thing that can happen is that
- 27:15the creator has already created the content,
- 27:18but the brand decides to cancel the campaign
- 27:20before posting. And if there's no kill fee provision,
- 27:25then the creator is going to expect to be paid
- 27:27in full because they've done the work. but the
- 27:30brand expects to pay nothing because the content
- 27:33was never published. So that's not necessarily
- 27:37a negotiation issue as I see it but more of a
- 27:40drafting failure and it often can escalate quickly
- 27:44into a dispute. So let's see if we can move to
- 27:49the next slide and then we'll see take a look
- 27:53at how payment clauses are often drafted in practice.
- 27:57So at first glance, this type of provision looks
- 28:00fine, right? The influencer gets paid, a fixed
- 28:05fee, they invoice the company, and the payment
- 28:08is due within 30 days. Very standard. From a
- 28:12brand perspective, this is great. Payment is
- 28:14conditioned on the influencer satisfying all
- 28:18obligations, which gives the brand flexibility
- 28:21to withhold or delay payment if there are any
- 28:25type of issues. But from a creative perspective,
- 28:29there's no protection if that campaign is canceled.
- 28:33So it's what I was speaking about in the previous
- 28:39slide. Let's say the campaign doesn't... perform
- 28:46doesn't perform well is canceled or it's not
- 28:49what they what the brand expected right so the
- 28:53creator could complete all the work and still
- 28:56be waiting on payment so these are type of the
- 28:59disputes that typically arise when contracts
- 29:03are not clearly fleshed out, they're not clearly
- 29:07drafted, and problems like these arise. They
- 29:11don't arise right now, but after the work is
- 29:14completed, that's when you see the real issues.
- 29:17So we can turn to the next slide, tip six, regarding
- 29:23scope. So scope creep is a real thing. It's something
- 29:27that content creators... always struggle with,
- 29:32especially when they're engaging with brand deals.
- 29:36Scope is where most of the deals quietly break
- 29:39down because it's not just about the main deliverables,
- 29:42it's about everything surrounding them. So you
- 29:45want to think about additional deliverables,
- 29:48appearances or events, reposting or engagement
- 29:51requirements, because these are often requested
- 29:55after the agreement is signed. For example, a
- 29:58brand might say, can you just attend an event?
- 30:03You are creating content for our makeup brand
- 30:06and we're having a PR event. Can you be part
- 30:09of that? Since you have a lot of followers, it
- 30:12would be great. It would be great publicity.
- 30:15Or can you do one extra post, right? That's a
- 30:18common one that I often get on behalf of clients
- 30:22that are content creators. can you do just this
- 30:26extra one it was a great hit but you know it'd
- 30:29be great if you can do something similar not
- 30:31necessarily a new type of concept it's just something
- 30:35you know similar to the one that you did and
- 30:37then we could just post it on on your Instagram
- 30:41but that was not in the contract and so once
- 30:45you later you start doing and being willing to
- 30:52make a specific edit or make another video or
- 30:55appear in a publicity event, then brands keep
- 30:59on extending the scope of what you were originally
- 31:04engaged for in the first place. So now you're
- 31:07left having a disagreement. Was that included
- 31:11in the contract or is that extra? So every additional
- 31:16obligation should be clearly defined and priced.
- 31:19So that's something that has to be negotiated
- 31:21upfront and included in the contract because
- 31:25if it's not defined, it becomes expected. And
- 31:28if it's not priced, then it becomes a dispute
- 31:31later on. So that is a constant struggle for
- 31:34creators with brands because brands want to extend
- 31:38the scope of what the original engagement was.
- 31:41And then that's where you go. down a rabbit hole
- 31:45in doing one of one publicity event and then
- 31:49doing another post and and so forth. So let's
- 31:54let's go on to the next slide and see how an
- 31:59example of how scope can be expanded beyond content.
- 32:03So this clause requires that the influencer to
- 32:06attend in -person promotional appearances. First
- 32:10class this might seem minor. But this actually
- 32:13is a significant additional obligation on top
- 32:16of what they've already been engaged to perform.
- 32:20So from a brand perspective, it is absolutely
- 32:23valuable, right? They're getting extra publicity.
- 32:25They're getting more exposure, more access to
- 32:27the creator, and more ways to leverage the partnership.
- 32:31But from a creator's perspective, this is much
- 32:34a heavier lift, right? And if this isn't clearly
- 32:38scoped and compensated, this is where disputes
- 32:41can really start. So compensation should be tied
- 32:46to these type of appearances. Then you have to
- 32:49go into the weeds, right? Travel, is the creator
- 32:53going to be compensated for travel? Or are there
- 32:59any type of time limits? Are they supposed to
- 33:02show up for the entire publicity event? So there's
- 33:06also scheduling parameters that have to be negotiated
- 33:11in advance and incorporated in a contract. So
- 33:15lots of these type of details have to be Negotiated
- 33:24talked about discussed previously because then
- 33:26you go into the the issues right of whether or
- 33:30not this was this is going to be compensated
- 33:33by the brand or not the brand would like It is
- 33:39in the brand's best interest to leave these things
- 33:41a little bit more open right in some respects
- 33:47because then they can just have the creator perform
- 33:54these additional obligations with not necessarily
- 33:57additional compensation. So it just depends what
- 34:00side you are on, but it's very important to think
- 34:04about these things and incorporate them in the
- 34:06contract beforehand. Because you never know with
- 34:08content creation, there might be a nice video
- 34:10that gained a lot of traction and made a lot
- 34:15of, they made a lot of reshares by different
- 34:19people, right? gained a lot of audience members.
- 34:23And then that might evolve into something else.
- 34:27So it's always good to think about it with those
- 34:30things in mind. And as transactional attorneys,
- 34:35our job is to think ahead, right? We're always
- 34:38thinking about issues that can arise. And so
- 34:41incorporating those skills into these type of
- 34:44contracts. It's going to be helpful in preventing
- 34:48disputes in the long run. So if we can go to
- 34:52tip number seven on the next slide. So usage
- 34:58rights, how the brand can use the content. So
- 35:02who can use it is only that brand. Sometimes
- 35:05brands have different types of subsidiaries.
- 35:07And so it's important to ensure as a brand that
- 35:12it's not just for depending right depending on
- 35:16how you want to use it but maybe it's going to
- 35:18be that type of video it's going to be applicable
- 35:21to the other types of subsidiaries that you have
- 35:24in connection with your brand or you know if
- 35:26you have other type of brands that you like L
- 35:30'Oreal L 'Oreal is a is a big big brand and so
- 35:34they have different types of products so can
- 35:37they use it for other um other your types of
- 35:41products as well that video if it's relevant
- 35:43so those are things to think about for what purpose
- 35:48can they use the content whether paid ads are
- 35:51included or not the duration of those rights
- 35:55is it's indefinitely basically who's going to
- 36:01own the content at the end right from a brand
- 36:05perspective they want the broad usage rights,
- 36:09the ability to repurpose content across different
- 36:12platforms because that is cost -effective, efficient,
- 36:17and especially if they want to use it to promote
- 36:20different types of products, right? It's going
- 36:22to be very beneficial for the brand. For a creator's
- 36:28perspective, this is where they need to be a
- 36:30bit careful because broader usage rights means
- 36:35more exposure for the brand, but also more commercial
- 36:39exploitation of their likeness, right? And that
- 36:42should definitely come at a higher price. So
- 36:45let's say a brand takes a creator's content and
- 36:48runs it as paid ads for a year. But if the contract
- 36:52doesn't distinguish between content and usage
- 36:56rights, the brand may be getting the value essentially
- 37:01for free. So those things need to be priced separately.
- 37:05So it is very important to make sure that it
- 37:10is very clear as to who owns it, who can use
- 37:14it, who owns it, what's the purpose for it, whether
- 37:17paid ads are included or not, because those are
- 37:20types of issues that as attorneys on the other
- 37:24side, we tend to So it is very important that
- 37:30those are clearly upfront negotiated in advance
- 37:34and make sure that you're taking into account
- 37:38and foreseeing these kind of things. So if we
- 37:42can go to tip number 8, exclusivity. So exclusivity
- 37:51clauses are one of the most common sources of
- 37:54disputes in creator agreements. And the reason
- 37:57is they're almost always drafted too broadly.
- 38:01So how do you fix that, right? So it's very important
- 38:05to name the specific type of competitors if possible.
- 38:12Clearly defining the category. and setting a
- 38:16diff for a beauty brand, right? Are they only
- 38:19going to be hired to create content on a particular
- 38:24makeup brand or is it does beauty like if they're
- 38:29hired to promote this beauty brand encompass
- 38:31all the products that this beauty brand carries,
- 38:35right? Because in makeup there's so many different
- 38:37things. They can do content for eyeshadow, actually
- 38:42foundation, mascara, all these different things,
- 38:46right? So you want to make sure as content creator
- 38:51to ensure like what are you being asked to develop
- 38:58right what kind of products and as the as the
- 39:02brand making sure that they know you're protecting
- 39:07your brand right because you wouldn't want to
- 39:09hire a content creator to do promotional content
- 39:13for a particular type of foundation and then
- 39:16you see them promoting another competitor right
- 39:20so so it is very important to make sure that
- 39:25it is you get really granular If your agreement
- 39:29just says creator may not work with competing
- 39:31brands, what does that actually mean, right?
- 39:34Does it mean the exact same product, the broader
- 39:37category like all cosmetics or anything remotely
- 39:40related? But from a brand perspective, they want
- 39:45broad exclusivity to fully protect their investment
- 39:48in the campaign. So it is from a brand, you would
- 39:53want to think of it about it more broadly, right?
- 39:57and to ensure that the creator that you've chosen
- 40:02to promote the products within your campaign
- 40:06to not take part in competing advertising efforts.
- 40:12and is very important for that. But from a creator's
- 40:16perspective, the kind of language can restrict
- 40:19a significant portion of their livelihood. Remember
- 40:22content creators do this for a living. They have
- 40:25replaced their full -time jobs with creating
- 40:28content and videos and photos and all these different
- 40:31things. So if you restrict a content creator
- 40:35from doing any type of promotional content for
- 40:41a cosmetics line, and that's what they're known
- 40:45for, then you've kind of eliminated their availability
- 40:49to partake in other campaigns for other brands.
- 40:55So as counsel for creators, then you would have
- 40:59to really try to negotiate, okay, what does it
- 41:04mean, right? Competing. competitors or a competing
- 41:09industry or things like that and make sure that
- 41:12you're protecting your creator in the long run.
- 41:18And that's where the issue really arises. So
- 41:22not necessarily from that faith, I would say,
- 41:25but from different interpretations of the same
- 41:27clause. Let's take a look at an example on the
- 41:31next slide. So this is an exclusivity clause.
- 41:39So here's how an exclusivity clause is seen in
- 41:42practice and compared to what we discussed earlier.
- 42:02The agreement is identifying the restricted parties
- 42:06directly. So from my brand perspective, this
- 42:14is helpful. It creates a clear, enforceable boundaries
- 42:16around who the content creator can work with.
- 42:20But from a creator's perspective, this is much
- 42:23more workable than a broad restriction, right?
- 42:25Because they know exactly what's off limits and
- 42:27everything else is fair game. So very clearly
- 42:30defined, if they're engaging with a cosmetics
- 42:33brand and they're just hired to develop content
- 42:36related to foundation, then that's basically
- 42:39it. And so it kind of delineates what content
- 42:45they can and cannot create. And also what kind
- 42:51of different, because sometimes creators might
- 42:54just focus on one type of line of promoting type
- 42:58of content, and then other creators have added
- 43:01more variety to their content creation. So they
- 43:04don't only focus on makeup, but they focus on,
- 43:07let's say, working out and health and fitness
- 43:11and different types of areas, right? So then
- 43:15let's say you have a brand that is all in the
- 43:18health and fitness industry. So they develop
- 43:21workout clothes, supplements, things like that.
- 43:27Then and you just hired this content creator
- 43:30just to promote gear and do promotional content
- 43:43for their end, right? So those are things that
- 43:46If you're hiring one content creator to do a
- 43:49specific work for your particular business, right?
- 43:54But then they have, your business has different
- 43:57avenues, then they sell different products, different
- 44:01merchandise. How are you going to distinguish
- 44:03between those and how are you going to restrict
- 44:06a creator from? engaging in promoting a particular
- 44:11type of product supplements or whatnot, so it's
- 44:16very Useful as a brand to also think about those
- 44:20things and making sure that Even though they
- 44:25the creators known for a particular area. They're
- 44:28not going to be promoting competitors that might
- 44:34might not sort of align to what you're doing
- 44:37as well, but it's best that there's a clear distinction
- 44:42between the two. So let's go to tip number nine,
- 44:47take down. So take down clauses are really about
- 44:51crisis control, right? So they're not heavily
- 44:53negotiated until something actually goes wrong.
- 44:56So what do you need to define? Who has the right
- 44:59to request a removal? How quickly can the must
- 45:04the creator respond and who bears the liability
- 45:07if the content stays up? So because timing is
- 45:11everything in these situations. So I creator.
- 45:15becomes controversial. Let's say they become
- 45:17controversial overnight. So with these creators,
- 45:20they're like engaging in so many different things.
- 45:22And let's say it's a good image for your particular
- 45:25brand, right? You hired them to develop content
- 45:29promoting this product that you're about to launch.
- 45:32And it turns out they've... They're engaging
- 45:35in other content that you do not know, right?
- 45:40They either have an OnlyFans account or they've
- 45:43engaging in other types of activities that it
- 45:49creates a bad reputation to be associated with
- 45:52your brand. So now the brand needs that content
- 45:55taken down immediately, right? Everyone doesn't
- 45:58address this. You're negotiating in real time
- 46:02during a PR crisis essentially. So which is the
- 46:05worst possible moment to be negotiating anything.
- 46:08So from a brand perspective, they want broad
- 46:11immediate takedown rights with short response
- 46:14when there was sometimes 24 hours or less. So
- 46:18that's favorable for the brand. From a creator's
- 46:22perspective, Creators want time limits. For example,
- 46:26ensuring takedown requests are reasonable, that
- 46:29they're not being asked to remove content arbitrarily.
- 46:32They will also want to promote clarity around
- 46:36it. Who is responsible if something goes wrong
- 46:38after posting? So those are some things to think
- 46:44about. Who is going to be responsible to take
- 46:49down a particular ad? Are you going to also have,
- 46:52as the brand, are you going to be able to have
- 46:53access to that content creator's account and
- 46:57take it down or do you have to wait on them?
- 46:59Do you include a morality clause tied to a takedown?
- 47:03Does the brand have unilateral removal rights
- 47:05or is there a standard that must be met? So those
- 47:09are the questions that need to be asked while
- 47:11drafting this type of section. um as a a few
- 47:16key takeaways I would say that takedown clauses
- 47:20aren't just operational they're about allocating
- 47:24reputational risk right and if you don't define
- 47:26them clearly you're leaving both sides exposed
- 47:29at the at the exam moment where risk is the highest
- 47:34so it is very important to also ensure that um
- 47:40thinking about from the brand's perspective,
- 47:42right? Thinking about how you want your product
- 47:44being associated when you're engaging with these
- 47:46content creators. Because I've had clients on
- 47:48the brand side that specifically do not want
- 47:52content creators engaging in OnlyFans. They do
- 47:56not want that. So ensuring that they're not going
- 48:00to engage in that type of work, it has to be
- 48:05delineated in the contract. And if they decide
- 48:09to down the line open an OnlyFans account and
- 48:11engage in that type of activity, then basically,
- 48:16they're in breach of their agreement. And then
- 48:20the content, they have the right to take down
- 48:23the content that they've promoted previously.
- 48:28So things like that are also very important to
- 48:32make sure that as the brand, you're still promoting
- 48:36your brand, you're making sure that it is not
- 48:41going to be associated with activities that your
- 48:47company or brand is not part of, right? You don't
- 48:51want to be associated with those things in the
- 48:54case of the brand. But in the case of the content
- 48:57creator, you still want to have control, right?
- 49:01Even though these content creators are Developing
- 49:05content on behalf of brands. They still want
- 49:07to have be able to have control as they have
- 49:09control with the editing with the filming With
- 49:12the vision of the campaign in the creative space.
- 49:15They also want to have some sort of control in
- 49:17terms of Taking down removing posts in case you
- 49:21know something goes down so that is also something
- 49:26to look for as well and think about before going
- 49:30through the going through the contract drafting.
- 49:35So let's go to the next slide in terms of boilerplate
- 49:41terms. So boilerplate. So boilerplate terms and
- 49:46conditions, this is where sophisticated deals
- 49:49tend to fall apart because these are provisions
- 49:53people tend to skim, especially content creators.
- 49:58They're representing themselves, right? there's
- 50:02a lot of terms and conditions that they just
- 50:04come over. But they're often the ones that control
- 50:08what happens when things go wrong. So when you're
- 50:13reviewing disagreements, there are a few areas
- 50:15you really want to focus on. operating the terms
- 50:21like the platforms terms of service. So sometimes
- 50:25in these boilerplate terms, oftentimes there
- 50:29will be incorporation of different platforms,
- 50:32the terms of service of let's say, TikTok or
- 50:35Instagram or other types of platforms, right,
- 50:38incorporated in there. So that's really important
- 50:42to piece out and really take the time to assess
- 50:47what's what is actually included in the terms
- 50:51and conditions. Also, there's indemnification
- 50:56and limitation of liability, reps and warranties,
- 51:00and ownership of the content, which is huge.
- 51:04And it's huge because you want to make sure who
- 51:08owns the content at the end. And is it the brand
- 51:14itself? Was the creator just hired? Assessed
- 51:31and actually you have to read through the terms
- 51:35of terms and conditions of the agreement and
- 51:38make sure at the end who owns the who owns the
- 51:42content right, but many agreements. are structured
- 51:47as work for hire or full assignments to the brand.
- 51:57Sometimes it's either work for hire or the creator
- 52:03assigns it to the brand. Also, it covers Disputes
- 52:09right over who can reuse the content as we mentioned
- 52:13earlier, right? Who can we use the content? Who
- 52:15has those usage rights? It's very important who
- 52:19can license it. And what. And use different their
- 52:32own portfolio of 2 and many of these. Agreements,
- 52:39especially. Then the of conditions, and most
- 52:46people think it's just. Hi, April, could you
- 52:53repeat the last sentence or start over with the
- 52:56last sentence? Oh, did I freeze? Yeah, it looks
- 53:05like. connection is kind of. Yeah, so I was talking
- 53:09about the standard terms and conditions. Yeah.
- 53:16Okay. Can you hear me now? It looks like it's
- 53:20stabilized a bit. If you could just repeat that
- 53:22point again, just to make sure you can get a
- 53:25better train of your thought. Yeah, of course.
- 53:31So I was talking about the terms and conditions.
- 53:33It's really important to piece them out because
- 53:37sometimes, as I mentioned, it incorporates platform
- 53:42rules. And it's very important that the creator
- 53:46knows, if you're a creator's counsel, to know
- 53:49what they're actually agreeing to because it
- 53:51might not just be the standard terms of content.
- 53:55standards, terms, and conditions that are typical
- 53:59in an agreement. But it might be that there's
- 54:03TikTok's platform rules embedded in there, right?
- 54:07And so now the content creator is responsible
- 54:11for that as well. So it's very important to understand
- 54:15what they're agreeing to. And in terms of the
- 54:19brand, it's really important. That terms of conditions
- 54:24include ownership, right? Because as a brand,
- 54:28you want to be able to own the content. You don't
- 54:31want to be licensing content from the creator.
- 54:35You want to make sure that either they're doing
- 54:40worker or hire agreements with the brand or they're
- 54:46assigning the content rights over to you. And
- 54:52so that way you can use it as as you place moving
- 54:57forward. So then that's really important. Also
- 55:00termination rights, right? A lot of what happens
- 55:04with brands hiring on content creators is what
- 55:07I've seen is that they get content creators get
- 55:10really excited to get their first brand deal
- 55:12and then they start. they start receiving a lot
- 55:17of merchandise, clothes, cosmetics, et cetera.
- 55:20And then they decide not to continue with the
- 55:24development of promoting the brand, right? They
- 55:28stop doing the haul videos, the Instagram reels,
- 55:34things like that. So very important that you're
- 55:38also putting how can you terminate them right
- 55:41and if there's something that they have to give
- 55:43back they have to reimburse things like that
- 55:45just to protect the brand and making sure that
- 55:50content creators are not just at first creating
- 55:54content just to get the merchandise and all these
- 55:59things right but are actually complying with
- 56:05what they were hired to do. So that's really
- 56:10important. So those are the 10 tips of content
- 56:16creation and drafting. And those are the typical
- 56:20points that you will see in sections within an
- 56:25agreement that are heavily negotiated and are
- 56:29pretty the standard structure of a contract.
- 56:34brand deal between a creator and a brand. So
- 56:39please let me know if you have any questions.
- 56:43I'm opening it up for questions. We only have
- 56:46around three minutes left, but happy to answer
- 56:51any questions that you've encountered as you've
- 56:54been engaging in these deals. All right, April.
- 57:00So it actually looks like we have quite a few
- 57:02questions. Um, in the Q and a right now, so it
- 57:06looks like Joey is asking when the deal includes
- 57:08paid. Oh, I can hear you. You're cutting in and
- 57:10out. Okay. Joey is asking when the deal includes
- 57:18paid usage a little bit of it. Do you mind putting
- 57:30in the chat? Because I hear you. Okay. Yeah,
- 57:37so it's here. It's within the Q &A feature. Just
- 57:43one second. Okay, so when the deal includes paid
- 58:07usage of the content from blend to cap or limit
- 58:10the ad spend, what is the industry standard here?
- 58:15So usually with paid paid advertising, what I've
- 58:24seen from my you know, the deals that I've created
- 58:27is that new brands will usually limit the type
- 58:30of spend per ad. And so they'll make sure that
- 58:36there are certain parameters in terms of the
- 58:38cap. So that way, they're not using most of the
- 58:44budget for that particular campaign. So in terms
- 58:49of how I've seen brands navigate this is, yeah,
- 58:53they usually will put a cap on it. And to ensure
- 58:56that their ads are being efficiently utilized.
- 59:02there because each ad is very costly for brands
- 59:05so that's how they usually tend to do it so I
- 59:17have another question. So even in the absence
- 59:20of the kill fee provision, wouldn't the covenant
- 59:23of good faith and fair dealing still requirement
- 59:25still require payment if the creator completes
- 59:28the work and only fails to publish because the
- 59:30mind this reminds me of the situation when an
- 59:33employer fails to pay commission because the
- 59:36work is no longer employed because the employer
- 59:38laid the worker off thoughts. Yes. So what I've
- 59:43seen with, you know, depending on on the brand,
- 59:46but that's been like a constant struggle with
- 59:49content creators, right? Not being paid by doing
- 59:54the work, right? And so that's why we've been
- 59:58focusing a lot on, as counsel for creators, making
- 1:00:03sure that there's actually a kill fee involved.
- 1:00:07Because what happens is that payment is usually
- 1:00:12not guaranteed. And so unless, you know, like,
- 1:00:18so it's different ways of also structuring payment
- 1:00:21too. So what I usually do with my, you know,
- 1:00:25when I'm representing our content creators, I
- 1:00:27make sure that payment is guaranteed upon delivery,
- 1:00:31right? Because they, I want to ensure that they
- 1:00:35get paid regardless of the, if the campaign ever,
- 1:00:40if the campaign actually came to fruition or
- 1:00:42not. So. So that's really important. So that's
- 1:00:46why it's usually that I put that language in
- 1:00:50there. But I've run into other attorneys that
- 1:00:54have dealt with creators not getting compensated
- 1:00:58at all. And so that's why it's really recommended
- 1:01:01to at least put a kill fee because they might
- 1:01:04be working in developing this this video. They've
- 1:01:07completed X amount. X amount of time, right,
- 1:01:15in developing. It's not completed yet, but they've
- 1:01:21spent a lot of time and then let's say they pull
- 1:01:23the plug on the campaign, right? So then they
- 1:01:27still have to, they should be compensated for
- 1:01:29at least part of the work that they've delivered
- 1:01:32or invested their time on. So that's why it's
- 1:01:36very important to have that type of kill fee.
- 1:01:40provision in there. Feel free to send me other
- 1:01:46kind of questions. I'm happy to discuss this
- 1:01:49individually as well. Maybe you have any other
- 1:01:53types of questions or if I could share some insight
- 1:01:57in terms of like bullet point outlines of what
- 1:02:03I typically see in addition to this presentation.
- 1:02:06I've been happy to serve as a resource. So this
- 1:02:09concludes our presentation, my presentation with
- 1:02:15the Beverly Hills Bar Association. So yes, happy
- 1:02:18to answer any questions after this. Just feel
- 1:02:21free to contact me.