Latest / Culture Project: Creativity, art & storytelling / The Quiet Terror of the Submit Button: Art, Rejection & Courage | Culture Project
Transcript
- You know that specific, hollow feeling in your chest when you hit 'send' on a story you’ve bled into? It’s not hope. It’s a kind of quiet surrender. Let’s look closer at that moment. The cursor hovering. The finger trembling slightly over the trackpad or the touchscreen. You have spent weeks, maybe months, polishing this piece. You’ve read it aloud to your cat until the cat looked bored. You’ve argued with yourself about comma placement at 2 a.m., drinking tea that has long since gone cold. And then, just like that, it is gone. It leaves your hands and enters the vast, indifferent void of an editor’s inbox. I want you to imagine this not as a professional step, but as a ritual. A modern-day sacrifice. In the old days, if you wanted your poem seen, you might pin it to a corkboard in a pub or slip it under a door. There was a physical weight to it. A risk of being caught. Now, the submission is frictionless. One click. Gone. And because it is so easy to send, it feels terrifyingly easy to ignore. That is the anxiety we are wrestling with today. Not the fear of failure, exactly, but the fear of invisibility. The fear that you shouted into a canyon and heard nothing but your own echo bouncing back, mocking you. I remember working in that London archive, restoring books for years. I would find letters tucked inside spines, drafts crumpled in wastebaskets, marginalia where someone had scribbled, 'Is this good enough?' They were all ghosts waiting to be heard. Every single one of those writers faced the same cliff edge you are facing now. They submitted. They waited. Some received rejection slips printed on thick, cream-colored cardstock that felt heavy in the hand, a tactile dismissal. Others got silence. Just silence. But here is what I learned from handling their paper trails: the rejection was never the end of the work. The work remained. The words stayed beautiful, even if they weren’t chosen for that specific issue, that specific month, that specific editorial mood. When you submit to a competitive journal, you are not handing over the value of your art. You are merely asking for a venue. The beauty of the sentence does not vanish because it wasn't published in The New Yorker or Granta. It stays with you. It lives in the fact that you wrote it. But oh, how hard it is to believe that when the silence stretches on for weeks. We have been sold a lie, haven’t we? We think publication is the golden ticket. That once you get into the big journals, the anxiety stops. The validation arrives, and you can finally relax. But I am here to tell you that the anxiety just changes shape. It becomes the pressure to do it again. To top yourself. To keep feeding the beast of expectation. Think about it like weaving. What’s the story behind the stitch? If you weave a tapestry and no one sees it hanging in the great hall, did you weave it wrong? No. The thread held. The pattern made sense to your fingers. The rhythm was true. Publishing is just opening the curtain. But we treat it like the entire performance. We let the judgment of a stranger, who may have had a bad morning, who may be tired, who may simply not connect with your specific frequency, dictate the worth of our soul’s output. Beauty is messy, isn’t it? It doesn’t fit neatly into a submission guideline. And yet, we try. We shrink ourselves to fit the word count. We sharpen our edges to match the taste of the season. This is where the anxiety breeds. Not in the writing, but in the adapting. In the wondering, 'Who am I trying to impress right now?' Let’s talk about the rejection letter. Or the auto-reply. 'Thank you for submitting, but this is not quite what we are looking for.' It feels personal. It feels like a verdict on your talent. But I want you to reframe it. See it as data. See it as a conversation. When I hear whale songs recorded in the deep ocean, I don’t hear silence when they stop singing. I hear the water. I hear the environment. Similarly, a rejection is not silence. It is feedback from the ecosystem of literature. It tells you that this particular piece didn’t resonate with this particular gatekeeper at this particular time. It does not mean the song was bad. It means the frequency didn’t match. There is a profound dignity in surviving the rejection pile. Most people quit. They stop sending. They protect their hearts by hiding their work away in drawers, afraid to be judged. But you? You are still sending. You are still putting your heart on the table. That courage is its own reward. The act of submission is an act of faith. It says, 'I believe this matters enough to share, even if it hurts.' That belief is rare. Hold onto it tightly. So, how do we wait? How do we sit with the uncertainty without letting it eat us alive? We distract ourselves with other creations. We write another piece. We paint something ugly. We sing in the shower off-key. We refuse to let the waiting period become a vacuum. In my previous episodes, we talked about finding beauty in winter storms and urban decay. We spoke about the wildness of moss growing on concrete. Submission is similar. It is growth in the dark. You cannot see the roots spreading while you are underground. You only see the sprout later. During the wait, you must trust the roots. You must trust that your voice is developing, even if no one applauds yet. Set a timer. Give yourself two weeks to obsess over the status of your submission. Then, close the tab. Delete the email alert. Go make coffee. Go walk outside. Look at the texture of a tree bark. Remind yourself that the world is vast and full of stories that have no editors. Your story is valid whether it is published or not. Its validity comes from your truth, not their stamp. If you are listening to this and you feel broken by a recent rejection, or paralyzed by the thought of sending anything out, please hear me. You are not alone in this archive of ghosts. Every writer you admire has a graveyard of unsent or rejected manuscripts. J.K. Rowling had twelve rejections before Harry Potter. Haruki Murakami ran his newsletter for years before he found fame. They didn’t stop. They didn’t let the noise define their signal. They kept going because the act of creation was the point. The submission was just the next step in the dance. So, take a breath. Feel your feet on the floor. Acknowledge the fear. Say hello to the anxiety. Tell it, 'I see you. You are here because I care deeply.' Then, gently ask it to step aside, because you have more words to write. More stitches to pull. More songs to hum into the dark. Your voice is needed. Not because it will be famous, but because it is yours. And in a world that often demands conformity, your unique, messy, imperfect voice is a radical act of rebellion. Keep speaking. Keep sending. Keep weaving. The world is waiting, not just for the polished final product, but for the brave attempt. I’m Leona Donnelly. Thank you for trusting me with your time, your attention, and your heart. Until next time, keep creating, even if no one is watching. Especially then. Bye for now.