Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / Mining the Future: Why Critical Minerals Are America’s New Backbone
Transcript
- 0:04Hello and welcome to the American Council of Engineering Companies Engineering Influence podcast.
- 0:10My name is Thomas Grogan. I'm the chief economist at ACEC and I'm very happy
- 0:15today to be joined by Dan Paolo, vice president and senior process engineer at Barr Engineering.
- 0:23Today's podcast we're going to talk about critical minerals and I think to kind
- 0:27of you know get started on that topic Dan why don't you introduce yourself and
- 0:31tell us a bit about your background and then we'll get into critical minerals.
- 0:37Sure. Thank you, Thomas. I'm happy to be here and hope this is informative for everybody.
- 0:42As you mentioned, I'm Principal Vice President at Bar Engineering Company,
- 0:46Senior Process Engineer, Chemical Engineer by Training.
- 0:50I have 26 years of experience. The first 12 were in applied research and development.
- 0:57And then in the last 14 years, I've been at Bar Engineering.
- 1:00So I'm based in Southern California. I'm assigned to our Salt Lake office in the Western US.
- 1:06And from there, I've been leading teams that are doing a lot of work on the
- 1:11critical mineral space, especially for clients in the West, Western US, Canada, and elsewhere.
- 1:19I work with a lot of multi-discipline teams, and the projects tend to range
- 1:25from the whole spectrum, from scoping studies and very early stage,
- 1:31all the way through your detailed design for construction.
- 1:35Well, you know, I think critical minerals are having a moment right now.
- 1:41And that's a big reason why we wanted to do this podcast and get you on.
- 1:45I think before we kind of get into this moment that we're having,
- 1:48maybe we could first start by, you know, setting the stage for our audience
- 1:52by defining what it is we mean when we talk about critical minerals.
- 1:57And then we could get into their importance right now as they're pretty top
- 2:01of mind for anyone working in industry today. Sure.
- 2:05If we look at the one slide that I provided to you, there's a whole list of
- 2:10them. There's currently 60 of them.
- 2:13And the Energy Act defines a critical mineral right now as being essential to
- 2:19economic or national security,
- 2:21being vulnerable to supply chain disruption for one reason or another,
- 2:26and also being serving an essential function in manufacturing in some way relative
- 2:33to those things. things.
- 2:35And the slide that I provided shows one of my favorite things, the periodic table.
- 2:41And for clarity, I took out all of the non-naturally occurring elements so that
- 2:47it's even more clear that when you say 60 minerals or 60 elements from the periodic
- 2:52table, you're talking about two-thirds of the periodic table.
- 2:56Everything from the lightest metal, which is lithium, all the way to the heaviest
- 3:00metal, natural one, which is uranium.
- 3:03And not everything in between there is included, but you can see that a wide
- 3:10swath of the periodic table is addressed with these 60.
- 3:15The other thing that is super important here is,
- 3:20And relative to the definition that the Energy Act provides is on slide two,
- 3:26we see that there's 12 of those critical elements that are 100% where the U.S.
- 3:34Is 100% dependent on imports.
- 3:36And then there's another 31 where we're at least 50% dependent on imports.
- 3:42And so you see that that applies to the vast majority of those that are identified as critical.
- 3:50And then you throw in,
- 3:52any other disruption sort of vulnerabilities, and then that makes up the rest
- 3:58of the list. And so it's pretty comprehensive.
- 4:01And it also speaks to how dependent we are on a lot of different technologies
- 4:08and things that go into them.
- 4:10Yeah, no, I mean, I think that's really, you know, interesting and eye-opening
- 4:15that about two-thirds of the periodic table are essentially these critical minerals,
- 4:20you know, that essentially are naturally occurring.
- 4:24So some amount of mining or extraction is needed to get these out of the earth
- 4:31and, you know, into a usable state.
- 4:36I think, you know, maybe for some of these critical minerals,
- 4:40what are some of the big ticket end items that are,
- 4:46so let's say we extract lithium or helium or potassium, You know,
- 4:50what are they going into that are being used,
- 4:54let's say, in construction, building a hospital, building a data center,
- 5:00building a wastewater facility?
- 5:02What are kind of those end components that are dependent on some of these critical minerals?
- 5:08Yeah, good question, because you can easily get lost in the fact that there
- 5:12are so many of them and they all have their...
- 5:15Some of them are very niche. now if you
- 5:18look at lithium it's most people are aware
- 5:21of lithium we're aware of lithium ion batteries they're aware
- 5:25of its criticality the u.s actually produces a fair amount of lithium and we're
- 5:29working on developing even more but that one that one's i think most people
- 5:35know that the the primary use there is in lithium ion batteries for data center for you know power.
- 5:44Energy storage, excuse me, for energy storage,
- 5:48Electric cars, all of our devices that we use every day that have batteries in them.
- 5:54And then if you think about others, another one is copper.
- 5:58We talk about the electrification of everything.
- 6:03Well, you've got to get those electrons to where they need to go.
- 6:06And there's a lot of copper involved in that and transmission and distribution of electricity.
- 6:12If you look at the rare earth elements, which are all the ones you can't pronounce
- 6:16at the bottom of the periodic table, So,
- 6:18again, back to the whole niche thing, they're very important for high-intensity
- 6:23magnets and other things that have to do with defense, high-tech, all kinds of things.
- 6:30And finally, you know, kind of going from lithium to uranium,
- 6:36uranium is kind of having a moment as well, apart from being listed as a critical
- 6:42element because of the power needs of data centers and electrification.
- 6:48And so it's an interesting time for uranium. There's really a lot of activity
- 6:53there as well. So you can kind of see how it cuts across the whole.
- 6:58Economy for the United States. Yeah, absolutely.
- 7:02And, you know, you had started to bring up that some of these elements such
- 7:06as lithium, the US is also producing.
- 7:09And so thinking back on slide two, for those, you know, other elements that
- 7:15we are at 100% dependent on, you know, basically importing those in the US today,
- 7:23you know, what are we producing,
- 7:26mining, extracting.
- 7:29And, you know, what are those key minerals that we are dependent on importing
- 7:36for and, you know, dependent on supply chains as well?
- 7:39Yeah, the big one has been, if I think about imports, the big one has been kind
- 7:45of broadly the rare earth elements.
- 7:47So there's been a lot of focus on how can we onshore something like that,
- 7:54whereas things like copper silver
- 7:58is on the list are things that we've
- 8:01they're elements that we've produced in the united states in relatively high
- 8:04quantities but they're still critical for
- 8:07one reason or another because of the increased demand that's expected or or
- 8:12other reasons like that and so we we produce a lot of minerals on in the u.s
- 8:18one one other example boron is on the list I live here in Southern California
- 8:23near one of the largest borax mines in the world.
- 8:27And there's a huge resource there. It's been mined for many decades,
- 8:32but yet it's on the critical list for reasons that may not have to do with the
- 8:38fact that we produce so much of it, but other things.
- 8:42Other considerations. And so, you know, you look at that, you look at that slide
- 8:47and you see that, yeah, there's a 12 that are where we're 100 percent dependent
- 8:51and there are others where we're less dependent.
- 8:54And then the other nuance to it
- 8:56is we do import from a lot of friendly countries. Canada produces a lot.
- 9:01And so even though we're importing, we're importing from a stable,
- 9:05friendly country versus importing
- 9:09from either an adversarial country or one that's just not stable.
- 9:13There are some other smaller countries in the world that produce key elements
- 9:18like cobalt, for instance, where they may be an unstable place.
- 9:22And so there's that vulnerability there, not that they're adversarial towards
- 9:27us necessarily, but that just their own stability makes that supply chain vulnerable. Right.
- 9:35And, you know, I think as we've been talking about these critical minerals,
- 9:40we've been mentioning supply chain a few times.
- 9:44I even believe in that Energy Act definition, maybe the third or fourth, you know.
- 9:51Definition of what makes a mineral critical is it being used in manufacturing
- 9:57and, you know, strategic supply chain reasons.
- 10:02I think in the U.S., especially post-COVID, there's been a bit more of a focus
- 10:07on reshoring, building up the
- 10:11industrial base a bit more after what's happened over the past decades.
- 10:15Could you talk a bit on how you are seeing government and industry,
- 10:19you know, working together,
- 10:21collaborating to address these critical mineral supply chain issues and,
- 10:26you know, whether it's improving the supply of them or improving the supply
- 10:32chain so it moves more efficiently?
- 10:34Yeah, it's been...
- 10:37The thing that we all need to remember, we didn't get here overnight to this
- 10:42disposition that we're in.
- 10:43If you want to look at the vulnerability, and we're not going to get out of it overnight either.
- 10:48And so what we've seen is over the past decade or more, the government has been...
- 10:56And first of all, I want to say it's a bipartisan issue.
- 10:58There's bipartisan support. This is not a partisan issue.
- 11:03It's bipartisan support in Washington that says we've got to do something.
- 11:06We've got to help our industry to get out of where the situation we're in.
- 11:11And so one thing that we've seen, and we work a fair bit on the applied R&D
- 11:16side as well at BART and supporting those projects.
- 11:19We've been working on projects for well over 10 years on the extraction of rare
- 11:26earths from things like lignite coal.
- 11:28So where you start getting creative
- 11:31about where can we find these critical materials and extract them.
- 11:36Resources that we have right under our feet. And so the U S department of energy
- 11:41has funded a lot of research in that area.
- 11:43The department of defense has come in and, and funded certain projects.
- 11:48I've even seen them approach large companies who already operating.
- 11:55So let's say they're producing copper and the government knows,
- 11:59Oh, you've got this other element in your, or we need you to focus on making
- 12:05sure you're capturing that material because we need it.
- 12:09And and you see that happening the other thing that happened i think around
- 12:15i'm not exactly sure when it was but i think it was during the obama administration
- 12:19the cmi was set up it's the critical minerals institute it's it's based in ames
- 12:24iowa it's a kind of a national lab sort of set up.
- 12:27And one thing that they were focused on, they had multi-pronged approach,
- 12:32but one thing they were focused on was the,
- 12:35Can we find replacements for some of these key ingredients that we're so dependent on?
- 12:43And so all of that that I just said is more on that research side.
- 12:48And then you've got, more recently, the USGS has gotten involved.
- 12:53They've always been involved in mineral, kind of the yearbook of what are we
- 12:57doing, where are the resources, and things like that.
- 13:00But they've also taken on this thing called the MRI, the Earth Mapping Resource
- 13:05Initiative, which is kind of a flyover to just look at using using high tech
- 13:11to to look for elements, key elements.
- 13:14And they might be in waste piles somewhere in an existing mine.
- 13:18And you get that kind of surface view, but it's an initial look at,
- 13:24oh, there may be this may be a good place to go drill for for resource.
- 13:30Fast 41 has come in. Some people have heard about that. That has to do with
- 13:34transparency in permitting.
- 13:37It doesn't necessarily change the permitting laws, but it's meant to create
- 13:42a more predictable and transparent permitting system for new mines and related things like that.
- 13:50And then, there's a long list, and then the USXM Bank has been involved a lot.
- 13:57They've set up Project Fault. They've set up loans with specific developers
- 14:04who are developing new resources and providing capital that way as well.
- 14:09So there's a lot going on on the governance side from the, like I said,
- 14:14kind of the R&D side of like, hey, what's possible all the way through to,
- 14:19hey, you've got a mine and you need financing, we can help you.
- 14:23So it's pretty broad.
- 14:26And so then maybe diving in a little bit on the announced Project Vault,
- 14:32which is announced in February of 2026.
- 14:35And I believe the Export-Import Bank is contributing about $10 billion.
- 14:41And then there's another $2 billion of private capital involved.
- 14:46Does that move the needle on some of the issues with either shortages or getting
- 14:55these materials into the finished state fast enough?
- 15:01What is the general timeline for something like that?
- 15:06It seems like in this space, we're talking about years, if not decades for certain
- 15:11sort of development to get, you know, maybe a system online,
- 15:17you know, kind of what do you see that impacting,
- 15:22you know, the US critical mineral market and maybe the short term?
- 15:28In the short term, if the project vault is not one vault, first of all,
- 15:33I mean, it's the different materials that are focused on and that would be stored
- 15:39in various locations, probably undisclosed.
- 15:44But it is a public-private partnership. And the idea is, if you want to have
- 15:49a pantry full of goods...
- 15:53They don't have to initially come from domestic production.
- 15:57And so those supply chains that are open right now, you can be stockpiling.
- 16:02But the public-private part of it is that the private end users are buying into
- 16:08it and sort of paying their part of the timeshare, if you will.
- 16:12And so that if I'm an automotive company and I ran into shortages during COVID
- 16:19and I don't want that to happen again,
- 16:21I'm going to invest in those elements, those materials as part of the vault
- 16:27so that when the next crisis comes around,
- 16:31I can hopefully not disrupt my activity or at least lessen that because we've
- 16:40got extra food in the pantry. Yeah.
- 16:43Or for that rainy day. So that's, that's the idea behind it.
- 16:47And I think I think it's a good idea of, of, you know, getting those end users really bought into it.
- 16:53And they're going to benefit from it, but they need to invest in it as well. Right.
- 16:57And I mean, you bring up a good point about private industry who,
- 17:01for a large portion of these minerals are going into their products.
- 17:08Are you, over the past few years or even more recently,
- 17:13seeing these firms, I mean, just thinking of the amount of money we're being
- 17:18told will be spent on all the capex for data centers and AI,
- 17:23are companies being more proactive about that?
- 17:26About securing these materials themselves as opposed to maybe,
- 17:30you know, waiting on their supplier or OEM to give them, you know,
- 17:35the semiconductor or other piece of, you know, high-tech equipment.
- 17:41Yeah, you see it with companies like Tesla investing.
- 17:46General Motors has invested in lithium projects. They are going upstream on
- 17:52that supply chain to really try to secure their positions and help make sure
- 17:59that the things that they're developing that are in demand are going to be available.
- 18:06And again the focus on domestic or nearby you know they call it nearshoring,
- 18:13you may be investing in canada because
- 18:17it's because it's nearby it's friendly accessible and
- 18:21so you know for instance potash is
- 18:23on the list we get most of our potash out of canada but
- 18:28still on the critical list partially because it's such
- 18:31a high volume material it's so important to agriculture that
- 18:34you know for different reasons these things end up
- 18:37on the list but you know back to your question though especially the
- 18:40auto seeing the automotive companies kind of
- 18:43jumping into that and going going upstream for sure and so then you know thinking
- 18:50holistically how how does developing this critical mineral production you know
- 18:59really helped the U.S. industrial ecosystem.
- 19:02Well, the whole story is we're going to do it here.
- 19:08We're going to create jobs, and we're going to roll up our sleeves, and we know we can.
- 19:12And I agree with that sentiment.
- 19:16I'm part of a few trade organizations, one of which is the Society for Mining,
- 19:21Mineralogy, and Exploration.
- 19:24Mining, Metallurgy, and Exploration, SME. I'll just say SME.
- 19:30And as a society, we've been focused on this, this issue, this critical minerals,
- 19:34but also the fact that because the mining industry in the U.S.
- 19:38Has its ups and downs, if it's down long enough, the universities are shutting
- 19:43down certain programs because there's no students or there's no demand, right? Right.
- 19:47So mining programs in the United States, there used to be a lot more of them.
- 19:52They've started coming back or they come back in different forms within existing
- 19:57departments in those universities.
- 19:58But that sort of ebb and flow can really be a challenge for having the trained workforce.
- 20:06So you talk about education, there's the training for just skilled workers that
- 20:10are going to operate these plants or do the maintenance on them.
- 20:16Or those that are going to build them. So you've got that whole workforce issue.
- 20:21And then again, can we do it? Yeah, we can do it. People want high-paying jobs.
- 20:25They want stable work. They want to work on things that are important.
- 20:30The other thing that the SME has done, the part of what's called the Mineral Education Coalition.
- 20:37The MEC is really big on let's get into the school.
- 20:41So let's get into the grade schools and, you know, show them a rock and say,
- 20:45this looks like a rock to you.
- 20:47But, you know, what's in this comes out and it's in your cell phone or it's,
- 20:51you know, to educate the public that all of these things you enjoy as part of
- 20:56this, this modern economy that we have.
- 21:00They all come from somewhere and we are educating people that this doesn't happen by accident, right?
- 21:09And that if we want it to come from us and not a country that either pollutes
- 21:14or treats their people poorly or is adversarial to us, then we need to invest here.
- 21:20And we need to see that something like mining and manufacturing are not inherently
- 21:24bad and evil and polluting, but that they can be done right.
- 21:27We have very strong environmental laws in this country.
- 21:31BARD works on the environmental side a lot. We help our clients with permitting
- 21:35and compliance all across industry.
- 21:39And so getting that message out and then educating the public as well.
- 21:44I was at an open house last year for a company that they do this every couple
- 21:51of years. They have an open house.
- 21:53And the community comes and they have speakers and they talk about what they're doing.
- 21:57So it's that open door of, hey, we're not just weird building,
- 22:01bleeding your water or something.
- 22:04We're part of the community too. We live here too. And that's what a lot of
- 22:08my mining colleagues have.
- 22:11The message we're trying to get out. We live here too. We care about the environment.
- 22:15But we can also responsibly source these materials domestically.
- 22:21And so there's a lot you talk about the US ecosystem,
- 22:27even you mentioned data centers there's this,
- 22:32rush to build data centers while it takes construction companies to build data
- 22:35centers of all those construction companies are busy building data centers and
- 22:40I want to go build a mining processing facility,
- 22:43and I'm looking around well where is everybody well they're busy and so you have these.
- 22:50Stresses on the overall supply chain, if you were looking at it like that.
- 22:56The other thing that we've been doing more of in this country,
- 23:01just from that same sort of ecosystem point of view, is how can we make things more circular?
- 23:07We've got companies that are signing up battery recycling facilities.
- 23:11We've been working on some of that.
- 23:13And where the cobalt, the nickel,
- 23:15the lithium that's in those batteries is coming back into the cycle.
- 23:20So it's a big question, and there's a lot there.
- 23:24And like I mentioned earlier, it takes time. It takes effort for those of us
- 23:29in the industry to go out and educate the public when they may not be getting
- 23:33a good view of what we do and how important it is.
- 23:39Yeah. You know, I think, you know, talking about.
- 23:43These issues, we see that there is very strong demand throughout from the initial
- 23:51raw item through its finished good.
- 23:54And while we are, we have supply constraints, either getting the materials out
- 24:00and over, getting them processed, the workers to do that work to then enable that whole system.
- 24:08So we're seeing supply constraints on basically a few fronts with respect to,
- 24:13you know, these critical minerals, thinking about, you know,
- 24:16the member universe of ACEC member firms, how might they be impacted by some
- 24:23of these supply constraints?
- 24:25And do you see any changes, you know, the horizon in terms of,
- 24:30you know, maybe some of these supply constraints improving or,
- 24:33you know, not maybe staying the same for a bit until more investment happens?
- 24:39Well, the way it's been for us and for those we either partner with or compete
- 24:44with, there's a lot of work out there in this series.
- 24:47And we've really been enjoying the fact that there is all of that work.
- 24:52The phone's ringing every week with a new project of some sort.
- 24:57And I'm sure a lot of your member companies are seeing that as well.
- 25:01So it might not just on the mining side, the manufacturing side,
- 25:06the infrastructure, the data centers that we've been talking about,
- 25:11those all need design work.
- 25:14They all need permitting and compliance work.
- 25:17They all need the construction and commissioning and the operation and the maintenance.
- 25:23And so, you know, think about the members of ACEC, it's touching on all of them
- 25:30in some way because it's, what are we doing? We're doing engineering.
- 25:35And it's needed in all those areas we've been talking about.
- 25:39So it's, and I'm sure, you know, those listening that are in that space are
- 25:44nodding their heads saying, yeah, it's a busy time.
- 25:47So it's an exciting time there's a lot of optimism I've seen so much optimism
- 25:54lately there are I go to a lot of mining conferences and my colleagues do too,
- 25:59The attendance has been huge. Interesting.
- 26:02They're the small regional conference that's held in Idaho every year.
- 26:06It has been growing like crazy because Idaho has cobalt.
- 26:10They've got other base metal and transition metal mines up there.
- 26:15That's just an example, but these local conferences have been very busy.
- 26:22People have been very excited. They have a lot to share.
- 26:25And so just overall for the engineering community, it's a great time to be saying,
- 26:30yeah, we're going to roll up our sleeves. We can do this, you know.
- 26:35And, you know, has this now with your, you know,
- 26:40experience and being at bar for so long, have you noticed changes or things
- 26:46that maybe you're doing differently, you know, in 2026 for the consulting engineering work you're doing?
- 26:53Given, you know, what is happening right now?
- 26:57How is, you know, how is Barr handling kind of this, as you mentioned,
- 27:02large increase in demand for this work and service? Yeah.
- 27:08It's a challenge. I think most people in consulting would say that they hate having to say no.
- 27:16And we've had to say no a little bit more than we've wanted to.
- 27:20And it might not be a no. It might be a, well, we can help you,
- 27:24but we need to partner to provide you exactly what you need.
- 27:28We've been doing quite a bit of partnering with other companies to deliver services.
- 27:37Just the sheer amount of activity or the excitement behind it and the roll up
- 27:46your sleeves kind of thing.
- 27:48I've seen that, at least with the folks we have internally, we're a flat organization.
- 27:53And so we have kind of a free market within the company. i've seen
- 27:56people say i really want to work on that project because it's
- 28:00doing x y or z it's it's moving the ball forward
- 28:03and so that's been exciting too
- 28:06because it's been so fun and and and relatively easy to to develop teams around
- 28:11the projects but then overall as a company it puts a strain on the overall workload
- 28:17and that's where partnering or having to sometimes defer things are decisions you have to make.
- 28:25But the other thing we found, and I work on the engineering side in terms of
- 28:28the design, the studies through the design work, it allows us to bring in our
- 28:35other services. We do life cycle analysis. So for instance,
- 28:40You want to make red earth elements or you want to make something that's crucial
- 28:44to the economy and should be electric economy.
- 28:48You also want to show that you're doing it responsibly and energy efficiently and that kind of thing.
- 28:53So we have folks that can provide those kinds of studies.
- 28:56We do life cycle analysis work, this whole circularity, environmental part that
- 29:03I mentioned, process hazard analysis and that kind of thing.
- 29:07Because some of these are new processes.
- 29:10For or not haven't been used a lot in the
- 29:12u.s let's say and you want to be careful that you're doing
- 29:15it doing it safely as well so it's it's
- 29:19been yeah it's a wild ride but but
- 29:23a fun one and an exciting one because we're we're
- 29:26seeing and one other thing i'll add to that is that i'm seeing
- 29:29i mentioned we work from the whole
- 29:32concept side all the way through to execution just seeing
- 29:35a lot more projects coming through where they're like we want this
- 29:38designed now we want to build it tomorrow
- 29:41we want to ride this wave before it
- 29:44goes away and so there's that like those
- 29:47projects that are going towards construction are just seem that much more urgent
- 29:52right now well you know this has been really fascinating conversation and highlighting
- 30:00just how embedded critical minerals are in our everyday lives,
- 30:05let alone what's happening in the AEC space and, you know, the economy at large.
- 30:10So as we kind of wrap things up, just wanted to, you know, give you a few moments
- 30:16to share any advice you might have to our listeners or members on what to expect,
- 30:21you know, in the future in this critical mineral space.
- 30:25Sure. I'd say all of us as professionals who understand how these things are
- 30:30done, where these materials come from, how they get to us, what it takes to produce them.
- 30:39I mentioned earlier on education, it's up to all of us to educate the public
- 30:43that this is, you know, you don't want to mine in your backyard,
- 30:48but you still want all of these things.
- 30:52And doing it the right way, too, and just positively educating the public on
- 30:58these types of issues, educating the upcoming students from elementary school upward.
- 31:06Get them excited. Hey, I want to go into mining. I want to go into manufacturing
- 31:10because it's really cool and I can be part of the solution, right?
- 31:16Or the environmental side at the same time. we
- 31:20so there's there's that aspect to it of
- 31:23of educating educating our
- 31:26you know our neighbors and such and then
- 31:29and just also remembering we didn't get here by accident look at china's position
- 31:36on this whole thing it was very well crafted over many years and so they didn't
- 31:43get their backs and we didn't get to where we are by accident we got here by
- 31:46you know you could say we took our eye off the ball or whatever.
- 31:49So it's going to take effort to turn that around, to turn the ship around kind of thing. And.
- 31:56We're doing it. And I've seen, I've seen a consistency, like I said, bipartisan.
- 32:01And so you don't have, it's not like every four years, you know,
- 32:04going 180 degrees on some of these things.
- 32:07And so it's, it's a long game.
- 32:10I think we need to be patient, but we also need to be have that urgency.
- 32:14Well, let's do what we can now and let's keep doing what we can over the next
- 32:1710 years, whatever it is.
- 32:20Cause it takes a while to permit and build a mind too.
- 32:24You can't do that overnight just because you have the rocks in the ground that
- 32:27are really nice rocks that people would like to have in their cell phones or their Teslas.
- 32:33But it takes a lot to get to that point. Right. Yeah. Now, as you mentioned,
- 32:38the whole life cycle can take a lot.
- 32:40Well, Dan, thank you and Bar Engineering so much for being part of this podcast.
- 32:46Really, really enjoyed the conversation today.