Latest / The Pin and Plan Podcast - Pinning with Purpose / How Pinterest Trust Is Built
Transcript
- 0:02So we're talking about Pinterest growth and it doesn't slow down
- 0:07because you're not creating enough content, but it could
- 0:09slow down if Pinterest doesn't clearly understand what problem
- 0:14you solve with your content or your business and so on.
- 0:17Now today we're talking about Pinterest trust and how it's
- 0:20actually built. And this episode kicks off a
- 0:23three-part miniseries that will completely, in my mind,
- 0:26completely change how you think about Pinterest and even, you
- 0:29know, how you interact with Pinterest.
- 0:31Welcome back to the Pinon Plan Podcast.
- 0:33I'm Lisa, long time Pinterest pioneer and PBC member or
- 0:38Pinterest business community member.
- 0:39We call it the PBC and I'm doing this in video today.
- 0:43So hello, this is me and I am the owner and founder of Body
- 0:47Mind Mood. Yep, Lyft and build because it's
- 0:50all about fitness for me. I love being in the gym and yes,
- 0:52I do sell these. And I'm also the owner and
- 0:55founder of the simple site lab. I love creating websites and
- 0:57website design on Squarespace with Squarespace, A longtime
- 1:01member of Squarespace as well, and I'm a bit of a nerd when it
- 1:04comes to that. Now, I'm also someone who
- 1:09honestly, if I'm being honest, I really believe that growth
- 1:13online should should not feel so crazy and unhappy and not fun
- 1:18and stressful and right. And unfortunately, a lot of
- 1:21creators, and that is my cat in the background, a lot of
- 1:24creators are really feeling the pull with having to create
- 1:29content. It should be something that's
- 1:30sustainable right? Now, if you've listened to my
- 1:33recent episode, The Pitcher's Trust Loop, then you already
- 1:36know that this idea has is something that I have and like
- 1:41really playing with in my head for quite a while.
- 1:44And that you also know that Pinterest growth isn't about
- 1:47doing more right. It's it's about building trust
- 1:50overtime. Now, as a side note, if you see
- 1:53me looking down, it's because I have notes to keep me on point,
- 1:56keep me on track. I don't really like going off
- 1:59the cuff. It makes me feel funny.
- 2:02Now this, that episode, the Pinterest Sleep really helped
- 2:05clarify clarify something for me in that it's what inspired this
- 2:09miniseries. Now over the next three weeks,
- 2:12I'm going to be breaking down how Pinterest trust is built,
- 2:16how Pinterest content actually gets found on the platform, and
- 2:19of course, how Pinterest content converts.
- 2:21Because without, you know, when we think about Pinterest content
- 2:25and how it's converting, you want to do it without all the
- 2:27pressure, the hype, and the stress and burnout that a lot of
- 2:30creators feel. So today we're starting with the
- 2:33Foundation Trust, right? It's trust.
- 2:37So let me set the framework up here for you and just take this
- 2:41idea, this first idea that I'm going to talk about with you
- 2:45through all of the series and, and, and beyond, right?
- 2:48Pinterest is not Instagram and it's not TikTok and it's not,
- 2:52right? It is more of a, I guess,
- 2:56planning platform and certainly has evolved into becoming a
- 3:00planning platform. I think that, you know, in the
- 3:01onset was not, it's also a platform where people make
- 3:05decisions. So technically it could be a
- 3:08decision platform because you go there to find solutions and then
- 3:11you kind of act on those right now.
- 3:13What does that mean? It means Pinterest does not
- 3:15reward the loud and boisterous content creators, the ones that
- 3:21grab your attention for 15 seconds or 20 seconds.
- 3:24And I don't mean that in a negative way, but it's it's not
- 3:27like that Pinterest actually rewards more creators and
- 3:32content based on how clear it is, how consistent it is, and if
- 3:38it actually helps to solve a problem or help the Pinner or
- 3:41user looking at that content, giving them something to do with
- 3:47it. Right.
- 3:48If Pinterest, in my opinion, can't really understand, you
- 3:53know, who your content is for and what it helps them do or
- 3:57right, then it doesn't really distribute it the way that you
- 4:00want it to. So don't get me wrong, Pinterest
- 4:04does distribute content, but it distributes it.
- 4:06It wouldn't distribute it as confidently if your content when
- 4:11when the algorithm is looking at it, if it's not clear about who
- 4:13it's for and what it does, then it kind of it puts it out there,
- 4:16but not really to the people that you want it to go to.
- 4:19So how Pinterest understands your content?
- 4:21Let's do this. I want to start with something
- 4:24very practical here because trust on Pinterest really does
- 4:27begin with understanding. And I think that that can be
- 4:30said for most platforms if you start off with a good with
- 4:33understanding and the trust will build before Pinterest can
- 4:37really, you know, trust your content, it has to really
- 4:41understand a few things. Specifically what your pin is
- 4:45about, who the pin is for, and what kind of problem does it
- 4:49help solve or what kind of solution or take away does it
- 4:52offer to the Pinner, the user that's looking at that content?
- 4:56Now, Pinterest has a job, right? The algorithm has a job, and
- 5:00that is to match your content with the search intent of the
- 5:04people that come on to the platform.
- 5:05And it can only do that when your content is really specific
- 5:09and easy to understand. So clarity, clarity, clarity,
- 5:12clarity. Oh yeah, clarity.
- 5:15Pinterest users don't open up the app, and I think we can all
- 5:18appreciate this and start scrolling sort of aimlessly.
- 5:21Do I look? Do I scroll aimlessly on TikTok?
- 5:26Kind of kind of. Yes, I do.
- 5:29Yes I do, but do I get on Pinterest and start scrolling
- 5:37aimlessly and hope that it's going to entertain me?
- 5:39No, I don't. You've got to remember that a
- 5:42lot of Pinterest users that come to the platform often come with
- 5:46a sort of, you know, questions in mind, one or more depending
- 5:49on what they're trying to do or what they're trying to learn
- 5:52about or achieve or decide on or buy.
- 5:55So think of things like what should I do?
- 5:58Where do I start? What's the best option for me
- 6:02and how do I fix this? These are some of the questions
- 6:03that they will ask. And so, you know, you have to be
- 6:08sort of thoughtful about it, right?
- 6:09And think about that from the perspective of the pinners and
- 6:12the users on the platform. Pinterest prioritizes content
- 6:16technically, in my opinion, that answers those questions in a
- 6:19very clear and thoughtful way, whether it's through visual pins
- 6:25like video or like photos, or whether it's through verbal
- 6:30right or if it's you've got a lot of context.
- 6:33However it's presented, as long as it it answers questions
- 6:37clearly and right, it will prioritize that content On
- 6:41Pinterest. When you talk about clear
- 6:43understanding of content, what that means is think of it like
- 6:47this. One clear topic per pin, 1 clear
- 6:51problem being solved per pin, and 1 clear result or outcome
- 6:57per pin that the Pinner or user rate, however you choose to call
- 7:00them, can take away, right? What it isn't on Pinterest is,
- 7:06for example, inspiration. That's vague.
- 7:09So the pin looks inspiring, but you're not quite sure how that
- 7:13matches the this broad lifestyle messaging, right?
- 7:18We all look, we all know the creators that speak to
- 7:20everybody. They wanna be everybody to
- 7:23every, you wanna be something to everybody.
- 7:25But they end up creating so much content and it's so broad that
- 7:29they actually don't help anybody.
- 7:31Just saying. And the present presentation in
- 7:35that kind of mindset, like when you're talking about content
- 7:38that isn't clear, it could be presented in any way.
- 7:41It can be video, it can be photos, it can be right,
- 7:44whatever. There's no set standard for
- 7:47that, really. Your pin is, you know, easy to
- 7:51understand. I believe Pinterest knows when
- 7:55to show it, right, who to show it to, and which sort of
- 8:00searches it belongs to, right? It belongs in.
- 8:03It understands it right away. There's certain things that it
- 8:06needs to know in order to do that.
- 8:09Now, clarity, we're talking about being clear on Pinterest
- 8:13and clear content and all of that.
- 8:15That is really the first layer of trust, right?
- 8:18Because Pinterest can understand you and you understand what it's
- 8:21looking for. Then hey, you've got this kind
- 8:23of like new relationship happening.
- 8:26Once Pinterest starts to understand what your content is
- 8:29and who it's for and how it helps, then the next signal that
- 8:33it watches isn't what you think. It's not comments.
- 8:37It's not likes, but it's, you know, actually saves.
- 8:42More to the point, quiet saves, right, because people are saving
- 8:46on Pinterest. But engagement on Pinterest, I
- 8:49think most people recognize is very, very quiet.
- 8:51It's not Instagram, you don't see these likes and right, it's
- 8:55not like that. Most Pinners, you know, most
- 9:00users on the platform save ideas, get this to secret
- 9:04boards. Yeah, they do.
- 9:05And and I'm not sure I'm going to say this if the algorithm
- 9:08actually knows that people are saving to private boards.
- 9:11We have actually, as pioneers have reached out to community
- 9:14manager to find out whether or not that's true.
- 9:17So keep that in the in your back pocket.
- 9:19I will let you know once I know Pinners planned quietly, right?
- 9:25They're doing it unbeknownst to the creators, and they're
- 9:29revisiting the content that they save later or consistently
- 9:34later. Like they just keep going back
- 9:35to it until they either make a decision or maybe it's just
- 9:38something they enjoy watching or whatever it is, but they're
- 9:40saving it. But they're not saving it
- 9:42outwardly. They're saving it privately on
- 9:44secret boards. So even if your pins don't get a
- 9:47lot of visible engagement, it doesn't necessarily mean that
- 9:50your content or your pins are not working.
- 9:53It just means that you can't see it.
- 9:56OK, now that isn't the case sometimes for people who come
- 9:59into the PC and say, well, you know, I've got zero impressions,
- 10:02my pins are dropping, That might be a different issue.
- 10:05This is something where you know you're posting consistently, but
- 10:08you're just not seeing those likes.
- 10:10Follows right? Your comments, you you get the
- 10:14idea. A save in my mind, especially
- 10:19one that is saved to a private board because that really is
- 10:21pretty significant, really does tell Pinterest that the content
- 10:26matters enough for this person or persons to keep.
- 10:30And that is a huge trust signal. Huge, right?
- 10:33Really strong. Um, I know that a lot of people
- 10:37look at comments, followers, monthly views, right?
- 10:42They're looking at likes they're looking at, but those really at
- 10:45the end of the day, in terms of engagement on the platform don't
- 10:50have as much of an effect, I believe, as the quiet saves.
- 10:53And remember, when I talk about quiet saves and not just talking
- 10:55about private boards, I'm also talking about people who save
- 10:59off of the platform. So if you notice when you go to
- 11:02a PIN, you've got that little share icon a lot of times you
- 11:05can share to Apple Notes, you can share to Google Keep, you
- 11:08can share to your computer, to your phone.
- 11:11You don't necessarily have to share it to secret board.
- 11:14You might do all of those or none of them or one of them,
- 11:17right? Or just stay on the platform.
- 11:21So think about that. Food for thought.
- 11:24So Pinterest understands what you help with, right?
- 11:27Users are saving your content, but quietly on the down low.
- 11:31And the final layer of trust really is authority.
- 11:34And I mentioned this in the previous podcast.
- 11:36One of the things you really want to try and do, especially
- 11:38in the new year with content that you're creating is try to
- 11:41become that sort of authority in your niche.
- 11:44And when I say authority, don't don't think of it as drastic,
- 11:47but you know someone that people go to for advice on whatever
- 11:52that particular niche is. Pinterest does not rank content
- 11:57based on popularity. Now if you want to check that
- 11:59out, that's directly right from from Pinterest help.
- 12:03It ranks content based on topic authority.
- 12:07OK. So you know it's not based on
- 12:09whether or not a PIN goes viral, right?
- 12:12You could have a viral PIN, but that doesn't, that doesn't
- 12:15change how the distribution of content is for you, your, your
- 12:19profile, your niche and so on. Um, authority, right, or topic
- 12:25authority can, you know, on Pinterest kind of means that you
- 12:28consistently talk about the same things.
- 12:31So that's one thing. Your content solves related
- 12:34problems. So you have a sort of main thing
- 12:37that you talk about and then you have other, other things that
- 12:40you talk about and it may solve those issues and your, your pins
- 12:45or ideas, they, you know, they your content, it builds on, on
- 12:48each other, right? You're not kind of all over the
- 12:51map. That's not, not really what you
- 12:53want to do. And I do believe that smaller
- 12:55accounts do better than the larger accounts.
- 12:59And part of that is because they focus in they, they sort of
- 13:04niche down on what they're talking about, on the content
- 13:07that they're creating and they are consistent all the way.
- 13:11And they are always offering smaller businesses tend to offer
- 13:15more solutions and options and freebies.
- 13:18And right, because they don't, it's not quite the same thing as
- 13:22the larger companies. So, you know, they tend to have
- 13:25to do a little bit better when it comes to authority.
- 13:28Now, Pinterest ones, you know, right, Pinterest has its own
- 13:32idea as well as about how it looks, how authority will look
- 13:36on the platform. Again, Focus Nation is, you
- 13:39know, usefulness, right? You're creating, they're
- 13:41creating pins that are useful and of course visual patterns
- 13:43like so the content is very similar but different.
- 13:47And when you see it in your feed, you know it's that
- 13:49particular company or that particular creator.
- 13:52Pinterest wants to know at this point, right?
- 13:56Can we trust this creator to consistently help users in this
- 14:00particular niche or topic, Right, That's kind of what
- 14:05they're checking out. And when the answer is yes for
- 14:07the algorithm, because it is algorithm, then I really believe
- 14:11this distribution becomes better and it just kind of starts
- 14:15happening and starts quicker and it gets better, right.
- 14:19So pulling, pulling all this together because I know it's a
- 14:22lot of information. Pinterest trust is built through
- 14:25understanding, through clarity in terms of the content,
- 14:29specific topics, clear outcomes, right?
- 14:32It knows what it is as soon as it sees it.
- 14:34It doesn't have to think about it really quiet engagement,
- 14:37right? So quiet saves secret boards off
- 14:40of off of Pinterest. So think Apple Notes or Google
- 14:43Keep, they, they save, but they're not noisy about it and
- 14:48you may not even know that they've saved it.
- 14:50And of course, authority where you're focusing on strategy and
- 14:54outcomes usefulness, right? You're consistent in your
- 14:57patterns and, and the sort of how you create content versus
- 15:01going viral, right? Because there are some people
- 15:04who come to Pinterest who just want to be viral.
- 15:07And to my mind, all of this combined is the foundation,
- 15:10right? Everything else sits on top of
- 15:14it, right? So you have sort of trust, but
- 15:18then you have, you know, likes, comments, follows, monthly views
- 15:22and and like that all sits on top of that trust.
- 15:25OK, so next week we're moving into Part 2 of the Pinterest
- 15:30Trust framework on how Pinterest content gets found.
- 15:34I'll be talking about search first content.
- 15:36OK, Pinterest SEO without sort of all the hoohah and the hype
- 15:41and making some, you know, I guess kind of clarifying the SEO
- 15:45because I know a lot of people really struggle with it and why
- 15:48being searchable beats being trendy, right?
- 15:51When you come on to Pinterest and you're uploading content,
- 15:53you want to be searchable, right?
- 15:55You just don't, you don't want to be in the moment.
- 15:58So if Pinterest has ever felt, I guess, unpredictable and
- 16:02confusing, that next week will bring a lot of clarity.
- 16:05So I hope you will join me and I will be posting even though it's
- 16:07the holidays, it's Christmas, yay, I will be posting next week
- 16:11and the week after. So listen at your leisure
- 16:14because of course I know everybody's with families.
- 16:17Now, before I wrap this up, I want to see this especially as
- 16:20we head into the holidays and towards 2026 because it's wow,
- 16:252026. If this episode helped you
- 16:29rethink Pinterest a little bit and how you approach Pinterest
- 16:32with your content, with your business, I would really love to
- 16:35hear from you inside of the business community again.
- 16:37You can always find me. Just tag me at Body, Mind, Mood.
- 16:41I would love to say hello. And as we close, you know, out
- 16:47the year here, I really hope that all of you, you know, those
- 16:51of you who listen to me who are joining for the first time, that
- 16:54you give yourself some permission to slow down when it
- 16:57comes to content creation. Because I see way too many
- 17:00people being stressed, stressed out about it and being really
- 17:04like harried about it And right, you know, slow down, reflect,
- 17:10take a breath and plan, but don't do it in like a frantic
- 17:13way or chaos. You know, like you feel like
- 17:16you've got in, you're rushing and don't do that.
- 17:19Remember that Pinterest is a long game.
- 17:21Your business is a long game. And 2026, to my mind, I don't
- 17:25think it needs any more hustle really.
- 17:27I think we've got a lot of hustle going on here.
- 17:30I think it just needs more understanding, a little more
- 17:32clarity. So I'm really grateful that
- 17:36you're here. And for those of you who joined
- 17:38me earlier this year, thank you for for supporting me and, and,
- 17:42and listening each week. I really appreciate it.
- 17:44I'm excited for what you're building and I will see you next
- 17:47week. I hope you have a great holiday
- 17:49and a happy New Year. Bye for now, see you in the PC.