Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Final Settlement E015: The Common Language of Lightning with Roy Sheinfeld
Transcript
- 0:02It all comes down to computers communicating.
- 0:06The information superhighway can be a confusing mix of on ramps
- 0:09and off ramps. Bitcoin is worthless,
- 0:14artificial. Gold.
- 0:16Is it still rat poison? Probably rat poison squared.
- 0:19We need to get into the. World of OK, this is actually
- 0:22foundational technology. What the Internet of Money does
- 0:26is it creates a single network which can do a microtransaction
- 0:32to a giga transaction. The Internet is going to be one
- 0:38of the major forces for reducing the role of gun.
- 0:42The one thing that's missing that that will soon be developed
- 0:46is a reliable E cash. Welcome back to Final Settlement
- 0:54episode 15, I believe. And today on the show we have
- 0:59Roy Scheinfeld from Breeze Technology.
- 1:01Roy is the Co founder and CEO of Breeze, which is a Bitcoin
- 1:06company that's focused on lightning infrastructure and
- 1:09really making lightning easier to use for both individuals and
- 1:13and businesses alike. They provide open source
- 1:16software development kits like the Breeze SDK, which we'll talk
- 1:19about, as well as solutions for Lightning service providers.
- 1:23And they also have a mobile app with a number of innovative
- 1:25functionalities. Prior to to founding Breeze in
- 1:29in 2018, Roy spent many years building in the realm of
- 1:32enterprise software. So very excited to have Roy on
- 1:34the show today. A number of topics to get into,
- 1:37but Roy, welcome. Thank you for joining us.
- 1:40Thank you for inviting me, Brian.
- 1:42Thank you, Michael. Yes, super excited for this
- 1:46episode. I was thinking about I was
- 1:48driving to to record. How do we introduce you?
- 1:51And I don't know if this is, I would embarrass you, but I think
- 1:53like the godfather of lightning, you've been building so far, so
- 1:56long and on lightning that I feel like there's only a few
- 1:59other folks in the Bitcoin industry that have also come
- 2:02from traditional technology, but then also have been, you know,
- 2:07effectively hacking at, you know, lightning and 2nd layers
- 2:10and finding different solutions, different implementations.
- 2:13So really excited to hear kind of the journey.
- 2:16And then what's, what's the latest?
- 2:17Because I feel like your breeze is on the bleeding edge of
- 2:19things. Yeah, yeah.
- 2:22Thank you for making me feel old, feel old, Michael.
- 2:24But we definitely started early. Early on, I think we founded
- 2:30Breeze with the first main transactions running on
- 2:35Lightning. So yeah, we were.
- 2:38We were lucky enough to get in early and then to start
- 2:42building, expanding the Latin technology.
- 2:45We're not there yet, but very hopeful that we'll get there
- 2:48soon. Yeah, yeah.
- 2:50We'll, we'll get into all that. Maybe it makes sense to take a a
- 2:54bit of a step back earlier, you know, prior to founding Brees.
- 2:57I'd love to learn a little bit more about, you know, your
- 2:59career prior to even Bitcoin and when you started to sort of grok
- 3:03and understand Bitcoin. And then, you know, once
- 3:06Lightning came along along like, you know, making that jump to,
- 3:09to focus specifically on on lightning infrastructure.
- 3:12I think, you know, at that time 201718 super nascent, like
- 3:16taking a bit of a, a leap in the sense of like this is the area I
- 3:20want to focus. So I'd love to hear about that,
- 3:22that sort of trajectory. Sure.
- 3:26So yeah, I, I, I worked for the in the Israeli high tech scene
- 3:33for about 20 years. Started off as a software
- 3:37engineer working on CC Plus plus projectsthen.net, different
- 3:46project, but mainly around enterprise software businesses.
- 3:52Worked as a consultant for a long time.
- 3:54Then I kind of joined the company called Mainsoft, which
- 4:00was also a company in the enterprise software business.
- 4:04I was supposed to be there for three months and ended up
- 4:07staying for 15 years, and I actually helped pivot the
- 4:13company from one business to a different business.
- 4:19We started off by creating a compilers and and ended up as
- 4:24creating document collaboration software for large enterprises.
- 4:31We had a lot of Fortune 100 companies part of our customer
- 4:36base and I was the Co founder and CTO of Harmony.
- 4:42We renamed the company from Mainsoft to Harmony and I served
- 4:46as the city of of Harmony for about 8 years till 2017 where
- 4:58and that's I'm I'm a betweener since 2013.
- 5:02So I I actually read the white paper because my friend Akiva
- 5:12that ended up founded Breeze together with me.
- 5:17Breeze I'm the Co founder but I have two other Co founders that
- 5:21were part of harmony and and and Akiba read the white paper and
- 5:28he told me and my other partner that we should kind of read the
- 5:33white paper. We read the white paper in 2013.
- 5:37Of course, we didn't understand anything.
- 5:40So we started the having our lunch breaks talking,
- 5:46deciphering the, the, the, the white paper, talking about
- 5:51different concepts and different aspects of Bitcoin from the
- 5:57software engineering part, the crypto, the cryptography, the
- 6:01game theory, the economics. So people stopped sitting next
- 6:06to us in on, on this last breaks because we kind of the only
- 6:11thing that we was talking about was was Bitcoin and, and we all
- 6:19bought some bitcoins back in 2013 and we kind of started
- 6:25following the space in 2017. I, I got Crohn's disease,
- 6:35Crohn's disease. If somewhere some of the some of
- 6:37the listeners are unfamiliar. It's an inflammatory bowel
- 6:42disease. It's and the actually it's, I
- 6:52got into a state where I was kind of completely down for six
- 6:57months. I couldn't even, I couldn't eat,
- 6:59I couldn't move. I was, and I was in kind of my,
- 7:05the prime of my career and, and that gave me a slap on the face
- 7:13basically. And it brought me into a state
- 7:17where I had to reflect on why, why I ended up staying in bed
- 7:27for six months. And during this chronic disease
- 7:33is a, is an autoimmune disease where the body attacks itself.
- 7:39And, and mostly it's about it's a stress related disease like
- 7:45the, the trigger is stress. So I had to ask to, to ask
- 7:49myself questions like, why am I stressful?
- 7:54And am I doing the thing that I need to do?
- 7:58Am I aligned with my mission in life?
- 8:01I, I know like it sounds like a cliche, but I really had to ask
- 8:05this question myself in order to start and rehabilitate from the,
- 8:10from the disease. And, and part of the answers
- 8:16were that I'm not bringing the value and I'm not doing the
- 8:20stuff that I, I'm supposed to do and I, I enjoy doing.
- 8:26As a result, I started, I started working in Bitcoin
- 8:33because Bitcoin was my passion and I wanted to bring value in
- 8:38the area where I was passionate about.
- 8:42And that was together with the emergence of Lightning Network.
- 8:47So the two things kind of happened in conjunction.
- 8:51I got the Crohn's disease, which kind of I had to reshuffle the
- 8:56cards that I received. And I since I, we've been
- 9:01following the, the Bitcoin space.
- 9:03We saw the the merchants of lightning network.
- 9:05I don't, I, I, I'm not sure if you remember like 2017 was like
- 9:09the post lock size wars and like the narrative of Bitcoin being a
- 9:13digital gold was, was really, really strong at that time.
- 9:18Like a lot of, I saw a lot of Bitcoiners like give up on the
- 9:22premise and the promise of Bitcoin, which was for me a
- 9:27peer-to-peer, peer-to-peer of cash and, and, and and that like
- 9:32seeing that together with this new promising technology that
- 9:36emerged in the in the form of lightning network.
- 9:39I told myself, OK, like I need, I need to do to, to deal with
- 9:44that already. Like I started seeing the
- 9:47problems that for the collected lighting network can be, can
- 9:51have in the market, like the the, the challenge of bringing a
- 9:56lightning to mainstream users. And the, yeah, that's why we
- 10:01founded Breeze and that's why we started Breeze.
- 10:04And we started Breeze as a, as a wallet app, which I hate, by the
- 10:10way, I hate the term wallet. I hate the fact that people need
- 10:14to use wallets to interact with Bitcoin.
- 10:17But we had kind of to launch a user facing app in order for us
- 10:23kind of to interact with the market and to develop the, the
- 10:27gaps and to kind of bridge the gaps that exist in, in, in, in
- 10:33Lightning, but slow slowly, like we're transitioning to our true
- 10:38calling that we envisioned from the get go.
- 10:41And it's about not bringing people to lightning, but
- 10:46actually trying to bring lightning to where people are.
- 10:51And that's that's kind of the mission of Breeze.
- 10:54At Onramp, we believe that Bitcoin is the most important
- 10:57asset of the 21st century. The hard part is securing it
- 11:01right. There are shortcomings with
- 11:03keeping your coins on an exchange, but also with setting
- 11:06up your own self custody arrangement.
- 11:08On Ramp solves for these concerns.
- 11:10Our multi institution custody solution maximizes security and
- 11:14minimizes counterparty risk, ensuring that your Bitcoin
- 11:17remains securely in your possession and provides built in
- 11:21inheritance planning to ensure your family is protected as
- 11:23well. On Ramp provides Peace of Mind
- 11:26for your Bitcoin journey, whether for your whole stack or
- 11:29for part of it as a compliment to your existing self custody
- 11:32setup. For more information, check us
- 11:34out at on rampbitcoin.com. All of that story, I didn't know
- 11:40that about you Roy. And I think that is very
- 11:43indicative of we don't choose Bitcoin.
- 11:45Bitcoin chooses us, whether it's from the allocation in mind
- 11:50virus to like ultimately working in the space, haven't been as
- 11:53around as long as you, but have been around building and hiring.
- 11:56And, and you kind of, I'm sure you've seen this where
- 11:59individuals are stuck kind of in the traditional world and they
- 12:02have to make that decision point.
- 12:04And I always in my mind, I hope, you know, provide a framework,
- 12:08but the decisions made for them, they're, they don't know it yet,
- 12:12but they've already made the decision because no money, you
- 12:15know, all the accolades. It's the, it's the framework
- 12:18that Bezos talked about where he said, like when he first started
- 12:21Amazon was like, well, when he was on his deathbed, would he
- 12:24regret it? Because if that's the choice,
- 12:26like would he regret failing or leaving D Shaw?
- 12:28And it's very similar to this, like the individual that you
- 12:31want on your team and to be participating and that we invest
- 12:33in you, you just, there's no other choice.
- 12:35And, and the money and the other thing we figured out.
- 12:37And if it doesn't get figured out, well, you left it out on
- 12:40the field versus just like having that regret, that regret
- 12:44framework. So makes sense.
- 12:46I couldn't take three more. I couldn't take three more.
- 12:48And I always compare it to artists like a musicians or, or
- 12:53people in the performing art like, you know, it's not going
- 12:56to be easy, but you don't have you don't really have a choice.
- 13:00Like you said, they might be between chooses you like if you
- 13:03that's your calling, you need to follow your calling.
- 13:06And, and, and, and between is hard by the way, compared to
- 13:10other start-ups that I worked in the low time preference.
- 13:14Yes, of course it's easy to say low time preference, but when
- 13:17you're running a startup, a Bitcoin startup that is based on
- 13:22the low time preference, it's far like it.
- 13:24It doesn't work in the kind of the Fiat economy and the VC, the
- 13:28traditional, the traditional VC wall like any startup is
- 13:33expected to get to a significant revenue stream within two years,
- 13:38three years. It's very challenging to do that
- 13:42in Bitcoin, but we, yeah, I, I accept the challenge.
- 13:46Like we're here to, to, to do something that we believe brings
- 13:52value to the wall. And you know, what's my kind of
- 13:56my, my, my, my metric is the fact that I wake up every day
- 14:00with a smile on my face. That didn't used to happen.
- 14:03And even it's even the, even though it's so challenging, even
- 14:09though like it's a, you know what Elon masks said about like
- 14:12running a startup, Like it's chewing glass, staring at the
- 14:15obese, like, yeah, so, So what? Like still, I'm so excited about
- 14:20building bridge. I'm so excited about
- 14:22contributing to Bitcoin and contributing to a better future
- 14:25that like, I wouldn't choose anything else over it.
- 14:29Yeah, it's, it's very well said. You know, it resonates with me
- 14:33as well, sort of I, I made the jump from the traditional
- 14:36finance space a few years ago and part of it too.
- 14:40I, I don't know who I heard described it like this, but you
- 14:43know, once you start to really understand Bitcoin at a deep
- 14:46level, you recognize that contributing to the space in any
- 14:50way you can, applying your skill set in any way you can is sort
- 14:53of the highest form of leverage on like just broader impact on
- 14:57society. And so it is sounds cheesy, but
- 14:59it is somewhat of a higher calling in the sense that once
- 15:02you have have that deep level of understanding, you say, OK, this
- 15:04is the best thing I can spend my time on.
- 15:06And I would be foolish not to. It's it's very, very well said.
- 15:11I want to go back to what you're describing in sort of your
- 15:14journey around, you know, the realizing that this thing
- 15:19lightning was coming out and, and maybe that triggered in your
- 15:21head. Maybe this is how we get back to
- 15:23that original promise of peer-to-peer digital cash.
- 15:27And I would love to hear, you know, your thoughts and
- 15:30perspectives on from that time period.
- 15:33So you know, say 2017 to now the, the sort of progression and
- 15:38the advancement of lightning infrastructure.
- 15:40Generally speaking. I think broadly for people on
- 15:43the edges or, or taking a cursory view at this may lament
- 15:47sort of where we are with lightning in terms of its, its
- 15:50progression and advancement. But as someone's, you know,
- 15:53being there from the early days and really, you know, building
- 15:56on this building this infrastructure very, you know,
- 15:59very deeply I'd, I'd love your thoughts on, you know, your view
- 16:03of sort of state of the Lightning Network today.
- 16:05What else needs to be done? But really, you know, provide
- 16:08some context for where we are relative to to 2017.
- 16:12Definitely. So when I started in, in late
- 16:182017, early 2018, I, I knew that it's a long journey and we're
- 16:26really running a marathon here. Like unlike other in the
- 16:30ecosystem that were really hyping lightning in, in not
- 16:36really, I don't think it was it was.
- 16:41I think they, they set like their own expectations for
- 16:45likely to succeed really fast. Like we saw that the challenges
- 16:49in the technology. We saw that the the how much
- 16:53building is required in our kind of to bridge the gap between the
- 16:57technology and normies and and we started working initially,
- 17:04even without exploring use cases and go to market.
- 17:09We started the kind of bridging the gaps, bridging the
- 17:14technology gaps that allow us to bring self.
- 17:18For me, lightning is self custodial lightning, but I don't
- 17:21think there's a lot of value in, in building banks Oregon
- 17:25custodial lighting solutions. There are there is some value,
- 17:29but it doesn't manifest the value proposition of Bitcoin.
- 17:32So we started kind of of of, of bridging the technology gaps
- 17:36that existed. We brought lighting to mobile
- 17:41devices. That was kind of the first step,
- 17:45running nodes, running liking nodes in in the context of your
- 17:49mobile device without you having to run a liking node in a in a
- 17:53server environment or as part of a hardware device.
- 18:00That was the first step. We created this notion of an LSP
- 18:04enlightening service provider. This is something that Breeze
- 18:06brought to market. So similarly to the way that you
- 18:10connect to the Internet, you don't know anything about how
- 18:14Internet protocols work as a as a normal user, you just take
- 18:18your router and and and plug it to a socket, your home and
- 18:21you're magically connected to a network called the Internet.
- 18:25We try to bring the same notion to the Latin network and we, we
- 18:29invest, we invented this, this concept of a lightning service
- 18:33provider that magically connects end user to the Latin network
- 18:37and kind of obfuscate all the technical complexities away from
- 18:42end users. You don't need to do channel
- 18:46management, you don't need to deal with inbound liquidity
- 18:49problems. So we tried kind of to, to
- 18:53bridge the, the user experience gap in, in that regard.
- 18:58And I think we came a long way if like if I'm comparing, if I'm
- 19:03rewinding to 2017 to till now, like we didn't have wallets like
- 19:09Breeze, like Phoenix back in the day.
- 19:12And this is something that came out of the work, the collective
- 19:16work of people in the ecosystem, but but it's mostly a Phoenix,
- 19:26the async team and and and us that kind of try to bring self
- 19:30custodial lighting to to the masses.
- 19:34What I learned along the way is that is that technology is just
- 19:41one piece of the puzzle. It's an important piece of the
- 19:43puzzle, but you need to at large.
- 19:49People don't care about Bitcoin like we care about Bitcoin.
- 19:52We like Bitcoin, but people, this is something that's always
- 19:58frustrating when I go to Bitcoin conferences like you, you,
- 20:02you're at a Bitcoin conference, There's thousands of excited,
- 20:05the Bitcoiners talking about the Bitcoin, about Bitcoin.
- 20:08And then you step outside of the venue and you ask someone in the
- 20:13street like what he thinks about Bitcoin.
- 20:15You'll be lucky if they know what Bitcoin is.
- 20:19So no one cares about Bitcoin outside of our bubble.
- 20:23And, and, but I learned and we learned through exploration,
- 20:28through market exploration that there is value proposition to
- 20:32Bitcoin and we just need to manifest the the utility of
- 20:35Bitcoin and to find the right ways of bringing this utility to
- 20:39the masses. It's not about Bitcoin per SE,
- 20:43it's about the the utility that Bitcoin provides.
- 20:46So as the as part of our journey with Breeze, we added some
- 20:53experiences to to to our app. We added the podcast player that
- 21:00allows you to stream Satoshi's to content creator.
- 21:03We were maybe the first or second implementation of what is
- 21:07known now as a podcasting 2.0. We added the point of sale
- 21:13interface to to Breeze that allows merchant to accept
- 21:18payments without the need of a bank account.
- 21:22We've added the marketplace of apps that allowed people to
- 21:25easily buy gift cards in bit refill or do trades on L and
- 21:29market. And every time we've added a new
- 21:33experience to breathe, we, we saw a surge in users, number of
- 21:38transactions, velocity, all the metrics grew by an order of
- 21:43magnitude. So whenever we add, we added
- 21:46something on the, on the technical side, on kind of the
- 21:50implementation detail, I don't know like 0 confirmation
- 21:53channels or, or, or, or UTXO consolidation or whatever we, we
- 22:01done from a technical standpoint, it didn't really
- 22:04move the needle. But whenever we added an
- 22:07interface, a new user experience, then we saw, we saw,
- 22:11we saw a growth. And maybe it sounds stupid in
- 22:16retrospect, but it made us realize that applications and,
- 22:22and meeting people needs, that's the that's the key.
- 22:25Like it's, it's true for every industry, but it's, it's very
- 22:29true for Bitcoin as well. You need to solve real world use
- 22:35cases, real world problems in order to get Bitcoin adoption.
- 22:40So naturally the next step in our revolution was to take the
- 22:45infrastructure that we've built for our wallet and improve that.
- 22:50We, we also incorporated other technologies, green light from
- 22:54lock stream and and now we're doing liquid swaps and we're
- 22:59using balls. But we're kind of try to figure
- 23:03out how instead of building new experiences in Bris, how we can
- 23:07have domain expert and developers integrate Bitcoin
- 23:11payments into their own solutions.
- 23:14And that's what we've been focusing for the past two years.
- 23:17And it's also an iterative, there's also iterations about
- 23:24the the SDK solution. But I think we understand much
- 23:31better now which users need Bitcoin payments and where to
- 23:36meet them. We have a very clear go to
- 23:39market strategy and I'll say a dirty word, but I'll say crypto.
- 23:44There's a lot of crypto users that need Bitcoin as a mean of
- 23:48payment and we intend to meet them and to provide lacking
- 23:52payments and bring lacking payments into a crypto
- 23:56solutions. That's kind of our our our main
- 23:59focus from a business standpoint, that's our main
- 24:01focus right now. But we can also envision how
- 24:07Bitcoin payments and lacking payments are going to be
- 24:09integrated into mainstream solutions down the lock.
- 24:14Spoken like somebody that's been staring into the abyss for a
- 24:18long time because because yeah, I mean, I think this is where we
- 24:22really, you know, Brian had a 10 plus year traditional background
- 24:26or background in traditional finance.
- 24:27I was kind of 10 plus year in traditional technology similar
- 24:29to yourself. And one of the things that's
- 24:31been missing in Bitcoin is what you just said from somebody
- 24:34that's external be like, oh, that makes complete sense.
- 24:36But when you're in Bitcoin and you kind of tink used to
- 24:39tinkering that you have to go through the implementation of
- 24:42the tech is the cool part. And and what I've learned or
- 24:45what I've seen is like I remember like multi sig from the
- 24:47consumer perspective becoming very big in like 1617, but it's
- 24:51really starting to like it took a while to catch up.
- 24:54It took a while to figure out for consumers to leverage.
- 24:56And so the tech is always like ahead by like 3 to 5 plus years
- 25:00until you find the commercial applications in the commercial
- 25:04interest. And so it's always a cousin of
- 25:07what you're describing. I think of as like Frost and all
- 25:10these different implementations around like custody and mini
- 25:14script is like, it's great, but the market has to be able to
- 25:17understand grok, put confidence. And so you're looking at at
- 25:19least five years before anybody's using if, if that
- 25:24because we're going to tinker with it.
- 25:25But to get to market to understand it and then build
- 25:28what's needed or what they're looking for is completely two
- 25:31different things. There's one thing to build what
- 25:32we want. There's another thing to build
- 25:33with the market. Well, a understand and B
- 25:35actually provide value. Yeah, the technology is just the
- 25:39foundation and then you need to iterate with the market in order
- 25:43to find the right product, market fit and to bring the
- 25:45solutions to market. The advantage that I have and I
- 25:49think you guys have as well is that we have some Gray air, like
- 25:53we're not hackers, we're not. We're here to run the marathon
- 25:57and we understand that technology is just one piece of
- 26:01the puzzle. And I think Bitcoin in general,
- 26:06we need more people like that in the ecosystem.
- 26:10It's not just about the technology, it's a lot about
- 26:15marketing. I think we're missing a lot of
- 26:18talented marketers in the Bitcoin ecosystem.
- 26:23I think we're missing product designers.
- 26:25I think we're missing creativity.
- 26:27I think we're missing a lot of stuff that exists that is, that
- 26:31does exist in other other ecosystems.
- 26:34And we're lacking because of our complete 95% technology focus.
- 26:41And it's right, it's, it's true that we're in the technology
- 26:44phase of Bitcoin. Like we're just, we're just
- 26:46taking our baby steps in kind of crossing the chasm, but it
- 26:51doesn't mean that we don't need to kind of pull these people in
- 26:54in order for us to accelerate the go to market process.
- 26:59Yeah, that also, it reminds me of, you know, Roy, you have a a
- 27:04Medium page that has some very insightful commentary on there.
- 27:08And one of the articles that you've written is, is
- 27:10essentially saying Orange Pilling has stopped working, or
- 27:13at least in the traditional sense of what, you know, people
- 27:16have been doing for years in terms of trying to convince
- 27:18people of Bitcoin. And it really resonated with me.
- 27:21And Michael and I have talked about this.
- 27:23But like, you know, the best form of new Bitcoin adoption is,
- 27:27is arguably someone who's using Bitcoin and they don't know it.
- 27:30And that speaks to what you're saying around the actual
- 27:32utility, the use cases, leveraging these superior
- 27:36monetary rails to bring to market experiences that are
- 27:40better and actually unachievable on the traditional rails.
- 27:44And that's, and that I think is the point of, of that piece that
- 27:47you put out, which is basically like, that's a better way of
- 27:49orange peeling you, you do it without even bringing up the
- 27:51word Bitcoin. Yeah, we live in a more in, in a
- 27:56mean culture and orange peeling is a mean and it's been working.
- 28:02I have a friend, Sergey is the CEO of Bit Refill.
- 28:05He always ask like why there are no conferences around VPN, Like
- 28:11why there are no VPN conferences?
- 28:13Why, why are we doing this Bitcoin conferences?
- 28:17And, and that's a, that's a valid question.
- 28:19I think there's a, I'll say something maybe a bit
- 28:23provocative, but I think there's a, there's a lack of confidence
- 28:27among Bitcoiners with this orange peeling.
- 28:31It's either you're in or you're out.
- 28:34It's either you're orange peeled or you're not.
- 28:36And, and, and it's kind of, they are avoiding the real
- 28:40discussion. And the real discussion is
- 28:43what's the value proposition of Bitcoin?
- 28:45And are do people care about the value proposition of Bitcoin?
- 28:51How can we bring the utility of Bitcoin to the masses?
- 28:55Do is there a, a utility that applies to the masses?
- 28:59I think all of these questions are questions that are not being
- 29:03answered. If we'll continue with this
- 29:07orange building and even what Satoshi said, like if you don't
- 29:10get it, I don't have any time to I don't have time to explain to
- 29:12you. That's not the way software
- 29:15expands in the world and that's not the way the technology
- 29:19brings innovation to the world. You don't need to explain the I
- 29:25I have another article where where I I I I compare a Bitcoin
- 29:32payments to digital camera. Like, you know, when the, the
- 29:37digital camera first take it came out, it was used to replace
- 29:43the, the, the film camera and, and it didn't change anything
- 29:47really in the way that users and people behave like they just had
- 29:51a better way to develop pictures, maybe more faster ways
- 29:56to develop picture high quality pictures and, and all of that.
- 29:59But our behavior, our human behavior didn't really change,
- 30:05only the convergence of the digital camera into mobile
- 30:08devices that really kind of brought a, a, a whole set of use
- 30:13cases and really change you human behaviour.
- 30:16Like we can't really eat dinner before taking a picture of it
- 30:20and we can't really interact with other unless it's in an
- 30:24Instagram post or a TikTok story.
- 30:29And, and, and, and, and, and that's the way digital camera
- 30:33actually completely change human behaviour.
- 30:36And I, I don't think we're there yet in terms of Bitcoin.
- 30:39I think Bitcoin has the potential.
- 30:41I'm 100% sure Bitcoin has the potential of changing human
- 30:45behavior. I think the fact that we haven't
- 30:49been able to manifest it, it's, it's our problem and it's a
- 30:53problem that we need to solve. Value need to move the way
- 30:57information moves, the way that we interact with information on
- 31:02the Internet. There's no way that we won't be
- 31:05able to interact with value in the same manner, but we're we're
- 31:09unable to manifest this utility to the masses right now.
- 31:13And instead of trying to do that and trying kind of to find the
- 31:17use cases and to solve the problems and to find where
- 31:22technology converge AI and and and and Bitcoin or or nostril
- 31:28and social and Bitcoin like instead of exploring more uses
- 31:33like that, we're constantly talking about orange building
- 31:37and talking about about all the, the, the, the narrative of of
- 31:44Bitcoin, which is good for creating the 1st kind of the the
- 31:52jump start the the ecosystem. But I don't think it scales, and
- 31:55I think we need to scale through technology.
- 31:59That's exactly right. I mean, we, we talk about this a
- 32:01lot. It's, it's almost feels like you
- 32:04need to make your products if you really want to scale and
- 32:07make it a a big difference is you need to make your products
- 32:10easy enough for somebody that cares nothing about Bitcoin to
- 32:15get access, but with the quality of somebody that's looked at it
- 32:18for 10 years to appreciate right, right.
- 32:22And, and, and that ties in the taste, marketing, all the things
- 32:25that the best entrepreneurs have done, but we're so early.
- 32:29And So what I, I used to say and it got me in trouble, but I, I
- 32:31still believe it is some of the best companies have never been
- 32:34built yet in Bitcoin. And that, and the reason why is
- 32:36because that means that the best entrepreneurs do not even know
- 32:39about Bitcoin. They know about it in the, in
- 32:42the name of Bitcoin, but they don't know about it like the way
- 32:44we understand it. And because of, and it's, it's
- 32:46easy to understand when you think about through the lines
- 32:48because of Bitcoin $66,000, if everybody knew about it or the
- 32:51best entrepreneurs would be $660,000 or $6.6 million.
- 32:55And when those individuals come in and grow Bitcoin deeply, but
- 32:59then also understand commercial behavior and how to market and
- 33:02build products, that's when you get to that.
- 33:05That's when you get to that kind of taste.
- 33:07And historically, everyone that deeply understands Bitcoin, they
- 33:11want to build things for the hardcore person and the hardware
- 33:14person. We can't expect every net new
- 33:16Bitcoin person to come in to to get to that level.
- 33:19It's just not feasible. That's not how people operate.
- 33:22We're going to get to some total addressable market if people
- 33:24like get Bitcoin deeply and they're evangelical and then we
- 33:27end up as AVPN to your analogy of like, there's no more
- 33:30conference. It's just money.
- 33:31It's just the thing that you use.
- 33:34So yeah, it's it's again going back to the abyss when somebody
- 33:37has a background in traditional, you know, technology or
- 33:39entrepreneurship and then has been looking around and it's the
- 33:41idea maze that everyone talks about from an entrepreneurial
- 33:43perspective. It's like everyone knows how
- 33:46successful Amazon's been. Nobody knows how unsuccessful
- 33:48they've been, how many times they've been wrong, right?
- 33:51And then you go through the maze and you back out and you go
- 33:53through the next door and you have to continue to go through
- 33:55until you find the way. There's no other way.
- 33:57And. When you find a way without
- 33:59doing that. Exactly.
- 34:01And when you go through that, you come to these conclusions of
- 34:02like, oh, wait, we've been designing the wrong thing for
- 34:05the for the wrong people. You got to you got to design
- 34:07with them in mind. But at the end of the day, it
- 34:08has to be easy for somebody's grandma to pick up and say, oh,
- 34:11This is why it makes sense. Exactly, exactly.
- 34:14And I agree with you again 100% that we're not there yet.
- 34:18I think that again, the potential of Bitcoin is it's in
- 34:21this, the convergence of it to some other domain that we
- 34:26haven't seen yet. And that's why our mission right
- 34:29now is kind of to lower the barrier of entry of a domain
- 34:33expert to interact with Bitcoin payments.
- 34:36Like it should be that simple for a developer out there to
- 34:40tinker with Bitcoin and to start engaging in, in transferring
- 34:46value. The way we transfer information,
- 34:48it should be kind of on the same, on the same level of ease
- 34:53of use and, and, and basically that's the way we're designing
- 34:57the next, the next wave of the Breeze product is kind of
- 35:03constantly lowering the barrier of entry, constantly making it
- 35:06easier and simpler for other domain expert to tinker with
- 35:11Bitcoin and to integrate Bitcoin.
- 35:12And I think the the potential there is is is huge.
- 35:18Yeah, it makes makes a ton of sense.
- 35:19Maybe you could go a little bit deeper on, you know,
- 35:22particularly what, what Breeze is, is focused on today and how
- 35:25you're, you know, working to achieve that vision that you
- 35:28just outlined of making things more usable, you know, reducing
- 35:33those barriers to entry for developers.
- 35:35And and like Michael is saying, just smart, entrepreneurial
- 35:38people to be able to add value to the space.
- 35:42Yeah, definitely. So, so lightning is complicated.
- 35:49It's it's if you want today without solutions like the
- 35:55bruises, decay to embed the bit. When I say Bitcoin payments, I
- 35:59mean lightning because another one of my articles is where I
- 36:04talk about lightning is the common language of Bitcoin.
- 36:07Like the way Bitcoin speaks right now in terms of payments
- 36:10is through the Lightning network.
- 36:12And we see that where Lightning is becoming the interface of
- 36:15products like Fedi and products like Cashew and products like
- 36:20our Lightning is becoming kind of the interface and the common
- 36:24language which will between different Bitcoin
- 36:28infrastructures. But in order to speak Lightning,
- 36:33you need to do a lot of heavy lifting.
- 36:36What we're trying to do with the Breeze SDK is to obfuscate all
- 36:40the heavy lifting from you, exactly like we what we've done
- 36:43with the Breeze wallet from an end user standpoint, we're
- 36:46trying to do that on the developer.
- 36:48From a developer standpoint, developers don't need to know
- 36:51anything about Lightning. They just need to call an API in
- 36:55order to send payment or receive a payment.
- 36:59And, and we, we, we want to make it simple and, and and stupid
- 37:05for developers to integrate their Bitcoin payments into
- 37:08their solutions. We started off by basically it's
- 37:13an end to end holistic solution. So when I say send payment, I
- 37:18mean that you have a lighting node, you have a built in LSP,
- 37:23you have on chain interoperability.
- 37:25There's another, there's a lot of pillars, technology pillars
- 37:29that that you need to set up in order to kind of to provide this
- 37:33holistic experience. What we're doing at risk right
- 37:35now is iterating on that product and and and and finding ways to
- 37:40make it easier and easier and to kind of obfuscate the the
- 37:45complexities from developers and eventually end users.
- 37:51Our last iteration is what we call a node list implementation.
- 37:56So we have two flavors of the SDK.
- 37:59We have a native implementation where we provide a hosted fully
- 38:05featured lighting node running on the cloud infrastructure
- 38:09using the green light infrastructure from block stream
- 38:13and we have customers like Relay and green from block Stream and
- 38:21and Big Box that integrated. That's the native flavour.
- 38:26But now we added a new flavour to the SDK, which is the nullus
- 38:30implementation. And in the notice
- 38:32implementation, you don't even need to run a lighting node in
- 38:35order to interact with Lightning.
- 38:36The underlying infrastructure is liquid.
- 38:39We're using a Liquid as a way to store Bitcoin for end users and
- 38:45Lightning. The lightning interface is done
- 38:48through a submarine swaps. So if you want to make a
- 38:51lighting payment, you're doing a liquid to lighting swap, you
- 38:54want to receive a lighting payment, you're doing a lighting
- 39:00to liquid swap. And it's kind of what Aqua has
- 39:04in the Aqua wallet, but it's kind of encapsulated in a very
- 39:08simple API that every developers can integrate.
- 39:13And there will be other iterations on the on the bridges
- 39:17decay as well, maybe with stable coins, maybe through other
- 39:22technologies other than Liquid. Yeah, You know, I, I one thing
- 39:30that you mentioned in there going back to lightning being
- 39:33this common language, I think that is perhaps, you know, I
- 39:39think people are beginning to to come to that conclusion.
- 39:42But I think early on, if we rewind, you know, 5-7 years, I
- 39:47think there was more of a thought that, well, you know,
- 39:50there's going to be these different attempts at scaling
- 39:53layers for Bitcoin and you know, maybe it's going to be, you
- 39:57know, winner take most. I think what we've started to
- 40:00see over the past few years is that it's not going to be where
- 40:03to take this. There's going to be many
- 40:04different scaling approaches, scaling methodologies, different
- 40:07layers, whether they're layers, twos, threes, fours, whatever,
- 40:10you know, you want to deem them. But lightning is, is actually
- 40:14different than all those in attempts in the sense that it's
- 40:17this connective tissue that ties all these potential layers
- 40:20together. And that was pretty eye opening
- 40:23for me because I think early on in my understanding I was.
- 40:27You know, a little bit more thinking, well, you know, if
- 40:30lightning doesn't work, then then what's, what's going to be
- 40:33the one that does? And it's, that's not really how
- 40:35I, I think it's now currently playing out.
- 40:38I I agree and from early on the UK you can read my earlier
- 40:43articles. I always said that lightning
- 40:46isn't one-size-fits-all and I think when once you understand,
- 40:51forget the technology. Let's talk about lightning
- 40:53economics. Once you understand the function
- 40:57of the LSV, the cost, let's talk in in, in in startup terms,
- 41:02Let's talk in COC and and LTV terms.
- 41:07Once you start to kind of formalize what's the economics
- 41:12of lightning, you understand that lightning isn't one size
- 41:15feel fits all. And even if you had, then if you
- 41:21don't, if you don't have like the constraint of the Bitcoin
- 41:24mentioned in terms of the number of transactions and the number
- 41:27of channels that you can open and so forth, The economics of
- 41:31lightning, they work. When you understand your users,
- 41:37when you understand the usage patterns, then you can build a
- 41:40solution that accommodates a need, their need, their specific
- 41:47use case. You can't have one LSP, by the
- 41:50way, it's very similar to transitional financial
- 41:53offerings. You, you don't have a one like
- 41:58one bank for all types of users. You have a commercial bank and
- 42:01you have a retail bank and you have different products that
- 42:05service different, different types of users.
- 42:09And it's exactly the same with Bitcoin.
- 42:11You can't have one LSP that serves generically all type of
- 42:17users. You need to tailor the right
- 42:20economics to the right audience. And once you start to understand
- 42:25that, you understand that that there may be other solutions.
- 42:31What I call the last mile problem that not every user will
- 42:38want to pay for a, for a UTXO. If there are users that are not
- 42:43willing to carry the cost of a UTXO, what are the solutions
- 42:48that we offer them? So then emerge solutions like
- 42:52Fediment and ARC. And by the way, we're talking
- 42:56again in very small bubble of a Bitcoin ecosystem, we're
- 42:59ignoring the hundreds of Bitcoin layer tools that are popping up
- 43:03and, and, and, and, and staggering the amount of VC
- 43:07money is funneling their way. So what will be the common
- 43:13language of Babylon and Bhutanics and and and and, and
- 43:18the hundreds of Bitcoin projects that are you can can argue if
- 43:25they're native Bitcoin or not native Bitcoin doesn't really
- 43:28matter. People will use these layer 2
- 43:31technologies and and, and and. Lightning has a huge advantage
- 43:35in that regard because it doesn't have.
- 43:38You don't have to maintain the global state in lightning.
- 43:41Basically the state of lightning is maintained in the Bitcoin
- 43:45main chain. If all these layer 2's are
- 43:47interacting with the main chain, it means that they can easily
- 43:51have a lightning interface. You can't say that about other
- 43:55layer 2's because if you want to use them as kind of the common
- 43:59interface, that means that they need that every project needs to
- 44:03bring a new stack of state in order to kind of to interact
- 44:07with another layer too. And and the the the the the
- 44:12ingenuity of a, of a channel, of a lighting channel, the fact
- 44:15that it doesn't carry a global state, only the peers need to
- 44:19understand the, the, the intermediate state of, of of the
- 44:24channel. That, I think is very powerful
- 44:27for for lighting to be served as a common language going forward
- 44:32between native Bitcoin and between non-native Bitcoin as
- 44:37well. Does your Bitcoin custody setup
- 44:39keep you up at night? Maybe you still have coins
- 44:42sitting on an exchange worried about hackers.
- 44:45Or maybe you've set up your own self custody, but don't feel
- 44:47safe with your Bitcoin savings stashed on a little plastic
- 44:50device in your desk drawer. Gain Peace of Mind with On Ramp
- 44:54and our multi institution custody solution.
- 44:57Here's how it works. On Ramp creates a dedicated
- 45:00multi sig vault just for you. Three separate institutions each
- 45:03hold a key on ramp bit go and coin cover, but none can move
- 45:08funds unilaterally. Instead, only you have control
- 45:11over your coins. With on ramps multi institution
- 45:15custody, you'll sleep better at night knowing your Bitcoin is
- 45:18stored with best in class security on chain with fault
- 45:21tolerant multi sig. If you believe your Bitcoin is
- 45:24going to be worth a lot someday, don't jeopardize that future by
- 45:28exposing your coins to hackers on exchanges, $5 wrench attacks
- 45:32in the real world, or perhaps most importantly, the risk that
- 45:35you might screw something up with a highly technical self
- 45:38custody set up on ramps. Multi institution custody
- 45:41eliminates single points of failure, reduces your personal
- 45:45attack surface and technical burden, and provides access to
- 45:48financial services that allow you to confidently secure your
- 45:51Bitcoin, including inheritance planning, insurance backed
- 45:54warranties for all balances and transactions, low cost trading,
- 45:58and more. Bitcoin is a once in a species
- 46:01asset, Secure it right. Learn more at onrintbcoin.com.
- 46:06Yeah, it's super fascinating. There's multiple levels.
- 46:08This might be like a weird or dumb analogy, but I think of it
- 46:11as like the continents in the globe or like the main chain.
- 46:15And then the the ocean is like the the universal way to get
- 46:20across and you don't care how you get the parcels to the other
- 46:23thing. And like, so the ocean like
- 46:25provides you this experience and whether it's a ship or the
- 46:28different type of ship, how it gets there, you just care about
- 46:30it getting there. And then you take different
- 46:32forms of like trade-offs with the counterparty risk.
- 46:36And then ultimately, you never know, you just get adoption and
- 46:39somebody can pontificate which one's right or wrong, but at the
- 46:41end state, it's over time the Lindy proves how which one was
- 46:45right or wrong. And it's still too early on
- 46:47certain respects. And everybody has their own idea
- 46:50as a counterparty risk and what they care about.
- 46:52But the end of the day, like we need the other 7 billion people
- 46:56to get on board. And if it works out and it
- 46:59wasn't our vision of it, it doesn't really matter when you
- 47:01think about it. It's what only matters what
- 47:03consumers use. And this kind of ties into it's
- 47:06really interesting on the this notion.
- 47:11I would love to hear more about block stream and and and the
- 47:16what's the what's? Their liquid.
- 47:21Liquid, because liquid's been looking out there for a while,
- 47:24right? And I think of Liquid as this
- 47:25hybrid of kind of fettiment structure.
- 47:28It was kind of what we do in multi institution custody.
- 47:30It's this notion of like the keys, you're pushing the the
- 47:33risk to a trusted group of key partners.
- 47:36It has counterparty risk, but at the end of the day, it allows
- 47:40for a more seamless transfer of BTC through a programmatic way
- 47:45that was historically a little bit harder when everyone had to
- 47:47open up a channel. So it ties the Bitcoin over
- 47:50here. So when Pierre first brought
- 47:52this up, I thought it was insanely elegant for what you
- 47:56guys are trying to achieve, because it's not trying to
- 47:57achieve all the bitcoins stored. It's trying to like move these
- 48:00assets over in a way that reduces counterparty risk, but
- 48:04also increases the ability and for volume.
- 48:06And so I'd love to just hear that was a good like
- 48:09understanding of it on a high level and then how you guys came
- 48:12about that and where you see that going.
- 48:14Definitely. So liquid is in my mind is and
- 48:22and and you alluded to that is a global federation basically.
- 48:26So I I really like for example the Fedi project and Fedi Mint
- 48:31is a technology. The problem with Fedi Mint is
- 48:33someone there's someone needs to set up a federation and there's
- 48:41no there's no global federation in the fediment conceptual like
- 48:45you need to find the federation members, you need to to to make
- 48:51them the trustees of the federation and setting up
- 48:55locally for regions for organizations.
- 48:59And that's something that we have very hard time using
- 49:04because you want a plug and play product.
- 49:07So if you want a plug and play product, you basically need to
- 49:12opt into a global federation. And when you take a look around,
- 49:17Liquid is a great technology for that because you have already
- 49:21the federation set up, you have already, the trust model is
- 49:30already very explicit and very well explained.
- 49:35And now if you're opting into accepting the trust profile,
- 49:40there's not a lot of work that needs to be done.
- 49:43You just need to create the Lightning interface on top of
- 49:46Liquid in order to speak Lightning as a common language.
- 49:51Not everyone will accept Liquid as as, as the global federation.
- 49:55And that's why we need to aspire to build a more native Bitcoin
- 50:00solution. Because by the end of the day in
- 50:03Liquid, you peg BTC to LBTC and, and and and you trust the, the,
- 50:12the federation, the the federation to with your BTC,
- 50:19with your peg BTC and you convert them to LBTC.
- 50:25And there's no unitorial exit without the permission.
- 50:29It's becoming from a permissionless chain to a
- 50:33permission chain. You need the permission of the
- 50:36federation to peg out. But once you accept this trust
- 50:42profile, I think it's a much easier solution than run a
- 50:49lighting node natively on a mobile device or in the cloud.
- 50:54Doesn't matter, because once you have a Lightning native lighting
- 50:57solution you need, even if the state isn't global, you need to
- 51:02start managing the state. That's one.
- 51:07Secondly, there's no way to share the cost of a UTSO.
- 51:13The the, the biggest advantage of a solution, a side chain like
- 51:17liquid that it allows you and all of these solutions are
- 51:21Fedimi side chains. They're all trying kind of to
- 51:26share the cost of the UTXO. That's kind of the, the, the
- 51:30underlying technology. It means that you don't need to
- 51:34have the real estate allocated in, in, in, in, in the main
- 51:42chain. You can have a shared apartment
- 51:44where the real estate is shared among all the, the, the, the
- 51:49resident of the apartment. And if we're going back to your
- 51:53analogy of Lightning being kind of the railways, Lightning he's
- 52:00the railways. I think he's the highway.
- 52:02But when you get into a specific piece of real estate, the
- 52:07question is whether you get into an individual.
- 52:10An individual can buy private homes and private houses and buy
- 52:17real estate on the main chain. That's kind of the villa, but
- 52:21you can also get into a shared apartment building, which is
- 52:26kind of my analogy to a side chain like Liquid where a lot of
- 52:30resident share the same real estate.
- 52:34And that's what we're trying to do with Liquid.
- 52:37I think Arc is a very promising technology that is trying to do
- 52:40the same even in a better way because you're not using a
- 52:44different asset, you're using a native Bitcoin with with other
- 52:49trade-offs. Of course there's always
- 52:51trade-offs. So I think going forward, yeah,
- 52:55I, I, I, I'm, I'm really, I really like what you said Brian,
- 52:58because I think the future is not is is is is very diverse in
- 53:04terms of solution. I think we're going to see a lot
- 53:08of different solutions that are, that are tailoring or or serving
- 53:14different use cases and different needs.
- 53:17They will all choose the the best solutions for their problem
- 53:21and let me become kind of the glue between all these different
- 53:25technologies. Yeah, no, absolutely.
- 53:27I, I, it always comes back to trade-offs.
- 53:29And the really interesting thing about liquid to me and it, it's
- 53:33sort of aligns with everything we've we've talked through here
- 53:35is a sense that, you know, I, I forget exactly the, the year
- 53:40that Liquid went live. But you know, I think there had
- 53:44there hadn't been a ton of adoption and I think it was
- 53:47primarily a result of people being concerned around the
- 53:51trade-offs of having that peg in peg out situation and you know,
- 53:56an alternative token where there's a lot of.
- 53:59Not sure. I'm not sure I agree.
- 54:00I think liquid suffered from the same disease that Bitcoin in
- 54:04general suffered and it's a too much focus on technology less
- 54:09focus on go to market. I think liquid if liquid liquid
- 54:15add USD before Toronto like like if liquid was tried to to kind
- 54:23of fulfill a very specific use case, I think they would have
- 54:26killed it. I think liquid tried to be the
- 54:29Jack of all trade and they really they weren't able kind
- 54:34kind kind of to find the right product market fit for liquid.
- 54:39So they tried to do trades and they try to do save a coin and
- 54:45they try to do so many things and to be a generic
- 54:49infrastructure which is good. Now we companies like Breeze,
- 54:55like there are other companies that are building on Liquid
- 54:58Stocker and even the first ARC implementations are being done
- 55:02on Liquid. Now there are companies that are
- 55:04building on Liquid as a technology and and I think
- 55:09that's the way to bring Liquid to market.
- 55:12Yeah, absolutely. I think we where I was going to
- 55:14go with that. That's helpful context.
- 55:16And I think you're right. I think where I was going with
- 55:19it was I think there has been a bit of a realization more
- 55:22recently that it just makes things easier.
- 55:24Like it just, it allows these more commercial use cases to be
- 55:29more accessible to folks and, and I think developers are, are
- 55:33rocking that as well. And, and more, so more be more
- 55:36willing to, to work in lightning or work on liquid and integrate
- 55:40liquid. I'm curious, going back to this
- 55:42concept of the peg in peg out, like, what are your thoughts
- 55:45around like is a, is a quote UN quote trustless peg system
- 55:50feasible? What's the closest we have to
- 55:53it? And how do you, how do you think
- 55:54that plays out over the next 5-10 years of development?
- 56:00Yeah, it's a great question. I I think there are 222 pillars.
- 56:041 is how to make it less trusted.
- 56:09Meaning in Liquid, for example, now you need the 11 out of 15
- 56:16signatures in order to to, to do a peg in peg in peg out.
- 56:21I think with the, with the type of integration you can, you can
- 56:28increase the order of magnitude of, of people participate,
- 56:33participating in a in a liquid federation and that's going to
- 56:36change and reduce the trust significantly.
- 56:42That's one aspect. The other aspect is projects
- 56:44like a bit VM and and for example, there's a rootstock
- 56:51that is working on a trust list peg in peg out using bit VMXI
- 56:57think it's visible. I think it's early days, but I
- 57:01think beat VM for doing a trustless peg in peg out is a
- 57:04very promising technology. And I think we're going to see
- 57:08eventually. I, I'm not a prophet, I can can
- 57:12tell you exactly when, but I think we'll see major technical
- 57:17advances in doing trustless peg in peg out into side chains
- 57:21using projects like beat VM. Very cool.
- 57:26One, one question a little bit sort of higher level, almost
- 57:30philosophical. And I've, I've read your
- 57:32commentary on this as well. But I think for a while there
- 57:36was this connotation that in terms of the, the monetary sort
- 57:42of use cases of money and specifically Bitcoin, that there
- 57:45may have been a sort of a logical progression of first
- 57:49Bitcoin needs to be a store of value, Then it moves to a medium
- 57:52of exchange and then it's a unit of account.
- 57:54And, and I've sort of come to a bit of a realization from from
- 58:00listening to folks like yourself.
- 58:01And then we also had Fitzstein, Alex, Alex Goldstein on the pod
- 58:05of a few months ago and he had some similar comments around it.
- 58:09You know, it's almost like the the medium of exchange or the
- 58:13store of value use case, I should say, is actually sort of
- 58:17just a sub segment of the medium of exchange use case in the
- 58:20sense that it's just you're, you're pushing out the duration
- 58:24of that spend, right. So it's exactly, I'm not
- 58:26spending it today, but in 10 years I might want to spend it.
- 58:29So it's still a meeting of exchange use case.
- 58:31It's just what is your time horizon on that?
- 58:33Curious your thoughts on any of that And and did you come to
- 58:36that conclusion more recently or have you always thought about it
- 58:39like no? I explained why I started
- 58:42Breeze. I wanted to kind of, to, to help
- 58:45Bitcoin transfer from from or kind of to break the, the store
- 58:49of value narrative and, and, and kind of manifest the, the, the,
- 58:54the medium of exchange aspect of Bitcoin.
- 58:57That's why I started with. But I, I, I wrote an article
- 59:00called the false dichotomy between a store of value and
- 59:03medium of exchange because the discourse that I kind of was fed
- 59:07up with the discourse of people trying kind of to push the
- 59:11narrative of Bitcoin is first store of value, then a medium of
- 59:15exchange. And I wanted to kind of to
- 59:17explain why I see as the the two reinforce each other.
- 59:22I agree with Alex. I think most of the assets in
- 59:26the world are both and I think Bitcoin is both is a, it's a
- 59:31store of value and it's a medium of exchange.
- 59:33And no, it's not still, it's not yet a unit of account, but but
- 59:39if you take a look at Bitcoin and you and you understand, and
- 59:45in in the article, I give example, like historical example
- 59:49about the other, other assets like ingots and, and and gold
- 59:55and even the US dollar. How the medium of a change
- 59:59aspects are intertwined with the store value aspects of the of
- 1:00:03the of the asset. You understand that you can't
- 1:00:07separate one of the other and and.
- 1:00:11And store value is a medium of exchange, just in a long time
- 1:00:17span. And the medium of exchange is a
- 1:00:21store value on a very short time scale.
- 1:00:27The number one use case of Bitcoin is what people are
- 1:00:31trading Bitcoin in, in huge volumes.
- 1:00:34Like people maybe aren't aware, but Bitcoin is an asset of a $1
- 1:00:38trillion valuation right now. But in every year we we we trade
- 1:00:44Bitcoin. In 2022, it was something
- 1:00:47between a $15 trillion to $38 trillion.
- 1:00:53That's kind of the velocity of Bitcoin.
- 1:00:55So people trade Bitcoin a lot. And the number one use case of
- 1:00:59Bitcoin is trading it as a speculative asset.
- 1:01:02When you trade Bitcoin as a speculative asset, is it a store
- 1:01:06of value or a medium of exchange?
- 1:01:08Like, yeah. It's an interesting point you
- 1:01:11brought up because we experienced this in the Middle
- 1:01:15East without like saying too much, we resolve between India
- 1:01:18and like Middle Eastern countries where there is very
- 1:01:22wealthy people that exchange very large sums of Bitcoin for
- 1:01:25land and other things. And they and they don't hold the
- 1:01:28Bitcoin for very long. It's just, you know, talking
- 1:01:30about like 10s, if not hundreds of millions of dollars.
- 1:01:32And they're they're effectively doing what you're describing and
- 1:01:34they know it's not going to 0, but they're also using it as a
- 1:01:37way to move capital across countries.
- 1:01:42Yeah, even gold is traded on one $50 million a day, like that's
- 1:01:47the the transaction volume of gold.
- 1:01:49So in the in the article, basically I claim that there's
- 1:01:53no such thing. There are, by the way, edge
- 1:01:55cases. I give example of cigarettes in
- 1:01:58prison, for example. It's a great medium of exchange,
- 1:02:01but they go stale after a few weeks.
- 1:02:03So it's not a store value or something like a stolen Picasso.
- 1:02:10Yes, it's a great store value, but you can't really exchange
- 1:02:13it. So there are edge cases, but
- 1:02:15most of the assets are always both.
- 1:02:18Definitely Bitcoin. It doesn't mean that Bitcoin
- 1:02:21doesn't have it's shortcoming as a medium of exchange.
- 1:02:23And it doesn't mean that volatility in their adoption
- 1:02:27doesn't mean that capital tax gain in their adoption.
- 1:02:30Yes, there are still problems to be solved, but Bitcoin is being
- 1:02:34used every day a lot as a medium of exchange.
- 1:02:37And I've kind of fed up with the means of, OK, you don't don't
- 1:02:40want to buy coffee with Bitcoin or whatever.
- 1:02:42No, it's not about that. It's about how do we make it the
- 1:02:45best asset in the world. And in order to make it the best
- 1:02:48asset in the world, it needs to be tradable.
- 1:02:53Yeah. Roy, what would you say the.
- 1:02:54Biggest difference in your mind is from gold and Bitcoin.
- 1:02:58Personally, I think there's going to be something different
- 1:03:00for. I don't know if there's anything
- 1:03:02objectively that would be said, but.
- 1:03:05No, I think also first I think all this stuff about intrinsic
- 1:03:09value is I don't subscribe to that.
- 1:03:13People don't use gold because it's a good conductor, because
- 1:03:17you can make a jewelry out of it and site goes for Bitcoin like
- 1:03:22the value that we give to Bitcoin is the value that we
- 1:03:25think is a collective. Bitcoin is war.
- 1:03:28I think you can't really compare Bitcoin to gold because of the
- 1:03:32the the physical property like it's a native digital asset.
- 1:03:38Gold isn't a native digital asset and you can't make it a
- 1:03:42native digital asset. So for me, the fact that you can
- 1:03:46move Bitcoin at the speed that you move information, the fact
- 1:03:54that you can have a global currency based on Bitcoin, the,
- 1:03:59the, the, the divisibility of Bitcoin, all the medium of
- 1:04:02exchange properties of Bitcoin for me are far better than than
- 1:04:06gold. And that's why I think Bitcoin
- 1:04:08has a potential to, to, to take on gold as an asset.
- 1:04:16But I think that the key is by manifesting the the medium of
- 1:04:21exchange properties of Bitcoin. Yeah, no, I totally agree.
- 1:04:26I think, you know, part of the, you know, part of the narrative
- 1:04:32of adoption for the past few years have been a one like, you
- 1:04:35know, the institutional players are getting involved and for
- 1:04:37them the the common theme is, OK, Bitcoin is digital gold and
- 1:04:44and frankly, it just doesn't do it justice, though to your point
- 1:04:47is like it it because it is actually an improvement on gold
- 1:04:50in so many different ways. I forget who said this, but I
- 1:04:53saw it on on Twitter a few weeks ago.
- 1:04:55But it's like Bitcoin isn't digital gold.
- 1:04:58Gold is just analog Bitcoin in the sense that for for thousands
- 1:05:03of years, it's like the best we could come up with to, to have
- 1:05:06this thing that was scarce, durable, portable in some sense,
- 1:05:11but we didn't have the technology for Bitcoin, but gold
- 1:05:14was the best we got to. Yeah, and everyone mentioned
- 1:05:17Russian law, of course, like and they don't understand that
- 1:05:21Bitcoin is superior or medium of change.
- 1:05:22We didn't have that in the past. I'll call out Sailor for a
- 1:05:29second, if I may. If you saw Sailor video from
- 1:05:32today, like there's a clip running on Twitter where he
- 1:05:37talks about the crypto anarchist or or whatever trying to sell
- 1:05:44their hardware wallets. Like he basically called out
- 1:05:47the, the, the folks that are preaching not your keys, not
- 1:05:51your coin as a crypto anarchist and because they're selling some
- 1:05:56agenda. Well, Michael Saylor also is
- 1:05:59selling an agenda and the agenda and and one Bitcoin is being
- 1:06:04portrayed as a medium, as a store of value and not as a
- 1:06:08medium of exchange because these individuals Sailor wants you to
- 1:06:12buy micro strategy stocks and the ETFs, the the black rocks
- 1:06:17want you to buy their ETFs. It's a very once you this
- 1:06:22narrative. Once you have this narrative of
- 1:06:25Bitcoin as as an asset that is not transferable and you don't
- 1:06:29need to own directly. Yes, why not opt in opt to buy
- 1:06:35an ETF or to buy a micro strategy stock.
- 1:06:40So everyone is pushing their own agenda.
- 1:06:44Everyone everyone has an angle. I have an angle.
- 1:06:47I admit that that is disclaimer. I want people to use Bitcoin as
- 1:06:51a medium of change and that's the agenda that I'm pushing.
- 1:06:54So when you, when you, when you read something, when you and
- 1:06:59again, we're coming back to the meme culture that we all live
- 1:07:03in. When you see a meme, when you
- 1:07:05see kind of a narrative that is is is is there, try to
- 1:07:10understand like what's the agenda behind the narrative and
- 1:07:13understand why Bitcoin is being portrayed as a store of value,
- 1:07:17because the reality shows definitely not just the store of
- 1:07:22value. Yeah, that's, it's such a great
- 1:07:24point. We talk about this a lot.
- 1:07:26Everybody has their agenda, everybody's pushing it.
- 1:07:28But this goes back to what we talked about on, you know, which
- 1:07:32vessel is the best to get used. Well, it's still early.
- 1:07:35So you have to look at the agenda.
- 1:07:37You have to look at context, instincts, commercialization,
- 1:07:42all the things in the market will determine it.
- 1:07:44I think where Sailor and both sides of those are are right and
- 1:07:48wrong in that like Sailor is saying that we need to
- 1:07:52institutionalized the space, we need, you know, regulations or
- 1:07:55whatever, and there's a little bit there on the other side is
- 1:07:57not your keys, not your coins is an important function to prove
- 1:08:00that the system's right. But both sides are wrong.
- 1:08:02In that if it goes back to the self custodial or you started
- 1:08:05Lightning as non custodial and you realize well maybe not
- 1:08:07everybody cares about that. In the same way.
- 1:08:09If we expect everyone to write 12 words on a plastic device,
- 1:08:12they may never come into the space.
- 1:08:14And do we care about them doing that or do we want them in the
- 1:08:16space? In the same way, Sailor has to
- 1:08:18put air cover over the fact he's a centralized custodian and he's
- 1:08:22at any point at risk of having all of his assets lost.
- 1:08:25And we talked about this because we basically sit in the middle
- 1:08:28and we say that multi institution custody might
- 1:08:30actually be a way the vision of the future looks like, because
- 1:08:35you basically get the benefits of both while being able to
- 1:08:38always take delivery and keep the system honest, which ties
- 1:08:41back to the, the, the, the mints and liquid.
- 1:08:43It's like, I think a big part that the market has missed is
- 1:08:46the fact that I'll take a little bit of different stance to give
- 1:08:50you guys. Like if, if we all agree gold
- 1:08:53was money as the bedrock of society for thousands of years,
- 1:08:56right? So it's not 12 trillion.
- 1:08:57It's just the, the way capital was exchanged that I take the,
- 1:09:02the stance that the difference between gold and Bitcoin, if we
- 1:09:04had to pin it to 1 is, is script is multi seg because you take
- 1:09:10the single is an asset for the very first time that's
- 1:09:14universally accessible, but can be held by different people.
- 1:09:16It's basically governance built into the protocol, built into
- 1:09:19that one piece of gold and that had never been done before.
- 1:09:21And that's how you can get second layers.
- 1:09:23That's how you can basically put all these mints together.
- 1:09:27And that's the like innovation in mind, not the innovation, but
- 1:09:30it's the thing that makes it different because to your point
- 1:09:34where you were saying about we can transfer Bitcoin around,
- 1:09:37even though it's not the same, it kind of is the same.
- 1:09:39Like you can transfer dollars around a wire.
- 1:09:41You can do a bunch of stuff theoretically around a gold
- 1:09:43standard, but you still have counterparty.
- 1:09:45Not without. Exactly.
- 1:09:46Not without the third party. That's that's the value
- 1:09:49proposition. But it's very similar with like
- 1:09:51anything we talked about today, there's still some layer of
- 1:09:54counterparty risk and we all had to figure out what we could when
- 1:09:57it comes to definitely that. And so the idea is.
- 1:10:01Well. Well, how do you get to the
- 1:10:03fastest point to take the delivery of that?
- 1:10:07That's where like dollars in gold are very different, right?
- 1:10:09It's because there's too many claims on the dollars and you
- 1:10:13can basically, you know, they the seasonable, all the things
- 1:10:15we know about the dollar standard on Bitcoin, it's a
- 1:10:18little bit different because you can keep the system honest.
- 1:10:20You effectively like if a bank run happens, you can you can
- 1:10:22move the assets over. So that's like in my.
- 1:10:25Mind that big differentiator is this notion of governance built
- 1:10:29into the bank and then it allows for the movement to be the LAR
- 1:10:32bill to sound. You move the money and that
- 1:10:35confiscation risk becomes a lot different of a profile.
- 1:10:40Yeah, I, I, I tend to agree. I think, yeah, yeah, it's a,
- 1:10:45it's a long conversation. Like I don't know if we can get
- 1:10:49into that, but basically if everyone could own their own
- 1:10:54UTXO, I'm not sure you need multi CI.
- 1:10:58Think multi C comes into play where you're trying kind of to
- 1:11:00share the custody of a UTXO. What would everyone but so this
- 1:11:07is the this is I think the big question is how does somebody
- 1:11:12let's pretend technically that you as possible to own your own
- 1:11:14UTXO, How would that be done? Like where would the portions
- 1:11:19store it? OK.
- 1:11:21So I think that's it. That's it.
- 1:11:24There's an entirely there. There's I, I think unlike crypto
- 1:11:29by the way, I think we're not exploring that enough.
- 1:11:32I think there's a lot of ways to make it easier for users to hold
- 1:11:41their their keys without going into multisync.
- 1:11:45Multisync is one solution, but there are others.
- 1:11:49It's it is a matter of trust. Basically, you need to trust the
- 1:11:54the your keys with and to kind of integrate it into your
- 1:11:59existing trust profile. I'll give you an example with
- 1:12:03Breeze and we've been called out a lot on on, on the fact that we
- 1:12:08don't share mnemonics in the Breeze world.
- 1:12:10When you download the Breeze wallet, we don't really let you
- 1:12:17have like the regular wallet where you need to write down
- 1:12:20your 12 words. We actually use Google and
- 1:12:24Apple, and the assumption is that if you trust if you're
- 1:12:31using Android or if you're using your iPhones, you have trust in
- 1:12:39Google or Android. And most of the users want to
- 1:12:42leverage that trust in order to store their keys.
- 1:12:47Yes, it's not acceptable for for all use cases.
- 1:12:52I won't trust Google with $1,000,000, but I will trust
- 1:12:55Google with $1000. Me as personally as a user.
- 1:12:59So I think there's a landscape of multiple solutions and multi
- 1:13:03multiple trust profiles that are unexplored.
- 1:13:06Yes, I agree with you. Multi sig is going to be
- 1:13:10definitely a problem, a problem solution in in in that
- 1:13:15landscape, but it's not the sole solution.
- 1:13:17I think there will be others and if you take a look at other
- 1:13:20crypto projects on how did they solve this product, There are
- 1:13:25integrating the saving and the trust profile into identity
- 1:13:31solutions and other solution that are outside the multi
- 1:13:34Seagram. Yeah, it makes sense.
- 1:13:37I think the big thing where I can't in a it goes to talk in
- 1:13:42her book, but I just can't get away from we have helped a lot
- 1:13:45of people like on board to to multi sig.
- 1:13:48I was previously at Unchained and it's less about multi sig.
- 1:13:51It's more about human component where I think like Fetty and
- 1:13:54also yeah, where I think Fetty and blockstream have really
- 1:13:57missed a boat and which are reference took them time to get
- 1:14:00traction. And at the end of the day, like
- 1:14:02money is a social construct and you need counterparties that are
- 1:14:05Val, what is the term that are like vetted, that have
- 1:14:10liabilities, that have balance? That you already trust, right,
- 1:14:13as a human. And that's what Saylor is, is,
- 1:14:15is talking about. I agree with Saylor in that
- 1:14:17regard. Like if you have a bank and you
- 1:14:19trust the bank as a, as a, as a citizen of the United States and
- 1:14:23you and, and if we'll be able to onboard the bank to Bitcoin and
- 1:14:27you trust the bank, why not have the bank custody your, your key?
- 1:14:32Great. That's because it's a social
- 1:14:34contract that you already exist. I think it doesn't mean that
- 1:14:41Bitcoin doesn't offer a wide spectrum of other solution and a
- 1:14:45more sophisticated banks to be built on top of the Bitcoin
- 1:14:48technology and even allowing you the freedom to do peer-to-peer
- 1:14:52transactions or so. Yeah, yeah, the the social
- 1:14:56constructs a big, I think gap in the market like as you
- 1:14:59referenced, you need humans to pick up the phone and talk to
- 1:15:02and know they're accountable. And it when everything's
- 1:15:05ephemeral and anonymous and because very difficult to use
- 1:15:09products because money, again, you want recourse, you want
- 1:15:11accountability when it comes to your money.
- 1:15:14Yes, and as a as a child, you want to get your allowance from
- 1:15:19your parents and so you trust your parents, so you can trust
- 1:15:22your parents with a key. I think all these social
- 1:15:24constructs like we need to think in a way that normal people are
- 1:15:29thinking, but there's a lot to do what I'm trying to tell you.
- 1:15:32I think we haven't explored enough this this space from from
- 1:15:38a key saving, key holding, key protecting standpoint because
- 1:15:43we've built product for ourselves.
- 1:15:45Yeah. And one just thing to bring up
- 1:15:47is like the unknown unknowns, this notion of like negative
- 1:15:50space. I don't even know if this is the
- 1:15:52right term, but effectively the thing that is missing, that no
- 1:15:56one knows is missing. And what I would describe that
- 1:16:00is not your keys, not your coins.
- 1:16:01In 12 words, everyone says it's easy.
- 1:16:04And sure it's easy for anybody to do it for $10 a $100, a $1000
- 1:16:09if you study for three years, maybe for all of your wealth.
- 1:16:11The reality is it is very hard for somebody to park a material
- 1:16:15amount of their wealth with no counterparty alone on an island.
- 1:16:18And so sure, it keeps the system honest, but B, how much capital
- 1:16:22does it keep out of the space? And if the ultimate goal is to
- 1:16:25meet people where there are, are there other solutions to bring
- 1:16:28to market and then they can initially, they can never really
- 1:16:30graduate. And if that solution is not
- 1:16:32good, well, it'll fail and the next one will will come about.
- 1:16:35But to assume that that is the only thing while we sit at a
- 1:16:39trillion. Like I'm convinced if we had
- 1:16:40better solutions we'd get $10 trillion because people are
- 1:16:43scared to put their money here because they do not want to end
- 1:16:45up in a landfill or half by N Koreans which are the common.
- 1:16:49Tropes and that goes back to their orange feeling that Ryan
- 1:16:53mentioned. Like why I am against orange
- 1:16:54feeling is because basically part of orange feeling is people
- 1:16:57telling you, OK, that's what you need to do.
- 1:17:00You need to save this 12 board, but that's not the way you bring
- 1:17:04technology to market. You need to explore the space.
- 1:17:08You need to find solution, innovative solution.
- 1:17:10That's and there's no one way to do things.
- 1:17:15No, there's a diversity of ways and and I agree with you that we
- 1:17:19haven't even scratched the surface when it comes to to to
- 1:17:24multi sig products. Yeah, and the only thing about
- 1:17:27custody, and maybe this goes for everything, but definitely
- 1:17:29custody is there is no perfect solution.
- 1:17:31There's just perfect trade-offs. And so everyone loves to argue
- 1:17:35about it when the reality is there is there is no solution.
- 1:17:37It's everybody just has their own risk profile on the tax
- 1:17:40surface. They're trying to.
- 1:17:41Oh, and it's always moving. It's always changing depending
- 1:17:43on where they live, who their counterparties are, where their
- 1:17:45government's doing, what their family what how, how much
- 1:17:47capital or notoriety they have and who's targeting them.
- 1:17:51But you think we kind of have it figure out in terms of
- 1:17:57technology, you think like in terms of the products that we
- 1:18:00can build in order to help people do become custody.
- 1:18:04I don't think we're there yet at all.
- 1:18:05Like we're just taking baby steps.
- 1:18:08What products do we have like? Occurring.
- 1:18:13Yeah, yeah, that's, it's definitely true.
- 1:18:15I mean, even like somebody that wants to step in from an
- 1:18:17exchange or participate, it's very hard for them to even
- 1:18:21cryptographically. Like when you think about
- 1:18:24sharding of a private key, like that is generally pretty
- 1:18:27proprietary. Like somebody has to be very
- 1:18:29technical to be able to handle that on an institute.
- 1:18:31On an individual level. Being outside of that, you're
- 1:18:34using a Ledger or treasure or coal card to secure or you're
- 1:18:38having to do, you know, TPMS and the whole process.
- 1:18:40But even that alone, that being more universal, would open up
- 1:18:43more ability or more of a design surface for people to think
- 1:18:46about custody. Yeah.
- 1:18:48But even I'll just give you an example from something that it's
- 1:18:52not technology at all. Like why there's no company like
- 1:18:55a Brinks or something that are are opening that physical
- 1:18:58location guarded that that people can save their keys
- 1:19:03there. Like why why don't we have that
- 1:19:06in place? I don't know.
- 1:19:09I don't have a good answer for that.
- 1:19:11And it's well, you're, you're right, because we or talks
- 1:19:14globally with key holders. And one of the things we've I've
- 1:19:16always envisioned was the wherever the bullion
- 1:19:20depositories are, right where people recognize Switzerland,
- 1:19:22Singapore, Germany, like their prime to be key holders, not
- 1:19:27only from their clients, from their perspective, right as
- 1:19:29gold, you know, Bitcoin E tech gold, they know.
- 1:19:31How to save stuff? Yeah.
- 1:19:33They can save it and they can also monetize from the the the
- 1:19:37demonetization of the gold. It's a it's a perfect synergy
- 1:19:40for that. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:19:44This. Is this has been a, this has
- 1:19:46been a fascinating conversation, boys.
- 1:19:47I know we're, we're, we're bumping up on time and want to
- 1:19:50be respectful of your time. Roy, was there anything else you
- 1:19:52wanted to mention or, or where can people find you and and
- 1:19:56learn more about Breeze and what you guys are doing?
- 1:19:59So our website is Breeze dot technology breeze without an E
- 1:20:04at the end BREEZ. So so our website, feel free to
- 1:20:12take a look at the medium. It our medium where I post a lot
- 1:20:17of articles about things that annoy me in Bitcoin, Yeah.
- 1:20:26I'm easily reachable. Feel free to the Emmy on
- 1:20:29Twitter, on LinkedIn, on whatever.
- 1:20:33Right, Thanks so much for coming on.
- 1:20:34It was it was an awesome episode.
- 1:20:35Like you said, we just got to see where it goes and I think it
- 1:20:38went to a lot of good places and look forward to having you
- 1:20:40having you on again. Thank you so much, Michael.
- 1:20:43Thank you, Brian. Thank you for.
- 1:20:44Awesome. Thanks for right take care.
- 1:20:47Bye. Bye.
- 1:20:48Thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:20:51If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:20:53episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:20:56app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:20:58today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:21:01Before we finish, a quick reminder that On Ramp Media is
- 1:21:03for informational and entertainment purposes only, and
- 1:21:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:21:09Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:21:11to hear from you. Visit on rampbitcoin.com/contact
- 1:21:15to schedule a consultation with one of our private Client
- 1:21:18advisors.