Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Carmax CEO Fired, Elon’s Pay Package Approved, Gas-Powered Scouts
Transcript
- 0:00[gentle music] Good morning. We have a bit of a wild Friday, November 7th- Uh, yay... for you. I mean, sometimes it just comes in hot.
- 0:07Today we're talking about CarMax's CEO getting fired, Tesla approving Elon's pay plan, and some gas-powered scouts. No, I'm not talking about Boy Scouts. Not Boy Scouts. We have a...
- 0:18I mean, look, sometimes you just have a show. The world's upside down. It [laughs]... I mean- Literally flipped... people getting fired, it's not even about AI this time. That's wild. How about that? I mean, it's...
- 0:30Feels like a, a very ferocious Friday. [laughs] Actually, it, it is a fero- You know what? It... Because you know why? Mm-hmm. It's Black Friday number one, everybody. Is it number one? It's Black Friday number one.
- 0:43[laughs] Kidding. Wow. We've been talking about Black Friday- We're starting... I know, I-... so much I feel like- I know... yeah I know.
- 0:50I mean, I feel like we're gonna have a lot to talk about today, and everyone needs to get to their stuff. So let's just talk about it.
- 0:54CarMax shares plunged 24% yesterday as the used car giant issued a grim forecast and announced a very [laughs] surprise leadership shakeup. The market doesn't like surprises.
- 1:06With profits slipping and competition heating up, the company's betting on new leadership to stabilize its course and unlock some more potential.
- 1:13CarMax expects used unit sales to fall 8 to 12%, and earnings to dip sharply to 18 to 36 cents a share. Their stock is down nearly 50% so far this year, while competitors- Oof... like Carvana are up 50% year to date.
- 1:29So CEO Bill McNabb is stepping down. I mean, I don't know if he's stepping down or he was stepped down, it sounded like. Retail veteran David McCrite will serve as the interim CEO.
- 1:40Uh, he's already a part of CarMax's team. Former CEO Tom Folliard returns as interim executive chair, citing a need for hands-on guidance. Got a little Starbucks story, a little Apple story here. Um, [tsks]
- 1:52you know, Folliard said, the, quote, "The company's recent results do not reflect its potential. Change is needed." Ah, okay. So here's the thing.
- 2:00They, they did mention that it looks like, uh, m- in December they're gonna announce the CEO, so I feel like this has been a long time coming, and maybe there's be- been some insight from Bill Nash on maybe what's needed next.
- 2:13But it's clear that taking some level of newfound entrepreneur- entrepreneurism is extremely important for CarMax. They've kind of stayed the course. They've been a champion of omni-channel.
- 2:25They kind of have, like, their rinse and repeat version, and Car- Carvana has come over the top on really owning something where Car- CarMax, uh, was in first, which is acquisitions off the street.
- 2:37And you see dealers even gaining some of that market share. So I can, I can imagine as CarMax kind of, like, hedging or, uh, you know, believing they had a moat around their business and now not- Mm...
- 2:47uh, needing to find new spark and, and re-energize. The fact that they have so many retail locations, that they have so much, uh, y- already out there, uh, uh, you know, as far as- Infrastructure, data structure- Yeah...
- 2:59capacity- It's-... marketing capability. It's like- I, I don't- They're dialed... see them going down. I don't see them going down. It's just about, like, what's the next turn? Yeah.
- 3:07I mean, you know, you said Black Friday sale. You and I were joking before the show. We're like, "I think it might be time for some CarMax stock." I'm like- Hey...
- 3:14it's, I was like, "You know, CarMax having a little bit of a different kind of Black Friday sale, a little unintentional one." But I mean, it's...
- 3:20You know, I wouldn't say, you know, yesterday we were like- Not investment advice. Yeah. [laughs] Yes. It's just not investment advice at all.
- 3:26[laughs] But I think, like, we talk about I would never bet against Toyota, right? We talk about that quite a bit. I'm not quite as strong as I would never bet against CarMax, not quite as strong. But, but fairly close.
- 3:36But pretty strong, though. Yeah.
- 3:37Especially the more you know about the way they're able to innovate their data architecture, their ability to market, acquire cars off the cur- Like, they're pretty resilient, and this, you know, the market hates uncertainty.
- 3:47Some uncertainty. Really hates surprises. And, uh, the fact that Carvana- Vana's been on a rip, right? Like, that's the closest comparison, even though they're much different.
- 3:55But I mean, like, Carvana's up 50%, you're down 50%, what are you doing? Right? That's the question. Speaking of what are you doing- Stop. Elon- Some time... was dancing with robots. Surprises.
- 4:06He was dancing- Mark it up, friend...
- 4:07with robots at the annual shareholder meeting, and the shareholders just gave him the green light for a massive pay package potentially worth a trillion dollars in exchange for him hitting some very ambitious targets over the next decade.
- 4:21That's probably an understatement. Uh, so it's not a payday right now, but, uh, it's got more long-term implications and opportunities.
- 4:28Over 75% of participating shareholders approved the plan amid all these loud chants in the room of, "Elon, Elon." So there's a lot of drama over big, uh, advisory firms voting against it, but 75%.
- 4:41As you know, Tesla has a lot of retail shareholders. Uh, the plan is tied to 12-month performa- or 12 performance-based tranches, each triggered by Tesla meeting s- specific goals: operational, profit, market cap.
- 4:54Uh, and they're saying they [laughs] they need Tesla to reach an $8.5 trillion valuation over the next 10 years. So that's ambitious.
- 5:02Um, you know, they ran a cam- media campaign to secure votes, which is unusual for them. And here's a quote from Chairwoman Robin, uh, Robin Denholm. Says, "Tesla is at an inflection point.
- 5:12Last year has been critical, has been a critical one in our history," and, uh, trying to make history- Yeah... again with some pay. So here, here's the thing.
- 5:20Obviously, this doesn't actually come with a payroll increase right now. This is all about future-based incentives. Mm-hmm.
- 5:25And the reason why I think people are chan- chanting Elon is 'cause they understand what Elon focuses on gets innovation in his brain, right? Mm-hmm.
- 5:35So, like, over the last couple years he's been so focused on humanoid robots, uh, um, [clicks tongue] SpaceX, and his acquisition of Twitter that's now X. And so much innovation.
- 5:48You know, his i- his ideas on Grok, his desire to get to the moon, his, uh, like, send people into space, has been focused there.
- 5:54And what I think they're hoping this does is return his focus over to Tesla as making the most innovativeproducts, EVs, autonomous vehicles, um, robo taxis on the road.
- 6:08And, and if they can do that, you know, the, the actual like Tesla as an entity will rise.
- 6:16I actually was having a conversation with someone last night that we had over at the house, and they were like, "You know, when I look back," and they're in the auto industry and the insurance industry, they said, "You know, when, when you look back over the last five, six years, the level of innovation on an actual, uh, actual like Tesla Model 3 or Model S is not that crazy.
- 6:35They haven't had a major redesign. They haven't had- It's kinda like the iPhone. Right. It, it's kinda like the iPhone at this point. It's the mainstay of like previous innovation.
- 6:42And this is, w- when they say it's been a cr- it's a critical year in the history, this pivot could potentially provide them the impetus for the kind of growth that I think the shareholders wanna see.
- 6:53Uh, a couple things not mentioned in, in the show notes, but definitely if you paid attention, a big part of the strategy is being able to deliver a million robots, right? So they're gonna be- Yeah...
- 7:04the first ever to manufacture humanoid robots like in a production line, like you manufacture cars. If you wanna see what that looks like, you can just watch like Iron Man 2.
- 7:13I think they did it in Iron Man 2 where Iron Man [laughs] they manufactured all the mass robots.
- 7:17But this, uh, also there were some things in there like, uh, in the approval package like should Tesla make a major investment in xAI.
- 7:27So you start to see the holdings and the strategies merging together with this approval. Mm. Yep, yep. It wasn't just on a pay plan. They let a, let another strategy. So it's n- uh, we say it all the time.
- 7:37You and I have been saying this for years. They're not a car company, right? They're a car company. And I think they're just gonna be less of a car company as time goes forward and they grow- You're right...
- 7:43the other things. So, eh. Speaking of car companies. Stop. Segway. Time. [upbeat music] Haven't talked about Scout in a while, but it turns out EV truck buyers want a little gas on the side.
- 7:57Over 80% of the 130,000 reservations for the upcoming Scout Terra and Traveler EVs are versions with a gas-powered generator to boost range. Mm.
- 8:07The EREV models offer 150 miles of battery-only range with a gas engine punch- pushing total range up to 500 miles. Customers are clearly favoring the just in case option, and CEO Scott Keogh isn't surprised.
- 8:21"The market has spoken," he said. One of, uh, on the idea of a gas-only Scout, Keogh doesn't, didn't hesitate. "I don't see it.
- 8:29There's a lot of drama now, people saying the world was all EV, now it's going back to 100% internal combustion. The world is still heading electric," is his, uh, acqui- uh, uh, acquisition or a- accusation, sorry.
- 8:44Uh, Scout's final, first vehicles will enter production in 2027 at its $2.3 billion fac- do- dollar factory in South Carolina. Super brilliant move. Um, Scott, very smart in not dying on the sword with EVs.
- 8:58He gets the opportunity to see what's happening and the carnage in all the other automakers. Ford yesterday announcing because of the aluminum fire, they might stop production in offering the F-150 Lightning, right?
- 9:09So it's an all-EV vehicle. I think Dodge was the first one that I ever heard, and we covered here on the show, of the EREV engines with the Ram, uh, Pro. What the... I can't remember.
- 9:20I can't remember what it's called, but the Ram, oh. I have no clue. I cannot remember that ever. I'm gonna think of it after the show. Oh, yeah. But they're gonna release this Ram.
- 9:28They're not doing the electric version of it, but it's gonna have this model, right, up to 700, 800 miles of range 'cause they have electric generator, full EV drivetrain, all the fun of driving an EV, all the power, um, all the economy if you don't drive and you keep it charged up to 300, but all the security.
- 9:42So he's got the opportunity to change. Kudos to them for pivoting, and I think this drivetrain is gonna be more and more common across manufacturers. Yep.
- 9:49And, uh, he just, I mean, look, if you're a well-funded newcomer and you don't have to deliver or start production for another year and a half, two years, you can make pivots like this- You gotta make pivots...
- 10:01without incurring any major losses like if you made the wrong product for a full year and now people don't want it. So, um, again- Did we talk about well-funded from dealer sales from wholesale DWs?
- 10:12[laughs] No, we didn't. We're just gonna leave that. I, I didn't either. Okay, sounds good. Leave it. Get out. [laughs] We can't get in that much trouble on a Friday.
- 10:19We want Scott to come and visit us at Otocon for crying out loud and, uh, talk about retail and what the customer wants, listening to it. If we listen to what the customer wants, guess what?
- 10:27They'll tell us, and we should give them that. [upbeat music]