Latest / The Film Hobbyist / The Pitt Season Two (2026): Spinning Its Wheels on Purpose
Transcript
- 0:12in and spend some time with the film hobbyist.
- 0:15My name is Lydia, and I love movies. We are sitting
- 0:32here in my attic room on a hot July day, the
- 0:37sun beating down through the window. A box fan
- 0:40just to my right, giving us minimal relief. I
- 0:44brought up a small white end table from our living
- 0:47room, and on it is sitting a tall glass of ice
- 0:51and two pitchers, one filled with freshly squeezed
- 0:55lemonade, the other with freshly brewed iced
- 0:58tea, minimally sweetened. Feel free to pour yourself
- 1:02a glass of either, or both. and find relief from
- 1:07the heat in the icy condensation on your hand.
- 1:11Take time to enjoy the sweetness and the sharp
- 1:15acid of the lemon or the mild bitterness of the
- 1:18tea's tannins. This is an era of trouble. Suffering,
- 1:26of course, is a long -term condition of humanity.
- 1:29It has existed throughout history, now is not
- 1:33unique. And yet it is fair to say we are in a
- 1:38heightened state of awareness about it. Work
- 1:41feels different. Large language models are forcing
- 1:45themselves into entire industries, changing work
- 1:49culture and job searching in devastating ways.
- 1:53Everything is somehow more expensive and worse
- 1:57in quality. Grocery budgeting is a nightmare.
- 2:01The news is just awash with awful wars and injustice
- 2:06and corruption, all seemingly out of our control.
- 2:12So it's important to enjoy what is before us.
- 2:17To hold the cold glass to our foreheads on an
- 2:20oppressively hot day. To notice the perk of mild
- 2:24caffeine, the pucker of our mouths to lemonade,
- 2:28the surprising bitterness of cane sugar. To remember
- 2:32that we are people who matter and that we are
- 2:35in bodies that have sensory experiences to notice
- 2:39and enjoy. It is important to sit and observe,
- 2:44to take a breath and let the stress leave our
- 2:48bodies. which is what I would like to offer to
- 2:52the many doctors and nurses of the pit. Come
- 2:56on, Dr. Robbie, you'll feel better after a glass
- 2:59of lemonade. Santos, it is easier to chart when
- 3:03you're subsisting on more than protein bars.
- 3:05Dr. Mohan, just sit down and take a gosh dang
- 3:09breath. If you are not familiar with the pit,
- 3:13That's okay. It's a medical drama on HBO Max
- 3:17that's only been out since last year, a mere
- 3:20two seasons under its belt. It's the baby of
- 3:23its executive producer and star, Noah Wiley.
- 3:27Wiley was a mainstay of the show ER, his character
- 3:31John Carter beginning as a medical student and
- 3:35continuing as a major part of the ensemble for
- 3:38an entire decade. Because of this, Wiley gets
- 3:42a lot of fan mail from medical professionals,
- 3:45sharing how his performance inspired their careers.
- 3:49It seems a little bit silly now, but ER was considered
- 3:53a breakthrough in realism for medical dramas
- 3:55when it debuted in 1995. By the time I learned
- 4:00about it, ER was pretty much a soap opera. But
- 4:04for a particular demographic, ER was an important
- 4:08show. In 2020, the fan mail changed. Doctors
- 4:15and medical professionals began to message Noah
- 4:18Wiley about what was happening, the sheer exhaustion
- 4:22and burnout and overwhelm in the midst of a global
- 4:26crisis. And Wiley started to mull on what a post
- 4:31-COVID ER reboot might look like. The reboot
- 4:36fell through. But from the bones of that idea
- 4:40emerged The Pit, an emergency room -centered
- 4:44medical drama for a post -COVID world. And they
- 4:48also made a really interesting structural decision.
- 4:52Each season would be a single shift, 12 hours
- 4:57spilling into 15 hours with overtime. Like the
- 5:01show 24, each episode would cover a single hour.
- 5:06This has an incredible amount of impact on how
- 5:10the story functions, with some pretty unique
- 5:12character and thematic implications as well.
- 5:16I've never been a huge fan of medical dramas,
- 5:19a big reason of which comes down to structure.
- 5:23A typical medical drama features one main medical
- 5:26issue per episode. It's introduced at the beginning
- 5:30and by the end it's dealt with. I don't mind
- 5:34the single -episode mystery style in police or
- 5:38detective procedurals, but I don't find medical
- 5:41cases on their own to be very interesting. Just
- 5:46a preference thing. And knowing that it'll be
- 5:49fixed in an hour gives me less reason to get
- 5:53invested. But the pit structure actually changes
- 5:58this. Because the entire season is 15 hours of
- 6:03almost real time, cases don't have to be finished
- 6:07in a single episode. And that adds a level of
- 6:11intrigue that has kept my interest in a way other
- 6:14medical dramas don't. There are still plenty
- 6:17of single episode issues, an emergency trauma
- 6:21case, a small injury, you know, but that's not
- 6:24always the case. Like a real emergency room,
- 6:29patients have to wait a long time, and we'll
- 6:32have a case introduced early in the season that
- 6:34will take multiple episodes before it's resolved,
- 6:37which means the significance of the case and
- 6:41its story purpose may change from episode to
- 6:44episode. One episode, it could be a nice background
- 6:47story, and then it could turn into the next episode's
- 6:50crisis. Or a patient may leave and have their
- 6:54condition worsen and end up returning later in
- 6:57the season because it's later in the day. The
- 7:01show is actually cool to rewatch because many
- 7:04of the memorable cases from later in the season
- 7:07will actually be present in the waiting room.
- 7:10You'll see a doctor come in and walk past a patient
- 7:14who will die of a heart attack five episodes
- 7:16later. A pretty significant event for one of
- 7:19the medical students. That might be the reason
- 7:23I get excited by the structure, this innovation
- 7:26in the medical drama, but it isn't the reason
- 7:30they included it. The reason is to explore the
- 7:33impact of a long day of work on doctors and other
- 7:37medical staff, to learn their coping mechanisms,
- 7:40and to witness their burnout as their mental
- 7:43health deteriorates. All medical dramas are actually
- 7:48about the doctors involved. This is why they
- 7:52have a tendency to get soapy and off the rails
- 7:55the longer they go on. The character stories
- 7:58have to go places, and since the sets stay the
- 8:03same and the work stays the same, most of the
- 8:07long -term drama comes from the interpersonal
- 8:10relationships. Who's sleeping with whom? Is their
- 8:15relationship a secret? Is it an affair? How will
- 8:19it make work awkward if they break up? Or maybe
- 8:22they both like each other, but keep missing the
- 8:25opportunity slow burn style. Over time, this
- 8:30gets tedious. The one medical drama I have been
- 8:35a fan of before The Pit, BBC's Call the Midwife,
- 8:39has sometimes gotten so bad that I start fast
- 8:43-forwarding the relationship scenes because holy
- 8:45cow has Nurse Trixie a horrendous love life.
- 8:50The emotional stakes keep rising until we're
- 8:53in full melodrama territory. The pit could absolutely
- 8:58become this if it runs ten years, no doubt in
- 9:01my mind. But they've given themselves an interesting
- 9:05out. Because each season takes place over one
- 9:10day, there really isn't any time for this romantic
- 9:14drama. In season one, it's revealed at one point
- 9:19that two doctors had a previous relationship,
- 9:21but... This is just a layer of their interpersonal
- 9:25dynamic, not drama. And because there's such
- 9:30a time gap between seasons, it makes perfect
- 9:32sense if an actor doesn't want to return. No
- 9:36need to kill them in a car accident that requires
- 9:38their colleagues to operate on them. They just
- 9:41transfer to another hospital. It's a common enough
- 9:45occurrence in medicine that there's no issue.
- 9:49These features mean that relationships can only
- 9:52move so much in a single season. Maybe a friendship
- 9:56starts, or a rivalry. Maybe there's a singular
- 10:00breakup that was already brewing in episode one,
- 10:03and we don't get to see the full consequences
- 10:05of. It's such a narrow window of time that the
- 10:10relationship dynamic moves at a slower pace.
- 10:13And the slower pace, that micro -movement of
- 10:17character growth contributes to a sense of build
- 10:19-up in each character, even as the incredibly
- 10:22quick pace of the emergency room rushes around
- 10:25them. The pit is set in the emergency room of
- 10:29the fictitious Pittsburgh Trauma Medical Center,
- 10:32whose staff both derogatorily and fondly refer
- 10:36to it by that name. Pit with two Ts, like William
- 10:41Pitt, for whom the city of Pittsburgh is named,
- 10:44but definitely on purpose sounding like Pitt
- 10:46with one T. Pittsburgh Trauma Medical Center
- 10:50is a teaching hospital. So amongst the full -fledged
- 10:54doctors, we also have a combination of senior
- 10:57residents, junior residents, interns, and medical
- 11:00students. The teaching hospital gimmick is a
- 11:03great excuse to include both highly technical
- 11:06medical jargon and copious amounts of exposition.
- 11:10Residents and medical students have to talk through
- 11:13the decisions they're making with the doctors
- 11:15training them, which includes quizzes on the
- 11:18various conditions and treatments they're facing.
- 11:21Those explanations are for the audience more
- 11:24than the various characters, but teaching hospital
- 11:27is an excellent hand wave here. Our primary protagonist
- 11:33is the attending physician, Dr. Michael Rabinovich,
- 11:36who goes by Dr. Robbie, a skilled and generally
- 11:40compassionate individual with a more casual attitude
- 11:44toward rules, whether that be hospital policy,
- 11:48cultural expectations, or sometimes the law.
- 11:52But he isn't a rock star hotshot. He just cares
- 11:56more about people and their care than ticking
- 12:00boxes. He's also very broken, specifically experiencing
- 12:05PTSD from COVID. In amongst the regular horrors
- 12:10of having to watch the painful, lonely deaths
- 12:13of countless people, dealing with limited supplies
- 12:17and no real treatment at the time, Dr. Robbie
- 12:21had to make the choice to pull his mentor off
- 12:24the breathing machine keeping him alive. A necessary
- 12:27choice that nonetheless haunts him. The pit is
- 12:32filled with all kinds of wonderful ensemble players.
- 12:36Dana, the charge nurse who takes no crap from
- 12:39anyone and cares fiercely for her co -workers
- 12:42and patients. Dr. Langdon, the hotshot senior
- 12:46resident with secrets. Dr. Mel King, big -hearted,
- 12:50dorky, and probably autistic. Santos, the confident
- 12:55and bullish medical student. Princess and Perla,
- 12:58the highly skilled Filipino nurses who trash
- 13:01everyone in Tagalog in front of their faces,
- 13:04and on and on. The pit is very interested in
- 13:08the specifics of how the hospital functions,
- 13:11so the women who work the front desk get character
- 13:14beats, as does the guy working security in the
- 13:17ER bay. There are sequences watching the cleaners
- 13:21who prepare the trauma bays and making fun of
- 13:25the ER techs who struggle to fill out charts
- 13:27manually. The show has a reputation for realism,
- 13:31except when it comes to obstetrics cases. Not
- 13:34unexpected when the show's consultants are ER
- 13:37doctors who carry a reputation of not knowing
- 13:41what to do with pregnant patients. Season one
- 13:45was expertly crafted to use this show's innovative
- 13:50structure to its fullest extent for intrigue,
- 13:54character, and theme. They built a really strong,
- 13:58overarching narrative, raising the stakes for
- 14:02Dr. Robbie so he could come to a breaking point
- 14:05by the season's end. Halfway through the season,
- 14:08there is a well -foreshadowed disaster that is
- 14:11narratively exciting, provides a major trauma
- 14:15trigger for Dr. Robbie, and serves as an emotional
- 14:18test for every one of the doctors and nurses
- 14:21on staff. What happens to each character in the
- 14:24face of a major crisis? Do they rise to the occasion
- 14:28with grace? Do they crumble under pressure? Do
- 14:31they ride such an adrenaline high that they stop
- 14:33taking care of themselves? It provides a little
- 14:36microcosm of similar stakes to COVID. It also
- 14:41made an incredibly hard act to follow. The big
- 14:45disaster TV plot is the kind of thing that usually
- 14:49comes after a show has been running for a while.
- 14:52Like, season one is usually more low stakes for
- 14:56us to get to know the world, and the excitement
- 14:59is fairly grounded. The longer a show goes on,
- 15:03the more excitement it begins to chase. This
- 15:07kind of big disaster is more of a peak third
- 15:12-to -fifth season kind of thing, after which
- 15:15shows often run downhill. How do you top that
- 15:19kind of high? Either you end up at world -saving
- 15:24stakes, or the show begins to spin its wheels.
- 15:28And with The Pit especially, This kind of structure
- 15:32could really ruin the sense of discovery through
- 15:35the formula. Part of the joy of that first season
- 15:39was the not knowing. Which cases are big deals?
- 15:43Which are small? It was wild to realize how well
- 15:47the disaster was foreshadowed, all the ways it
- 15:50had been building all day. But if the audience
- 15:54is expecting a mid -season twist, well then that
- 15:58ruins some of the fun. also misses out for the
- 16:02whole reason of the show in the first place.
- 16:06The Pit is not primarily an exciting and suspenseful
- 16:11thrill ride full of twists. It is because it's
- 16:15well -made, but that is not its purpose. Its
- 16:19purpose is to talk about the mental health of
- 16:21doctors and medical professionals, specifically
- 16:24about burnout, the slow death wrought by a hard
- 16:29day of work. And what makes a day hard? Well,
- 16:34yeah, it is devastating to work at a hospital
- 16:38in the midst of a crisis. It is terrible to watch
- 16:42people die, especially a great number of people,
- 16:46to make a hundred split -second decisions about
- 16:49who is going to make it and who isn't. But those
- 16:53aren't very common, especially for a single -location
- 16:57hospital. Your community may have a massive fire,
- 17:02or a disease outbreak, or a natural disaster.
- 17:08Maybe you'll see something awful once in a decade
- 17:12or so. For most medical professionals, it isn't
- 17:17a singular event, even one like COVID, that causes
- 17:21the most burnout and depression. It's the thousand
- 17:25cuts of a long ordinary day of work. The second
- 17:31season of The Pit chose to go all in on soul
- 17:37-crushing work. There is a big disaster, but
- 17:41one of the sorts that happens fairly regularly
- 17:44to hospitals. And instead of thrilling life -or
- 17:47-death decisions, it only means more paperwork,
- 17:50an entire hospital having to go analog to remember
- 17:53the physical minutia of forms and fax machines.
- 17:57Frankly, Season 2 is a little bit paperwork,
- 18:01the season. And there was some rebellion from
- 18:04the fandom. For a certain section of viewers,
- 18:08The Pit was a twisty thriller, and so they kept
- 18:11looking for the twists in Season 2. Which character
- 18:15was going to die tragically on the job? Which
- 18:18characters were secretly hooking up? What was
- 18:22the identity of the baby abandoned in episode
- 18:24one? And they were pretty disappointed by the
- 18:27season. These kinds of fans began grumbling about
- 18:31how lame the characters' storylines were, how
- 18:34every episode was a never -ending nightmare of
- 18:36the same issues over and over again. One character's
- 18:40storyline was that she just couldn't seem to
- 18:43finish her charts. She had to stay late to fill
- 18:47out forms. How boring and soul -crushing is that?
- 18:51Which is, I think, the point. Yes, season two
- 18:58of this show was not the finely -tuned masterpiece
- 19:01of season one. but I think it did an incredibly
- 19:05good job of using its form and structure to tell
- 19:08a particular story. Working in the ER can be
- 19:13a kind of purgatory, an endless stream of work
- 19:17that will wear you down. Even if, as a doctor,
- 19:21you are incredibly calm and composed and organized
- 19:23and orderly, your body may fail you, leaving
- 19:27you weak in the face of overwork and little rest.
- 19:31Perhaps you even have rest laying ahead. But
- 19:35when your normal is overwork, how can you turn
- 19:37off? Can you really stand the silence? I think
- 19:43this is a valuable conversation, one that procedural
- 19:47television is uniquely suited to facilitate.
- 19:51A procedural, cop show, law show, medical show,
- 19:55is comfort watching for a lot of people because
- 19:58of its predictability. There's catharsis in a
- 20:02formula playing out. Watching people do a job,
- 20:05solve a problem, finish the task is comforting.
- 20:09But when the problem is still the same, episode
- 20:12after episode, or we're seeing different facets
- 20:15of the same problem, we don't get the same kind
- 20:18of relief. If the characters are spinning their
- 20:21wheels, so are we as the audience. There are
- 20:26lots of shows that do this because of bad writing.
- 20:29My husband and I recently watched a few seasons
- 20:32of Smallville for the delight of how bad it is
- 20:35and had fun yelling at the TV about how absolutely
- 20:38stupid the recursive romantic plots are. Lost,
- 20:44a show I love but recognize its flaws, really
- 20:47started spinning its wheels in season three with
- 20:50the stupid polar bear cages that they kept trying
- 20:53to escape for half a season. The pit. on the
- 20:58other hand, spent its second season spinning
- 21:02its wheels intentionally. It hadn't run out of
- 21:07ideas, it just denied us the catharsis we were
- 21:10used to. It gave us the meta experience of having
- 21:15a really hard, long, burnout day where you just
- 21:19can't escape your problems. We did get some good
- 21:23thrills and high -quality character work. There's
- 21:27an episode just from the nurse's perspective
- 21:30that honored their care in a way that left me
- 21:33sobbing. There's a ripped -from -the -headline
- 21:37plot written and filmed months before reality
- 21:40echoed it. There's a final scene of two characters
- 21:44doing karaoke after work, headbanging away their
- 21:47exhaustion, belting out their work angst. But
- 21:52a good feature of good storytelling. is the experience
- 21:56of empathy, of letting us live a day in someone
- 22:00else's life. Yes, sometimes that's the thrill
- 22:05of competency, of watching a team work together
- 22:09to save lives. But it also means feeling a taste
- 22:14of the never -ending charts and the monotony
- 22:17of paperwork, the job that gives meaning but
- 22:21also might slowly kill you if... You never take
- 22:25time to enjoy a fresh, ice -cold beverage on
- 22:29a hot July day. So let us listen to each other,
- 22:34that we can learn the grind that gets us down,
- 22:38and find the rest and joy that helps us to move
- 22:43forward. Thanks for coming.