Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #66🎙️ |Public Inquiry Road Abandonment Week Beginning 26th May 2026 Day 1 |
Transcript
- 0:02The weather predicted that it would be another sunny day
- 0:07today. Walking into town, however, was quite overcast, but
- 0:12not cold. I was glad in a way, because having to go to the
- 0:16public inquiry when it is lovely, bright, warm day makes
- 0:20us lose the will to live. The sunny day did arrive when we
- 0:25were incarcerated inside this evening, sitting in the garden
- 0:29outside my home, listening to the birds as I write this in the
- 0:33cool of the evening, is really very pleasant. Without any
- 0:38ceremony at all, we were right back at the road abandonment
- 0:41discussion today was remarkable by the number of personnel
- 0:46representing DFI roads. I wonder, have they just awoken to
- 0:52the fact that they're in the middle of a public inquiry
- 0:55called by themselves, which ought to be overseen by people
- 1:00called inspectors, as referred to by the Council for Dalradion,
- 1:04mr. Stuart Beattie, but when third parties queried if it was
- 1:10a public inquiry or roads inquiry, we were told it was a
- 1:14conjoined inquiry, which we now understand that along with that
- 1:20title comes the fact that all the rules might be changed, so
- 1:26it seems like the rules that are applied to roads inquiries are
- 1:31conveniently waived, while the inspectors, who are not
- 1:34inspectors, but who are required to be inspectors by the roads
- 1:39inquiry, are simply our well-loved, tried, and tested
- 1:43faithful commissioners. They didn't seem to have different
- 1:46hats on today, or badges, saying inspector, and indeed denied
- 1:51they were inspectors. Who knows who or what they really are? If
- 1:59you've got any idea, please send suggestions by postcard. The
- 2:03best suggestion will receive an SOS T-shirt. Mary Brawley quoted
- 2:09a number of regulations and outlined how procedurally the
- 2:13commission seems to have broken them. She referenced Schedule
- 2:17eight, which may allow exceptions to the manner in
- 2:20which the inquiry is proceeding, but then said that these
- 2:25exceptions have not been outlined to third parties,
- 2:30thereby denying natural justice and the opportunity for everyone
- 2:34to speak. There was some conversation around Doug Hill's
- 2:39exclusion last week, which she pointed out that whilst Doug
- 2:43self excluded, and then was subsequently banned from
- 2:46attending, and the police called after he left, was it necessary
- 2:51to bar him from the rest of inquiry? She said, yes, Doug was
- 2:55loud, but she also pointed out commissioners have been loud as
- 2:59well, and have even shouted at times, and also why she agreed
- 3:03Doug had been rude by using one swear word beginning with the
- 3:07letter S. She categorically denied that he'd been
- 3:11threatening and wanted that on record. Pat Hardy then stepped
- 3:16in to request an adjournment, as all third parties were finding
- 3:20it difficult to replace Doug Hill's expertise, and to give
- 3:25them a chance to get another expert, as the other parties
- 3:29known that Doug Hill would be there to represent Save Our
- 3:31Spurns, did not have their own experts, and these experts are
- 3:36very expensive and difficult to get at short notice. Save our
- 3:41Spurns also agreed to support Pat's request for an
- 3:43adjournment, as we had identified another roads expert,
- 3:47but haven't had the time to finalise it. The request was
- 3:52then passed to the other side. Elvin and Beatty, councils for
- 3:56DFI, and Dalradion, both singing as usual from the same hymn
- 4:00sheet were in agreement that it was not a breach of proceedings,
- 4:04and the removal of our roads expert was self-inflicted, and
- 4:08basically we should suck it up. mr. Fagan, counsel for FODC,
- 4:13interestingly seemed to be shy about joining this discussion
- 4:17and withheld his counsel. The commission then adjourned for 10
- 4:22minutes while they went away to discuss it. Save our spurns
- 4:26withdrew outside to contemplate this latest development. On our
- 4:32return, we were told the adjournment was overruled. We
- 4:36moved on then to tourism, led by mr. Tom Tett, on behalf of Del
- 4:39Radian, with little or no evidence stated that there
- 4:43seemed to be negligible recreational use of the road
- 4:47that is to be abandoned, and from this had drawn the
- 4:50inference that there would be no noticeable impact on tourism.
- 4:55Fagan for FODC countered with the wider picture on spoiled
- 4:59landscape. Tapes that people want to visit, that they're not
- 5:02necessarily looking for a built attraction. In fact, that would
- 5:05take from the experience that they are actively seeking. Going
- 5:10back to the subject of the replacement road, Logue from
- 5:15DFI, one of the Shire being beings that inhabit this
- 5:19department, suggested that by adding two new bends onto the
- 5:24proposed road, it would slow down boy racers who told laugh
- 5:29like this has ever been a problem there, and that there
- 5:33has been a partial relaxation of regulations given to the road
- 5:37because of these special bends. One might think you could find a
- 5:41better reason to replace a perfectly adequate existing
- 5:44local road than boy racers performing mating circles in
- 5:48their tractors. Regulation relaxation includes reducing the
- 5:54width of the road from six metres to three metres. Proposed
- 5:59road gradients will be 10 per cent, and Pat Harty went on to
- 6:04say that this road is a hall road for the mine, and the
- 6:07design quality is so poor that the engineer who signed it off
- 6:11should be struck off from the chartered engineers. This seemed
- 6:14to upset the commissioners a little. He continued that the
- 6:18council wouldn't pass it, even if it was just a dirt track
- 6:21specification, not one for Hall Road, as was being proposed,
- 6:27that it was obvious that the road was following the
- 6:29topography of the site, and that there was no ground
- 6:32investigation, no geotechnical assessment, and he went on to
- 6:37spend almost an hour speaking about standards and the
- 6:40derogations from it read the proposed new road later on the
- 6:47morning. Mary Brawley added in that there was no vertical and
- 6:50horizontal alignment, no scheme options report, no survey
- 6:55evidence, limited public consultation, no material
- 6:59assessment, no bill of quantities, no artworks
- 7:03programme plan, no design drainage, no site establishment
- 7:08plan, no risk register. I can go on and on, but you probably get
- 7:13the drift. Dorman of Hoy Dorman, the company that drew up this
- 7:19wonderful plan for the road replacement droned on for almost
- 7:23another hour, basically refuting everything that Pat Hawley and
- 7:26Mary Brawley had said earlier on. He started with the first
- 7:30thing to keep in mind is that the replacement road should
- 7:34retain existing characteristics and distinctiveness of the
- 7:38route. The proposed replacement road will have a four foot high
- 7:42fence on one side and a significant security seven foot
- 7:46high fence on the other side, with a toxic way stump of 57
- 7:50metres high and a gate stroke barrier at either end. Oh, boy,
- 7:55one good thing, though, there will be a view to the south, and
- 7:59of course the road will be safe from boy racers, that's along
- 8:03with all the gradients and bends, etc. It would be tarred
- 8:06and to carry heavy loads. Contrary to what Beatty said,
- 8:11this will be a haul road, no matter how they dress it up, as
- 8:14it is over engineered to be simply a replacement road that
- 8:18nobody asks for. The existing road is more or less straight,
- 8:22with views all around, mature hedges, trees here and there,
- 8:27and it's an absolute joy to walk on at any time without barriers,
- 8:30without fences. Quite the contrast, you might say. And
- 8:36that's about all that happened today. Lots of very tedious and
- 8:39boring details, which were trashed out after hour after
- 8:42hour. They expect to complete this section tomorrow. We'll see
- 8:46you all then. And don't forget, if you're listening from Spotify
- 8:52or an Apple, do follow us, give us a review, either written or
- 8:57press the stars. It really makes a difference. Thanks, everyone.
- 9:01And see you soon. Bye.