Latest / 10 Minute Murder | Bingeable True Crime Stories / The Murder of Mo

Transcript

The Murder of Mo · 10 Minute Murder | Bingeable True Crime Stories

0:13
Discretion advice. This is ten minute murder. Anna Mariah Wilson, known as
0:43
Moe, grew up surrounded by people with a deep love for sports. Her
0:48
entire family was athletic in some way, and as a young child, Moe
0:52
quickly fell in love with competitive cycling. She was also a talented skier,
0:57
but cycling was the sports that she wanted to spend the rest of her life
1:00
doing. Even after graduating from high school and then receiving her Bachelor's of Engineering
1:04
degree, cycling was at the center of Moe's life, and eventually she was
1:10
able to launch into a career as a professional gravel cyclist. In late twenty
1:15
twenty one, Moe had a fling with another professional gravel cyclist, world champion,
1:21
Colin Strickland. Even though the two shared a deep passion for the sport,
1:26
the romantic part of the relationship quickly ended. But while Moe and Colin
1:30
were quick to move on, Colin's ex girlfriend, Caitlyn Armstrong was not.
1:37
Colin and Caitlin, who was a relator and yogurt teacher from Michigan, had
1:40
an on again, off again kind of relationship. During one of their separations,
1:46
Colin started dating Mo but afterwards he decided to get back together with Caitlin.
1:51
On the eleventh of May twenty twenty two, Moe was staying at a
1:55
friend's house in Austin, Texas, while preparing to compete in a cycling race.
2:00
While she was in town, she decided to meet up with Colin.
2:02
The pair traveled to the Deep Eddy pulled together for a swim, and then
2:07
had dinner together before Colin dropped her back off at her friend's house. Before
2:10
leaving to see Mo, Colin lied to Caitlin about where he was going,
2:15
hoping that she would not find out that he was meeting up with Moe.
2:19
However, after using her laptop to look at his messages, Caitlyn managed to
2:23
use the exercise app Strava to track his location. Only a couple of hours
2:30
later, Moe's friend Caitlin Cash got home and found Moe lying in a pool
2:34
of blood on the tiled bathroom floor. This, by the way, is
2:38
a different Caitlyn spelled with the sea instead of a K. She dialed nine
2:43
one one, telling the operator quote, I can't tell what happened. She's
2:46
not awake and there's blood all over her face. When first responders arrived at
2:52
the house, they pronounced Mo dead at the scene. Mo's autopsy revealed that
2:55
her cause of death was blood loss due to multiple gunshot wounds, one to
3:00
the chest and two to the head. The angle and positioning of the bullet
3:05
holes revealed that she had been shot while lying face up on the floor,
3:08
in the same position where her body was later found. Several nine millimeter casings
3:14
were found at the scene, but the gun that was used to shoot Mo
3:17
was nowhere to be found. Now that investigators knew that Moe had been murdered,
3:23
it became crucial to find out who had been in and out of the
3:25
house before Caitlin Cash arrived home at nine forty five. Police were able to
3:31
recover footage from several neighborhood surveillance cameras which showed Colin Strickland pulling up outside the
3:37
address and dropping Moe off. It was clear from the footage that Colin remained
3:42
in the vehicle, he had not followed Moe inside, and he had not
3:46
returned to the property after leaving. However, less than two minutes after Moe
3:51
had gone inside the house, a second vehicle had been captured near the address,
3:57
a black twenty twelve jeep Grand cherry Key, identical to the car that
4:01
Caitlyn Armstrong drove. Initially, Colin told the police that he didn't know Mo,
4:08
but after a while he admitted that the two of them were still romantically
4:12
linked, and that he often deleted text messages from his phone to prevent Caitlin
4:15
from finding out. And to pause the story really quick, if you've ever
4:19
find yourself in Colin's situation here, which I hope and pray that you never
4:24
do. But Colin is asked by the police if he knows Mo. He
4:29
says he does not, when they know he definitely knows Mo. Doing that
4:32
only makes him look like he's hiding something He's guilty in some way. So
4:36
if you ever find yourself in that situation, do not lie tot the police,
4:41
especially about something that they already know. They're just asking to see what
4:44
you say to gauge whether or not you could be a suspect. It makes
4:47
the investigation go by smoother, and the police were able to focus on the
4:51
possibility of who actually committed the crime. Okay, back to the story.
4:57
Despite Colin's best attempts at hiding his infidel, Caitlyn found out and she was
5:01
willing to do anything to make sure that Colin and Moe could no longer see
5:05
each other. The police received an anonymous tip from somebody close to Caitlin,
5:11
claiming that shortly after finding out about Colin and Moe's continued relationship, Caitlyn expressed
5:16
interest in buying a gun. The jeep's plates were traced and investigators confirmed that
5:24
the car was registered to Caitlin and Colin's address. On the twelfth of May,
5:28
police searched the property and recovered Caitlyn's firearm, a nine millimeter handgun,
5:33
which matched the casings that had been found with Moe's body. On that same
5:38
day, coincidentally, Caitlyn was arrested due to an unrelated misdemeanor theft warrant.
5:44
Four years prior. She had gotten botox done and left the SPA without paying
5:48
for her treatment. The police questioned her, but then released her immediately afterwards
5:53
because of an error that caused her recorded date of birth in the police database
5:58
not to match the one printed on the outstanding warrant. It was only a
6:00
technicality, but it meant that Caitlin was free to leave. The following day,
6:04
she went to a dealership and sold the jeep Cherokee. After that,
6:09
she began the process of fleeing the country altogether. On the fourteenth of May,
6:15
Caitlyn got on a flight to New York and visited her sister Christine.
6:18
She spent four days there before boarding a flight to San Jose, Costa Rica,
6:24
but the ticket was under Christine's name instead of her own. From then
6:28
on, Caitlyn stopped using her own name, instead introduced herself as Ari and
6:33
using the full name Alison Page. She arrived in Santa Teresa, a small
6:39
beach town located west of San Jose, and booked accommodation at a surf and
6:44
yoga lodge called Don John's. Caitlyn tried to blend in with the other travelers,
6:48
working on her laptop on the lodge's patio and going out for drinks with
6:53
the other guests in the evening. Despite going by a different name, Caitlin
6:58
was still concerned that she would be recognized. There was a warrant out for
7:01
her arrest, and the Austin Police Force had asked the US Marshals for their
7:06
assistance in locating her, and on the twentieth of May, the Marshals released
7:11
a wanted poster with Caitlyn's picture on it. So after spending a few weeks
7:15
in Santa Teresa, Caitlyn made a trip back to San Jose, where she
7:20
dropped thousands of dollars on plastic surgery to change the appearance of her face.
7:26
By late June, the US Marshals were closing in and they had started to
7:30
interview locals and travelers staying in Santa Teresa. According to CBS News, who
7:35
interviewed one of the US marshals signed to tracking her down, he said,
7:40
quote, we decided we were going to put out an ad or multiple ads
7:44
for a yoga instructor and see what would happen. Those Craigslist ads appeared to
7:48
pay off. Less than a week later, they were able to locate Caitlyn
7:53
sitting outside Don Johns on the patio. One of the marshals who apprehended Caitlin
7:58
initially didn't recognize her due to to the plastic surgery, saying quote, Initially
8:03
it didn't appear to be her, but as I got closer, I realized
8:05
it was her. It appeared she had a bandage on her nose and her
8:09
lips were a bit swollen. Her hair was a little bit lighter. The
8:13
marshals escorted Caitlyn to the closest jail before she was extradited back to the United
8:18
States. On the eleventh of October twenty twenty three, only a few weeks
8:24
before the trial, Caitlyn attempted to escape from law enforcement a second time.
8:28
She was escorted out of jail by several corrections officers to go to a medical
8:33
appointment, but after her appointment was finished, she was able to break free,
8:37
removing the restraints from one of her hands and sprinting away from the officers.
8:41
While she was running, Caitlyn ripped down her jailed pants, revealing that
8:46
she was wearing thermals underneath in a hope to be less recognizable. After her
8:50
path was blocked by a six foot tall fence, Caitlyn attempted to climate and
8:54
was grabbed by one of the corrections officers in pursuit. It was pretty clear
8:58
that the escape attempt was not spontaneous. In fact, prison staff had noticed
9:05
Caitlyn exercising vigorously for months before her escape attempt, doing squats in her cell,
9:11
practicing hours of yoga, and running as much as she was able to.
9:15
Caitlyn also made sure to complain about an injury that would guarantee her leaving
9:20
to go see a doctor without any restraints on her legs. A search of
9:24
her jail cell revealed a thin, sharp piece of metal, which investigators believe
9:28
that she used to remove one of her handcuffs. With Caitlyn's attempted escape failing,
9:33
the trial's opening statements began on the first of November. More than twenty
9:37
witnesses testified, including one of Caitlyn's close friends, Nicole Mertz. Nicole told
9:43
the court that during a conversation with Caitlyn, she asked her what she would
9:48
do if Colin ever started dating someone else. Seriously, Caitlyn had been quick
9:52
to reply, I would kill her. The trial concluded on the sixteenth of
9:56
November, when after only a couple of hours of deliberation, the jury reached
10:01
their verdict. Caitlin Armstrong was guilty of Moe Wilson's murder and received a ninety
10:07
year prison sentence. During the trial's punishment phase, Moe's mother told the jury
10:11
quote from the day she was born, Moe had a force in her.
10:16
She lived as if every day was her last day, and she lived it
10:20
so fully. She never wasted any time. It's as if she knew her
10:24
life would be short. That's ten minute Murder for today, brief and bingeable
10:48
true crime. My name is Joe, I'm the host, and thank you
10:52
so much for taking the time out of your day to listen to ten Minute
10:56
Murder. If you're on to the next episode, you're on a binge,
10:58
don't let me stop you. But if you're new to listening to ten Minute
11:01
Murder, take the time now to subscribe to the podcast. That will more
11:05
easily help you catch up on all of the back episodes and all the new
11:09
ones will be right there in your face when you open the app to listen.
11:13
If you like this episode, leave a rating and review on Apple,
11:16
Spotify, Audible, any place that that's possible. Your positive feedback helps the
11:20
show grow. You can go to ten minute Murder dot com for all things
11:24
related to the podcast and coming up on the next episode of ten Minute Murder,
11:28
let me tell you what that story is going to be about. As
11:31
a matter of fact, let me just read you what's written here, and
11:33
this is what's going to be in the episode description, so that you know
11:37
exactly which one you're listening for. A killer stalked the streets of nineteen nineties
11:41
apartheid South Africa, targeting vulnerable women and leaving a trail of brutality behind him,
11:48
using a front and the promise of a potential job to lure his victims.
11:50
In this twisted, sadistic murderer perpetrated the life of pain that seemed to
11:56
follow him like a dark cloud. Right, it sounds pretty interesting, so
12:01
do not miss that one coming up on the next episode of Ten Minute Murder.
12:05
And that's going to do it for today. Thank you so much for
12:09
listening to Ten Minute Murder.