Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Therapist Flirts With Client
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserve listeners. It's just me today. I received an email recently
- 0:05from someone emailing in as a client saying that her and her therapists are maybe
- 0:13starting a romantic sexual type of relationship, and so I thought I would review
- 0:20that email in this episode and talk about all the different things that need to
- 0:26be discussed when we talk about this sort of thing. So let's get into
- 0:32it. This emails from an anonymous YouTube member. She says, I would
- 0:37like your opinion on my therapist. I feel like there is a lot of
- 0:42transference countertransference going on, but I've never been in therapy before, so I
- 0:50don't know if it's normal. I didn't expect such a strong emotional connection with
- 0:55my therapist, so maybe I'm just over analyzing it. I started therapy about
- 1:00five months ago, so it sounds like for the first time five months ago
- 1:06started therapy. I'm a forty year old female with two children. I have
- 1:11been in an abusive marriage since I met my husband in high school. Okay,
- 1:15so she's forty two kids, currently married, and she's saying abusive and
- 1:23she's been with him since high school, so you know, twenty plus years.
- 1:29I found a therapist and wanted my kids to go to therapy as well,
- 1:34so the therapist sees all three of us separately, so sees the mom,
- 1:40the emailer, and also her two kids. I thought this was normal,
- 1:46but I've recently been told that it's not okay. Just chiming in.
- 1:49So I'm guessing that you might have been asking around about this transference, countertransference,
- 1:57or maybe something else, and people are saying to you that it's not
- 2:00normal, or maybe even claiming it's unethical for your therapist to see you and
- 2:07your two kids all individually in therapy, And the way people talk about this
- 2:15is absurd. People, even ethics teachers, sometimes miss the market on this.
- 2:23When you actually talk to people who adjudicate these kinds of things, or
- 2:25who litigate these things in court, or who review these things for licensing boards,
- 2:34they will never tell you that it's unethical for a therapist to see a
- 2:38mom and or two kids individually. There are pros and cons to it.
- 2:43There is a con in that what if one of the kids wants to confide
- 2:49in the therapist about the mom, and the kid feels afraid to do that
- 2:54because the kid might feel like the therapist is on the mom's side or that
- 3:00the mom's going to find out about it or something. You know, that
- 3:01confidentiality. Another con is that as a therapist, it would be hard to
- 3:07remember what is confidential. Now. Sometimes you can mitigate that by just having
- 3:13an ROI having an agreement between all three people that you can disclose information and
- 3:19share. But you know, again that degrades the sanctity of the confidentiality agreement
- 3:25that you can have with clients. You know, there's a lot of benefit
- 3:28to that. You know, there's various other cons as well, But the
- 3:32pros are that the therapist is pretty intimate with the family system. So when
- 3:39the therapist is talking to one of the kids, the therapist knows in their
- 3:45mind other stories or context that will help that the kid. You know,
- 3:53one scenario that I would run into is say you have a teenager that is
- 3:59complaining about their parents being strict, and I am a family therapist who works
- 4:04with everyone. Would I wouldn't normally, I don't know if I ever did
- 4:10actually just flat out see people individually. What I would do is I would
- 4:15treat families and I would occasionally meet individually with different members of the family.
- 4:20And one of the benefits of that would be that if the teenager was complaining
- 4:27to me about the parent, then I wouldn't, you know, because if
- 4:30I was just an individual therapist with the teenager, I would listen and do
- 4:36it everything. I would do everything I could to help the kid, but
- 4:41I wouldn't be able to do much beyond that. As a family therapist that
- 4:45is also seeing the parents, I could literally go to the parents in the
- 4:48next session and say, so, your kid complained about this and that.
- 4:53And I would always ask the kids like, do you want me to talk
- 4:56with your parents about this? And for some people they'd be like, well,
- 4:59that's triangulation, and yeah, but there are functional triangulations, and there's
- 5:05also just helping families, you know, getting the ball rolling between, especially
- 5:11when family members can create so much animosity and conflict that it's hard for them
- 5:16to get back on track without someone in between at first. Anyway, So
- 5:21I could go, you know, I'd ask the kids, so, do
- 5:24you want me to talk to the parents, And the kid might say,
- 5:27well, well, what are you going to say? And I would tell
- 5:29the kid what I was going to say, and the kid would say,
- 5:31okay, yeah, that'd be good. And then I go to the parents
- 5:33and I would say, look, you know, your kid complained about you
- 5:38in the falling way. I'm not saying that your kid is right or wrong,
- 5:41but in the effort of open communication, I thought I would help to
- 5:46do this so that we could build some trust so the two of you can
- 5:48actually talk. Or I would open the conversation in the next family session.
- 5:53You know, I'd be like, so, Johnny, last time we talked,
- 5:57we agree that you would bring up the following thing complaint to your parents.
- 6:01So go ahead once you complain to your parents now, and you know,
- 6:04there's a lot of benefit to having one therapist who is treating multiple members
- 6:10of a system. You know, and the list goes on and on.
- 6:13But what you'll hear from people, almost universally is it's unethical for a therapist
- 6:17to see a mom and the two kids individually at the same time. And
- 6:23no book says that that it's unethical to do that. No review board is
- 6:30particularly for family therapists. But you know, even for individual therapists, there
- 6:34are cautions, there are considerations. There are situations when you probably should not
- 6:42do that, like if, for example, the mom was abusive, then
- 6:46to have the to sorry, to have the you know, the mom and
- 6:56the kids with the same therapist could make the kids feel less safe, that
- 7:00kind of thing. And this really drives me nuts, particularly as a family
- 7:03therapist, because our whole profession is based on having the option, when clinically
- 7:12and ethically sound, to do so, to see multiple members of a family
- 7:18in the same room, and to have different configurations, different you know,
- 7:23subgroups of the family, see just the parents, or just the kids,
- 7:26or just one parent one of the kids, or or even just one of
- 7:30the kids, and you meet individually with them at times, and to have
- 7:36outsiders and other professionals in my field claim that it's unethical to do so,
- 7:44it's like, you know, family therapy has been around in earnest since the
- 7:47seventies, so let's wake up. It's sort of like if you're a psychiatrist
- 7:53and of the vast majority of people, including people in our industry, say
- 7:59that prescribing pills is unethical, It's like, our whole industry is based on
- 8:03this. Why do you think we have this profession college marriage or family therapy
- 8:07when if the entire profession is unethical at its core, you know, it's
- 8:15really disheartening. And I'll even hear people in marriage to family therapy that will
- 8:20claim it's unethical to see multiple people individually. So it's again, there are
- 8:24considering, it's there are things to think about, but it's it's not unethical.
- 8:31That the amount of crap that I see on Reddit and on the Internet
- 8:35about what is and what is not is ethical is it's astounding just how how
- 8:41many misinformed, stupid people there are out there. And yeah, it's really
- 8:48disheartening, and I blame it on our profession because there are answers, there
- 8:54are experts, there are people who can actually speak to these issues with intelligence,
- 9:01but somehow we don't elevate them or listen to them enough or care to
- 9:07ask them what their opinion is. We all just spout. I find that
- 9:11a lot of therapists just spout. They just say like it's unethical because they
- 9:16think it is or they feel that you know, and they're insecure and they
- 9:20can't tolerate not knowing, and and they don't know who to ask. I
- 9:26mean, I'll I know that was me for many years in the beginning of
- 9:28my career. When I ran into an ethical dilemma or question, I didn't
- 9:33know who to ask. I could look up the codes and read it,
- 9:37but it's it's it's not very clear. There's there are so many, I
- 9:41would say, the vast majority of ethical dilemmas that we run into as therapists,
- 9:46or questions that we run into in our ethical codes. It does not
- 9:50help to read the ethical codes. The ethical codes are very baseline. They're
- 9:54very just fundamental things. You know, like you will respect your client,
- 10:00you will try to uphold confidentiality unless there's a reasonable reason that you would break
- 10:07confidentiality. You will not have sex with your clients. You know, real
- 10:11basic shit, and almost nothing about the various different situations that are you know,
- 10:20talked about in our field regarding what is and what is not ethical.
- 10:22Anyway, So getting back to you, remember you're forty, you're in an
- 10:28abusive marriage, you go to therapy for yourself, your two kids, and
- 10:33moving on. Here, here are some things that have been said and happened
- 10:37over the last five months. Okay, I think the rest of this is
- 10:41all about the transference countertransference. My first session, my therapist asked me if
- 10:48I was famous. He had mentioned a few times and various sessions that I
- 10:52reminded him of an actress. One day after one of our sessions. He
- 10:56messaged me and said he remembered it and it was a movie called Salts.
- 11:03The main character in that movie is Angelina Jolie, arguably the most beautiful woman
- 11:09on the planet. I scoffed and said, yeah, right, I wish.
- 11:15And he insisted that I looked like Angelina Jolie and said I needed to
- 11:20increase my confidence. Okay, well, just charming in here. You know,
- 11:24I'm guessing this gets worse as we go through this, but just that
- 11:26on its own, it's not necessarily a problem. And if it makes you
- 11:31feel uncomfortable, which I don't know if it did at the time, then
- 11:35just tell him, Just say, hey, you know, I don't want
- 11:39to talk about my appearance and therapy. You know, thanks for the compliment,
- 11:43but it's not really why I'm here. It's a hard thing to do
- 11:46to say to a therapist, honestly, But if there's a relationship where you
- 11:50should be able to say something like that and be safe and get a very
- 11:56good therapeutic response, it would be with therapist. So but anyway, moving
- 12:03on, he asked about my sex life with my husband. He asked if
- 12:09I'm satisfied with my sex life with my husband. Once he told me that
- 12:13I should stop at a sex store on the way home to grab some plastic
- 12:18toys. Later he told me that he was a sex therapist for six years.
- 12:22Just chiming in here, Okay, we're starting to hear some minor yellow
- 12:28flags. For some people, this would be a slam dunk indication of an
- 12:33unethical thing that's happening. It's not necessarily and we'd really have to hear what
- 12:37was said and how it was said, and what the justifications were. You
- 12:43know, there's nothing wrong with a therapist raising the topic of one sexual life.
- 12:50Now, of course, the therapist should be careful, particularly if it's
- 12:54a male therapist and a female client, that there should be a lot of
- 12:58care around. Like I'm gonna ask you a question, do not feel like
- 13:03you have to answer it. I'm just wondering if you wanted to talk about
- 13:07your sex life or how satisfied you are. I'm not going to ask you,
- 13:11you know, this is me talking as a therapist. I'm not going
- 13:13to ask you questions in detail, and at anytime you can just say I
- 13:16don't want to answer that, but I think it might be if you want
- 13:22to helpful to you, If you could explore your sexual satisfaction of your life
- 13:28and we could talk about maybe what you could do to improve it or something.
- 13:33Is that something you want to talk about? Is that okay? Yeah?
- 13:37Absolutely? So did that happen or is this the beginning of a pattern?
- 13:43Because if it is, then yikes. But if not, then it's
- 13:46totally fun. But again, if it makes you feel uncomfortable, then you
- 13:50should always just say, hey, you know, I don't really want to
- 13:52talk about that right right now, or that's not really why I'm here.
- 13:56And if I asked a question of that nature and a client told me that
- 14:03they weren't comfortable, I would bend over backwards to apologize and say, yeah,
- 14:09totally, I'm sorry. I you know, here's why I was asking
- 14:11that question, And thank you for telling me that you're uncomfortable talking to you
- 14:16know, I totally respect that, and you know, I'll make sure to
- 14:22not go on that route road again, or if I do, I'll really
- 14:26just make sure that you're you are comfortable even beginning to go down that road,
- 14:31you know. So going back through email, he gives me a lot
- 14:35of compliments my therapist. He tells me I'm beautiful on the inside, and
- 14:39out. I shaved my head and one day I came in with my wig
- 14:46on and he said I was gorgeous. He told me I'm a wonderful mother
- 14:50and that I'm a rare fine and he told me to never change. One
- 14:56day he was looking at me with this look on his face, and I
- 15:01asked what it was, and he said he was admiring me. Just chumming
- 15:05in again. Okay, I'm guessing this is a ramp up to it getting
- 15:11worse, which is than it really changes this. But if I just heard
- 15:16this, then it's not necessarily a problem. If you're uncomfortable with it,
- 15:22then by all means say so. But for a therapist to you know,
- 15:30so, I don't do this. I feel like in my twenty five years
- 15:33or almost thirty years as a therapist, and I've probably only had a handful
- 15:39of times where I've ever had a reason enough to talk about a client's appearance.
- 15:48I avoid it for a variety of reasons. One because it's not a
- 15:54topic that is even on the table as an option, or there's no real
- 16:00reason to comment on someone's appearance or how attractive they are or something. But
- 16:06I feel like years and years ago I remember thinking in my mind, like,
- 16:12I don't want to do this right now, but I feel like it
- 16:17would help the client if I did tell them that they were indeed attractive.
- 16:22And the only thing I can think of is to why. I don't even
- 16:25know if I did it at the time, but I do remember having that
- 16:27thought in my head. And the only reason why I would have thought that
- 16:30was because I would have thought it was the only way to help someone overcome
- 16:37their distorted idea of themselves as a disgusting, ugly person or something. And
- 16:44you know, there's a tactful way of doing it right where it's just like,
- 16:48look, you know, I'm a human being as well as a therapist,
- 16:52and I'm not saying that I'm attracted to you, but because that's not
- 16:56really how I am as a therapist. But I will say that you are
- 17:03objectively attractive. I'm guessing to a lot of people. So the fact that
- 17:08you see yourself as a disgusting person, you know, I've been trying verious
- 17:15different ways to counter the way that you see yourself, which I think is
- 17:19interfering with your self esteem and also interfering with your relationships and the possibility of
- 17:25relationships. You know, I've been trying verius different things to combat that,
- 17:30and I'm going to continue to keep doing those things. But I also just
- 17:34hope that maybe I can just say this one thing and it will help us
- 17:38get down this road of I'm pretty sure I would pet a lot of money
- 17:44that a lot of people, if I were to pull them on how they
- 17:48saw you as on a scale from one to ten, that a lot of
- 17:52people would put you pretty high up there, certainly much higher than you see
- 17:56yourself. So you know, end of role play, that that would be
- 18:03the way that I might say it. And I wouldn't say I'm attracted to
- 18:10you or you're you're beautiful to me. Now, another therapist might do that.
- 18:15I have known therapist sounds creepy, but I know male therapists who can
- 18:21absolutely pull that off in a fatherly or grandfatherly way. I know this one
- 18:27therapist who is beloved by everybody, and he's a very much of a grandfather
- 18:32figure, and he absolutely has said things like that to people, clients and
- 18:41students right in front of me, and they eat it up, you know.
- 18:48And I would talk with the students after these these interactions and they would
- 18:52just speak glowingly about this professor, and and so you know it, we
- 19:00don't usually hear about those kinds of vibes in our society. We tend to
- 19:07basically see men in this context in one of two ways. It's just like
- 19:12they're two kinds of men. You have men who refrain from saying such things,
- 19:18and then you have groomers who do say those sorts of things. You
- 19:22know what I mean. I think there's a wide variety of types of people
- 19:26or motivations or vibes that people can give off if they're going to compliment you.
- 19:32But anyway, so it's if I just heard this bit from someone,
- 19:38a client saying, you know, my therapist told me to see let's let's
- 19:41read this back. He says that I'm beautiful on the inside and out,
- 19:48and he said I was gorgeous with my wig on. He told me I'm
- 19:52a wonderful mother and that I'm a rare find and to never change the thing,
- 19:59to never change. I mean, it's kind of weird because that's why
- 20:00you go to therapy, right, But I'm guessing he maybe the communication was,
- 20:04you know, don't change your appearance or something, or you don't need
- 20:08to change for someone to love you or something. So I mean, one
- 20:14of the changes that might be happening or that a therapist might be building towards,
- 20:19is you don't need to change to love yourself. What you need to
- 20:23change is how just how you see yourself like. You don't actually have to
- 20:27change, but your view of yourself should change to meet up with reality that
- 20:33you're a good person. You don't need to change anyway. And then he
- 20:37said, looking looking at me, he was admiring me. Yeah, you
- 20:41know, it's hard to tell, but I'm guessing this this gets worse here,
- 20:45or let's take a break, all right? Going on, he has
- 20:52told me that I will have no problems getting a man. He said,
- 20:56if I put a blast on Facebook, everyone would be asking for a date.
- 21:03He has made it very clear that he has attracted to me. He
- 21:06even told me in our last session that I was attractive. All right,
- 21:10just chiming in, Yeah, this is a problem. This is when I
- 21:15start to get upset at this therapist and other therapist and I'm not there.
- 21:19If this therapist we're here to defend himself, he might be able to convince
- 21:25me. But I've seen this a lot that it's almost like there are two
- 21:30mindsets in my field. Both are wrong. On one side of the fence,
- 21:37you have people are saying that it's unethical to be attracted to your clients
- 21:42and there's something wrong with you if you're attracted to your clients, and you
- 21:48should never admit to anyone colleagues or clients or anyone if you do have an
- 21:55attraction to a client, because that means you're some sort of disgusting pervert or
- 22:00something, and obviously that's wrong. And then on the other side of the
- 22:04fence, you have people who are like, if you're attracted to a client,
- 22:08you should immediately tell them, because if you don't, it's crazy making
- 22:15or gas lighting to a client because they'll detect it. But if you don't,
- 22:19if you deny it, then you're actually driving them crazy. So you
- 22:26should just admit it, and you should just deal with it up front and
- 22:33make it part of the therapy. Again, this is stupid, it's short
- 22:37sighted, it's simple minded. Now, can you bring it up in therapy,
- 22:44sure, but a lot of things have to happen before you, as
- 22:49a therapist, just blurred out that you're attracted to a client. You should
- 22:56get pretty comprehensive consultations, revision, and or therapy to sift through those feelings.
- 23:06One number two, you should have been noticing those feelings earlier on,
- 23:12possibly even in the first session. It'd be weird for an attraction like that
- 23:18to just emerge later downline. Of course it could, but usually they emerge
- 23:22it right away for therapists. So that's another thing. The other thing is
- 23:26that when you do tell a client, which always needs to be in service
- 23:32of the client and not yourself as a therapist, then it has to be
- 23:37predetermined how you're going to do that and why, and then there has to
- 23:40be a whole amount of attention and space made for the client to explore how
- 23:47that feels to them and the impact on therapy that that's going to have.
- 23:52It can be done, and it might actually help the therapy. It's not
- 23:56common that it would be wise to do so because at the very least it's
- 24:03it's a distraction to the client, but it's also you know, potentially really
- 24:10distracting and also threatening to a client. So can you talk to your clients
- 24:18about attraction? Yeah, but if you did, it would have to be
- 24:21something like, look, you know, I have to admit, you know,
- 24:25like I'm trying to think about some common scenario. So let's say that
- 24:30you have a therapist who pretty quickly realizes they're attracted to their client and is
- 24:37trying to suppress it. Oh, you know, let it go, Let
- 24:38it go. And then a few sessions down the line, he's thinking,
- 24:42oh, you know, you know, I keep thinking about this client.
- 24:47Oh, I think I'm having some kind of transference here that is of an
- 24:52erotic or romantic nature. And okay, I need to talk with my colleague,
- 24:57and you know, he goes to his colleague and well, I'll just
- 25:02use myself. This has literally never happened because for whatever, you know,
- 25:07I've I've studied a lot of the research on the prevalence of this kind of
- 25:11attraction to clients, and it's you know, it's fairly high for people of
- 25:17all genders a therapists, but to varying degrees. Right, you know,
- 25:21there's extremely mild attraction to obsessive attraction to a client, and it's a you
- 25:29know, it's a fairly common experience, particularly if you're a therapist with enough
- 25:32people over time. And for me, though I don't know if it ever
- 25:37has happened in my life, there's just something about being a therapist that it
- 25:45turns that off for me. I've noted that, oh, this person is
- 25:52attractive, but it just I feel like there's so much, you know,
- 25:57it's sort of be like what I imagine a first responder might feel like.
- 26:03If you're an emergency medical professional and you arrive at a car accident and you
- 26:11come up on one person's very injured and it's the husband and the wife,
- 26:18or let's say it's it's it's two women friends and one woman is very injured
- 26:23and the friend was also in the car, but she she's unscathed, she's
- 26:29fine, And let's say this, the unscathed woman is very attractive. Well
- 26:33to a first responder, I'm guessing you know, in the back of their
- 26:38mind, they might note that the uninjured person is attractive, but there's so
- 26:44many other things that you're you're panicking about, you know, or not panicking
- 26:49necessarily, but that you're you're concentrating on. Right, You're you're trying to
- 26:55save someone's life. You're you're thinking about a lot of medical things and monitoring
- 27:00that. That's how I am as a therapist. I'm not panicking as a
- 27:03therapist, but I'm focused so much. Or I suppose it's more akin to
- 27:08say a medical professional like I don't know a proctologist or something, or a
- 27:17gynecologist or a it will be GUI n or or I don't know, just
- 27:21a general practitioner that you know, you're there to do a job and you're
- 27:25you're not just casually hanging out. So I don't know. That's the only
- 27:30anyway point is is that it's pretty common anyway. So let's let's say that
- 27:34that it was me and I had that experience that I said earlier, Well,
- 27:40I would immediately talk to Bob. I would say, hey, we
- 27:41got to talk, and so I would start to lay out my feelings and
- 27:45I would just kind of ramble and he would listen and ask questions. And
- 27:49you probably asked like, well, do you think this is going to be
- 27:52doable? Do you think you should refer her out? Or is there is
- 27:57it possible that you might be able to keep this under wraps and not let
- 28:03her because the other factors, Well, if this becomes a focus in my
- 28:07head, it'll interfere with treatment. I won't be able to concentrate on treatment,
- 28:14or I'll be constantly second guessing my treatment. It's like, am I
- 28:17Am I only saying this because I'm attracted to her? Or is it?
- 28:21Is it something else? You know, there are considerations, and so I
- 28:26would have that conversation and let's say that I determine that, you know,
- 28:30I can manage, and then I say, well, let's set up a
- 28:33time, you know, every couple of weeks, we're all check in with
- 28:36you with this, and then I proceed with treatment. And in my head,
- 28:40I'm just like, well, maybe it'll go away, and let's say
- 28:41it doesn't. Let's say it kind of gets worse, like as I as
- 28:45I get to know her, she's you know, mentally compelling, you know,
- 28:51she her personality is very attractive too, And I find myself late at
- 28:56night. I'm really uncomfortable using myself in this scenario, but I'll just keep
- 29:02going because it's, uh as this has never happened to me. But you
- 29:07know, it's late at night and I'm I'm just thinking about her, you
- 29:12know, or you know it's that lovey feeling. Oh, I can't imagine
- 29:15having this. This is so you know, it's it's normal to have it
- 29:21at times, but I just can't imagine anyway. So then I go back
- 29:25to Bob, It's like, oh, it's getting worse. You know,
- 29:26I'm thinking about her at night. And and then you know, we talk
- 29:30about how to make sure the frame of therapy is upheld, and you know,
- 29:34we talk about maybe referring out again, and and let's say we decide
- 29:38not to refer out. But I am you know, reminding myself, don't
- 29:45go over on sessions, don't text her outside of session. That that's just
- 29:52a temptation to start kind of having a back and forth, which is the
- 29:56beginning of the slippery slope for these sorts of things. I might want to
- 30:02go into therapy to figure out, like what is it about me that?
- 30:07Why am I attracted to a client so much? You know, is it
- 30:11is it just a cigar? Is a cigar that we you know, if
- 30:15we did meet in real life, might we have hit it off? Is
- 30:19it just that? Or is there something about her that's hooking me in a
- 30:25pathological way? How are my relationships going? That would be the main question,
- 30:30because that usually is what's happening that. You know, therapists who do
- 30:37this sort of thing are often going through a divorce and drinking a lot,
- 30:41So looking at those factors would be important. And let's say I do all
- 30:48that work, and let's say you know, my well, let's say that
- 30:52my relationship. Let's say I'm single at the time, and my relationships aren't
- 30:57going so well, and you know, you can't just snap your fingers and
- 31:02fix that sort of thing. Maybe even in therapy, I'm going through kind
- 31:06of a difficult period with what we're talking about, like some major trauma or
- 31:11loneliness stuff. And I talked with my therapist about the transference or the countertransference
- 31:18I'm having with the client, and and I, let's say I determined that
- 31:23for a very variety of reasons, it just would not be in the best
- 31:27interest of the client for me to refer them out. You know, there's
- 31:30some reasons why that might be the case. Okay, So after all that,
- 31:33this is, you know, probably three four, five months in,
- 31:37eventually I tell my therapist and Bob that I think my client can can tell.
- 31:48I think she can tell because the way I look at her. She
- 31:52actually asked me what I was looking at she she she had this you know,
- 32:00this look, and she has this question. God, you know,
- 32:04even as I get to this point, I'm still like, why the fuck
- 32:07would I tell the client. It'll just muddy the waters. It'll just make
- 32:13it weird for the client. You know, why would I want to dump
- 32:16it on the client? But okay, I'm trying to really force my I'm
- 32:21sure there's another scenario, but I'm too COVID mind to think of another one.
- 32:25So let's say that we determine that I'm going to tell the client.
- 32:30So I plan at how I'm going to say it, and then I say
- 32:34to the client, look, I you know the other day you asked,
- 32:37yeah, so maybe it was that, Like the client asked, you know,
- 32:42you seem to look at me sometimes and it seems like you, I
- 32:49don't know, it seems like you're trying to tell me something with your eyes
- 32:52or something. And let's say that I determined that I probably was, but
- 32:58in the moment with the client, I'm like, no, no, that
- 33:00I don't know what you're talking about. And then the client there's a there's
- 33:04a relationship rupture there because the client feels one thing, but I'm telling her
- 33:08another thing. And I determined that for the client's interest, I should come
- 33:15clean so that the client isn't made to feel crazy for their instincts. You
- 33:21know, maybe it's a part of the client's issue that they came in for
- 33:24me for that people had gas lit them seriously before, and here I am
- 33:30doing it to her again. So I'm like, okay, So next session,
- 33:34I say, so, I thought a lot about what you said last
- 33:40week, how you said I was looking at you in a particular way,
- 33:44and and you seem to be very convinced of that, and you had cited
- 33:50other kind of vibes that I'd had with you in previous sessions, and then
- 33:53you asked me about it, and I said that there wasn't anything there.
- 33:59Well, I felt like I felt guilty afterwards because I was kind of lying
- 34:07to you, and I think you might have felt that I was deceiving you.
- 34:12And I really don't want to make you feel like I'm deceiving you or
- 34:15that I'm discounting you or gaslighting you. So I you know, I talked
- 34:22with my therapist. This is me talking in there. I talked with my
- 34:25therapist. I talk with a colleague of mine, and I've been talking about
- 34:30this issue for a long time, and we all determined that I would tell
- 34:36you this, which is that I do indeed have an attraction to you,
- 34:44but nothing will ever happen between us, because I'm your therapist and I'm here
- 34:50to help you, and I take my ethical codes very seriously and my duty
- 34:53very seriously. But I don't want you to you have an experience with me
- 35:01where you're experiencing something from me, a vibe from me, and then you
- 35:06ask me about it, and then I just lie to you that it's not
- 35:10there. So that's the only reason why I'm telling you I'm dealing with it.
- 35:15Long story short, it's because you know, there are some issues in
- 35:20my life that helping you kind of triggers, and so I think that's what's
- 35:25happening here. At no point in our lives, even after therapy, will
- 35:32we ever even being a friendship because I take these relationships very seriously. I
- 35:38take therapy very seriously. But for the sake of your treatment and for the
- 35:45sake of not lying to you, I'm telling you that when you asked me
- 35:51that question the other day, you might be right that I might actually kind
- 35:55of have a vibe with you. I know this is kind of a big
- 36:00deal to say in therapy, and I apologize because you know I've been trying
- 36:05to because this happens sometimes, you know, attraction sometimes happens for a therapist,
- 36:09but usually you can kind of wait it out and it'll go away,
- 36:13especially if you're consulting about it and that sort of thing. But this one
- 36:17didn't really go away. So you know, I'm sorry for lying to you
- 36:22last week. Do you forgive me? And also how does it feel to
- 36:27hear me say that? So end of role play. That's the full scenario
- 36:32right where I could imagine maybe it would be justified. It's still highly questionable
- 36:39whether or not it's worth it to reveal to the client for kind of a
- 36:45minor rupture there. You know, another thing that I could have said would
- 36:51be like, look, I want to apologize for last week. You asked
- 36:53me if I had a vibe with you, and I said I didn't,
- 36:57and I was a little dismissive of it. What I will say is that
- 37:04I think if you, I just have a lot of admiration for you.
- 37:07I think you're a great person. I'm not attracted to you because i'm your
- 37:12therapist, but I was. I probably had you know, so end of
- 37:17role play. This is me half answering, half being true, but also
- 37:22half lying to for the sake of the client. You know, so that
- 37:27they aren't you know, confused or pulled out of their therapy or you know,
- 37:35threatened in any way. This is my problem that I'm having, it's
- 37:38not. It's not her problem. It's not. So that's always the considerations,
- 37:45like if I'm going to self disclose or if I'm going to do anything
- 37:47in therapy, what's the best choice for the client? And then when I
- 37:52leave the office, then I have to deal with my ship, you know
- 37:55what I mean. So the two camps that I often here are your there's
- 38:01something wrong with you for being attracted to a client, which isn't true,
- 38:06or always tell your client, And I'm like, no and no, that
- 38:13you might tell your client under very strict circumstances after much consultation and therapy,
- 38:21and even then it's questionable as to whether or not that's in the best interest
- 38:25of the client. Have you said all that? There is another scenario like
- 38:32the grandfatherly vibe that is totally legit that I've never really tried to adopt,
- 38:39which is that, you know, a grandfatherly sort of person could say to
- 38:45a female client, I do have you know I am attracted to you,
- 38:52not that anything will ever happen, but you are a beautiful, gorgeous person.
- 38:57And if I were fifty years younger and not your therapist, I would
- 39:02have absolutely wanted to go on a date with you. And and that's it.
- 39:07That's all you say, right, and you mean it. You know,
- 39:10as a grandfatherly seventy five year old therapist talking to a thirty year old
- 39:16woman who you determine as a therapist might benefit from a little self esteem boost,
- 39:22and you know that the client won't misinterpret it or be creeped out by
- 39:25it, and it's in the surface of the client. You know, it's
- 39:29in the service of the client. Could you pull that off? Yeah,
- 39:34you could. You know there there there's a legitimacy to that. You'd have
- 39:37to be very self aware. And you know because it's not like sventy five
- 39:43year old therapists and thirty year old clients don't have impropriety, improprieties and relationships
- 39:52outside of therapy, because they do. But if if you know that about
- 39:55yourself, and you know that the client and you you know, determined predetermined
- 40:00that the client isn't at risk of confusion or threat or something along those lines,
- 40:07then you know you could do that in the service of a client,
- 40:10So, anyway, going on with your So you tell us anonymous YouTube member
- 40:17that well, let's take a break. All right, we're back from the
- 40:24break. So what were you telling us? He says that he has made
- 40:31it very clear that he has attracted to me. Okay, yeah, I
- 40:36don't know what the circumstances were. Maybe he is talking to his therapist and
- 40:40a consultant, but it's not It doesn't sound like it. But who knows?
- 40:47Going on with the email. I once said something along the lines to
- 40:51him about us hanging out, and I knew that we couldn't. Oh sorry,
- 40:57I read that weird. I think COVID makes it hard for me to
- 41:00read. I feel like I'm reading really in a labored manner. Let me
- 41:05try to make the funt bigger. I once said something along the lines to
- 41:09him about us hanging out, but I knew that we couldn't hang out.
- 41:14He said, I was going to make him lose his license because he really
- 41:19wants to hang out. Just charming him. Okay, yeah, there's no
- 41:24reason to even think that, let alone say it to tell a client that,
- 41:31yeah, I want to hang out outside of therapy with you too,
- 41:36but you know, oh boy, you're gonna make me lose my license?
- 41:40Yikes? Just what are you doing going on most of my appointments? I
- 41:45mean, so, shouldn't that be a red flag to a therapist if you're
- 41:51even thinking such a thing, let alone saying it out loud, like,
- 41:54oh, I might lose my license? Do you think maybe that's a time
- 42:00I'm to check in with yourself, not only with this client, but maybe
- 42:04just take a full inventory what the fuck is wrong with your personality going on
- 42:08most of my and and that usually is the case. I've you worked with
- 42:14people, both professionally and and also as a podcaster with cases like this,
- 42:20and it seems to me that therapists who go down these roads have something significantly
- 42:27wrong with their personality, that there's something going on there. There's so many
- 42:32things that you would have to overlook within your own soul and training to proceed
- 42:39down a road like this, because it's not just a sudden thing. You
- 42:43know, you heard me describe in that scenario, I laid out of all
- 42:49the things that I would experience. It was just like, oh, I
- 42:52think I'm attracted this person. I would I would notice right away in the
- 42:57first session, and then well, maybe it'll go away, we'll see how
- 43:01you know, it goes second session, you know, second, third session,
- 43:05it's still there. That's when I immediately consult with someone. And you
- 43:09know, there's so many things that will happen to a therapist that we are
- 43:15obviously supposed to be aware of and take action around, some sort of action.
- 43:21And these people that go down these roads don't hesitate for a second,
- 43:28and they blow past literally thousands of alerts that are trying to tell them to
- 43:36stop and think, and they just don't. There's something wrong with someone,
- 43:42you know. Of course, psychopathy comes to mind, but it also could
- 43:46just be actual narcissism, not the internet version. God, the amount of
- 43:51bullshittery on the Internet around narcissism, it's it's getting worse and worse. It's
- 43:57really stark. Yeah, four years ago it was bad, but now it's
- 44:05just constant, particularly if you're on TikTok and shit. I mean, it
- 44:10is awful. I mean, it's bizarre. How did this word narcissist or
- 44:19narcissism basically just completely replace what people used to on the internet call sociopath or
- 44:25sociopathy, which is at least closer to the mark. Even though the vast
- 44:30majority of forensic psychologists don't use the term sociopath or sociopathy. We use the
- 44:37term psychopathy or psychopath or any social and all the bullshittery around the distinctions between
- 44:44these three constructs are really quite alarming as well in the Internet, even among
- 44:49clinicians by the way, So it's really bizarre. And also I think it's
- 44:57harmful because the way they talk about a narcissist is that I think it's like
- 45:02a cartoon version of the way that TV shows and movies, you know,
- 45:08like like the TV show You on Netflix, I think it was. It's
- 45:14like people watch too many movies like Hannibal Lecter and stuff, where it just
- 45:21constructs this notion of personality and then people start applying it to everyone that bothers
- 45:29them, particularly in relationships. It's like, you know, yeah, I
- 45:32was my boyfriend. I was with him and he said he loved me,
- 45:37but then one day he cheated on me, and when and then he broke
- 45:40up with me, as if he just didn't care. He must be a
- 45:44narcissist. He's been grooming me from the beginning, He's been manipulating me from
- 45:49the very start, And you're like, well, wait, so what I
- 45:53mean maybe, but it's more likely that he's a regular human just like you,
- 46:00and he fell in love with you and he cheated, which which is
- 46:06what a lot of people do, unfortunately, And he is lying to himself
- 46:10because he's ashamed of himself and he doesn't want to believe that he's a bad
- 46:15person, so he made justifications up in his mind that it was okay to
- 46:21cheat on you or to break up with you in the way that he did.
- 46:23And it's kind of eating away at him on the inside, but consciously
- 46:28he's justifying it in various different ways. And and everyone does that you've done
- 46:32that, you just don't want to admit that you've done it. That doesn't
- 46:37make someone one narcissistic and two your version of a narcissist, which is basically
- 46:45someone who wakes up in the morning and it is on a master plan to
- 46:51ruin people's lives. You know, did this person ruin your life? Yeah?
- 46:54It sounds like I'd be devastated if I original shoes. But what's where's
- 47:00this weird? Yeah? I've been over this anyway. So so anyway,
- 47:04I'm talking about the sort of people that go down these roads, and it's
- 47:09and you know, it's not that severe, right that typically, Like I'll
- 47:15give one example, there was someone I was working with who had this problem.
- 47:21She was a professional mental health professional and had an ongoing relationship with a
- 47:27client, and when she was discovered by officials and sanctioned and outed in a
- 47:36variety of ways. Long story short, she didn't really absorb the situation even
- 47:45after she was caught as a mental health professional, such that a year or
- 47:50two later she was doing it again or something like that. I can't remember
- 47:53their details, and she would make these excuses about it. She would say
- 47:59things like, well this time it's different, or I don't understand why I
- 48:02can't have a relationship, or you know, these really just simplistic statements.
- 48:07And she was very smart too, She's a very smart, very accomplished professional.
- 48:12But the mental gymnastics that are that's indicative of trauma and of personality characteristic
- 48:19characterological disorders was so severe. You know, when I talk about personal disorders
- 48:24distortion as a homework, if you're OCPD, the distortion is that because you
- 48:31have this flawed behavior, you made this one mistake or this one imperfection,
- 48:37or you might then the world is coming to an end and no one will
- 48:42ever love you. You don't consciously feel that way, but you do feel
- 48:45that way, and you do distort it. You know, if you're Bob
- 48:49and you believe that you're dirty to the core and no one would ever love
- 48:53you if they really do, that's a distortion. If you're borderline and you
- 48:57think that people are banning you left and right and secretly want to break up
- 49:02with you all the time, even though that's not the truth, that's a
- 49:07distortion, right. So for these individuals that are having at least chronic affairs
- 49:14with clients, there's a distortion. There's something going wrong there, right,
- 49:19And yeah, it's upsetting that they don't get the help they need, because
- 49:25certainly people with personal dis orders and distortions can be excellent therapists and very ethical.
- 49:31It's upsetting when people don't take the time or put in the effort or
- 49:37have the supervision or mentorship to guide them to monitor this kind of thing.
- 49:44Anyway, So most of my appointments are on Fridays because the day works out
- 49:49best for me. After the last two sessions, in their early evening,
- 49:52he called me and asked me if I wanted to come back to the office
- 49:54and talk to him some more, but I declined. Just chiming in here.
- 50:00Yeah, this is a classic sign of the slippery slope of a therapist
- 50:05abusing a client. It's it's one of the classics. In fact, now
- 50:08that we've gotten to this point, let's review all the classic signs that we've
- 50:14that we've seen so far, so just talking about this classic sign is so
- 50:21you start with a client as a as a client, and there's and the
- 50:25frame of therapy is being upheld right there. There's no boundary crossings at all.
- 50:30And in our lingo we have boundary crossings and boundary violations, so I'll
- 50:36kind of violations are worse than than crossings essentially, And so so that's that's
- 50:42on one end of the spectrum. On the other end, the spectrum is
- 50:45sleeping with your client. Okay, so the slippery slope. And research finds
- 50:51that because there was a pretty extensive set of research that looked at how do
- 50:57these things happen? How do you go being a client to being someone's lover?
- 51:04And isn't the word lover? It's kind of funny, but sometimes that's
- 51:08the word they use in literature. Let's seeing us very you know, uptight
- 51:14journal article in this academic publication will use the word lover anyway. So what
- 51:23they found in the research was that almost always there's this progression, this slippery
- 51:29slope, and what you'll find is that there will be a little bit more
- 51:35contact outside of this session. There will be you know, face to face
- 51:38contact out of the session, and at some point you meet outside of the
- 51:44office, right where you go to a coffee shop. You know, you
- 51:47make up some excuse or there's anyway my brain isn't working right right, I
- 51:52think COVID is couching up with me. But some of the classic signs are
- 51:58he's calling you and asked if you want to come back to the office to
- 52:01talk with him. Some more so, it's it's it's not going to a
- 52:06restaurant, it's not going to a hotel room. It's just in his office.
- 52:10But it definitely is a boundary crossing. Now would it be okay for
- 52:16a therapist to do that. Absolutely there might be a situation where a therapist,
- 52:22you know, like if I had if I was a sort of there
- 52:24and I used to do this kind of work as my schedule allowed for it.
- 52:27It doesn't anymore, and it hasn't for a long time. But if
- 52:30I had a major disruption, sorry, if I had a major relationship rupture
- 52:37with a client, say on a Tuesday, and by Wednesday or Thursday,
- 52:43I'm just like, oh, you know, let's say it's a borderline client
- 52:46and I really cared about this client. We had this rupture and it was
- 52:51my fault, and I'm thinking, if I wait all the way until Tuesday,
- 52:55there's a chance that the client will downloard spirals so much mood wise and
- 53:01also with our relationship, that they'll never come back again. So I've got
- 53:06to nip this in the butt. So I might actually call the client and
- 53:09say, hey, you know, I really want to talk about what happened
- 53:14last session, and I want to apologize, but I want to do it
- 53:16in person, and I don't want to wait until Tuesday. So how about
- 53:22we make an emergency session tomorrow on Friday? Is that okay with you?
- 53:27And I won't charge you for it? Might I do something like that?
- 53:30Yeah? I don't know if I ever did, but I could see myself
- 53:34doing that. Yeah, so that's okay. But if it's in the midst
- 53:37of all this other stuff, like I'm attracted to you, I'm admiring you.
- 53:43You look like Angelina Jolie. You're going to make me lose my license.
- 53:50You're gorgeous, You're a rare find. You know, it's it's just
- 53:57all the classics signs. And for the record, some of you might think
- 54:01that, you know, therapists like this or predators, and certainly that's one
- 54:05way of looking at it. The vast majority of therapists who do this sort
- 54:08of thing are not Machiavellian psychopaths. There's something wrong with them, and they
- 54:15end up in the same way that everyone else does, falling in love with
- 54:17their clients such that it clouds their judgment and so they're in their heart.
- 54:25They are restraining themselves a lot. They can't help it, right, the
- 54:31relationship is and they start to convince themselves, you know, it's just like,
- 54:35well, therapy is almost over with this client, and you know,
- 54:38it's okay to socialize a little bit with a client now and then, and
- 54:44then eventually the persons saying, look, you know, we terminated therapy.
- 54:47Now we can date now. It's okay. You know, according to ethical
- 54:51codes, and if you really look at the ethical codes of all the professions,
- 54:54it's clear that it's not just this blanket open check that says, you
- 55:00know, past this certain point. Because in the ethical various different professions,
- 55:06they'll lay out a time span of just like you can't you know, socialize
- 55:09or have a romantic relationship with a client unless you have been terminated for X
- 55:15amount of years, right as clients. I believe in marriage family therapy,
- 55:21I did a whole review of all the different professions. I think in marriage
- 55:22family therapy there's there's it says never essentially, you know, because some of
- 55:28them say like one year or two year or seven years. But I think
- 55:30a marriage family therapy they're just like never, like it just stop. But
- 55:37even then, if you do wait the amount of time, it still needs
- 55:42to be within the client's interests meeting that you as a professional, If you
- 55:47were to date a former client, you would have to have determined that it's
- 55:52not going to ultimately harm the client, the former client, and you know
- 55:55that's a hard thing to determine. So what I always say is, you
- 56:00know, just there's a lot of fish in the sea, and stop dating
- 56:06former clients. There's there's no reason to do that. Also, the fact
- 56:12that you're attracted to a client, you know, is probably an issue in
- 56:16and of itself, like there's a top down nature to that relationship that is
- 56:22not uh, you know, conducive to a fair relationship. And that is
- 56:28often what will happen in these relationships is the the client will you know,
- 56:34the former client will start to want things in return, you know, like
- 56:39I would like you to admire me, you know, because often there's a
- 56:43lot of admiration from client to therapist, right, and a therapist who narcissistically
- 56:50need that might seek seek to date clients because clients already start out worshiping them
- 56:58in a certain way. And then when that balance that scale is attempted to
- 57:05be balanced by the former client as things move forward, oftentimes the therapists can't
- 57:09tolerate that and then they end it. That's not always the case, but
- 57:14anyway, going on, he lets me stay late after our sessions if the
- 57:20next client hasn't come yet. Just champing here. Yeah, another classic sign
- 57:23staying late in and of itself really nothing. I always tell my colleagues and
- 57:32my supervisees that you should not do that unless there's a big reason. Like
- 57:38I had a client once that scheduled me for an appointment to an in home
- 57:45family therapy appointment, and the daughter had died tragically and suddenly the night before,
- 57:52and so they called me for emergency session, and so I scheduled them
- 57:57for an hour, and I showed up, and you know, as we're
- 58:00getting close to the end of the hour, I was just like, we're
- 58:01nowhere near being done with this session. You know. It was just a
- 58:05big family in their living room, and and the session ended up going three
- 58:09hours. So I quote unquote went over. But in that scenario it was
- 58:16and I think important to do that. I had the time to do that,
- 58:20the clients wanted to do that, So yeah, can you go over
- 58:24sometimes? Sure, you know, are some therapists a little looser with that
- 58:30sort of thing. Yeah, but I don't recommend it. You know,
- 58:34I never get complaints from clients about ending on time. I mean occasionally a
- 58:39client will be like, oh, man, you know, maybe we should
- 58:45schedule longer meetings or something, and I'm like, yeah, we can talk
- 58:47about that. But I do hear because I'm really anal about ending on time.
- 58:55And very occasionally I will go over if you know, I have a
- 59:01client who we reach like this actually happened not too long ago with a client
- 59:07that it was literally the last like thirty seconds of the session. And I
- 59:15think it was me that brought something up, and I thought it was just
- 59:19kind of a wrap up thing to say to this session, to you know,
- 59:23some sort of summary, and it opened up a can of worms with
- 59:30the clients. And I was like, oh, I shouldn't have said that,
- 59:35and then I, well, it was my fault. So I was
- 59:38like, I can't just end the session right now because it would feel really
- 59:43weird. And you know, now that I think about it out loud,
- 59:46I probably could have ended it, but because I felt guilty, I didn't
- 59:52want to. So that's another thing that often is the reason why therapists will
- 59:58go over is because the therapist isn't aware of their unjustified shame that they feel
- 1:00:06about themselves, because that's that's often a driver of that kind of thing.
- 1:00:09And I think that was at play for me at the time. But I
- 1:00:14didn't go too far over. I you know, my my sessions end on
- 1:00:17the on the ten, you know, on the fifty, when the big
- 1:00:22hand gets to the ten, that's when I end sessions. And I think
- 1:00:28we went like h for another twelve minutes or something, and I didn't have
- 1:00:32a client afterwards, so it didn't matter. But the reason why we want
- 1:00:37to keep the frame of therapyists so that you know, if you go over
- 1:00:42one, you're likely to bleed into the next session. And as you know,
- 1:00:46you clients out there who have therapists who show up late, you know
- 1:00:51how that feels. It doesn't feel good, especially when you're on time.
- 1:00:55So you're not doing anyone any favors by doing that, including your own practice.
- 1:01:00But also if you go over with a client one day and then the
- 1:01:07next day you don't, particularly if the client has sensitivities around abandonment, then
- 1:01:10they might think, oh, I wasn't a good client today. That's why
- 1:01:14my therapist didn't reward me with going over. Like, just end the fucking
- 1:01:17session on time. It's not hard to do as a therapist. I remember
- 1:01:22thinking this when I started out, because it was kind of hard in the
- 1:01:25beginning for me, because you feel bad when you're starting out just abruptly ending.
- 1:01:31You know, It's it's not how things usually go in life, right,
- 1:01:35especially when someone is talking about something very personal and they're crying. It's
- 1:01:42not normal to in a social situation or even with a coworker to just suddenly
- 1:01:47say, oh, sorry, time's up, we have to end this conversation.
- 1:01:52It feels very, very weird and rude, right, but you just
- 1:01:55got to get used to it. You also learn ways to ramp the client
- 1:02:00down. Like if I was, you know, when the big hand gets
- 1:02:05to the nine and I had a client that was still kind of in the
- 1:02:09midst of a lot of emotion and crying or something, I might say to
- 1:02:15them, so we have about five minutes left, but I really want to
- 1:02:19hear more about this, so I just want to remind you about that.
- 1:02:22Plus we can talk about this next time, and I think we should,
- 1:02:27but I just want to remind you. But you know, peace continue.
- 1:02:29So I'm preparing them right so that it just doesn't come out of left field,
- 1:02:32because you know, clients doesn't necessarily look at the clock as they're going
- 1:02:36through a session. I actually don't encourage clients to look at the clock because
- 1:02:40I'll remind them. You know, they client, especially if it's a long
- 1:02:44term client with me, they can usually kind of tell by the rhythm of
- 1:02:47my language that we're rap we're getting closer to the end. Because there's certain
- 1:02:53ways that I talk at the end of a session anyway. So yeah,
- 1:03:00just you know, keep it in your pants, don't date clients, and
- 1:03:06as a much minor er issue and your sessions on time going on here,
- 1:03:14he has also initiated three hugs with me, just chiming in. Yeah.
- 1:03:19Again, in and of itself, not likely an issue because you can certainly
- 1:03:24do that as a therapist, but it's not recommended that men initiate hugs with
- 1:03:32women clients, especially unless you really ask or something. But you know,
- 1:03:39I've hugged clients before. I don't I don't think I've ever initiated one.
- 1:03:45Well maybe I have with men. It would always be with Ben if I
- 1:03:49was initiating, but but that's not common anyway. So you take all this
- 1:03:57into it. So those are all the different behaviors. You know it it
- 1:04:00doesn't look good, it doesn't it's there's a there's an off chat. I
- 1:04:03would give, you know, like a three percent chance that if we had
- 1:04:06videotape and we heard from the therapist that there wouldn't be a problem here,
- 1:04:11and you know, it'd be like no, no, no, this and
- 1:04:13that needed to dah. There's a there's a small chance, but you know,
- 1:04:16given everything we're hearing it doesn't it doesn't sound good. And the thing
- 1:04:20that I think the YouTube member is leaving out is that she's also attracted to
- 1:04:26the client or to the therapist. She is having those feelings. I don't
- 1:04:30know to what extent, but so it's not like he's just it's not one
- 1:04:38directional. It sounds like it sounds like it's at least somewhat too directional.
- 1:04:41It sounds like maybe more from him, but anyway, going on with email,
- 1:04:45he is forty four years old and single with no kids. He has
- 1:04:49talked to me about women that he dated. Again just chiming in. There's
- 1:04:55nothing inherently wrong with that kind of self disclosure, but when we take everything
- 1:04:59into count, it is worrisome. Worrisome in that I'm worried for the client,
- 1:05:06pretty worried for the client, and there's well, where do I put
- 1:05:12to it. I'm worried that this So even if the client, the email
- 1:05:17or in were to end the relationship now and say yeah, I don't,
- 1:05:23I think this is going down a weird roads. It might even be going
- 1:05:27down a weird road for me and my attraction. So you know, look,
- 1:05:30I'm going to terminate I'll find out a therapist there's a possibility, and
- 1:05:34I've worked with people like this before, where for the next ten years,
- 1:05:41the client could still be reeling and having a variety of motions afterwards, from
- 1:05:47loss to longing to hurt and anger, feeling betrayed. Right, because it's
- 1:05:56a sacred bond a therapist and a client. There's a vulnerable that a client
- 1:06:00hands over to us, and for us to play around with that and to
- 1:06:05be attracted to someone and to entertain or flippantly play around with the possibility of
- 1:06:13dating or something, it's violating to the client and often is seen that way
- 1:06:19by clients, not not always right away. It can feel that way because
- 1:06:25when you're in the midst of the lovey dovies, you only see the lovey
- 1:06:29dovies five years later, once the lovey dovies wear off is when you start
- 1:06:32to go like, well, wait, what how come he was I was
- 1:06:38the client? Well, and it can it can feel really violating. It
- 1:06:42can. It's similar to like a rape because the emotional vulnerability and the how
- 1:06:49you just lay yourself open, right and for someone to insert their own sexuality
- 1:06:59or romantic needs into that, it's it's violating. It's betraying, right.
- 1:07:06This is why it's fucking important that people get trained on this and are monitored
- 1:07:13on this sort of ship because it's it's it could be really devastating there.
- 1:07:16That's another point I want to say, is there gonna be a real delayed
- 1:07:19negative effect for people going for clients who go through this sort of thing.
- 1:07:26So you know, if a client checks into with themselves ers like well,
- 1:07:30I don't mind this, or I kind of like the attention. It's not
- 1:07:34necessarily true that you'll always feel positive about what's happening going on. I'm finding
- 1:07:42myself getting very attached to him emotionally, and it's hard keeping the space between
- 1:07:46us. Sometimes I daydream about being with him, but I know that can't
- 1:07:50happen. I'm not trying to be conceded, but I know I am reasonably
- 1:07:56attractive as a woman, and I'm fairly certain he likes me. Is he
- 1:08:00trying to create transference between us and the hopes of helping the therapeutic process just
- 1:08:06chiming in? Not likely. There is a possibility of that that he is
- 1:08:13trying to create transference, maybe meaning that he's playing up or playing into his
- 1:08:19attraction to you to try to get you to be attracted to him. I
- 1:08:25mean, that's not the standard of practice, and I certainly can't see a
- 1:08:29reason why that would be justified. But I've never heard of such a thing.
- 1:08:34And really the standard of practice if you do anything along these lines,
- 1:08:40is to encourage parental transference, meaning that I might encourage a client to see
- 1:08:47me as a parent, which is, you know, obviously very different than
- 1:08:53seeing me as a romantic partner. Right now, if I and I have
- 1:08:58had this, it's very common for a client to be attracted to me or
- 1:09:03to be in love with me, to want to marry me. And it
- 1:09:08sounds funny. I'm not saying it's common that people fall in love with me,
- 1:09:12but it's par for the course, you know, I would say,
- 1:09:17let's see, I don't know, maybe even this highest fifty percent of clients
- 1:09:21who are borderline or historyonic or have similar schemas will have some sort of significant
- 1:09:30transference to me. And all therapists that that treat, you know, therapists
- 1:09:35who are like me, that are attachment oriented and long term, you know,
- 1:09:39like Bob and me, it is a commonplace for that to happen,
- 1:09:44and that all is normal and okay, and expected and and fine, so
- 1:09:55there's that. But I might with all my clients try to create a transference
- 1:10:02to me as a parent, Like if I have a client who was neglected
- 1:10:08a lot emotionally, then I in the back of my mind or sometimes in
- 1:10:14front of my mind, I'm very much not trying to manipulate my client,
- 1:10:18but trying to emphasize a vibe between us that is parental and I am giving
- 1:10:25them attention and to really make it a deeper corrective experience. You know,
- 1:10:30it's one thing to get attention from your therapist. It's nothing to get attention
- 1:10:35from a father figure. You know what I mean. And I'll be explicit
- 1:10:39with clients. You know, I don't play games with people. I'll say
- 1:10:43things like, do you you know we're talking about the fact that they were
- 1:10:47neglected and weren't given enough attention, And I might overtly ask them do you
- 1:10:54feel like I give you attention? Do you feel like I'm paying attention to
- 1:10:58you? One? I'm very curious because I sometimes the dynamic can develop where
- 1:11:04they still feel like even I am not paying attention to but you know,
- 1:11:09say they say, yeah, I do, I do feel like you pay
- 1:11:11attention to me, and I might say, oh, that's good, I'm
- 1:11:15glad, and then I might even use fatherly language, you know, like
- 1:11:19I'm really proud of you, and I think of you as I have a
- 1:11:23lot of admiration for you. You know, there are things that I look
- 1:11:27up to you about. You know, you do this, this and this,
- 1:11:29and I think that's really admirable. So I'm trying to bolster that transference.
- 1:11:34I've literally never in my mind thought I should try to bolster a romantic
- 1:11:42transference towards me, you know, that I should try to encourage a client
- 1:11:45to fall in love with me or be attracted to me or something. And
- 1:11:51even if I had, which I had, I certainly wouldn't emulate an attraction
- 1:11:58to a client to encourage that. That. That's I can't imagine a clinical
- 1:12:03justification with that going on. I have mother neglect issues, so she's saying
- 1:12:12that she was neglected by her mom. I was also molested as a child,
- 1:12:16I was sexually coarse as a teenager, and I'm currently in an abusive
- 1:12:21relationship. My issues run pretty deep, but I feel like I'm a relatively
- 1:12:27strong person. I mainly want a therapy for the validation that I was being
- 1:12:31abused and to help with my kids, any thoughts on what is going on
- 1:12:36here and of email. Right, So you're saying that first off, that
- 1:12:42you have a lot of issues of being harmed. So it's and it's kind
- 1:12:47of a perfect recipe for this sort of exploitation from a therapist that either doesn't
- 1:12:57know what they're doing or no is that they're you know, harming clients in
- 1:13:02this way. If you were neglected by your mother, you know there's a
- 1:13:08transference of that sort to therapists. Right, I'm just like, well,
- 1:13:11I really not only am craving attention and non neglect, you know, I'm
- 1:13:17craving I'm I'm craving a tunement and love from this therapist. But I needed
- 1:13:26a lot because I didn't get any of it growing up. And then you
- 1:13:30add the fact that uh and so and so that that craving is good and
- 1:13:34fine and in a normal transference canter transference relationship can be very corrective if when
- 1:13:42a therapist does give attention to a client like that, but it also opens
- 1:13:45you up to be exploited because you know, you're so desperate you'll you'll overlook
- 1:13:53things or anyway, and then you've also been sexually coerced and molested as a
- 1:14:00child, as a team, and that can not always lead to and you've
- 1:14:05only this is your first batt of therapy, and I'm reminding myself out loud,
- 1:14:10so you know, you're probably at the very beginning of this sort of
- 1:14:15self discovery and healing at least to some extent. And I wouldn't be surprised
- 1:14:23if in fifteen years after you do a lot more recovery, possibly with a
- 1:14:28different set of professionals, that you look back at this time and think that
- 1:14:33you were actually playing a script that you know when you're you were young and
- 1:14:41you were you know, being exploited, that there was a danger there,
- 1:14:45right and when you were under danger and under threat by the people that were
- 1:14:50harming you, one of the you know, you have fight, flight,
- 1:14:55freeze, appease or fawn and faint or you know, very different words for
- 1:15:00it, but the word to focus on here is appease or fun. And
- 1:15:09it's a very natural defense, a very helpful defense when we're being victimized and
- 1:15:14we're powerless as children to turn off our internal self preservation and to hand ourselves
- 1:15:23over because it's better to be harmed under those circumstances than to be harmed when
- 1:15:30you're trying to get away or you're trying to say no or resist. It's
- 1:15:38it's much safer to allow the harm to happen under your own appease. You
- 1:15:45know you're appeasing the victimizer. Also, sometimes the victimizer will go easier on
- 1:15:53you if you're if you're smiling during the abuse. So one of the things
- 1:16:00that will happen over time, if that's repeated a lot, is in the
- 1:16:03moment of someone grooming you or harming you, you literally will not have access
- 1:16:11to your emotions or the self that is being harmed, So it doesn't feel
- 1:16:16like harm. It feels like it feels like you want it. Yet you
- 1:16:19might even become such an appeaser or such a funner that you even encourage the
- 1:16:25abuse to happen. And I don't know if that's a mechanism at play for
- 1:16:30you, anonymous YouTube member, but I would be surprised if in fifteen years
- 1:16:36you look back and you think, yeah, that absolutely it was going on.
- 1:16:40That fucking bastard was supposed to be protecting me and he was just another
- 1:16:45person that was abusing me and coercing me and harming me in that way.
- 1:16:50I mean, what the fuck. Therapists are not supposed to do that sort
- 1:16:54of thing. And I would agree with you when you say though in the
- 1:16:59future, and you know, you say here, my issues run pretty deep,
- 1:17:01but I feel like I'm a relatively strong person. This has nothing to
- 1:17:05do I'm sure you are very strong, but this has nothing to do with
- 1:17:10being strong or weak. I'm wondering if you have a stereotype of people who
- 1:17:16are victimized in these situations as being weak. No, anyone, especially someone
- 1:17:23who's been through what you've been through, regardless of how strong they are,
- 1:17:28can be absolutely harmed by this. The vast maure we've looked into this,
- 1:17:31and the research demonstrates the vast, vast majority of clients and or of yeah
- 1:17:40of clients who engage in relationships with therapists. You could argue you're at the
- 1:17:45cusp of it, or even kind of You've got at least one toe in
- 1:17:48the door there. Now, of course, this isn't none of your fault.
- 1:17:53This is all his fault. You have zero responsibility. You're free to
- 1:17:57be attracted to him, You're free to say that, free to fantasize about
- 1:18:01him. Or ask him out. You're free to do all those things,
- 1:18:04and there's nothing wrong with that. I've had, you know, dozens of
- 1:18:10clients do that to me. And I at no point did I think I
- 1:18:14was being violated, because, you know, the first time it happened,
- 1:18:19it was alarming. That was an intern, and it was a woman from
- 1:18:25Russia actually, and she I think just didn't know that it was not what
- 1:18:32you're supposed to do. And I think I even had it captured it on
- 1:18:36on audio. I was recording episodes for my classes, and I think I
- 1:18:43even and it was a very indocession. Never forget that. Actually, it's
- 1:18:46funny. I haven't thought about that one a long time. And I was
- 1:18:49caught so off guard. I was like, oh, no, I'm I'm
- 1:18:51sorry because it was it was just so unexpected, you know. Anyway,
- 1:19:00so you have done anything wrong. But the vast, vast majority of client
- 1:19:05clients and therapists who enter into these kind of romantic sexual relationships, the vast
- 1:19:12majority of the clients will be massively traumatized and harmed negatively impacted for the rest
- 1:19:17of their lives. It's not a casual thing that happens to clients. It's
- 1:19:25really ill advised for him to be doing this, So we can't count on
- 1:19:31him, though necessarily I don't know. There's a chance that he does know
- 1:19:34what he's doing and everything's fine. I can't tell from a description, but
- 1:19:40there is a chance that we cannot depend on him to protect you, and
- 1:19:45we cannot depend on him to know what to do with this, And we
- 1:19:50can't rely on you to know what to do with this because you're the client.
- 1:19:57But you're the one that I'm talking to you right now, and so
- 1:20:02if there's anything you can do to protect yourself, you should obviously do it
- 1:20:08right. And this is what I would do if I were in your shoes,
- 1:20:13is one I would put it in my mind as far away as possible
- 1:20:18that this is even cod COVID mind. What I would do, first off
- 1:20:28is stop myself from consciously thinking that it was a viable option that the two
- 1:20:35of us would get together, even though my heart and body might want to.
- 1:20:41I would remind myself and I have a lot of episodes on this whole
- 1:20:44thing, by the way, you two member, some of them might be
- 1:20:46for patrons, yet it might have to become a patron listen to those,
- 1:20:48but that there's a fair amount of episode, you know, like a therapist
- 1:20:54kisses a client. A therapist there's another one. There's a bunch of them.
- 1:20:59I I've made erotic countertrance or erotic countertransference might be a couple of the
- 1:21:08episodes anyway. So that's one thing, because if you allow yourself to believe
- 1:21:16that it is something that is viable or that you want, it'll, i'm
- 1:21:21guessing, interfere with your ability to protect yourself moving forward. The other thing
- 1:21:28I would do now if you got to if you presented this case to a
- 1:21:32lot of people, including a lot of professionals, they would say terminate,
- 1:21:36and certainly you can, but that's often a simplistic answer that most clients won't
- 1:21:42do. So if you want to terminate, you can. Now, you
- 1:21:46know, you haven't talked about the therapy if it's benefiting you a lot,
- 1:21:49because if it's benefiting you a lot, it's hard to find a good therapist,
- 1:21:54you know. So it's possible that you know, a couple other options
- 1:21:59might be worth exploring. Now, if it continues and it gets worse,
- 1:22:04then termination is probably the only answer to protect you. But another possibility is
- 1:22:15that you could maybe rein it in a little bit. And here's what I
- 1:22:19would say to him. As I would say, so, I've been thinking
- 1:22:24a lot about our relationship, and you know, you and I talk about
- 1:22:29attraction. You've said you've been attracted to me, and and I did ask
- 1:22:34you if you wanted to meet up outside of therapy that one time, and
- 1:22:36you said that you couldn't because you'd use your license or whatever. And and
- 1:22:43I'm just wondering what your thoughts are about this whole thing, because I'm I
- 1:22:50asked around about this, and people were saying that I should terminate with you,
- 1:22:57that I should fire you as my therapist. But I actually like coming
- 1:23:00to see you. But people were telling me that you were going to harm
- 1:23:06me and that you were being unethical, and I don't know, I'm just
- 1:23:11curious what you think about that something like that. That's what I would say,
- 1:23:15And then I would just stop and listen to what the therapist, and
- 1:23:16I would really take note of what the therapist said. I might even ask
- 1:23:23the therapist to put it in writing. I'd be like, you know,
- 1:23:26could you put it in writing? Because I want to I want to ask
- 1:23:30a friend of mine about your response, So could you put it in writing.
- 1:23:36So if the therapist is on the up and up, which is slightly
- 1:23:43possible, like if let's say I had I'm the therapist and a client came
- 1:23:48to me and said something like that to me, Well, I am on
- 1:23:53the up and up, So what I would say is the following. I
- 1:23:58would say, Oh, my odd, I'm so sorry that I did that.
- 1:24:04I mean, that is awful. I'm you know, it sounds like
- 1:24:09you've been thinking about this and I am so sorry. I really did fail
- 1:24:15as a therapist in this way, and I'm glad that you brought up Thank
- 1:24:19you. Yeah, I do have some issues, and I guess I should
- 1:24:26be talking with a supervisor or my therapist about this, so I'll do that.
- 1:24:34And yeah, I guess I've just been a little too loose about things
- 1:24:42with you. I think maybe because I feel like we could have been friends
- 1:24:46outside of therapy, but that's no excuse. I'm a therapist. I should
- 1:24:51have known better. Yeah, you know, I really made a mistake there.
- 1:24:58I'm sorry, and I've been doing it for a while, so I'm
- 1:25:00going to really try to stop that and we can get back to working on
- 1:25:04therapy and you want it in writing, absolutely, after we adjourn today,
- 1:25:12I'll I'll write up a whole thing and and send it to you and and
- 1:25:16you can bring that around to wherever you want. You know. That's what
- 1:25:21I would say, And I would have no problem doing that. I would
- 1:25:29document the shit out of the session, and I would get consultation to document
- 1:25:32the shit out of that. I would have follow up conversations with the client
- 1:25:36afterwards and document the shit out of that, not only because I care,
- 1:25:41but also, like, this is a lawsuit waiting to happen. Obviously,
- 1:25:45now, if the therapist says anything you know that's pretty far afield from that,
- 1:25:51like what are you talking about, or you know, just suddenly terminates
- 1:25:58with you without any kind of explanation, then I don't know. To me,
- 1:26:04you have your answer. You're like, oh, this is this isn't
- 1:26:09gonna work well, not only in this dimension, but how can I trust
- 1:26:15them with anything beyond this at this point because of the incompetence that's being displayed
- 1:26:21right now, you know. So you know that's that's that's what I would
- 1:26:28do again. Number one is I would put my thoughts in check and say,
- 1:26:34stop entertaining this. I'm saying this my if I was you the client
- 1:26:39be like, I need to really stop entertaining this notion that somehow he and
- 1:26:44I could the other thing. And one of the things you can tell yourself
- 1:26:46along these lines is, well, yeah, under this circumstance, we seem
- 1:26:54to have an attraction and compatibility if you will, that is emulative of a
- 1:27:01romantic compatibility. But there is no fucking way I can know if we're actually
- 1:27:12compatible because this is such a this is such a different context where I come,
- 1:27:18you know. And that's another complaint that former clients will say when they
- 1:27:24are in a relationship with their former therapist, is you know, before when
- 1:27:30he was my therapist, he was I loved him because he was the best
- 1:27:33listener and he was so caring and compassionate. And I've never had a partner
- 1:27:40that was like that. Well, now that we lived together or we're dating,
- 1:27:45he doesn't listen. He never listens to me anymore, or he doesn't
- 1:27:48listen to me the way he used to. And it's like, well,
- 1:27:53yeah, because he was your therapist, you know. Now. I don't
- 1:27:57blame clients, but it's if you are in that situation, no, you
- 1:28:05should really you should know that, you know. For example, Stacy,
- 1:28:10my wife does not see me the way my clients see me. You know,
- 1:28:15my clients will see me as this idyllic some of you actually see me
- 1:28:21as this idyllic person, you know, And believe me, if you were
- 1:28:27stay in her shoes, you would not see me that way. So that's
- 1:28:31normal. A lot of you see Bob in this idyllic way. Believe me,
- 1:28:35if you were calling, I'm guessing you wouldn't see Bob in that way.
- 1:28:39It might be really hard to even imagine that, right, But it's
- 1:28:43it's a very different So it's you know, it's not a bad relationship,
- 1:28:45but it's a very different relationship and you know, filled with glory and frustration
- 1:28:53like any other marriage. So that's another thing to tell yourself, anonymous YouTube
- 1:29:00member, that you're you're having an attraction to him in this context, and
- 1:29:08there's a really good chance that if you were legit going to date him.
- 1:29:13Now I know you're not saying you want to date him, because you're just
- 1:29:15like, oh, that's ever gonna happen. But the sooner you can kind
- 1:29:18of clamp down on those those those kind of urges. There's nothing wrong with
- 1:29:23you know, having a sort of flighty attraction or what if kind of a
- 1:29:28thing. It's another thing to be thinking in the way that I think that
- 1:29:31you and him are thinking. Now. If I was talking to him,
- 1:29:35it'd be a much different story. I would be telling him, look,
- 1:29:40dude, this is one hundred percent year responsibility. You have to clean up
- 1:29:44this shit, and you have to We have to figure out whether or not
- 1:29:47you need to pull back from clients altogether because something you know. I'm only
- 1:29:53saying these things to you because I don't have the opportunity to say something to
- 1:29:56him. If I did have access to both of you, I wouldn't give
- 1:30:00you any advice because this is asking way too much of you as a client
- 1:30:04that your therapist should be having all these conversations with you and doing all the
- 1:30:10necessary things so that you don't have to, you know, do anything.
- 1:30:15You know, like I was saying earlier, clients will sometimes fall in love
- 1:30:18with me. It's my job to figure out how to deal with that,
- 1:30:24how to help the client within that context. It's I would never tell the
- 1:30:28client, oh, boy, well, you know, you got to figure
- 1:30:32out how to manage your feelings so that you can show up a therapy.
- 1:30:34I wouldn't that's stupid. Right, I would never do that, but so
- 1:30:39I want to be clear that I'm only giving you advice because I can't I
- 1:30:44don't have access to him. Another thing you can do, now, thinking
- 1:30:47about it, is you have the therapists listen to this episode and just say
- 1:30:54hey, I want you to listen to this episode in your free time,
- 1:30:57and then we can talk about the next session and then see what he says.
- 1:31:00Yeah. Again, I don't know the situation, and if he were
- 1:31:04here, maybe he'd be like, no, there's this and that, and
- 1:31:06you know, I just don't know. But that's another option. So yeah,
- 1:31:14Well that went on a lot longer than I thought it would. It's
- 1:31:17two hours. I guess it's just been a while since I've had a chance
- 1:31:20to talk about this, and I don't, you know, I felt like
- 1:31:26it'd be good to, you know, lay all this out again. There
- 1:31:30was a time when it was a frequent thing that we would talk about on
- 1:31:34this podcast eight years ago ish or something. I'm not sure exactly why,
- 1:31:43but not so much in the last number of years. And so maybe that's
- 1:31:46why I turned this one email into an entire episode. All right, Well,
- 1:31:53everyone out there, please take care of yourself because you deserve it,
- 1:31:56you really really do wor wor