Latest / Free Cities Podcast / 161 - Swen Lorenz: Demography is Destiny
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Free Cities podcast. My name is Timothy Allen and this is the official podcast
- 0:17of the Free Cities Foundation.
- 0:30Hello and welcome to this episode number 161 of the Free Cities podcast brought to you by the
- 0:38wonderful Veritas Villages. They are building off-grid freedom-oriented communities in Latin
- 0:44America but you already knew that didn't you? You're a regular listener to this show. You also
- 0:49know that these communities will appeal to people who like freedom and who are looking to live
- 0:56amongst like-minded people in places like Nicaragua, Panama and Costa Rica. And for the Bitcoiners,
- 1:04you also know you can buy your property with Bitcoin and you can spend Bitcoin at communities.
- 1:10They can even help you mine Bitcoin with the excess energy that your home will inevitably
- 1:16produce. www.veritasvillages.com forward slash free cities. Now, before I break down this episode,
- 1:25I want to implore you to listen to the end if you're interested, because after the conversation, I have dropped a small narrated addendum to this episode during the interview with today's guest, Sven.
- 1:41Sven Lorenz, he's a returning guest.
- 1:44He mentioned that he was going to write an article about what's been going on in Sark recently because so many people were coming up to him and asking him in real life.
- 1:58Now, he wrote that article and he wrote it just after our conversation.
- 2:02So I read it and I've compared it to our conversation.
- 2:06So I've added a few things which have transpired since we spoke.
- 2:11So make sure you carry on listening at the end.
- 2:14And now if you're a listener to this podcast, you'll hopefully know Sven.
- 2:20Sven's been on before.
- 2:21He's a Sark resident who was at the centre of the recent bid to rejuvenate the island
- 2:28by buying up the Flailing Sark property portfolio of the Barclay family.
- 2:34I'll put a link to my last interview with Sven in the show notes.
- 2:38He appeared alongside the senior of Sark.
- 2:42and between the two of them they gave me an overview of the island how it operates what it is
- 2:48and the problems it was facing at the time so that's a good sort of starter interview if you
- 2:53don't really know what SARC is and what's been going on there this episode is an update on the
- 2:58current situation in SARC since the bid to buy the property and rejuvenate the island which failed
- 3:04and i also talk with sven about the wider issue of confidence in government in general
- 3:12uh right here's the summary for the curious in this conversation sven reflects on sark as a
- 3:19microcosm of wider structural pressures facing small jurisdictions and increasingly europe
- 3:26itself he offers a sober assessment of an island grappling with stagnation demographic imbalance
- 3:32and missed opportunities for renewal, including a high profile investment effort that ultimately failed to materialize.
- 3:41That's the Sark bid, of course.
- 3:42From Sark, the discussion broadens into questions of capital, mobility and confidence in the future.
- 3:48Why people are beginning to move their money away and themselves.
- 3:52How governments respond when that happens and what it means to think seriously about where and how to build a life
- 3:59and a business in an era of growing constraint that's a pretty good summary actually and
- 4:06i did ask my ai to to speak a little bit more highbrow that actually does sound much better
- 4:12so well done ai i will try and be brief in this intro because i'm also going to record the addendum
- 4:17after this but a little bit of housekeeping there won't be any value for value comments this week
- 4:22sorry i mentioned that last week but then i've just realized that we're heading into the christmas
- 4:27holidays so I'm having to queue up three episodes in order to be able to actually take some time off
- 4:34over Christmas so unfortunately I won't have the comments to speak of what I will do instead is a
- 4:42bumper episode in the new year to kick the new year off let's say and in the meantime please
- 4:48consider subscribing to this podcast on fountain.fm I say this every week but it really does help this
- 4:55week you've got a bonus episode that was an interview with me talking about the state of the
- 5:01UK and early access to the normal show the show with Mark Edge that's six bucks a month please
- 5:08subscribe on Fountain with Bitcoin preferably or Fiat I also published last week a news episode
- 5:16it was a little experiment and it went down incredibly well that was a preview of the current
- 5:23goings-on in the honda and general elections which i gleaned from a big conversation that we had
- 5:29directly with our friends and colleagues in the country so from now on i'm going to start doing
- 5:35those much more regularly not on a particular day because news in this industry comes when it comes
- 5:43let's say so i'll be doing them as and when but subscribers you'll get early access to those too
- 5:50you lucky things right this is all part of the expansion plans that i have for this podcast
- 5:56interest is growing we're getting a lot of listeners and as we both grow as a media producer
- 6:04and as the industry grows in general it makes total sense to me to expand so that's what's
- 6:11going to be happening i'm going to be adding new bonus episodes new news episodes and possibly more
- 6:18i'm taking on quite a lot it's it's it's true but i can just see what's happening here in this
- 6:25industry we're starting to explode and i think it's important that we are there and we are at
- 6:31the center of it all as we currently are but going forward too right that's enough from me
- 6:37time for the conversation you know what to do other than of course fantasizing about living
- 6:44car free on a small quiet island off the coast of France. Yes, that's right. Just sit back,
- 6:51relax and enjoy my conversation with Sven Lorenz.
- 7:07Sven, excellent. Do you know what I just did?
- 7:10um i was like you know since since i last spoke to you i haven't really had any sort of sark updates
- 7:19or or any not even that many thoughts about it it's kind of like because it was all building up
- 7:24to such a crescendo it then fell off a cliff so what i just did was i i just did google news
- 7:31sark uk i thought i better see i but it's very very funny what what came out you know i was
- 7:38expecting to see drama with the barclay brothers and blah blah let me tell you the last this is the
- 7:44most recent six articles written about sark and this is just classic sark number one is the most
- 7:51recent sark tractor license fees could double as sark budget debate right number two winter ferry
- 7:59changes are really hard for sark pupils number three sark needs to put economic development top
- 8:06of agenda. That's the
- 8:08most radical one.
- 8:10Four, Sark dairy farmers give up.
- 8:13That sounds sad. So they had
- 8:15a UK farmer set up a dairy farm and they closed it now The Sark crew tackles very tricky cliff fire And the final one rare diseases sufferer
- 8:27Thanks, lifesavers in Sark.
- 8:29Basically, Sark doing Sark things.
- 8:32No one really mentioning we need, apart from that one thing, which is Sark.
- 8:37This is the Guernsey Press as well.
- 8:38The others are BBC, all BBC.
- 8:41You know, Sark needs to put economic development top of agenda.
- 8:44But all the rest of it seemed pretty depressing.
- 8:47Things closing down, things shutting.
- 8:49So, like, come on, you're the man on the ground.
- 8:53What's happening in Sark right now, regardless of all the other stuff?
- 8:57Is it, you know, did Sark have a bit of a lull after the result of all your sort of work came through?
- 9:04Or were people on the island not as invested in the idea so much as you were, obviously?
- 9:10So I'm obviously biased and I'm talking up my own book, but my expectation after our deal didn't come through was always that SARC at best was going to stagnate and probably was actually going to gently slide downhill.
- 9:26And I think it is a reasonable and possibly even quite objective assessment to say that this year SARC has definitely gone downhill, possibly edged towards call it crisis.
- 9:40Yesterday, the budget came out.
- 9:43Chief Police, the Parliament of the Ireland, has to approve the budget every year,
- 9:46and that meeting is coming up.
- 9:47My taxes are going up 21%.
- 9:50And that's a lot, considering, because they're not much, anyway.
- 9:56In percentage terms, it's a lot.
- 9:58Taxes across the board are going up massively.
- 10:02It's now being recognized that there is a backlog of infrastructure investments
- 10:06and more financial obligations coming down the road.
- 10:11I would say that even though there are no official statistics,
- 10:15businesses in Saak have generally not done all that well this year.
- 10:19You hear different things from different people.
- 10:21But what you can say is that the quality of tourism seems to decline further.
- 10:29We have the so-called T and P tourists,
- 10:34which are the worst kind of tourists
- 10:36because they're basically day trippers
- 10:38who come to the island often from cruise ships.
- 10:40They buy a tea, they use the facilities
- 10:42so they're basically costing the money
- 10:45because you need infrastructure for them
- 10:47and they don't really leave revenue on the island.
- 10:50And all of that is indicative of an island
- 10:53that I think it's a bit like, you know,
- 10:55the general situation in Europe
- 10:56where yes, things are great in a way
- 10:59and much of the rest of the world
- 11:01would love to have the same problems
- 11:03but it's sort of declining.
- 11:05It's, you know, cynics would say
- 11:07or would ask, have they given up the will to live?
- 11:10And is anything ever going to improve?
- 11:13And I think the headlines that you picked
- 11:16from the news sources there.
- 11:18I didn't even pick them.
- 11:19Indicative.
- 11:20That was it.
- 11:20That's all I had to go on.
- 11:23Yeah, I mean.
- 11:24Yes, and that's before you have mentioned
- 11:26the never-ending drama about the electricity company,
- 11:29which has now led to Guernsey offering a loan of a million and a half,
- 11:35which would not even begin to cover the investments needed,
- 11:39but would in a way move SARC away from being debt-free
- 11:43and not being answerable to anyone to then having a creditor
- 11:47that happens to be the neighboring bigger island.
- 11:51Are these developments that would make me, you know,
- 11:54enthuse me to buy a house there, build a business, invest into the future. No, I'm very happy to live
- 12:02there. I'm very open about I'm using the special status of Sark for my own advantage. I'm also
- 12:07giving something back to the community. I do pay my taxes. But am I building a future there? Not at
- 12:13all. I've said for years I'm renting because this island has huge issues. And they could only be
- 12:18unblocked, in my opinion, through either a major investment or a major initiative,
- 12:25everyone coming together, something big has to happen. All this small stuff that's being done,
- 12:30you know, if it's even getting done at all. I mean, you know, the electricity saga has been
- 12:35rumbling on for so many years that I've long stopped following it. It's not very inspiring,
- 12:41and it's a great place to live. If you're older, you know, then you can say, yeah,
- 12:45I'll just live out my days.
- 12:46You know, it's good enough for me.
- 12:48But is there a future for young people?
- 12:50Is there a prosperous, confident future for Sark as an independent and truly unique entity?
- 12:59There's a question mark.
- 13:01It strikes me a little bit, like you say.
- 13:04It's like there was an opportunity for massive change.
- 13:08and because it wasn't taken even sark with its such a small government goes back and does
- 13:15government things it's like we need more money so let's take more money let you know the opportunity
- 13:19was there for a solution and because it wasn't taken now and this is what i see in mainland
- 13:26uk you know like there's a failing government that's broke which is slowly fleecing people
- 13:32instead of basically inviting people to come in,
- 13:37bring their capital, bring all their productivity,
- 13:40and then sort of correct the problem that way.
- 13:43The way they seem to be addressing it is by saying,
- 13:46no, do you know what?
- 13:46Let's try and rinse a little bit more money out of the people
- 13:49that we've got, or maybe try and borrow a bit more.
- 13:53It seems like maybe the Sark government,
- 13:56even though it's tiny, is still doing the same thing.
- 13:59Pretty much.
- 14:00And I mean, this is where we're getting into politics and personalities.
- 14:04But I would say even more so after the recent wave of members of parliament stepping down.
- 14:10So there was another article that might pop up somewhere on Google if you look for it about, I think, in the last 12 months, six members of Sarg's parliament have stepped down, which is a third of them.
- 14:22And for what?
- 14:23I mean, not some, you know, just because they don't believe in the place anymore or because they.
- 14:29it's always a combination of reasons and i can't speak for them but i can you know point towards
- 14:35what they've said in public and which was printed in the media which is along the lines of
- 14:39not being heard no new ideas being considered sarg being run by a small elite that wants to keep you
- 14:48know other people from having a say even though they're member of parliament i mean none of this
- 14:52is unusual that's politics everywhere it's a microcosm of the uk it really isn't it i am
- 14:58For a long time, I've been saying that Sark's problems and challenges and also opportunities are really not all that unique.
- 15:05It's sort of like the same in every small island jurisdiction around the world.
- 15:12And sadly, now I'm inclined to say its problems and where it finds itself is not too dissimilar from the rest of Europe.
- 15:21Always with a caveat or with the addition that Sark is sort of at least 50 years behind the rest of Europe in many ways.
- 15:28which is the saving grace.
- 15:30So, you know, welfare entitlements have not grown out of proportions
- 15:33because there just basically is hardly any welfare system.
- 15:37And there is no major issue with debt that's been accumulated by governments.
- 15:42But it's going in that direction,
- 15:44and you can only live off past achievements for so long.
- 15:48And the demographics of the place, I think, are quite telling.
- 15:51There's the old saying that demography is destiny,
- 15:54and the average age of SAAC is now above 60 again.
- 15:57and I think I can say that now that I'm above 50 myself you know from a certain age you think
- 16:05differently and you probably also care less about the future because it's not going to be your future
- 16:09you just want to hold on to what you've got and this is the generational conflict that exists
- 16:14elsewhere in the world in across Europe and there was a certain period during the pandemic when
- 16:21sarks population was rejuvenated to a certain extent I had a bit of a hand in that and we've
- 16:28had churn in the meantime and things going back somewhat towards you know where we used to be in
- 16:33the average age is I think now I don think there an up official statistic but I would say just walking around you see the place is old It also physically falling apart And none of that is you know again coming back to what I said earlier inspiring to build a future in SAC
- 16:50That said, I'm having a great time there.
- 16:52My taxes, even though they're up 21%, I think most people would love to be in my place.
- 16:58It's all relative, you know, we're complaining about things that are actually not that bad.
- 17:02I take it your tax increase isn't a tractor license.
- 17:06What caused 21% of your taxes to go up then?
- 17:09Is that income tax or something?
- 17:12So we have a simple system in SARC, but it has several options.
- 17:17And I'll just explain one because that's the one that applies to me.
- 17:19You can basically say in simplified terms, I don't want to declare income.
- 17:23I don't want to declare assets.
- 17:25Instead, I pay a sort of flat tax that is based on the size of the property I inhabit.
- 17:31as owner or as tenant.
- 17:34And that's what I do.
- 17:35And the budget has come out.
- 17:39SARC needs money.
- 17:40SARC has been burning through its reserves for years.
- 17:42There's virtually nothing left now,
- 17:44which is very different to where SARC used to stand.
- 17:48Interestingly enough, it used to be pre-democracy,
- 17:52pre-2008 when democracy was introduced,
- 17:54that SARC actually, from what I know,
- 17:57had significant reserves.
- 17:59And they've been spent over the years.
- 18:01so now to generate more revenue taxes need to go up and 21 percent is you know for me it's not
- 18:11a big deal being very honest about it but for someone who has you know who lives off a regular
- 18:16employment salary i don't think their employment their salary is going up 21 percent this year
- 18:21different people have different increases i heard someone say 14 percent yesterday it depends a bit
- 18:26on your circumstances but yeah it's a massive increase and it's just indicative of what's
- 18:29happening and you you read the budget and you know exactly it's not going to be enough
- 18:32another victim of democracy then we can say quite quite uh i would i would also
- 18:39possibly democratic system possibly even more so lack of planning because issues that are arising
- 18:46now which are costing money have long been known could have been planned for could have been dealt
- 18:50with in a more uh creative way and that's what i mean about the democratic process though because
- 18:57often that is the result you get, trying to get consensus.
- 19:02If someone, and I think if I understand correctly,
- 19:05prior to the democratic system, it was a top-down system.
- 19:11Top-down, but dominated or operated by the landowners
- 19:16who have multi-generational interests
- 19:19rather than wanting to get through the next year's budget
- 19:22or the next election.
- 19:24That was the difference in my view.
- 19:26There's a lot of feudalist nostalgia on SAC when you speak to people.
- 19:30I don't think I asked this at the time, but when you were trying to generate the investment to sort of replenish the place,
- 19:42did you talk about the governance model changing or was it going to be considered exactly the same?
- 19:48Not at all. We would have never done that because we did not want to be seen to be even considering to do the same thing as the current large portfolio owners that everyone knows of have done in the past.
- 20:03We were not going to tell the place how it needs to be run.
- 20:08There is an existing system which we think is attractive overall.
- 20:11It has its flaws, but you can work with it.
- 20:13So whatever changes on the governance level would always be up to the voters, not any large investor.
- 20:22I mean, how much can you say about what actually happened?
- 20:26I mean, I know, obviously, a deal wasn't struck.
- 20:29But can you elaborate a bit on what the problem was or why it didn't happen?
- 20:34Because it seemed obviously, from my perspective at least, it seemed like a massive opportunity.
- 20:40and I think if what you're saying now about the fact that since then things aren't going great I'd
- 20:47say obviously and for no one right exactly there's no winners here there's absolutely no winners
- 20:54um so it's a no-brainer for me that getting the massive amount of investment would have been great
- 21:00other than maybe for some 60 to 70 year old people who just want to be left alone and don't want
- 21:06you know possibly I don't really know I've never even been there but can you explain kind of what
- 21:11happened and what you know it's actually pretty simple and I've never been shy to summarize what
- 21:17happened from my perspective so officially and on the surface we simply could not agree on a price
- 21:24for the transaction and you could in a way leave it at that but then you can also speculate whether
- 21:31any price would have gotten the transaction done and there may be legal or other reasons
- 21:39on the side of large property owners of SARC for why they didn't or maybe couldn't accept
- 21:46an offer or in fact any offer and I'm sort of I'd be you know I'd be risking getting into trouble
- 21:57for you know spelling that out further because that's you know like getting into all sorts of
- 22:01legal uh quandaries and slander and all sorts of stuff and i really honestly i don't care
- 22:06what was important for me is that we raised the money we had a plan a proposal and
- 22:14it wasn't accepted it didn't go anywhere and that's fine you know and then you just you know
- 22:19you move on with life um it's just as a you know speaking as a resident it's sad to say that in a
- 22:26you know the place is probably not going in a great direction right there a sense of i told you
- 22:31so floating around the island at all i mean if i all i can say is that i have also been outspoken
- 22:41that you know if no one and you know leave leave me aside you know leave leave us our group aside
- 22:48if no one unblocks the backlog of infrastructural investment
- 22:55and the lack of long-term planning on SARC,
- 22:58then the place will not do well.
- 23:00And it's common sense.
- 23:02It's not surprising.
- 23:03It doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure that out.
- 23:05If you live there, you see it on a daily basis.
- 23:08So would I say I told you so?
- 23:10No, because, you know, like...
- 23:12It's not enabling.
- 23:13It doesn't happen.
- 23:14And in a way, I'm in the luxurious position also.
- 23:17So unlike my colleague and friend, the senior of Sark, you know, who has a distinct long-term interest in the place by way of his family's presence and interest and title, I'm in the luxurious position to say, you know, I did my best and I delivered.
- 23:33My biggest worry at the time, to be very frank, was that I didn't raise the money that would have made me look unsuccessful.
- 23:39And we had the money and it didn't go anywhere.
- 23:42So from my perspective, I've just moved on and I do something else in my life.
- 23:44I'm not going to tie my entire existence to Sark, as many other people do.
- 23:51But yeah, it's just sad to see.
- 23:54So I'm going to pry a little bit because I'm interested.
- 23:58When you generate an amount of capital to invest, I'm assuming, I think you've told me this,
- 24:05that someone comes in, gives you a valuation, and then you generate that capital.
- 24:10Is there any negotiating after that?
- 24:12You said like you put your bid in, you show, okay, this is what we think it's worth, here's the money.
- 24:18And if they say no, isn't there a – I mean, you mentioned that maybe they weren't even ready to receive any bids.
- 24:24You don't know that from their side.
- 24:26Well, I would say two things.
- 24:28I mean, first of all, yes, there was.
- 24:30Will I share details of conversations that were held?
- 24:33No.
- 24:33But you can look up what's in the media.
- 24:35And in the media, it's very clear that we offered 20 million.
- 24:38The buyer says we wanted 100.
- 24:40and in a way that ends the conversation there and there. Did you say you heard that in the media or
- 24:47did they tell you that? No, no, we were told that as well. Why didn't their lawyer say we won 100
- 24:53million or something to you directly Presumably that would have been a Well again I don want to go into specific conversations that were had between you know multiple people at the table but so i mean i can say that other people who looked
- 25:06at this real estate value did at 16 we offered 20 you know so we already offered goodwill and a
- 25:12premium and then you know to look at 100 there's just no conversation to be had beyond that that's
- 25:21the public side of things you know fair enough fair enough there's two being okay well that so
- 25:27but what about your own personal opinion on the whole thing now then i think the last i spoke to
- 25:32you was an email when i heard that the deal had fallen through and and i think i said to you look
- 25:37you know is that it and you were like never say never well so again we're very open and i think
- 25:44i'm actually going to write an article about this before the end of the year just to update people
- 25:47because I'm getting regular questions, you know,
- 25:49being cornered on the Sark ferry literally yesterday, you know,
- 25:52and people being curious.
- 25:55And in a way, I want to be very transparent.
- 25:57And we have a so-called special purpose vehicle, an SPV, a company,
- 26:03which is just a shell.
- 26:05It's the Sark property company.
- 26:06We have retained that.
- 26:08All four of the directors are still directors.
- 26:10It's in good stead.
- 26:11It's ready.
- 26:12I have investors who are you know they would be delighted to take my call when I rang up all of
- 26:19our investors last time and I said we don't need your money after all literally half of them
- 26:24immediately replied when you need it again just let me know and now that I know so much more about
- 26:30it I'd invest a larger amount you know raising money once you've done it is so much easier to
- 26:36do it a second time just as much I have moved on with my life and I'm doing other things now
- 26:42So, yes, things could always be looked at a second time.
- 26:46Am I pursuing anything right now?
- 26:47Absolutely no, because I did invest two and a half years of my life on it,
- 26:51and I'm not going to make my life's mission.
- 26:54And sometimes you just also need to recognize there's not always a happy ending.
- 26:58So what would it take for you to take back up the mantle of trying to kickstart this again?
- 27:05Would it take, would someone need to come in from the other side, the Barclays side?
- 27:10I'd say that's a question I could only really answer together with my three other directors.
- 27:15So I'm not going to answer that one right now.
- 27:18But the SPV is there.
- 27:20We have access to capital.
- 27:22Sark is staffed for capital.
- 27:23You see that.
- 27:26Wouldn't take much to, you know, get things going.
- 27:28Just as much am I doing anything on that front right now?
- 27:31Absolutely no way.
- 27:32I'm very busy with very positive things that are happening in my life.
- 27:35So it's not even remotely on my to-do list.
- 27:39Well, I mean, that's a definitive answer. It's incredible, really, when you think about it. But when you look at the parties involved, there's three major parties. There's kind of you guys, there's the Barclays, the property owners, and then there's the people of Sark.
- 27:56And you can see the incentive for you guys and for the people of Sark to move forward.
- 28:03But the incentive for the other side is less obvious, especially if they're prepared to quote an extremely high fee.
- 28:13And the obvious question which anyone will ask is to what extent are they potentially harm strung by financial and legal issues that exist on their side?
- 28:22you can only speculate about that but you know that's the first question any lawyer would ask
- 28:27in this situation is this about money or are there other blockages that will prevent anything from
- 28:32happening and this is another reason why i'm you know not spending much time thinking about this
- 28:37because that's you know completely beyond my my judgment my insight or you know my power to do
- 28:42anything about do you have you did you say earlier that you'd noticed that the the tourism industry
- 28:48quailed a little bit since then as well? Is that a factor of anything or is that just
- 28:53nothing to do with the fact that there was a lot of press around the time when the bid was happening?
- 28:59No, no. I'd say it's fair to say that SARC tourism has been in a secular decline probably for decades
- 29:05which started with the Channel Islands, Guernsey, Jersey, SARC, Alderney were places where probably in
- 29:11the 60s and 70s you traveled for a bit of sunshine but then cheap flights came into existence and
- 29:17people from the UK prefer to travel to Spain where you've got guaranteed sunshine and everything else
- 29:22is a lot cheaper and that trend has probably become more pronounced with the the so-called
- 29:27cost of living crisis in the UK where prices are up dramatically taking a family from the UK to
- 29:33Guernsey is really expensive nowadays I know yeah I looked in we I looked into it I've got there's
- 29:38five of us yep I looked into it and yeah it's not cheap to get that very short distance by plane
- 29:45And then you add to it the question whether the tourism facilities and what's on offer has improved in the last couple of decades.
- 29:52And I mean, given Sark's dilapidated status, I think the question answers itself.
- 29:57Sark lives of its natural beauty and its heritage and its history.
- 30:01And there are some great facilities on the island, but overall it's not become exactly more competitive.
- 30:06Then Sark also occasionally gets a bit lucky.
- 30:09So this past year there has been a significant influx of French tourists.
- 30:13So somehow the French have now discovered that you can, you know, with effort.
- 30:17Do they come straight from Prague?
- 30:19No, and this is one of the major issues and that's been talked about forever.
- 30:23And that would be the most obvious thing to do to boost tourism.
- 30:27But because that was something that the Barclay family wanted back in the days,
- 30:31it's always been turned down on the back of that.
- 30:33That's a Barclay idea, which is why this thing has not been anywhere.
- 30:35Did they want it for tourism reasons?
- 30:39Yep, they owned hotels and they wanted tourists to come from Normandie and Brittany,
- 30:43where you've got 20 million people visiting every year.
- 30:45So you need like half a percent of that to come to Sark and you're good.
- 30:48I mean, it's a no-brainer. It's very close to France.
- 30:51How long would a ferry ride be?
- 30:53An hour or something like that.
- 30:54It's a complete no-brainer. It's been talked about for 15 years.
- 30:57Every year it's like, oh, it's really going to happen now.
- 31:00You know, like we've got a good new team and nothing ever happens.
- 31:04But you were planning on upgrading the port as well.
- 31:07Would that have had an impact there as well?
- 31:10That could have certainly facilitated all sorts of other things.
- 31:15And instead people are coming to a port that has issues,
- 31:20starting with comfort and convenience and ending with health and safety.
- 31:24So French tourists are going to the UK and then flying to Guernsey?
- 31:28No, they come to Guernsey and Jersey first and then do a…
- 31:31Can you get directly from France to Guernsey?
- 31:32Yeah, you can.
- 31:33During summer of the year when the weather is nice.
- 31:35And what was the reason that that's just that is that just something on Instagram, probably that just kicked off?
- 31:41Something just kicked off. So, I mean, we had a couple of years when there were lots of cruise ships stopping over in Guernsey, and they then sent groups over to SAC, the famous T&P tourists. Now it's the French people coming. But overall, the numbers look okay, but the spend per visitor is not doing well, from what I hear anecdotally from a variety of business owners.
- 32:02presumably because they can't stay for too long either they can't stay for too long there is a
- 32:07cost of living crisis restaurant owners tell me you know people come in and order a meal but no
- 32:12drinks or just want tap water that sort of stuff it's true it's the same where i live in out in the
- 32:17rural england the part you know people don't go out as much as they used to especially you know
- 32:25when you consider that even a simple meal in the uk now is relatively expensive if you take your
- 32:30whole family out it's not like it was yeah i think i hate to sound negative but it there's a lot of
- 32:40it's a bit of a shit show at the moment isn't it everywhere it is and you could change things so
- 32:44easily and so quickly so for example in september i brought a group of 48 friends colleagues and
- 32:49readers to sarg for a weekend where we you know indulged quite lavishly in you know culinary
- 32:56delights and and other activities and business owners told me that one group coming in september
- 33:02which is off season made a significant difference for them it's like literally you know one person
- 33:07organizing one group already makes a difference in these businesses for it would be i don't know
- 33:12i'd say it'd be a perfect place to do retreats wouldn't it you know like business retreats
- 33:17whatever it would just be it's got
- 33:19I mean, obviously, some people from our organization did such a thing.
- 33:25And you had a great time.
- 33:27Yeah.
- 33:27So I hear.
- 33:28Yeah, absolutely.
- 33:28It could all be done.
- 33:30And in a way, it's almost heartbreaking and a bit of a shocker, you know, why is so little happening?
- 33:36And as you said, you know, one of the headlines you read on Google News is about the ferry timetable being thinned out so much that even the residents complain.
- 33:45You know, then, you know, never mind tourists.
- 33:47Well, maybe to end on a, let's end this section on a positive note, maybe it'll come to a head. I mean, could you predict that it would come to a head? I mean, there must be even a point where everyone's losing out.
- 34:02this is generally how political change happens things have to get really bad before eventually
- 34:10they turn around is sark in a spot yet where it's really bad i i don't think it is um but that's just
- 34:19my subjective perception and other people may well disagree in any case i sort of i keep an open mind
- 34:26as to the entire thing. As I always keep saying, I'm just renting. I'm enjoying my time there. I've
- 34:33had some great years on Sark. My career has certainly advanced thanks to the exposure that
- 34:38I had through the whole attempt to invest in Sark. So I'm, you know, positively satisfied with my Sark
- 34:45experience and not making my future dependent on it. But I'm also in a, you know, very comfortable
- 34:50position. And I can easily say that for other people, it's quite different.
- 34:53right well let's talk about your other things that you're doing then let's turn this around
- 35:00it's all not it's not all dark doom and gloom um you're um you'll speak we're at the free cities
- 35:06conference obviously in prague welcome by the way and um and you're you're going to be talking
- 35:13and loosely speaking and i like this term vote with your money we've got vote with your feet
- 35:19We've got vote with your boat.
- 35:21Basically, we've got vote with everything except a little tick on a thing, which I think I could definitely get behind.
- 35:27But that's the title of what you're going to be talking about.
- 35:30And the subtitle is Investment Opportunities in the Era of Capital Flight.
- 35:38That's a very 21st century thing, isn't it?
- 35:42I mean, especially, I don't know how much you know about capital flight from the UK.
- 35:46But if what I read in the very normal press is anything, you know, is true, it appears there's a lot of capital flight from the UK.
- 35:55And I think probably a lot of it's spurred by potential government changes in taxation.
- 36:04I mean, you obviously know a lot about this.
- 36:07Why is there so much?
- 36:08Why are there so many millionaires leaving the UK?
- 36:10And why is there so much money leaving our shores?
- 36:15So I think there's a whole number of subjects that we can speak about here.
- 36:19But let's start with the most obvious one, which is what's in the media every day.
- 36:22People leaving the UK and people with money or professional skills or the ability to build companies they're leaving.
- 36:30I think what's driving it is not so much the absolute percentage tax rate or specific issues that they're upset about.
- 36:40I think what I see among my contemporaries is it's the fact that there's just no improvement in sight at all.
- 36:49When politics are bad and frustrating, you think, OK, in two years there's going to be another election and, you know, we just need to sit this one out and then it'll be fine again.
- 36:58And this time people are saying, no, there's just no way out.
- 37:02I mean, first of all, the Labour government will be in power for, I think, another three years now, unless anything dramatic happens.
- 37:10And even then, I mean, we've had how many years of the Tories?
- 37:14And they've basically pursued policies that made Tory, like conventional or traditional Tory voters, absolutely despise them like never before.
- 37:24And in terms of voting with your feet or voting with your money or your boat, there's this meme going around, which is basically that you can't vote your way out of this situation.
- 37:34because we are in some way, as cynics would say,
- 37:38in a uniparty system where it doesn't matter who you vote for,
- 37:41different politicians, same crap, basically.
- 37:45No matter who you vote for,
- 37:47they can't make the permanent bureaucracy,
- 37:50aka deep state, go away.
- 37:52They can't make the accumulated debt
- 37:55and the entitlements go away.
- 37:57You might be able to inflate your way out of it,
- 37:59but that's not exactly what you want either.
- 38:02And it's a hopeless situation.
- 38:04And I see, interestingly enough, a lot of people in the UK, also very much so in Germany,
- 38:11people who would not previously have done more than to just moan about it.
- 38:16I see them packing up, selling up and voting with their feet and taking their money with them.
- 38:21And that's a new development.
- 38:22And it's certainly, I think, building up.
- 38:25And it's going to be a continuous feature in the landscape.
- 38:29And that leads you to the next question.
- 38:31At what point are government going to say no more?
- 38:33You know, we're bleeding out here.
- 38:34We need capital controls again.
- 38:37And that's something I've been speaking about for years now.
- 38:39And it seems like we're getting closer to that point.
- 38:43So capital controls would be exit taxes and wealth taxes.
- 38:48Are they capital controls?
- 38:49So I think it's worth taking a step back and looking back in history.
- 38:52Capital controls used to be something fairly common until the 1980s, probably.
- 38:59It was not uncommon for countries, including Western countries, to basically tell its citizens you can only take a certain amount of money outside of the country every year and you need to invest it at home, etc., etc.
- 39:12We have forgotten how recent capital controls were a fairly common feature of the financial landscape.
- 39:20And I started talking about this subject in 2022 when I was at a conference for family offices in Vienna.
- 39:28and I pointed out in a presentation to them
- 39:32that the various supranational institutions
- 39:36had put new regulation in place
- 39:38to make capital controls easier in the future
- 39:41based around ideas such as capital controls
- 39:45are possible in circumstances related to national security
- 39:50which of course is always, you know, that's anything.
- 39:54and I found it very interesting that they introduced specific wording
- 39:59to allow capital controls as a preventative measure.
- 40:03So in between national security and a preventative measure,
- 40:06you can just do whatever you like.
- 40:08And once you give politicians power, they're going to use it to their advantage.
- 40:12And back in the days, if you spoke about capital controls,
- 40:14you were still somewhat like a tinfoil hat wearing conspiracy theorist.
- 40:18now what we're seeing I think is a the rise of several different ways how to directly or
- 40:28indirectly introduce capital controls one is for example exit taxes and they're always done in a
- 40:34very pernicious way where yes of course you're allowed to leave you know but you know it's just
- 40:40you just can't keep your company you have to sell your company and Germany is the know-how leader in
- 40:47this aspect they invented exit taxes in the 1920s and then the 1930s used one particular
- 40:54religious or ethnic group to really perfect the whole system of exit taxes and they've been a
- 41:00world leader in it ever since other countries are introducing it there are now issues or you know
- 41:07regulations like for example i think finland has just banned large numbers of foreigners from buying
- 41:15real estate in the country, which in a way is a sort of reverse capital control.
- 41:19You can't come in.
- 41:20And we're seeing more and more of that.
- 41:22And if the flow of capital to safe havens or perceived safe havens increases further,
- 41:29then you could see measures such as you can only take a certain amount outside of the country every year which is for example something South Africans have been used to ever like forever It going to come back It interesting You said that the meme now is
- 41:46you know, this is happening, which is new. I agree. And it's not just people that are into
- 41:55finance and people are into this kind of stuff. It's normal people talking about it now. So
- 42:01So it's probably nearer to a bit of a flash, you know, kind of like a flashpoint than we think.
- 42:09Because already people are feeling the pain in daily life.
- 42:15And according to this, it's going to get worse.
- 42:19Because capital control, do you include a wealth tax as a form of capital control?
- 42:23Yeah, absolutely.
- 42:24Right.
- 42:24and I know from experience that when certain people start talking about wealth taxes it means
- 42:32it's coming it's just you know like it gets leaked out slowly but surely and it's one of the most
- 42:40egregious taxes I think are wealth taxes it's one of the most miserly taxes it's literally the one
- 42:46that they say right we've taxed you all the way up to the top and now we want the rest and it's
- 42:52the worst the same with the exit tax it's like rather than being competitive to try and keep you
- 42:59here i'm just going to stop you leaving you know it's like when they put a wall up to stop you
- 43:03going you know which side of the wall you're supposed to be on you know it's like the same
- 43:08thing happened in east germany we know that you know um but but i think i think when normal people
- 43:15in the pub start talking about, you know, these kind of things. And then it's quite serious.
- 43:22And like you say, I have a slightly different opinion. I think most, I see the uni party idea
- 43:29is real. And, but I see a lot of people on the ground talking about potentially a third party
- 43:37idea. And from my perspective, I don't see any difference there. I think it doesn't matter what
- 43:42they say, they're still going to, even if they get into power, which it could, I would
- 43:47say at the moment currently, probably more likely than anything, they're still going
- 43:51to hit the same blob, the same mass of bureaucracy, the same hole in the same deficit, the same
- 43:57everything.
- 43:59And there's not a lot you can do when you're a government because you don't make money.
- 44:02You either borrow it off you or me or institutions, or you take it from you or me or institutions.
- 44:09and they haven't got any other options.
- 44:13So what is the answer apart from, you know,
- 44:17when I heard in the mainstream news that so many million millionaires,
- 44:23so many, was it 16,000 millionaires had left or whatever,
- 44:28I think they were probably the smart money thinking about it.
- 44:32There's probably smarter money that was even before them.
- 44:35but but i would imagine that that means that in the not too distant future um it's too late
- 44:42you're either paying when you leave or or you're not and that's pretty pretty bad for for your
- 44:49average i think middle class people you know i was thinking about it the other day i i'm sorry
- 44:55to rant on a bit but it's all it's all welling up in me now but i was thinking about our house that
- 45:01we own that's basically taken best part of 30 or 35 years to own this lovely big pile of stone
- 45:11nobody else owns it apparently we do and now I'm thinking okay it's a it's potentially becoming a
- 45:19liability um so maybe then we'll save it we'll sell it and move to a better place and when I
- 45:28went through every stage of this process i was basically being hammered selling it taxed i mean
- 45:34keeping it taxed selling it taxed taking the money abroad to look for a better life taxed you know and
- 45:41it's like they're so miserly so it's so wrong and broken and and you know so what do you do i mean
- 45:50obviously you you would advise me to probably get the hell out would you i'm telling everyone
- 45:55And however hard and expensive it may be to leave,
- 46:01it's not going to get any cheaper and it's not going to get any easier.
- 46:05And to give you an example, I mean, or two examples,
- 46:10I moved to the Channel Islands in 2017 because I saw bad things coming our way.
- 46:16And I was too early, but I moved to Sark at a time when 20% of the real estate was empty.
- 46:20So I could literally freely pick the house that I wanted to leave in.
- 46:23try moving to the Channel Islands now, you know, find anything and it'll be twice as expensive
- 46:31and you may not even get anything closely resembling of what you want.
- 46:36And then again, capital controls and also just tightly sort of like connected to the subject of leaving.
- 46:43So three years ago, you could have gone to the Channel Islands and opened a bank account with a leading private bank
- 46:49with an opening deposit of 250,000.
- 46:52that's been up to 2 million now.
- 46:55And it's a hard limit
- 46:56because the compliance regulations
- 46:59that banks are now under for non-resident clients
- 47:03have become so onerous that banks say,
- 47:06sorry, if you don't bring 2 million,
- 47:08we just literally can't deal with you, sorry.
- 47:10So it's just getting harder and harder to get in.
- 47:13And I think that will only become more of a problem
- 47:17as more people move abroad.
- 47:19That said, there are always options.
- 47:21and much as, for example, the Channel Islands have a very limited housing stock
- 47:24and are sort of like full, you have places like Dubai
- 47:27where you can just, you know, you just extend in the desert and you build.
- 47:30So yes, there's always an option somewhere.
- 47:33But generally speaking, it won't get easier to extricate yourself
- 47:37from your own country and it will not get easier to get in elsewhere.
- 47:42That's before we've spoken about second passport programs
- 47:44and things like that, all of which become more and more regulated,
- 47:47more expensive.
- 47:47so I'm a broken record I've been saying this for 25 years to people just leave
- 47:54but presumably there is a geo arbitrage there is competition worldwide for people
- 48:02so it's you're talking about Europe the UK really Europe in the UK right
- 48:08yes absolutely I'm talking about Europe and the UK because I'm of a certain age where
- 48:12You know, most of my contemporaries want to stay somewhere close to Europe or in Europe because of family and parents and things like that.
- 48:21Younger people may be more flexible.
- 48:23And the great news is that we live in the golden age of the digital nomad visa, the golden visa, and countries competing for the productive.
- 48:31And you also have more options than ever before.
- 48:34You need the money to pay for it, but you certainly have more options than ever before.
- 48:38And there's now this wonderful thing called the Internet where you can look up all this information.
- 48:41in the 1990s when I wanted to read up about alternative you know tax residencies and
- 48:47passports and all that sort of stuff you had to buy underground books you know like books from
- 48:52underground publishers and they were really expensive and you know it was much more tedious
- 48:57so in a way it's a great time to be alive and you just have to pick what's best for you and in a way
- 49:02the free cities conference where we're at these days is where I think the philosophy or the motto
- 49:09is very much don't try to change the system where you are because by god have we tried and it's not
- 49:16it's not moving just build something new elsewhere and that in a way includes build yourself a new
- 49:21life elsewhere where you are welcomed and liked and treated well and uh ironic well not ironically
- 49:29as a matter of fact there are more projects in the free city space than ever before and
- 49:34and there is a real sense of momentum right now.
- 49:38And I'm probably one of the closest people to many of the projects.
- 49:43And I can definitely attest to the fact that I can feel it already,
- 49:47especially even in the last few months.
- 49:50And that why I mentioned the meme that you can vote with your feet has blossomed very quickly when you think about it I mean I think in this day and age with the internet I think everything does
- 50:05I don't think, I think a good idea when it sort of gets released out into the wild these
- 50:10days will basically flourish on account of the internet.
- 50:15And that is one of the ones that I can't believe how many people I know, real, what I would
- 50:21normal people talking about options like this um which is unfathomable especially in the UK because
- 50:32I don't know I love the UK I love where I live I love British culture I feel a fully immersed
- 50:40Brit I love it um but I'm still I'm I'm like I I think I'm like you except I actually do own a
- 50:49property in the UK. But I don't feel sentimental about it anymore. It's weird. It's been a couple
- 50:57of years that so many cogs have been turning in my mind that I suddenly realize I'm no longer
- 51:04sentimental about wanting to spend my old age in the UK. And it's really sad in one sense,
- 51:11but it's also exciting because I'm in this world, this world we're in now, which is super exciting.
- 51:17There's a lot of people doing a lot of things, but I'm one of those people that does have friends and family in Europe and I do want to stay, but I'm quite prepared to go now, you know, and really that's a major hurdle.
- 51:36That would have been a major hurdle for me.
- 51:37Yes, the number of people who are talking about this, considering it and potentially close to doing it has probably gone up by a hundredfold.
- 51:47It's not a specific figure, but it's gone up by so many multiples that I can't even begin to imagine how many people that's now.
- 51:55Everyone's speaking about it.
- 51:58Where do you advise then?
- 52:01Without too specific, do you just advise get out?
- 52:04Or where do you say, where are the best places to sort of migrate your capital to?
- 52:12Well, on the one hand, it depends on your individual circumstances.
- 52:15But the advice I always give is, you know, choose that one place that really appeals to you, even if it's not perfect.
- 52:22Just get out and learn and experience how it is to live in a different place.
- 52:29And then you improve and you optimize by moving on from there, if you have to.
- 52:34Just make that first step.
- 52:36I'm speaking to a lot of people who are in this forever loop of talking about what's the perfect place where I'm going.
- 52:45And there is no perfect place.
- 52:46And if you think about that for too long, then you will never move.
- 52:50And maybe some people just like speaking about it.
- 52:54But if you're serious about it, just move somewhere, rent something, try it out, and then move on if you don't like it.
- 53:00I think the reason a lot of people keep speaking about it is because they're deeply optimistic that things are going to change.
- 53:05That's my feeling.
- 53:07I really feel like I know, for example, there's been a few phases of people I know leaving the UK.
- 53:12The phase we're at now is we'll see what happens in three years.
- 53:16We'll see if reform or whoever it is do actually shake stuff up, which I don't think they will,
- 53:23because I thought Trump was going to shake things up.
- 53:25And, you know, he's kind of everything's bigger and more expensive and more money, more borrowing, everything, you know.
- 53:33So I don't imagine.
- 53:34Have you got any anecdotal evidence of the kind of phases people go through when they actually decide to go?
- 53:41You're saying like, get out and then sort of look back in hindsight.
- 53:45That's kind of what you're saying, isn't it?
- 53:46It's like, just try it, because if you don't try it, you'll never know what you're missing out on or whatever.
- 53:51do people tend to sort of like dip their toes and then and then realize it's the right thing or
- 53:56do you get a lot of people coming back do you get a lot of people just jumping feet first or
- 54:00so my experience my best experience and most useful insights about this i think are from
- 54:06living in sark and having helped a lot of people move to sark in one capacity or another and two
- 54:13things happen very often one is that they are utterly shocked how easy it was and how nice life
- 54:20was subsequently once they were on the other side of the wall.
- 54:25And the other thing is that in any jurisdiction,
- 54:28and even more so in a tiny island jurisdiction,
- 54:31you have, inevitably you have churn.
- 54:35People move somewhere and they realize
- 54:37it's not quite what I need or what I want.
- 54:40But then they're on the other side of the wall already,
- 54:42and then they don't move back to where they came from,
- 54:45but instead they move to somewhere else
- 54:47that might suit them better.
- 54:48and that's a recurring theme i see and in a way that i hope hope inspires people to you know
- 54:56take that jump and then just you know work your way forward from there what about actual investment
- 55:02wise then what what are the what are the options that mostly people sort of what routes to most
- 55:10people go down in those terms well i think everyone always constantly speaks about real
- 55:17estate, which I find utterly boring, I have to admit, because the real estate you live in is not
- 55:22an investment. I would say the most exciting investment to speak about is your business.
- 55:28Wealth is mostly created from setting up and growing businesses. And I would say in this day
- 55:35and age of the internet and global options, to call it, for lack of a better word,
- 55:42it's extraordinarily exciting to look at jurisdictions and potential places to live
- 55:49from the perspective of would I want to run a business from there would it be advantageous for
- 55:52my career as an entrepreneur as a business builder to be based there and I think that's really the
- 55:59number one aspect to look at the weather transport links the school system food culture time zones
- 56:08All of that is very, very important and everything always comes as a package and nothing is ever perfect.
- 56:13But ask yourself, where do you want to build a business?
- 56:16Because that's where you're probably going to make the most money.
- 56:18What do you think of the situation in America as an option for relocating capital, yourself, your family?
- 56:28I think America is one of the most underappreciated options.
- 56:32So I have myself been, you know, occasionally taking a curious look at that.
- 56:37and the reason for that is twofold first of all it's the world's biggest market
- 56:41so if you want to build a business and you want to have a domestic audience that you can sell to
- 56:47there's just nothing else unless you want to move to china you know and i don't speak chinese so
- 56:51that's not my option and the other one is that america offers many options because it's 50 or
- 56:59however many states and then these sort of jurisdictions that are part of it like puerto
- 57:03Rico and Guam and whatnot else. And in between the different state systems for tax and different
- 57:13loopholes, I think tax is not too bad. And it is by far outweighed by the economy and the market
- 57:21being so big that, as I always say, you know, I don't mind paying high taxes if my income is 10
- 57:26times higher than elsewhere. I'm still coming out ahead. It's just a lifestyle decision primarily.
- 57:31Some people love America, some people hate it.
- 57:33And it's not easy to get in, but there are so many interesting routes,
- 57:38some of which are underappreciated.
- 57:40It's all rapidly changing.
- 57:41I don't want to speak about individual visas because I'm not up to date on a day-to-day basis.
- 57:45But until fairly recently, the highly talented visa was a great route to get in.
- 57:49And I know 25-year-old kids who got in as highly talented,
- 57:52even though they were like medium talented maybe.
- 57:58Same with schools.
- 57:59Yeah, so yeah, the United States is a potentially great option and it just goes to show there are
- 58:05Different things work for different people. I'll tell you the most unusual option that you will never have heard about
- 58:10Go on. Well, you want to bet that I haven't heard about absolute shocker for you
- 58:15Right I like a good guessing game Give me a clue So no you won be able to guess Okay It the UK for me in my specific circumstances because what everyone has completely missed
- 58:28noticing, because it doesn't apply to most people, when the Labour government canned
- 58:33the non-DOM status, which was the ability for non-Brits to basically be based in the
- 58:38UK and only pay taxes on their local income and keep everything else outside of the country
- 58:43tax-free.
- 58:43When they canned that, they introduced a new set of rules that as a non-Brit, you can move to the UK and effectively live there as a non-dom for four years, provided you haven't lived there in the last 10 years.
- 58:58So because I've been away for 10 years, I could now move to the UK and spend four years there and only pay taxes on my local income and keep everything else outside of the country tax-free.
- 59:09Wow. So you mean as in SARC is not the UK?
- 59:13Correct.
- 59:13Yeah. So I could move to London.
- 59:16And pay no tax.
- 59:17Well, I would pay a bit on what I need, you know, to live and stuff.
- 59:21But I would probably, my global tax rate would be in the single digits.
- 59:26You're right.
- 59:26Limited to four years. Not ideal if you have family, you want to relocate everyone and, you know.
- 59:31Four years is four years in this day and age.
- 59:34That's one of the symptoms of this day and age, I think, is people don't think in 25 year, you know, batches.
- 59:42yeah yeah and i'm saying that as an you know to illustrate there are so many surprising options
- 59:46that you only find if you do a lot of research about this the world's your oyster
- 59:50yeah well i agree that the world's your oyster but i also have to you know acknowledge that
- 1:00:00my roots my family's roots are well and truly in the ground where we are and um i think
- 1:00:07I think I it's almost like I fall into the category of someone who would just have to take
- 1:00:14take the kick up the ass from the government there's not much I can do if they decide to start
- 1:00:21wealth taxing my property I'm in you know I mean I don't know how it works necessarily if it's
- 1:00:26anything like the US system then I'm in trouble because I've we've we've amassed like for like I
- 1:00:34say for 35 years we've been climbing the ladder of property so can i just add one thought here
- 1:00:40maybe also to just stress that it's not all about taxes really it's about you know you get into
- 1:00:45trouble if you tweet certain things if you've got certain opinions they might want to inject you
- 1:00:50certain substances they might want to lock you into your house for a year or two you add up all
- 1:00:55of these different factors it's not just about you know saving taxes it's just not a great place
- 1:01:02to live anymore in many ways, sadly.
- 1:01:05I agree with you.
- 1:01:06I do 100% agree.
- 1:01:08It's just that,
- 1:01:10and I think this is where countries
- 1:01:12have you really, you know, trapped,
- 1:01:17is that the longer you stay somewhere,
- 1:01:19the deeper your roots go.
- 1:01:21This is why countries, I think,
- 1:01:22like the Emirates, especially Dubai,
- 1:01:25somewhere like that,
- 1:01:26is still highly competitive
- 1:01:27because there's only been a few generations
- 1:01:29of people that have ever even lived there.
- 1:01:31and as a result their friends and family are probably still somewhere else you know 90% of
- 1:01:36is is is incomers and they'll be outgoers at the drop of a hat if things turn around
- 1:01:43and places like the UK they know that intrinsically they they can viscerally feel that
- 1:01:49that they can do all kinds of stuff before you get up and go and and unfortunately they they
- 1:01:54appear to be doing that and um I'm I'm one of the people who's kind of I don't know put it this way
- 1:02:01It's discussed at the kitchen table for the first time in the last few years, the option of moving.
- 1:02:06I think currently in its form, it's like, well, let's wait for the kids to reach a certain age and then do it.
- 1:02:11But, you know, if push comes to shove, it won't be that.
- 1:02:16I can assure you.
- 1:02:17I just know.
- 1:02:18What would be your line in the sand to leave Sark, to leave Europe?
- 1:02:25um my circumstances are probably a bit different in the sense that sort of every
- 1:02:31seven or ten years i tend to go for a significant life change and i i'm generally concerned that if
- 1:02:39you live in small island communities and i'm not in one for the first time i lived in the
- 1:02:43galapagos islands for quite some years as well um you become a bit too closely associated with
- 1:02:51that island and maybe a bit too focused on that you know island life and then it's good to throw
- 1:02:57yourself into a different situation again to make sure you remain competitive and you you know your
- 1:03:04life's not all about this one place that you live in i i've yeah god i i don't know i mean i'm having
- 1:03:11that debate with myself i mean i have no one to speak to at the kitchen table so you know i just
- 1:03:15make my own decisions but i'm talking to myself i i look at options and for me it's very much
- 1:03:21business and career driven and I've had some unbelievable opportunities offered to me because
- 1:03:26of the work that I did in Sark. None of them has come through to a point where I have signed
- 1:03:32anything but they're coming my way and you know will I be there forever? At the very least for me
- 1:03:39it's been obvious thing to maybe move to Guernsey you know where the infrastructure is better, better
- 1:03:45restaurants, less issues with, you know, transport and infrastructure and so on and so forth.
- 1:03:52I don't know. I'm looking at options, but right now I'm not going anywhere.
- 1:03:58I'll be honest, we've had Guernsey and Jersey up on right move a couple of times in the last few
- 1:04:02years. I mean, what I didn't realize is you have a two-tier or they have a two-tier
- 1:04:08housing market there, right? One for incomers and one for people from the area.
- 1:04:13absolutely yeah and the price differences are quite dramatic yeah it's like and twice as much
- 1:04:18if you're an income yeah and again there are so many loopholes and special regulations that you
- 1:04:22only are aware of once you really spend a bit of time researching that so for example for me
- 1:04:27once i've been in sark for eight years i gain the right to live in the cheap part of the guernsey
- 1:04:34housing market ah because you're a local at that point it's sort of it's a special thing for sark
- 1:04:39But are there many rentals?
- 1:04:41I can't imagine there would be many rentals in that market.
- 1:04:44Yeah, there's everything.
- 1:04:45I mean, Guernsey has 62,000 people.
- 1:04:47And I mean, I'm probably just used to there's just nothing on Sark.
- 1:04:50No, but I mean, like if you look at where I live, rentals were decimated by, for example, Airbnb, because I live in a tourist area.
- 1:04:59some people realized that renting someone their house for like a thousand a month or renting it
- 1:05:06out five days five days a month for a thousand is a better option and and as a result there were
- 1:05:12very few properties to to live in long term you can find rentals in guernsey and i i there i would
- 1:05:18have less hesitation to buy something because guernsey is not at in an existential risk like
- 1:05:23sark for example you know you buying a house in guernsey doesn't mean you end up with a stranded
- 1:05:28asset which in sark you may well end up doing but if the government whatever the uk government does
- 1:05:33what what's what are the implications on guernsey and jersey and sark for example sark nothing in the
- 1:05:40first instance nothing because these islands all govern themselves they're independent from the uk
- 1:05:45in the second instance yes there's a dialogue and guernsey and jersey can't do any wild things so
- 1:05:53if Guernsey tomorrow started to offer a business visa specifically for sanctioned Russian oligarchs,
- 1:05:59you know, they would get a call from London and, you know, would be told off for doing that,
- 1:06:04even though theoretically it's in their right.
- 1:06:05But I mean, none of that would ever happen.
- 1:06:07In Guernsey, and I speak about Guernsey because that's next door to me and I've spent a lot of time there.
- 1:06:13I know very little about Jersey, but that's just my ignorance.
- 1:06:18In Guernsey, things look pretty good for the long term.
- 1:06:21I mean, there's either no debt or just a little bit of debt. The GDP as a percentage of the overall, sorry, the tax, the taxation as a percentage of GDP is still only 24%, which in other parts of Europe is double that.
- 1:06:39crime and it's still a very happy place.
- 1:06:43So as a microcosm, it's not falling foul of the same problems
- 1:06:49that larger states are falling for?
- 1:06:52Not at all, no.
- 1:06:53And what would the reason be?
- 1:06:54Just more wealthier people there?
- 1:06:58I think it's culture.
- 1:07:01I'm not an expert for Guernsey.
- 1:07:02I hesitate somewhat to, you know, like portray the island in a certain way.
- 1:07:06but Guernsey is as I always say like how the UK used to be in the 1980s there was a certain culture
- 1:07:14things are being done in a certain way that's respected they're being done in the right way
- 1:07:19there is community people speak to each other things are coordinated in a reasonable fashion
- 1:07:25and is it improving no it's not exactly getting much better there either but it's it's a bit like
- 1:07:31Switzerland you know like it's such a happy place that whatever you complain about if you live in
- 1:07:35switzerland 99 of the rest of the world would love to take your place switzerland also though
- 1:07:41relatively wealthy place one of the and we'll wrap it up money money helps i have a jewish
- 1:07:47friend who always says his mom told him whether you're poor or you're rich it's great to have money
- 1:07:54but i mean the truth the truth of the matter is whenever we discuss on this podcast
- 1:08:03options, geo-arbitrage options, basically, you really end up coming down to two sort of
- 1:08:10categories. One is you go to where the rich people are. The other is you go to where the system hasn't
- 1:08:16quite, you know, managed to get as ingrained somewhere like Paraguay or here. And they're the
- 1:08:22two options, unfortunately. And, you know, so that you see a lot of wealthy places around the world,
- 1:08:29which are doing absolutely fine.
- 1:08:30They're like isolated from what you see
- 1:08:34in these great large states,
- 1:08:36which are essentially failing.
- 1:08:38There's not, you know.
- 1:08:40And it's a sad thing, really.
- 1:08:42I mean, when I think it through,
- 1:08:45it's really sad to think that that's the system we're in.
- 1:08:49And that you and I, I think, both come to the conclusion
- 1:08:53that you can't actually fix it.
- 1:08:55You can't fix it.
- 1:08:56The only fix is a collapse fix, which is a terrible fix.
- 1:09:01It's the worst kind.
- 1:09:03But you can't unravel this.
- 1:09:05This is a bunch of string and so knotted, you cannot unravel it.
- 1:09:11You have to throw it away.
- 1:09:12Or in the case of what we do here, yeah, you have to build something new somewhere,
- 1:09:16which is inevitably in one of those countries that hasn quite amassed all this bureaucracy and red tape and you know But yeah I mean I don know Let not end on a let not end on a tell me something positive
- 1:09:31Come on.
- 1:09:32Well, what you just said, I would, I would second every word of that.
- 1:09:35On a positive note, I mean, to repeat what I said earlier, you have more options than ever before.
- 1:09:40And I mean, I'm old enough to remember, for example, in the 90s, when you want to fly somewhere,
- 1:09:44you had to go to a travel agency.
- 1:09:45They looked up the secret knowledge in their computer about the flight times.
- 1:09:49Then you had to make a bank transfer to them.
- 1:09:51Three days later, you picked up your paper ticket, which you needed at the airport.
- 1:09:55We live in a golden age of you've got your smartphone in your pocket.
- 1:09:59Countries are vying for the productive, the young, and anyone who's got at least a few dollars in their pockets.
- 1:10:08And it's sad to give up on the country that you grew up in, that gave you opportunities.
- 1:10:14that you feel deeply rooted in.
- 1:10:17But unfortunately,
- 1:10:19there is not always a happy ending
- 1:10:21for everything in life.
- 1:10:22And sometimes you just need to recognize reality
- 1:10:24for what it is and move on
- 1:10:26and deal with it in the best possible way.
- 1:10:29And I think this is why, you know,
- 1:10:31another reason why I'm at the Free Cities Conference
- 1:10:33this time again,
- 1:10:34because I want to see what's happening
- 1:10:35in this industry because,
- 1:10:37and I'm not getting paid to say this,
- 1:10:40but I think your industry,
- 1:10:42you know the team that you're working with you are about to take off in a way that I don't think
- 1:10:48people many people would think possibly yet and I think you're on the cusp of something absolutely
- 1:10:56dramatic and amazing and probably in a few years time we'll be you know at this conference in a
- 1:11:02different venue because so many more people will want to attend and we'll think back to you know
- 1:11:06the days when we met in Prague and there were a couple hundred people and you know we did these
- 1:11:10podcasts and stuff like that so i think great stuff is going to happen in new industries with
- 1:11:15a free cities movement geo arbitrage plan b all this stuff and all i can say is you know come to
- 1:11:22this event listen to the podcasts support the group by buying the books and the various other
- 1:11:29outputs that people affiliate with it have created i'm i'm only loosely part of it because you know
- 1:11:35the plan that I had didn't work out so I'm just basically a user of the whole alternative system
- 1:11:40and I love it you are a user but you are part of it Sven it's um because there is you know it's um
- 1:11:48it's a it's an ecosystem which is basically about living about living with people and about you know
- 1:11:53it's not some walled place that no one can come in it's not a gated you know it's a it's a it's a
- 1:12:01is an industry that needs all kinds of people basically and I do agree with you that the you know things like the fact that there are these new memes that appear in daily life about moving to other countries and moving to better places
- 1:12:17Those are the signals that we are in this time.
- 1:12:20And I know, and as you probably know, there's a lot of things about to pop, so to speak, in this industry.
- 1:12:27And we're all here for it.
- 1:12:30I mean, you know, so yeah, many thanks for popping in.
- 1:12:36I won't be able to be there for your talk, unfortunately,
- 1:12:38but I think I probably got the gist of it just then.
- 1:12:42Delighted to have this conversation.
- 1:12:43Looking forward to seeing you again in the future.
- 1:12:45And hope this was of use to your readers, followers.
- 1:12:48It will be, it will be.
- 1:12:49And I'm still, I'm still, I still think Sark will happen
- 1:12:54because it has to happen.
- 1:12:56like if sark sark's like um you know either sark happens the way that some in some shape or form
- 1:13:05the way you envisaged it or it just dies so so what it can't and it won't die no one's going to
- 1:13:13let sark die it's a beautiful place and it's got a history it's got people that are living there
- 1:13:18but it it it needs that there's no other what's the alternative like some form of communism
- 1:13:25that's not going to solve the problem so so i'm still i'm still there with it i think it i think
- 1:13:31one day just like you say one day we'll be sitting talking about the good old days when we all met up
- 1:13:36in prague we'll we may be on sark talking about it and and i because i think sark has to happen
- 1:13:42because i think when you have a resource when you have a resource like that somebody somewhere
- 1:13:48is going to make it happen because people look for things like that like you did people look
- 1:13:53look for for for things to transform like that and i think it will it's just difficult at the moment
- 1:14:00but um but good luck anyway and and thanks for popping in it's good to see you again i'll i'll
- 1:14:05we'll see where our paths cross next thanks tim
- 1:14:08right here's the addendum i mentioned at the beginning of this episode basically during the
- 1:14:18show as you heard Sven mentioned that he was about to write an article and in a couple of places he
- 1:14:25went into more detail than what we discussed in the show I will leave a link to the full article
- 1:14:33in the show notes so go and check that out what we did cover from the article I'll mention those
- 1:14:39things now because it'll just give you a good recap on what's going over there he talked about
- 1:14:44taxes rising sharply and reserves running out He talked about the Guernsey loan discussion offering one and a half million the big infrastructure backlog and the electricity saga as a major sort of risk factor
- 1:15:01on SARC. And then the demographics slash tourism decline. These were all quite a substantial part
- 1:15:09of the article but we already addressed those things what was new and i'll go into these now
- 1:15:16very briefly the tax overhaul that he mentioned is moving from talk to process the article reports
- 1:15:23that parliament explicitly confirmed in the november 2025 budget debate that there will be
- 1:15:31in quotes a big public consultation next year about a fairer way to raise tax revenue the secondly
- 1:15:40the guernsey loan that he mentioned has conditions that do raise autonomy questions
- 1:15:47his article says that sark pledged future alcohol tax revenue as collateral for the 1.5 million loan
- 1:15:57and obviously then raises the question of whether this could be a step towards debt servitude.
- 1:16:05One to look out for.
- 1:16:07Thirdly, the infrastructure numbers are put on the record.
- 1:16:11The article actually cites an internal document putting needs of around £20 million
- 1:16:18versus an annual government budget of £2.5 million.
- 1:16:23pounds and sven's estimate of 20 to 50 million is the total backlog in his article right finally
- 1:16:33electricity crisis he quotes the details much deeper and in his article he claims residents
- 1:16:41face a one pound 13 per kilowatt hour electricity cost which is incredible and actually sven says
- 1:16:51it's the world's highest electricity cost which was later reduced by government edict the company
- 1:16:58is claiming damages and the government is attempting nationalization and a taxpayer funded
- 1:17:05community-owned structure total costs for that could be double digit millions with what Sven
- 1:17:15calls a in inverted commas non-zero risk of bankrupting SARC right there you go that's all
- 1:17:23the latest stuff over and above what we already talked about in the interview many thanks for
- 1:17:29listening to this addendum and I will see you in the next one