Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How the Spotlight Effect Makes You Overthink Office Moments
Transcript
- Lucas: Luna, have you ever sent an email with a typo and then spent the next hour convinced everyone who read it is judging your competence? Luna: Absolutely. I once sent a proposal to a senior director with 'definately' instead of 'definitely'. I was sure my career was over. Lucas: Right, and that feeling — the sense that all eyes are on you after a minor slip — is so common that psychologists actually gave it a name: the spotlight effect. Luna: Is that the one from the Cornell study where people wore an embarrassing t-shirt and thought everyone noticed? Lucas: Exactly that. 1999, Gilovich, Medvec, and Savitsky. They had students put on a Barry Manilow t-shirt — which, at the time, was about as uncool as you could get — and then walk into a room with a group of peers. Later, the students estimated how many people noticed the shirt. The actual number was about 23 percent. The students thought it was closer to 50 percent. Luna: So they nearly doubled the attention they thought they got. And that's the core insight — we overestimate how much others notice us. Lucas: Yeah. The researchers called it the spotlight effect. And it's not just about embarrassing t-shirts. It plays out in offices every single day. You fumble a slide during a presentation and replay it in your head for a week. Meanwhile, your colleagues probably forgot about it by the time they got to the break room. Luna: Why does it happen, though? Is it just egocentrism? Lucas: Partly. The explanation is that we're so focused on our own behaviour — we feel our own anxiety so vividly — that we assume others are tuned into us at the same frequency. But they're not. Everyone else is busy worrying about their own stuff. It's a failure of perspective-taking. Luna: So it's like the opposite of empathy. You can't get out of your own head long enough to realise people aren't judging you. Lucas: Exactly. And there's a related concept called the 'invisibility cloak' that the same researchers explored. In a follow-up study, they had participants wear a t-shirt they were proud of — something like a cool band logo. Those participants also overestimated how many people noticed, but to a lesser degree. So the effect is stronger for negative or embarrassing events, but it's present for positive ones too. Luna: That makes sense. I remember when I got a promotion and I thought everyone would be talking about it. But most people didn't even know until I mentioned it. Lucas: Right. So the takeaway is that your internal experience is not a reliable guide to what others perceive. And in the office, that can be liberating. If you make a mistake on a conference call — maybe you accidentally unmute when you're complaining about the coffee — the spotlight effect tells you that the embarrassment is mostly in your head. Luna: But is there a downside? I mean, could the spotlight effect also make you too casual? Like, if you think nobody's watching, you might slack off? Lucas: That's a good point. The effect isn't about reality — it's about the gap between perception and reality. If you're being sloppy, people might notice more than you think. The research is about the overestimation of attention, but it doesn't say you're invisible. The key is calibration. Luna: So how do you calibrate? How do you know when you're in the spotlight versus when you're overthinking? Lucas: One practical trick is to ask a trusted colleague. Say 'Hey, did that comment in the meeting come off weird?' Most of the time, they'll say 'I didn't even notice.' And that data point can recalibrate your internal gauge. Another strategy is to observe how often you notice others' minor mistakes. You'll realise it's rare and fleeting. Luna: I've used that second one. Once I started tracking how many typos I caught in other people's emails, and how little I cared, I realised my own typos weren't a big deal. Lucas: Exactly. There's also a cognitive reframing technique. When you feel the spotlight, remind yourself that your audience is focused on the content, not you personally. Unless you're giving a keynote or being evaluated, people are generally self-absorbed. Luna: But what about situations where you actually are being evaluated? Like a performance review or a pitch to executives? Lucas: Those are higher-stakes, and the spotlight effect can still distort your perception. You might think one stumble ruined the whole presentation, when in reality the executives were focused on the numbers and the strategy. They probably didn't even hear your verbal stumble because they were doing math in their heads. Luna: So the advice is to separate the objective outcome from your subjective feeling. Lucas: Right. And there's a neat corollary: the spotlight effect also applies to your successes. You might think your contribution went unnoticed, but often people saw it and just didn't mention it. So it cuts both ways. Luna: That's reassuring. I wonder if there's a generational component. Do younger workers suffer from the spotlight effect more because they grew up on social media where every post is scrutinised? Lucas: That's a great question. The original study was pre-social media, so it's a baseline. Some recent research suggests that people who use social media heavily do have a heightened sense of being observed — but it's a correlation, not proven causation. Still, it's plausible that constant performance on platforms trains your brain to think you're always on stage. Luna: And then you bring that mental stage into the office. So maybe we need to consciously 'unstage' ourselves when we walk into work. Lucas: Yeah. And that leads to a practical tip: before a meeting, take a second to remind yourself that no one is watching you as closely as you're watching you. It sounds simple, but it can lower your anxiety. Luna: Speaking of lowering anxiety, if people enjoy these episodes and want more, there's a way to support the show that keeps it ad-free. Lucas: Yeah, we've had listeners ask. If this podcast helps you navigate your work life, you can support it at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That's F-E-X-I-N-G-O. And it genuinely helps us keep doing deep dives into these topics without sponsors. Luna: It's a small thing that goes a long way. And now back to the spotlight effect — Lucas, you mentioned there's a second study about the 'invisibility cloak.' Can you tell me more about that? Lucas: Sure. In a follow-up, participants wore either an embarrassing shirt or a flattering shirt. The embarrassing shirt group overestimated noticeability by a lot. The flattering shirt group also overestimated, but by less. So the effect is asymmetric: negative events feel more spotlighted than positive ones. Luna: Probably because negative events are more salient to us. We're wired to remember threats. Lucas: Exactly. So when you mess up at work, your brain amplifies the memory. But it's an illusion. And knowing that can be a powerful tool for resilience. Luna: So the next time I trip over a word in a meeting, I'll remind myself: it's just the spotlight effect. Lucas: And then move on. Because the research shows that people are actually pretty forgiving. They're not dwelling on your mistake. They're probably thinking about their own lunch.