Latest / Surrounded / Top 5 Most Heated Debates | Surrounded
Transcript
- 0:00From Jubilee Media,
- 0:01this is Surrounded,
- 0:02where one brave soul faces a room full of disagreers.
- 0:04Hey listeners,
- 0:05this is John Regalado.
- 0:07We are on the road right now recording brand new episodes of the show
- 0:10with some really amazing featured guests.
- 0:13We can't tell you who they are,
- 0:14but we know you guys are gonna love them.
- 0:16And we can't wait for these episodes to come out.
- 0:19But for today's episode,
- 0:21we are going to dig back into some of the
- 0:24spiciest and most interesting prompts from the past year.
- 0:27The show has had so many interesting interactions,
- 0:30whether they're heated,
- 0:31emotional,
- 0:32or just
- 0:33Funny,
- 0:33and we just wanted to share some of our favorites with you.
- 0:37So we hope you enjoy,
- 0:38and please do tune in
- 0:40for the episodes that we're filming right now.
- 0:42Thank you guys so much for your support.
- 0:44If you are not a subscriber for the show,
- 0:46please subscribe so that you don't miss the future episodes.
- 0:49Uh,
- 0:49we'll see you soon,
- 0:50but in the meantime,
- 0:52enjoy these top 5 moments.
- 0:53I'm Mandy Hassan.
- 0:54I'm Doctor Jordan Peterson.
- 0:56I'm Amanda Seales.
- 0:58Hi,
- 0:58my name is Candace Owens.
- 0:59Hi,
- 1:00I'm Sam Cedar.
- 1:01Today I am surrounded by 20 conservatives.
- 1:04My first claim is Trump's attack on DEI hides his real goal,
- 1:08which is to give corporations more power.
- 1:15Hi
- 1:16hi
- 1:16how are you?
- 1:17Good
- 1:17how you doing?
- 1:17OK,
- 1:18when it comes to DEI,
- 1:20essentially if a person
- 1:22was not racist
- 1:23he would hire someone regardless,
- 1:25right?
- 1:26So why would we need a policy
- 1:28to protect a person if we've
- 1:30moved past racism.
- 1:32So would you consider yourself racist?
- 1:34Wait,
- 1:35are you suggesting we've moved past racism?
- 1:37Would you consider yourself racist?
- 1:39I consider myself,
- 1:40and sometimes I practice,
- 1:41I think we all practice like some form of,
- 1:44uh,
- 1:44you know,
- 1:45white supremacy.
- 1:46I think actually like
- 1:47we all do to some degree.
- 1:49Well,
- 1:49I'm,
- 1:49I'm glad that you're saying that.
- 1:51So
- 1:52I guess going to the LGBT topic,
- 1:54it seems like it's very prevalent for you as an issue.
- 1:56It seems like a big issue.
- 1:58I mean,
- 1:58the Republican Party spent literally hundreds of
- 2:01millions of dollars demonizing trans people.
- 2:04Well,
- 2:04the reason why they've done something like that,
- 2:06and I think you're misconstruing the narrative,
- 2:08they haven't demonized them.
- 2:09They simply want protections back for their own children.
- 2:12Because children are being stripped away from their parents their own children,
- 2:16children are being stripped away from their parents.
- 2:18Yes,
- 2:18due to AB 954,
- 2:21they've now included gender identity as a
- 2:24premise
- 2:25to remove and strip parental rights for children who,
- 2:29who maybe they are,
- 2:30uh,
- 2:30rejecting their gender ideology.
- 2:31So,
- 2:31but you'd be OK with parents who agree with their,
- 2:34their,
- 2:35their children's doctors to provide,
- 2:38uh,
- 2:38gender affirming care.
- 2:39I do not agree with that.
- 2:40Do you?
- 2:42I,
- 2:42I believe that parents and doctors can make those decisions
- 2:47if with the kids.
- 2:48If a child can't smoke,
- 2:49drink,
- 2:49or have sex before the age of 18,
- 2:51they should not be able to consent to a sex change.
- 2:54Now in terms of a DEI initiative,
- 2:56in terms of a DEI initiative,
- 2:58the reason why there's military bans on trans women and trans men
- 3:02is because they do not have the ability
- 3:05to
- 3:05cooperate at a mental capacity
- 3:08when they're constantly undergoing hormone treatment
- 3:10as well as depression pills,
- 3:11as well as different mood stabilizer pills
- 3:14and so when you go out to combat,
- 3:16do you really think you're gonna bring an ice cooler pack with your,
- 3:19uh.
- 3:20Whether that be a hormone,
- 3:21estrogen,
- 3:22or whatever it may be
- 3:23while you're about to shoot someone of the opposing,
- 3:26uh,
- 3:27war,
- 3:27the executive orders that Trump gave were DEIA uh orders that had
- 3:32to do with agencies that have nothing to do with the military.
- 3:36Yes,
- 3:36they do.
- 3:37Yes,
- 3:37they absolutely do.
- 3:38The FDA.
- 3:40They just,
- 3:41they just,
- 3:41they just revoked the ability of the Air Force
- 3:44to teach Air Force members about the Tuskegee Airmen.
- 3:48What,
- 3:49what are,
- 3:49what are we talking about here?
- 3:51OK,
- 3:51well,
- 3:52Honestly,
- 3:52like they're rewriting history.
- 3:55Well,
- 3:55that's your perspective,
- 3:56right,
- 3:57but at the end of the day
- 3:58if a person to see airman,
- 4:00we can all agree existed,
- 4:01just listen to this.
- 4:02If,
- 4:02if you were racist,
- 4:03right,
- 4:04and you were an employer
- 4:05and if you wanted to absolutely be racist and exercise that,
- 4:08you would,
- 4:08I think DEI sort of prevents people from seeing the.
- 4:11Reality
- 4:12if a person truly wanted
- 4:14to to hire you based on your intellect,
- 4:16based on your skill set,
- 4:18they would.
- 4:18DEI essentially provides
- 4:20tax cuts
- 4:22for the end of the year when you create your tax returns
- 4:24they give you a tax credit for hiring someone who is black or a person of color.
- 4:29I don't know if in in these agencies,
- 4:31in agencies and private,
- 4:32uh,
- 4:33uh,
- 4:33private in government agencies,
- 4:34they don't get tax cuts for,
- 4:36for hiring people and the other thing I want is to protect the other
- 4:39thing I wanna discrimination unders uh the other thing I wanna kind of state here
- 4:43is that I've realized that a lot of the times with the liberals
- 4:46is that you guys push for,
- 4:47for example,
- 4:48for DEI and people
- 4:50of Latino
- 4:51or Hispanic descent and a lot of the times what you
- 4:54don't realize is you're actually doing more harm than good.
- 4:57By putting them in positions where you
- 4:59make them believe that it's based on the color of their skin,
- 5:02it's based on
- 5:04DEIA
- 5:05does not
- 5:06is not it's based on merit.
- 5:08DEI emphasizes color,
- 5:09skin color,
- 5:10physical attributes says that you're the people
- 5:13who work in your agency,
- 5:14it is about,
- 5:15it's about anti-discrimination,
- 5:16discrimination against what?
- 5:19Against people who
- 5:21may have different uh cultural mores may have
- 5:24different but that's irrelevant to a job,
- 5:26right?
- 5:27It should be based on merit
- 5:28and that is the emphasis people get hired as a merit,
- 5:32but if you're,
- 5:32if you're,
- 5:33if the DEI you get.
- 5:35The DEIA,
- 5:37uh,
- 5:37I'm talking about Trump's rescission of these
- 5:39orders on these agencies as an employer,
- 5:41wouldn't you hire a person of color,
- 5:43dude,
- 5:44if you could pay them less?
- 5:45Listen,
- 5:46we're talking about government agencies that do not get tax cuts.
- 5:51They don't,
- 5:52the
- 5:53government agencies,
- 5:54they don't.
- 5:55No,
- 5:56they do.
- 5:57They absolutely do.
- 5:58I'm talking about every private and public sector gets
- 6:02tax cuts when you hire a person of color.
- 6:05Government agencies don't pay taxes.
- 6:08Government agencies operate on,
- 6:10uh,
- 6:10are funded by the government.
- 6:12That is not true.
- 6:13That is not true.
- 6:14And you know what?
- 6:15I think,
- 6:15I think
- 6:16the,
- 6:16the whole juxtapose of this entire conversation,
- 6:18what month is this?
- 6:20This is,
- 6:21uh,
- 6:22January.
- 6:22OK,
- 6:23so we can agree on that.
- 6:25The FDA
- 6:28does not
- 6:29pay taxes.
- 6:31It does not get a tax cut
- 6:34because it doesn't pay taxes.
- 6:36DEIA.
- 6:39Forces them
- 6:41as an agency to say if you have a job opening,
- 6:45you must
- 6:46do your best efforts to make sure that every I like
- 6:49that part of a buzzword you must do your best effort.
- 6:52I love that buzzword
- 6:54because you feel like you have to,
- 6:56you're pressured to.
- 6:57Yes,
- 6:58you shouldn't be pressured to hire someone based on skin color.
- 7:00No,
- 7:00not to hire.
- 7:01Someone on skin color,
- 7:01but put up notice
- 7:03about about what what the
- 7:06that the job exists.
- 7:07Make sure that you put it in different communities so that you have
- 7:10as wide an application pool as possible and therefore you get tax cuts
- 7:15at the end of the year when you file taxes,
- 7:17you get a tax cut for hiring someone who
- 7:18speaks a different language or different skin color.
- 7:21I don't know how to respond to that.
- 7:27Nice to meet you.
- 7:28OK,
- 7:29so
- 7:29you say that women are more fulfilled at home with
- 7:32kids than going out into the workforce or getting educated,
- 7:34but that just really doesn't bear out when you look at the stats,
- 7:37when you look at how
- 7:38working mothers are way less likely to be in poverty.
- 7:40Maternal education is the number one predictor of childhood outcomes,
- 7:44better scores,
- 7:45uh,
- 7:46getting higher incomes in the future,
- 7:47fewer behavioral problems,
- 7:48better mental health.
- 7:49So
- 7:50it's weird to me with,
- 7:51and college educated women are least likely to get.
- 7:53Divorced
- 7:54and they're the only women,
- 7:55the top 10% of women,
- 7:56of women in socioeconomic,
- 7:58the top 10% of women are the only women whose marriage rates are going up.
- 8:02So they're getting married,
- 8:03they're staying married,
- 8:04and their kids are doing better.
- 8:05When you look at stay at home mothers,
- 8:07you see that they're more likely to report being depressed.
- 8:09They're more likely to report having
- 8:11anxiety and anger and all these types of things.
- 8:14So how can you say that?
- 8:15It seems like a woman,
- 8:16if you want to get married and have kids,
- 8:17you should go to college and have a career.
- 8:19So I,
- 8:19it sounds to me like.
- 8:21Looking at totally different statistics because everything that you said,
- 8:23I've,
- 8:23I've actually read the exact opposite.
- 8:25I'm glad we're on a fact check show with you.
- 8:27Exactly.
- 8:28Oh,
- 8:28it's so exciting.
- 8:29That's going to be amazing,
- 8:30OK,
- 8:30because I know,
- 8:31like I said,
- 8:32I think what we're talking about is that
- 8:33there was this widespread report on female happiness,
- 8:36and I know that it was,
- 8:36it was formally debunked and it was,
- 8:38that's not what I'm talking about.
- 8:39Pew Research,
- 8:40University of California.
- 8:41In fact,
- 8:41working mothers today spend more time with their children
- 8:44than women did in the 1960s that were at home.
- 8:46OK,
- 8:47well,
- 8:47women that I can tell you women that are at home are obviously
- 8:49spending more time with their children than the people who are at work,
- 8:52and their children are not faring off any better and they're faring off worse.
- 8:55How are you measuring their children faring off worse?
- 8:57Uh,
- 8:58how likely they are to,
- 8:59uh,
- 8:59higher incomes,
- 9:00better scores,
- 9:01fewer health problems,
- 9:02fewer behavioral issues,
- 9:03and better mental.
- 9:04So the,
- 9:05the,
- 9:05just to get back to the claim that I'm making here
- 9:07is that
- 9:08it is obvious that women who have children are going to be more fulfilled.
- 9:12How is that obvious?
- 9:13Because you said that.
- 9:16No,
- 9:16it's not obvious because I said so.
- 9:18It's because when you look at all the statistics in
- 9:20terms of women who are choosing not to have families,
- 9:23they are,
- 9:23as the person who just sat here before you mentioned,
- 9:26they are suffering from more depression.
- 9:28They're suffering from more anxiety,
- 9:29and I,
- 9:29and
- 9:30yes,
- 9:30no,
- 9:30that,
- 9:31that when you look at it,
- 9:31you can't just say voluntarily don't have children.
- 9:34No,
- 9:34I'm not saying that,
- 9:35but that's not true,
- 9:37OK?
- 9:37It is true.
- 9:38It is actually true that women who are choosing their careers
- 9:41over starting families are finding themselves leaning more onto.
- 9:45To
- 9:45medicines like Xanax,
- 9:47anxiety inducing medicines,
- 9:48and depression because
- 9:49they suspended that time frame where women really should be
- 9:52looking to find a partner and to start a family
- 9:54because they were
- 9:55instead pursuing their careers.
- 9:56There has been a,
- 9:57there,
- 9:57it has been,
- 9:58it is a dishonest,
- 9:59it is,
- 9:59it's totally a dishonest narrative
- 10:01that men and women want the same things out of life.
- 10:03We don't.
- 10:04We absolutely do not want the same things out of life.
- 10:05In fact,
- 10:06we don't even measure,
- 10:07we don't even measure success the same.
- 10:09Men and women don't even measure success the same.
- 10:11So,
- 10:12but,
- 10:12but,
- 10:12but tell me how.
- 10:13The women who are working and getting educated,
- 10:15why are they faring off better in all of these?
- 10:18I am telling you that I do not believe they
- 10:20are faring off better in all of these measures.
- 10:21I do not that because I,
- 10:23I am,
- 10:23because of what
- 10:24I am telling you that we are looking at totally opposite statistics.
- 10:27Like,
- 10:27so you're sitting here telling me that
- 10:28the statistics show that women who are working
- 10:31are producing better children,
- 10:32and I'm saying that 20 2012 Gallup poll that
- 10:35the women that staying at home exactly wrong,
- 10:37saying that women that grow up in
- 10:38a two-family home where the mother stays at home are faring off better than the,
- 10:41the.
- 10:42Children who are being raised in an environment
- 10:44where the women are working,
- 10:45where both of the parents are working don't get away from the home.
- 10:48I do get to work from home.
- 10:49No,
- 10:49no,
- 10:49no,
- 10:49but the,
- 10:50I mean,
- 10:50I've watched your show.
- 10:51You talk about all the nannies you hire,
- 10:53and it's so hard to find a good nanny.
- 10:55Talked about all of the nannies I hired,
- 10:57but we have.
- 10:57I spoke about how difficult it was to find a babysitter who knew how to cook a meal,
- 11:01and that's because you don't need a babysitter.
- 11:03You're already,
- 11:04you could retire right now to let people respond to you when they're,
- 11:06when they're speaking.
- 11:07You don't want to
- 11:09to respond to you.
- 11:10No,
- 11:10you don't want to.
- 11:11You want to be working,
- 11:12which is great.
- 11:13You're telling me what I want now and then accusing me of telling you,
- 11:15Wait,
- 11:15are you,
- 11:16you don't want to work.
- 11:16Can you just let me finish because you've said so many words that you just,
- 11:19what you're trying to do here,
- 11:20like your argument style is I'm gonna say so much,
- 11:23not let her get awarded,
- 11:24and then walk away and feel like I've won.
- 11:25We're not having a conversation because you've not let
- 11:27me respond to either one of your points.
- 11:29OK.
- 11:30What I am saying to you,
- 11:31for first to answer what you just said,
- 11:32which was a lie,
- 11:33what I spoke to you about on the weekends is that it's been increasingly difficult
- 11:37to find
- 11:38a 25 year old.
- 11:39Who even knows how to make boxed macaroni and cheese,
- 11:42right?
- 11:42It's,
- 11:43and that's crazy.
- 11:43That's,
- 11:44and that is in large part due to feminism.
- 11:45Women don't even
- 11:46focus.
- 11:47Women don't even focus.
- 11:48Like there's this,
- 11:48there's this,
- 11:49there's this idea that
- 11:50women shouldn't be cooking.
- 11:51Like there's something fundamentally wrong with women even learning how to cook,
- 11:54you know what I spending as much time with your children as
- 11:56you possibly can because that's the way to get the most fulfillment.
- 11:58No,
- 11:59and that's what I'm trying to say.
- 12:00I am speaking to you and then stop,
- 12:02OK.
- 12:02Could you please
- 12:03let somebody
- 12:04get in a word you.
- 12:06You're not.
- 12:06You actually have not let anybody.
- 12:08Like I said,
- 12:10it's,
- 12:10it's,
- 12:11no one benefits when you're just speaking over me and not allowing me to respond.
- 12:14All you're proving is that you have an attitude and you believe in feminism,
- 12:18but you're not,
- 12:18see,
- 12:18you're,
- 12:19that's what I'm saying.
- 12:19You just have an attitude and it's not,
- 12:21it's not cute,
- 12:22it's performative.
- 12:22I'm actually address my point.
- 12:24I will be quiet if you address my point.
- 12:25Does anybody actually feel here that I am being allowed to address
- 12:29any of her points when she just keeps running over me?
- 12:31Like you,
- 12:32I'm literally trying to answer your first point of you saying
- 12:35that I don't stay at home.
- 12:38Fair point.
- 12:40Fair point.
- 12:41Obviously I get that you're all anti-Canice and pro-feminist,
- 12:44but also it's not productive if you're not actually OK,
- 12:46address the point.
- 12:47You spend more time saying that I'm not addressing that you,
- 12:49you don't have a chance to talk.
- 12:50I mean you the whole time you could have
- 12:52addressed the point and you could have talked,
- 12:53so go for it.
- 12:54Just want you to know that you're not coming across
- 12:55as somebody who wants to actually have a conversation.
- 12:57So to get back to the claim,
- 12:59because I don't even know where you're at,
- 13:00you're now talking.
- 13:00You're saying that I said stuff in my podcast wherever you want but I never said.
- 13:03I'll go wherever.
- 13:03So do you want to start with me working at home.
- 13:06Work at home.
- 13:06You just said
- 13:07something about me.
- 13:08You travel all around the world.
- 13:09I,
- 13:10you,
- 13:10you,
- 13:10you do,
- 13:11you do speeches,
- 13:11and I love that.
- 13:12I love how ambitious you are.
- 13:13That's a really great trait.
- 13:15And if you were truly said that,
- 13:16you would be more fulfilled.
- 13:17Now one thing you do find is women,
- 13:19they don't want to stay at home when you pull them.
- 13:20They just want flexible working hours and
- 13:22flexible working conditions like you have,
- 13:24and I think we should all advocate for that.
- 13:26It's not one or the other,
- 13:27but when you sit here and you go,
- 13:28you'll be more fulfilled doing this and spend all your time doing that,
- 13:30we would love for you to leave the public eye and go focus on what makes you fulfilled,
- 13:34OK.
- 13:39My next claim is that black on black crime
- 13:41is a result of underinvestment and over policing.
- 13:50So you say that black on black crime
- 13:51is due to underfunding and over policing essentially.
- 13:55uh,
- 13:55I actually don't necessarily disagree with one of those.
- 13:58Um,
- 13:59I think that however the government,
- 14:00who do you think should be responsible for
- 14:03the funding piece of the black community?
- 14:04Should that be something that the government should step into or should
- 14:06that be something that we as black people need to handle ourselves?
- 14:09Uh,
- 14:09Doctor Jordan Peterson and.
- 14:11Uh,
- 14:11even Thomas Sowell and several others have stated one thing that poverty and crime,
- 14:15there's a positive correlation.
- 14:16There's also a positive correlation in the black community
- 14:18of absentee fatherism being one of the root causes
- 14:21leading into criminality.
- 14:22Black male black males that grew up without a father
- 14:24are
- 14:2510 times more likely to engage in criminal activity.
- 14:28And so I think one of the,
- 14:28can I put a pin right there and ask you a question?
- 14:30Ask me whatever you like.
- 14:31What is the root cause
- 14:33of there being.
- 14:34fathers.
- 14:35Bad decision making on the part of the fathers.
- 14:37We live in a patriarchal system,
- 14:38like it or not,
- 14:39men have dominated the socioeconomic,
- 14:40economic and political power of this country and the world since our existence.
- 14:44So our bad decision making,
- 14:46especially when we focus on the black community,
- 14:48is the root cause of of fatherlessness.
- 14:51Not marrying the women we decide to lay down and have children with,
- 14:54not being careful with the seeds that we plant in women.
- 14:56A woman can get pregnant
- 14:57without a man planting his seed inside of her.
- 14:59So therefore,
- 15:00so it's marriage.
- 15:01Well,
- 15:02that's a,
- 15:02that's a part of it.
- 15:03That that's marriage is a part of it.
- 15:05But the true
- 15:06piece that I'm looking at is connectedness between familial units.
- 15:09The black community was at its economically strongest while being at its poorest
- 15:13during the,
- 15:14uh,
- 15:14segregation era.
- 15:15Prior to 1968,
- 15:16Dr.
- 15:16Martin Luther King in his last speech said that
- 15:18we have an annual income.
- 15:19of more than $30 billion a year,
- 15:20which is more than all of the exports of Canada and more or more than all
- 15:24of the exports of the United States and more than the national budget of Canada.
- 15:27That was when we were economically at our poorest.
- 15:29Yet
- 15:2985% of our black children were growing up
- 15:32with a father in the home.
- 15:33There was less black on black crime.
- 15:35There was less,
- 15:36uh,
- 15:36disenfranchised.
- 15:37Why was there less black on black crime?
- 15:39Because we needed to live together.
- 15:40We had,
- 15:40we had to stick by each other.
- 15:42We had to stick.
- 15:42What was there also less of?
- 15:44I'm not sure where you're leading.
- 15:44That's a leading question.
- 15:47I don't,
- 15:47you don't like this.
- 15:47I don't like leading questions.
- 15:48No,
- 15:49I like direct stuff.
- 15:50So essentially
- 15:52when we were living in our own communities,
- 15:53we were also policing our own communities.
- 15:56So we were not being
- 15:59used as statistics in the same way to determine
- 16:02how resources were provided to our own communities.
- 16:04When we were going
- 16:05to the government saying,
- 16:06hey,
- 16:07we deserve because we are supposed to be separate but equal,
- 16:11we weren't saying,
- 16:12hey,
- 16:12we want to be with y'all.
- 16:13We were essentially.
- 16:14We want what you are stating we deserve.
- 16:17And that is what all of the efforts of the civil rights movement has been.
- 16:20It's literally just been to say,
- 16:22you said when we got out of the Civil War
- 16:25that we would be considered citizens and all all
- 16:27citizens should be getting equal access to these things.
- 16:30However,
- 16:31you are actively allowing the Klan
- 16:33to harm us.
- 16:34You're actively allowing who's killed more black people,
- 16:37the Klan or us?
- 16:38I would like to continue my statement.
- 16:40I'll let you speak uninterrupted.
- 16:41When we talk.
- 16:42About this concept of
- 16:44who is harming us.
- 16:45We are really
- 16:47making a false claim when it comes to black on
- 16:49black crime as if there isn't white on white crime.
- 16:51There's also this unnecessary
- 16:53effort to try and pathologize
- 16:55black on black crime in a way that you don't try to pathologize white on white crime.
- 16:59There are white people killing each other
- 17:01every single day.
- 17:02Now they may be on jet skis
- 17:04in the pictures after they shoot up their whole family,
- 17:06but nonetheless,
- 17:07there are white people killing each other every single day.
- 17:09Now much of the reason why you
- 17:10See more numbers in terms of black on black crime are for two reasons.
- 17:13One,
- 17:13the statistics be lying all the time.
- 17:15We have seen this numbers.
- 17:16We have seen this in a real way.
- 17:17So in New Jersey,
- 17:19so in New Jersey,
- 17:20what numbers can be trusted because with the previous speaker,
- 17:21I'm about to tell you right now,
- 17:23OK.
- 17:23So your sources you can't such numbers.
- 17:25No,
- 17:25I'm literally about to give you an example of numbers not being able to be trusted.
- 17:28OK,
- 17:28talk to me.
- 17:28That's what I was doing.
- 17:30So,
- 17:30OK,
- 17:31then,
- 17:31then listen.
- 17:32is.
- 17:33So listen,
- 17:33in New Jersey
- 17:35they had a statistic that was created by the police department that said look.
- 17:38How many black people are committing crimes.
- 17:41Look at how crazy this number is.
- 17:42These black people are so exorbitantly violent.
- 17:44Look at this.
- 17:45And then
- 17:46people went
- 17:47and actually matched
- 17:48the names that they were booking
- 17:51with the faces of the actual people incarcerated,
- 17:54and it was proven
- 17:56that they were lying.
- 17:57So that's one,
- 17:57OK,
- 17:57so that's one instance.
- 17:58Hold on.
- 17:58No,
- 17:59no,
- 17:59you're talking to somebody that works as a
- 18:00police dispatcher when I'm not making content.
- 18:01So here's the thing.
- 18:02So no,
- 18:03no,
- 18:03no,
- 18:03you see,
- 18:04well,
- 18:04the truth is you're about to see the truth if you just give me a second,
- 18:06like Trump.
- 18:06Just give me a second.
- 18:07I'm,
- 18:07I'm gonna do the weave,
- 18:08but give me a minute.
- 18:09Well,
- 18:09here's what you all keep doing.
- 18:10You keep interrupting me when I'm talking,
- 18:12and you don't want to hear the point that I'm gonna make,
- 18:14and yet you want me to respect your point,
- 18:16and that's not how a debate works.
- 18:18So if you want me to keep getting louder,
- 18:20I will do it.
- 18:21But ultimately,
- 18:22if I show you respect,
- 18:23give me the respect back.
- 18:24I let you talk.
- 18:25I let you make your points.
- 18:26I am countering your points,
- 18:28and my points are just as valid as yours,
- 18:29even though you got a pocket square
- 18:31and a Church of Christ,
- 18:32uh,
- 18:32pin on your chest.
- 18:33It's not a Church of Christ,
- 18:34whatever.
- 18:35Across,
- 18:35same difference.
- 18:36You got an American flag and you think you know something because you're a cop,
- 18:38and ultimately,
- 18:39and ultimately it's a it's a cab all day over here.
- 18:42So let me make that clear.
- 18:43But let me also add to my point.
- 18:46My point is
- 18:47that you can sit here
- 18:49and blame black people on black people all day long
- 18:52and not acknowledge that we are forced into,
- 18:55you're coming to interrupt me again.
- 18:57I haven't even said a word.
- 18:58All right,
- 18:58that is flags,
- 18:59so I'm gonna ask you to return to your seat.
- 19:01It's a waste of my time.
- 19:03Y'all just want to be seen.
- 19:05I don't need to be seen.
- 19:06My next claim is that
- 19:08morality and purpose
- 19:10cannot be found within science.
- 19:15How are you doing?
- 19:16Nice to meet you.
- 19:17Nice to meet you.
- 19:17I guess since you said morality and purpose cannot be found in science,
- 19:21um,
- 19:21it would just depend on like what you're referencing.
- 19:23If you're saying a description of your
- 19:24psychological preferences would be considered within science,
- 19:26sure,
- 19:27but I don't think that you have to say that it
- 19:28comes from science in order to be like an atheist.
- 19:30As an agnostic atheist,
- 19:32I don't know if God exists and I don't believe that a God exists,
- 19:35and the only ones that I would really reject would be like the all-knowing,
- 19:37all powerful,
- 19:38all good,
- 19:39perfect notion of God that plenty of Christians like prescribe themselves.
- 19:43So I guess.
- 19:44To this claim.
- 19:45You're basing a position of morality and purpose in some like notion of God
- 19:50that isn't the same type of notion of God that typical Christians would prescribe.
- 19:54Your notion of God is what typical Christians?
- 19:56Yeah,
- 19:57typically when I talk to Christians,
- 19:58they,
- 19:58they say that they believe in an all knowing about Cardinal Newman,
- 20:01who defined God as conscience.
- 20:03He's a major influence on all of Catholic social theory.
- 20:06How about that Christian?
- 20:08Sure,
- 20:09I'm,
- 20:09so do you believe in the all-knowing,
- 20:10all powerful,
- 20:11all good notion of God?
- 20:12What do you mean by believe?
- 20:15Do you think it to be true?
- 20:17That's the circular definition.
- 20:18What do you mean when you say you believe?
- 20:21How is that circular?
- 20:22Because you added no content to the answer by substituting.
- 20:26The word true
- 20:28and believe.
- 20:29I said,
- 20:29you think it to be true.
- 20:31All right,
- 20:31so
- 20:32if you believe something,
- 20:33you stake your life on it.
- 20:35What do you mean by that?
- 20:37You live for it
- 20:39And you die for it.
- 20:41That's what I mean by that.
- 20:42It isn't something that you say.
- 20:44It isn't something that's associated with logical consistency.
- 20:48It's not declarative,
- 20:49it's not propositional.
- 20:51It's not a
- 20:51figment of your imagination.
- 20:54It's the presupposition of your attention and your action.
- 20:57And you're either fragmented,
- 20:59in which case you worship multiple gods,
- 21:01or there's some unity at the bottom of it
- 21:03that makes you an unstoppable force.
- 21:08OK,
- 21:08so you're saying that you don't believe something if you wouldn't die for it.
- 21:12Not really,
- 21:12no.
- 21:13OK,
- 21:13so how would you define belief?
- 21:15Something you say,
- 21:16while I explain like I could believe it is the case that this pen exists,
- 21:19but if someone like threatened my life,
- 21:21right,
- 21:21I would lie in order to be able to save my life,
- 21:24right?
- 21:24Like I,
- 21:24I think you would do that too.
- 21:25You wouldn't lie to save your life,
- 21:27so sure
- 21:28you,
- 21:28you wouldn't lie to save your life.
- 21:31How much do you know about me?
- 21:32I didn't lie to save my career.
- 21:34I didn't lie to save my clinical practice.
- 21:38Would you lie,
- 21:38lie to like save your children,
- 21:39your mom,
- 21:40your dad?
- 21:40I don't think lying would save them.
- 21:43Can there ever be a circumstance logically that lying could save someone?
- 21:46Yeah,
- 21:46and if you're steeped in sin,
- 21:47you're likely to live in circumstances like that.
- 21:50I'll give you an example.
- 21:51If you're like uh in like Nazi Germany and it is the case that
- 21:53there's like Jewish people in your attic and you're trying to protect them,
- 21:56would you lie to like the Nazis?
- 21:58I would have done everything I bloody well could,
- 22:00so I wouldn't be in that situation to begin with.
- 22:03It's a hypothetical and it's not answerabletheticals.
- 22:06No,
- 22:06I can't answer a hypothetical like that because it's far.
- 22:11Look,
- 22:12don't play games.
- 22:12Yes you are.
- 22:14If you present me with an intractable moral choice that's
- 22:17stripped of context and you back me into a corner,
- 22:19you're playing a game.
- 22:21I just told you,
- 22:22I would do everything that I could.
- 22:25To make sure that I'm never in that situation.
- 22:28By the time you've got there,
- 22:30you've made so many mistakes that there's nothing you can do that isn't a sin.
- 22:34Being born in Nazi Germany and,
- 22:36and trying to protect people that you care about,
- 22:38like there could be a Jewish friend that you have,
- 22:39and you want to protect them.
- 22:40I think you have them in your attic that line of questioning.
- 22:43Give up on just like trying to clarify your position
- 22:46because it,
- 22:46you don't like,
- 22:47are you like uncomfortable with me asking this question?
- 22:49It's just a basic.
- 22:49hypothetical.
- 22:50Like I could ask you,
- 22:51it's just a basic hypothetical where you're like you
- 22:54put Jews' lives at stake in Nazi Germany.
- 22:56That's just a basic hypo.
- 22:58Obviously you would lie in that scenario to save their life,
- 22:59but you're like not trying to answer this question for some reason.
- 23:03I just told you why.
- 23:04Are you anti-fascist?
- 23:06Like,
- 23:06so you're anti-fascist asking that.
- 23:08I was just asking,
- 23:08just clarifying,
- 23:09but like,
- 23:10OK,
- 23:10again,
- 23:10you're not answering this hypothetical because you know it
- 23:12shows that you clearly would lie to save it.
- 23:15Obviously that's not what truth is
- 23:17acceptable,
- 23:17obviously because I care about truth.
- 23:19I wouldn't be in that scenario,
- 23:20obviously,
- 23:21right,
- 23:21logically,
- 23:22because that's already happened,
- 23:23like that's in the past.
- 23:24You don't have a time to travel device.
- 23:25We're bringing this logical hypothetical up to show you that
- 23:28in some circumstances that do happen within the real world,
- 23:31you would lie to save people's lives.
- 23:32So your definition of truth isn't actually.
- 23:34We're typically using it.
- 23:35So what you're trying to do is you're trying to muddy the waters when I ask you like,
- 23:37do you believe this?
- 23:38Do you think this to be true,
- 23:39so you don't actually have to answer the questions,
- 23:41and plenty of Christians don't like that because they clearly see
- 23:43that you don't really like want to be associated with Christianity.
- 23:45Imagine that I was in a situation where
- 23:48the best I could do as a consequence of my previous mistakes
- 23:52was to tell the least amount of lie I could manage.
- 23:55But that would likely indicate that I had made all sorts of catastrophic,
- 23:59catastrophic errors on my way there.
- 24:02So,
- 24:02so you would lie to save someone's life.
- 24:03So again,
- 24:04you do believe it to be true in that circumstance,
- 24:05even though you like lied in that scenario.
- 24:08So clearly that the context that I put it in.
- 24:10You were not willing to die for it.
- 24:11You were not willing to,
- 24:12willing to let other people die for it.
- 24:13So that's not what you see to be true then,
- 24:16seemingly.
- 24:18You're doing exactly what I said you were
- 24:20doing at the beginning of the conversation.
- 24:22You're generating an impossible,
- 24:24restricted hypothetical
- 24:26with no precursors to back me into a corners impossible?
- 24:29Is there something contradictory about it?
- 24:31Nice to meet you.
- 24:31Yeah,
- 24:32nice to meet you too great conversation.
- 24:35My final claim is that Donald Trump's plan for Gaza is ethnic cleansing.
- 24:42No one.
- 24:43Great.
- 24:43Hello sir.
- 24:44Welcome back.
- 24:46Alright,
- 24:46so I agree that Trump wants to do a cleansing,
- 24:50but not an ethnic one
- 24:51because that area requires a lot of cleansing.
- 24:54Because when you have a population that was
- 24:55taught from early childhood age to hate Jews,
- 24:59Christians,
- 24:59and pagans,
- 25:00you need some serious re-education.
- 25:02Number 1,
- 25:02that's not true,
- 25:03and number 2,
- 25:03that's not what he's proposing.
- 25:04Well,
- 25:04I mean,
- 25:05most Palestinians by polling number do support Hamas.
- 25:09They support resisting Israel.
- 25:11Well,
- 25:11I mean,
- 25:12the thing is,
- 25:12you know,
- 25:13what did they do in the first place
- 25:15that they're in this.
- 25:16What you call open air prison.
- 25:18Great question.
- 25:18What did they do to deserve being occupied?
- 25:20Well,
- 25:21here's the thing,
- 25:21because the Islamic Republic in Iran
- 25:23is using them as a tool.
- 25:25What has I got to do with this,
- 25:26as a tool
- 25:27for their Islamic expansion.
- 25:29When did the Islamic on,
- 25:30hold on,
- 25:30when did the Islamic Republic of Iran,
- 25:32you're Iranian American,
- 25:33I believe.
- 25:33Yes,
- 25:34I am.
- 25:34When was the Islamic Republic of Iran founded?
- 25:361979.
- 25:37When was Gaza occupied by Israel?
- 25:39Uh,
- 25:3919,
- 25:41well,
- 25:41the very first time,
- 25:4267,
- 25:43yeah,
- 25:43so
- 25:44can we do the math together?
- 25:4512 years before the Islamic Republic of Iran existed,
- 25:48Israel was oppressing,
- 25:49occupying,
- 25:49dispossessing the people of Gaza.
- 25:51So your argument makes no sense.
- 25:52Are there any terrorist organizations at the time?
- 25:54The PLO was considered a terrorist organization by the entire Western world.
- 25:57Alright,
- 25:57so was Hamas there?
- 25:59Hamas did not exist till the 1980s.
- 26:01Exactly.
- 26:01My point is,
- 26:03after the Islamic Republic came,
- 26:04it.
- 26:05Became chaotic
- 26:06because the Islamic Republic has started to use
- 26:09the what's the so-called innocent Palestinians for their own
- 26:11so-called innocent Palestinians you don't think Palestinians are innocent.
- 26:14Not all of them.
- 26:15What about the 17,000 children who were killed?
- 26:17They're doing 17,000 children were killed,
- 26:19but they not innocent?
- 26:22Who's responsible for that?
- 26:24Israel.
- 26:25Hamas is responsible.
- 26:26Hamas is responsible for hiding in hospitals and and banking tunnels underneath.
- 26:30Shot in the head by Israeli snipers,
- 26:32Israeli snipers aren't responsible for that.
- 26:34Look,
- 26:35it's a simple question.
- 26:35Here's the problem.
- 26:36When Israeli snipers shoot Palestinian children in Gaza in the head,
- 26:39as eyewitness testimony and doctor's testimony proves,
- 26:42that's not the fault of the Israeli snipers.
- 26:44This is,
- 26:44this is the problem,
- 26:45because when you have the problem is you won't answer the question.
- 26:47I'll ask you a third time.
- 26:48When Israeli snipers shoot Palestinian children in the head,
- 26:50is that not the fault of Israeli snipers?
- 26:52Well,
- 26:53you got to let me finish.
- 26:53No,
- 26:54you've got to answer the question.
- 26:554th time.
- 26:56snipers shoot Palestinian children in the head.
- 26:59We're running out of time.
- 26:59I need to know what you think about innocent children,
- 27:01because what you said was pretty outrageous.
- 27:02You said so-called innocent Palestinians.
- 27:05For the 5th time when Palestinian children are shot in the head by Israeli snipers.
- 27:08Is that not the fault of Israeli snipers?
- 27:12What did,
- 27:12why did you tell me?
- 27:13Did the children deserve to be shot in the head?
- 27:15Because the problem is,
- 27:15you know,
- 27:16millions of people are watching you say they just brainwashing children.
- 27:19They start brainwashing children at a,
- 27:21at a very long time.
- 27:22age.
- 27:22So you support sniping children in Gaza.
- 27:25Do other people here support sniping children in Gaza?
- 27:28Is that a conservative position now?
- 27:30What if they're wearing a suicide vest?
- 27:32They weren't.
- 27:32But what if they are?
- 27:33They're not though.
- 27:34Dozens of children.
- 27:35I have friends who went there,
- 27:36doctors went to Gaza,
- 27:37American doctors.
- 27:38They came back and said we have multiple children.
- 27:40What if they are?
- 27:40What if they are hell bent on killing you and your family?
- 27:44A 10 year old child,
- 27:45an 8-year-old child,
- 27:46a 6-year-old child.
- 27:47Because,
- 27:49because like I said,
- 27:49you're sitting on their television and millions
- 27:52of people are gonna see your neighbors,
- 27:54your friends,
- 27:54millions of people killing of millions of people don't know what's going on.
- 27:57Even your fellow right wingers are saying don't go this far.
- 28:01White genocide,
- 28:01sure,
- 28:02but don't millions of people don't understand the brainwashing that
- 28:05is going on in the Islamic Republic and in Palestine
- 28:09to create this hatred with Iran so much
- 28:11that you're supporting the.
- 28:12Killing of Palestinian children who never harmed you or any other Israeli.
- 28:15That's insane.
- 28:16Look,
- 28:17and the fact that you support Trump's ethnic cleansing now doesn't surprise me.
- 28:19I didn't say ethnic cleansing.
- 28:21I said cleansing of the land because you need to
- 28:23cleanse the land from the Slobodan Milosevic said similar stuff.
- 28:26You've been voted out.
- 28:27Please return to your seat.
- 28:28Thank you guys for listening.
- 28:30That was the top 5 moments we selected from this past year,
- 28:34and we are so excited for new episodes coming out.
- 28:37So if you are not a subscriber,
- 28:39please subscribe wherever you get your podcasts.
- 28:41And if you're interested in video versions
- 28:44of the episodes,
- 28:45we have the full
- 28:47main
- 28:48episodes as well as now follow-up episodes of the podcast
- 28:52available on Jubilee's YouTube channel.
- 28:54So give us a subscription there.
- 28:56Thank you guys so much for listening,
- 28:58and we will see you next time.