Latest / No Way Out / Command and Control Systems with S. Anders Christensson
Transcript
- 0:21Ponch Rivera: Hey.
- 0:21Mark McGrath: Mark.
- 0:22Ponch Rivera: Great to see you.
- 0:23Ponch Rivera: And today we have Anders Kristensen on with us, who's from the Swedish Defense Forces and spend a lot of time working on NATO command and control.
- 0:32Ponch Rivera: So why are we here today?
- 0:34Ponch Rivera: What are we going to talk about?
- 0:35Ponch Rivera: Well, a lot of times, folks want to go beyond Boyd.
- 0:38Ponch Rivera: They want to take apart Boyd.
- 0:39Ponch Rivera: We want to make sure that it's not a stagnant thing.
- 0:44Ponch Rivera: Right, john Boyd didn't give us something, that's just hey, this is a dogma, you got to follow it.
- 0:49Ponch Rivera: So we want guests to come on and kind of challenge Boyd, and we have that today with Anders.
- 0:53Ponch Rivera: So, anders, welcome to the show.
- 0:55Ponch Rivera: How are you doing today?
- 0:56Anders Christensson: sir, great, absolutely Glad to be with you.
- 0:59Anders Christensson: Great From Stockholm, sweden.
- 1:03Ponch Rivera: Yeah, and thank you.
- 1:03Ponch Rivera: Thank you so much for being here.
- 1:05Ponch Rivera: So right before we went live today, we were talking about the.
- 1:08Ponch Rivera: Did you call it the Dota loop?
- 1:10Ponch Rivera: Is that correct?
- 1:11Anders Christensson: Right Dynamic Oda loop which essentially fuses in that.
- 1:19Anders Christensson: You have to be aware of that.
- 1:21Anders Christensson: Your decisions will alter the outer system and the inner system.
- 1:30Anders Christensson: And outer and inner system comes from the terminology from Herbert Simon, a Nobel Prize winner.
- 1:40Anders Christensson: Often we call the outer system the operational area and the inner system is our command and control system.
- 1:52Anders Christensson: Now our professor, Bant Bremer, now deceased, has made a theory based on Boyd but expanded it upwards.
- 2:06Anders Christensson: By that I mean he uses Jens Rasmussen's design logic or design hierarchies, because, as Herbert Simon says, this is design logic when you are going to design a command and control system.
- 2:28Anders Christensson: So here, by the design hierarchy, Jens Rasmussen states okay, what's the purpose of command and control, what is the design criteria, what is the functions, what is the processes and what form is it that are designed to accomplish, the processes that are executed in the functions that the functions has to meet when it comes to design hierarchy, to meet the purpose.
- 3:14Anders Christensson: So that means that five steps going downwards and as well upwards.
- 3:23Anders Christensson: And Boyd emphasizes the processes, the human processes, in his what Chet and the other guy, Chet and Chuck mentioned about yeah, mentioned about the, but essentially it's a process.
- 3:51Anders Christensson: He states he's not going dwelling so much into the abstract functions.
- 3:58Anders Christensson: What is orientation, what is decision?
- 4:03Anders Christensson: What is in a mathematical term that is lacking on what Boyd has?
- 4:13Anders Christensson: You know that Mickey Ensley also, which is a psychologist, yes, has focused on form, layer five, and how that accomplish in processes.
- 4:30Anders Christensson: But you have to move up to set the criteria, what the do da loop has to accomplish, and there you have to have observability of the external system, the outer system, and you have to meet sterability with the inner system and that harmonizes with Ashby and Viq and so on.
- 5:04Anders Christensson: Absolutely so if you want to calculate with it, you have to go from layer one, purpose, layer two, design hierarchy, design criteria on the functions.
- 5:25Anders Christensson: Then you can observe the processes that are going on in the staff.
- 5:36Ponch Rivera: And when you mean staff, you're talking about the organization, correct?
- 5:39Anders Christensson: Yes, the organization and operational level from strategic to operational level, right and further down.
- 5:46Mark McGrath: And as you say in your paper, with that you wrote with with Dr Bremer, I mean, this is all human centered, this is all centered on the human, and the human is the one that makes the command and control function.
- 5:57Anders Christensson: Absolutely Humans.
- 5:59Anders Christensson: Do click in from processes and form, because in form, layer five, you choose people, you organize them in a certain way, you add up technology, you add up methods and so on, all those artifacts that you actually can do, and they are combined in the processes.
- 6:28Mark McGrath: Yeah, well, you say.
- 6:30Mark McGrath: I love this line from your paper.
- 6:32Mark McGrath: It should not be designed in such a way that the people will have to help the command control system solve its problems, as if a lot of the problems that wind up coming from these systems.
- 6:41Mark McGrath: That's what becomes.
- 6:42Mark McGrath: The function of the system is to solve all its problems and it's not centered on.
- 6:46Anders Christensson: You know, people ideas things in that order, as Boyd was saying you have to have help from the layer one, two, three to support the processes.
- 6:56Anders Christensson: So humans know okay, we're doing good now in our command and control or we're doing lousy.
- 7:05Anders Christensson: You have to have the ability to see now we're not, we're not coping with the right stuff.
- 7:16Ponch Rivera: And I want to bring up something on command control.
- 7:18Ponch Rivera: Not everybody, you know, it's kind of a four letter word out here in the US right now that command control is bad in organizations.
- 7:24Ponch Rivera: Our understanding of command control is all living organisms, living systems, need some type of command control.
- 7:30Ponch Rivera: It's just, you know, when you look at complexity theory you need some type of command control.
- 7:35Ponch Rivera: Now John Boyd talked about leadership and appreciation.
- 7:37Ponch Rivera: Can you walk us through what you mean by command and control and a command control system, so you can help our listeners ease into that?
- 7:47Anders Christensson: Okay, in the command and control systems.
- 7:51Anders Christensson: It consists of people, how they are organized, what type of tools they have, what training they have and if they are working together, and that you can observe.
- 8:09Anders Christensson: You can always observe processes.
- 8:12Anders Christensson: You can see that.
- 8:14Anders Christensson: Okay, this group is actually producing sufficient information that has to go into next in the line of organization.
- 8:28Anders Christensson: You can actually see that Now.
- 8:34Anders Christensson: If you want to make some sort of test or experiment, I urge to visit Bloom's Taxonomy.
- 8:44Anders Christensson: Bloom's Taxonomy is stating what stages do you have to go through if you're learning?
- 8:54Anders Christensson: So there you have.
- 8:58Anders Christensson: You have to know the terms, the relationships and you have to have the ability to do analysis and synthesize and then value.
- 9:13Anders Christensson: These are things that you can observe that you're the learner is doing.
- 9:21Anders Christensson: You can actually see, okay, he has met the criteria.
- 9:28Anders Christensson: Because if we don't can do that, the Bologna process would be obsolete, because 46 countries is using Bloom's Taxonomy for learning.
- 9:47Anders Christensson: That's the common, a commonator between all university and technology the educational system in 46 countries, so in US.
- 10:01Anders Christensson: So we can use that to actually see.
- 10:06Anders Christensson: Or is the staff actually learning Now?
- 10:15Anders Christensson: That's the process Now, when it comes to level one, to direct and come up with a plan that we can execute.
- 10:31Anders Christensson: Plan is feed forward, control is feedbackwards.
- 10:37Anders Christensson: So it's essentially focusing the processes and level five, but they are omitting level one, two, three, which you have to have.
- 11:55Anders Christensson: It's mathematical criterias that are demanding the processes to do right.
- 12:06Ponch Rivera: Andrew, there's so much we can pull out of this conversation.
- 12:09Ponch Rivera: Number one when John Boyd was looking at the Toyota production system, he saw that control was outside and bottom up.
- 12:16Ponch Rivera: It was from the outside, from the customer.
- 12:18Ponch Rivera: When we think about that, do you concur with that?
- 12:20Anders Christensson: line.
- 12:20Anders Christensson: Thought Absolutely absolutely.
- 12:22Ponch Rivera: Yeah.
- 12:23Ponch Rivera: And then you brought up many names and I just want to highlight those here.
- 12:26Ponch Rivera: I may miss a couple.
- 12:28Ponch Rivera: You brought up Ashby, you brought up Galvik.
- 12:30Ponch Rivera: You brought up Micah Ensley.
- 12:33Ponch Rivera: I'm going to just touch on these real fast.
- 12:36Ponch Rivera: Requisite variety we've talked about that on the show, how critical that is and how that connects to John Boyd's ootl With Micah's work.
- 12:43Ponch Rivera: And you may be talking about different work that I'm very familiar with, but that's the different levels of situational awareness, which is very important and we can make that connection to Boyd's work.
- 12:52Ponch Rivera: And then there's Carl Weich, who we talked about quite a bit on the show, and that is in the world of, of the sense-making stuff.
- 12:58Ponch Rivera: Sense-making, yeah, yeah.
- 12:59Ponch Rivera: So we have sense-making with Carl Weich and we have sense-making with Dave Snowden he's going to pound me for forgetting his name there, but Carl Weich's work is going back to.
- 13:11Ponch Rivera: What I want to highlight here is you can observe things, and that's what he did.
- 13:16Ponch Rivera: He went out and observed how these organizations operate at the edge of the envelope and, instead of creating a case-based approach, he looked at these things and said hey, this is how this works in these high-risk environments, such as the flight deck of an aircraft, carrier, nuclear power plant, submarines, aviation, things like that.
- 13:35Ponch Rivera: So what I'm going with this is everything I'm hearing from you is authentic, right?
- 13:40Ponch Rivera: That's why this is an important conversation.
- 13:43Ponch Rivera: I haven't heard anything that isn't inauthentic and isn't saying that Boyd's work is invalid.
- 13:49Ponch Rivera: What I'm hearing from you is it's good, but we need to go.
- 13:52Ponch Rivera: We need.
- 13:53Ponch Rivera: Boyd gave us a gift, right?
- 13:55Ponch Rivera: He gave us something.
- 13:56Ponch Rivera: Take this and run with it and make it better, right?
- 13:59Mark McGrath: Do you agree with that?
- 13:59Mark McGrath: Yes, okay.
- 14:00Ponch Rivera: And that's how we I think we agree on that 100%.
- 14:03Ponch Rivera: Yes, mark, do you have anything to add on what?
- 14:06Mark McGrath: we heard so far.
- 14:07Mark McGrath: Well, I mean, that's what our podcast is dedicated to is the development and advancement of Boyd's theories, because even his If you've read the Franz O'Singh books Science, strategy and War the very last line is that this is intentionally left open for exactly what you're talking about, for us to continue to build and use it, not as a religious dogma, which Boyd would inject himself to do exactly what we're doing, to talk about it, and that was one of the things when I was reading your work that jumped off the page.
- 14:39Mark McGrath: You're talking about something that's absolutely human-centered and that the systems and the technology support decision-making, that the humans a staff, a commander, those are human beings that have cognitive biases, they have learning, they have other things, absolutely.
- 14:54Mark McGrath: Just one thing.
- 14:55Mark McGrath: I would ask a clarification point.
- 14:57Mark McGrath: When you say Duda like dynamic, observe, orient, decide, act, am I hearing you correctly to say that our process of Uda, our orientation that cycles through Uda, has to be dynamic and not static, because dynamic would Absolutely because both the outer system and our inner system I mean the troops will be tired when they have done something.
- 15:25Anders Christensson: They have to reload, they have to rest, they have to do so the state variables in the inner system and the outer system is altering because of our decision, because of actions.
- 15:43Anders Christensson: Decision has to go back and reinforced, and so on.
- 15:51Mark McGrath: And what you allude to in the abstract of your paper, a command post for complex operations that you wrote with Professor Brenner.
- 15:59Mark McGrath: When you say that line it should not be designed in such a way that the people will have to help the command and control system solve its problems the dynamic Uda.
- 16:09Mark McGrath: If you keep your orientation dynamic, you're avoiding that, you're trying to avoid that.
- 16:13Mark McGrath: So what you're saying in that sentence of the system solving its problems, that's the static orientation, that's the static Uda loop.
- 16:22Anders Christensson: Yeah, the static when it comes to decision making and the process of science of that Brenner came through that saw that originally we see decisions as a decision and then it takes a long time before next decision has to be done.
- 16:51Anders Christensson: But in military operations this is much faster.
- 16:58Anders Christensson: So that's why he says, okay, we have to have a dynamic.
- 17:02Anders Christensson: So that states the mons on the staff to have a better notion of what is going on both in the operational area but as well as in our own troops, our inner system.
- 17:24Ponch Rivera: Andrew, what are the dangers of knowing too much?
- 17:26Ponch Rivera: And let me give you some context.
- 17:27Ponch Rivera: We learned about the 1,000-mile screwdriver from the idea that a general who can watch a predator feed can do something from his office in Ramstein, germany, or here in the US.
- 17:38Ponch Rivera: How much is too much visibility Too much is?
- 17:44Anders Christensson: when you're blurring or confusing, because all the information is not leading to your end state.
- 17:55Anders Christensson: It's your end state that is defining what is this strategic objectives and how are we going to meet those strategic objectives.
- 18:08Anders Christensson: All other information that is not supporting this is obsolete and confusing.
- 18:20Mark McGrath: That's the focus and direction, right, that's the Schwerpunkt, as Boyd would say, absolutely.
- 18:25Anders Christensson: Thank you, so you need to source down.
- 18:29Anders Christensson: Okay, what we have, this situation today in our outer system, in our operational area.
- 18:39Anders Christensson: Is this what we want to have?
- 18:41Anders Christensson: Can we describe the future demanded situation that we strive for?
- 18:53Anders Christensson: How would you describe that?
- 18:56Anders Christensson: And you describe it as if you were there.
- 19:01Ponch Rivera: Right.
- 19:01Ponch Rivera: So I'm going to throw a couple things at you on the OE, the operational environment, the external environment, some things we're learning from complexity theory, some things we learned from effects-based operations too.
- 19:13Ponch Rivera: So I want to expand on this because this is critical to what we highlight on the show From complexity theory.
- 19:21Ponch Rivera: When we look at the operating environment, the external environment, we look at where we are.
- 19:26Ponch Rivera: We want to understand that through situational awareness.
- 19:28Ponch Rivera: Where are we now?
- 19:29Ponch Rivera: And we look at the evolutionary potential of the present to modify the future, because we can't define a future high definition destination, a smart goal or anything like that in a complex environment because it's complex.
- 19:43Ponch Rivera: So we can run multiple probes, go through the OO Probe, get that feedback from the environment and move in a direction rather than go to a destination, and this is something that we've been talking a lot about on the show.
- 19:56Ponch Rivera: And I want to bring up effects.
- 19:58Ponch Rivera: You may be familiar with effects-based operations from many years ago.
- 20:01Anders Christensson: Absolutely.
- 20:03Ponch Rivera: That was something that we were trained on and fighter pilots and military members.
- 20:08Ponch Rivera: They learn how to start with the end state in mind and work backwards.
- 20:11Ponch Rivera: And a lot of situations dropping a GBU-12 or 16 or a GBU-28 on a target that's kind of a complicated thing.
- 20:21Ponch Rivera: It's a known thing.
- 20:22Ponch Rivera: I know where the target is most likely.
- 20:24Ponch Rivera: I can work backwards, I can find out the time I need to launch from the carrier.
- 20:27Ponch Rivera: I can look at all the threats in the environment and adapt to them.
- 20:31Ponch Rivera: But that's the effects-based operations.
- 20:33Ponch Rivera: I can put an effect on something that I know.
- 20:36Ponch Rivera: Right.
- 20:37Ponch Rivera: The problem with this type of thinking is when you bring that back into and say, hey, this is how it works in the military.
- 20:43Ponch Rivera: It has bounded applicability.
- 20:44Ponch Rivera: That type of thinking works in a complicated environment and I'm using complicated from Dave Snowden's Kinevan framework.
- 20:52Ponch Rivera: It doesn't necessarily work in the complex environment.
- 20:55Ponch Rivera: So this is a shift in thinking for leaders in the military and all leaders is hey, we can't take these one-size-fits-all approaches to all-deeds command and control and apply it to the complex environment.
- 21:08Ponch Rivera: So, if I'm hearing you correctly, the way we look at the external environment and the decisions we make, those decisions are going to change the external environment, or we have to update our internal environment, which is our orientation to always adapt.
- 21:23Ponch Rivera: So I think we have alignment on that.
- 21:26Ponch Rivera: Is that what you're talking about?
- 21:28Anders Christensson: as well.
- 21:28Anders Christensson: Sinofin, if you look at his model of simple, complicated, complex and chaotic system, we can add the atomic quantum system in the middle.
- 21:47Anders Christensson: But since that is for atoms, relativity and Schrodinger his equations, we leave that out.
- 21:59Anders Christensson: Now, if you look at the structure on a system, it's stable over time.
- 22:08Anders Christensson: When it comes to simple system and complicated system I mean a submarine is a complicated system but it's stable.
- 22:20Anders Christensson: If you go to the other side, you have quick, dynamic altering systems, structures.
- 22:27Anders Christensson: The structure is altering If you see on the flock, or it's warm or whatever.
- 22:32Anders Christensson: They are altering in structures forever.
- 22:37Anders Christensson: And also, when it comes to chaotic system, they will smoothly, not knowing, run over the edge and take another state.
- 22:52Anders Christensson: That is completely different, which is very much sketched by Loren Cobb's the Cusp theory, which is the butterfly, the butterfly phenomena.
- 23:09Anders Christensson: But all those three systems has to meet Ashba's requisite variety at all levels, and Janir Bariam in US has stated that this has to be met on each decision level.
- 23:33Anders Christensson: Which means that here we can be start in very abstract terms.
- 23:41Anders Christensson: But you have to meet the requisite variety.
- 23:45Anders Christensson: You go down one decision level and that also has to be met by requisite variety.
- 23:56Anders Christensson: Now it's very difficult to calculate complicated systems versus complex systems.
- 24:10Anders Christensson: But if you I mean here I have to do an anecdote, if we were about to rewind the last 15 minutes we will never end up in the same process flow.
- 24:32Anders Christensson: So reality is not taking the same path over and over and over again, that is, it's not on the map.
- 24:47Anders Christensson: So we have to have a notational system that reflects sufficiently your outer system and that when you come into modeling and simulation, you have agent-based simulation, you have fuzzy sets, you have all those beautiful mathematical tools that you actually can mimic some sort of possibility tunnel over time.
- 25:20Anders Christensson: So if you're keeping yourself within that capability or the effect tunnel, you can actually simulate your own possibilities as well as your adversaries.
- 25:40Anders Christensson: I mean, he can't walk to the moon from here and up, he has to have a rocket, he has to have all sorts of beautiful things to move up to.
- 25:54Anders Christensson: So you're bounded by rules, right, and those rules, yes.
- 26:00Ponch Rivera: So these are things that are like counterfactual.
- 26:03Ponch Rivera: There's things that we can do and things we cannot do, and the enemy and our opponent, or however you want to look at, is the same thing.
- 26:09Ponch Rivera: And that understanding if I hear you correctly that simulation, that modeling, if you can model that, which is not a landscape like we think about when we drive our cars, but it's a mind and time space landscape, absolutely, if you can model that and I think this is really important because we've been doing a lot of work in this lately this is where leaders need to spend their time in understanding Absolutely.
- 26:31Anders Christensson: Okay, absolutely, I mean Joint Chief Staff said for some months ago, we will have.
- 26:41Anders Christensson: We are in deep problems when it comes to say, okay, if we're going to defend Taiwan, all simulation packages are showing that we're losing, so how are we going to meet this?
- 27:00Anders Christensson: So, essentially what you're saying we have to take much, we have to study much more time on the possibility space that we can do.
- 27:11Anders Christensson: Yeah.
- 27:14Ponch Rivera: So do you need a simulation or can this be done manually with just like a tabletop exercise?
- 27:20Anders Christensson: No, because of the complexity.
- 27:22Anders Christensson: It's difficult for a human brain to calculate all the processes that individuals are going on and producing in interactions.
- 27:34Anders Christensson: So you have to have it in some sort of simulation, computer-based simulation, and that was actually done during the MNE4 at Virginia.
- 27:49Anders Christensson: So it came from us, so it was there where we tested it and that was 2006.
- 27:59Ponch Rivera: So is there a danger with this, though that's what I'm concerned about.
- 28:02Ponch Rivera: So what I understand about complex systems is we really can't model them and we get into systems of system snaking, and I know NPS Naval Postgraduate School is looking at these, trying to take $180 million and simulate what's going on around us.
- 28:14Ponch Rivera: If my understanding is correct and I may be wrong on this we can't really.
- 28:18Ponch Rivera: The map is not the terrain.
- 28:20Ponch Rivera: We cannot map an external system.
- 28:21Ponch Rivera: Any effort to do that is and you go back to John Boyd it's gonna change the system.
- 28:28Ponch Rivera: What I'm hearing from you is there are people that believe we can map an external or our system.
- 28:34Ponch Rivera: Is that correct?
- 28:35Anders Christensson: I believe so.
- 28:36Anders Christensson: I believe so strongly Because you just need sufficient mimic to the reality, not everything.
- 28:48Anders Christensson: And of course you have to be critical.
- 28:54Anders Christensson: You have to live with your adversary all the time when you're producing a model and then come to counter-motivated.
- 29:07Anders Christensson: So there you have the struggle, which has to be very vivid.
- 29:17Ponch Rivera: Right.
- 29:18Ponch Rivera: So we talk about mapping, I hate to say using a mapping.
- 29:21Ponch Rivera: You call it a mental model, a map, you can call it a digital twin.
- 29:24Ponch Rivera: This is important to understand the external environment.
- 29:27Ponch Rivera: So we have to take the different perspectives of our human system to understand what's going on the outside.
- 29:33Ponch Rivera: The danger I see with that is and I'm gonna use an analogy here when you look at your phone to see what the weather is outside and you see that it says it's sunny.
- 29:45Ponch Rivera: You walk outside and it says it's rainy, it's raining.
- 29:48Ponch Rivera: Which one's right?
- 29:51Ponch Rivera: This one?
- 29:52Ponch Rivera: The reality to me is on the outside, but we can get the reality is always right.
- 29:58Ponch Rivera: Right, so we got.
- 29:59Ponch Rivera: And that's a danger with this.
- 30:00Ponch Rivera: We don't want people to get fixated on the simulation, we want them looking outside.
- 30:03Ponch Rivera: No no, no, it's a tool.
- 30:06Anders Christensson: It's a tool Mobility, simulation, gaming and evolving is tools.
- 30:13Mark McGrath: And you did use the word sufficient.
- 30:14Mark McGrath: It suffices, it doesn't have to be precise.
- 30:19Mark McGrath: As Boyd would draw out the OODA loop, he would say this is an illustrative abstraction, it's not a precise measure of Right, right.
- 30:30Mark McGrath: So let me ask you this, because I see this when people explain and describe OODA loop, or I see this even with command control systems People are so hell bent on identifying exact precision to that reality that they would go back to you can't.
- 30:45Mark McGrath: Yeah, you can't.
- 30:45Mark McGrath: So they would go to Pontius's example to say, well, the weather said this, but it's doing it outside.
- 30:49Mark McGrath: Now I'm completely confused and I'm derailed.
- 30:51Mark McGrath: What you're saying is, if I hear you correctly and correct me if I'm wrong what you're saying is models and maps and systems have to be sufficient enough that empower the human cognition and we learn as we go, that we continue to adapt and develop.
- 31:04Mark McGrath: Is that correct?
- 31:04Mark McGrath: Absolutely absolutely.
- 31:07Anders Christensson: I mean, if you're looking at the phone on its sunny outside, when you come out it's raining, but one thing is that the temperature is almost nice.
- 31:21Anders Christensson: So there you have one system state that you can rely on.
- 31:29Anders Christensson: It's just to allude to your example Don't take me on that.
- 31:38Ponch Rivera: So to say, so, anders, you've been working with a lot of NATO folks over the last several many years and I wanna ask what's preventing them from understanding and I'm not saying we understand this completely, but we're all students of this, so I'm talking about our discussion, we had up to this point what's preventing leaders to understand this type of thinking?
- 32:00Ponch Rivera: How do we look at the external environment?
- 32:05Anders Christensson: I would say it's coming down to the words command and control.
- 32:09Anders Christensson: Command is stating your will I want to see this done and control is downwards up and they have to meet.
- 32:27Anders Christensson: So NATO folks are either talking about command or they are talking about control, Not in the same that they have to meet each other.
- 32:43Anders Christensson: So the induction, the intel guys, has to be better to describe in notations that you can actually simulate your operational environment.
- 33:05Anders Christensson: So the commanders can what if I have this target or this goal?
- 33:13Anders Christensson: What happens then?
- 33:15Anders Christensson: And between these two, when they meet, they source out or they calculate or they visualize the possibility space.
- 33:25Anders Christensson: So again, you have to be critical.
- 33:32Anders Christensson: It's many dimensions on this one, the commanding stuff, but it also many dimensions in the infraration, in induction process that the intel has to do.
- 33:48Anders Christensson: And it's lucky that the intelligence, and it's lucky that we now can see that artificial intelligence is actually extracting text to also loop diagrams where you can see enforcing or balancing loops within the environment.
- 34:20Ponch Rivera: And this goes back to an earlier point that our commanding control system is observable.
- 34:23Ponch Rivera: We can see, okay.
- 34:26Ponch Rivera: So we talk about this a lot.
- 34:28Ponch Rivera: We say that teamwork is observable, therefore I can measure it, but I gotta know what teamwork actually looks like.
- 34:34Ponch Rivera: And the same may be true in what are you looking for with artificial intelligence within a commanding control system?
- 34:40Ponch Rivera: What can be fleshed out of that system and be usable by AI?
- 34:46Ponch Rivera: And I wanna go back to the Kinevan framework too, which is, hey, that complex world where we can only understand things in retrospect may not be a good place to put I may be wrong on this put artificial intelligence.
- 34:59Ponch Rivera: That may be a space where we want humans to operate, because humans have going back to flocking and things like that, the dynamic systems.
- 35:06Ponch Rivera: Humans are pretty good at detecting weak signals.
- 35:12Anders Christensson: Absolutely.
- 35:13Ponch Rivera: Okay, so is this the same approach that you're trying to take?
- 35:16Anders Christensson: with this commanding Again, modeling and simulation, ai and all that beautiful tools.
- 35:24Anders Christensson: They are artifacts and you can always reason or contradict what you are stating and you have to have a vivid discussion in the staff so they actually can pinpoint down and highlight those weak signals.
- 35:53Anders Christensson: Often there are devils in the detail is the weak signals, I would say.
- 36:13Mark McGrath: And at no point are you ever in your proposition.
- 36:17Mark McGrath: You never violate that order.
- 36:18Mark McGrath: That Boyd says people ideas, things.
- 36:21Mark McGrath: It always goes in that order Ideas and things serve people.
- 36:25Anders Christensson: Well, when it comes to behavioral signs, I'm not fighting those guys because they are thinking right, because they have studied people and they have seen that there are things, that there are coming good things out of it.
- 36:44Anders Christensson: But you have to frame those guys with the purpose design criteria, which is observability and steribility or, as Celiax says, reachability.
- 37:03Anders Christensson: You have to reach, have the ability to reach your state, otherwise you won't be able to do anything.
- 37:14Anders Christensson: You have to sufficiently reach your state.
- 37:20Mark McGrath: And you can't do that by looking inward alone.
- 37:23Mark McGrath: And Boyd admonished in organic design for Kareana Control.
- 37:27Mark McGrath: He said that any command control system that forces his adherence to look inward is going to disintegrate.
- 37:35Mark McGrath: It's going to become unglued.
- 37:37Mark McGrath: What you're suggesting is you have to look out both ways, both ways yeah.
- 37:42Anders Christensson: Both ways.
- 37:42Anders Christensson: It's Janus head, janus looks in and out.
- 37:49Anders Christensson: You can actually, if you take the classical do the loop or the order loop, the observe, orient, decision and act and make a control circuit of it.
- 38:07Anders Christensson: You can actually build a transfer function from your steering to the response.
- 38:20Anders Christensson: And if you look at that equation you'll see that if and you try that what happens?
- 38:30Anders Christensson: If the now under the line is zero, what happens Then?
- 38:36Anders Christensson: You can explain all sorts of what happens in the outer world and your system because of its zero.
- 38:47Ponch Rivera: Yeah, andrews, I'm hearing this from you.
- 38:51Ponch Rivera: My expectations of this conversation were to look at Boyd and kind of rip it apart.
- 38:56Ponch Rivera: What has worked anyway.
- 38:58Ponch Rivera: What I'm hearing from you is the opposite, and that is there is value in what John Boyd provided to us.
- 39:05Ponch Rivera: Plenty of value.
- 39:06Anders Christensson: But on the process and form.
- 39:08Anders Christensson: Level four and five, and they are framed by the level one, two and three.
- 39:19Ponch Rivera: Okay, and I'll have to go through that model again.
- 39:23Ponch Rivera: Level one, just remind the audience.
- 39:27Anders Christensson: And purpose.
- 39:28Anders Christensson: You produce a direction and how to reach that direction.
- 39:34Anders Christensson: That's the purpose of command and control.
- 39:39Anders Christensson: Now the criteria design criteria is that you have to have it.
- 39:44Anders Christensson: You have to have the external system, the outer system, observability you have sufficient state vectors, tensors or whatever variables that are actually mimicking what's going on outside there.
- 40:04Anders Christensson: And, as Ashby says, the steering, the inner system has to meet those criteria, those variables, so you actually can manipulate towards an end state.
- 40:23Anders Christensson: And number three, the functions.
- 40:27Anders Christensson: The abstract functions of data collection, presented for orientation, where you actually pick out which are the essential states for our mission.
- 40:46Ponch Rivera: Right.
- 40:49Anders Christensson: And then you go further and say okay, how should I do this?
- 40:53Anders Christensson: Yes, that's the planning.
- 40:57Ponch Rivera: Yep, that's a counterfactual or plan.
- 40:58Ponch Rivera: Yes, Right.
- 40:59Ponch Rivera: Yeah, so what I'm hearing from you is we're learning a lot about the same things from the neuroscience community.
- 41:07Ponch Rivera: The free energy principle we talked about that on the show, everything you walk through just is the same thing we're hearing from them.
- 41:13Ponch Rivera: In my opinion, I may be off on this, but the observation is that sensing capability it's sending that new information, that information that is surprising, because our brains want to minimize surprise.
- 41:26Ponch Rivera: We don't want all the information coming into us.
- 41:28Ponch Rivera: We always want the difference between what we expect and what's actually coming in.
- 41:32Ponch Rivera: The counterfactuals, or that planning or that prediction.
- 41:35Ponch Rivera: That's an internal thing to the internal system that's making a prediction about.
- 41:39Ponch Rivera: Let's do this and run it through our system to see what happens before we act on it.
- 41:43Ponch Rivera: So that's a simulation, right, and this might be related to Gary Klein's work too with RPD.
- 41:48Ponch Rivera: Absolutely.
- 41:50Mark McGrath: Okay.
- 41:51Ponch Rivera: So there's a and I love this conversation.
- 41:53Ponch Rivera: So many things were pulling from and we have to apologize to our listeners because there is so many references in this and this is kind of like a synthesis of what we've been talking about.
- 42:06Ponch Rivera: You hit on so many things today, from quantum physics to biology and anthropology.
- 42:16Anders Christensson: Yeah, this has been awesome.
- 42:17Anders Christensson: It's why the science of command and control is cybernetics.
- 42:23Anders Christensson: That's the host area.
- 42:29Anders Christensson: I would say it's cybernetics.
- 42:33Ponch Rivera: And as we start to and this is important for us, as we start to, we're generalists, right, we're not specialists by any means, but we're bringing all this together on this podcast to go hey, look, when you're talking about artificial intelligence, go look at how different modalities of prayer or meditation, or even psychedelic assisted therapies help you mitigate your past experiences, right, that trauma, that PTSD and all that.
- 43:00Ponch Rivera: There's a connection there.
- 43:00Ponch Rivera: Or take a look at the connection between those things and agility in an organization and resilience in an organization.
- 43:08Anders Christensson: And that's why this is so Agility.
- 43:09Anders Christensson: For me, agility is that you actually have a quick turnaround in your dynamic decision.
- 43:18Anders Christensson: You see weak signals in the outer system and you source out and try to what are we going to meet this with?
- 43:31Anders Christensson: That's an agile system for me.
- 43:36Ponch Rivera: Yeah, so you have tempo and time there, or speed, right.
- 43:38Ponch Rivera: You have the how are we observing the external environment and how fast can we respond to something we see in it?
- 43:44Ponch Rivera: Right, and I think is that kind of aligned to what you said about agility.
- 43:48Ponch Rivera: Right right, right, right.
- 43:49Ponch Rivera: I like that line of thinking.
- 43:51Ponch Rivera: It's not when we're probing in a complex environment.
- 43:56Ponch Rivera: We're running multiple safe-to-fail tests, or probes, if we will, to find out where we get repeatability so we can amplify it or dampen it right.
- 44:03Ponch Rivera: So we want to move faster and that's what we're trying to do with improving an oodaloupe in a complex domain.
- 44:10Anders Christensson: Absolutely.
- 44:12Ponch Rivera: Okay, yeah, this is great.
- 44:13Ponch Rivera: I love this.
- 44:13Ponch Rivera: And I'm sorry if you're losing or Because you have Go ahead.
- 44:18Anders Christensson: You have to be aware of that.
- 44:19Anders Christensson: You can outmaneuver.
- 44:21Anders Christensson: You have a higher pace around all this than the adversary.
- 44:27Anders Christensson: And now we're getting the tool AI, which is shrinking the time of modeling tremendously, so you actually can pinpoint down faster what is the sufficient reachability and how am I going to meet this?
- 44:52Ponch Rivera: Here's another question what happens to organizations leaders that don't embrace this type of thinking?
- 44:57Ponch Rivera: What's going?
- 44:58Anders Christensson: to happen.
- 44:58Anders Christensson: I think they will be outmaneuvered.
- 45:01Anders Christensson: They are going to ask what's happening.
- 45:06Anders Christensson: They are not doing the action Guys that are actually in for this fast pace.
- 45:18Anders Christensson: They are dominating the environment.
- 45:22Anders Christensson: But the other guys that are not with you, they are going constantly asking what's going on.
- 45:30Anders Christensson: What's going on?
- 45:31Anders Christensson: Fill me in, Fill me in.
- 45:36Mark McGrath: So when you say fast pace, it's not merely fast on its own, it's at a faster pace, deliberate action with continuous learning and adaptation.
- 45:46Mark McGrath: Absolutely, Absolutely, absolutely.
- 45:50Mark McGrath: Yeah, that's the perfect word for it.
- 45:54Anders Christensson: I mean, if you're faster than the adversary, you win.
- 46:00Ponch Rivera: With higher quality.
- 46:02Mark McGrath: Yes, Of course Of course.
- 46:03Anders Christensson: All right.
- 46:05Ponch Rivera: Andrew, this has been an absolutely fascinating conversation.
- 46:07Ponch Rivera: I just want to thank you for your time today.
- 46:09Ponch Rivera: We look to have you back on the show.
- 46:11Ponch Rivera: I mean, again, I want to set the stage for everybody.
- 46:15Ponch Rivera: I thought we were going to attack John Boyd here, but I think we all agree there's value in it and we can continue the work by taking a look around and what's happening with the advances in technology, lessons from biology, complexity theory and making that Oodle-loop better, Absolutely.
- 46:37Anders Christensson: Absolutely.
- 46:40Ponch Rivera: Mark, do you have any last minute thoughts for Andrew today?
- 46:45Mark McGrath: No, I think that Andrew has said multiple times absolutely.
- 46:49Mark McGrath: I mean, this is absolutely why we have our business and this is absolutely why we have this podcast.
- 46:54Mark McGrath: It's building and developing and advancing these ideas because it was left open intentionally with a tremendous foundation to go in different directions.
- 47:01Mark McGrath: It's, you know, punch you use the term generalist.
- 47:03Mark McGrath: This tolls from every angle and I think the imperative thing for those that are listening is that your systems, that you have to command and control your sports team, your company, whatever it is, if they're only looking inward, your competitors are out there, they're going to identify that quickly and they're going to be able to strike and outmaneuve you, as you say.
- 47:27Ponch Rivera: Well, we want to thank Andrews for being on our show today.
- 47:29Ponch Rivera: Thanks for taking time in your late afternoon to be with us.
- 47:32Ponch Rivera: Again, we want to have you back on the show Maybe middle of next year to look back and see where we are with AI, because I think that's going to be a bigger thing.
- 47:41Ponch Rivera: Absolutely, but I do want to turn it over to you, Andrews.
- 47:43Ponch Rivera: Is there anything you want our listeners to know about your work, what you're doing and how they contact you?
- 47:50Anders Christensson: Well, you have my email and we're working on two things, and the first one is this plan, which is the command stuff, and I am working to use AI to actually reach sufficient reachability so they can work together, these two, and define some sort of possibility space that you can maneuver in.
- 48:26Anders Christensson: If you want to read about the possibility space, I urge you to read Gibson.
- 48:37Anders Christensson: He is a fine guy that explains psychology for this.
- 48:45Ponch Rivera: And that's affordances, correct.
- 48:47Anders Christensson: Yes.
- 48:48Ponch Rivera: Right, yeah, and we're doing a lot of mind time space mapping with affordances, so I love it.
- 48:54Ponch Rivera: This is great.
- 48:55Ponch Rivera: Yeah, all right, andrews.
- 48:57Ponch Rivera: Hey, thank you so much for being on the show, being on no Way Out Again.
- 49:00Ponch Rivera: We'll invite you back on in the middle of next year and I just want to thank you again, please.
- 49:05Anders Christensson: Absolutely, it has been.
- 49:06Anders Christensson: Thank you, andrews.