Latest / Bloomberg Law / Lawsuits Over Baltimore Bridge Collapse & South Carolina's Map
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law, with June Brusso from Bloomberg.
- 0:07Speaker 2: Radio Cruiser undertaking the complicated work of removing mangled steel
- 0:14Speaker 2: and concrete at the site of the deadly collapse of
- 0:17Speaker 2: Baltimore's Francis Scott Key Bridge after a container ship lost
- 0:22Speaker 2: power and crashed into a supporting column, killing six workers
- 0:27Speaker 2: and throwing the Eastern US transportation network into chaos. Officials
- 0:32Speaker 2: say that in those murky waters, divers can't see a
- 0:35Speaker 2: foot in front of them, and with all that mangled,
- 0:39Speaker 2: intertwined steel above and below the water, the site is
- 0:43Speaker 2: a safety risk. Here's Marylyn, Governor Wes Moore.
- 0:47Speaker 3: You're looking at three four thousand tons of steel that's
- 0:50Speaker 3: sitting on top of the ship, and so beginning to
- 0:53Speaker 3: in sections be able to create that pathway, create open
- 0:56Speaker 3: channels so we can actually get boats, get tugs inside
- 1:00Speaker 3: the area.
- 1:01Speaker 2: And two channels have been opened near the side of
- 1:04Speaker 2: the collapse bridge to make way for smaller vessels and
- 1:08Speaker 2: as the crews continue to work. The owner of the
- 1:11Speaker 2: ship filed a lawsuit on Monday, denying responsibility for the
- 1:15Speaker 2: collapse and trying to limit its legal liability to forty
- 1:19Speaker 2: three point seven million dollars the current value of the
- 1:22Speaker 2: ship and its cargo, in a case that credit rating
- 1:26Speaker 2: agency Morning Star DBRs predicts could become the most expensive
- 1:31Speaker 2: marine insured laws in history. Joining me is Michael Stirley,
- 1:35Speaker 2: a maritime law expert at the University of Texas at
- 1:38Speaker 2: Austin School of Law. Michael, who do you anticipate will
- 1:41Speaker 2: be filing lawsuits here?
- 1:44Speaker 4: The short answer is, anybody who did something wrong is
- 1:47Speaker 4: likely to be sued here, or anybody who can plausibly
- 1:50Speaker 4: be claimed to have done something wrong is likely to
- 1:52Speaker 4: be sued here.
- 1:54Speaker 2: So of course the victims and the families of the
- 1:57Speaker 2: victims are going to sue. But what about the state
- 2:01Speaker 2: or county or whoever for the cost of rebuilding the bridge,
- 2:05Speaker 2: which could cost experts say four hundred million dollars or more.
- 2:10Speaker 4: Oh, I'd be surprised if get that small, but I
- 2:12Speaker 4: read recently that the inflation adjusted value of the original
- 2:15Speaker 4: construction was roughly twice that. I mean, broadly speaking, you'd
- 2:19Speaker 4: see claims coming from three main points. You have the
- 2:23Speaker 4: property damage claims. Anybody whose property was damaged as a
- 2:27Speaker 4: result of this accident. Most obviously that's going to be
- 2:30Speaker 4: the owner of the bridge, which understands the state of Maryland,
- 2:32Speaker 4: so they will certainly be doing The federal government has
- 2:36Speaker 4: indicated that it's going to be paying the rebuilding costs,
- 2:39Speaker 4: so they may have the subrogated claims, basically stepping into
- 2:42Speaker 4: the shoes of the state of Maryland saying we paid
- 2:45Speaker 4: reimburss Us for what we paid for your your damage.
- 2:49Speaker 4: They will probably be minor property damage claims. Whatever vehicles
- 2:54Speaker 4: ended up in the water, you know their owners will
- 2:56Speaker 4: have property damage claims and relatively mine on the scheme
- 2:58Speaker 4: of things. Then the second brought category you have as
- 3:00Speaker 4: the personal injury claims. There were at least two workers
- 3:03Speaker 4: who went into the water who survived, and then you
- 3:06Speaker 4: had the six workers who went into the water tragically
- 3:09Speaker 4: did not survive, So the be wrongful death claims from
- 3:13Speaker 4: the families of the decedents and that it was only
- 3:16Speaker 4: be personal injury claims from the two people who survived.
- 3:20Speaker 4: There may be other people who claim negligent fiction of
- 3:23Speaker 4: emotional distress who were in the zone of danger and
- 3:27Speaker 4: suffered mental harm. Broadcasts of personal jury claimants. Typically these
- 3:32Speaker 4: disasters tend to attract what are called economic laws claimant,
- 3:36Speaker 4: people whose claims they suffered economic loss as a result
- 3:39Speaker 4: of this disaster. Typically, those claims do not succeed unless
- 3:44Speaker 4: the person also suffered some physical injury property damage. So,
- 3:47Speaker 4: for example, this stake to recover for the economic loss
- 3:51Speaker 4: and not collecting bridge tolls for the next however many
- 3:54Speaker 4: years it takes to rebuild the bridge. Because they suffered
- 3:57Speaker 4: property damage, they can also recover for their econom I'm across,
- 4:01Speaker 4: but if you have businesses to say I'm getting less
- 4:05Speaker 4: business because people can't cross the bridge to get to
- 4:07Speaker 4: my business, you know they're going somewhere else because now
- 4:09Speaker 4: they're going through the tunnel. But they didn't suffer any damage,
- 4:12Speaker 4: any physical damage. Those claims are typically dismissed in the
- 4:15Speaker 4: maritime law. How many people will be in those three categories,
- 4:19Speaker 4: I don't have enough information, but the ape workers and
- 4:22Speaker 4: the bridge owner are certainly going to be obvious claims.
- 4:26Speaker 4: It looks like those woill be the big money amounts.
- 4:30Speaker 2: So the owner of the ship is trying to limit
- 4:32Speaker 2: liability to about forty two point seven million dollars and
- 4:37Speaker 2: they claim that the collapse of the bridge was not
- 4:39Speaker 2: due to any fault, neglect, or want of care of
- 4:41Speaker 2: the companies, and they shouldn't be held liable first of all,
- 4:45Speaker 2: and if they are held liable, then they shouldn't be
- 4:47Speaker 2: for more than the current value of the ship and cargo.
- 4:50Speaker 2: This is a common move by ship owners after catastrophic crashes.
- 4:54Speaker 2: Isn't it tell us about that skewer? I'd say obscure
- 4:57Speaker 2: for most of US law from eighteen fifty one that
- 5:00Speaker 2: involves the Titanic.
- 5:01Speaker 4: Well, I mean eighteen fifty one was obviously what sixty
- 5:05Speaker 4: some years before the Titanic, although the law was famously
- 5:08Speaker 4: invoked in the Titanic case. So Congress passed the statute
- 5:11Speaker 4: in eighteen fifty one designed to encourage investment in shipping.
- 5:16Speaker 4: Middle of the nineteenth century was before the era when
- 5:19Speaker 4: the corporate form became common, so it was designed for
- 5:23Speaker 4: an era when individuals and partnerships generally owned vessels, and
- 5:28Speaker 4: the idea was that if an individual risked all of
- 5:32Speaker 4: their assets by investing in the ship, that made it
- 5:35Speaker 4: a less appealing investment. I mean, you could imagine today
- 5:38Speaker 4: that if all of the shareholders of BP had to
- 5:41Speaker 4: chip in to pay for the cost of the BP
- 5:43Speaker 4: oil spill and the golf, that would make people less
- 5:47Speaker 4: willing to invest in companies that base those kinds of risks.
- 5:50Speaker 4: Now the corporate form obviously takes away that risk. You know,
- 5:53Speaker 4: if you buy shares in BP, the value of your
- 5:56Speaker 4: share is at risk. But worst case scenario is your
- 6:00Speaker 4: share value goes down to nothing. You know, the company
- 6:03Speaker 4: goes into liquidation. But the rest of your assets are
- 6:06Speaker 4: not subject to those cranes. And what the eighteen fifty
- 6:09Speaker 4: one Limitation Act essentially does is treat every ship as
- 6:13Speaker 4: though it were an individual corporation. So if you can imagine,
- 6:17Speaker 4: you know, suppose that this shipowner, instead of owning this
- 6:20Speaker 4: ship and other assets as well, owned nothing but the ship,
- 6:24Speaker 4: and then the ship is in a terrible accident, takes
- 6:27Speaker 4: out a bridge, facing massive lawsuits. If the ship were
- 6:30Speaker 4: in fact a single corporation, the corporation with clear bankruptcy
- 6:35Speaker 4: say that our only asset is the ship. You know,
- 6:38Speaker 4: total value, you know, forty million dollars. Liquidate the corporation,
- 6:42Speaker 4: take our assets and distribute them pro rat among the claimants.
- 6:45Speaker 4: Shareholders lose the value of their investment, but that's the
- 6:48Speaker 4: extent of it. Essentially, what the Limitation Act does is
- 6:52Speaker 4: the same thing. It says, even though the shipowner owns
- 6:56Speaker 4: other assets. It will be allowed to limit its liability
- 6:59Speaker 4: under circumstances to the value of the asset involved in
- 7:04Speaker 4: the accident. Now, as you say this is very common,
- 7:08Speaker 4: I've previously predicted that the chances of a limitation action
- 7:11Speaker 4: being filed here were somewhere north of ninety nine point
- 7:14Speaker 4: nine nine percent. It didn't take long for that prediction
- 7:17Speaker 4: to be to be justified. Chippotas routinely do this, and
- 7:21Speaker 4: they routinely do it even in circumstances where they know
- 7:24Speaker 4: they don't qualify for limitation. You know, if you look
- 7:27Speaker 4: at the look at the BP oil spill again, you
- 7:30Speaker 4: know Transotion was the owner of the vessel there. They
- 7:32Speaker 4: filed a limitation petition. The district court held they were
- 7:35Speaker 4: not taught to limit their liability, but Transition still got
- 7:39Speaker 4: a major benefit out of doing that. You look at
- 7:41Speaker 4: the Alfarro disaster, the Bestlona there filed a limitation proceeding. Again,
- 7:46Speaker 4: they were held not entitled limitation, but they still got
- 7:49Speaker 4: a benefit. What the limitation action does is centralize all
- 7:54Speaker 4: the litigation in one court. Now Here, we've got the
- 7:58Speaker 4: bridge owner a personally claimants that we've got at least
- 8:02Speaker 4: nine obvious claimants, but for the limitation proceeding, they could
- 8:07Speaker 4: possibly file in nine different courts, and very likely they
- 8:12Speaker 4: might be filing in the state court. You know, the
- 8:14Speaker 4: state of Maryland may well prefer to sue in its
- 8:16Speaker 4: own courts rather than going to federal court. Personal linjay
- 8:19Speaker 4: lawyers often prefer state court over federal court, and depending
- 8:23Speaker 4: on where the eight workers live, they may file in
- 8:26Speaker 4: eight different state courts. So the vessel owner would be
- 8:29Speaker 4: in the position of having to defend you nine different suits,
- 8:33Speaker 4: but all arising out of the same incident, all involving
- 8:35Speaker 4: the same facts in nine different forms, and having to
- 8:40Speaker 4: go through everything nine different times, and having the risk
- 8:43Speaker 4: of inconsistent results. By filing this petition, all of the
- 8:47Speaker 4: litigation is channeled into the federal District Court for the
- 8:50Speaker 4: District of Maryland. If you read the petition that inevitably
- 8:53Speaker 4: includes the boilet plate provision, asking the court to require
- 8:57Speaker 4: all claims to be filed in that court and enjoining
- 9:00Speaker 4: litigation anywhere else. So even if they don't get limitations,
- 9:04Speaker 4: the best of owner at least gets the benefit of,
- 9:07Speaker 4: at least for the time being, having everything in this
- 9:10Speaker 4: one court, and what's more, in one court sitting in admiralty,
- 9:13Speaker 4: which generally means no jury.
- 9:15Speaker 2: What would plaintiffs have to do in order to overcome
- 9:18Speaker 2: that liability limit? What do they have to show?
- 9:21Speaker 4: But they have to show basically that the owner was
- 9:23Speaker 4: at fault. You know, the statutory language is the falter
- 9:27Speaker 4: knowledge of the owner. I think there are several limitation
- 9:31Speaker 4: provisions in maritime law that use somewhat different language falter privity,
- 9:34Speaker 4: falter knowledge. I think falter knowledge is the language in
- 9:37Speaker 4: this statue. So they have to show that the owner
- 9:40Speaker 4: did something wrong. Now, what's a bit unusual. The counterintuitive
- 9:45Speaker 4: there is that they have to show the personal fault
- 9:49Speaker 4: of the owner. And of course the owner is a corporation.
- 9:51Speaker 4: The corporation acts only to its agents. But the way
- 9:54Speaker 4: the law has been developed, they have to show the
- 9:58Speaker 4: fault of basically se your management. They have to show
- 10:01Speaker 4: that shore side management is at fault here, not simply
- 10:05Speaker 4: that people onboard the vessel did something wrong.
- 10:08Speaker 2: What about mechanical failure.
- 10:10Speaker 4: Well, mechanical failure could be a late defect that the
- 10:13Speaker 4: owner is not it fought for, or it could be
- 10:16Speaker 4: the result of a failure to maintain the vessel properly,
- 10:19Speaker 4: which the owner, is it fault? For often when a
- 10:21Speaker 4: ship loses power, it's some problem with the bunker fuel. Now,
- 10:25Speaker 4: if it's a problem with the bunker fuel, the owner
- 10:27Speaker 4: is going to going to bring in the bunker fuel
- 10:29Speaker 4: supplier and say it's your fault that this happened. But
- 10:32Speaker 4: the claimants are certainly going to say to the owner,
- 10:35Speaker 4: you know, you should have taken better care to make
- 10:37Speaker 4: sure you got good bunker fuel, and then there'll be
- 10:39Speaker 4: a fight about whether or not the owner was responsible
- 10:41Speaker 4: for that.
- 10:42Speaker 2: Is it a difficult hurdle for plaintiffs to overcome this
- 10:46Speaker 2: liability limit.
- 10:48Speaker 4: Most limitation actions result in limitation not being granted. So
- 10:53Speaker 4: most limitations and vessel owners know this, they still file
- 10:56Speaker 4: the limitation claims to get the benefit of the concursis
- 10:59Speaker 4: to get the benefit of having all of the claims
- 11:01Speaker 4: filed in the same court. Even if they don't get limitation,
- 11:04Speaker 4: they still get a major benefit from the concursives. In
- 11:06Speaker 4: most cases, the court finds that the owner did something wrong,
- 11:11Speaker 4: they could have avoided the accident. The owner's management did
- 11:15Speaker 4: something wrong and therefore they're not entoitled in the liability.
- 11:18Speaker 4: Whether that happens here is going to depend on what
- 11:21Speaker 4: the facts are. I certainly don't know enough of the facts,
- 11:24Speaker 4: and I suspect nobody yet knows enough of the facts
- 11:27Speaker 4: to know how that's going to play out. But the
- 11:29Speaker 4: process will continue and the court will figure out whether
- 11:32Speaker 4: or not the owner did something wrong here.
- 11:34Speaker 2: Coming up next on the Bloomberg Lawn Show, I'll continue
- 11:37Speaker 2: this conversation with Michael Stirley of the University of Texas
- 11:41Speaker 2: at Austin's School of Law, and we'll talk about the
- 11:44Speaker 2: insurance coverage. I'm June Grosso and you're listening to Bloomberg.
- 11:51Speaker 2: Two channels with different damps have been opened near the
- 11:54Speaker 2: side of the collapse Francis Scott Keybridge in Baltimore Harbor
- 11:58Speaker 2: to make way for small vessels. During a briefing today,
- 12:02Speaker 2: authority said the weather was hindering the work. Brigadier General
- 12:06Speaker 2: John Lloyd said the divers are working in low visibility
- 12:09Speaker 2: and hazardous conditions on the bridge wreckage.
- 12:13Speaker 1: The same complexity and challenges, even more.
- 12:16Speaker 2: So, are below the water as well.
- 12:19Speaker 3: And I think that's what's going to make it such
- 12:21Speaker 3: a challenge in removing this wreckage.
- 12:23Speaker 1: It's not only what you see above the water, but
- 12:26Speaker 1: below the water.
- 12:27Speaker 2: As well. Transportation Secretary Pete Buddha Judge has said there's
- 12:31Speaker 2: no timeline for reopening the busy port of Baltimore because
- 12:35Speaker 2: of the complexity of the work.
- 12:37Speaker 1: It's not just that you have to remove the wreckage,
- 12:39Speaker 1: it's that you have to do it in a way
- 12:40Speaker 1: that doesn't cause portions of the bridge that are there
- 12:44Speaker 1: across the water to shift. They've been under a lot
- 12:47Speaker 1: of compression and tension. They could behave almost like a
- 12:50Speaker 1: spring if they are not expertly managed.
- 12:53Speaker 2: As the recovery continues and parts of the ship remain
- 12:56Speaker 2: stuck at the sign of the accident, the owner of
- 12:59Speaker 2: the ship that rammed into the bridge is seeking to
- 13:02Speaker 2: limit its liability for the accident. The company, Grace Ocean,
- 13:06Speaker 2: filed a lawsuit in federal court on Monday, claiming the
- 13:10Speaker 2: collapse of the bridge was not due to any fault, neglect,
- 13:14Speaker 2: or want of care, and that it shouldn't be held
- 13:16Speaker 2: liable for any loss or damage from the disaster. But
- 13:20Speaker 2: if it is held liable, it shouldn't be for more
- 13:23Speaker 2: than the current value of the ship and its cargo.
- 13:26Speaker 2: I've been talking to maritime law expert Michael Stirley of
- 13:29Speaker 2: the University of Texas at Austin School of Law. So
- 13:33Speaker 2: Bloomberg Intelligence reports that the ship alone has about three
- 13:37Speaker 2: billion dollars of reinsurance coverage just generally, does reinsurance kick in?
- 13:44Speaker 2: Does it cover the costs if the owner's suit for
- 13:47Speaker 2: limited liability fails?
- 13:49Speaker 4: Well, there are two kinds of insurance that are relevant here.
- 13:53Speaker 4: A number of news agencies have been reporting that the
- 13:55Speaker 4: ship had only I think it was ninety million dollars
- 13:57Speaker 4: of insurance. That's talking about its hullm machinery insurance, which
- 14:01Speaker 4: they're kind of properly insurance. That's the insurance that the
- 14:04Speaker 4: vessel owner has to reimburse it if the vessel is
- 14:08Speaker 4: lost or damage, and the vessel owner is citing that
- 14:11Speaker 4: in the limitation petition to show what the value of
- 14:14Speaker 4: the ship is, which is releatant limitation proceding. The insurance
- 14:17Speaker 4: that you're talking about is liability insurance, which is probably
- 14:21Speaker 4: the more important insurance here, and that's the insurance that
- 14:25Speaker 4: the vessel owner has to cover its liabilities if it's
- 14:28Speaker 4: not liable to a third party. And typically the case
- 14:31Speaker 4: like this, the vessel will be entered in what's known
- 14:33Speaker 4: as a P and I club, which is basically a
- 14:36Speaker 4: kind of mutual insurance company where the vessel owners get
- 14:38Speaker 4: together and pull their risks. I've read the news reports
- 14:42Speaker 4: that this vessel was entered with Britannia, one of the
- 14:44Speaker 4: major P and I clubs, and typically the vessel owner
- 14:47Speaker 4: will have a certain retention amount what most people would
- 14:50Speaker 4: think of it as a deductible, So the vesselan will
- 14:52Speaker 4: be responsible for the first some level I don't know
- 14:55Speaker 4: what the individually negotiated for each case, say the first
- 14:59Speaker 4: ten million dollars be the vessel owner's responsibility. Then the
- 15:01Speaker 4: P and I club will pick up the neck, you know,
- 15:03Speaker 4: whatever the club is arranged, and then beyond that you
- 15:06Speaker 4: go into reinsurance. There are about a dozen P and
- 15:09Speaker 4: I clubs in the world, the International Group of P
- 15:11Speaker 4: and I Clubs, and they pull the risk among themselves,
- 15:14Speaker 4: and then beyond that they go into reinsurance in the
- 15:16Speaker 4: secondary market. If the vessel owner is allowed to limit
- 15:20Speaker 4: its liability, then the vessel owner and it's P and
- 15:22Speaker 4: I club will be able to avoid taking advantage of that.
- 15:25Speaker 4: If they're not god of the limit liability, then you've
- 15:28Speaker 4: got a big insurance fund that's going to cover a
- 15:30Speaker 4: lot of the losses here one point to make those
- 15:32Speaker 4: The limitation, by its terms, permits the vessel owner to
- 15:36Speaker 4: limit its liability. That has been interpreted to allow both
- 15:40Speaker 4: the vessel owner and what's known as a bareboat charterer
- 15:43Speaker 4: to limit liability. A bareboat charter is someone who doesn't
- 15:47Speaker 4: actually own the vessel, but operates as though they were
- 15:49Speaker 4: the owner. Sometimes throwing some Latin here called them the
- 15:53Speaker 4: owner pro hot Beechey. I mean, if you think about
- 15:55Speaker 4: it in a more familiar consumer context. You know, if
- 15:58Speaker 4: you buy a car, obviously it's your car, you know
- 16:00Speaker 4: you own it. But if you lease your car, so
- 16:03Speaker 4: you get a three year lease, technically you don't own
- 16:05Speaker 4: the car, but you act like you own the car.
- 16:08Speaker 4: It's for all intents and purposes, you are operating it
- 16:10Speaker 4: as though you own the car. That's essentially what a
- 16:12Speaker 4: bareboat charter is that you have leased the vessel for
- 16:16Speaker 4: a fixed time period, but you operate it. You do
- 16:19Speaker 4: all of the you know, you hire the crew, you
- 16:21Speaker 4: arrange provisions, you make all the decisions, you run up
- 16:24Speaker 4: like you own it. So the Limitation Act protects the
- 16:26Speaker 4: owner and that bareboat charterer. This limitation petition claims limitations
- 16:32Speaker 4: on behalf of both the owner and the vessel manager.
- 16:36Speaker 4: I will be very curious to see whether the court
- 16:39Speaker 4: allows the vessel manager to lim a liability that's not
- 16:42Speaker 4: an obvious obvious beneficiary is a limitation Act. It's interesting
- 16:46Speaker 4: to see how that plays out.
- 16:47Speaker 2: Until I started doing research, I didn't realize how many
- 16:50Speaker 2: maritime accidents there have been in recent years. A dive
- 16:54Speaker 2: boat caught fire off the coast of southern California in
- 16:57Speaker 2: twenty nineteen and killed the thirty four pus. So the
- 17:01Speaker 2: litigation has not yet been resolved there. So are we
- 17:04Speaker 2: anticipating this is going to take years and years and years.
- 17:08Speaker 4: I don't know how long it's going to take to
- 17:09Speaker 4: resolve the Conception Fire case, but yes, there is a
- 17:13Speaker 4: lot of litigation going on there. The Conception Fire actually
- 17:15Speaker 4: prompted Congress to amend the Limitation Act for one of
- 17:19Speaker 4: the very few times in its history. You know, the
- 17:21Speaker 4: statute was amended after the Titanic. For the most part,
- 17:25Speaker 4: it hasn't changed a whole lot since eighteen fifty one.
- 17:27Speaker 4: But in December twenty two, I think it was, Congress
- 17:32Speaker 4: had a very minor amendment to exclude what it called
- 17:36Speaker 4: covered small passenger vessels from the scope of the Limitation Act,
- 17:39Speaker 4: basically to say that the next time that a disaster
- 17:42Speaker 4: like the conception happens, the vessel owner can't claim the
- 17:45Speaker 4: benefit of limitation. So every once in a while Congress
- 17:48Speaker 4: does respond to very high profile accidents when the mandments
- 17:52Speaker 4: of the Limitation Act.
- 17:53Speaker 2: And so the case is involving this bridge collapse will
- 17:58Speaker 2: take years and years.
- 18:00Speaker 4: I would be surprised if this has resolved quickly, but
- 18:02Speaker 4: you never know. I mean, most cases in fact settle
- 18:05Speaker 4: so as we learn more about the accident, that the
- 18:07Speaker 4: parties learned more about the accident, If it becomes obvious
- 18:10Speaker 4: that the vessel owner did something wrong, and if it
- 18:12Speaker 4: fault and won't be allowed to limit liability, then a
- 18:14Speaker 4: settlement may happen more quickly. I wouldn't be surprised if
- 18:18Speaker 4: the personal injury claimant end up settling fairly quickly, even
- 18:22Speaker 4: if the litigation overpaying for the replacement of the bridge
- 18:24Speaker 4: goes on much longer. In the VP oil spill case,
- 18:27Speaker 4: for example, there were I think it's there are eleven
- 18:30Speaker 4: Transocean Workers employees who were killed in the accident. Those
- 18:33Speaker 4: cases settled very quickly, Transocean took care of its employees
- 18:36Speaker 4: that didn't need to go into extended litigation. You know,
- 18:40Speaker 4: the big fight was over who is going to pay
- 18:42Speaker 4: for the clean up costs, not the personal injury claims.
- 18:44Speaker 2: I have to say, this is a whole different legal
- 18:46Speaker 2: area for me. I appreciate your insights. That's Michael Sterley
- 18:51Speaker 2: of the University of Texas at Austin School of Law,
- 18:55Speaker 2: coming up next on the Bloomberg Law Show. This year's
- 18:58Speaker 2: congressional elections in South Carolina will be held under a
- 19:01Speaker 2: map that a panel of three judges head rule was
- 19:04Speaker 2: unconstitutional and discriminatory against black voters. Why because the Supreme
- 19:10Speaker 2: Court hasn't issued a decision in the case, despite the
- 19:13Speaker 2: fact that oral arguments took place back in October. In
- 19:17Speaker 2: other legal news today, Donald Trump has sued two co
- 19:21Speaker 2: founders of his newly public Trump Media and Technology Group,
- 19:25Speaker 2: claiming they set the company up improperly and shouldn't get
- 19:29Speaker 2: any stock in it. It's the latest legal skirmish over
- 19:32Speaker 2: who gets how much of the hot but flailing meme stock.
- 19:36Speaker 2: Trump alleges that the two violated an agreement about the
- 19:40Speaker 2: setup and don't deserve their eight point six percent stake,
- 19:44Speaker 2: currently valued at six hundred and six million dollars. The lawsuit,
- 19:49Speaker 2: which was filed on March twenty fourth in Florida State Court,
- 19:53Speaker 2: comes after the pair brought their own suit against the
- 19:56Speaker 2: former president in Delaware Chancery court over the they are
- 20:00Speaker 2: promised stake in the social media company. The legal fight
- 20:04Speaker 2: is playing out amid wild swings in shares of Trump Media,
- 20:09Speaker 2: which began trading last week after it merged with a
- 20:11Speaker 2: special purpose acquisition company known as a SPACK. The stock
- 20:15Speaker 2: dropped twenty one percent on Monday after Trump Media disclosed
- 20:19Speaker 2: in a securities filing a fifty eight million dollar loss
- 20:23Speaker 2: and a relative trickle of revenue for twenty twenty three,
- 20:26Speaker 2: and reiterated a warning that it needed the money from
- 20:29Speaker 2: the SPACK deal to keep operating. The judge in Delaware
- 20:33Speaker 2: said he was gobsmacked to learn of Trump's Florida suit,
- 20:37Speaker 2: which he filed instead of bringing counterclaims against the duo
- 20:41Speaker 2: in his Delaware courtroom. He also said he'd consider possible
- 20:45Speaker 2: sanctions against the former president in the Delaware case. I'm
- 20:49Speaker 2: June Grosso, and you're listening to Bloomberg. This year's congressional
- 20:54Speaker 2: elections in South Carolina will be held under a map
- 20:58Speaker 2: that a panel of federal judges found was unconstitutional and
- 21:02Speaker 2: discriminatory against black voters. The case is in the hands
- 21:05Speaker 2: of the Supreme Court, which heard oral arguments last October.
- 21:10Speaker 2: With no decision from the High Court, the failure of
- 21:13Speaker 2: Republican legislators to redraw the map, and time running out
- 21:16Speaker 2: ahead of voter deadlines, a federal court ruled that the
- 21:20Speaker 2: unconstitutional map will be used. Joining me is elections law
- 21:24Speaker 2: expert Richard Brefald, a professor at Columbia Law School. Rich
- 21:28Speaker 2: tell us about the history of this case.
- 21:30Speaker 5: Following the twenty twenty census, the Republican legislature of South
- 21:34Speaker 5: Carolina redistricted. It didn't need to change the number of seats,
- 21:36Speaker 5: but they moved them around in order to improve the
- 21:39Speaker 5: prospects for the Republican Actually its congress from Nancy Mace,
- 21:42Speaker 5: who represents the District one near Charleston, and what they
- 21:45Speaker 5: did is they basically made her district more Republican and
- 21:49Speaker 5: an adjacent district more democratic, and so doing they moved
- 21:52Speaker 5: a significant number of black voters from her district to
- 21:55Speaker 5: the adjacent district, District six. That led to a lawsuit
- 21:58Speaker 5: that this was a form of racial jerryman, that the
- 22:00Speaker 5: voters were being moved because of their race. That lawsuit
- 22:04Speaker 5: was brought and the plaintiffs won that case before a
- 22:07Speaker 5: free judge court in early twenty twenty three. The judge
- 22:10Speaker 5: director of the legislature's redistrict legislature has been resisting that
- 22:13Speaker 5: ever since and has taken appeals, and the case was
- 22:16Speaker 5: actually argued before the Supreme Court in October, six months ago.
- 22:19Speaker 5: Now Supreme Court had yet to rule on South Carolina's appeal.
- 22:23Speaker 5: Many thought that that would be decided much earlier, since
- 22:25Speaker 5: they heard the case fairly early in the term, with
- 22:28Speaker 5: the legislature not having redistricted in this case having been
- 22:31Speaker 5: sitting in the Supreme Court now for quite some time.
- 22:33Speaker 5: The three judge court basically decided it's too late. The
- 22:37Speaker 5: period for people filing to become candidates in the primary
- 22:40Speaker 5: had already opened. In fact, I think it's already closed
- 22:42Speaker 5: by now. There's soon going to be the deadline sometime
- 22:44Speaker 5: in April for sending out military and overseas ballots. And
- 22:48Speaker 5: the fort basically said, although the ideal would be to
- 22:51Speaker 5: go forth, because they did hold the current lines unlawful,
- 22:54Speaker 5: going back to the start of twenty twenty three, they said,
- 22:57Speaker 5: given the fact that the litigation hasn't been resolved the
- 23:00Speaker 5: Supreme Court, the legilature hasn't done anything yet, it's too
- 23:03Speaker 5: late for this year. So although we don't like it,
- 23:06Speaker 5: we are going to allow the elections to go forward
- 23:09Speaker 5: under the old rules that the Court had said we're
- 23:11Speaker 5: in constitutionalize as a racial cherry mander.
- 23:13Speaker 2: So the Court said they're going to now use the
- 23:16Speaker 2: maps that were declared unconstitutional. Is there anything else this
- 23:20Speaker 2: court could have done to avoid that?
- 23:23Speaker 5: Well, I guess they could have appointed a special master
- 23:26Speaker 5: and actually drawn the lines themselves. I think their feeling was,
- 23:30Speaker 5: you know, we will know eventually from the Supreme Court
- 23:33Speaker 5: whether these are good lines or not. And it is
- 23:35Speaker 5: beginning to get close to the election. And I think
- 23:37Speaker 5: the problem is the case began blending its way to
- 23:39Speaker 5: the Supreme Court about a year ago. They actually had
- 23:42Speaker 5: that oral argument, as I said, six months ago. It's
- 23:45Speaker 5: just taken a huge amount of time to move forward,
- 23:48Speaker 5: and no one really quite understands why it's been delayed
- 23:51Speaker 5: so long in the Supreme Court, especially since I think
- 23:53Speaker 5: many observers felt that South Carolina actually did reasonably well,
- 23:56Speaker 5: in the urga, it's hard to tell the Supreme Court
- 23:58Speaker 5: is going to affirm the lower court or not, And
- 24:00Speaker 5: in any event, the state has effectively won, at least
- 24:03Speaker 5: for this year. Even if the Supreme Court affirms, the
- 24:06Speaker 5: Court agrees that the lines are un constitutional, those lines
- 24:09Speaker 5: are going to be used for the twenty twenty four election.
- 24:11Speaker 2: Both the state and the civil rights groups who were
- 24:14Speaker 2: challenging the map had asked the Supreme Court to issue
- 24:18Speaker 2: a decision by January first, so they could prepare for
- 24:20Speaker 2: the upcoming elections. Is this the first time or have
- 24:23Speaker 2: there been other times when the Supreme Court has not
- 24:26Speaker 2: been acting particularly fast and has allowed maps that have
- 24:31Speaker 2: been declared unconstitutional to be used.
- 24:33Speaker 5: Well, I think that's what happened actually with the Alabama
- 24:36Speaker 5: at agation, where the Supreme Court stayed a lower court
- 24:39Speaker 5: decision holding a plan highlight Soavotian Rights Act. The Supreme
- 24:43Speaker 5: Court stayed that and then more than a year later,
- 24:46Speaker 5: finally actually decided the case and actually said that the
- 24:49Speaker 5: lower court had been correct. At that point, the map
- 24:52Speaker 5: was changed, but in the meantime an election had been
- 24:54Speaker 5: held under the map, which the lower court had felt
- 24:56Speaker 5: was illegal. But the Supreme Court had stayed for consider
- 25:00Speaker 5: period of time so that they could decide the case,
- 25:02Speaker 5: so that effectly the twenty twenty two election.
- 25:04Speaker 2: It just boggles the mind that in a case like
- 25:07Speaker 2: this they can't get a decision out. Although I mean,
- 25:11Speaker 2: the Supreme Court has been handing out decisions more slowly
- 25:14Speaker 2: as of late.
- 25:15Speaker 5: This does seem to have been one of the slowest years.
- 25:17Speaker 5: The people who keep track of this and have said
- 25:19Speaker 5: that they got off to the slowest start of any
- 25:22Speaker 5: year in a very long time, and they've still issued
- 25:24Speaker 5: relatively few opinions.
- 25:26Speaker 2: So we had the Alabama case where the Court came
- 25:29Speaker 2: out with a ruling that was favorable to the challengers,
- 25:33Speaker 2: but yet, as you say, in the oral arguments, it
- 25:35Speaker 2: seemed like it was going against the challengers in South Carolina.
- 25:40Speaker 2: Explain the difference between the two cases.
- 25:43Speaker 5: The issue in this case really has more to do
- 25:46Speaker 5: with how do you disentangle racial jerry mandering from partisan jerrymandering.
- 25:51Speaker 5: Kind of the central issue in this case is the
- 25:54Speaker 5: publican legislature in South Carolina is happy to say that
- 25:57Speaker 5: what they did was a partisan jerrymander because even the
- 26:00Speaker 5: Supreme Court's decision a few years ago. Partisan jerrymandering cannot
- 26:03Speaker 5: be challenged. It's non justiciable. It's not on constitutional, according
- 26:06Speaker 5: to the Supreme Court. But racial jerry mannering is, and
- 26:09Speaker 5: all fund the two were closely connected. If you're moving
- 26:11Speaker 5: a big block of black voters who happened to be Democrats,
- 26:14Speaker 5: or Democratic voters who happened to be black, there's a
- 26:16Speaker 5: debate as to what exactly the state is doing. The
- 26:18Speaker 5: Low Court here concluded that, based on a variety of factors,
- 26:21Speaker 5: it was better characterized as a racial gerry mander. The
- 26:24Speaker 5: issue in Alabama was differently complicated in that there the
- 26:28Speaker 5: state was using a basic configuration of how to draw
- 26:31Speaker 5: districts in the state that they've been using for some time.
- 26:33Speaker 5: They may just minor changes from one the census to
- 26:36Speaker 5: the next, but was not a conscious or an obvious
- 26:39Speaker 5: effort in the twenty twenty redistricting. But the plainters were
- 26:42Speaker 5: able to show that the district things structure that the
- 26:45Speaker 5: state had been using for several decades discriminated against black
- 26:48Speaker 5: voters because of the way the districts were drawn, and
- 26:51Speaker 5: although you couldn't show that the state intended to do this,
- 26:53Speaker 5: they were able to present alternative maps which were just
- 26:56Speaker 5: as straightforward, you know, no more convoluted, no more you know,
- 27:00Speaker 5: odd shapes than the map being used. We should provide
- 27:03Speaker 5: fair representation for black voters. So that case was very
- 27:06Speaker 5: much about what does fair representation require for minority voters?
- 27:11Speaker 5: And this case was really about whether or not the
- 27:12Speaker 5: discrimination going on here was racial or partisan.
- 27:16Speaker 2: So this ruling came a day after a different federal
- 27:19Speaker 2: court upheld a congressional map in Florida that favors Republicans
- 27:24Speaker 2: and raises a seat held by a black Democrat. Just
- 27:28Speaker 2: explain what happened there.
- 27:30Speaker 5: Again, I think it was a similar question of whether
- 27:32Speaker 5: or not this was race or party, and they concluded
- 27:34Speaker 5: it was party, and when it's party, it's you know,
- 27:37Speaker 5: this may sound really weird to people. First, the whole
- 27:40Speaker 5: idea of race versus party, that they're different and that
- 27:43Speaker 5: they can be disentangled, but that partisan gerry mandering can't
- 27:47Speaker 5: be challenged and racial gerry mandering can be. And so
- 27:50Speaker 5: much turns on how you're going to characterize what exactly happened.
- 27:54Speaker 5: And you know, those can be hard questions as to
- 27:56Speaker 5: whether or not it's racer party, even that they're often connected.
- 28:00Speaker 2: Often it seems like they're inextricable, but so Also on Thursday,
- 28:05Speaker 2: a federal appeals court issued a ruling that all but
- 28:08Speaker 2: insures North Carolina will use state legislative maps this fall
- 28:12Speaker 2: that have been challenged.
- 28:14Speaker 5: They basically again decided, following a lower court decision, that
- 28:18Speaker 5: they would not block the maps. Those were maps that
- 28:21Speaker 5: were adopted by the Republican legislature in the fall and
- 28:24Speaker 5: a Voting Rights Act claim was brought. And I think
- 28:27Speaker 5: in some ways what's happened is that they basically decided
- 28:29Speaker 5: they wouldn't block it for now. You again, some of
- 28:32Speaker 5: these things come up on motions for conjunctions. In other words,
- 28:34Speaker 5: given that the election is coming soon, flink just want
- 28:37Speaker 5: to stop the new law from taking effect and then
- 28:40Speaker 5: hold the trial. And the state is saying, well, no,
- 28:42Speaker 5: the law. Ca'm going to think you can have a
- 28:44Speaker 5: trial later. Then we can change it later if you
- 28:46Speaker 5: find it's unlawful.
- 28:48Speaker 2: And voting rights advocates say that's too late, because you
- 28:52Speaker 2: can't change the vote.
- 28:53Speaker 5: There is this thing known as the per Cell principle,
- 28:56Speaker 5: the idea that you shouldn't be changing the rules governing
- 28:59Speaker 5: an election too to the election. No one knows when
- 29:02Speaker 5: is it too close to an election, But we're probably
- 29:04Speaker 5: being to get there at least for primaries, even if
- 29:07Speaker 5: some of the earlier action in a case they have
- 29:10Speaker 5: taken place months ago. You know. I think in this case,
- 29:12Speaker 5: in the North Carolina case, there was a decision going
- 29:15Speaker 5: back to January twenty three. It's just took you a
- 29:18Speaker 5: long time for it to kind of prokly through the system.
- 29:21Speaker 2: Are states here basically trying to run out the clock?
- 29:24Speaker 5: I think they often do. I mean they often basically say, well,
- 29:28Speaker 5: no preliminary injunction, no emergency motions please, And then as
- 29:32Speaker 5: they continue to bring appeals that will delay things, there
- 29:36Speaker 5: may eventually be a trial, and then there may eventually
- 29:39Speaker 5: be an appeal to a trial, and the appeal may
- 29:40Speaker 5: actually get decided. And that's kind of what happened in Alabama.
- 29:43Speaker 5: But just sometimes they do seem to be stretching it
- 29:45Speaker 5: all out in delay and delay and delay.
- 29:48Speaker 2: So these decisions, along with others in recent months, does
- 29:52Speaker 2: that mean that the congressional maps for twenty twenty four
- 29:55Speaker 2: are largely set?
- 29:57Speaker 5: I think that's right. I think that the litigate is
- 30:00Speaker 5: now just about done. We are into April. Many states
- 30:04Speaker 5: already had their primaries. I think there are probably no
- 30:07Speaker 5: primaries later than June, or at least not many. I
- 30:10Speaker 5: think we're getting very late in the season and we're
- 30:12Speaker 5: probably done.
- 30:13Speaker 2: I want to get your reaction to a political article
- 30:17Speaker 2: that said that Republicans came out ahead in the battle
- 30:20Speaker 2: to control the House in twenty twenty four thanks to
- 30:23Speaker 2: the redistricting aggression of North Carolina Republicans and the timidity
- 30:28Speaker 2: of New York Democrats.
- 30:30Speaker 3: Yeah.
- 30:30Speaker 5: I think there's a lot to be said for that.
- 30:32Speaker 5: Maybe a little defensive of the New York Democrats. They
- 30:34Speaker 5: had a tough situation, but yes, North Carolina did a
- 30:37Speaker 5: very sharp gerry mander and basically moved three seats from
- 30:40Speaker 5: the Democratic to the Republican column, which is huge. The
- 30:43Speaker 5: problem in New York is that New York does have
- 30:45Speaker 5: this independent redistricting Commission and this redistricting process that the
- 30:49Speaker 5: state adopted in the twenty tens and which was used
- 30:52Speaker 5: for the first time in twenty twenty two, and the
- 30:55Speaker 5: state failed to do it right, according to the New
- 30:57Speaker 5: York State's highest court, leading to the appointment of the
- 30:59Speaker 5: Special Master, who came up with a plan that was
- 31:01Speaker 5: fairly favorable to Republicans. The Democrats got a second shot
- 31:04Speaker 5: of this by persuading the quart of Appeals that they
- 31:06Speaker 5: had a right to try again. But I think they
- 31:08Speaker 5: were a kind of gun shy based on what happened
- 31:10Speaker 5: the first time, and they did not want to make
- 31:12Speaker 5: an aggressive move to seriously change what was done in
- 31:16Speaker 5: twenty twenty two, so they tinkered. And my understanding from
- 31:21Speaker 5: the more political people is probably mostly might have affected
- 31:26Speaker 5: the outcome in one district. Mostly it seems to me
- 31:28Speaker 5: that they were kind of protecting Democrats who were in
- 31:31Speaker 5: vulnerable districts, and they have recalculated one of the districts
- 31:35Speaker 5: that which went narrowly Republican last time in a way
- 31:37Speaker 5: that makes it even more truly even. But it seems
- 31:40Speaker 5: as though it's, you know that based on redistricting, it's
- 31:43Speaker 5: not clearly with the any Democratic pickups in New York
- 31:45Speaker 5: or at most one. At one point Democrats were thinking
- 31:47Speaker 5: optimistically they could be three, four or five. So there
- 31:50Speaker 5: was definitely a loss of three seats in North Carolina,
- 31:53Speaker 5: not clear that there was any game in New York.
- 31:56Speaker 5: The Alabama was probably a pickup because of the redistricting there. Again,
- 32:00Speaker 5: so if we're just talking about maps, I think the
- 32:03Speaker 5: remapping was marginally pro Republican.
- 32:06Speaker 2: Adam Kinkaid, the executive director of the National Republican Redistricting Trust,
- 32:11Speaker 2: toll Politico. It's a marginally more favorable map in twenty
- 32:15Speaker 2: four than we even had in twenty two.
- 32:17Speaker 5: That sounds about right, That sounds about right now. Of course,
- 32:21Speaker 5: twenty two was an election where many people thought the
- 32:24Speaker 5: Republicans were going to do really well, and although they
- 32:26Speaker 5: did take the House, they took it much more narrowly
- 32:29Speaker 5: than had been predicted. Much will turn on, of course,
- 32:32Speaker 5: the presidential election. You know, we're's still six months out
- 32:35Speaker 5: from that or more so. No one knows how that's
- 32:37Speaker 5: going to go. And turnout us often different in presidential
- 32:40Speaker 5: election years than in off years. So the Republicans, I think,
- 32:44Speaker 5: were hoping for a lot in twenty two. They won,
- 32:46Speaker 5: but they'd won more narrowly than people had expected. They
- 32:49Speaker 5: may be slightly better off now, but the presidential election
- 32:52Speaker 5: will matter for a lot, and maybe the kind of
- 32:54Speaker 5: the messiness of the Republican Congress will matter for something too.
- 32:57Speaker 2: It's going to be a long seven months, that's for sure.
- 33:01Speaker 2: Thanks so much, rich that's Professor Richard Ruffald of Columbia
- 33:04Speaker 2: Law School. And that's it for this edition of the
- 33:07Speaker 2: Bloomberg Law Podcast. Remember you can always get the latest
- 33:10Speaker 2: legal news by subscribing and listening to the show on
- 33:13Speaker 2: Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast,
- 33:18Speaker 2: slash Law. I'm June Grosso and this is Bloomberg