Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Incentives Rewired: Bitcoin’s Role in Reshaping Real Estate
Transcript
- 0:02It all comes down to computers communicating.
- 0:06The information superhighway can be a confusing mix of on ramps
- 0:09and off ramps. Bitcoin is worthless artificial
- 0:14gold. Is it still rat poison?
- 0:17Probably rat poison squared. We need to get into the world of
- 0:21OK, this is actually foundational technology.
- 0:24What the Internet of money? Does is it creates a single.
- 0:27Network which can do a microtransaction to a giga
- 0:33transaction. The Internet is going to be one
- 0:38of the major forces for reducing the roller gun.
- 0:42The one thing that's missing that that will soon be developed
- 0:46is a reliable E cash. All righty, welcome back to
- 0:54Final Settlement. Today is Monday, April 21st,
- 0:572025. Bitcoins pumping a little.
- 1:00The rest of markets are are down.
- 1:03Exciting times. And we've got a great podcast
- 1:05for you today. Two fantastic guests, Leon
- 1:08Wankum and and Kelly Lannon. And really today's pod is going
- 1:12to be a broad overview of of the convergence of Bitcoin and real
- 1:16estate. And I would say Kelly and Leon
- 1:19are really the two most prominent sort of foremost minds
- 1:23at that intersection, really articulating the ways in which
- 1:28Bitcoin can be infused with, with real estate de risk real
- 1:32estate to a certain extent. And really, you know, one thing
- 1:36that Leon, Leon has talked a lot about is, you know, there's just
- 1:39monetary premium associated with the real estate market today,
- 1:42300 trillion roughly. And most people use real estate
- 1:46as a store of value today. For the past, you know, 50 years
- 1:49or so since we left the gold standard, real estate has been a
- 1:52form of money in the sense that people use it as a store of
- 1:55value. And so now that we have Bitcoin,
- 1:57the sort of store of value perfected digital sound money,
- 2:02we may see that that monetary premium premium erodes over
- 2:05time. And there's a lot of
- 2:07opportunities to build products around that convergence of of
- 2:10these two asset classes. And so super excited to have the
- 2:13guys on on the show today. How we doing voice?
- 2:19Thanks. For having us.
- 2:21I'm particularly excited not only because the the price is
- 2:24bumping this morning, but this is a conversation long overdue.
- 2:28I feel like we've gotten more interest on the on ramp and
- 2:30early riders side around investors and developers looking
- 2:33to infuse BTC. And then I consider Leon and
- 2:36Kelly good friends. And I think Kelly, me and you
- 2:38might go back to 2020 bitlock boom when there was only about
- 2:42180 people crazy enough to to descend on Texas, Dallas, TX to
- 2:46attend a conference in the middle of COVID.
- 2:49And Kelly since back then and Leon as well.
- 2:52But Kelly, I just remember viscerally explaining how real
- 2:54estate and Bitcoin needed to be infused in Bitcoin loans.
- 2:58So it's it's an awesome and a privilege to have you guys talk
- 3:01about this today. Yeah, that was a good time.
- 3:06I mean, I would say, I would say both of you are also sort of
- 3:08emblematic of the type of individual that you know, we try
- 3:14to search out and also try to find us in terms of early riders
- 3:17on ramp, the Guild that we launched last week, it's, it's
- 3:20folks that have sort of external expertise if you will.
- 3:23And so, you know, both of your expertise in real estate, then
- 3:28finding Bitcoin and sort of trying to merge those two things
- 3:31is something that we're going to see across all industries over
- 3:33the next several decades is people taking their experience
- 3:37and learnings from other parts of the world and society, other
- 3:41asset classes and bridging the gap to infusing Bitcoin in those
- 3:44things. So maybe that's a good place to
- 3:46start maybe for both of you. Maybe we could start with Leon
- 3:49in just terms of your, your background, particularly in real
- 3:52estate and then how you sort of came to Bitcoin and saw the
- 3:56convergence between these two fields?
- 3:58Yes, first of all, thank you for having me guys.
- 4:01And I'll make it short. My background in real estate
- 4:06sort of that's the family business.
- 4:08So to say something, I grew up upon construction sites, real
- 4:13estate developments where places I've I've been around in my
- 4:16youth and then while studying financial economics and prior to
- 4:20that I studied philosophy. I kind of fell down a Bitcoin
- 4:24rabbit hole, eventually writing my master's thesis about Bitcoin
- 4:28and then joining the real estate construction business in 2016.
- 4:33And for a couple of years, I didn't put much thought into
- 4:36both asset classes in terms of combining the two.
- 4:40I thought about real estate as one business and Bitcoin as a
- 4:44savings technology. But over time, I realized
- 4:47basically what you just laid out, that real estate, in fact,
- 4:51it's not just a business, it's actually a savings technology.
- 4:54And then I came to the conclusion that Bitcoin is a
- 4:56better savings technology. And that led me down the path of
- 5:00thinking about how to combine the two to strengthen real
- 5:04estate and make use of Bitcoin as a superior store value.
- 5:08Awesome. So I, I came to it from a
- 5:14similar perspective. I grew up here in Phoenix, AZ.
- 5:17My dad's been a home builder since the late 80s.
- 5:20And I always tell people that I never got grounded.
- 5:23I just got sent to the job site. So I've been around real estate
- 5:27development and construction in the single family space in in
- 5:31the multifamily, small multifamily space for pretty
- 5:34much my whole life. It didn't really occur to me
- 5:38what was going on until probably 20/16/2017.
- 5:42I joined a organization called the International Blockchain
- 5:46Real Estate Association, which was a real estate focused
- 5:51blockchain effort that focused on public blockchains, which at
- 5:55the time was basically Bitcoin. And I did a trip to New York
- 5:59City and I stayed there for about a week in advance of the
- 6:03conference. And I kind of came to the
- 6:04conclusion that, you know, this this method of development that
- 6:09they do in Manhattan is obviously much different than
- 6:11Phoenix. But I went down the rabbit hole
- 6:14of like, why is that? So after I got back, I started
- 6:18reading all sorts of things. A familiar thing for a lot of
- 6:21Bitcoiners is Strong Towns by Chuck Marrone.
- 6:25That's a good book. There's also a website.
- 6:27So I've been following his work since, yeah, since about then.
- 6:31So almost 10 years and that kind of lead from the association
- 6:36that I had joined kind of falling apart to jumping into
- 6:39Bitcoin full time. And that was about the same time
- 6:41that Bitcoin standard got published.
- 6:44So from there I kind of just married my experience the the
- 6:50principles that I had learned from strong towns and then the
- 6:54principles of sound money and trying to figure out how
- 6:57exactly, you know, this should work.
- 7:00How I grew up in the in, you know, Phoenix with suburbia as
- 7:03a, it was a way different development model compared to,
- 7:07you know, most of the major cities of the world that are at
- 7:09least, you know, a couple 100 years old.
- 7:11So that's kind of how I, I got into it.
- 7:13I started Bitcoin urbanism at the same conference that Michael
- 7:16and I met one of the other guys in Bitcoin gave me a good ration
- 7:23of grief at the bar for not just starting to write.
- 7:26So I kind of just did that and you know, more or less here,
- 7:31here we are. So I'm, I'm excited to have this
- 7:34conversation. I know that there's a lot of
- 7:37drive by comments on Twitter or other things where people are
- 7:39talking about it. And Leon's done a wonderful job
- 7:42on various podcasts discussing the various routes to kind of
- 7:46siphon away the store value premium from real estate, which
- 7:51is kind of an artificial store of value and has been for, you
- 7:55know, at least the majority since the 70s.
- 7:58And then back into a hard asset Bitcoin, where we can hopefully
- 8:02get some, at least from my perspective, some holistic
- 8:05changes to a Bitcoin urbanism environment.
- 8:07So. Wonderful.
- 8:10Yeah. And so just to, to pull on that
- 8:12thread of, of the monetary premium a little bit more in
- 8:16terms of, you know, why and how real estate has become a
- 8:20predominant store of value over the past several decades.
- 8:23It really speaks to, you know, broken money and the idea that,
- 8:26that you can't save in Fiat, you can't save in Fiat currency.
- 8:30So you need these other alternatives, whether it's real
- 8:32estate, equity markets, etcetera.
- 8:35So maybe we can, we can start there in the sense of, you know,
- 8:38the problem and, and really the Fiat problem and how sort of
- 8:42unsound money has led to some perverse incentives in, you
- 8:46know, the real estate market and real estate development in
- 8:48particular. And so maybe maybe that's a good
- 8:51place to start for for both of you is, you know, really what is
- 8:54the problem at hand in terms of, you know, why, you know, Fiat
- 8:58and unsound money has led to all these various issues within the
- 9:01real estate market and real estate development in general
- 9:03do. You want to go?
- 9:07You want? Yeah, No.
- 9:08Leo, you, you go first. I'll follow up after you.
- 9:11OK, sure. I think if somebody is listening
- 9:16right now that isn't real estate development.
- 9:18What I'll now portray as a problem, I think for most of us
- 9:21is actually not a problem. It's actually the reason why
- 9:24real estate has been doing so well.
- 9:26But what I'm describing now is the negative effects of monetary
- 9:30inflation. So as new currency units enter
- 9:33the market, existing currency units lose purchasing power and
- 9:36people are forced to invest, and they invest in scarce assets.
- 9:40And one of the assets that people chose is real estate.
- 9:43That is due to the scarcity of land.
- 9:46So real estate has been tied to wealth for thousands of years.
- 9:50But if you think about it, it was the agricultural capacity of
- 9:53land that made it valuable, not the scarcity.
- 9:56Because on a gold standard, gold was scarcer than land.
- 10:00So people used gold to store value, and then they used land,
- 10:03for example, to run a business or to make money.
- 10:06And land was also tied to political power.
- 10:08So in ancient Greece and Japan and India and Rome, all these
- 10:12different cultures, if you owned land, you were considered
- 10:15somebody eligible to vote or eligible to carry certain
- 10:19political power, right? But what happened in 1971 is as
- 10:23the money started to expand, as the monetary supply started to
- 10:26expand, you can actually see that the price of real estate
- 10:30closely follows the supply of of money.
- 10:33So if you look at M2, the rate of monetary expansion since 1971
- 10:39was between 7 and 8%, depending on what statistic you're paying
- 10:43attention to. And residential real estate, for
- 10:45example, grew by around 6.7% at the same time.
- 10:49So it very closely follows the expansion of the monetary
- 10:53supply. And this is also because people
- 10:56get loans for buying real estate.
- 10:58So it's not just the scarcity in real estate that favors its use
- 11:01as a store value. It's also the ability to get
- 11:05loans to purchase the real estate because that has an
- 11:08interesting effect. If we say the expansion of the
- 11:12monetary supply is 8% and real estate grows in market price by
- 11:177%, if I take on a loan and I have a leverage of let's say 5,
- 11:23it doesn't grow by a factor of 7, it grows by a factor of 7 *
- 11:275. That's why buying real estate
- 11:29and investing in real estate on leverage with borrowed money
- 11:34allows you to actually outperform the rate of monetary
- 11:36expansion, right? And that is why people chose
- 11:41real estate as their preferred store value.
- 11:43And today, we can safely say that real estate is the most
- 11:46used store value in the world. But that dynamic changes with
- 11:50Bitcoin because Bitcoin without leverage over the past 10 years
- 11:55had a compound annual growth rate of over 50%.
- 11:58And since 2010, when it had its first market price, Bitcoin had
- 12:02a CAGR, so a compound annual growth rate of over 140%.
- 12:07So it becomes very obvious that since Bitcoin emerged, there's
- 12:11no need to invest into real estate.
- 12:12People can just save in Bitcoin by default.
- 12:15And that creates a problem because it creates competition
- 12:19for real estate, meaning people now have a different store value
- 12:22that they might prefer. You asked me what the problem
- 12:25is. The problem of the past 30
- 12:27years, in my opinion, if we talk about architecture and also what
- 12:31Kelly alludes to, urbanism or urban design, there was no need
- 12:36to provide housing of quality because people bought it anyway
- 12:41because they needed to place their money somewhere.
- 12:43And that's something that can safely save from experience over
- 12:46the past 10 years, especially since 2009 when interest rates
- 12:51were below a percent in Europe. Also in the in North America,
- 12:56people had such high demand for real estate than in deals.
- 13:01Some of the people that bought real estate from us, they didn't
- 13:05even see the real estate. We just sent them the numbers
- 13:08and they sent somebody to look at it just to check that we
- 13:12didn't lie to see that it's fully vacant, it's fully rented
- 13:16out. But sometimes the buyer didn't
- 13:19even look at the asset. And I think that is actually
- 13:22crazy. And that is a prime example of
- 13:25how broke money can also break incentives in the investment
- 13:28world, because you should not invest in something that you
- 13:31don't understand. Very well said.
- 13:36So I'll. Try not to echo a lot of the
- 13:38things that Leon has said, which he's very much exactly correct
- 13:41that real estate in general is a game of leverage.
- 13:44And it's managing leverage so that internally your your Irrs
- 13:48are better than they normally would be if you would just
- 13:51bought the asset, you know, fully with equity.
- 13:54But Leon is generally correct in that the amount of credit that
- 13:58has become available specifically for real estate
- 14:01becomes a a feedback loop. In addition that the the
- 14:05inflation that occurs allows you to theoretically, you know,
- 14:10increase rents at the same rates and keep your asset value the
- 14:15same. So the the other flip side of
- 14:19that is that with all of the credit printing that happens,
- 14:22governments are able to regulate things to a greater degree.
- 14:26So a good example of that is the the US home mortgage market
- 14:31which is a highly regulated basically commoditized
- 14:34investment, whereas around the world most mortgages for homes
- 14:40are floating rate mortgages. So the US is a very special case
- 14:44where the investments or excuse me, the the mortgages that are
- 14:47made are fixed for a very long period of time up to 30 years.
- 14:51Some commercial mortgages may even go to 35 or 40 years
- 14:54depending on the circumstance. But it's important to realize
- 14:58that it's a very captured market as far as regulation goes and
- 15:04that they're able to do that because they can print money
- 15:07essentially to afford the regulations.
- 15:10And that's from a high level perspective, from the, from the
- 15:12lower local jurisdiction perspective, they're able to
- 15:15control what gets built and how. So for real estate developers,
- 15:19it's looking at a, a formula essentially of if I have a piece
- 15:24of property here and I know that I can get a specific zoning
- 15:27which allows me to increase either the density of
- 15:29residential units or a different more intense use type, whether
- 15:34that's commercial office building or tower or whatever it
- 15:36is. Think about the value of the
- 15:39land being held under by a pressure cooker.
- 15:41And that pressure cooker is zoning.
- 15:43So if you're able to change the zoning and raise your limits,
- 15:47then you've created a substantial amount of value that
- 15:49otherwise wouldn't have existed. So for real estate developers,
- 15:52at least particularly in the US, being able to change where your
- 15:56limit is, is where a lot of the value is and why why it becomes
- 16:00such a lucrative business in that regard.
- 16:05So when you have a combination of the leverage that's available
- 16:10for real estate owners, the leverage that's available for
- 16:13developers, and then being able to navigate the the the
- 16:17processes effectively and successfully, then you're able
- 16:22to create a substantial amount of wealth using the tools and
- 16:26systems that exist as a result of Fiat money, in my opinion.
- 16:30So yeah, that's that. That's really, in my opinion,
- 16:35kind of what drives a lot of the value that people use and
- 16:39they're able to pull it out with with creative money.
- 16:44Yeah, I think one thing in our mental model from a high level
- 16:47perspective and we all experience this with our friends
- 16:49and family that maybe made some capital in real estate.
- 16:52They think like they're geniuses and they think that at no point
- 16:55can you invest in real estate and it goes down.
- 16:57I experienced this personally with family in 21 when they all
- 17:00wanted somebody to buy a house and and that's the first time I
- 17:02think for a from a while that people are actually underwater
- 17:05right now is the lower interest rate and in 21.
- 17:09But I think what Leon said, it's really the model around
- 17:13expansion of the monetary units and ultimately the distortion of
- 17:17not only capital allocation, but the second and 3rd order
- 17:19effects. So like equities, bonds and the
- 17:21real estate or the largest, right, roughly 121, thirty
- 17:24trillion for equities and bonds and then roughly 40 trillion in
- 17:28real estate. As you start going further and
- 17:31further from the value of the underlying asset or commodity,
- 17:36you start, right, because equities have value based on
- 17:38cash flows and other parameters. And then bonds also have value
- 17:42in real estate dependent on location or other productive
- 17:46underlying fundamentals. But as you just start to
- 17:48increase more units and look for something that Leon says really
- 17:51well is its relative scarcity versus absolute scarcity.
- 17:55And so people are pricing that all day long.
- 17:56And as more units come into the system, it just gets further and
- 17:59further distorted. I would make the case and you
- 18:01guys are closest to this today at this exact moment, it's the
- 18:04most distorted it's ever been just simply because they're
- 18:06more, there's more monetary units in the system.
- 18:11And Mike, just commenting on what you said, I can also feel
- 18:17that since 2021 when interest rates started to go up, you
- 18:21basically see that the demand and the liquidity available for
- 18:24real estate went down. And from 2009 or the end of 2008
- 18:30until 2021, interest rates were so low.
- 18:33There was so much liquidity available to flow into real
- 18:37estate that was easy to make a quick buck, so to say.
- 18:41But due to the structural problems that the expansion of
- 18:44the monetary supply has created at this point, inflation that
- 18:48actually helps real estate development because inflation
- 18:51also means the debt that you take on today will be worth less
- 18:55in the future. But the problem is, as we are
- 18:59hitting the end of a long term debt cycle, inflation is so
- 19:03strong that it increases maintenance and construction
- 19:07cost to a level where the incoming liquidity cannot make
- 19:12up for anymore. So I think so right now we're
- 19:16sitting at sort of like a scenario, I call it the
- 19:18crossroads or paradigm shift. But if you're working in real
- 19:22estate development and you're aware of the fact that inflation
- 19:26has been rampant over the past five years and nation states
- 19:29need to be able to to dampen it a bit, you need to find other
- 19:34ways to juice up your returns. And Bitcoin, of course, comes in
- 19:38handy here. Yeah, absolutely.
- 19:41And maybe maybe we can dive in there now you know how, how does
- 19:45Bitcoin influence this equation and how can you know, a sound of
- 19:50a form of sound money actually improve all these incentives
- 19:53that we're talking about? I think one of the things that
- 19:55you both alluded to and even just anecdotally, I think we see
- 19:59it is the the degradation of quality of building
- 20:04infrastructure, new home constructions.
- 20:07I see this everyday. It's like it's just we're, we're
- 20:10so far from what you know, it used to be 50 years ago or even,
- 20:14you know, 20 years ago in terms of the actual quality being put
- 20:18forth by new builds. And I think part of that is, is
- 20:22exactly what you're describing. It's the, it's the misaligned
- 20:24incentives and then ultimately the misallocation of capital
- 20:27where no one really care, you know, the, the person building
- 20:30the home doesn't necessarily care how high quality is it is
- 20:34if they know they're going to be able to sell it because it
- 20:35demands there basically. So maybe now we can sort of
- 20:39transition to, you know, how Bitcoin fits into this equation
- 20:43in in both of your minds. And maybe just before that, just
- 20:47adding the layer into inflation affecting CapEx and OpEx,
- 20:51because again, well, this is a specific to real estate, that
- 20:54degradation we feel from the quality of service when we buy
- 20:56food all the way to the infrastructure we live in and
- 21:00operate. And so I think it's important
- 21:02we're like that's breaking down and then Bitcoin as a natural
- 21:06solution, if you guys can touch on that.
- 21:12Go ahead, Leon. You're first.
- 21:13Kelly, don't be shy, you know he likes piggybacking on Leons.
- 21:17Alright answers. Right, here we go.
- 21:19So from my perspective, the, the, the, the CapEx and Optex
- 21:24situation is, is difficult to manage because your, if your
- 21:28costs arise, you, if your costs rise because of basically
- 21:32printing more money and adding more currency to the pool, then
- 21:37it's more likely, at least in my experience the last couple years
- 21:39is that those costs are very sticky when not coming down.
- 21:43So if you're in a, in a, in a situation where theoretically
- 21:47your rents would rise because they added more money, it goes
- 21:51to what Leon is saying is that real estate is not scarce.
- 21:54So they build more unfortunately, if your costs
- 21:58aren't coming down because they've inflated the currency to
- 22:02a degree and then they're also building more units or that, you
- 22:06know, real estate is a process. So if they started building
- 22:08stuff in 2019 that's now just coming online, then all of your
- 22:11costs are elevated, but the rents have come back down from
- 22:14where they were. So now you're in a position
- 22:16where your CapEx is, you know, maybe 510% higher than you had
- 22:20originally anticipated it being, but your rents are down 5%.
- 22:24So now you've got a 15 point swing in your margins because
- 22:29you were trying to basically game what was going on at the
- 22:31time with what is the reality now.
- 22:35So that's where you start to feel it in like the quality of
- 22:39the construction. Because if you're going through
- 22:40the process and, and costs are going up 510% and you're
- 22:43signing, you know, change orders once a week because lumber has
- 22:47gone up or drywall is not available or whatever it is, you
- 22:51have to start cutting costs somewhere, right?
- 22:53You have a set amount of money you have, well, you have, you
- 22:57more or less have a set amount of money.
- 22:58You're either using your bank capital to build it and then you
- 23:01have some equity or you're having to get more equity from
- 23:04your partners in order to finish the job.
- 23:06And that's one thing that they, that they don't like doing is
- 23:09giving you extra money to finish the job.
- 23:11So at that point you have to become creative and say, OK,
- 23:14what kind of product can I deliver by removing certain
- 23:19things that are, you know, considered like quality of life
- 23:22enhancements, right? If that's in a, a community
- 23:26area, how can I get away with not putting in a BBQ, right?
- 23:29So that may save me on my change order for drywall or lumber or
- 23:32something like that. So you get to a point where I
- 23:34say, OK, well, in the design as well, how many corners can I
- 23:39remove from a unit? And that's it.
- 23:41That's an actual consideration, right?
- 23:43So if you have an elevation of a home that has various depths and
- 23:48all of these things, every corner that that elevation has
- 23:51with the change is more expensive to do.
- 23:54So that's, you know, one thing you see when you see new homes
- 23:57is that they basically just look like a four sided box, right?
- 24:01And that's the most cost effective way to do it.
- 24:04So in the, in the business is called value engineering.
- 24:07So you value engineer, you know absolutely everything that you
- 24:10possibly can to reduce your costs in advance of knowing that
- 24:15you know, something's going to happen and my costs are going to
- 24:17go up. Or if you're in the middle of
- 24:19it, you're, you're trying to figure out how do I remove
- 24:22certain elements that I haven't yet built in order to offset
- 24:25some of the costs that I'm facing now.
- 24:27So if you do that over a long enough period of time, let's say
- 24:3250 years since since the Nixon shock, then what you're left
- 24:36with is basically what we have today.
- 24:38There's a very famous inspect home inspector who's actually
- 24:43based out of Phoenix, who has a very big following on TikTok and
- 24:47Instagram where he goes and shows people videos inside
- 24:51behind the walls of how the construction is done right.
- 24:54So there's, there's all sorts of videos where, you know, the the
- 24:58wall in your bedroom isn't even connected to the trust in the
- 25:00house. It's literally just a floating
- 25:02hall with drywall attached to it.
- 25:04Or the fact that there's holes around, you know, an electrical
- 25:08panel where water could get in behind.
- 25:10You know, that stuff is all supposed to be insulated and
- 25:12not, you know, subject to to shorting out terrain, but still
- 25:17the quality of the stuff that's going on is just, you know, bad.
- 25:21In addition, think about it this way.
- 25:23If you have specific labor costs that you know will go up with
- 25:27time because of inflation and you have piece meal crews or
- 25:30whatever it is who work on a per job basis, they'll they'll walk
- 25:33off your job for a dollar, you know, a dollar an hour extra or
- 25:36whatever it is. So that's something that you're
- 25:38always constantly facing literally with every crew that
- 25:41shows up to your job, there's guys that drive around and that
- 25:44are willing to to snag them if they need something.
- 25:47You know, if that happens to them or if they need something
- 25:49done and somebody folded shop happens all the time.
- 25:52Is that I can't tell you how many times it's happened to us
- 25:54in the last five years. Probably happened once every two
- 25:57or three months, depending on depending on the crew.
- 26:00So you in addition to that, if they're working on a piece meal
- 26:04job, right, they're only getting paid to set amount to frame your
- 26:07house. They are less likely to spend
- 26:10100% of the time getting 100% of the details than they are to
- 26:14just get 80 to 90% and hope that, you know, maybe you won't
- 26:18notice or that the inspector won't notice or that it's really
- 26:21not that important that they can kind of get a work around around
- 26:25it. So after a long time of that,
- 26:28you end up in the situation where we're in now where you go
- 26:30into a house and you're like, wow, is this really, is this
- 26:33really what I paid for? And in, in Leon's comment, it's
- 26:36like, yeah, this is what you have to accept because A,
- 26:39there's not much on the market, B, there's lots of competition.
- 26:43There's ten other people behind you that are willing to buy this
- 26:46and you're more or less stuck with the product that's
- 26:49available. So you know, when we think about
- 26:53Bitcoin in this regard, we think about a hard money that can
- 26:58inflate that if it is going up in value compared to something
- 27:01like the US dollar which inflates at 7 to 8% a year, you
- 27:05know you're losing essentially 7 to 8% of the quality of
- 27:09construction you get on an annual basis.
- 27:12So if you want to use something like Bitcoin and reverse the
- 27:15trend, then you get what we had 100 plus years ago where not
- 27:19only were the homes for the average person great, they're
- 27:24getting better all the time. And that's kind of what we're
- 27:27hoping to get back to, at least on a Bitcoin standard with real
- 27:31estate or incorporating Bitcoin into real estate, which allows
- 27:34you to reverse that trend on your own using the hardest
- 27:38currency, non demand. Yeah, make sure that maybe
- 27:42jumping onto that or into that, I want to talk about the
- 27:47solution that Bitcoin offers for the problem that Kelly just
- 27:51explained. And I just want to make people
- 27:52aware of the financialization of the asset class of real estate.
- 27:57Jeff Booth recently posted a picture and he showed the
- 28:00average price for home in the US in 1944 was $4000, and today
- 28:06it's over $400,000. So that's a 100X increase.
- 28:10And I looked into some more historical numbers and I looked
- 28:13into the Middle Ages in Europe. So in the 15th century in the
- 28:19Rhine area, which is now West Germany.
- 28:22Back then it was the empire founded by Carl the Great and
- 28:25then passed on to his sons. They used the gold based
- 28:28currency called the Rhine Golden, and it was basically a
- 28:32gold currency. And a Carpenter owned around 150
- 28:37goldens a year, which is equivalent to around $50,000
- 28:40today. And one year's wage allowed the
- 28:44Carpenter to buy a house, Not a home, a house.
- 28:48So 500 years ago, a Carpenter in the Middle Ages was able to
- 28:52acquire a house, a home with one year's salary.
- 28:57Today, the average income in the US for two people for the two
- 29:01person household is 80,000. Meaning for one person it's
- 29:0640,000. And since the cost, the average
- 29:11cost for a home in the US is 400,000, it would take the
- 29:15average person 10 years to be able to acquire a home.
- 29:20And I think that shows that the living standards today are not
- 29:26better than the Ware 500 years ago.
- 29:28And the reason for that is because of Fiat money.
- 29:31Monetary expansion makes everything more expensive.
- 29:34From the perspective of a real estate developer, from the
- 29:37perspective of a landlord, I could say that's perfect for me
- 29:41because my product is getting more and more expensive.
- 29:44But as you, Kelly, explained very well, at the end of the
- 29:48debt cycle, the inflation also hits US.
- 29:51So right now we are very concerned about the rising
- 29:55CapEx, maintenance cost, construction cost and also
- 29:58regulation that forces us to provide solar on the roof,
- 30:05sometimes have flowers on the wall, things that don't really
- 30:09make sense and they're not economically viable, but
- 30:12bureaucrats want us to do that. So usually what we do or what we
- 30:17consider is can we raise rents because that's the profit
- 30:21margin. That also creates another
- 30:23problem because it causes living conditions to deteriorate
- 30:27because the price for housing goes up as landlords
- 30:31continuously raise rents with inflation.
- 30:34So I want to provide the solution now because what I
- 30:37personally really like about Bitcoin, both the network and
- 30:40also the money or the currency, however you want to define it,
- 30:43is that it does provide a practical solution to this
- 30:46problem. And I want to give you an
- 30:48example of what we did. So this is a real life example.
- 30:51One of the properties that we run, it's a 70 apartment
- 30:56residential property and has around €750,000 rental income
- 31:02per year. In February or March of 2024, we
- 31:07took 80,000, which is a bit more than 10% of the rental income.
- 31:11We bought 1.7 Bitcoin with it and these 1.7 Bitcoin are worth
- 31:16now more than like I looked last week they were worth about
- 31:20160,000. Price went up a little bit.
- 31:23So I think that now they should be worth one 180,000 while the
- 31:27rest of the rental income that we saved lost 2% purchasing
- 31:30power due to inflation. So you can clearly see that by
- 31:34using Bitcoin and to create maintenance reserves, we were
- 31:41able to outperform the rate of monetary inflation by a factor
- 31:45of 50. And we all right, so because
- 31:49Bitcoin, we also have now a very good timing, of course, because
- 31:53we went into Bitcoin into the bear market, now we're in the
- 31:56midst of a bull market. Bitcoin is very volatile.
- 31:59So if we talk in three years, maybe the performance will be
- 32:02worse, maybe it will be better. But if we talk in 10 years or 20
- 32:06years, I can guarantee you the performance will be much better.
- 32:10So you need to have a long time horizon and using Bitcoin, but I
- 32:13think you also need to have a long time horizon with real
- 32:15estate and developing a project. Usually, I would consider the
- 32:21time horizon that I invest in that project to be 30 years.
- 32:24Like that would be the average time horizon I would consider in
- 32:29constructing and managing an asset.
- 32:31Of course, some assets have to be sold in order to have money
- 32:36for the ongoing operations. But because we are a real estate
- 32:39developer and we also manage the assets that we build, we have a
- 32:43long time horizon anyway and Bitcoin fits into that
- 32:46perfectly. And I think maintenance reserves
- 32:50are stage 1 of using Bitcoin in real estate management.
- 32:56Gotcha. Yeah, no, that's, that's a
- 32:57fascinating example or or case study to walk through.
- 33:01I'm curious, like you, you sort of mentioned this, but like the
- 33:04the time horizon or the duration is very important here, right?
- 33:06Because if someone you know, who's a, a real estate guy is
- 33:09listening to this and they know, you know very little about
- 33:13Bitcoin, but they hear it's very volatile, they could say, well,
- 33:16you're just cherry pick picking this, this time frame to and,
- 33:19and it worked out for you. But you know, what if Bitcoin
- 33:21had dropped 50% in that time frame?
- 33:24So maybe if you could put a finer point on the actual sort
- 33:27of synergies in terms of duration of these assets.
- 33:30And and you know how you think about the time horizon of
- 33:33something like this, at least in this first example for
- 33:36maintenance reserves and then we can go into some of the other
- 33:38sort of applications or examples.
- 33:41Sure, make it quick. I said 30 years because that's
- 33:45my personal time horizon. That's quite long, of course.
- 33:48And if you want to flip a property, I'd say construction
- 33:51takes five years at least. It can work out faster.
- 33:55Some people can construct in three years.
- 33:57But on average, if it's a property with let's say maybe
- 34:0320304050 units upwards, it will take four to five years.
- 34:07And that's the same time period that Bitcoin takes to go through
- 34:11a halving cycle. So Bitcoin goes through halving
- 34:14cycles every four years. The amount of Bitcoin that's
- 34:16being issued every 10 minutes. So that's being released halves.
- 34:20And that usually leads to price increases due to decaying supply
- 34:25in an increase in demand due to a higher price, which usually
- 34:30leads to more press and more demand for Bitcoin.
- 34:34So to shorten the investment cycle, I'd say a four year to
- 34:39five year period is the minimum of holding Bitcoin as a reserve
- 34:43asset. Yeah, absolutely that that's
- 34:45helpful context because and and another way of looking at this
- 34:48or or saying this is, you know, if you look at bitcoins 200 a
- 34:51week moving average, it's pretty much a you know, it's a little
- 34:54bit of WAVY line, but it's up and to the right it it's sort of
- 34:57never goes down. So if you, if you have that at
- 34:59least four year term, 4 year horizon on, on Bitcoin, no one's
- 35:04ever lost money in Bitcoin. And in fact, you know, you've
- 35:07definitively definitely lost money if you're holding dollars
- 35:10over the past four years. So that is also the, there's a
- 35:13delta there. It's not just the Bitcoin
- 35:15outperformance, it's it's also the, the loss of purchasing
- 35:17power in terms of the alternative if you were just
- 35:20holding dollars. Liam, do you have something?
- 35:24OR. I also just.
- 35:25Wanted to kind of shift gears a little bit just to touch on the
- 35:29distortion of the credit markets in real estate as well as not
- 35:33just the money supply. Obviously here in the US we have
- 35:37the 30 year fixed mortgage at extremely low rates either
- 35:40because of the amount of mortgages that are bought up by
- 35:44the Fed, Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and.
- 35:46Fixed rates extremely low. And just the fact that you can
- 35:50get. Real estate at a fairly low
- 35:52level or leverage on your real estate at a fairly low level
- 35:56maybe one of the reasons that real estate is the largest asset
- 36:00in the world. It's easier to get a low
- 36:02interest rate on, you know, your home here in the US than it is
- 36:06to get large leverage on things like equity and bonds.
- 36:12Was. Was curious kind of how you see
- 36:14Bitcoin leverage and real estate kind of all converging together
- 36:21as kind of Bitcoin especially. Over a long time horizon and and
- 36:25how you see those products working out together.
- 36:29Well, see, I'll take a stab at that.
- 36:31I think that as time goes on and we'll use the example of the US,
- 36:35as their debt gets larger and larger, it becomes more
- 36:39important for them at least to stay afloat to issue more
- 36:42currency, right? So we're kind of at an
- 36:44inflection point where more inflation has to occur in order
- 36:49to keep the status quo, which actually reduces the quality of
- 36:52life for everybody involved. But it's basically just trying
- 36:55to keep the ship afloat. So if you're using real estate
- 36:59is your store value and you're hoping that any gains you can
- 37:03get in rent or reductions in the cost of your leverage is what's
- 37:07going to basically, excuse me, protect your store value in the
- 37:12real estate, your equity in the real estate, Then you kind of
- 37:15have a problem because now you're facing an uphill battle
- 37:17where eventually the, the connection between rising rents
- 37:22and rising property values will break.
- 37:25So there's only so much that people can handle to pay for
- 37:28rents. And then if that's the case and
- 37:31they can't afford your rent increases in order to keep up
- 37:33with your costs, now you have a problem.
- 37:36And I think that there's historical precedent, especially
- 37:38with what's the, the, the, the favorite Bitcoin book when money
- 37:44dies, where they talked about especially how real estate
- 37:48during the, the Weimar hyperinflation did well up to a
- 37:51point. And that point basically breaks
- 37:54when people are unable to coordinate their purchases or
- 37:57their income and these other things in order to pay rent.
- 38:01And if money starts inflating faster on a monthly basis, then
- 38:04you're able to control your rents, then you have a problem.
- 38:09So when you throw in Bitcoin with your leverage or if you're
- 38:12acquiring Bitcoin with your cash flows, then you are able to
- 38:16hedge against this kind of inflation that's occurring,
- 38:20right? Even if your costs are going up
- 38:22and you're you're allocating a portion of your income to
- 38:25Bitcoin, your Bitcoin should at least you know, we're using it
- 38:30the past as as, as, as a guide to the future, that your Bitcoin
- 38:34will outpace the increase in your costs and that you can
- 38:37still stay afloat and a minimum survive, right?
- 38:40A lot of times when these kind of situations happens, it's
- 38:42about surviving, who can survive.
- 38:44So you're able to protect yourself from the OpEx side with
- 38:49Bitcoin by allocating the cash flows and then you're able to
- 38:53protect your equity side with Bitcoin by allocating a portion
- 38:56of your debt to Bitcoin. So Leon has famously written
- 39:02about this. He has a nice website, I'm sure
- 39:03we'll cover that later. That kind of discusses like how
- 39:06do you, how do you allocate to Bitcoin?
- 39:09How much do you allocate to Bitcoin to be safe?
- 39:11Because a lot of times people don't realize that like, you
- 39:13know, even though it's coming from debt, it's actually coming
- 39:16from the equity. So if you are, you know, buying
- 39:19a $10 million property and you want to get, you know,
- 39:22$1,000,000 in Bitcoin, you've got to have that $1,000,000 in
- 39:26equity to put in because that's essentially what's what it's
- 39:29being used for. Now you can explain the benefits
- 39:32and all that which is you know part of what your job is as a as
- 39:36a developer or a long term owner or even as like a A10 year kind
- 39:41of investor, which is a lot of the standard pool of investment
- 39:44for multifamily in the US or even commercial.
- 39:48So I think personally that we are at a perfect time to be
- 39:53discussing this because we are at a point where inflation is
- 39:56probably higher than we think it is.
- 39:57It's definitely been higher than we thought it was in the past
- 39:59five years and. Specifically, operators and
- 40:03developers have to look for a method to essentially protect
- 40:08their wealth over a long period of time.
- 40:10So I'm in the same position with Leon, where our average bill
- 40:14takes from four to six years and that's getting all the plans,
- 40:17all the approvals and all that and then hopefully trying to
- 40:19sell it. Now we're, we're looking at
- 40:21changing our horizon to up to 15 years, which is buying and
- 40:24holding it for a period of time and trying to convince our
- 40:28partners to allocate a portion of that to Bitcoin as a hedge.
- 40:31Now it's not like a, a hedge is like, I'm, I'm more pro Bitcoin
- 40:36and against real estate. It's like, listen, this is a
- 40:38deal. We know that this has happened
- 40:41in the last five years and we want to allocate a portion to
- 40:44Bitcoin to protect our downside, not necessarily our upside, but
- 40:48it's our downside. If we're worried about, you
- 40:51know, 50,000 apartment units coming online in the next 18
- 40:54months, how do we how do we compete with that, you know,
- 40:57owning 20 to 50 units, right? So it's an important analysis
- 41:02now going forward in my opinion that we are actively at least
- 41:07I'm actively pushing for consideration in our deals.
- 41:12Yeah, this is a a super exciting theme that I think we're all
- 41:15going to have to cumulatively crowd source as a as a like not
- 41:22opportunity, but how it's executed on.
- 41:25And what I mean by that is I've talked to very large venture
- 41:30capital investors that have gone down the rabbit hole and they
- 41:33can't get their LP's and their their general partners to fully
- 41:36embrace Bitcoin. But they're trying to wrap
- 41:38around how do they allocate 10% of the fund for their next fund
- 41:41just to downside protect that. I know Leon and as well as
- 41:44Kelly, you just spoke about it of this notion of protecting
- 41:47against default is a natural like mechanism for Bitcoin to be
- 41:52infused and almost any credit instrument.
- 41:55And so like that's one example, but another one is like the I'm
- 41:59curious your guys's feedback on this.
- 42:01So I had random like experience in real estate.
- 42:03I was with Google Fiber helping get that across the like SE and
- 42:07so would go and pitch NDU owners and commercial real estate.
- 42:10Unlike the the quote we use, for better or worse is like it's
- 42:14like you built a Ferrari and then you have hubcaps on it.
- 42:16If you had like dial up or if you didn't have fiber, it's like
- 42:18you want to increase the the the the value, the equity value of
- 42:24it. And in similar I was that we
- 42:27work randomly and like saw a bunch of capital destruction.
- 42:29But point being is instead of it being Bitcoin, imagine there's
- 42:33like some other notion of you're just adding something to
- 42:36creative. It's like this amazing pool on
- 42:38the roof with a like helicopter pad, like that's effectively
- 42:42what you're putting into the the real estate.
- 42:44And so it's like less about this like notion of it's Bitcoin,
- 42:47it's native Internet beans. You know, it's like there's
- 42:50something there that you can just explain that it's bolted on
- 42:53and it's part of the package that I think that like once we
- 42:56can explain and it gets into the zeitgeist, it'll just be
- 42:59understood. I'm sure you guys have thought a
- 43:01lot about it as well. Well, certainly, certainly
- 43:06trying to figure out how. And then I'm sure Leon can
- 43:10attest to this a little bit better.
- 43:11It's certainly trying to figure out how to properly explain that
- 43:14it's not, you know, we're not adding Internet money to our
- 43:17building. You know, we, we are trying to
- 43:20hedge against what we think is a, an inflation risk in cost and
- 43:24in income that allows us to at least navigate the, the, the
- 43:30period of time it takes to do what you know, we do as a
- 43:33business. Yeah, for sure.
- 43:37I, I agree. And I also say that let's assume
- 43:41we just assume that we understood that Bitcoin is a a
- 43:46better store of value than real estate and we assume that this
- 43:49mindset over time is a mindset that's generally accepted and
- 43:53over time and maybe a majority of the population will have that
- 43:57mindset. And the speculation that is
- 43:59currently happening in real estate is going to move over
- 44:01into Bitcoin. Real estate development as a
- 44:04business will still be interested, right?
- 44:06And there will still be leverage involved, though differently
- 44:09under Bitcoin standard. That's a topic for its own.
- 44:12But what's important to understand is under a Bitcoin
- 44:16standard, if you take our debt, that debt will increase overtime
- 44:21because generally we'll witness deflation.
- 44:25Money will be scarce. Bitcoin is disinflationary.
- 44:28There's less supply over time, meaning it's purchasing power
- 44:32grows over time. So if you take debt that's
- 44:34denominated in Bitcoin, your debt denominated in Bitcoin
- 44:37grows over time. So there will be different risk
- 44:40allocations and risk factors on a Bitcoin standard.
- 44:43But nonetheless, providing housing is a service that will
- 44:47stay interesting. So the real estate business will
- 44:50not go away. That's that's certain.
- 44:52So now the question is how do you manoeuvre this paradigm
- 44:55shift that's happening? And I think that I would await
- 44:59it. I see Bitcoin also.
- 45:00If you add it to the credit structure, it's almost like
- 45:04you're running a successful retail store on a High Street
- 45:07and you open up a website, right?
- 45:09You'll just open up a new possibility, providing the
- 45:14information that you have, which is what products you have at
- 45:17what price to a broader customer base.
- 45:20So it doesn't mean that you stop operating a shop.
- 45:23It just means that you open up a portal into the Internet and you
- 45:25can grow your business much larger.
- 45:28And it's the same with real estate.
- 45:29Assuming the example of having a property or a development worth
- 45:3410 million, you take on an additional million and and debt
- 45:37on provided as equity to buy Bitcoin.
- 45:41You can actually sleep better at night and focus on developing
- 45:45real estate. You're not so worried about the
- 45:48problems of the political system, geopolitics or other
- 45:53issues because you benefit from the increase in bitcoins value
- 45:57over time and it makes your job easier.
- 46:00And I think any industry over time, I mean, the mining
- 46:03industry is an obvious choice. The oil and gas industry is an
- 46:06obvious choice, but every industry, industry that's debt
- 46:09intense is doing the right move when adding Bitcoin into a
- 46:14credit structure. And this is beneficial for the
- 46:17lender because you hatch against multiple problems, but it's also
- 46:22beneficial for the bank, for the creditor.
- 46:24Because think about it, if you lend somebody money in a debt
- 46:27intensive business, that business becomes increasingly,
- 46:30increasingly risky with more inflation and with the Fiat
- 46:36system in the debt cycle reaching new peaks, new highs,
- 46:40there's a possibility of whoever took out a loan going bankrupt.
- 46:44But if the Bitcoin are then held in a multi custody solution,
- 46:49even if the real estate developer goes bankrupt, you
- 46:52hold custody on the Bitcoin. So also from that perspective,
- 46:55you hatch yourself against against default.
- 46:59So I think it's not just from the perspective of the real
- 47:01estate investor in this particular case, it's also the
- 47:05bank or whoever provides the loan who would benefit greatly
- 47:09from providing additional capital for the purchase of
- 47:12Bitcoin. Yeah, this is the beauty of
- 47:15Bitcoin is the incentive model across from every participant.
- 47:21It makes sense to adopt it. The the sad and, and great part
- 47:25is it's truly asymmetric in the sense that if you adopt it, you
- 47:28will win in the future. If you do not, you will lose.
- 47:31And so it's in that way Darwinistic, which is bad but
- 47:34also or sad, but it's also great for opportunity.
- 47:38It just a contextualize a lot of this.
- 47:41My wife worked for a pretty large tech company and these
- 47:44people make significant amounts of capital.
- 47:46It's kind of Fiat tech company. They take off and you know, bank
- 47:49holidays and work couple hours a day and all that.
- 47:53She doesn't listen to this. So I could say that, but point
- 47:55me is she told me, she told me the other day that so she's on
- 48:00this call with 20 people and they asked a note about, I don't
- 48:04know how it came up, but it's like what would happen if you
- 48:06won the lottery and 18 out of the 20, her and one other person
- 48:11were the only person that didn't answer this this way would say,
- 48:13buy a house. These people cannot afford a
- 48:16home. And she was just shocked because
- 48:18she just doesn't, you know, a lot of people just don't
- 48:20recognize how perverse this problem is because as we all
- 48:23know, you know, feeling secure is a big is a core part of like
- 48:27humanity. And if you can't have your own
- 48:28home, a lot of people don't feel like they can raise a family,
- 48:31they can have kids. And there's just a lot of deep
- 48:33underlying tones that why this is so important from the
- 48:36individual all the way to the, you know, producer of the
- 48:39properties. Yeah, it's a, it's a reasonable
- 48:43point. And you know, a quip that I've
- 48:46heard many times before is like, you can't live in your Bitcoin,
- 48:48right? So like there's, there's obvious
- 48:50utility value associated with real estate.
- 48:52And so to Leon's point, like real estate development's not
- 48:55going away overnight, but there is going to be this, this
- 49:00transitionary period where people start to realize that
- 49:03there's just a sort of more pure form of savings technology that
- 49:07exists. And so they don't need to
- 49:09necessarily, you know, buy the second, third home to store
- 49:12value. They can just buy Bitcoin.
- 49:15You know, I'm curious, you know, we before we, we hit record, you
- 49:18had mentioned that you were at a conference that wasn't a Bitcoin
- 49:21conference, it was a real estate conference.
- 49:23And you were, you were sort of talking about these ideas and
- 49:26these themes and concepts to folks.
- 49:28I'm curious how that was received.
- 49:29And sort of like, you know, I think we've sort of outlined the
- 49:33clear problem here in terms of Fiat inflation, the degradation
- 49:39of quality in real estate over time and this potential
- 49:42solution. So like what is in your mind
- 49:45sort of the, the disconnect that still remains in terms of people
- 49:48in the real estate business who are listening to this
- 49:51conversation or were at the conference where you spoke?
- 49:54What is what are the sort of the few things that they need to
- 49:57understand to realize that this is something they they need to
- 50:01think critically about or they're just going to get left
- 50:03behind basically? I think I'll ask answer your
- 50:09question shortly about how my presentation was perceived by
- 50:14the real estate crowd. But I think Kelly, I'd be
- 50:16interested to hear also how you see it.
- 50:18But talking about myself, real estate development and
- 50:22construction is very stressful. So days can go from 6-7 in the
- 50:27morning until 11:12 at night and you have very little time.
- 50:31So you have very little time to dedicate yourself to studying
- 50:34other technologies or other fields.
- 50:37And especially when interest rates are low, things are going
- 50:40so well that you quickly dismiss other opportunities or other
- 50:45technologies because you think I'm doing so well, I don't need
- 50:49that. I think the reason for myself, I
- 50:52why I became so interested in Bitcoin was because I also
- 50:54learnt about Bitcoin before getting into actual construction
- 50:59and I was sort of addicted to falling to learning about
- 51:04Austrian economics. So that's how Bitcoin really
- 51:06connected with me because throughout school I always knew
- 51:11something is wrong about the inflationary Keynesian monetary
- 51:17system, that we live in it. But I could never really, I
- 51:20didn't really understand why I couldn't point my finger onto
- 51:23the exact issue. And then Austrian economics and
- 51:27learning about the different School of Economics that really
- 51:30helped me to understand the superiority of Bitcoin as a
- 51:37store value. Because we also have to say,
- 51:40especially in the US, there are tax advantages that exist around
- 51:44real estate investing that make it very interesting.
- 51:47And these tax advantages do not yet exist for Bitcoin, even
- 51:51though I believe over time, game theory will cause any
- 51:54jurisdiction that understands the properties of Bitcoin as a
- 51:58scarce form of money to classify Bitcoin as money as what it is,
- 52:03or as legal tender. And don't tax transactions
- 52:06because as long as you tax transactions on Bitcoin, it
- 52:09cannot be used as money. And that is a problem today.
- 52:12But once the tax incentives that exist around real estate will
- 52:16also exist in Bitcoin, I think it'd become more obvious why
- 52:19Bitcoin is such a good store value and not talking about the
- 52:22real estate crowd. So I went to Toronto, some
- 52:26friends of mine there that became friends over time now
- 52:28because we've chatted a lot, They run a real estate brokerage
- 52:32firm called Brockstar Real Estate and they also provide
- 52:34additional info and insights for their clients through a podcast
- 52:39and a newsletter. And I talked in front of I think
- 52:42it was like 1000 plus real estate investors.
- 52:44And I'll be very honest to you, I was shocked by how positive
- 52:48they received whatever I presented to them because when I
- 52:51talk with friends and family still until this day, they don't
- 52:55really understand what I'm doing.
- 52:57Some of my very close associates that I work with and my
- 53:00partners, they do by now because I spent a lot of time writing on
- 53:04this and sharing my articles with them.
- 53:07But business partners that we work with on the construction
- 53:10side especially, they think I'm just a nice guy.
- 53:13That's like a little bit crazy and they hope that I'm not going
- 53:16to go bust. And then within the next decade,
- 53:19that's really their mindset. So then travelling to North
- 53:21America, I think you guys are also a bit ahead of the curve.
- 53:25I have to say that you people in Europe, they tend to adopt
- 53:28technology a little bit later because they are very much
- 53:31intertwined into traditional family structures and
- 53:36communities. And it's similar in Japan.
- 53:38You don't want to make a mistake.
- 53:40If you make a mistake once, people will tell you your whole
- 53:42life you make a mistake. If you make a mistake, It's my
- 53:46perception from North American culture, both Canada and the US,
- 53:50if you make a mistake, people say that he took a risk, he'd do
- 53:53better in the future. So that's why I think that
- 53:57whatever I had to say was perceived well.
- 54:00And, you know, I had interesting conversations afterwards, and I
- 54:05think it's kind of exciting. I feel very, very energized and
- 54:08motivated when I think about the possibilities that Bitcoin
- 54:12brings to the real estate sector.
- 54:15Yeah. What were, what were some of the
- 54:18follow-ups? I'm, I'm sure people came up to
- 54:20you after your presentation and and were curious to learn more.
- 54:24What was what were some of the sort of highlights or excerpts
- 54:27from from some of those conversations?
- 54:29Some people outright said why should I even own a property?
- 54:33I'm just going to sell it and put all my money into Bitcoin.
- 54:36And I said, you know, that's generally speaking not probably
- 54:39not a bad deal. But for example, if you are a
- 54:42real estate developer, you can actually bring your knowledge
- 54:48into a deal, put in zero equity and get 50% of a property.
- 54:53Meaning, let's assume that I have knowledge about real estate
- 54:56development and I have good contacts to a bank and somebody
- 54:59else brings the equity. I can secure financing from the
- 55:03bank and then construct the building.
- 55:06And I brought in 0% equity, no dollar, and I get 50% of the
- 55:10property. That's a good deal.
- 55:12But if you have money that you want to save, just put it into
- 55:16Bitcoin. There's no need to invest it
- 55:17into real estate. That's actually true.
- 55:19Yeah, Yeah, it makes sense. Also where the energy comes from
- 55:23in the sense of we've talked a lot about why this is an
- 55:27opportune time, but to give it some backing in 21, when the
- 55:31price of Bitcoin was rising, we had a lot of conversations with
- 55:34real estate developers and individuals, and it was still
- 55:37very hard. You know, real estate's flying,
- 55:39everyone's happy. The people that we got a lot of
- 55:41traction with and experience specifically in Texas was like
- 55:44with YPO groups, individuals that are running businesses
- 55:47feeling inflation post 2020. But now you have this flipping
- 55:52where interest rates rose faster than they could have ever
- 55:55expected. You have the you know the
- 55:58Bitcoin price going over six figures, which is a is a big
- 56:01moment I think from a psychological perspective.
- 56:03And then this new administration that has become friendly all
- 56:07that converging with the natural increase in inflation and the
- 56:11the cost of goods to produce and then as well as not being able
- 56:14to keep up with rent that it makes sense that now people are
- 56:17looking for solutions. And so, yeah, I don't know
- 56:21Kelly, if any of that supports kind of where you're seeing the
- 56:25the feedback or openness that's probably changed for the past,
- 56:28you know, call it 6 to 12 months versus past, you know, few
- 56:30years. I would say that that people are
- 56:34kind of starting to come around and for, I would hate to use
- 56:37like my experience and say, unfortunately, you know, our
- 56:39properties aren't performing as well as they should be.
- 56:41But it's one of the things that we have to explain and say, hey,
- 56:44you know, internally we know that our costs are going up or
- 56:47that rules are changing and we can't collect the rubs that we
- 56:50used to. So it's, it's a conversation of,
- 56:53OK, well, we know that regulations are getting a little
- 56:56bit tighter than what we would like.
- 56:58Rents are down, you know, 5 to 8% depending on which part of
- 57:02town you're in. And then our expenses continue
- 57:05to go up like 3, you know, at 3% like clockwork.
- 57:08So what, what are we going to do?
- 57:10You know, I'm, I'm in the process of putting together a
- 57:14package to basically show a current pool of investors like,
- 57:18listen, this is something that we can consider.
- 57:20You know, we, we are, we're paying our loans, We have some
- 57:24excess cash. We should consider, you know,
- 57:27putting in 1015% of our cash flows into Bitcoin.
- 57:31And it's not so much that like this is the the Hail Mary to, to
- 57:37get, you know, some sort of specific return that everybody
- 57:40wants. It's like, listen, this is kind
- 57:41of the situation we're in. There's a lot of units coming
- 57:44online. Our expenses are still going up
- 57:47and we are, you know, spending a lot of time managing how to
- 57:51prevent this from happening. This is still where we are.
- 57:55It's it's probably my new hobby horse that, you know, we are at
- 58:01that inflection point where it's like this needs to be something
- 58:05standard that we present. In the past, it's been much
- 58:09harder. I've I'm in the same situation
- 58:11with Leon where, you know, if we are talking to either family and
- 58:16friends, where you're passing, you know, the hat around for
- 58:18money to raise capital for a new project, that it's like Kelly
- 58:22the the the Bitcoin guy is asking for money.
- 58:24Are you going to actually build the building?
- 58:26Are you going to just buy, you know, Bitcoin and send me
- 58:28pictures of somebody else's building?
- 58:30And it's, it's, it's said in jest, but from that perspective,
- 58:34it's like, yeah, I, I'm still kind of in that position where,
- 58:38you know, I wouldn't say I'm not being taken seriously.
- 58:41I'm definitely being taken more seriously with Bitcoin at, you
- 58:44know, 85,000 or up to almost 110,000.
- 58:47So. OK, well, you know what, what's
- 58:50he talking about? Why are, you know, why, why is
- 58:52this happening? And then we, we also have the
- 58:54same conversations where, you know, if we're asking for
- 58:57investor money, if we need 50% equity to get bank financing to
- 59:01construct something, it's like, well, why are we giving you 5
- 59:03million? Why wouldn't I just buy Bitcoin?
- 59:05And I think I heard at a presentation one time, it's
- 59:08like, well, you, you should, you should definitely do that.
- 59:11But you know, at the end of the day, we all have bills to pay
- 59:14and there's value that needs to be created in order to keep our
- 59:18lives going. So, you know, real estate
- 59:20developments not going anywhere. Shelter is a very much needed
- 59:24service. There's got to be somebody that
- 59:26navigates all of the processes and the construction in order to
- 59:30do so. So we're not trying to close up
- 59:33shop and just sell all the assets that we have.
- 59:37We are just trying to maintain the ability to provide a return
- 59:41for a service that, you know, we've been doing for a long
- 59:44time. It's not, you know, people are
- 59:46still being born. People still need a place to
- 59:48live. People need to shop somewhere.
- 59:50They need to work somewhere like this.
- 59:51This stuff isn't just going away.
- 59:53So the the conversations are how do we protect ourselves into the
- 59:57future and. It's that that's kind of, you
- 1:00:02know, that's the hardest part of trying to figure it out.
- 1:00:04So yeah. Yeah, I, I think it's, it's a
- 1:00:08very important framing in terms of the, the downside protection
- 1:00:13sort of narrative. Like this isn't a high risk
- 1:00:16flyer on, on Bitcoin that we're hoping, you know, generates
- 1:00:21these fantastic returns. Like, no, this is, this is
- 1:00:24actually to protect your downside in terms of what you're
- 1:00:27already planning to do and what we can know, you know, pretty
- 1:00:30confidently in terms of the, the erosion of purchasing power and
- 1:00:34Fiat is going to be detrimental to, to whatever your long term
- 1:00:37plan is. And so this is just a way to
- 1:00:39help protect against that. I guess one, one part that I'm
- 1:00:42curious about, and we've sort of alluded to this in, in various
- 1:00:46respects, but like, you know, as this transition begins to play
- 1:00:50out over the next several years and that huge monetary premium
- 1:00:54associated with real estate starts to erode, then what does
- 1:00:58that look like from a sort of profitability standpoint for the
- 1:01:03average real estate developer? If you know that that premium is
- 1:01:07getting eroded and, and probably happens gradually.
- 1:01:10I don't think that that's something that happens
- 1:01:12overnight. People talk about a similar
- 1:01:13dynamic with gold and, and Bitcoin demonetizing gold.
- 1:01:16Like I think that's a very gradual process over probably
- 1:01:19multiple decades. But how do you guys think about
- 1:01:23sort of the prospects for a real estate developer in that world
- 1:01:27where you do start to see that erosion?
- 1:01:29Like how does that impact their unit economics?
- 1:01:32And are they really sort of shit out of luck if they're not
- 1:01:35adopting Bitcoin to some extent in into their plans if that
- 1:01:39actually starts to manifest? Yeah.
- 1:01:42And just before you do so, would love to just add the one last
- 1:01:46point that you had Kelly of the downside protection.
- 1:01:50I think that there's. A great benefit to Bitcoin in
- 1:01:53terms of looking at your investments over a long time
- 1:01:57horizon, but also ensuring that you have liquidity for an asset
- 1:02:01that otherwise is somewhat illiquid, like if you have.
- 1:02:06Stable rents and rising expenses, and you have loan
- 1:02:10obligations. You don't necessarily want to be
- 1:02:12a force seller at the an opportune price if you're 100%
- 1:02:17exposed to real estate. But if you have an asset that's
- 1:02:19liquid 24/7, 365 that is on that is not necessarily tied to the
- 1:02:25real estate. You can instead sell that if
- 1:02:29you're waiting for another time to actually sell your real
- 1:02:31estate, which which is pretty great to have kind of
- 1:02:36uncorrelated more liquid asset. But but sorry didn't, just
- 1:02:41wanted to hop in with with that. Point as well.
- 1:02:45No. And I'd say that you're, you're
- 1:02:47exactly correct. You're in a situation where
- 1:02:49you're, if you are a long time owner and manager of of real
- 1:02:54estate, you are constrained by essentially your cash flows or
- 1:02:58your your property valuations and your ability to pull out a
- 1:03:02positive amount of equity, right?
- 1:03:04So that would be essentially your liquidity in protection.
- 1:03:09Now, if you incorporate something like Bitcoin as, as a
- 1:03:13hedge for, you know, downside, then yes, do have an additional
- 1:03:18release, you know, relief valve if you had to do it.
- 1:03:22Now, one thing to consider with the, I guess the, the inflation
- 1:03:27in the money supply is that when you own real estate, right, the
- 1:03:30idea of protecting your store value is that that inflation can
- 1:03:34benefit you so long as you, you know, you're not a bad operator,
- 1:03:38so to speak, of a property. But on the flip side, if you
- 1:03:42incorporate Bitcoin into that, you are also receiving the
- 1:03:45upsides to that inflation, albeit at a greater advantage,
- 1:03:49right? The price rises faster than the
- 1:03:51inflation does, even if you're using, you know, off market
- 1:03:54statistics like the Chapman index or, or shadow inflation or
- 1:04:00what. I can't remember if that's the
- 1:04:01correct name of that website, but that's kind of like the
- 1:04:03idea. In addition, Oh man, I lost my
- 1:04:11train of thought. Leon, you can take over.
- 1:04:13OK, sure. So I think personally, if you
- 1:04:19really think about it, if you take a alien perspective, let's
- 1:04:23say you're an alien, you're looking onto this world and you
- 1:04:25can see people live very mobile, people travel constantly.
- 1:04:31We have electronic based currency systems and we are
- 1:04:35highly digitalized, but still we use tangible objects to store
- 1:04:39most of our value. So I think there's a mismatch in
- 1:04:43in the way that we operate as a human species and the way that
- 1:04:47we store value. And that mismatch occurred due
- 1:04:50to the absence of a digital store value and due to the
- 1:04:54existence of land as a scarce good.
- 1:04:57I can see why we're using it as a as a predominant store value.
- 1:05:01It's also because real estate yields cash flow, which is not
- 1:05:05used to analyze it as an investment, but it's used to pay
- 1:05:09back the bank who gives you money that didn't exist prior to
- 1:05:12that. It's also very important to
- 1:05:14understand, I think, the dynamics of the Fiat system.
- 1:05:16So for an institution that lends money, real estate development
- 1:05:20is actually great business because you can create money
- 1:05:23that didn't exist prior to that. And then that money can be paid
- 1:05:27back with the rental income, which is also rising with
- 1:05:30inflation. So the interest rates and the
- 1:05:34difference between the money that you need to pay, maybe a
- 1:05:37government bank or another commercial bank that's bigger
- 1:05:39than you that gave you the money to then lend out to.
- 1:05:42We have a constructed property that's a great business model
- 1:05:45for for the bank. And that's also why land, why
- 1:05:47real estate became this predominant store value.
- 1:05:51But now we have Bitcoin. Bitcoin is the digitalization of
- 1:05:54value. The Internet is going to move
- 1:05:56from a place where information was shared and stored to a place
- 1:06:00where value can be shared and stored.
- 1:06:03So naturally humanity will accept that and they'll
- 1:06:07understand that. And that means that if you are
- 1:06:10in real estate development at this point, I personally would
- 1:06:14only stay there if you are a real estate developer.
- 1:06:18If you're a speculative investor, I personally would
- 1:06:21just move on to Bitcoin, to be very honest with you, but
- 1:06:24because. Sorry.
- 1:06:33My nephew, yes. So if you're, if you're on real
- 1:06:37estate development because you're a speculative investor, I
- 1:06:40think you would be better off going into Bitcoin.
- 1:06:43And if you are a real estate developer that isn't real estate
- 1:06:46development because you like the business, you understand the
- 1:06:49insurance and out of it. I would suggest to look at
- 1:06:52Bitcoin to look at ways to integrate it into your business
- 1:06:55model, using it for maintenance reserves, using it to include it
- 1:07:00into new project financing. And also what we have not
- 1:07:04discussed yet, which is very obvious.
- 1:07:06The refinancing of real estate is one of the most interesting
- 1:07:12moves that you could do. As the value of your real estate
- 1:07:15goes up with inflation, you can refi the the portion that you
- 1:07:20haven't financed yet and put that.
- 1:07:21Usually you put it into new development.
- 1:07:23You can also roll it over tax free.
- 1:07:26But what I would suggest you can roll some of the equity, some of
- 1:07:29that capital over into Bitcoin. So you don't necessarily need to
- 1:07:33sell your real estate to benefit from Bitcoin if you are a real
- 1:07:37estate developer. Yeah.
- 1:07:39I mean, this is maybe a great transition to that topic, but
- 1:07:42one thing I wanted to call out as an example, Leon, is we've
- 1:07:46seen this and these are tropes. There's probably a lot more
- 1:07:49relevant ones, but I think of The Big Short and then recently
- 1:07:53in Big Short, they had the strippers that were allocators
- 1:07:55to real estate. And then right, Like it's
- 1:07:59because rising interest rate cost of capital, you know,
- 1:08:02effectively shows everyone they're handed if you're
- 1:08:04actually an expert or if you are just pretending to be 1.
- 1:08:08And it's similar with 2021 and the Airbnb crisis.
- 1:08:11I don't think it gets talked about enough.
- 1:08:12But in every market, everyone was buying these homes to Airbnb
- 1:08:15out low interest rates. People have more capital to
- 1:08:18spend. There's more people working.
- 1:08:21So there's, you know, more tech companies that have hired.
- 1:08:24So you have people traveling and have capital expenditures out
- 1:08:26there. As those interest rates rose,
- 1:08:28we've seen, you know, the the housing market kind of get hit
- 1:08:31with these houses not being filled up on vacation to be
- 1:08:34sold. And this is ties into what we do
- 1:08:36at early writers. We look at like the venture
- 1:08:38capital space in the past, call it 50 years, what was spent to
- 1:08:42be a professional industry meant by people that have built 1st
- 1:08:46and then allocate second has historically turned into this
- 1:08:49monstrosity of anybody says, hey, I'm going to go to school,
- 1:08:52then I'm going to start allocating capital.
- 1:08:54And as the asset price appreciates or Bitcoin becomes
- 1:08:59the cost of capital, you hear this theme is the hurdle rate.
- 1:09:02It becomes very hard for people to return the capital because
- 1:09:05it's very hard for people to spend their Bitcoin.
- 1:09:06You have to produce real value in that world.
- 1:09:10And so maybe some of the strategies to talk about,
- 1:09:12because we've been approached by different real estate investors
- 1:09:16that also grok Bitcoin and they're thinking about whether
- 1:09:19it's to Kelly's point, sweeping cash flow.
- 1:09:21So like one real estate strategy that they have is producing cash
- 1:09:24flow dividends back to their investors.
- 1:09:27What does that look like from some hybrid of BTC and cash or
- 1:09:30sweeping that to increasing the equity value?
- 1:09:33So another strategy that this particular investor did was
- 1:09:37taking that excess capital and then reinvesting in tenant
- 1:09:41improvements to increase the equity value ultimately to sell.
- 1:09:43But what does that look like to put that digital Cafe as you
- 1:09:46reference that as access to now the Internet or Bitcoin and
- 1:09:49increases that and then the access to equity leverage and
- 1:09:53refinancing or things that I think are just starting to be
- 1:09:56seen. Curious how you guys think about
- 1:09:58that and where you see opportunities, you know, on the
- 1:10:00horizon. Hi, everyone, appreciate you
- 1:10:03still listening to the podcast. Hope you're enjoying it.
- 1:10:06Kelly and Leon really brought a lot of information.
- 1:10:09It's an incredible and exciting time given the convergence of
- 1:10:12all things happening global macro, Bitcoin, real estate.
- 1:10:16As a reminder, we touched about it a little bit on the pod and
- 1:10:19last week we launched the Guild network for honor and private
- 1:10:21clients, as well As for early writers investors.
- 1:10:24If you want to learn more about that, reach out to me personally
- 1:10:27Michael at on rampbitcoin.com or contact at earlyriders.com.
- 1:10:33Now as a reminder on ramp offers financial services across the
- 1:10:37spectrum. So it not only you know, manages
- 1:10:40multi institution custody to help secure your asset for long
- 1:10:43term preservation, but also we offer lending, trading,
- 1:10:47inheritance, planning, Iras and much more.
- 1:10:50If you want to get in touch with us, learn more about how we can
- 1:10:52help perfect your custody solution from Single Signature
- 1:10:56Collaborative Custody or Leaving your Bitcoin on a Coinbase or
- 1:10:59Gemini, please reach out to us and we'd love to talk with you.
- 1:11:07Well, I'll jump in the, I think it is a positive effect the the
- 1:11:15real estate cash flows is a is low hanging fruit.
- 1:11:17You can explain that like, listen, even even if we're using
- 1:11:195% of our cash flows to hedge, you know, potential expense
- 1:11:24jumps, then this is OK. Or if it's 10 or 20, whatever it
- 1:11:27is, that's something that you can easily come to.
- 1:11:30The The the other aspect of pulling equity out with a
- 1:11:33refinance is that you know that money is generally tax free.
- 1:11:37So what do you do with it? Normally you distribute it back
- 1:11:39to your investors. But if you are in a long term
- 1:11:44hold position, you can say, listen, here's the thing, we can
- 1:11:48take this money and we can just distribute it or we can take
- 1:11:50this money, you know, hold Bitcoin for this amount.
- 1:11:54You know, we're probably only going to refinance it once,
- 1:11:56maybe twice over a 10 year old. And we're going to roll this
- 1:11:59into the returns in a way that, you know, we're not having to
- 1:12:04sell the Bitcoin at the end of it if we don't want to.
- 1:12:06We can, you know, deliver PC if that's what you want.
- 1:12:08Or, you know, you can, you can obviously take this PC and sell
- 1:12:11it and that's your your gains. On the flip side, what this does
- 1:12:15is that it, it turns the kind of like a merchant building plan or
- 1:12:21business plan, which is what kind of my family has done into
- 1:12:24a long term hold business plan where it's like, listen, we
- 1:12:27actually benefit the longer we hold this with the refinancing
- 1:12:33processes and tools that exist in the United States.
- 1:12:36So if we, if we get all this done and we create this value or
- 1:12:41you know, if we're doing like a value ideal, like what you
- 1:12:43talked about, you buy it, you put some cash into improving
- 1:12:46the, the units or the common areas or you know, repainting
- 1:12:50the building, doing updates, stuff like that.
- 1:12:53And you're able to collect rents greater than the cost that you
- 1:12:56put in on a camp rate basis. It's like, OK, well, now you've
- 1:13:00created value that you can put into Bitcoin and you can hold it
- 1:13:03over a long period of time. What that does is it changes it
- 1:13:07from a transactional nature with real estate to what you know
- 1:13:12would be considered the norm 100 years ago.
- 1:13:14It's like, OK, well, I'm a developer, much like what Leon
- 1:13:17was saying, I'm a developer. I'm going to build this for you
- 1:13:19with our partners, but I'm going to take, you know, a significant
- 1:13:23amount of equity. But we're going to hold this and
- 1:13:25manage it right, because this is essentially our baby.
- 1:13:28We want this to succeed over a long period of time.
- 1:13:31We built it. We, you know, we have
- 1:13:34specifications that we include when we build it because we're
- 1:13:36managing it in a certain way. You know, we're into ultimately
- 1:13:39familiar with the build, the building.
- 1:13:42This isn't like, you know, the fix and flips that were famous
- 1:13:45in the United States from 2006 to 2008 or even from 2019 to
- 1:13:502022 where it's like, you know, I'm in and out of a property in
- 1:13:53three months. It's kind of like a lipstick on
- 1:13:56a big deal where I change the carpets, maybe I change the, the
- 1:13:58countertops and threw in some new appliances and then all of a
- 1:14:01sudden the property is magically worth like $100,000 or more.
- 1:14:04So that's not, that's not what you know we're looking for,
- 1:14:07although that is a business model that you know works with a
- 1:14:10high degree of risk. I think it is a good strategy
- 1:14:16for basically extending the term of real estate ownership saying
- 1:14:20that like, listen, we can extract some value out of this
- 1:14:23using the existing credit Fiat system and refinance.
- 1:14:26We're going to put it into something that can't be debased
- 1:14:29and we are going to ride this out for as long as, you know,
- 1:14:33you want to or as long as we can or as long as we've agreed to in
- 1:14:36that in the end, you know, we're nurturing now 2 assets over a
- 1:14:41long period of time, our Bitcoin and the real estate itself.
- 1:14:45So I think it becomes a much less transactional business
- 1:14:50where it's, it's more of an ownership business and that
- 1:14:53we're we're doing this because we'd like to do it like Leon
- 1:14:56said and that we are hoping to provide the higher quality,
- 1:15:00higher quality of service and the higher quality of product.
- 1:15:05I agree with you, Kelly, and just to add, I would say
- 1:15:11approach your portfolio like without an ego and just be very
- 1:15:15realistic. So if you own assets that are
- 1:15:18non core seldom and buy Bitcoin with it because Bitcoin is the
- 1:15:23new hurdle rate, right Michael, like you said, that's that's a
- 1:15:26fact. Bitcoins increase in purchasing
- 1:15:29year on average year over year. That's the new hurdle rate.
- 1:15:32The new hurdle rate will define how people invest their money.
- 1:15:36And if you understand that, I think it's healthy to look at
- 1:15:40your portfolio if you are a landlord and if you develop
- 1:15:44properties and you manage them, sell non core assets to buy
- 1:15:48Bitcoin, recapitalize with Bitcoin as the capital base of
- 1:15:52your venture. And then secondly, if you if you
- 1:15:55own properties with partners that do not want to sell or you
- 1:15:59do not want to sell because you would have to pay taxes or for
- 1:16:02other reasons, start with the rental income.
- 1:16:06Second, secondly, refinance. And also something I just want
- 1:16:09to mention shortly is Bitcoin mining because what we are doing
- 1:16:13at the moment, we are exploring how we can incorporate Bitcoin
- 1:16:16mining into our developments to save on energy cost.
- 1:16:19So energy costs have skyrocket since the war in East Europe and
- 1:16:27we pass these costs onto tenants, but it just increases
- 1:16:32the living costs. So what we are looking to do is
- 1:16:34we want to incorporate mining. We're doing it right now with
- 1:16:37individual apartments. And as we understand it more, we
- 1:16:40want to incorporate also into new developments to basically
- 1:16:44use the heat that is being produced while mining the extra
- 1:16:48seat 2, then heat the buildings, heat the pool, have warm water
- 1:16:52or use it for other needs. So incorporating Bitcoin mining
- 1:16:57into real estate development is something that I personally find
- 1:16:59very interesting to save on energy cost.
- 1:17:02And a nice side effect is it might be centralized to network
- 1:17:05as well and then for new developments.
- 1:17:08And that's something I'm eagerly working on with some
- 1:17:10institutions right now. And I also created a website
- 1:17:13digitalrealestate.org that you can use to understand this.
- 1:17:19I want to only ideally, ideally only stunt new development
- 1:17:24projects Exactly. If we can also acquire
- 1:17:28additional capital to buy Bitcoin and that would increase
- 1:17:32the investment performance and it would also we hatch against
- 1:17:40the downside. So for all new developments, our
- 1:17:43planners to raise additional capital and buy Bitcoin, we hold
- 1:17:48the Bitcoin in the same entity that also holds the building.
- 1:17:51And then we hatch ourselves against the downside, against
- 1:17:55the possible scenario of the monetary premium that sits in
- 1:17:59real estate flowing into Bitcoin.
- 1:18:02We also create this novel capital base that we can then
- 1:18:04use to potentially also lend against, because you can do
- 1:18:08things with Bitcoin, you can sell it or you can lend against
- 1:18:11it. And I think it's an interesting
- 1:18:13asset to lend against as long as the increase in purchasing power
- 1:18:16of Bitcoin outperforms the rate of Fiat interest rates.
- 1:18:20And I think that will be the case for a long time.
- 1:18:23And what you can see here, actually in the model in the
- 1:18:26year 2025, you can see there's Bitcoin acquired, sorry, there's
- 1:18:32a real estate project worth 10 million, and you add a million
- 1:18:36in Bitcoin on top of it. And then over time, you can see
- 1:18:39how it increases the investment performance.
- 1:18:42And it's crazy. I mean, as a Bitcoiner, we
- 1:18:44understand this, but we've built this model to help real estate
- 1:18:48developers understand and visualize the paradigm shift
- 1:18:53that Bitcoin really brings us, this near perfect form of money
- 1:18:56and near perfect store value. Yeah, it's it's an excellent
- 1:19:00breakdown and truly like the basis of our full thesis at this
- 1:19:04firm is what Brian alluded to in the beginning is professional.
- 1:19:07We've historically in the 1st 15 years of Bitcoin seen the
- 1:19:11tinkerers that like to play with it, but haven't had the
- 1:19:14professional experience to understand how do you actually
- 1:19:16infuse the asset to make it make sense outside of Bitcoin.
- 1:19:20And the reality is something that we can't really fully
- 1:19:24comprehend because we're so far down the rabbit hole.
- 1:19:26But Kelly alluded to it earlier is, well, why wouldn't they just
- 1:19:29buy it? And it's like, we'll, we'll do
- 1:19:31it. And the problem is that a, they,
- 1:19:32they won't do it. And even if they did, they won't
- 1:19:35hold it through that volatility because there's a lot of work
- 1:19:39that takes for somebody to see that volatility because we're
- 1:19:41going to see volatility for a while.
- 1:19:43Maybe it'll dampen a bit. But the reality is there's a lot
- 1:19:46of value to deliver an operational excellence from the
- 1:19:49background that you guys have. And then once you layer on
- 1:19:52Bitcoin, that's how you blend that return profile to downside
- 1:19:55protect with the real estate with the upside of bitcoins
- 1:19:57appreciation. And there's just going to be a
- 1:19:59lot of money to be made because that story hasn't been told to
- 1:20:01the private markets yet on specifically private capital.
- 1:20:04And then obviously the banks are slowly warming up to this.
- 1:20:07And ideally that's going to blend together because obviously
- 1:20:10banks have the lowest cost of capital because it's inorganic.
- 1:20:13But yeah, it's it's truly an exciting time because all of
- 1:20:15this like story is starting to converge into something that can
- 1:20:18be distilled and there's a 15 year track record to support it.
- 1:20:22Yeah, the other, the other component that that just made me
- 1:20:25think of Michael as like it's similar to the dynamic that we
- 1:20:28talked about on the custody side of things where, you know, until
- 1:20:32someone really gets burned or they feel the pain of an
- 1:20:35inferior custody system, it you almost need that pain in in
- 1:20:40order to incentivize someone to see the vision of a superior
- 1:20:44form of custody. I'm saying that's similar in
- 1:20:47some respect to like what I think how this will play out
- 1:20:49over the next decade or so is like there will be early movers
- 1:20:53that that see this and, and understand Bitcoin and
- 1:20:55understand how it can basically trust that model that we just
- 1:20:59had up on the on the page. But there's going to be a whole
- 1:21:02slew of investors and real estate folks who just, you know,
- 1:21:06either haven't done the actual real work on Bitcoin to to
- 1:21:10believe that story. And so in my mind, like they're
- 1:21:14going to have to see some pain of not adopting Bitcoin
- 1:21:17basically and seeing other real estate developers flourish as
- 1:21:21they do adopt Bitcoin. And then at some point there's
- 1:21:24going to be a realization of like, OK, like that is the thing
- 1:21:27and I need to adopt it, otherwise I'm going to die.
- 1:21:29Because I mean, that's, and I'm sure Leon and and Kelly, you're
- 1:21:33seeing sort of some early movement into this space, but I
- 1:21:37would imagine it's few and far between still like relative to
- 1:21:39the broader landscape of real estate development.
- 1:21:43And so I think there there might need need to be a little bit
- 1:21:46more pain in terms of people, you know, running into these
- 1:21:51inflationary headwinds in their typical real estate practices
- 1:21:55before they actually wake up to the solution.
- 1:21:57Would you guys agree with that sort of line of thinking?
- 1:21:59Just add one thing. This is actually how Leon and I
- 1:22:02first hit it off over a dinner a few years ago was referencing.
- 1:22:06You can make the case that up until today or with multi
- 1:22:08institution, you couldn't really execute on the strategy because
- 1:22:11ultimately maybe they they got the strategy right.
- 1:22:15In the same way it's easy to buy Bitcoin, but it's hard to hold
- 1:22:17it because you left it on Celsius block by FTX mount Cox,
- 1:22:21you can go down the whole list. And so Bitcoin is insanely
- 1:22:25volatile and to insert it in traditional financial constructs
- 1:22:29or instruments and their type of custody, which is single party,
- 1:22:33you're embedding more risk on top of another risky model
- 1:22:38because this is all risk, this is investment and you have to
- 1:22:40lower that that risk. And so that redundancy and fault
- 1:22:43tolerance built in a multi institution in my mind is how
- 1:22:46you can actually start to build these contracts where you can at
- 1:22:48least downside protect that the custodial solution won't fail.
- 1:22:52And then you have to now execute as the asset manager.
- 1:22:56So that's, I think, a part of that.
- 1:22:59Totally, yeah, because we haven't even really touched on
- 1:23:01that component of it too. But it's like even if you get a
- 1:23:03real estate guy to believe all this, it's like, OK, well then
- 1:23:06what? What do I do with the Bitcoin?
- 1:23:07Do I leave it on Coinbase? Like probably not, can't really
- 1:23:10do this with the ETF. So you need you need the actual
- 1:23:14underlying collateral to do it. But then the question is how do
- 1:23:17you actually hold it for 10 plus years, right.
- 1:23:20And that's, that's something that I think we're on to and on
- 1:23:22the custody side, but still very early in sort of the market
- 1:23:26realizing that. Yeah.
- 1:23:30I. Would agree.
- 1:23:31So one of the things that I've mentioned was the you know, when
- 1:23:35or to Michelle point and to your point, Brian, is that a lot of
- 1:23:40individuals experiences individual loss or custody
- 1:23:43problems and not necessarily understanding that there are
- 1:23:47now, you know, professional solutions where, you know, multi
- 1:23:51institutional custody is like this is the the Cadillac of
- 1:23:55doing it in a professional sense, right.
- 1:23:57So if we're if myself or Leon are trying to convince people
- 1:24:00like, well, how do I how are you going to hold the Bitcoin when I
- 1:24:03put it on Celsius or block fly and it's gone.
- 1:24:06It's like, OK, well, that was years ago and now we have new
- 1:24:10services that are being provided by something, you know, company
- 1:24:13like on ramp where you have multi institutional custody,
- 1:24:15your keys aren't being held by you.
- 1:24:17It's not on a calculator looking piece of plastic in, you know,
- 1:24:21the in your junk drawer in your kitchen that you forgot about
- 1:24:23five years ago, right. So it is changing in that when
- 1:24:29I've had these conversations before, I'm like, no, listen,
- 1:24:32like we're not leaving it on Coinbase.
- 1:24:34We're going to put it in a special custody solution where
- 1:24:37it's not just going to disappear.
- 1:24:39These are people who do this professionally and this is how
- 1:24:42they hold it. But one other thing I wanted to
- 1:24:44mention is that, you know, when you said that there's got to be
- 1:24:47paying for this kind of thing to happen, I think we're going
- 1:24:50through that to a degree now at least a lot of the projects that
- 1:24:54were built or came online in the US, at least in Phoenix in you
- 1:24:58know, the 2020 to 2022 or 2023 era, if those are being sold
- 1:25:03now, they're being sold essentially at cost or slightly
- 1:25:07below cost. So there, there is no equity for
- 1:25:11either the builder or the Equity Partners to take home when it's
- 1:25:14being sold. It's just being sold because it
- 1:25:16has to go, right. If there's, if the, if the debt
- 1:25:19covenants are being forced upon them by the bank and say, you
- 1:25:23know what, it's got to go, you can't afford it.
- 1:25:25And if the Equity Partners aren't going to raise the money
- 1:25:27to pay down the loan if they don't meet like a debt service
- 1:25:30coverage ratio test, then it's like it's OK to the market we
- 1:25:34go. And I've looked at probably half
- 1:25:36a dozen deals in the last month. I would say where you're buying
- 1:25:42it for, you know, ten 2025% below the cost of like what it
- 1:25:46would take for me to build it, right?
- 1:25:48And that's not like my fees or the investors return or
- 1:25:51anything. This is just the sticks and
- 1:25:52stones cost of doing it. So it's a, it's AI think it's an
- 1:25:56opportune time to say like, Hey, listen, if we, if we protect our
- 1:26:00downside from what's going on right now, the pain that you're
- 1:26:03experiencing, this is kind of a scenario that we can look at and
- 1:26:06say, OK, well, it's not a, it's not a total loss, right?
- 1:26:09You didn't get wiped out on your equity.
- 1:26:11So and then, you know, with multi institution custody, it's
- 1:26:14like this is, you know, this isn't me holding it on your
- 1:26:18behalf. This is a third party, a
- 1:26:20professional service that's holding it.
- 1:26:22And you can read all about their qualifications.
- 1:26:25Yeah, absolutely. I know what I said we're.
- 1:26:28We're coming up on time, but I have a question for you guys in
- 1:26:31the sense of like the door into Bitcoin from real estate is only
- 1:26:35so, so big. And as the price appreciates, it
- 1:26:38gets smaller, right? Because more awareness.
- 1:26:40People all come to these, you know, conclusions on their own
- 1:26:43volition. And curious how you guys like
- 1:26:45talk about or think about it. The reason why I'm asking is I
- 1:26:48don't know if you've ever, I'm sure some people seen this
- 1:26:50margin called fantastic movie. I rewatched it this weekend and
- 1:26:54they ultimately have a fire sell on equities because they're just
- 1:26:57like the first one, you know, through the door is the one that
- 1:26:59kind of makes it in that position.
- 1:27:01And so I think about real estate in that sense.
- 1:27:03Like obviously the Fed would step in if there's a
- 1:27:05deleveraging, but it's still the same aspect.
- 1:27:07Like you can get out of the position for pennies on the
- 1:27:09dollar, but you're ultimately going to be buying much less
- 1:27:11Bitcoin once you come if you have a billion dollar portfolio.
- 1:27:15I'm just curious if you guys think about that or how you
- 1:27:18think about it or it or talk about it.
- 1:27:22You know, I, I mean, I have a profound sense of urgency,
- 1:27:24urgency when it comes to that. I feel that we have to move very
- 1:27:29quickly, very fast. Bitcoin monetizes so fast that
- 1:27:32if you don't act quickly, you will be penalized over time.
- 1:27:36But that pain is also important for you to get going.
- 1:27:40So I think that people might dismiss it now, but in five
- 1:27:44years and 10 years, the pain will be so strong that then
- 1:27:47they'll jump in. So I personally have a very,
- 1:27:51very strong sense of urgency. But I do believe even if you
- 1:27:55don't want to go full into Bitcoin, if you don't want to
- 1:27:57sell core assets, if you don't feel like refinancing property
- 1:28:01to buy Bitcoin is a good idea, or if you don't think you should
- 1:28:03include Bitcoin directly into project financing, I think at
- 1:28:08five years you would think so and 10 years you would think so.
- 1:28:10Everybody would think so at some point because Bitcoin is the new
- 1:28:14hurdle of it. It's not going to go away.
- 1:28:16It just takes time for that information for the majority to
- 1:28:20be absorbed. Yeah, that's, it's very well
- 1:28:23said. I think you're starting to see
- 1:28:27early signs of, of people recognizing that.
- 1:28:29But like I think, yeah, we're, we're still very early things
- 1:28:32like, you know, if the US government ultimate issues pit
- 1:28:35bonds like that would be a a strong signal that like, you
- 1:28:39know, this is manifesting. It's it's sort of bleeding into
- 1:28:42all other aspects of traditional finance and and structure
- 1:28:45products. Who knows if we actually see
- 1:28:48the, the United States government issue bit bonds as a
- 1:28:50topic for another day. But something like that would be
- 1:28:54a a very strong signal to the average person that like, OK,
- 1:28:57like this is a real thing. Like I need to think about it
- 1:28:59more critically. But yeah, I know we're, we're a
- 1:29:03little over time, but maybe where can, where can we point
- 1:29:06folks to to learn more? Both Kelly and Leon?
- 1:29:08I know Leon, you're also finishing up a, a book that
- 1:29:11you've been working on. So want to let you pump that as
- 1:29:14well. Yeah, I'm eagerly also waiting
- 1:29:20for Kelly's feedback because what Kelly really did he put me
- 1:29:24on to or he made me think about the effects of of Bitcoin on
- 1:29:28architecture and Bitcoin urbanism.
- 1:29:30So the designs of our cities that are also not only but there
- 1:29:35are result of of Fiat money. I think that modernism and Fiat
- 1:29:40money and modern architecture, the Bauhaus and the
- 1:29:44International Style that came from sub from from urban America
- 1:29:48in the 50s, it's all intertwined.
- 1:29:51So they all came into existence in the early 20th century.
- 1:29:55So they worked in tandem. Sometimes they benefited each
- 1:29:58other, sometimes they didn't. But there is a big effect of, of
- 1:30:02the way that we store value and the way that we organize cities
- 1:30:05because the financialization of the SA class real estate and
- 1:30:09commuting with cars and so forth has arguably destroyed
- 1:30:14communities. And that's something that I'm
- 1:30:16working on right now and eagerly awaiting Kelly's feedback on
- 1:30:21that. And the book, which has the
- 1:30:23word, the name Digital real Estate will be released in Q4 of
- 1:30:26this year. And I have 3 chapters in the
- 1:30:29book, 3 main chapters. The first one is the investment
- 1:30:32thesis about real estate and Bitcoin being very similar or
- 1:30:36the same with Bitcoin being the better store of value.
- 1:30:40The 2nd chapter really is a handbook of how to include
- 1:30:43Bitcoin into real estate development.
- 1:30:45And the 3rd and final chapters on the socio economic effects
- 1:30:49that Bitcoin as a new hurdle rate will have on real estate
- 1:30:52investments, interest rates and so forth.
- 1:30:56And the website that you guys just shared, digital
- 1:30:59realestate.org, it's for free. So you guys go ahead and use it.
- 1:31:04You can include Bitcoin into your financing models, and maybe
- 1:31:07it helps you understand why including Bitcoin into real
- 1:31:11estate financing is helpful. Awesome.
- 1:31:15Kelly, where can folks find you? Well, I, you can find me on
- 1:31:19Twitter slash X at KT Lannon LANNAN or at
- 1:31:24bitcoinurbanism.substack.com. And that's probably the the best
- 1:31:31places to go. I, I know I've told Mike about
- 1:31:34this. I've recently stepped back from
- 1:31:35the family business and I'm exploring some opportunities to
- 1:31:38do Bitcoin and real estate more, I guess concretely.
- 1:31:44So, yeah, reach out to me there if this is something that
- 1:31:47interests you guys or if you just want to chat about it.
- 1:31:50I I love getting the DMS because there's always fun conversations
- 1:31:55after these kind of podcasts and stuff go live.
- 1:31:57So yeah, reach out to me through the website
- 1:32:00thebitcoinurbanism.subsec.com or Twitter.
- 1:32:02Katie Lennon. Awesome.
- 1:32:05Well, thank you, gentlemen. This has been a fascinating
- 1:32:07discussion and I think will be very useful for folks in real
- 1:32:10estate and elsewhere to to learn about this convergence.
- 1:32:13So thank you both for joining the show.
- 1:32:16Thanks guys. Thank you guys.
- 1:32:19Take care boys. Hi everyone.
- 1:32:23Thanks for tuning in to another episode of Final Settlement.
- 1:32:25We had an awesome pod with Leon welcome and Kelly and Lannon
- 1:32:29talking about all things real estate, Bitcoin, and the future
- 1:32:32they both hold. Appreciate you listening to the
- 1:32:36podcast. If you enjoy everything that
- 1:32:37we're producing, please like and subscribe and share it with your
- 1:32:41network. As a reminder, on Ramp is your
- 1:32:44trusted partner in securing generational wealth.
- 1:32:46Whether you're an individual that's been holding Bitcoin for
- 1:32:48years or a net newcomer looking to build a material position and
- 1:32:53want to figure out a way not only to secure it against any
- 1:32:58kind of physical attacks, but also, you know, single custodial
- 1:33:01failure, but also for friends and family that are looking to
- 1:33:04get in this space. As you may know, we offer multi
- 1:33:07institution custody that perfects custody from having a
- 1:33:11single counterparty be your Bitcoin holder or potentially
- 1:33:15lose those assets, but then also helping individuals that have
- 1:33:19historically had to rely on self custody by storing hardware
- 1:33:22devices spread across their house, city or state.
- 1:33:26You can reach out to us at honor@bitcoin.com or you can
- 1:33:29shoot me a note. I'd love to hear from everyone
- 1:33:31at Michael at honor@bitcoin.com. Thanks.
- 1:33:35Thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:33:37If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:33:39episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:33:42app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:33:44today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:33:47Before we finish, a quick reminder that On Ramp Media is
- 1:33:49for informational and entertainment purposes only, and
- 1:33:52nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:33:55Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:33:58to hear from you. Visit on rampbitcoin.com/contact
- 1:34:01to schedule a consultation with one of our private Client
- 1:34:04advisors.