Latest / The Sticky From The Inside Podcast / Remote and Hybrid Didn’t Break Your Culture, They Revealed It
Transcript
- 0:10Hello and welcome to Sticky from the Inside, the employee engagement podcast that looks at how to build stickier, competition-smashing, consistently successful organisations from the inside out.
- 0:22I'm your host Andy Goram and I'm on a mission to help more businesses turn the lights on behind the eyes of their employees, light the fires within them and create tonnes more success for everyone.
- 0:39This podcast is for all those who believe that's something worth going after and would like a little help and guidance in achieving that.
- 0:46Each episode we dive into the topics that can help create what I call stickier businesses, the sort of businesses where people thrive and love to work, and where more customers stay with you and recommend you to others because they love what you do and why you do it.
- 1:03So, if you want to take the tricky out of being sticky, listen on.
- 1:10Okay then, so let's just start with a story most of us will probably recognise.
- 1:18A team goes remote or hybrid.
- 1:21All of a sudden, performance starts to dip, maybe a bit of tension creeps in, misunderstandings start to grow, trust begins to fade and is eventually maybe even lost.
- 1:34The leaders and managers of that organisation start saying and believing things like, oh it's so much harder to manage people now, this hybrid working thing has, well it's broken our culture, remote just doesn't work for us.
- 1:48And you know what, maybe that's true, but maybe it's not.
- 1:52I just wonder if, I wonder if today's working environment actually broke anything at all.
- 1:59Did it really break it or perhaps has it just removed the scaffolding or pulled back the curtain to reveal what was probably already there before?
- 2:10You know, the stuff like the office talk, the body language we feel and see, the glances, the tones, the subtle cues, we didn't even realise we were relying on to keep work, well, working.
- 2:23What if it didn't change human behaviour at all but exposed the human systems we'd accidentally built and showed them to be far more fragile than perhaps we imagined, or even if we even thought about in the first place.
- 2:37Systems that relied on proximity instead of clarity, presence instead of trust, time instead of output, that kind of thing.
- 2:46Well my guest today thinks that when we stop blaming people and start examining the conditions they're working in, a very interesting picture emerges.
- 2:57Ellie Holbert is the founder of Impact Advisory Services and she works with leaders and teams to understand why good people end up behaving oddly, why performance slips without anyone quite knowing why, and how to redesign the fundamentals so work actually works again.
- 3:16So to be clear, I don't expect this to be a conversation about whether remote or hybrid work is good or bad.
- 3:23I expect it to be a conversation about what it has revealed.
- 3:26Ellie, welcome to the show.
- 3:28Thank you so much for having me, Andy.
- 3:30I'm so excited to be here with you today.
- 3:33I'm really really looking forward to this conversation.
- 3:36I think we have talked a lot and when I say we, I mean the world has talked a lot about the pros and cons of hybrid and remote and I don't know we've always been talking about the right things and maybe we'll get a chance to sort of dig into some of that today.
- 3:51So yeah, I'm really looking forward to it.
- 3:53It's a topic I think a lot of people are sort of facing into at the moment.
- 3:56Before we start getting all excited and passionate about the things we're going to kind of go through today, let's just take a pause.
- 4:02Do us a favor, Ellie.
- 4:03Give us a nice better introduction to you, what you do, and what you focus on today for us.
- 4:09Sure, absolutely.
- 4:10Well, as you mentioned, I'm Ellie Holbert.
- 4:11I founded a consultancy called Impact Advisory Services where I work with HR leaders and executives to improve the resilience and the performance of their remote and dispersed teams.
- 4:23So I have about a decade of management consulting experience and as a management consultant, what I found time and time again was that organizations would be willing to invest resources into new tools, new technologies, re-orgs, but that they did not necessarily achieve the value and the output they were looking for because the team required to deliver that work was not set up for success.
- 4:48And so in my experience, I decided to take a different approach and I developed a playbook for creating the framework that enables high performance across teams regardless of location.
- 5:01And I found that this playbook works regardless of industry, regardless of business size.
- 5:06And since then I have been on a quest, if you will, to unlock the value that is hidden within organizations simply because the conditions for that top performance need to be refined and specifically to do that for remote and dispersed teams.
- 5:22I love that.
- 5:23I love actually also speaking to somebody who's had so much focus on remote and
- 5:26dispersed pre and post pandemic because I think that's fascinating because you will have seen
- 5:33what was already in existence before and organizations that made this stuff work
- 5:38post the kind of hot mess we've all got embroiled in post pandemic when we've, I guess a larger
- 5:43number of people have had to look at this pretty quickly and make a lot of decisions on the fly.
- 5:49Absolutely.
- 5:50What I found in terms of work before the pandemic was that there were still very much gaps.
- 5:55It was not perfect by any means, but that people were able to lean into the performance of work rather than the proof of the work itself.
- 6:04And that the performance of work is much harder to conduct in a remote setting.
- 6:09We do not have those informal cues, the body language to signal influence and authority.
- 6:15Really our work has to speak for itself in a more clear way.
- 6:19And that's really the crux of why it has been so challenging is that remote just revealed gaps that were already there and it took away our ability to smooth over those gaps.
- 6:28I think that's the thing I'd like to kind of dig into this.
- 6:32I don't know.
- 6:32I might use the word myth, but I don't know if hybrid and remote has broken culture.
- 6:39I mean, there's been enough stuff written to say that it has, but in your experience from what you've just sort of said, that doesn't necessarily ring true, right?
- 6:49So if you were to sort of like talk to your past self in from your future position, what would you be whispering in your ear right now to say, hey, hey, hey, pull back the curtain, have a little closer look at this.
- 7:02What are the sort of, I guess, elements of that myth that you've seen?
- 7:06Yes, absolutely.
- 7:08I think it depends on how culture is defined.
- 7:11So when people describe their experience of closeness in a collective environment as culture, yes, remote does complicate that.
- 7:20Connection can still, of course, be established.
- 7:22I've seen incredibly well-connected remote teams, but it does look different.
- 7:26However, I describe or rather define culture as how we get work done around here.
- 7:32And here is not physical.
- 7:33It's not bound by time and space.
- 7:35It's simply, how do we get work done here?
- 7:38And so remote culture, it is different from in-person culture in that it requires a different level of intention and it requires a different level of structure, process clarity, role clarity, but also communication.
- 7:53Part of why this is the case is that in a remote setting, we lose so many of the signals that we use to detect, but also communicate safety and belonging and influence.
- 8:05So when we look at human communication, there are nine different forms of human communication.
- 8:11In a remote setting, only one is fully available, and that is our verbal words.
- 8:16There are others that are somewhat available, like our pace, our cadence, our tone, our facial expressions, but those are actually somewhat distorted by technology.
- 8:24And so often those signals can add more ambiguity than they do clarity.
- 8:28So what that means is we are trying to communicate the same level of clarity and influence and connection with one of the nine available forms of communication.
- 8:39And so that's why remote can feel so challenging is because the direct verbal communication required, it is an outsized amount.
- 8:48It can feel very unnatural for the communicator and the person being communicated to.
- 8:54It can feel a bit off-putting, sometimes even threatening if trust is not in place.
- 8:59All of that to say this is why it's so important to lean into creating trust and clarity and systems because in our interpersonal work remotely, we need to communicate in a very direct verbal manner to be effective.
- 9:14So this sounds fascinating to me, right?
- 9:18You've chucked in some numbers in there.
- 9:20You've talked about the sort of levels of communication or even methods, channels of communication, and actually sort of saying, well, remote hybrid, whatever you want to call it, cuts a lot of them out, right?
- 9:33And it only leaves one maybe behind.
- 9:37Can we dig into that a little bit?
- 9:39Because I'm interested to try and think about and get your sense on, as humans, how we actually function in the work setting and communication must play such a fundamental role in that.
- 9:52What do you think are the key lessons that we can learn then from very successful remote organisations, dispersed organisations, and take into more of the, well, maybe less intentionally remote, but now working in this new environment, we've got a blend going on.
- 10:08What are some of the key things you think we need to lean into?
- 10:11Yes, I would say it is incredibly beneficial to think about the neuroscience behind our collective human behaviour and organisations, but also as it pertains to communication.
- 10:23And specifically, I mean, the level of threat detection that our brains conduct on an ongoing basis, completely unconsciously.
- 10:32Our brains scan our environment, I believe a recent statistic I read was every six seconds, we subconsciously scan our environment for signs of safety.
- 10:40And we do that virtually as well as in person.
- 10:43And so I think leaders of organisations especially need to recognise how frequently their employees are looking for signs that they are safe and that they belong or trying to detect threat that may suggest they are not safe and they do not belong.
- 11:02And the reason I bring that up is when we think of the neuroscience behind this, there are different parts of the brain, they're responsible for different things, it's very important that they are all supported in doing their job well.
- 11:14So we have the amygdala, that's the fight or flight part of our brain, we have the prefrontal cortex that's responsible for our personalities, judgment, strategic thinking.
- 11:23What happens is when we are in an environment of high ambiguity, our brains generally speaking will interpret that ambiguity as threat.
- 11:32And our amygdala comes online, the prefrontal cortex essentially goes offline, we don't have access to it.
- 11:38And so what we want to see is an environment where people are able to cool down their amygdalas and be able to access their prefrontal cortex because that's where bold action comes from, that's where innovation comes from, that's where strategy comes from.
- 11:53And so we can actually use neuroscience as an advantage in understanding the goal here is to transmit signals of safety so that people can do their best work.
- 12:04And I love warm and fuzzy, don't get me wrong, I love warm and fuzzy, but this is actually not even about warm and fuzzy, this is neuroscience and applying these principles is highly profitable and will lead to better business outcomes.
- 12:17So I would say we need to think about how do we transmit and connect, transmit those signals of safety and to do so consistently over time.
- 12:26That applies to in-person settings, hybrid settings, but especially applies in a remote setting.
- 12:33We need to think about how do we create clarity and structure and process so that people have less ambiguity, so that the ambiguity they do need to manage is not so overwhelming and interpreted as so threatening that they shut down and are not able to do their best work.
- 12:51I think this is what I find fascinating because those things still are just as important in a non-dispersed organisation, right?
- 13:00They're just human fundamentals.
- 13:03It's just our ability to pick up on them when we're not necessarily in the proximity of people that's different.
- 13:08I love the fact that you talk about it needing to be more intentional.
- 13:12So we've really got to design the systems, the processes, the methods of communication where we're, I guess, echoing or at least communicating the structure around clarity or giving people clarity, helping them feel safe.
- 13:28I think the thing about this is that I found fascinating is if we think about
- 13:32the structure of empowerment, right, the need for clarity and freedom, that lovely blend of
- 13:39knowing exactly where you're going and what you've got to do, but being given the opportunity for
- 13:44self-expression within that framework, that sounds from what you're saying to take on a very
- 13:49different guise in a remote and hybrid setting.
- 13:53Have I interpreted that correctly?
- 13:56Absolutely, because in an in-person setting we are able to organically understand with a bit more context what is appropriate and inappropriate risk-taking within that organisational culture.
- 14:10We can pick up on that pretty easily in an in-person setting with those nine signals available to us.
- 14:17In a remote setting, we're trying to understand the level of experimentation that is acceptable using only verbal communication.
- 14:25So what does that mean?
- 14:26That means that people, employees, individual contributors, they are put in a position of having to experiment and find the guardrails often by bumping right into them or stepping on each other's toes.
- 14:40And that's what we don't want to see.
- 14:41I think often leaders, because leaders are generally speaking in a hierarchical position of authority or status or power, they sometimes forget what it feels like at the different levels where those things are not in place.
- 14:58And so in my advisory and coaching work with leaders, I often encourage them to remember we need to lower the bravery bar here and help people experiment more boldly.
- 15:10And it is the leader's job to set up those guardrails of what is appropriate experimentation, what types of pushing back, constructive criticism, continuous learning, innovation as a team.
- 15:23It's on the leader to create the forums for that to occur and it's on the leader to make clear what is the boundary in terms of bold experimentation.
- 15:33I love that.
- 15:35You make me smile when you talk about we forget when we get to different levels.
- 15:39I mean, I instantly think of the sort of whole Dunning-Kruger effect and the bit that, you know, you don't know what you don't know at the beginning and you have huge amounts of confidence around that sort of stuff.
- 15:49But as soon as you see it, you start to wonder if you'll ever get to grips with this.
- 15:52And by the time you've mastered it, you forget the poor people at the end.
- 15:57And that happens all the time, right?
- 16:00Unintentionally, maybe, but it happens all the time and causes lots of issues.
- 16:04I think this reliance on verbal or even the backup, I guess, of written communication also leans into the fact that the understanding of psychological traits and behavioural preferences in this setting is really important, right?
- 16:18Because I would imagine that there is more danger for misinterpretation of message in this setting based on our behavioural preferences.
- 16:29If we don't recognise those different communication preferences, then we're going to get ourselves in hot water more often.
- 16:35We're going to lead to perhaps more ambiguity or lack of clarity.
- 16:38And that's a different challenge for leaders in that dispersed world.
- 16:43Absolutely.
- 16:44And I think, Andy, you bring up a great point, which is we need to make the invisible visible.
- 16:50There are many different ways that we can do this.
- 16:52Like you said, with those behavioural preferences, those thinking styles, I see a lot of effective teams apply assessments, both for understanding of themselves, but also to have a shared language for communicating with one another, where there's no personalisation of blame.
- 17:09It's a matter of styles.
- 17:10And all of the styles are equally valid.
- 17:12We just need to work through understanding one another's natural styles and also being able to flex our own so that we are able to work effectively with others that may think or communicate differently.
- 17:22So I do recommend assessments as a great way to have shared language that is not personal.
- 17:28It provides a great framework for doing that.
- 17:30And in addition to the assessments, when we think about making the invisible visible, I find that many teams often take the very basics for granted.
- 17:41And by that, I mean, there's an assumption about people knowing what they are supposed to do, about others knowing what everybody else is there to do.
- 17:49These very basic things, we can't take them for granted, especially in a remote setting.
- 17:55Gallup actually found that only 47% of employees know what is expected of them at work.
- 18:02So as a baseline, and this included co-located teams, as a baseline, there is a less than 50% chance that each person on your team knows what they are there to do.
- 18:11And then, oh, go ahead.
- 18:13No, no, no.
- 18:15I've heard this stat.
- 18:16I work with this stat many, many, many times.
- 18:19And every time someone else utters it, I have a bit of a brain meltdown because I'm just like, that's just madness, right?
- 18:25Like over 50% of the workforce state that they don't know what they're there to do.
- 18:31Exactly.
- 18:31I will say as well, I see that in my work with organizations.
- 18:36I see evidence for that statistic all the time.
- 18:39And part of my role often is to go into an organization.
- 18:43I assess the health, the effectiveness of their teams.
- 18:46I help them come up with very specific plans and programs for improving their performance and their effectiveness.
- 18:53And in doing so, I've assessed many teams.
- 18:55I have yet to assess a team where when I come in, everybody can name what everybody else is there to do.
- 19:03That has not happened a single time.
- 19:06That is such a great point.
- 19:08Again, living in our own heads, living in our own four walls, not making the connection to the person, maybe in the old way of working was sat next to us.
- 19:17We might be able to get a bit more of a feeling on that.
- 19:18But yeah, having a broader sense of what everybody else is going on, that must contribute not only to clarity, but to that sense of community and belonging in that organization as well, right?
- 19:29Absolutely.
- 19:30Because to remedy this, people have to basically admit that they don't know.
- 19:35And that requires a level of emotional exposure that most people are not willing to take very understandably.
- 19:41Especially, I will say in the United States, I see more dramatic examples of this because so much depends on our employment.
- 19:48Our access to health care depends on our employment.
- 19:50So leaders need to understand that how much they are asking people to risk when they're asking people to speak openly and honestly.
- 19:59So to remedy that, you have to admit that you don't know.
- 20:03And then other people likely have to meet you halfway and admit that they don't know either.
- 20:07And that is not necessarily what often happens.
- 20:10And asking these basic questions, I'm amazed at the value and the performance enablement that can happen from just working on those two specific practices of defining what everybody is there to do and making sure everybody knows what everybody else is there to do.
- 20:28Teams transform when they address just those two incredibly basic fundamentals.
- 20:34I don't know about you, Ellie.
- 20:35Maybe it's just my own imposter.
- 20:37But when we start talking about these things, I feel like a proper fraud because these feel, like you've said, like basic, fundamental, foundational things that everybody should understand and every leader should have at the top of their list.
- 20:52And yet it's just based on assumption most of the time that people know these things.
- 20:59And I think as soon as you do start to sort of pull back the curtain, lots of this stuff is revealed, right?
- 21:04Lots of this stuff is revealed.
- 21:05And to your point, if you don't have the trust, people aren't even going to admit to this stuff.
- 21:11So they're going to say, oh, yeah, yeah, yeah, I've got it.
- 21:13But the reality is they don't feel safe enough to be vulnerable enough to say, hang on, I don't understand.
- 21:20You know, that's bad.
- 21:23I wonder whether this is the right point to start thinking about the cost of this stuff.
- 21:29Because you said right at the beginning, when you're going and you help businesses, there's a tangible sort of revenue profit piece that you're tying this behavioural stuff in, this system stuff in, this people stuff in.
- 21:41And I'm really interested to hear about the cost when these systems that we've put in place just do not work and don't function.
- 21:49And I wonder whether we could look at it in a pretty funky way.
- 21:53You can say no, if I've got this kind of a bit weird.
- 21:56But when we listen to what was really, really going on, what sort of behaviours do you hear leadership complain about that are actually just human responses to pretty poorly designed systems that they're trying to work in?
- 22:14Do you encounter that you're nodding?
- 22:17I love that.
- 22:18Do you encounter that in your work?
- 22:20Absolutely, I encounter this in my work.
- 22:23And specifically, what I often observe is leadership at the leadership layer, I often observe complaints about how much praise or recognition people seem to be seeking simply for doing their job and meeting expectations.
- 22:38There's a frustration on the leadership level of do I need to be patting backs, you know, just for doing a job well done.
- 22:44And what I find is that that's a scenario that most leaders can relate to.
- 22:49I have found that that is not actually an indication of a personal failure or that an employee is seeking more validation than is appropriate.
- 23:00What I find is that is actually a signal that there has not been enough clarity and communication from the beginning of a process so that people know what good looks like and they have a clear definition of done.
- 23:13So when we see that ambiguity in a system, people are seeking feedback and understanding all throughout the flow of their work and at the end to validate that what they have delivered is on target and it meets expectations.
- 23:25So that is people looking for clarity so that they can do their job well.
- 23:30But leaders often observe it as a need for handholding and kudos that goes above and beyond what they find to be acceptable.
- 23:37When we look at it from a human systems perspective, this is a signal that the system needs more clarity.
- 23:44It needs a better definition of done and that definition of done needs to be shared by all and that will drastically reduce that one behavior.
- 23:52So that's just one example of what I often see.
- 23:55Is that a common thing that you see in all organizations?
- 23:59Yes.
- 24:01It's fascinating, isn't it?
- 24:02Because I suspect that attitude, it's not an intentional attitude to be annoyed by that sort of stuff.
- 24:07This stuff's accidental in most places, right?
- 24:09Yes, exactly.
- 24:11And part of it is that it distracts leaders from what they would like to focus on and what they can do best, which is often making contact externally with the market, focusing on the strategy of the business.
- 24:22So it does valid point.
- 24:24It distracts them from the work that they need to do.
- 24:26But that is a signal that the system can be refined.
- 24:30Yeah.
- 24:30I think what you've said here also about the difference between acknowledging someone for doing their job and praising and recognizing somebody for going into the realms of excellence and doing something extraordinary is a really fascinating point.
- 24:48We had Jen Mueller, the sports broadcaster on the show a few episodes ago, and this was a point she was making really, really strongly.
- 24:55And you can feel people's frustration with this apparent need now to get a lollipop for every time you show up for work.
- 25:03This is not what we're talking about.
- 25:05But again, the conversations, the systems, the processes, the relationship between the leader and the team needs to make this stuff really, really, really clear.
- 25:14And not just in written stuff, but in the behavior that's witnessed.
- 25:18So I think we're pretty good as people sussing out how things work around here if we're seeing these consistent signals.
- 25:27If the leadership behaves in a consistent, constant way, then we get that we're not looking for a pat on the back every time we show up.
- 25:36But actually, we're going to make the effort to do more things if we want the recognition, if we want to go for it, because that's what gets rewarded.
- 25:42So I think there's a lot of that consistency piece that's at play here.
- 25:47Absolutely.
- 25:47I agree.
- 25:48And I think if I had to distill that down into what is the role of the leader in this, I would say effective leaders of remote teams, especially, they engage in proactive pattern detecting, and then wayfinding.
- 26:03So it's that combination of what am I hearing from those that are bold enough to share feedback, and also proactively seeking that feedback.
- 26:12Too often, I see an organization do an employee engagement survey maybe once a year, and leaders aren't necessarily translating those insights to their leadership style and refining it over time.
- 26:26I recommend a different approach.
- 26:28I recommend that leaders intentionally carve out spaces to receive feedback from their teammates, and that often can look like a retrospective.
- 26:38So for anybody that is not familiar with agile software development methodologies, a retrospective is simply a time-boxed moment where the team comes together to talk about how they conduct work together.
- 26:51They're not focused on the technical aspects of their work.
- 26:54They're focused on how they work together.
- 26:56A very simple format is to do a stop-start-continue method, which is the team discussing what should we stop doing, what should we start doing, what should we continue doing.
- 27:07There are so many amazing tools to do this virtually.
- 27:09It's very effective.
- 27:11It's the leader's job to create these spaces for these insights to reach them.
- 27:16And the effective leaders that I see of remote teams are the leaders that intentionally carve out these forums and see them as very important, and they act on the insights that are made available in these forums.
- 27:29So the leader's job is the detecting, finding spaces for people to provide feedback, and then it's the wayfinding, saying, I don't know exactly where we are headed, but directionally, let's go that way.
- 27:41Understand what is the level of experimentation that is acceptable, stating the definition of done, stating expectations, the wayfinding.
- 27:50Leaders don't need to give everybody all of the answers all of the time, but they are a wayfinder and a pattern detector when they are doing it well remotely.
- 27:58I love the whole notion of the pattern detector because it takes us out of the individual transaction or thing with an employee and starts to take a leadership role in looking up, looking ahead, and putting some of these things together.
- 28:11I think one of the costs of these things can be particularly, and again, you must hold me accountable to sort of say, Andy, that's not how it works, if it's not how it works.
- 28:20But my impression in dealing with some organisations that have a much heavier remote or hybrid basis, and I found this particularly within an IT function particularly, is that one of the costs, I think, is this expectation that there is no sense of belonging, there is no sense of greater part.
- 28:37And so actually, retention of people is really hard because people just move to the next project for the next check, and there is no sense of us.
- 28:49And some of it is due to the systems, some of it is due to the communication.
- 28:54Some of it, to me, feels like, well, they've accepted that there is going to be none of this extra stuff within their function, within that organisation, and so they don't expect it.
- 29:05And so there isn't that level of connection and commitment inside some of those organisations.
- 29:09I'm not saying this is everybody, by the way.
- 29:12And I think that's a huge cost.
- 29:14If you're having to constantly hire, retrain people because that lack of belonging and connection, that's a huge cost to businesses.
- 29:25Yes, absolutely.
- 29:27I could illustrate that as well with a specific case study that made.
- 29:31Please do.
- 29:32Yeah, yeah.
- 29:32Because I've seen these dynamics play out, and specifically on a technology team.
- 29:37So absolutely, I've seen that play out.
- 29:40I worked with a team, they were within a financial services organisation that had thousands of employees, and this team was tasked with a very high visibility, well-funded, key initiative, critical for the future of this organisation.
- 29:55And the team that was assembled to conduct this work, it included some full-time employees from the organisation, but also a collection of different vendors.
- 30:04There were no formal teaming agreements in place.
- 30:07The team did not understand what they were there to do.
- 30:09It was a critical risk.
- 30:11I assessed the effectiveness of this team and the health of the team.
- 30:14The average score of the assessment tool we used was a 2.4 out of 5 when I walked into this team.
- 30:20So it was critically low.
- 30:21We conducted an eight-week, what I call a team accelerator program, where we addressed the fundamentals.
- 30:27We assessed the health, we helped everyone understand what they are there to do, what everybody else was there to do.
- 30:34We also found that the lowest score in that assessment was people feeling that they did not know each other well as people.
- 30:40That was a 2.2 out of 5.
- 30:42So we created personal canvases, and these were with technologists, and they were very happy to do this.
- 30:47It's a simple PowerPoint slide about me and what I care about and my hobbies and interests.
- 30:52And during a standing meeting that was already in place, we just took 10 minutes and gave one person per week the floor to share about them, and we asked them questions.
- 31:02We also tried to carry through that connection on an ongoing basis by creating a Microsoft Teams water cooler channel.
- 31:10So this was a channel just dedicated to chitchat, talking about weekend plans, travel plans, restaurant recommendations.
- 31:17And it enabled people to continue to get to know one another asynchronously, but it didn't clog critical business channels with fluff, if you will.
- 31:26But we made clear that we want to connect, and if you want, this is the channel to do that.
- 31:31We also did cross-functional knowledge sharing sessions, where people were able to share their work in more detail and also make clear to the other teammates what helped them do their role very well, what was the information they need from others, and what role are they trying to play in enabling others to succeed.
- 31:51And those information sharing sessions were invaluable for this team.
- 31:55We also implemented retrospectives.
- 31:57We started out every two weeks because we really needed to turn this team around.
- 32:02Eventually, we were able to hold back on that and do about once a month.
- 32:05So within this eight weeks, again, all of this was not expensive.
- 32:09It was not groundbreaking.
- 32:11But we applied these practices, and we did it consistently.
- 32:15Eight weeks later, we assessed the health and effectiveness of the team, and the average score was 4.8 out of 5.
- 32:21And that was incredible within eight weeks.
- 32:25And these results, what I found so striking, they were sustained for such a long time.
- 32:29So when we talk about turnover, like you mentioned, this team had zero percent regrettable turnover.
- 32:36And that was sustained for almost two years.
- 32:39So for two years, not a single person left the team that the team wanted to retain.
- 32:45Not only did they have incredible retention of top performers, the team also accelerated their delivery because they were communicating so effectively.
- 32:53They were surfacing risks and dependencies very early on.
- 32:57So they were able to complete a critical initiative six months ahead of schedule.
- 33:01This team also, I love the employee engagement scores.
- 33:05That stands out to me.
- 33:05We were able to achieve 95 percent employee engagement for 18 months.
- 33:11And then vendors that were supporting this team, they saw an increase of 11x in their revenue because they were performing so strongly that they grew, their account grew in this organization.
- 33:25And then the C-suite recognized this team as the top performing team in the enterprise.
- 33:30Other teams were reaching out to this team, trying to understand what they were doing differently.
- 33:35And a critical initiative that this team was responsible for, the C-suite funded them at 20 percent more than they even asked for because they felt that they were doing so well, they wanted to invest heavily in this team.
- 33:48So these are shocking results for most organizational effectiveness consultants.
- 33:53I added up the financial benefit of all of these, all of this value add, and I found that across an 18-month period, these efforts enabled 4.5 million dollars of added value, essentially out of thin air.
- 34:08There were some consulting fees associated with this work, of course, but even taking those fees into account, this organization saw a 45x return on their consulting fees.
- 34:17And you don't see 45x in business hardly ever.
- 34:21I mean, 2x would be great, 3x is great.
- 34:23But I kid you not, I'm so passionate about this work because the results that I have seen, creating 45 million dollars of value out of thin air, everyone on this team, they loved being on this team, they said this was their favorite team they worked on.
- 34:37It's so simple, it's so basic, but the business results are absolutely shocking.
- 34:42Yeah, I mean, this stuff sort of makes my heart sing because I think some of the solutions to some of this disconnection and team malfunction are far simpler than other people would have you believe.
- 34:56I suspect a lot of the answers sit within the team themselves if they're just engaged and asked about what do we need to do, how do we improve this.
- 35:05I guess a couple of things I would ask you to help me evangelize about this stuff is because regardless of those numbers, some cynical people will still be sitting there going, really?
- 35:1745x based on some like Tinder profiling within the business and sharing some stuff about yourself and talking more and having communicated.
- 35:27Really?
- 35:28And I want to say yes, really.
- 35:30So help me out here.
- 35:32That's the crux of it, right?
- 35:34Yes.
- 35:34I mean, I am asked this by some skeptical executives when I come into executive teams to support them.
- 35:40And essentially, yes, my answer is yes, this works.
- 35:45I can say it in many different ways, but if the question is, is this true?
- 35:49Does it work?
- 35:50Yes, it does.
- 35:52And I would say as well, it's not even a question of how we can add more value.
- 35:59Organizations are leaving money on the table by not addressing these problems today.
- 36:04And especially in our current economic environment, so many teams are being asked to do a lot more with a lot less.
- 36:14Headcounts have been drastically reduced in most organizations.
- 36:18And I am of the opinion, based on the evidence and what I have seen to be true, is that this is the only value left that has not yet been unlocked more broadly.
- 36:30There is value and human potential sitting within organizations completely untapped because of these very core fundamentals.
- 36:39And so for leaders that are skeptical of this, the proof is in the pudding.
- 36:44You improve these fundamentals, you will see profitability as a result.
- 36:49And I would argue this is probably your faster path to profitability than a shiny new ball.
- 36:56Yeah, I think, well, I mean, that's why I ended up jumping out of the work that I was doing in doing my own thing for that very reason.
- 37:05I just believe there is so much latent potential in the vast majority of people sitting in their jobs or doing whatever they're doing in their venues, just untapped.
- 37:18No one has even asked a question of them.
- 37:21No one has even attempted to engage more than the role they're performing, how else they can contribute.
- 37:27And I think as humans, I think genuinely most of us, we want to contribute something.
- 37:31We want to feel like we're doing something, like we're making a difference somewhere.
- 37:36I would like to ask you a little question just on the case study there, in terms of the role of momentum in making these things happen and how things kind of grow.
- 37:47Because I suspect in there, we would have had, in all the communication stuff you talk about that team, I guess there would have been some members of the team right at the front of that momentum curve, like, yes, we should do this and let's crack on.
- 37:58And they were right behind it.
- 38:00And maybe some others who were sitting on the fence going, well, we'll have a little look.
- 38:04Let's see what's happening.
- 38:05Did you experience that?
- 38:06Did that sort of play a part in the momentum?
- 38:08Was it the fact that you find those first followers who really get it, and they're the ones that stimulate and encourage everybody else?
- 38:14There were a few critical elements of why this was so successful.
- 38:18Something that's unique is number one, every single person on that team was new to the organization.
- 38:24They did not have an existing reputation or relationship network or organizational inertia holding them back from trying something new.
- 38:33They simply had not been there long enough to know how stagnant performance was in other places.
- 38:40So the newness of the team worked in their favor.
- 38:43It somewhat did not work in their favor in terms of organizational context and being successful in that aspect.
- 38:48It worked in their favor in terms of their willingness to experiment simply because there was no status quo for most people on this team.
- 38:56The leader was also very invested in these strategies.
- 39:01And that's key.
- 39:02When you try to make a change like this, people look to the leaders to see how palatable are these concepts to these leaders.
- 39:10And if leaders show an ounce of dismissiveness or resistance, you will not see the results that you could see.
- 39:16That leader was completely bought into these concepts.
- 39:19I was able to coach him and advise him individually on how to model these specific observable leadership behaviors over time that would enable this performance.
- 39:30And so because of that, those were the two elements that I think helped this team be very successful.
- 39:36But it's still possible to achieve this, even when you're working against organizational inertia, even if leaders are maybe just a little bit resistant to some of these concepts.
- 39:47I have found that with enough proof points, typically a few retrospectives and finding some actual data to support these assertions, you can still achieve these results.
- 39:57I'm with you.
- 39:58I believe you.
- 40:00I've felt it and I've seen it.
- 40:02I just think a lot of people struggling with this false badge of remote and hybrid, I think it's because it's new to a lot of places.
- 40:09But the stories you've told, the organizations you worked before were doing this before it became a thing that everyone else is trying to do and making a success of it.
- 40:17We can learn a lot from those things.
- 40:19I think the leadership role here cannot be underplayed.
- 40:21The whole point about pattern spotting and wayfinding, all that sort of stuff is critical.
- 40:27Your point here about leadership commitment, even if a team does have baggage, even if a team maybe doesn't have the belief, it's down to the leader to show real commitment.
- 40:38And sometimes belligerence to annoy people to say, hey, this is where we're going to go.
- 40:44This is what we're going to do.
- 40:45And I think that can set a huge tone of expectation going forward.
- 40:50Absolutely.
- 40:51And without that, it simply asks too much of our people to really put their neck on the line and take a bold risk to go against the culture.
- 41:01Often politically, that is not advantageous for most members of a team.
- 41:05So it really is up to the leader to do this.
- 41:07And I would say if you're on a team where you see potential for improvements, you want to be a part of the change.
- 41:14Your leader is not necessarily proactively wayfinding in this capacity.
- 41:18I find that talking about future value that can be added is a more politically safe method than necessarily saying we have a problem here.
- 41:30This environment is not safe.
- 41:32Certain things are not effective.
- 41:33That can cause a bit of a churn.
- 41:35It's a calculated risk for sure.
- 41:37In my experience, if people want to make a change, but they're concerned about the politics, I find that focusing on unlocking the value on your team is a more effective route.
- 41:47That's definitely talking leadership language right there.
- 41:50Absolutely value.
- 41:52Ellie, it feels like I've blinked and I've lost some time, but I've gained so much within that time.
- 41:59We have come to the part of the show I like to call sticky notes.
- 42:02This is where I'm putting you on the spot to say this is fab, but can you leave us with three simple nuggets to take away that we could fit on little sticky notes and maybe metaphorically stick them on our screens to give us a bit of a reminder.
- 42:14If we're thinking about your best pieces of advice for providing these enabling systems and approaches that we've talked about today for people to work in and to be of their best, what three bits of advice would you leave us with?
- 42:30Great question.
- 42:31I would say address three fundamentals.
- 42:35One, define what everybody is supposed to do.
- 42:38Make sure everyone knows what they're responsible for, that they understand what the others are responsible for.
- 42:43Revisit that on a weekly basis until it is very crisp and then revisit it a minimum once a quarter moving forward.
- 42:51Number two, define the north star of the team's efforts.
- 42:56Clarify what is that definition of done.
- 42:58Be very clear on what the team is trying to produce, what is the expected manner of producing it, when are they complete.
- 43:06And then the third, create just one consistent way to improve from the inside of the team.
- 43:12I would recommend create a retrospective, reflect on how the team works together, identify improvements, and more importantly, act on them and then do another retrospective and see how it went.
- 43:24If you do these three things, which are free, you don't even need a consultant to do it, you are going to see an incredible transformation on a team, most likely within a couple months.
- 43:35I love that.
- 43:36And for goodness sake, do not underplay the act on them element of that.
- 43:41All the talk in the world is amazing.
- 43:43Acting actually makes things happen.
- 43:45I love it.
- 43:46Ellie, I've loved talking to you today.
- 43:49It's been so wonderful to hear the things I believe in the normal world of work absolutely apply in the world of remote.
- 43:56And you've shared some wonderful things.
- 43:58You've shared some incredible numbers in terms of how this stuff works.
- 44:02If people would like to find out a bit more about you and the work that you do, where can they track you down, Ellie?
- 44:08Absolutely.
- 44:08You can find me on LinkedIn.
- 44:10I will put the link in the show notes for you, Andy.
- 44:13Please come say hello.
- 44:14I am just so grateful that in this crazy world we can connect with one another across the globe and help each other create more healthy, effective workplaces for all.
- 44:24So please do come say hello on LinkedIn.
- 44:27And then if you would like to apply these insights to your organization, I have a complimentary assessment.
- 44:33It's called the team health assessment.
- 44:34I'll provide that link for the show notes.
- 44:36It takes a couple minutes.
- 44:38You'll receive an overall score.
- 44:40You'll receive a score against some key dimensions of effective teams and some very specific guidance to support you moving forward.
- 44:47And I always meet with the people that complete that assessment to talk through the results completely complimentary.
- 44:53I just want to help everybody make a better workplace for all.
- 44:56And I love to find my co-conspirators in doing this work.
- 45:00I love it.
- 45:01I love the work that you're doing.
- 45:02It's been an absolute pleasure to meet you and get to speak with you.
- 45:05Thank you so much for coming on, Ellie.
- 45:07Thank you, Andy.
- 45:08Really appreciate it.
- 45:09Okay, you take care.
- 45:10All the best with your work.
- 45:12Thank you so much.
- 45:13Okay, everyone.
- 45:14Well, that was Ellie Holbert.
- 45:15And if you'd like to find a little bit more out about her or any of the things that we've talked about today, please go ahead and check out the show notes.
- 45:25So that concludes today's episode.
- 45:28I hope you've enjoyed it, found it interesting, and heard something maybe that will help you become a stickier, more successful business from the inside going forward.
- 45:39If you have, please like, comment and subscribe.
- 45:43It really helps.
- 45:45I'm Andy Goram, and you've been listening to the Sticky from the Inside podcast.
- 45:50Until next time, thanks for listening.