Latest / Crimes and Consequences / EP198: The Murder of Moriah Wilson
Transcript
- 0:00This episode may contain content of a graphic nature, including descriptions of physical and
- 0:05sexual violence against adults, children, and animals. Listener discretion is advised.
- 0:12Hi everyone, I'm Tanya and I'm Talia, and we are Crimes and Consequences,
- 0:18a true crime podcast. Hi Tanya, Hi Talia. Welcome back.
- 0:35Everybody did this week's episode of Crimes and Consequences. I hope everybody's doing awesome?
- 0:42Are you doing awesome? Don't answer? Am I doing awesome? I'm
- 0:46doing You're doing splendid, absolutely great today. If you haven't done so already,
- 0:51I'd like to ask y'all they hit that subscribe like follow, love you,
- 0:55button, love You. I think I should hit and they probably do.
- 0:58Let me kid they I know, harp by us Right, Are you
- 1:00ready? I am? All right? Well. It takes place in Austin,
- 1:04which is the state capital of Texas. Have you ever been to Austin?
- 1:08No? I want to go. It's known for its warm weather and
- 1:11it has three hundred days. It's unshiny. Oh my god. Seriously.
- 1:15Yes, we're from Michigan. We get one day. It's got a lot
- 1:21of food and are as. Wow, I know, I'd be so happy.
- 1:25Friendly communities. The economy is primarily driven by high tech industries like pharmaceutical
- 1:32companies, bio technology companies, IT and there are a lot of companies that
- 1:38are developing AI technology that's way too advanced for me. I'm gonna let that
- 1:44technology be has to me by because I think I'm done learning new stuff and
- 1:48I'm still trying to work on my iPhone. And something cute about Austin is
- 1:52there's a lot of people that have these bumper stickers that say, quote,
- 1:56keep Austin weird o. Cute little little keep. Yeah, that's cute.
- 2:00This is where Caitlyn Armstrong and Colin Strickland met. I'm gonna give you a
- 2:06little background on Caitlin. She was born November twenty first, in nineteen eighty
- 2:09seven. And you know where she grew up, Michigan, Livonium, Michigan.
- 2:15Yeah. Yeah, she went to high school there. Classmates described her
- 2:19as being outgoing, friendly, but sometimes it could be bossy and controlling.
- 2:23I know people like that. She was very athletic as a teenager, and
- 2:29she had this red, curly hair, so it kind of made her stand
- 2:32out. She liked volleyball, track and field and did some basketball in two
- 2:38thousand and five, she was voted best hair. Oh yeah, I'm picturing
- 2:43some really great hair. I would like some. Yeah. Like, no,
- 2:46I didn't get voted shit. Yeah, I mean neither. Don't worry
- 2:47about it. We're only not voted for shit category. She ended upvoting to
- 2:53Schoolcraft College. You know where that is? This community college. Before she
- 2:57went to Eastern Michigan University, she got a job working in finance for several
- 3:01years before she changed her career and she became a licensed realtor and on the
- 3:07side of yoga instructor. Oh my goodness, that sounds awesome from finance too.
- 3:13Yoga yoga good for her. Yeah, that finance probably stressed her out.
- 3:16That's why she did yoga. Yeah. In October twenty eighteen, that's
- 3:21when she met Colin, and she met him on the dating app Hinge.
- 3:25Oh hinge. It's better than Tinder, isn't it. I don't know.
- 3:29I don't know. This dating app that there are those that don't know,
- 3:32is designed for you to meet the one to fall in love with. And
- 3:38I don't from what I know, that's not really what it was for.
- 3:40Maybe the one for the night. I don't know, So let me tell
- 3:44you about Colin. He was born in November seventh, in nineteen eighty six,
- 3:47and he grew up in Johnson City, which is in Texas. His
- 3:52family they owned a farm on the outskirts of the city, and he developed
- 3:55a love for the outdoors, coming out in the country and he would ride
- 3:59his bike down the gravel roads. He was described as eccentric, and he
- 4:04loved music and he loved art, but he was eccentric. I love eccentric
- 4:09people. They're fun, yeah, just you know, not when they were
- 4:14family members, That's true. And just from experience. As he grew up
- 4:17on the farm, he became very conscious of where his food source was from.
- 4:23Because when I'm saying he grew up on a farm, I'm a girl
- 4:25I'm talking about he grew up on a farm. By the age of twenty
- 4:29five, he was a member of the Red Bull athletic community and he was
- 4:32a professional cyclist cyclist. I didn't see that coming. Yes, after college,
- 4:40he had won his first cycling race, so he was much better at
- 4:44biking than me. I haven't been on a bike in ages. And he
- 4:47had actually went on to compete internationally. He was considered a public figure for
- 4:53the cycling community, and he had a large following on Instagram. Wow,
- 4:57this whole world out there, say, there's all kinds of stuff out there
- 5:01that true crime cycling part of. So Colin and Caitlin's relationship was described in
- 5:09the beginning as being healthy. That's what her friends said. His friends said.
- 5:14Both Colin and Caitlin enjoyed cycling together, so it was kind of a
- 5:18hobby they had, like you and your husband, but only without a bike
- 5:23and not moving and sitting on the couch. As a relationship continued, it
- 5:27be got more serious. So when Caitlyn's apartment was hit by an ice storm
- 5:30that ended up barreling through Texas, oh yeah, it caused the pipes to
- 5:34burst. So they decided that would be a great time to move in together.
- 5:40They purchased some property together and they spent hours planning on the renovation of
- 5:46the house. So they took a big step. Yeah, it's a huge
- 5:49They also started a business together. It was a man and they're not married
- 5:54yet, Wheelhouse Mobile where they would restore and resell customized Barton trailers for those
- 6:00that don't know what a Spartan trailer is, their vintage style ur vs.
- 6:05Yeah, I think it's probably like those metal Yeah, I'm not really sure.
- 6:11I did look, but I think they're like old school r vs,
- 6:14wooden bagos, whatever, doesn't matter. They're restoring them, they're fixing them
- 6:17up, and they're selling them on the side. Caitlin became an agent for
- 6:21Sotheby's it's a broker of fine arts and jewelry. Could do all those auctions,
- 6:28yes, and she sold the trailers, oh nice, around three hundred
- 6:31fifty thousand bam. She had that background, remember, in finance, So
- 6:35she started to manage Colin's racing finances because he was making money, believing or
- 6:42not cycling around the place. I still wan't ride a bike, but that's
- 6:45fine, and so she had access to his passwords. Some close friends said
- 6:49that they felt that Caitlin had become obsessed with his online presence because he was
- 6:56a local celebrity and a celebrity with a cyclists out there. A friend of
- 7:00the couple recalled an awkward encounter that this person had experience with Colin and Kitlin
- 7:05like it was one of those things that made me really uncomfortable. One of
- 7:09Colin's sponsors, Rafa, it's a brand of cycling Clothing designed an exclusive cycling
- 7:16kit with all the sponsors logos on them as a gift. Colin decided to
- 7:21get a set for Caitlin, but told her that she couldn't wear it in
- 7:26public, just in case his sponsors didn't like that. And she's like,
- 7:30huh, what is this. One day, the pair decided to go for
- 7:33a ride with some friends and Caitlin wore that old I don't know cycling kit.
- 7:40I guess that's like a helmet with sure, I don't know what a
- 7:43cycling kit was. Colin told Kaitlin to change, like you need to change,
- 7:47you get out of it, and Caitlin said, you know what,
- 7:50I'm not going for a ride with you guys. I'm not going. So
- 7:55that was a sign of tension, but some also recall having to call Colin
- 7:59out on sometimes tis because it was really condescending. He would be rude to
- 8:03even his friends, and he was often demeaning to Caitlin. He was saying
- 8:07things that just to the people around him, it just wasn't right. It
- 8:13was it was rude, it was inappropriate, it was wrong. He was
- 8:16looked like a jerk. This is where the couple started to feel the strain
- 8:20of what it was like to actually have a partner, because you know,
- 8:22in the beginning, it's of honeymoon, yes and stuff. But now the
- 8:26cracks started to show between the couple, and as they said, friends were
- 8:30noticing. Now we're in October of twenty twenty one, the couple decided this
- 8:35is not a good idea. It would be best to end the relationship on
- 8:39mutual terms, but remain friends and roommates. No no, no, no,
- 8:45no, that does not sound like a good idea. No no,
- 8:48They split. They each had their own separate rooms in their home, and
- 8:52Caitlin reportedly had brought over multiple men. Oh no, she met on the
- 8:58dating app Bumble. She switched over to bumba Bumble because Hinge, you know,
- 9:03ended up not working out so well for her. And although this didn't
- 9:07seem to bother Colin at the time, he acted like he didn't because,
- 9:11oh, it fucking bothered him. I'm sure it had. But guess what
- 9:13he was doing. Oh he's doing the same thing, bringing home some girls
- 9:18and doing some how awkward kick a boom boom stuff. Awkward Is that I
- 9:22know, That's what I'm saying. That's why it's a bad idea yes,
- 9:24and Colin met Anna Maria Wilson. Anna went by Maria, and I'm gonna
- 9:31give you a little background down Maria. She was born in May eighteenth,
- 9:35nineteen ninety six, so she gonna be lit twenty five. She was born
- 9:39to Eric and Karen Wilson. She had brother named Matthew. The family lived
- 9:41in a small town called Kirby, which is a northern part of Vermont.
- 9:48She grew up in Kirby, and the Wilson family was surrounded by beautiful greenery.
- 9:52They loved the outdoors, just like Colin did. At a young age,
- 9:58Mariah displayed signs of perfectionism, which would overwhelm her and cause her to
- 10:03have anxiety. Oh yeah. In middle school, her parents center to a
- 10:05therapist to help her find a way to manage all of this. This trade
- 10:11would later become really prominent in her adult life. She was very motivated because,
- 10:16as you know, perfectionists are motivated to be perfect, right, and
- 10:20so she was very motivated to become something in her life. In twenty fourteen,
- 10:26she graduated from Burke Mountain Academy, one of the first ski academies.
- 10:31Wow, that's impressed in North America. There's a skid, And I know
- 10:35I was just thinking the same thing as someone that's skied once. I never
- 10:39skied, Yeah, I bet never. I bet you haven't. No,
- 10:41I didn't even do it. In high school. She had a talent for
- 10:46alpine skiing. Good for her. I don't even know what it was.
- 10:48But she placed third in the twenty thirteen US Junior National Championship downhill event at
- 10:54a national level. Yeah, she was good, and you know that third
- 10:58place wasn't good enough for her, right, She probably stressed about it,
- 11:01poor thing. But then something bad happened. She ended up tearing her acl
- 11:07and her sophomore year. Oh damn, but a healed, but then she
- 11:11tore it again three years later. She doesn't let of pain. She didn't
- 11:16let us stop her. She ended up growing up and learning to embrace adversity,
- 11:20the pain with a grace and a purpose. And she had a really
- 11:24strong work ethic. The people close to her would describe it as being abnormally
- 11:30amazing, like out of this world. Then she went on to attend Darthmouth
- 11:35College. She got a degree in engineering in twenty nineteen. She was pretty
- 11:39much ready to take the world on. She had a great education, and
- 11:45she did have a really good personality. In her spare time, she would
- 11:48write. She ended up traveling to different places in the world and enjoyed experience
- 11:54all the other cultures out there. She's got obviously some money going on,
- 11:58because yeah, that's not cheap. Dartmouth isn't cheap either. So even though
- 12:03she had her engineering degree, she was an aspiring chef. Oh me,
- 12:07and this girl is talent, right. She loved tackle Tuesdays. I love
- 12:11tackle. I like tackle Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday. And she ended up
- 12:18having a deep love for cycling. That became her biggest hobby and then it
- 12:24became her profession. So you can kind of see where I'm going. She
- 12:28had come to the decision that engineering wasn't for her, and so she ended
- 12:33up doing more cycling. She had had, by this time, a corporate
- 12:37job for a few years, and she was just getting sick of no corporate
- 12:41job. So yeah, working for the man blows. Long story shorty,
- 12:46she ended up being a professional cyclist. She want to be free nature and
- 12:50all that. I get it, girl, No you don't. It's totally
- 12:56not my chosen way to spend my time. No, I understand, some
- 13:01people do enjoy it. She became popular in the cycling community. And after
- 13:05competing in two gravel cycling seasons and they're like three months long. I know
- 13:11nothing about cycling seasons or gravel cycling season. She rose to the top of
- 13:15the pack and she had a lot of victories both in gravel and mountain races.
- 13:20Okay, she was she was forced to me rocking with Unfortunately, due
- 13:26to the worldwide spread of COVID, the racing community experience a hold on.
- 13:31They couldn't have any races. Yeah, we lost like two years, yeah
- 13:35lives, yes, but that didn't really stop Mariah and November of twenty twenty,
- 13:41she attended the proving ground of American Endurance Races and bombs and pressing.
- 13:46In just seven hours with only a hydration packet and two water bottles, she
- 13:50completed the Moobs White Rim Loop, a one hundred mile loop through the canyons
- 13:56of Colorado and the Green Rivers, and she set a record for women one
- 14:03hundred miles miles. Wow, seven hours and one hundred miles. Oh,
- 14:07I don't think I drive that fast. No, I mean yeah, but
- 14:11that is pretty impressive on a bike. Mariah was determined to be in as
- 14:16many cycling events as possible, and she told one reporter that she often found
- 14:20it hard to compete in all of them because there were all these overlaps and
- 14:24events, and she wanted to just do all of them, you know,
- 14:26she wanted to get into all of them. In October of twenty twenty one,
- 14:31Mariah moved to Austin, Texas, and she got very well known in
- 14:35the local cycling community. This is when Colin and Mariah met at a local
- 14:41cycling event in town and became bonded over their mutual love for cycling. Both
- 14:48of them were in the middle of a break up. Mariah had left because
- 14:50she broke up with her boyfriend, wanted a fresh start. She was newly
- 14:54single, and it didn't take long before their relationship developed laws. You know
- 15:01what I'm saying. Yeah, I know what you're saying. Girl. Colin
- 15:05didn't realize that his relationship he had with Maria hurt Caitlyn's feelings. So when
- 15:11I told you before, she was bringing over men, but he was bringing
- 15:16over women, right. He really didn't think Caitlin cared. No, I
- 15:20wouldn't either, but Caitlin was pretty open about her feelings towards Maria and that
- 15:26she didn't like her. Healing Head somehow gotten Mariah's number, I don't know
- 15:30how, and spent the next few months harassing and threatening her, telling her
- 15:35she'd better stay away from Colin. That never works, girl, That never
- 15:41works. Girl. You're just showing you're crazy. You live with him,
- 15:45he's your ex. You're bringing home guys because her Maria is not going to
- 15:50be like Caitlin's been calling me. She's nuts, right, How are you
- 15:54gonna win over someone by showing that you're crazy? Well, my thing is
- 16:00you dumped him. You don't want to be with him. You don't want
- 16:02to be with them, So what's the problems and you're being with other people?
- 16:04Why do you care what I'm doing? What is Colin's supposed to be
- 16:07alone for the rest of his life? Exactly? I know. The threats
- 16:10had become so constant that Maria attempted to end it by blocking Caitlyn and telling
- 16:15Colin, listen, you gotta stop her. This is out of control.
- 16:18But because all three of them we're into cycling. Oh come on, they
- 16:23shared the same group of friends. Oh no, and that made up the
- 16:27outings very awkward for all their friends involved. As you can imagine, it
- 16:33was only literally after two weeks of officially dating, Colin decided to call it
- 16:38quits with Maria. So this all happened in two weeks. She's harassment phone
- 16:44calls Maria's Yeah, she gets dumb by Colin. It didn't take long for
- 16:49Caitlin to snatch Colin back up and they rekindled the romance. But they really
- 16:55they did. Well, he's an asshole. Colin and Mariah would continue to
- 16:59be friends, and Caitlin didn't know that they were meeting privately. Still,
- 17:04no, you know how this all goes? Oh no, this is messy.
- 17:11Oh boy, Colin had changed Mariah's name and his phone to something different.
- 17:15I don't know what it was, so Caitlyn wouldn't find out. It
- 17:18was probably like Steve or something, their secret hanging out. But Caitlin eventually
- 17:23figured it out. There was basically a secret romance happening behind her back.
- 17:30And if you thought they were just grabbing coffee Maria and Colin, they weren't.
- 17:33They weren't, and Caitlyn started to act out even more and her behavior
- 17:37became very odd. Her behavior was really concerning. But before I tell you
- 17:45more, we're gonna take a quick break banish the end of summer blues.
- 17:49With Hello Fresh, no need to stress about how you'll handle it all this
- 17:53fall because Hello Fresh takes care of the meal planning and delivers preportioned ingredients right
- 18:00to your home, So whipping up a homemade meal is a cinch. Feel
- 18:04like you would love a wholesome homemade meal, but there's just not enough time.
- 18:07With Hello Fresh, all you need is fifteen minutes and you'll enjoy a
- 18:11tasty, satisfying meal made in your own kitchen. Just look for their quick
- 18:15and easy dinner options, plus quick breakfasts and lunches too. I've used Hello
- 18:21Fresh in the past, and there are so many reasons why I love it.
- 18:25Besides the convenience and the fact that I don't have to go to the
- 18:27grocery store, I love the fact that I don't have to plan a menu.
- 18:32I also love the fact that Hello Fresh has such a variety to choose
- 18:34from each week. Between chicken and fish and steak and vegetarian and low calorie,
- 18:41there's just so many choices. Go to HelloFresh dot com, slash crimes
- 18:47one hundred fifty and use the code crimes one hundred fifty. That's one zero
- 18:52zero five zero for fifty percent off plus free shipping. Again, go to
- 18:59Hello Fresh dot com slash crimes one zero zero five zero and use code crimes
- 19:03one zero zero five zero for fifty percent off plus three shipping. Hello Fresh
- 19:11America's number one meal kit. So we have this love triangle going on.
- 19:18It's May eleventh, of twenty twenty two, so this is recent. Just
- 19:23before ten pm, emergency services were called by Mariah's friend and she was in
- 19:29a state of panic. She was hysterical. She told nine one one she'd
- 19:33just returned home to find her friend motionless on the bathroom floor. Not long
- 19:38after that call was made, authorities arrived on the scene and they found a
- 19:42woman, Mariah dead. Oh no, she had multiple gunshot wounds. Oh,
- 19:49at a very close range. They'd been shot. She'd been shot.
- 19:55Mariah was supposed to perform in a mountain bike race the next day where everybody
- 20:00thought she was going to win, but obviously she didn't make it to that
- 20:03race. The autopsy confirmed that Mariah's death was homicide case. You're like,
- 20:08whoa, She just got the shot multiple times, which came as no surprise
- 20:12to the police. Given how gruesome the crime scene was. She sustained two
- 20:18gunshot wounds to the head and one to the chest while she was face off
- 20:22laying on the floor. The police inspected the crime scene and the officers found
- 20:26multiple shell casings, but they couldn't find the weapon in the house, and
- 20:32it led them to believe that somebody did this crime. The front door was
- 20:37unlocked at Mariah's home and her bike had been stolen. The officers found the
- 20:44bike later on had been tossed into this thick growth of bamboo about seventy feet
- 20:49from her friend's place where she'd been staying. So she was staying with a
- 20:52friend. The community of Austin and the larger cycling community to them Mariah's I
- 21:00mean, it really shook him to the core. She's young, she's active,
- 21:04and people were just confused, like who would come in and shoot Maria
- 21:11then in the head and then steal her bike because a big clue. No
- 21:17one could think of anybody that would want to harm Mariah because she was kind,
- 21:19friendly, well natured. She didn't have any enemies except for that toxic
- 21:26love triangle. Prior to Mariah's murder, Caitlin allegedly openly spoke about how she
- 21:33wanted to kill Maria. Oh, she did. So there were some people
- 21:37that were like, hmm, you had said you wanted to kill her and
- 21:41now she's dead. Is that a coincidence? I think? Since Maria was
- 21:45staying at her friend's house, the police interviewed her friend in an attempt to
- 21:49figure out like, who, why, what, what do you think happened
- 21:53the house? Maria was staying at her friend's house. It had like an
- 21:57electric lock or of those you needed the code to get in, and then
- 22:03there'd be a time stamp when someone accessed the property. Police were able based
- 22:07on that to tell exactly when Mariah had entered and acted the apartment and her
- 22:12timeline for the day. According to the timeline they put together after investigating,
- 22:18Maria and Colin had met up went to a local pool to go swimming together
- 22:23just before six pm. After a quick swim, the pair went to a
- 22:27restaurant for dinner. While they had dinner, Colin's phone started to go off.
- 22:33When he checked it, he saw it was Kate calling. He ignored
- 22:38the call because he knew that it would upset Caitlin and Maria, and he's
- 22:45not gonna be like, yeah, I'm sorry, I'm out at a restaurant
- 22:48right now with Maria. Then Colin took Maria home and that was about eight
- 22:52thirty pm. He never entered the property and he just went straight home.
- 22:56Colin and Mariah didn't know that Caitlin had been stock in the pair. Oh
- 23:02she had been, so she knew when she was calling Colin where they were.
- 23:06Yeah, there's probably looking at him. Right. There's the CCTV footage
- 23:11around the property where Mariah was staying, showing Caitlin's black jeep driving by the
- 23:15property at about eight thirty seven, just after Mariah had returned home from her
- 23:21date with Colin. Caitlyn jeep, it was distinct, it was large,
- 23:26It had that rack mountain on the back that for luggage and bike. The
- 23:30police were able to get a search warrant for Colin and Caitlin's house, and
- 23:34of course they'd find the same car that they saw on the CCTV footage.
- 23:40They also phoned in their search of the property a handgun, girl, What
- 23:45stupid ass, Why are you bringing that gun home? And it was it
- 23:48was identified as a murder weapon with the same bullets would have been found at
- 23:52the crime scene. Really, really, you brought it home? God,
- 23:56messy, messy messing. I'm not trying to make light of it, but
- 24:00there, but jeeze, you're going to kill somebody, at least try to
- 24:02cover your tracks. Colin was the only person of the property at the house
- 24:07when the police arrived, and so at first they were like, maybe it's
- 24:11Colin that did it, But he was very cooperative with the police. They
- 24:15interviewed him and he said, yeah, I've been seeing Maria on the side.
- 24:21I have nothing to do with this murder, he told him. He
- 24:23admitted that he went swimming, and he went out to dinner and he took
- 24:26her home, and of course he's the last person to have seen her,
- 24:30and only a few minutes after he took her home, she's dead. He
- 24:33also admitted to police that he lied to Caitlin about his whereabouts and after dropping
- 24:37off Maria, he sent Caitlyn a text message, Hey, how are you?
- 24:42I went to drop some flowers off for Allison at her son's house up
- 24:47north and my phone die. Heading home unless you have another suggestion and you'd
- 24:51like some food. He returned home about eight forty and guess who wasn't home?
- 24:57Yes, around a half hour later, Caitlin came home and then Colin
- 25:03and Caitlin had sex. Oh no, no, she just killed Maria.
- 25:11He just cheated on her with Maria. Yeah, and now they're they're having
- 25:15sex. Colin told police that in December of twenty twenty one, he did
- 25:19purchase two guns, one for himself and one for Caitlin, and the police
- 25:23believed them, so they took a closer look at Caitlin, and they discovered
- 25:27that Caitlin heady, classy warrant out for her arrest. Oh would she do?
- 25:33Just unpaid bills related to bow tax treatment? Girl, come on for
- 25:37paid for your bow tax So she'd had a few years earlier? What?
- 25:41Oh no, how's that possible? It's kind of funny. According to the
- 25:47warrant, Caitlyn got some bow tax treatment at this beauty spot in Austin.
- 25:51It costed six hundred fifty three dollars. When Caitlin went to pay, she
- 25:56pulled out a card and said, oh, you know what, this isn't
- 25:57the right card. The card I need to use is in my car.
- 26:00So she went to get the card, but she never came back to pay
- 26:03for her Both time she did a dining dash with Both times, she was
- 26:11arrested for the warrant, but then on a technicality, they wrote her a
- 26:15wrong birthday down so she was released. But before she was released from their
- 26:19custody, she was asked about Mariah's death and a relationship with Colin. She
- 26:25was asked, so she knew anything about what happened to Mariah? And she
- 26:27just rolled her eyes. Nah. When they confronted her about the CCTV footage,
- 26:33she simply said, I don't know anything about that. Lin't it cool?
- 26:38And there was nothing else to hold her on and as I said,
- 26:41that technicality made the warrant invalid, so she was let oh by the police.
- 26:47Only three days after Mariah's death, an anonymous tipster told police about Colin
- 26:52and Caitlin's on again off game relationship and how Caitlin had become furious and was
- 26:59shaking in anger whenever the name Maria was mentioned. This tipster said she was
- 27:06so angry that she'd often say she wanted to kill Mariah. Police were able
- 27:11to obtain some text messages between Maria and Colin that clearly indicated the pair still
- 27:15had feelings for each other. I mean obviously, so one of the text
- 27:19messages between Maria and Colin said quote, Hey, so I'd like to talk
- 27:25to you at some point. I originally text you on Friday, but appears
- 27:27that your texts aren't going through this weekend was strange for me. I just
- 27:32want to know what's going on. If you just want to be friends,
- 27:34then that's cool, but I'd like to talk about it because honestly, my
- 27:37mind has been going in circles and I don't know what to think. And
- 27:41then Caitlin became the prime, obviously prime suspect of Maria's murder, which caused
- 27:47her to lose her fucking mind. She suddenly moved out of her home with
- 27:52Colin, cut off all ties with Colin, stopped hanging out with a recycling
- 27:59group of friends, and deleted all of her social media accounts. She sold
- 28:03her black keep for twelve thousand dollars, so now she had some cash.
- 28:07I'm May seventeenth, a warrant was issued for Caitlin's arrest for the murder of
- 28:12Mariah, but by the time the police went to arrest Caitlin, she's gone,
- 28:18really girl gone, because you're going to get away. So Caitlyn's on
- 28:22the run and I have to admit something. Yes, I do know a
- 28:25little bit. I have a little personal knowledge about this case, because I
- 28:29do know. I wasn't gonna say it, but I do know somebody in
- 28:33Michigan that was with her for a couple years, like an ex boyfriend.
- 28:38But that's all I'm gonna say. Caitlin was caught on surveillance cameras at the
- 28:44Austin Birdstom International Airport wearing white pants, a blue jacket, and a black
- 28:48COVID mask. Yes, thank you whatever. She boarded a flight to Lagardia
- 28:56Airport to New York with her sisters stolen passport. She then traveled to Costa
- 29:02Rica. Oh, she stole her sister's passport. Costa Rica. Damn.
- 29:07This girl's on like some wild ass on the run. Costa Rica's nice too.
- 29:11She traveled to Costa Rica and settled in the town of Santa Teresa.
- 29:15It was about a three hour drive and a two hour ferry to get to
- 29:19the nearest airport. So she's like deep and deep in. She felt like
- 29:26she's pretty safe. She started to teach yoga to the tourists. Oh that's
- 29:33right, I forgot about the yell ga and the locals in the area,
- 29:36and she spent a lot of time at surfbars or on the island, and
- 29:38she's sipping Margharita's by the pool side without a care in the world. She
- 29:42got a job in a hostel and no one knew who she was. To
- 29:47her, she's gotten away with murder. She cut and dyed her hair.
- 29:52She went by Airy instead of Caitlin, and she got plastic surgery. She
- 29:56faced, yeah, she did so no one would recognize her. She got
- 30:00nose job for six thousand dollars. Wow, Okay, that's a cheap ass
- 30:03nose job number one, is it? I think? No, it sounds
- 30:07expensive. I don't know, but I don't know. So now she's Arie
- 30:10with different hair and nose. Yeah, and she'd pretty much fallen in love
- 30:15with paradise. She went to extremes. Oh yeah, hell yeah, man,
- 30:21she's on the run. Yeah. She became friends with a man named
- 30:23Teal Akerson. He worked at a tattoo shop on the island and they exchanged
- 30:29numbers and Teal noticed Ari or Arie. I don't know how she pronounced her
- 30:33new name, had a bandage on her nose and she said it was from
- 30:37a surfing accident. They went on a couple of dates where I'm gonna say
- 30:41Ari had suggested some very secluded spots on the island. Ari began to open
- 30:48up to Teal, said she was eager to explore the island and said that
- 30:52she'd gone through a terrible breakup, which is why she decided to go to
- 30:56Costa Rica. I'd say it was terrible. He had no idea that she
- 31:00was Caitlin running from a murder charge. Till ended up telling the Daily Beast
- 31:04quote, I didn't put any of it together. I mean, you wouldn't
- 31:07imagine it. After it all happened, and I hear that she's on the
- 31:11run, doing doing this, it made sense why she didn't want to be
- 31:15seen in public, why she wanted to go to secluded places. There were
- 31:18wanted posters up around the resort where Caitlin was staying. There was a big
- 31:26deal, fucking news. Hello, it's crazy in Costa Rica. At the
- 31:33resort, she was Wow, that's crazy. No one recognized her. She
- 31:37was staying at Don John Surf and Yoga Lodge for less than twenty dollars a
- 31:41night, so that's not really a resort. But maybe after only forty three
- 31:47days on the run, so she already had a nose job, damn,
- 31:49teaching yoga, making money in Costa Rica. Someone she was approached by the
- 31:55US marshals they were working with a Costa Rica and they demanded to see her
- 32:00identification. Already told him that she didn't have any, and they got a
- 32:05warrant and they searched her bedroom and they found her passport, and they brought
- 32:08her back to the US and she was charged for Mariah's murder along with additional
- 32:14federal charges of unlawful flight to avoid prosecution. On July twenty one, twenty
- 32:20twenty two, she was arraigned and she pled not guilty. She was being
- 32:22held on a three point five million dollar a bell. I don't blame them
- 32:28for that. She'd take off as soon as she could now. Colin had
- 32:31nothing to do with Maria's murder, but he defended her character in an early
- 32:37interview while Kate William was on the run, he initially told reporters that he
- 32:42was going into hiding in fear of his safety when it came to Caitlin.
- 32:45Then after she was caught, he told reporters that there was no relationship with
- 32:50Maria at the time. He was with Caitlin and they had gotten back together,
- 32:53and the affidavit for Caitlin's arrest completely skewed what the relationship had really been
- 33:00with Maria. Colin talked about his relationship with Caitlin and said, quote,
- 33:05we were clearly going our separate ways, but we didn't get enough inertia to
- 33:08separate. Caitlyn and I were involved in several business together. Maria and I
- 33:15communicated maybe twice a month after that, and I think the affidavit that basically
- 33:21said him and Maria had a relationship was skewed. Yeah, I quit your
- 33:27lion. Now. When I asked about whether he would have thought that Caitlin
- 33:30could have done something like this, he said, now, he didn't believe
- 33:34that she was capable anything like that, and he was shell shocked and in
- 33:39grieving mode, grieving the loss of caite of Caitlin. I don't know,
- 33:45he's shit, you know why he's seeing all that. He didn't want to
- 33:49look bad in the press, he said, quote, I would and I'm
- 33:52not trying to be totally mean to him, but damn son, he said,
- 33:57quote, I would say she is one of the least folatile people I
- 34:00have ever met, and that's why. It's so absolutely shocking. She had
- 34:04sides to her personality that I didn't think she shared with anybody. I had
- 34:07no indication of anything like this, even though she's signing threatening text messages when
- 34:14he was dating Maria. Many people were questioning his character after these interviews.
- 34:22Someone wrote on this one thread, Colin is not honest. Caitlyn shared information
- 34:27with a friend that she wanted to kill Maria, and she was shaking in
- 34:30anger when she did so. Colin had to have known of the emotional state
- 34:35of Caitlin he lived with her. Why would Colin lie to Caitlin about where
- 34:39he was going that day if you didn't basically know what was wrong? Right,
- 34:44just so you know. According to this thread, Colin now only bought
- 34:49the gun, but he awesome bought a silencer for it. Oh shit,
- 34:52And he knew that Caitlin couldn't buy a gun herself because she had that weren't
- 34:55for botox anyway. Anyway, Apparently, later Colin reflected on the night of
- 35:02Mariah's murder, and he felt pretty traumatized about how Caitlin had initiated sex not
- 35:09long after killing Mariah. Yeah, that's kind of great, and he thought
- 35:14the way she was behaving was rather unusual to him. He felt like he
- 35:19was a trophy for Caitlin. That's why she did it, like she had
- 35:22claimed him. Yeah, yeah, exactly. Colin says he bought the gun
- 35:28originally because in the summer of twenty twenty, Caitlin had told him that a
- 35:31man maybe was drunk or suffering from mental illness, was banging on their door
- 35:37and the man eventually laughed, but she was really scared. Caitlin also told
- 35:40him that there was a man screaming at her at a grocery store, and
- 35:45then when she would ride her bike, creepy men would follow her and make
- 35:46her feel in safe. So I don't know if she wrote her bike around
- 35:49with a gun, I don't know. Colin said that he had contemplated suicide
- 35:53after Mariah's death, and then he lost a lot of the sponsors for his
- 35:57cycling. Well, he's kind of like, I wouldn't want to I wantn't
- 36:01want to sponsor. Even though he didn't do it, It's like, well,
- 36:05you're kind so he's guilty by association, right, right right. Police
- 36:09later found out that prior to Maria's murder, Caitlin went to a firing range
- 36:15to practice, which showed that it wasn't a crime of passion. Yeah,
- 36:21it was premeditated. This is all alleged. I want to say this,
- 36:24This is all alleged. Nobody knows what Caitlin did her trials not to left
- 36:29hold. Oh, so this is all alleged, allegedly, alleged, alleged,
- 36:32alleged. Did I say that enough? Alleged? Alleged? She may
- 36:37very well be innocent, She very well maybe m Her defense to this so
- 36:45far, because there was no trial, is that she had to leave town.
- 36:50She had to get the new job because she was trying to flee from
- 36:52Colin and she was scared of him. Well, yeah, you know,
- 36:57that's what people do when they break up from someone. They go to a
- 37:00different country and get those jobs and started in yoga. Yeah, why not.
- 37:06In honor of their daughter's memory, Mariah's family set up the Mariah Wilson
- 37:09Foundation. Their goal is to raise money for community youth organizations centered on helping
- 37:15young people develop self confidence, strength, and enjoy through the activities Mariah was
- 37:20passionate about, including cycling and skiing. To this day, they have raised
- 37:23one hundred and forty one thousand dollars and that is the end of the story.
- 37:30So her trials not until October. Yes, I love to keep an
- 37:32eye on that. Yes, damn, that's it. That's it. Well,
- 37:37that was a wild ride, no pun intended. Oh I know't mean
- 37:43clever. We're so so clever, so funny. Thank you guys for all
- 37:47listening to this story. And you guys can follow it because it's going to
- 37:52be happening in October. It's not too far away unless it get crazy,
- 37:57unless it gets delay delay so I mean it couldn't then again, yeah,
- 38:01be like next year, who knows. But that's it. That's it.
- 38:06Thank you everyone for listening. And before you go, if you haven't hit
- 38:08the subscribe or follow button, please do so. And if you want to
- 38:14visit our website, it's Crimes and Consequences dot com. You can find out
- 38:19information there or at patreon dot com slash t nt crimes about becoming a Patreon
- 38:25member. What do they get with that? They get every weekly episode early
- 38:30release, commercial free. They also get an extra episode every week that's not
- 38:37released to the public. Yes, you can also subscribe if you listen on
- 38:39your Apple podcast app, you can subscribe through there, and we are,
- 38:45Yeah, why not do it? You know you want I did. And
- 38:49if you want to see us on family, yeah, so did all your
- 38:52family and friends. So we want to see us on social media. Even
- 38:54though we haven't quite been as activisty, we are on Facebook and Instagram at
- 39:00hardcore true crime, hardcore true crime. And I think that I think that's
- 39:06it. If I missed something, just look to the last today in the
- 39:08last week's episode, is there. I'm tired and I gotta go pick up
- 39:13my daughter. Exactly. Someone toil our next episode. Just don't kill each
- 39:16other. Bye bye,