Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Nick Sleep and Scale Economies Explained
Transcript
- 0:00Imagine an investor who launches a fund right on the eve of a
- 0:04massive global market crash. Oh wow.
- 0:07I mean not exactly auspicious timing.
- 0:09No, not at all. But over the next 13 years, this
- 0:12investor generates a staggering 921.1% net return for his
- 0:18clients. That is.
- 0:20That's just wild. Right.
- 0:21To put that in perspective, the broader market, the MSCI World
- 0:25Index, only managed 116.9% over that exact same period.
- 0:31So he absolutely crushed the market.
- 0:33Completely crushed it. And then at the absolute height
- 0:36of his game, he just. He simply walked away.
- 0:38Just like that. Yeah, he closed up shop, handed
- 0:40everyone their money back and completely disappeared from the
- 0:43institutional radar. It's like the ultimate Wall
- 0:45Street mic drop. You know, you rarely see people
- 0:48willingly walk away from a compounding machine of that
- 0:51magnitude. Exactly.
- 0:52So today we are diving into the investment architecture of
- 0:55Nick's Leap and his Nomad Investment Partnership.
- 0:59We'll look at how he went from hunting cheap stocks to building
- 1:02what he called a terminal portfolio.
- 1:04It completely flips traditional Wall Street thinking on its
- 1:08head. It really does, but before
- 1:10jumping into the analysis, a quick message to access more
- 1:13Advanced Research companion for modern intelligent investors and
- 1:17leverage our latest Deep Values agents.
- 1:20Welcome to download Deep values APP from App Store to track
- 1:23stock market temperature, Welcome to download iOS app
- 1:27Buffett Indicator from Apple App Store or Bubble Watch from
- 1:30Google Play. Disclaimer All analysis is based
- 1:34on publicly available sources and maybe subject to revisions
- 1:37or differing interpretations. All contents from this channel
- 1:41is for research and entertainment purposes only and
- 1:43does not constitute any investment or financial advice
- 1:46or service. Conduct your own due diligence
- 1:49before making investment or financial decisions.
- 1:51All right, let's get into it. So if you spend enough time in
- 1:53value investing circles, you'll inevitably hear whispers about
- 1:56Nicholas or Nick sleep. Oh yeah and his Co founder Kwai
- 2:01Zakaria who went by Zak. Right.
- 2:03And institutional analysts are constantly trying to track down
- 2:06Sleep's latest SEC Form 13F filings to see what US equities
- 2:10he's holding. It's Wall Street's version of
- 2:12trying to look over the smart kids shoulder during a test, but
- 2:16anyone searching for his current 13 F is going to come up totally
- 2:20empty handed. Because it just doesn't exist
- 2:22today, right? Right, it doesn't, which is
- 2:24crazy when you look at the track record they built with the
- 2:26London-based Nomad investment partner from 2001 to 2014.
- 2:31Yeah, we mentioned that 921% cumulative return that breaks
- 2:36down to an annualized gross return of 20.8% or 18.4% net
- 2:43after fees. So $1.00 invested with them
- 2:46turned into $10.21 gross. Well, a dollar in the broader
- 2:51market only became $2.17. What stands out here though, is
- 2:56the path they took to achieve that return.
- 2:58I mean, it was anything but a smooth upward trajectory.
- 3:01Right, because of 2000. Eight.
- 3:03Yeah. During the global financial
- 3:04crisis, Nomad suffered a brutal 45.3% calendar year drawdown.
- 3:10Wow, almost half the portfolios quoted value evaporated in a
- 3:15matter of months. Which I mean, a lot of fund
- 3:17managers would have completely panicked right there.
- 3:19Or honestly, their clients would have panicked and pulled all
- 3:22their cap. Oh, absolutely.
- 3:24But sleep didn't panic because he operated on a fundamentally
- 3:27different definition of risk. How so?
- 3:30Well, to him, risk was not quoted.
- 3:33Price volatility, A stock price flashing red on a monitor just
- 3:37wasn't a threat, right? Risk was the permanent loss of
- 3:40capital. If the underlying business was
- 3:43still structurally sound, you know, gaining market share and
- 3:47widening its Moat, the volatility was just temporary
- 3:50noise to be ignored. So if he was so successful at
- 3:53filtering out that noise, why did he shutter the fund in 2014?
- 3:57Well Sleep and Zakaria closed the fund to manage their own
- 4:00private and philanthropic wealth.
- 4:02Right, like the IGY Foundation, Yeah.
- 4:05Plus, Nomad was domiciled in the UK and eventually he held assets
- 4:09outside institutional US mandates, which is why there are
- 4:12no 13 FS today. But there was also some pressure
- 4:15from British regulators, right? Yeah, regulators were actually
- 4:18getting incredibly nervous about Nomad's portfolio.
- 4:21It had become exceptionally concentrated.
- 4:23Like almost all their money and just a few ideas.
- 4:25Exactly. And regulators naturally prefer
- 4:28diversification. They look at a highly
- 4:30concentrated portfolio and immediately see systemic risk.
- 4:34So they push Nomad to dilute their best ideas.
- 4:37Right to fit a more conventional check the box mold.
- 4:40And sleep basically said no thanks, here's your money back.
- 4:44I mean, giving money back when you're winning that hard is
- 4:47unheard of. It really highlights his
- 4:49ultimate priority which was conviction over conventional
- 4:52portfolio management do. You rather give up the
- 4:54institutional prestige than compromise his portfolio.
- 4:57He refused to dilute his best ideas just to appease
- 5:00regulators. So how does an investor build so
- 5:03much conviction that they'd rather close their fund than
- 5:06diversify? We kind of have to look at how
- 5:08sleep's brain evolved over time. Because he didn't start out
- 5:12buying and holding compounding machines forever, did he?
- 5:14No, not at all. Phase one of Nomad from roughly
- 5:182001 to 2004 looked very much like traditional Benjamin Graham
- 5:24style value investing. Looking for cheap cigar butts?
- 5:27Exactly, he was looking for 50 Cent dollars, you know,
- 5:30distressed assets, turnarounds like Xerox and can psycho.
- 5:33Well, the goal was to buy something intrinsically worth a
- 5:36dollar for $0.50, wait for the market to wake up, sell it, and
- 5:39hunt for the next one. Right.
- 5:41But then came the turning point with Auk transport company
- 5:44called Stagecoach. Oh right, What happened there?
- 5:47Nomad bought the stock cheap at around 14 pence.
- 5:51The company executed a turn around and the stock recovered
- 5:55beautifully to around 90 pence. Which hit his estimated fair
- 5:58value, so he sold it. Following the traditional
- 6:00playbook, yeah. But then he watched the stock
- 6:03rocket past 2 lbs. Oh man, that hurts.
- 6:06Selling an exceptional business just because it no longer looks
- 6:09classically cheap on a spreadsheet became
- 6:11mathematically the costliest mistake of his career.
- 6:14So he realized that anchoring to an initial valuation is a
- 6:17mistake. Exactly.
- 6:18Instead of asking, you know, what is this worth next year, he
- 6:21started asking, where can this business be in 10 or 20 years?
- 6:26He called that destination analysis.
- 6:28Right. It's kind of the difference
- 6:29between flipping thrift store furniture for a quick buck
- 6:33versus buying an heirloom piece that appreciates for generations
- 6:38You. Know that's a great analogy.
- 6:39You don't sell a priceless antique the moment it hits
- 6:42standard retail price. You hold on to it, and this
- 6:45completely changed his holding period.
- 6:47Wall Street competes on the next quarter, but Nomad expected to
- 6:51hold for roughly 260 weeks. Which is about five years.
- 6:54Right, while others held for like 20 weeks.
- 6:57That was his edge of time. But how do you actually identify
- 7:01a company that can grow for decades without collapsing under
- 7:04its own weight? Well, you look for sleep's
- 7:07greatest contribution to investment theory.
- 7:09Scale economy. Shared.
- 7:10Yes, SES, to understand this, you have to look at normal scale
- 7:14economics first. All right.
- 7:15Traditionally, as a company gets bigger, unit costs go down.
- 7:19They take those cost savings and boost profit margins for
- 7:22shareholders. Which is just standard business,
- 7:24right? But an SES company does the
- 7:26exact opposite. They give those savings back to
- 7:29the customer through lower prices.
- 7:31Wait, I have to push back here playfully?
- 7:33I mean, giving up profit margins goes against every MBA textbook
- 7:36on the planet. Isn't that just bad business?
- 7:39In the short term it looks highly irrational, but long term
- 7:43it creates what sleep called a robustness ratio.
- 7:46Leaving money on the table for the customer.
- 7:48Exactly. It creates an institutional
- 7:50habit. The customer realizes they're
- 7:53getting a massive surplus, so they buy more.
- 7:55That drives massive volume, which creates even more scale
- 7:59and lower costs. And it creates A Lollapalooza
- 8:02Moat that can competitors simply cannot afford to replicate
- 8:06tomorrow. Costco is the ultimate blueprint
- 8:08for this. Right, they cap markups at 14%
- 8:11for national brands. And 15% for their own Kirkland
- 8:14brand. Meanwhile, supermarkets mark
- 8:16things up 25 to 35%. Yeah, and Costco limits itself
- 8:19to fewer than 4000 SKU's, which generates massive purchasing
- 8:24power. They make their profit on
- 8:25memberships. I love that anecdote about CEO
- 8:28Jim Senegal refusing to mark up designer jeans.
- 8:31Oh yeah, he found a way to source them at a discount and he
- 8:34could have marked them up way higher than 14% and still
- 8:37undercut everyone. But he just flat out refused
- 8:40because he could. The rule was the rule.
- 8:42Exactly and sleep saw the same blueprint in Amazon.
- 8:45Because Amazon's price givebacks weren't lost margins, right,
- 8:48Right. Sleep realized Amazon's
- 8:50depressed reported net income was actually Jeff Bezos
- 8:54intentionally reinvesting into the customer experience.
- 8:57Like prime infrastructure and lower prices?
- 9:00Yeah, it was uncapitalized R&D. He was building an impenetrable
- 9:03Moat. So SES sounds like an
- 9:05unstoppable magic formula, but what happens when you try to
- 9:09apply it to the wrong industry? Will even geniuses make
- 9:12mistakes? Right, let's talk about Slip's
- 9:14personal portfolio shift in 2018 and the ASOS cautionary tale.
- 9:19Yeah. So in 2018, Sleep trimmed his
- 9:21personal Amazon position to manage single stock
- 9:24concentration risk. He sold at around $1500 a share,
- 9:28right? Right.
- 9:29And he reallocated into auk fast fashion retailer called ASOS.
- 9:34Yeah, the result was pretty brutal.
- 9:36Amazon went on to return over 950% from 2014 to 2021.
- 9:42Well, ASOS dropped over 90% in market value.
- 9:45Oh wow. I mean the irony here is he
- 9:47literally broke his own rule about not trimming A compounding
- 9:50machine to fund a secondary idea.
- 9:53He did, and the core lesson is why SES failed for ASOS.
- 9:57Price reductions alone do not guarantee a Moat.
- 10:00Because fast fashion is different from Amalon or Costco.
- 10:03Extremely different. The underlying industry dynamics
- 10:06must support the flywheel. Right like non perishable goods
- 10:09and high lock in. Exactly.
- 10:10Fast fashion has a 30 to 40% return rate.
- 10:13Wow, that high. Yeah, which destroys scale
- 10:15efficiencies with high reverse logistics costs.
- 10:18Plus, apparel has rapid style obsolescence.
- 10:21Huge inventory risk and fashion buyers have 0 brand loyalty and
- 10:250 switching costs. So the model completely broke.
- 10:28It did, but learning from these very mistakes, Sleep eventually
- 10:32distilled his entire universe of thousands of stocks down to a
- 10:36shockingly small, unbreakable core.
- 10:39What he called the terminal portfolio.
- 10:41Right and radical inactivity. By the end of 2013, Nomads US13F
- 10:47was incredibly concentrated. Extremely Amazon was 69.45%,
- 10:53Costco was 13.2%. Liberty Global was 10 three and
- 10:59Berkshire Hathaway was 705. Let's.
- 11:02Talk about Berkshire Hathaway, specifically JYCO because that's
- 11:05a classic E model. It really is selling direct to
- 11:09consumer lowered their costs, which lowered premiums.
- 11:12Which generated billions in 0 cost or even negative cost
- 11:16insurance float for Warren Buffett to allocate.
- 11:19Exactly. And then there's Liberty Global.
- 11:21Right, which was closer to the special situation value.
- 11:24Yeah, local cable network density in monopolies.
- 11:26And John Malone's capital allocation?
- 11:28It proves sleep wasn't only looking for perfect compounders,
- 11:31but valued rational capital allocators.
- 11:34So Sleep advised his investors upon closing the fund to simply
- 11:38hold these stocks untouched for a decade.
- 11:42The terminal portfolio companies so robust you can stop looking
- 11:46for replacements. But wait, isn't radical
- 11:48inactivity basically just falling asleep at the wheel?
- 11:51How is doing nothing an active choice?
- 11:54It's actually the hardest active capital allocation choice.
- 11:57Really. Oh yeah, It requires ignoring
- 12:00quarterly noise, Wall Street panic and the intense urge to
- 12:04take profits. Right.
- 12:06So bring it all together for you listening.
- 12:08Nick Sleep's genius wasn't just holding stocks forever.
- 12:11No, it was doing the grueling work to identify businesses
- 12:14whose moats automatically widen as they grow.
- 12:17Run by founders who prioritize the customers long term surplus
- 12:20over today's margins. Going from cheap cigar butts to
- 12:23the terminal portfolio. Exactly, and we want to end with
- 12:26a powerful question for you to Mull over.
- 12:28It's drawn from Sleep's checklist, but we haven't
- 12:30explicitly discussed it yet. It's.
- 12:32A great thought experiment as you.
- 12:34Look at your own investments or the companies you interact with
- 12:36everyday. Ask yourself this if you cannot
- 12:40explain why your 20th favorite stock idea is nearly as
- 12:45attractive as your top five, why do you even own it?
- 12:48It's so true. In a world obsessed with
- 12:50diversifying into mediocrity, maybe the greatest edge you can
- 12:54have is simply knowing when to do absolutely nothing.
- 12:56Perfectly said. Thank you so much for joining us
- 12:58on this deep dive.