Latest / The So What? / Connecting the Dots
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to the So What podcast, in which political economic analyst JP Landman
- 0:11discusses the issues uppermost in the minds of South Africans. You can find a written
- 0:16version of this content on JP's website, jplandman.co.za. I am Ruda Landman and I am your host.
- 0:28These first few recordings were done at our dining room table, but we will soon be moving
- 0:33into a studio.
- 0:35Hello and welcome once again to a recording to accompany JP's newsletter. This one dated
- 0:43the 26th of April 2022 under the title Connecting the Dots. It is going to be slightly longer
- 0:53than usual because the newsletter is slightly longer than usual. Maybe you want to listen
- 0:58to it in a few sessions, maybe you want to pour yourself a glass of wine and settle in.
- 1:06Why use the metaphor of dots and connecting the dots?
- 1:11It was Steve Jobs who said you can only connect the dots backwards, you cannot connect it
- 1:16forward. I think that is absolutely applicable to where we are in South Africa in terms of
- 1:21political analysis. There are a lot of forecasts going around, a lot of predictions going around,
- 1:27a lot of comment going around. What I do in this newsletter is simply to focus on things
- 1:32that actually have happened. The dots are already on the page. We don't want to speculate
- 1:39about what the page will look like. The dots are on the page. So it's a backward looking
- 1:45methodology if you want. We connect the dots and then we see what the dots tell us. That's
- 1:50basically what I do in this newsletter.
- 1:52The first group of dots, if I can put it that way, concern macroeconomic policy, macroeconomic
- 2:00framework. What exactly does that mean?
- 2:05Macroeconomic policy refers to two things. First of all, monetary policy or interest
- 2:10rates, independent reserve bank, inflation, fighting inflation and so on. That's all monetary
- 2:16policy. Fiscal policy is the second leg, second part of macro policy and that refers to government
- 2:23finances. Now, in the most up-to-date growth theory that we have in the world, that is
- 2:30one of the five critical elements of an economy that would like to grow. That is you've got
- 2:36to have stable macroeconomic policy. In other words, stable monetary policy and stable fiscal
- 2:42policy. Now, I think what has been done in South Africa in the last couple of years,
- 2:47if we connect the dots, are quite remarkable. If I can go to monetary policy first, let's
- 2:53go back to the ANC's conference in December 2017 at NASFEC. There was a resolution adopted
- 2:59that the South African Reserve Bank must be nationalized and it must become part of the
- 3:04public sector or it must be in government ownership. Also at that conference, there
- 3:10were all kinds of noises made about changing the inflation targeting regime in South Africa.
- 3:16Eighteen months after the conference in June 2019, Ismail Shula, who was then still Secretary
- 3:23General of the ANC, pushed the envelope a bit further. He issued a press statement to
- 3:27say that the government should pursue quantity easing. He didn't get a quantitative, but
- 3:34he got to quantity easing and he said that should be government policy. Also in that
- 3:39time, ex-President Zuma issued a tweet in which he said that quantity easing is indeed
- 3:45government policy and if a government doesn't implement that, the government can be recalled.
- 3:51He clearly made a threat there. He would recall that at the same time, the public protector
- 3:56in her infinite wisdom issued a report in which he said the inflation targeting regime
- 4:03in the country must be recalled and the mandate of the Reserve Bank must be changed. There
- 4:08was a huge amount of political pressure on the bank. If you connect those dots in 2017,
- 4:132018, 2019, you can see to what extent there was a total onslaught on the South African
- 4:19Reserve Bank and by implication on independent monetary policy. In June 2019, on precisely
- 4:27Tuesday, the 4th of June 2019, Ismail Shula issued that statement of his, which prompted
- 4:34Mr. Zuma's tweet and so on. 48 hours later, on Thursday, the 6th of June, the top six
- 4:41of the ANC issued a statement from the Tully House to say, this is not the policy of the
- 4:48ANC. The position of the bank remains unchanged. The authority of the Minister of Finance to
- 4:53decide on the inflation target was reconfirmed and that was put out as official government
- 4:59policy. Ismail Shula then find himself in a terrible position that 48 hours after he
- 5:05issued a statement, he now had to issue another statement on behalf of the organization and
- 5:11he is one of the top six have to sign it, committing the ANC to the opposite of what
- 5:16he propagated. There was a clear, clear, clear victory for Mr. Ramaphosa for sound monetary
- 5:22policy and I think we can put June 2019 down as the month on which the tide was turned
- 5:29on the Reserve Bank. Not the only important developments, there were also court cases,
- 5:35but that's a different set of dots and that has to do with a legal fight. I'm focusing
- 5:39here on the political dots. Also in that statement of the 6th of June 2019, the top six said,
- 5:47look, it is the policy of the ANC that the bank should be in public ownership, but we
- 5:52realize that there's a cost involved in it, in other words, you would have to pay shareholders
- 5:56out. In our current fiscal situation, we do not have the money for that and it's not prudent
- 6:01to pursue that option. So that put the whole Reserve Bank thing to bed, so to speak. Now
- 6:07note the dates here. We're talking June 2019, but it was long before a thing called COVID.
- 6:13It was long before that disaster hit us. It was quite clear which way the political wing
- 6:17was blowing. So if you look back since that time, since June 2019, it's now almost three
- 6:24years later, the status of the bank has grown further. Its independence is more assured.
- 6:31We've really deflected or defeated that attack that we saw on the sub-African Reserve Bank.
- 6:37So that's what the dots and monetary policy tell me. If you look at fiscal policy, it's
- 6:41much the same story. And there the turning point for me was in February 2019, more than
- 6:47three years ago, when the president in the state of the nation speech that February said
- 6:53very, very clearly, quote, we will not spend our way out of our economic troubles, unquote.
- 7:00Again, that was before COVID. So that was not on the table at all, where he said, we
- 7:06cannot carry on in the way that we've been going. We've got to curb our spending. And
- 7:11that has been stuck to. Now in 2020, of course, we got COVID and government expenditure, including
- 7:17at least considerably. But here is the benchmark. The economy shrank by about six and a half
- 7:23percent. We now know looking back. At the time, government stimulation measures to try
- 7:29and keep the economy going came to about 5.5 percent. And that is within the rule of thumb.
- 7:34The rule of thumb is if the economy contracts by five or 10 percent, then you must stimulate
- 7:40by five or 10 percent. And that's precisely what we've done. In fact, the one criticism
- 7:45many people make against the government on this particular dot is that we should have
- 7:49spent a bit more. Five point five percent was not enough. We should have spent six or
- 7:53seven percent. Whatever that is, that is what the dot tells us. In 2019 also, when the president
- 8:01made that speech, it was three months before the election. And the chatteling classes were
- 8:05going ballistic about how we're going to see a splurge of spending. Looking back, what
- 8:11does the dot tell us? The dot tells us that in that election here, spending was only 0.3
- 8:18percent more than the ceiling which was set by Treasury. I really don't think that's
- 8:23a catastrophe. In fact, I think it's quite an achievement. So if you look back at the
- 8:28COVID, you look back at the Natal unrest that we had in 2021, you look back at the load
- 8:33shedding that we had on top of COVID, then I think the fact that government succeeded
- 8:38in staying the course of expenditure is no mean achievement. Now, how did that come about?
- 8:44People immediately want to say, oh, it's because there was a commodity boom and we got extra
- 8:49money from there and that helped us. That's quite right. There was a commodity boom, but
- 8:52before the commodity boom, in other words, in the first half of 2021, two other things
- 8:58happened. First, government took a very firm stance on civil service increases and broke
- 9:03their negotiated agreement with the unions on three years of guaranteed increases. Now,
- 9:11the political significance of this mustn't escape one. Ramaphosa was brought into power
- 9:15with the support of Kusato, also others, but definitely Kusato. Now he goes and he breaks
- 9:22an agreement which was negotiated with them. His government breaks it and he says, we can't
- 9:27give that to you. That is not a sign of political weakness. That is not a sign of not looking
- 9:32after your fiscal expenditure. So that year, the increases were null. In the following
- 9:37year, the increases were kept to a minimum and we will see what happens in 2022. But
- 9:43certainly the tough decisions to tackle civil service increases have been made and the consequences
- 9:48are working through. How do we know that? Because in April, Moody's changed their outlook
- 9:53for South Africa from negative to stable. So clearly they can see that the dots are lining
- 9:59up behind prudent fiscal policy. Then we had the lucky break of extra money from the commodity
- 10:05boom and again, government didn't squander it. It was used to reduce the deficit and
- 10:11of course, part of it was used to subsidize people after the Natal unrest. So I'm very
- 10:18happy if we look back, that fiscal and monetary policy that we're meeting the requirements
- 10:23of what has to be done in that area. And that's what I think what the dots tell us.
- 10:29Something that your newsletter also points out and that I think we must actually remember
- 10:34is how close we came to a very rough edge with the attacks on treasury.
- 10:42A very important point and one which was confirmed this last week by the release of the fourth
- 10:48part of the Zondo Commission's report where Mr. Zondo detailed the attacks on treasury.
- 10:53If you remember that weekend special, Des Van Rohean as Minister of Finance, if you
- 10:58remember that about 15 months later, a year later, both the Minister of Finance, Gordon
- 11:04and the Deputy Minister, Deputy Minister Jonas were both just summarily dismissed. Zuma was
- 11:10really going for the treasury. In the end, he failed. He may have come with any whisker,
- 11:15but the fact is he failed. And that's the important point to bring across. And I think
- 11:20what we are now as the statue of the Reserve Bank has risen and become really unassailable,
- 11:27I think inside government, the statue of treasury has likewise risen. And we can talk about
- 11:32that under structural reform to indicate to what extent that has happened. So I'm really
- 11:37very happy with what I said that I think if you look back and you connect the dots on
- 11:42fiscal and monetary policy, we've done well.
- 11:46Your next heading is structural reform. And that's the next group of dots, if we can put
- 11:51it that way. Yes. But structural reform seems to me can mean almost anything to anyone.
- 11:57What do you mean? What do you think the government means when they talk about structural reform?
- 12:03Yeah, it's a very good point. Structural reform means different things to different people.
- 12:09On the left of our politics, it means take away the independence of the Reserve Bank,
- 12:14push up the budget deficit, print money to cover it and so on. On the right hand side
- 12:18of our political spectrum, it deals with deregulate labor markets, ban unions, there mustn't be
- 12:23minimum wages and all that kind of nonsense. What does government mean? Government has
- 12:28put down a very simple eight points or eight bullets, eight point framework. The first
- 12:35one, which is monetary and fiscal policy, which we've already discussed. And the other
- 12:39remaining six, there are eight in total fiscal monetary policy. The remaining six basically
- 12:44deal with introducing the private sector into what is called the network industries. And
- 12:50the network industries is telecommunications, internet, that whole area, spectrum. It's transport,
- 12:58railways and harbors. And it is infrastructure. There is an eighth element which we can talk
- 13:03about and that is what you can call social employment. So those are the eight things
- 13:08that government understands under their policy. That's how I read their policy. And we can
- 13:12take them one by one. The most important one, because it's happened already, is spectrum
- 13:18release. As you know, spectrum release was delayed for 10 years. For the first eight
- 13:23of the 10 years, because of political ineptitude and fighting between the minister and the
- 13:28regulator and so on, a U-turns that was made by the Zuma government, that was eventually
- 13:33sorted out after the mapporza came into power. The last two years, it was delayed by private
- 13:39sector opposition to the proposals for spectrum release. That has now also been overcome.
- 13:45The auction has taken place and 14.4 billion rand came into the treasury in payment for
- 13:50that. So that's, I think, a huge dot. Just by the way, Rudha, we must just note that
- 13:56when it comes to telecommunications and internet connection and so on, it's not just the government.
- 14:01It's also players outside government who've put down important dots. Think of the Facebook
- 14:07consortium that's building a cable linking the whole African continent with the world.
- 14:12And there's the Google cable, which is also supposed to be finished at the end of this
- 14:18year, which will increase by 10 times all the current capacity linking South Africa
- 14:24to the international internet world. Nothing to do with government, but also happening.
- 14:29So I think that the new spectrum release and so on, you look at quite big changes. Inside
- 14:35South Africa, MTN, Vodacom, and Remgrove subsidiary are working very hard to extend cheaper fiber
- 14:42connection into townships and rural areas at lower prices. All that will help to put
- 14:49South Africa on the front foot in terms of telecommunication.
- 14:53The second area is transport, and they're basically railways and harbors. Now, again,
- 15:00just look back and get the long term perspective. Portia Darby, the MD of Transnet, tells us
- 15:06his own words from mine that two years ago, two years ago, the model was a state run monopoly,
- 15:14a state owned monopoly in railways and harbors. Now the policy is to allow the private sector
- 15:19in. It's a big change. The fact that it was brought about by circumstances, brought about
- 15:25by pressure, well, that is how life works. And there's two ways that you can deal with
- 15:29pressure. You can ignore it and try to stumble through, or you can change direction. Clearly,
- 15:34there's a big change in direction. Again, one must have a feeling here for the practical
- 15:40difficulties. Before you can allow the private sector into ports or railways, two things
- 15:46had to happen. You had to separate the operations of Transnet and Portnet from the regulatory
- 15:52function. They were basically judge and prosecutor, if I can use that analogy, and you had to
- 15:58split those ropes. Secondly, you had to split infrastructure from operations so that you
- 16:05can get a true measurement of what cost is. Then you know what to charge people who come
- 16:09and use the infrastructure. Those two things took about 18 months, two years. They've now
- 16:14basically been completed. And what has happened in the last couple of months is a request
- 16:20for proposals was put out for a big new pier in the Durban Harbour. A request was put out
- 16:28for Kucha. And over the Easter weekend, just before the Easter weekend, a request was put
- 16:33out for a liquid gas terminal in Richards Bay. So you can clearly see which way Transnet
- 16:38is moving or Portnet is moving. As far as railway lines go, at the beginning of April,
- 16:45that freight rail opened up slots in the Gauteng Durban corridor for private operators to use.
- 16:53Now here, I just want to make a point. There's a huge amount of public discourse going on
- 16:59about the fact that Transnet and private operators are very far apart under conditions and so
- 17:04on. Let's just stand back a little bit here. South Africa has got a long history. It's
- 17:10a 100 year old history, more than 100 years of state monopolies in the network industries.
- 17:16It goes back to the days of South African railways and harbours. It goes back to the
- 17:20days of the South African post office long before Telcom. So we have a centuries old
- 17:27approach to these matters. Now you change it over from a state monopoly to private sector
- 17:33players participating. You've got to make new rules. You've got to develop new practices.
- 17:38What are those rules? Who must carry the risk? Who must pay for maintenance? Who carries
- 17:43the depreciation charge? What return will be a feasible return? Over what period? Two
- 17:49years, 20 years, 200 years? You've got to work these things out. They don't descend
- 17:54to you from heaven. We've worked them out in the case of toll roads. And how did some
- 17:58rail work at else? Well, Nazir Ali at the time brought everybody into the same room.
- 18:03The lawyers, the engineers, the builders, the government regulators, the bankers who
- 18:08must finance everything. And between them, they sorted out the toll road model, which
- 18:13is working fairly well for South Africa. Now you'll have to go through a similar process
- 18:17now with railway lines. You'll have to go through a similar process with ports. And
- 18:22that's part of developing, moving over from a state run monopoly to one in which the private
- 18:28sector participates. And I think this hysteria that we get from the chattering classes every
- 18:33time there's a kind of a disagreement is also really an area that asks for us to grow up.
- 18:40I think you need a little bit of empathy with people's frustration because things are announced
- 18:45and then it takes two years before anything happens. So it is human to get frustrated.
- 18:53It may be human, but you should also know why it is taking two years. If you have to
- 18:57separate the regulator from the operator and you have to separate infrastructure out that
- 19:02kind of thing, you know, we also need empathy for that. The reality is that it takes time
- 19:07to develop new practices. And that's where we are. We don't live in a Mary Poppins world.
- 19:13No, we don't. The next thing on your list of patterns of dots is energy reform. You
- 19:20have spoken about this quite often and there is a lot of information, a lot of there are
- 19:26a lot of numbers in this section. So I'm going to ask you to try and just very broad strokes
- 19:35and then we refer the listeners to a graph which is on the website.
- 19:40Yeah, absolutely. Look, in the last two years, I counted, I've written about energy seven
- 19:45times explaining what I think is going to happen and what indeed is now happening. Everything
- 19:50that we said will occur is proceeding. So it's quite gratifying from that point of view.
- 19:56I don't want to repeat any of that today. So all I do in my note is to focus on the
- 20:01recent load shedding. And here is the focus. We have load shedding in South Africa because
- 20:06we produce between 4000 and 6000 megawatts too little power. That's why we have load
- 20:13shedding. If we can wave a Harry Potter wand and tomorrow morning have 6000 megawatts of
- 20:18extra power, there'll be no load shedding. So it is now very simple. Just look at what
- 20:24is being done. Just connect the dots on what is being done to produce that 6000 megawatts.
- 20:31And as you say, there's a lovely graph which you have developed, which is in the text.
- 20:36And it basically tells us that that 6000 deficit that we've got is at the moment being covered
- 20:43by 11 and a half thousand megawatts of new capacity that's being installed. There is
- 20:50the last open window fall, which is being connected to the grid this year, 500 megawatts.
- 20:56There is the emergency power procurement, which is dominated by car power ship. Forget
- 21:01about car power ship. It doesn't look as if that deal will happen, but that was only 1200
- 21:07of 2000 megawatts. There's 800 megawatts left over. So you can add that in. Then there is
- 21:13the announcement of October 2020 that municipalities can generate their own power. So far only
- 21:19two municipalities have made use of it. Johannesburg was the first. Cape Town has done it recently.
- 21:25That adds up to about 300 or 500 megawatts. More municipalities will follow, I'm quite
- 21:31sure. But again, it takes time to work through these processes. You know, you don't wave
- 21:36your hand and then you have a municipality procuring power.
- 21:40The big, big game changer was in June 2021, when the president announced that you no longer
- 21:47need a license if you generate power up to 100 megawatts. The ceiling used to be one
- 21:53megawatt. Now from one to 100 is an enormous jump. And not only that, the president also
- 22:00announced in that announcement that you can generate the power below 100 for yourself
- 22:06or anybody else and you can sell it to anybody. This is a huge, huge change that took place.
- 22:13Something that we did predict in the seven times that I read about energy, but it has
- 22:18now happened. Now you can look at the graph in the piece. I'm not going to repeat it all,
- 22:24but all these changes that has already been announced, the decisions have been taken.
- 22:29We're busy with implementation. We'll add up to about 11 and a half thousand megawatts
- 22:34versus a four to six thousand deficit. Now just be careful. One megawatt of renewable
- 22:39power is not the same as one megawatt of base power. But again, be careful. Two things are
- 22:45shifting that. That is if your deficit is six and you get 11 and a half, you're covered
- 22:50to a large extent. And technology is also changing it. New storage technologies are
- 22:55coming in, which is making it possible for renewable operators to provide power 24 hours
- 23:00a day, even if they make use of renewable power. Near Postmasberg in the Northern Cape,
- 23:07there's a plant that is now run for, I think, 12 months. A solar plant run for 12 months,
- 23:13providing power 24 hours a day because of storage technologies that they've got. But
- 23:18I think you must make the point that this will be connected by 2025. It has been procured,
- 23:26but it is still being installed, as you say. Absolutely. Because it takes time to build
- 23:31a plant, then you've got to connect it to the grid. Then you've got problems in the
- 23:34grid. You've got to sort that out. In general, you can talk about 24 months, but in some
- 23:40cases even a bit longer from the date that you start until you actually connect to the
- 23:45grid. So this 11 and a half thousand on my cigarette box analysis will be connected to
- 23:51the grid by 2025. Now that's still three years out. So that to me implies, unless something
- 23:58else changes, that we will have load shedding for another three years. But it also makes
- 24:03it very clear that load shedding will not be a permanent feature of our landscape. I
- 24:08think one should say that as well. I don't think we're looking at a situation like Nigeria,
- 24:13for example, where they've now had load shedding for many, many years and people have just
- 24:17given up on the national system. Here the national system is changing quite dramatically.
- 24:23And it's changing from one which is dominated by a state utility, a state monopoly to one
- 24:28in which the private sector will operate. And by the way, talking about that, all the
- 24:33money needed for this 11 and a half thousand megawatts will come from private sector players.
- 24:38So you're talking massive investments that will take place in the economy already has
- 24:42taken place and will carry on taking place, pushing our investment numbers probably higher
- 24:48than what they were before COVID struck us.
- 24:51The next group of dots concern infrastructure. You've always been quite cautious about infrastructure
- 24:58because you said so many people had to agree on so many things. Is that shifting?
- 25:03Yeah, I think it is shifting. It's precisely right. Doing infrastructure where you mix
- 25:09public and private money and you've got private operators coming in, the kind of thing that
- 25:13we saw with toll roads, is quite a difficult thing to do. You need contracts, you need
- 25:19banking agreements, you need financial arrangements. Now in the case of roads, we've worked it
- 25:24out in other areas we haven't worked it out. And some areas don't lend themselves to it.
- 25:29I don't think you can use, for example, private finance to do a school in a poor area. It
- 25:36just doesn't lend itself to it. But a couple of things have happened. The first is when
- 25:41the president became president, he pushed the idea of the infrastructure fund. It took
- 25:45three years to get that going. He started with it in 2018. By 2021, the thing was established
- 25:51and operational. In this year's budget, Treshtree has allocated quite a few billion rand to
- 25:57it. I think the total for the period for the three years that the budget rolls is 13 billion
- 26:04or more. And they've committed themselves to a hundred, Treshtree has committed itself
- 26:08to a hundred billion over 10 years. And the idea is that you mix in the infrastructure
- 26:13fund, money from Treshtree, from the taxpayer and from the private sector. Now what has
- 26:18changed now is that the first seven projects have been approved by the infrastructure fund.
- 26:25The total investment will be about 21 billion, of which only 2.6 billion, a little bit more
- 26:30than 10% is coming from the infrastructure fund or from the taxpayer. The rest is coming
- 26:36from private players and development institutions. Now that tells you something about the ability
- 26:42of the infrastructure fund to leverage. If you can do 21 billion with 2.6 billion, then
- 26:48you're clearly in a new game. That's the same story. You allowed the private sector to come
- 26:53in to help to finance infrastructure. So I think that that was quite an important shift
- 26:58that took place. The second shift that took place is that the budget for the year that
- 27:03just ended is 22% higher in terms of government infrastructure spending than what it was in
- 27:09the previous year. And in fact, we are now at the level where the rands being allocated
- 27:15are more than what it was before COVID. So there's clearly a comeback in terms of infrastructure
- 27:21spending. But I think the most important dot in this area of infrastructure, Rudha, is
- 27:27the dot where government last year said very clearly and unambiguously, the state cannot
- 27:33do infrastructure. They have to involve the private sector. They have to develop skills
- 27:38and capacity. Now that recognition is a little bit like when you're an alcoholic. The road
- 27:44to recovery begins with admitting that you're an alcoholic. And what is happening at the
- 27:49moment is you're both at the infrastructure fund and at the unit called Infrastructure
- 27:54SA, which is in particular the Laws Department, precisely through its technical advice team,
- 28:00is busy developing the capacity and skills of people to build project pipelines. And
- 28:06that's why I think the dial is beginning to move here. We are not nearly as far advanced
- 28:12as we are in energy, but I think the movement is clear.
- 28:16So let's do a so what in the middle. What does all this mean? Why is it so important?
- 28:22Why do you write about it in such detail? Well, common sense tells you that if you allow
- 28:29the private sector into previous state monopoly areas, you would expect in theory an increase
- 28:36in investment and you would expect in theory an increase in productivity. And that is exactly
- 28:41what Treasury modeling has indicated. Treasury modeling indicates that these changes that
- 28:47we've been talking about can add as much as 1.7% to annual GDP growth. Now our growth
- 28:54rate up till now has been around about 1.5%. So if you can add 1.7, you basically double
- 29:01growth rate. You take your growth rate from 1.5 to 3.2. 3.2% growth is double the population
- 29:09growth rate of 1.6%. So you're now getting back on track. You're now getting back to
- 29:14where we were in the first 10, 15 years after democracy, where the economy grew much faster
- 29:20than the population. And that generates extra resources that can be used to develop. Basically,
- 29:25I think we are busy going back to where we sort of ended, if I may use that word, in
- 29:312008. South Africa had a lovely run, also economically and politically, until about
- 29:382008, 2010. Then the Zuma era kicked in with full force and we all know what happened there.
- 29:44Now, I think we, with a growth rate of 3%, 3.25%, double your population growth rate.
- 29:52We're going back to where we were before the Zuma era struck us.
- 29:57One thing that comes to mind for me, it sounds as if the famous or infamous trust deficit
- 30:04between the government and business or the private sector is being closed.
- 30:11I wouldn't say that at this stage. Let's give it a little bit more time. The private
- 30:17sector, in my view, doesn't appreciate the fact that they've got, really for the first
- 30:23time since Mandela, they've got a business friendly president. I don't think that penny
- 30:28has dropped yet. If you look at some of the things that are being said by business leaders
- 30:32and so on, they're not there yet. The government, on the other hand, doesn't have a full understanding
- 30:38yet of what it means to have the private sector participating. What conditions, what payback
- 30:46periods, what return on capital, what carrying of risk is digestible and whatnot.
- 30:53You've got problems on both sides. Business people don't appreciate what they've got
- 30:57in a business friendly president and the administration doesn't yet quite appreciate what it takes
- 31:02to run a business. I think we'll have to slog a bit more to overcome that trust deficit.
- 31:08The last thing that worries the whole of South Africa, of course, is the unemployment. Is
- 31:15the government doing anything which will shift that?
- 31:18As I said earlier, one of the eight pillars, seven of them deal with the economy. The eighth
- 31:24pillar deals with what I call social employment. This is essentially employing people in all
- 31:30kinds of what you can call artificial ways. Not because that's a permanent solution, it's
- 31:36not, but because it brings temporary relief. Here, the most important one is public employment.
- 31:43In October 2020, when COVID was really at its most merciless, the government announced
- 31:49that 800,000 people will be employed in a public employment program. Now, these are
- 31:54not civil servants. Let's just be clear about that. When you say public employment people
- 31:59immediately jump to civil service positions, that's not what it is. It's positions which
- 32:05gets a stipend of about three to three and a half thousand grand a month. It's not a
- 32:09civil service job. It's usually temporary. Now, at the moment, there are 850,000 people
- 32:15in this program, more than the 800,000 target. There's money in the budget for the next three
- 32:21years to take that up to a million people. Now, if you have a million people in public
- 32:26employment, then have you shifted the numbers on the 12 million unemployed in the country?
- 32:32No, not really, but you are putting a lot of money through 3,500 grand a month. You're
- 32:37putting a lot of money into the poorest people of South Africa in an effort to help. Then
- 32:42there are a couple of other initiatives that was also launched under this program. The
- 32:48one is the SA Youth Mobi platform, which has got 2.3 million young South Africans registered
- 32:55on that platform and 600,000 of them, 25%, have been placed in jobs. Then the National
- 33:04Youth Service, which has been around for a long time, but has completely collapsed, has
- 33:08been revitalized and they will probably employ 50,000 people this year. That is what has
- 33:14been budgeted for and what is planned. Now, again, will 50,000 people change the 12 million
- 33:19unemployed? No, it won't, but it will help 50,000 households. It will help 50,000 people
- 33:26to start getting into the labor market. There are four or five of these initiatives, what
- 33:31I call artificial initiatives, but they help to get people into the labor market. That's
- 33:36the important point. In the end, there's no substitute. If you want to employ more people,
- 33:42if you want to bring that down, that 12 million unemployed, you need more economy. You're
- 33:46not going to employ 10 million more people in the same size economy. You need a bigger
- 33:51economy to employ more people. That is where the structural reform measures come in. Until
- 33:57such time as the structural reform measures have kicked in and start having an effect,
- 34:02you need these kinds of short-term relief measures to combat poverty and keep stability
- 34:07in the country. If you step back and you look at the big picture, what are the main things
- 34:14that these dots tell you? I think the main thing that it tells me is a point that I've
- 34:19already made, and that is that I think we're going back to where we were in 2008, 2009,
- 34:26at the end of the Mbeki period, when we had a long run, a successful run in our economy,
- 34:32where the economy grew faster than the population, where we increased incomes. Because we increased
- 34:38incomes more, money was available to be spent. I think we're going back there. We're leaving
- 34:42behind us the stagnation that we've had over the last couple of years. That's the first
- 34:48point. The second point is, it was Bill Emmett, who was the editor of The Economist. He's
- 34:54now retired in Italy, I believe, who said that the journalist, like the instant analyst,
- 35:02is constantly at the risk of over-interpreting the short term and under-rating the longer
- 35:09term. I think there's a lot of that in South Africa. We are so carried away by the news
- 35:15headlines of the morning, never mind what will come this evening, that we run the risk
- 35:21of instant analysis and coming to the wrong conclusions. That's when I think a longer
- 35:26term view, which you can get by connecting the dots, is such an important input. I think
- 35:33the other thing that I want to say is, it was at the second investment conference in
- 35:372019, I think, where I was in the audience and I listened to the president, and he made
- 35:42a comment which, for me, summarized what he was busy with. It was the beginning of his
- 35:47tenure before COVID, but you can see that that's how he governs. He said, there's an
- 35:53old saying that a man who moves a mountain begins by carrying away the small stones.
- 35:59A man who moves the mountain begins by carrying away the small stones. I think that's what
- 36:05the Ramaphosa administration has been doing. They've been carrying away the small stones,
- 36:10which became bigger and bigger and bigger. You see it beautifully illustrated in energy.
- 36:16You're beginning to see it in transport, in ports and railways. You've seen it in
- 36:22spectrum. I have no question that the stones will get bigger through a process of structural
- 36:27reform, and eventually we will move the mountain.
- 36:34Thank you for listening to the So What Podcast. If you enjoy this content, please don't forget
- 36:39to leave a review and a rating, and please consider subscribing so you don't miss any
- 36:44future episodes. Also, tell your friends. Remember, you can find a written version of
- 36:50all JP's content at jplandman.co.za.