Latest / Adventures Through The Mind / MICRO:10 - Psychedelic Flashbacks: What They Are, and What They Are Not (HPPD) - Ed Prideaux
Transcript
- 0:00flashback as a term from what I, when I was looking into the history of the diagnosis of HPPD,
- 0:06it was like flashback was sort of like the sort of quick term to describe HPPD. Flashback HPPD
- 0:13were the same thing. And I know that in psychedelic culture right now, and in the research,
- 0:20there's a, there's a complex relationship to that terminology because of how it has been represented,
- 0:27hasn't really been accurate. And,
- 0:28And like terms like bad trip, I think there's sort of a press back to be like, oh, flashback
- 0:35isn't a thing.
- 0:36It's just like leftovers from the ignorance of the drug war propaganda against psychedelics
- 0:44and stuff like this.
- 0:46And I'm wondering if you can comment there about flashbacks and in particular, if you
- 0:55as you're talking about psychedelic flashbacks, what they are, what they're not, how they relate
- 0:59to HPPD, is whether or not, you know, A, it needs to be a psychedelic, such as could it be cannabis,
- 1:09which, I mean, might be counted as a psychedelic, actually, especially depending on high doses,
- 1:16you know, and whether or not it needs to be drug-induced at all,
- 1:20because I know one thing that's going around now in the culture is like, yeah, HPPD is a thing,
- 1:25but it mostly happens. There's a vast amount of people who get it not associated to drugs. And so
- 1:30we shouldn't attribute psychedelics to HPPD. We got to keep this perspective. We got to keep the
- 1:36brand clean here or something like that. There's a lot to speak to there, but that's sort of
- 1:40flashbacks and whether or not drugs need to be involved.
- 1:43Right. Yeah. The flashback issue. You know, the thing is, most people not in the community, so to speak, don't know what psychedelics really are about.
- 1:49Right.
- 1:54But I'd say I venture that everyone might mean my family and teachers at school included had heard of flashbacks before.
- 2:01So it kind of speaks to just how much.
- 2:03That term, and it's kind of associated, and it is basically a propaganda term, has penetrated how people perceive psychedelics.
- 2:12But for what it's worth, I was reading about the history of the flashback literature, and
- 2:20before this podcast, it seems to begin with a particular paper by this guy Horowitz in 69.
- 2:28So this is a couple of years after the summer of love.
- 2:33LSD use was declining and you're starting to see.
- 2:36And obviously there was a certain that obviously there was the existing turning tide that
- 2:40about how clinicians thought about psychedelics you know obviously they were initially perceived
- 2:45by many as being very promising captured by the counterculture more uncontrolled settings
- 2:51you start seeing people freaking out um and horowitz i believe based his writing on um
- 2:59people who had gone to the Haight-Ashbury Free Clinic.
- 3:02So this was a community-run health clinic
- 3:05in the Haight-Ashbury District in San Francisco,
- 3:07which was the epicenter of the psychedelic revolution.
- 3:10Totally, like epicentral.
- 3:12Yeah.
- 3:14And I believe that they had...
- 3:15If I recall, by 1969, about 50,000 people come in through various different things.
- 3:23A lot of people coming in having panic reaction to psychedelics,
- 3:28a lot of people with STDs, STIs, people with heroin addiction, methadone addiction, etc.
- 3:34But some portion of the people who had experimented with psychedelics,
- 3:40when interviewed by Horowitz, reported that,
- 3:43They'd notice certain, let's say, I think that the phrase he uses is spontaneously occurring phenomena.
- 3:52And so Horowitz and this other guy Schick the following year, they were the two main phenomena.
- 4:01the two first scientists to document the phenomenon,
- 4:03but I'll start with Horowitz.
- 4:05So Horowitz's paper,
- 4:07it describes a number of case studies through the Hayes-Ashbury flu clinic.
- 4:12And it's,
- 4:12it's like clearly colored by a negative lens on psychedelics.
- 4:18It's,
- 4:18it's,
- 4:18it's,
- 4:19it's very,
- 4:20I mean,
- 4:20it's just perfect for like journalistic copy at the time.
- 4:23So one case study he describes is this 17 year old who,
- 4:29He seems to have been a pretty eccentric character because he was like,
- 4:30um,
- 4:33Horowitz describes him singing a song of LSD and speed are for me.
- 4:38Like just singing this song.
- 4:41Anyway,
- 4:41this guy,
- 4:42uh,
- 4:42taking a lot of trips and he has started noticing quite vivid,
- 4:47uh,
- 4:48pseudo hallucinations of scorpions overrunning his body.
- 4:52Um,
- 4:53another guy,
- 4:54uh,
- 4:56I believe this is a woman, was having intense sort of prophetic visions of her getting into car crashes.
- 5:04And Horowitz describes, so it's very wide ranging, the flashback phenomenon.
- 5:10And then you see Schick come in the following year and he codified three different kinds of flashback.
- 5:16You had the perceptual flashback, which was, you know,
- 5:21It could include very vivid things like the scorpion guy or the car crash woman, or it could have been spontaneously occurring geometric phenomena.
- 5:31I didn't see much HPPD-style stuff like visual snow in these papers.
- 5:37But anyway, so you have the perceptual flashback.
- 5:39You have the mood flashback.
- 5:41I heard...
- 5:42So Schick writes about someone who would just have spontaneous onsets of depressive mood, which she attributed to a particular LSD trip, and he had somatic flashbacks.
- 5:57From the outset, it was a very broad phenomenon, but the conceptual core of it was the idea of the spontaneous occurrence.
- 6:08And then flashbacks, as you say, they were captured by...
- 6:11So...
- 6:13a certain wing of the drug warrior anti-psychedelic wing um and i was just reading
- 6:20before this about the narconon program which is run by the church of scientology
- 6:25and for what it's worth they've covered they've captured a lot of you know if you look up drug
- 6:29risk online narconon appears all the time i mean in the uk where the church of scientology isn't
- 6:35prominent at all
- 6:36You see their pamphlets being given out, I believe, to schools.
- 6:40And they related flashbacks to L. Ron Hubbard's New Life Detoxification Program, where you could clean all the drugs at your system.
- 6:49You can clean it all out your spine because that was a kind of parallel.
- 6:52Oh, yeah. LSD was in your spinal cord and it was like releasing back into your brain.
- 6:57Right. You know, I was just at a drink the other day and talking to a friend of mine who was at school in the early 2000s.
- 7:03And he was saying how in his like drug education classes, they would still parroting this bullshit that LSD accumulates in your spine.
- 7:05Yeah.
- 7:11And if you click it in the wrong way, you're going to have a flashback.
- 7:15So like it's obviously bullshit, but that end of it. But flashbacks.
- 7:21So as I say, from the outset, a very broad, fuzzy phenomenon. And it seems that the emphasis in the clinical literature is to move away from that term, because I mean, if only because it's so because it's so toxic, and it's been so weaponized.
- 7:37But that said, I mean, I was describing at the start of the podcast that there are two types of HGPD.
- 7:42You have the type one, which is like the flashback, the spontaneous occurrence.
- 7:47But, you know, interestingly, in the literature, there's a tendency to describe the type one flashback phenomenon as being positive, which is.
- 7:57It seems to be a lot of the time, but then other people find their spontaneous flashbacks actually quite distressing.
- 8:04So maybe that's another room for kind of for evolution and the literature.
- 8:11But and whether HGPD really...
- 8:14Whether it really is the same thing, these two types, I'm not sure because there seems to be quite a strong difference between it being an invested feature of your whole way of experiencing the world versus just spontaneity happening.
- 8:29But I think that's just why we need more research because, I mean, speaking as someone who has read the literature but is still not a scientist, I have no idea.
- 8:39idea what is going on when you have a spontaneous re-experiencing. But that said,
- 8:47another question you put in there was, what's the link to psychedelics? You're absolutely right that
- 8:54HGPD is an unfortunately name disorder because there is no
- 9:02the sole link between these changes and psychedelics. I mean, people, I mean,
- 9:08psychedelics in and of themselves are such a broad set of drugs. I mean, you have LSD,
- 9:15you have Ibogaine, you have DMT, you have psilocybin. I mean, LSD is serotonergic,
- 9:21and dopaminergic psilocybin i believe is just serotonergic but both can create these changes
- 9:28uh salvia can create these changes just cannabis i mean the cannabis hits is not it's it's hitting
- 9:34cannabinoid receptors uh maybe others are not an expert i think it has impact on uh dopamine
- 9:40receptors too but i'm not i'm not up on the right pharmacology of cannabis right
- 9:46Interesting. OK. But yeah, so all sorts of drugs can trigger these changes. I mean, even SSRI antidepressants have been linked to these perceptual changes. So what does all this suggest? It suggests on the one hand that...
- 10:03This is clearly a very complicated phenomenon
- 10:07at the level of neurophysiology
- 10:10that I'm not really an expert to address,
- 10:12but I can maybe outline.
- 10:13So the original hypothesis by Dr. Henry Abraham,
- 10:18who was the...
- 10:19who is the psychiatrist who first codified the condition of HGPD, is that psychedelics caused a surge of electrical current in the brain that damaged certain neurons that kind of control how the brain filters out vision information.
- 10:37And he links it to the serotonergic system. But as I just said, like non-serotonergic drugs, non-serotonergic recreational drugs can create these changes.
- 10:47And the fact that SSRIs can as well. But even people have had experiences where taking antipsychotics can trigger them.
- 10:59one but so a potential treatment for hdpd can create the changes themselves independently
- 11:04i've read reports of people taking a certain classes of antibiotics and then having these
- 11:10changes so there's no definitive link to just psychedelics sure and from what i understand
- 11:15there are also people who just have extreme experiences that have nothing to do with any
- 11:18kind of drug and end up having these changes too is that correct
- 11:21Right. Yeah. So this is something that's been emphasized by Dr. Terry Krebs, who is a really valuable voice on this issue, which is that people experience exactly the same kind of visual phenomena.
- 11:26So,
- 11:37The visual snow, the halos, the auras, the traces were just anxiety.
- 11:44And from the very limited reading I've done, this might make sense.
- 11:50even on a neurophysiological level,
- 11:52because anxiety is associated with lower levels of GABA.
- 11:57And GABA is what is being released to kind of inhibit...
- 12:03So if you have less...
- 12:07So I might be getting a little confused in neurophysiology, but less GABA is it ties into the theory that Abraham had outlined about kind of neuronal damage.
- 12:19And then at the same time, more anxiety is associated with more fixation on symptoms.
- 12:27So maybe this isn't a matter of neurophysiology at all.
- 12:30Maybe it's an issue of people in more anxious states fixating on certain symptoms that
- 12:36may be a fairly normal, but then within the anxious, elevated state, they're all intensified.
- 12:43We just don't really know. But psychedelics specifically, I mean, it's undeniable that
- 12:50despite the fact that there's a wide ranging pharmacology or indeed non-pharmacological
- 12:57influences that create these symptoms psychedelics do play a role i mean like sometimes very quickly
- 13:05i mean my i first started noticing changes the next day some people uh within a week some people
- 13:12within a few days but then at the same time there's so much vagueness in the literature some
- 13:17some people are diagnosed with having had hdpd 20 years later which doesn't make too much sense to me
- 13:22Um, but that said psychedelics just maybe not psychedelics are associated in some kind
- 13:31of special way.
- 13:32It seems there's something about the way they work, uh, that creates them more.
- 13:36I mean, LSD by far is associated with HPD more than any other drug.
- 13:41So whilst cannabis can cause it, whilst MDMA can cause them, LSD seems to be, um,
- 13:47above all the others, the one most likely to trigger them.
- 13:51I mean, from my personal perspective, I think that this is a very complicated condition,
- 13:56which just speaks to how little we know about how the brain works.
- 14:00And I think that drugs are likely some kind of just catalyst.
- 14:04They're a kind of psychoaccelerance that can create changes that...
- 14:12that can create changes that the brain and the visual cortex are already capable of producing.
- 14:20And there might be a kind of looping feedback.
- 14:24There might be a feedback loop with anxiety, but we just don't know.
- 14:31What you just heard was a clip from episode 152 of Adventures Through the Mind.
- 14:36The title of that is Hallucinogen Perception Persisting Disorder, HPPD, with Ed Perdeaux.
- 14:44It's one of my older episodes, and whenever I go back to make these clips, it always amazes me how...
- 14:51I guess how much progress, progress, progress, progression I have had in my audio and video quality. If you've ever gone back and watched anything from, especially before episode 100, compared to some of the things that are coming out over the last year or so,
- 15:08It's really night and day.
- 15:12Now that said, the whole episode does explore a topic that was at least at the time very under-discussed and discussed in a distorted way.
- 15:21It's still under-discussed, but at least it is coming more into the forefront thanks to people like Ed.
- 15:29That entire episode is going to be listed in the show notes of this one wherever you're checking it out. And that's it for this little micro. As you may or may not know, micros are clips from older episodes that come out in between full length episodes.
- 15:45And so the next episode coming out will be a full length one.
- 15:49And the one before you guessed it was also a full length one.
- 15:52The one before this episode was actually episode 200, a very long episode that featured for the first time a lecture that I recorded explicitly for the podcast, Slides and All.
- 16:02If you're watching it where you can, well, watch it, such as at least for now, Spotify and YouTube.
- 16:08And that's it. Please subscribe to the show if you like this. If you want other people to find it,
- 16:14you could share it, but you could also leave positive reviews and any kind of positive
- 16:18engagement, ratings and such, because that helps the algorithm be told that people like this so
- 16:25that other people can discover that they will also like it. And that's it. Thanks for listening to
- 16:30this short little micro. I've been your host, James Jesso, and I'll see you on the next one.
- 16:35And until then, take care and stay curious.