Latest / Tribe and Tribulations With Julia Makowsky / The Courage to Call: Supporting Jewish Women Through Unplanned Pregnancies
Transcript
- 0:00What happens if a girl who's 16 years old comes to you and says,
- 0:05my parents don't know I am pregnant and I don't know what to do?
- 0:11What's your first step?
- 0:13Let's slow down the process and think.
- 0:15Don't make a decision in a day.
- 0:16Slow that process down and call Shifra.
- 0:19Have conversations to understand what is there for you.
- 0:22The panic is often not what it seems.
- 0:25Pregnancy is technically hidden.
- 0:26And especially for the first three months, we have this idea,
- 0:29you can't tell anybody.
- 0:30If there's a risk of losing baby because you don't want to jinx
- 0:33anything because you might hurt somebody's feelings.
- 0:34The pregnancy is separate from the
- 0:35child.
- 0:36Forget wanted.
- 0:37Some people hate being pregnant.
- 0:38It does not mean that unloved child,
- 0:39you can absolutely love the child.
- 0:41You cannot want something and not know it's the best thing for you.
- 0:47Welcome back to Tribe and Tribulations.
- 0:50I am so glad you are here today.
- 0:53We are discussing
- 0:54something very meaningful, but also a little nuanced and something that is not talked about
- 1:06within the Jewish community.
- 1:10I am joined today with Erica Pellman, who is the founder of Shifra.
- 1:17Shifra is an organization that helps support women with unwanted pregnancies.
- 1:24While I know that the reaction when somebody says they don't want a pregnancy in a world where people are dying to get pregnant can be extremely triggering and overwhelming.
- 1:41And if that is your case, it's okay to check this episode out at a later date when you can take it in.
- 1:55Today's conversation shines a light on a topic that's often deeply personal and rarely discussed openly.
- 2:02I'm joined by the team behind Shifra, the only American-based organization dedicated to supporting Jewish women through unplanned pregnancies.
- 2:14They equip them for motherhood through counseling, financial assistance, practical resources, and ongoing support if needed.
- 2:22Working with rabbis and Jewish leaders across the spectrum,
- 2:26Shifra has helped more than 350 mothers and their babies into the world with dignity,
- 2:31compassion, and a strong support system.
- 2:35I am grateful to have this conversation and explore what it really means to show up for women
- 2:40and families when they need it most.
- 2:45For people who are just hearing about Shifra for the first time,
- 2:50why was it created?
- 2:52Well, first, thanks for having me, Julia.
- 2:54I appreciate it.
- 2:55It's my pleasure.
- 2:56Yeah.
- 3:00So I grew up in Texas, but I don't sound like it.
- 3:02I may sound like I'm from New Jersey, but in fact, I grew up in Texas.
- 3:07And in my 20s, I came to this part of the country to meet a Jewish man and get married, and that was all successful.
- 3:17and I was actually not having an unplanned pregnancy.
- 3:20I was actually trying to get pregnant and it wasn't working.
- 3:28And I went into my work one day and I was like, what do you want?
- 3:32I was in that, the other side of the spectrum.
- 3:34What do you want from me, God?
- 3:37What do you want me to do with my life?
- 3:39And in that moment, I thought back to a very different experience
- 3:43that had happened three years before when a friend of mine had called me
- 3:46to tell me that she was pregnant and she wasn't going to keep the baby.
- 3:50She was going to end the pregnancy.
- 3:53And that moment was so painful.
- 4:02It was so painful because even though I understood why she wanted to end the pregnancy,
- 4:09she was 23, the father of the baby was not good fatherhood material.
- 4:15she you know wanted to be a mother but not yet it was still a loss and suddenly I was in my own
- 4:22moment of longing for a baby and I had a question what if she had wanted to have that baby
- 4:29who would have been there for her even when it wasn't the right time because here I was I was
- 4:33in the right time and I couldn't get pregnant and I thought suddenly started thinking about
- 4:36people who are not in the right time what would they need to have that baby
- 4:40So it was born from that moment of just asking, like, what would she have needed?
- 4:49When she was in crisis, what would she have needed to have the baby?
- 4:52And that was the beginning of Shifra.
- 4:56Two weeks after I went into my work and I asked that question, I found out I was pregnant for the first time.
- 5:03Wow.
- 5:04So my journey has been looking at becoming a mother and then looking about how to help mothers who didn't plan on it.
- 5:14What gap did you see within the Jewish community?
- 5:18I know you're coming from a place of experience with your friend.
- 5:22But when you looked to start this organization, was there anything out there like this?
- 5:29There wasn't.
- 5:30That was what was strange is that in Israel, there has been organizations that were set up for 50 years and there was nothing in New York City.
- 5:40A Jewish woman gets pregnant in New York City and for whatever reason it is a crisis, there was no organization to go.
- 5:48None.
- 5:49The whole city that was dedicated to her needs.
- 5:51You could show up at a general social services but they don't have like – they're not set up for this particular crisis.
- 5:59You know, the millions of dollars that, say, an organization like OHEL spends, they're spreading it on every social service need, you know.
- 6:08But someone who's about to have a baby unexpectedly needs a lot of attention.
- 6:11And there was nobody there with that resources financially, the therapeutic resources, nothing.
- 6:17It wasn't there.
- 6:18It wasn't there.
- 6:18And it wasn't there for decades.
- 6:20I think it's also because people are scared.
- 6:23This is a conversation that is so uncharted territory for most people that the idea is like see no evil, hear no evil.
- 6:38Where it's like people don't have unwanted pregnancies.
- 6:42That's not a thing within our community.
- 6:44Of course you want a baby.
- 6:46But I've seen it.
- 6:48You've seen it.
- 6:50There are so many different reasons why a woman might be in a position that she can't have a baby or she's questioning whether or not she's able to.
- 7:03Can you give me a few examples of situations women have come to you in and you've been able to coach them through it and help them through that?
- 7:14Yeah.
- 7:15So a lot of times when people hear unplanned pregnancy, they think teen pregnancy.
- 7:19And that is not really – I am much more likely to get a phone call from someone who is 44, has given away all of her baby things, her youngest is 10 years old, and then she finds out she's pregnant.
- 7:31Wow.
- 7:32I'm much more likely to hear from her than hear from someone who's a teenager.
- 7:35But it's still an unplanned pregnancy, and she still does not know how she's going to handle the lifestyle change, going back to diapers.
- 7:43She may be married and in a secure place, but she thought her life was going one direction.
- 7:48And now knowing the demands of motherhood, she's scared about bringing a baby into her home.
- 7:54And I think that's more common than we care to admit because I know even with my last, I was totally ready.
- 8:03I wanted him.
- 8:06But while I was pregnant, I suffered from antepartum depression.
- 8:11and during my pregnancy I could not see past myself.
- 8:15I literally could not see past myself
- 8:18and there were moments where like,
- 8:19how am I going to do this?
- 8:21How am I going to do this?
- 8:22And luckily I had a husband who was extraordinarily supportive
- 8:26and pushed me to go get the help that I needed.
- 8:29But there are a lot of women out there
- 8:32who don't even know who to go to.
- 8:35And they're feeling alone,
- 8:37whether it's because they're in a domestic violence situation, whether they're in an antepartum depression situation like I was.
- 8:45Or like you said, they're 45 years old.
- 8:48They didn't think that they were going to have any more kids and all of a sudden they have a baby and they're like, what is happening?
- 8:54Right.
- 8:54And maybe their older kids have special needs.
- 8:57I mean maybe they're incredible parents and they're – or maybe it's the other end of the spectrum.
- 9:02They have a two-year-old.
- 9:03They have a one-year-old or less than one-year-old.
- 9:05They have a six-month-old and then they're nursing and they think that they can't get pregnant and they become pregnant.
- 9:10They're like, how am I going to have three under two?
- 9:13That happens.
- 9:16We get every type of scenario, people leaving marriages, people who decide to get married after they become pregnant, 40-year-olds, 20-year-olds.
- 9:25It's a whole spectrum.
- 9:29What do you do in Shifra that can help support these women?
- 9:35Can you talk a little bit about I'm – it's my first phone call.
- 9:39I don't know who to call.
- 9:41I'm feeling stressed.
- 9:42I'm feeling overwhelmed.
- 9:44Do I call Shifra?
- 9:45Do I call a rabbi?
- 9:46Do I call my husband?
- 9:48Who am I calling for help when I don't know what my next steps are?
- 9:53So for Shifra, one of the things that makes us different perhaps than others in the field of unplanned pregnancy is –
- 10:03Not that there's anyone else in this field in Jewish groups in the United States, but in general, is that the person who picks up the phone is a therapist.
- 10:10It's not a volunteer.
- 10:12And that therapist is going to be with you throughout your pregnancy.
- 10:17If you're having the baby through the baby's first birthday and if the pregnancy ends for any reason, also there for you after that.
- 10:24So that's number one is I, as a therapist, you appreciate that.
- 10:29I don't think this is a job for volunteers because people are grappling with a lot of
- 10:35complex issues.
- 10:36And I also don't think it's a volunteer because when somebody comes and they
- 10:39say, I have an older child with autism.
- 10:45I get extremely sick from my pregnancies.
- 10:47My marriage
- 10:48is on the rocks.
- 10:49I don't know how I'm going to afford the baby.
- 10:51I can't give you a simple answer
- 10:53to that.
- 10:54Okay.
- 10:55It's layers of issues.
- 10:57But what I can do is I can layer on layers of love,
- 11:00starting with an actual therapist who is going to be there for you through long-term, like through
- 11:06the entire transition, through the entire pregnancy, that one person.
- 11:10And then upon that,
- 11:11we layer more layers.
- 11:12So we have financial aid that is substantial.
- 11:15That isn't like,
- 11:16oh, you need baby clothes.
- 11:17It's asking people, what do you need?
- 11:19Some people need baby clothes.
- 11:20They gave away all their baby stuff.
- 11:22But some people have a cousin who can give them baby things.
- 11:24But you know what?
- 11:25Their house is so crazy and so disorganized and they are so overwhelmed.
- 11:30They're in tears thinking about bringing a baby home.
- 11:32And you know what?
- 11:33We're going to go and help her get it organized and get it together so she can have a space
- 11:37to welcome her baby home.
- 11:39And someone else calls us and they're homeless.
- 11:42I mean, we have Jewish women calling us who got kicked out of where they were living because
- 11:47they were pregnant.
- 11:48I'm not talking about a 17-year-old.
- 11:49I'm talking about a 35-year-old who was in an abusive relationship.
- 11:52She doesn't have a place to live and our money is going to go towards getting her stabilized and in a home.
- 11:58And whatever it's going to be for that woman – and some people don't need any money.
- 12:02They need the therapy or they need a couples counselor.
- 12:04We also have a couples counselor on staff to work with the marriage, work with the relationship to get them through it and navigate to the other side.
- 12:13And the thing is, is that I compare it to this.
- 12:20When I was younger, when I was 15, I went through a period of time where I wasn't sure if God existed.
- 12:30And I wanted to believe in God, but I just didn't.
- 12:33So I'm like, what if it's all made up?
- 12:35And I had this feeling of darkness and loneliness.
- 12:39and I remember I was with my mom and I was at the Shabbat table and I was crying and she looked at
- 12:45me and she said, it's okay if you don't believe, I'll believe for us both.
- 12:50And so sometimes people
- 12:51are calling, they're just in the dark and they don't know how to believe and not here, they're,
- 12:55they're pregnant.
- 12:56There's this possibility of this new life and they're, they still feel like
- 13:00they're in the darkness and it's okay to be in the darkness and I can believe for us both.
- 13:06I can know that there's another side to this, but you don't have to be there yet.
- 13:09And we will walk with you.
- 13:10And we're not going to solve your problems like instantly, but we're going to take the
- 13:14layer after layer of what you need to be taken care of.
- 13:19You know, what's so beautiful about that is that we live in a world where saying things
- 13:27out loud can feel so scary.
- 13:30And that's the first step is somebody coming and saying to you, I need help.
- 13:37I don't know if I could carry this burden.
- 13:41And there is that question sometimes where it goes, is this pregnancy right?
- 13:45And one of the things we forget as a community is that the mother's life comes before the unborn child's life.
- 13:58and there is not a rabbi that I know that disagrees with that because if God forbid
- 14:05a woman's life is on the line, they're there to support the woman whatever means necessary.
- 14:15And I think you are giving women the ability to make an informed decision because they have
- 14:22access to the things that maybe are holding them back from having the pregnancy.
- 14:29Right.
- 14:29So a lot of people look at it and if you're in a state of panic, as I'm sure you talk
- 14:34about with your clients and with your staff, when you're in fight or flight or freeze mode,
- 14:41right, you're in a state of panic.
- 14:43Everything seems fixed.
- 14:46That's why you freeze because it's like this is how life is and I don't know what to do,
- 14:50right?
- 14:51But nothing is really fixed.
- 14:52So it's not like I can't afford a baby.
- 14:55Whether or not you can afford a baby is not a one-moment thing.
- 14:58You may not be able to afford a baby right now, but we bring you resources.
- 15:01We help you get a better job.
- 15:02We help get you baby things.
- 15:04Whatever it is, maybe you could afford a baby.
- 15:09Or I can't handle another baby.
- 15:11Well, you're right.
- 15:12You can't handle another baby right now with the skills you have.
- 15:14But we have parenting classes.
- 15:16we have a therapist to work with you to expand your ability.
- 15:20I remember we had one woman call us
- 15:23and she, um, she had a three year old, she had a two year old and a one year old,
- 15:28and then she became pregnant and she actually had a Hector to end her pregnancy from her rabbi,
- 15:34but she was torn and she called us and we had a conversation with her.
- 15:38Um, and the issue was,
- 15:43she'd actually come from a very large family and she didn't she saw some unhealthy dynamics in that
- 15:48family and she was terrified you know that that maybe so many kids she could repeat those dynamics
- 15:55and what the counselor pointed out to her is somebody who cares that much is already a good
- 16:00mother somebody who wants that for their kids is already good married she could trust herself
- 16:06as a mother that she could get through it but also because we were going to walk with her
- 16:10And we – she worked with our therapist and worked with our Nurture Her Parenting program to the point where she not only continued the pregnancy, but people would come up to her and tell her how incredibly patient she was with her kids.
- 16:25Wow.
- 16:26I mean that's an impressive thing because even as a parent who wants a baby, most of us can be not so patient with our kids.
- 16:34So that's the thing is that unplanned pregnancies can give you a life that's better than what you planned.
- 16:39it can um that's the possibility there but not by like wishful thinking by doing the kind of
- 16:46inner work that pushed her to the absolute edge that one i mean her marriage was pushed
- 16:50the edge her husband did not want her to have that baby but now that when she chose to continue
- 16:56they had to reinvent the marriage and they did you know and so they ended up in far better than
- 17:01what a position than they would have ever hoped to but they had to go through the darkness to the
- 17:05light which yeah when when you started this organization this was not a one two three kind
- 17:18of thing this wasn't just like okay one day i'm gonna just like pick it up figure it out and go
- 17:24i'm assuming right no okay what are some of the trial and error moments that you've had while
- 17:35you know creating something meaningful like we being a parent is sometimes honestly my first
- 17:42kid is I love her she's so good but she's kind of my trial child like I'm I'm trying my best to
- 17:49figure it out right um but what is something that you've learned that's really helped
- 17:56your the community that you've built and this organization you've built feel supported well
- 18:02First, let me just say, you know, I told you the story.
- 18:03Like when I started Shifra, I found out two weeks later I was pregnant with my first child who is now 17.
- 18:11And I feel like, you know, it only takes nine months to gestate a baby.
- 18:14It takes me really more like 12 years to gestate an organization.
- 18:18I mean, maybe 14 years to gestate the organization to the point where we were, you know, three years ago we doubled the number of women we were helping when we actually got on Instagram for the first time.
- 18:30So it takes a lot longer.
- 18:32I mean, and it took a lot of resilience for me.
- 18:34I mean, the first year I had this idea, we had one person call.
- 18:38The second year, we had one person call.
- 18:41It took a long time to even find people.
- 18:44You know, we were in a catch-22.
- 18:46In order for someone to call an organization, you have to trust them.
- 18:50But in order for people to trust us, they need to call so we can show that we can help.
- 18:53So it took so many years to build up that trust and build up, you know, now we have
- 18:58a whole community of women who have been through their pregnancies and they're helping each other
- 19:03and they're, you know, but it's, it's taken a long time and it's a lot of trial and error.
- 19:08I
- 19:08didn't start off with therapists answering the phone.
- 19:10Initially I thought I could do with
- 19:11volunteers, but then I saw like, no, these things are too intense.
- 19:16Especially since when you think
- 19:18about it, that first phone call took a lot of courage for somebody to get on that other line
- 19:22and dial your number.
- 19:24And if somebody answers the phone who maybe isn't trained in managing
- 19:30a crisis situation or is overwhelmed and has their own emotional response to what's going on,
- 19:39they might not be able to really, A, dedicate time, energy, and emotional capacity to help this
- 19:48person come to a choice that is really life or death.
- 19:55Yeah.
- 19:56And it needs to be – I mean I also don't hire anybody who is under 50 for this job
- 20:01really.
- 20:02I mean it's like the counselors have to be someone who have lived their life, have
- 20:06raised their kids and have a tremendous amount of clinical training so that they really can
- 20:11do it with that, can walk the journey with them.
- 20:19I'm going to ask you something about something a little controversial and I know it's not
- 20:25comfortable but I think it needs to be asked what happens if a girl who's 16 years old comes to you
- 20:33says my parents don't know I am pregnant and I don't know what to do what's your first step
- 20:43so with a 16 year old the first thing that we would do is work with them on who is safe for
- 20:49them to tell in their support network i mean the first thing is awesome first obviously is she safe
- 20:55is what's the circumstances of this is she safe that would be the first thing we'll be taking
- 21:00care of because safety of the mother comes first and then the second thing would be helping her
- 21:05connect with someone in her in her it could be her parents supporting her and talk having that
- 21:09first conversation with her parents um because we're not going to work with someone under age
- 21:14unless we're there's they're with an adult yeah parental consent or or they've connected with
- 21:20another adult if somehow they couldn't live with their parents anymore and they needed another
- 21:23legal guardian then whatever it is and then there would there would be a process i mean we rarely
- 21:27rarely get that i'll tell you one story of when we did we had a 16 year old call us once um who was
- 21:35pregnant.
- 21:36She didn't find out she was pregnant until she was 32 weeks pregnant.
- 21:41What?
- 21:42Yeah.
- 21:43She didn't find out she was pregnant.
- 21:44She was 32 weeks pregnant.
- 21:45Wow.
- 21:46Someone had told her she couldn't get pregnant.
- 21:49Woe to that doctor.
- 21:50She had been, you know, not making a lot of good choices in a lot of ways.
- 21:55Not just that.
- 21:56She'd also been using some drugs.
- 21:58I mean, she was not doing great.
- 22:01And
- 22:01she
- 22:06was like talking about adoption
- 22:07and placing for adoption because that's generally like
- 22:10a choice
- 22:11in that stage of pregnancy
- 22:12at 16 she definitely was not
- 22:15ready to be a mom
- 22:18but then
- 22:19she went through a period of time
- 22:21in which she actually considered having a late term
- 22:23abortion and actually flying to Colorado
- 22:25and doing it because she was just so
- 22:29she was so scared and she felt
- 22:31Like maybe she just screwed up the baby permanently.
- 22:37And then there was not, you know, in that situation, what were we doing for her?
- 22:40We were praying for her.
- 22:42We were davening for her.
- 22:43You know, she was really in crisis.
- 22:45And my concern was she's going to live with this for the rest of her life.
- 22:48This is a 32-week-old fetus.
- 22:51And at the very last moment, she, I mean, we were all praying for her.
- 22:54I got people who were wanting to have kids praying for this girl.
- 22:57The last moment she wrote a text, I'm ready to make an adoption plan.
- 23:00We don't do adoption.
- 23:01But we connected her with a place.
- 23:03She got in a home and she ended up giving birth on Parsha Nitzavim, which is the Parsha that says choose life that everyone that you and your children should live.
- 23:13And but what's interesting is the postscript of hers.
- 23:16You know, her life after that changed for the better.
- 23:20She did Project Extreme.
- 23:22Wow.
- 23:22She she.
- 23:24Yeah.
- 23:24Project Streams.
- 23:25Amazing.
- 23:26She did Project Extreme.
- 23:27She ended up going to Israel.
- 23:28She got married.
- 23:30like that moment was actually an inflection point as hard as that i'm sure was she only
- 23:35knows she was pregnant for a short time but if it had been longer we would have had to take care
- 23:38you know connect her with people could take care of her but she didn't get worse she got better
- 23:43like that when she saw the birth adoption adoptive mother hold the baby she um she's
- 23:51she said to her mom i think i'm finally getting how much you love me well yeah but that's the
- 23:56minority of what we do.
- 23:57I mean, that's a one in 17 year story.
- 24:01Most people are, like I said,
- 24:02more likely to be 35 than 15.
- 24:04It's funny when we had a preliminary meeting about doing this
- 24:09podcast together and you happened to have mentioned that like there are women that are
- 24:14Hasidic women who will call up and ask for help because they've had 10 kids and all of a sudden
- 24:21they're pregnant again and they're like, I can't do this.
- 24:24It's not fair.
- 24:25And I think that
- 24:28understanding that every woman can have moments of not feeling like enough
- 24:38and not feeling like they can do it.
- 24:40And it doesn't matter whether you've had 10 babies,
- 24:46one baby, no babies.
- 24:49We all have self-doubt.
- 24:52And I think that that is kind of the underlying,
- 24:59I would say epidemic that come with women and motherhood.
- 25:05You know, we think that
- 25:07we're going to lose ourselves when we're a parent or we're going to not know what to do.
- 25:13We're going
- 25:13to screw up the kids.
- 25:14And by the way, you probably will screw up the kids a little bit.
- 25:17That's part
- 25:18of parenting.
- 25:19Okay.
- 25:20I think that most people think that like they have to have everything figured out
- 25:25all the time and most people don't have anything figured out.
- 25:29You know, we tell her, we often tell
- 25:31this to women who are feeling intimidated by this prostactive pregnancy that wasn't planned.
- 25:36This, this Neshama chose you actually.
- 25:40So as much as on one level, it feels like unplanned,
- 25:42And, you know, in the world of this world, it feels like, you know, this is an accident.
- 25:48Maybe not.
- 25:49Maybe this neshama came to you.
- 25:51This child chose you and knew what it was getting into.
- 25:55And this is actually this journey, you as a mom and the child, like for all of us, like this is the journey you're supposed to be on.
- 26:02I mean, for me, like one of the things I like to say is thank you, Hashem, for making my kids perfect according to your will.
- 26:09Not perfect according to my will.
- 26:10They're not, you know, kids don't fit your picture.
- 26:13They're way better.
- 26:15They're way better.
- 26:16And you have to know that about yourself.
- 26:18You don't fit some picture.
- 26:19You're way better.
- 26:22And, yeah.
- 26:26When people are coming to you, do you find that their need is more financial or more emotional?
- 26:32Yes.
- 26:33Yes.
- 26:33Yes to both.
- 26:36It's both.
- 26:37You know, and it's funny.
- 26:38Maybe there's two broad categories.
- 26:39Sometimes somebody is calling to us and like life is falling apart from them.
- 26:42Their marriage is falling apart.
- 26:45They have children with special needs.
- 26:46They feel like they're barely holding it together.
- 26:49And like then this comes on top and they're just like, I don't know how I'm going to take care of this.
- 26:54They're married.
- 26:55They're not married.
- 26:55Whatever it is, okay?
- 26:57And then there's some people who come and their life is so rigid and so clear.
- 27:02And I'm going to buy this house and I'm going to do this.
- 27:05And then they have this come, this unplanned pregnancy.
- 27:09and they don't have room for life.
- 27:11They have room for their plan and they don't have room for life.
- 27:15And it's like, can you make room for this?
- 27:17And those people, they don't have a financial need.
- 27:19It's not that.
- 27:20It's all emotional.
- 27:23It's okay, you're going to take one less vacation,
- 27:26like that kind of thing.
- 27:27But it's like, can you make room for life?
- 27:28Can you make room for a life that's better than the one you planned?
- 27:33I think the idea that it is better is so far from a person's brain when they're in it.
- 27:42For sure.
- 27:43Like meaning there are – I know in theory I wanted a baby.
- 27:49I want children.
- 27:50I want a family.
- 27:51But this might not be the right time or the right person or the right anything.
- 27:55So saying that to somebody, which is why it's important that you have a therapist on the other line, right?
- 28:00Because our initial response is like, but it's going to be so good and you're going to be a great mom and blah, blah, blah.
- 28:06Like that's not necessarily what somebody needs to hear.
- 28:11A hundred percent.
- 28:12I'm just – no, for sure.
- 28:14That was not what my counselor would say at all.
- 28:15But it's just like in the end, that is what happens is the making room for something.
- 28:20Making room.
- 28:21But that's not where you go first.
- 28:22Where you go first is it makes sense you don't want this baby right now.
- 28:26It makes sense.
- 28:27Like, you know, it's not the right time.
- 28:30Maybe it's not the right time.
- 28:31Maybe it's not, you know.
- 28:32But like I said, things aren't sort of not fixed.
- 28:35I was saying, you know, maybe you could afford a baby.
- 28:37Maybe you could learn to care a baby.
- 28:38Biggest fear people have is what if I don't want the pregnancy?
- 28:41Will I be able to love this baby?
- 28:44Wow.
- 28:44Right?
- 28:44That's the big fear.
- 28:46And the answer, what we find, is that when we love our moms and love them unconditionally,
- 28:52however they're feeling, whatever they want, something gets unlocked inside of them.
- 28:57and they find within them what they need to love their baby and they adore their baby.
- 29:02It's most common.
- 29:04If you have multiple children, it's my favorite child.
- 29:07When the women get their support, when they've been able to say out loud,
- 29:10I don't want this pregnancy as many times as they need to say it.
- 29:14There's no short-cutting the process of first telling the truth and processing it.
- 29:18But at the end, I've seen, because this is not my first rodeo, as they say.
- 29:25at the end, this is your favorite child.
- 29:28Maybe because of how hard it was to bring them in,
- 29:31we value things that are hard after the fact.
- 29:34Yeah.
- 29:35And I think having somebody there who's
- 29:38there to validate and not be judgmental because there's so much shame and so much grief and so
- 29:44much pain and to say out loud, I don't want this baby, I think is actually harder than continuing
- 29:53with the pregnancy or letting go of a pregnancy because that first step of admitting that
- 30:02I'm conflicted, I'm confused is so daunting because whatever choice you make is going
- 30:12to impact the rest of your life.
- 30:15And that's really scary.
- 30:17Yeah.
- 30:18We have people call us who just have tremendous grief about choices they've made.
- 30:22and you know I don't wish that on anyone nor do I judge them either this is because it's not about
- 30:31you just cannot judge when you're not in someone else's shoes that's not our place
- 30:35place is to love people through the crisis and and to really love them
- 30:42as someone who's walked alongside of these women what has it taught you about resilience
- 30:54I think
- 30:58I think there's
- 30:59no shortcuts
- 31:02it's a day to day thing
- 31:06but it's interesting
- 31:08we have a lifetime parenting
- 31:16course and it's called
- 31:18Nurtured Heart.
- 31:19It's its own thing
- 31:20but we give it for free to our moms
- 31:22for their whole lives if they want.
- 31:27You're continuing
- 31:28this pregnancy.
- 31:29It's not a one year
- 31:30commitment.
- 31:30This is a lifetime commitment so we have this lifetime
- 31:32parenting community
- 31:34to support our moms through
- 31:36with the little things like what do I do about
- 31:38sleep training and the big things.
- 31:40Whatever it is, I'm struggling with my child who's
- 31:42five at school that I had six years
- 31:44ago.
- 31:45Um, or I guess you had five years ago.
- 31:48Uh, but resilience, I think starts with seeing the good,
- 31:55you know, seeing the good and seeing the good in yourself and seeing the good.
- 31:58So that's what we try to reflect back is this tremendous strength of the women who call us.
- 32:04I mean, we have such respect for the women who have the courage to call us whatever happens.
- 32:09Like we see their strengths and we see their, their goodness.
- 32:12And even the people who are
- 32:13most of the time when someone's considering not continuing a pregnancy, it's because they want
- 32:17to be a good mother and they don't know how they could possibly be a good mother in this
- 32:21circumstance.
- 32:22And that in itself is amazing.
- 32:23They want to be a good mother.
- 32:25And we see that,
- 32:26we see that like they, you know, all the, when people are overwhelmed, it's because they care
- 32:32so much about life.
- 32:33They care so much about helping others and doing good and all the things.
- 32:38And so can you – the resilience comes from seeing that goodness and not needing it to be perfect, not needing it to be perfect to be great.
- 32:49within the Jewish community because we highlight on this podcast different types of Judaism.
- 32:56And some are more open to the idea that people have sex pre-marriage or they are living with
- 33:06a significant other or they're in a relationship.
- 33:09They've had 10 kids and they're married and they
- 33:12don't want the pregnancy, what can our communities all throughout the spectrum here do in order to
- 33:19support women who are feeling alone and stressed and kind of like they have nowhere to turn?
- 33:28I mean, I think the first thing is that it's important to slow down the process
- 33:33from the moment someone finds out that they're pregnant.
- 33:36If someone is making some sort of
- 33:39decision or thinking of making some sort of decision, slow down that process because you are
- 33:44in a panic mode and people do not make their best decisions when they're in panic.
- 33:48So it's just important first to like, to like give people space to, to, to say whatever they
- 33:53need to say.
- 33:54And it makes sense.
- 33:56Number one.
- 33:57And two, let's slow down the process and think
- 34:00really don't make a decision in a week.
- 34:02Don't make a decision in a day, like slow that process down
- 34:05and call Shifra, you know, have conversations to understand what is there for you.
- 34:10Because also the panic is often not what it seems.
- 34:16You know what I mean?
- 34:18Is it really about that there's no timing or is it about how much of a failure I feel like with this child?
- 34:23You know, is it really about this?
- 34:26You haven't seen this baby's face yet.
- 34:27You probably would love it if you saw it.
- 34:30But what you're seeing is maybe failures in other areas.
- 34:34And you don't even want to admit how much of a failure you feel like in this area.
- 34:37And so when this pops up, you're like, I just got to get rid of it.
- 34:41And do you think there's still a stigma when asking for support within our community?
- 34:48Of course.
- 34:49Of course.
- 34:50Yeah, it's hard to say that.
- 34:52And it's hard to say that I don't know what to do.
- 34:55It's hard to say I'm scared.
- 34:57It's hard to say I'm in the dark.
- 34:59Everybody's supposed to have it together.
- 35:01you know what is true communal responsibility look like in these moments
- 35:07i mean i think people need to be able to go to their rabbis and share i think i mean one thing
- 35:16we didn't touch on but there's a lot of dynamics that happen within married couples around this
- 35:21and i think it's really important um i mean we've had a lot of women call us telling us that their
- 35:26husbands are pressuring them to end their pregnancies a lot.
- 35:30And so women need to be,
- 35:34you know, they need to be able to talk to their rabbi.
- 35:37Rabbis need to share that this is a
- 35:39possibility.
- 35:39This could happen just like infertility is a possibility.
- 35:42It could happen.
- 35:42And it's okay
- 35:43to come to me with this problem.
- 35:46Um, and in that there's support for the family, there's support
- 35:52for the woman and there's also support for the you know the woman provides support for the man
- 35:57yeah we have a father's coach and a couple's like a couple's coach yeah so this is like the
- 36:03full gamut here you're really taking care of the family as a whole and looking at the unit
- 36:09holistically and going okay there's a lot of things at play right in this situation yeah right you're
- 36:16not just looking at it in a vacuum and going okay the mom doesn't want it so that's what's happening
- 36:20or the dad doesn't want it so that's what's happening or they can both not understand how
- 36:26they're feeling in that moment and i think there's a lot of uncertainty in life and especially
- 36:33when you are finding out you're pregnant there's this like being pregnant any situation it's very
- 36:40vulnerable so vulnerable you're so vulnerable i mean my last also so i mean it's been hard i thank
- 36:46God, I have four children, but it's not easy for me to get pregnant.
- 36:50I always want to.
- 36:5146,
- 36:52I still want to get pregnant again.
- 36:55And yet when you are, you're like, I'm not in charge here.
- 36:59I am so vulnerable.
- 37:01It is a vulnerable thing.
- 37:02What was the question?
- 37:06The question was like,
- 37:08how do we remove shame?
- 37:09How do we be there for every facet of this?
- 37:13Right.
- 37:13So there needs to be – there just – all the – our thing has been because our approach has been what do you need?
- 37:20Then everything has been developed to kind of deal with everything because as much as – I mean everybody's story is unique.
- 37:28The components, the layers that people need, the relationship layer, the financial layer, the emotional layer, the communal other mom support layer.
- 37:36Or, you know, we have to develop it.
- 37:39But it needs to be mainstream so that it's in every synagogue, just the way there's infertility stuff.
- 37:45It needs to be just out there.
- 37:47Like this is a possibility.
- 37:49And I think as a therapist and coach, I think it's extremely important to discuss because there's so much shame and so much isolation when we're talking about pregnancy.
- 38:01Because now that there's been this light on trying to conceive and infertility, okay, it's a lot easier.
- 38:11I wouldn't say it's easy by any means, but it's easier to ask for help.
- 38:15Right.
- 38:15Whereas something like this, people are dying to get pregnant.
- 38:21People feel so much shame like I got pregnant, but now I don't know what to do next.
- 38:27And I've seen that within my own practice and surrounding my friends and family.
- 38:32And I think that one of the things that you really did touch upon is we need to talk about the fact that it's really scary to be pregnant sometimes.
- 38:42Yeah.
- 38:42And it's totally normal to have these feelings and to reach out to people, have conversations.
- 38:49There is no shame in not being happy all the time.
- 38:54A hundred percent.
- 38:56And I think that that's part of the problem is that like within our community, having kids is part of the Masorah, part of generations.
- 39:06She's beautiful.
- 39:07And it's amazing and it's really what our foundation is built on.
- 39:11Like Avram – they said Avram is going to have as many children as the sand in the sea and the stars in the sky.
- 39:17And we can appreciate that while also still going, yeah, I don't want as many kids as the stars in the sky.
- 39:23Thank you so much.
- 39:25like it's okay to say i don't know what comes next and finding somebody who's going to validate
- 39:33you as a person and know that it's okay to have questions that doesn't mean you have the answers
- 39:40right but it's okay to have the questions it's okay not to be okay sometimes a hundred percent
- 39:46i think that yeah that was a phrase i got it covered i was like it's okay not to be okay
- 39:51So that gives you a place to stand on.
- 39:53What, since you've been doing this for 17 years, what are some language that family members or community members can use if somebody does come to them and say, you know, I'm pregnant.
- 40:07Surprise, I'm pregnant.
- 40:10But I'm so scared.
- 40:12And I feel lonely.
- 40:19I mean it just if you know that person and they've shared why this is I think the first
- 40:24thing to say is it makes sense yeah it makes sense it makes sense why you're scared it makes
- 40:31sense why this is lonely for you it makes sense yeah I think that one of the reasons why it's so
- 40:42scary to come to a place like Shifra or to a rabbi or to anybody at first is because we do,
- 40:51pregnancy is technically hidden, right?
- 40:53Okay.
- 40:54It's internal.
- 40:55And especially for the first three
- 40:57months, we have this idea.
- 40:58You can't tell anybody.
- 40:59You can't tell anybody because there's a risk of
- 41:01losing the other.
- 41:01You can't tell anybody because you don't want to jinx anything.
- 41:03You can't tell
- 41:04anybody because you might hurt somebody's feelings.
- 41:05You can't tell anybody and so on and so forth.
- 41:08Right.
- 41:09But here's the thing.
- 41:11It's okay if that's your choice and you want to not tell anybody, but it's also your choice if you want support, that there is no stigma in wanting to say, I want to share this joy with somebody or I want to share this fear with somebody.
- 41:28and let's say it's not comfortable going to a rabbi or a family member you should know that
- 41:34there are people therapists friends family members and organizations like shifra that are there to
- 41:44connect yeah and there to support you and validate you no matter what the feeling is you can call
- 41:50shifra and say you know i'm pregnant i'm so excited about it but i'm also nervous about x y and z
- 41:57right there's if you're in a well it's it's hard because it's really more for crisis we're for
- 42:03crisis but and inside of it there is it's normal also for there to be both feelings at the same
- 42:09time people can be you know a lot of our clients they feel both feelings at the same time you're
- 42:15going to feel more than one feeling and but if there's a there's a genuine crisis for us
- 42:20the crisis like you should call us you know if it's if you don't know and it doesn't most people
- 42:25calling aren't actually on the, some people are on the edge of making a decision about whether or
- 42:30not to continue the pregnancy.
- 42:31And some people aren't, they know there are, they, they're not,
- 42:34they know they're continuing the pregnancy, but they have no idea how.
- 42:37And they're also very
- 42:38welcome to call.
- 42:39I mean, that's, you don't, I don't want, the goal is to have a community where
- 42:44you don't get to the state of despair.
- 42:47That's a couple steps of being alone by yourself and
- 42:49panicked.
- 42:50You're, you know, a little scared.
- 42:52It's okay to call and reach out.
- 42:55I'd rather hear from
- 42:55you now than like let you dwell in fear for three weeks, three weeks, three months, nine months.
- 43:01Right.
- 43:02I mean, I think the, you know, the consistent experience is that when people
- 43:05are willing to say it, then they can process it, you know, and when you can't admit, you can't
- 43:11release.
- 43:15I think there's a lot of shame within the community in general and, and for women as
- 43:22a whole because biologically we're supposed to be nurturers.
- 43:26Biologically we're supposed to want
- 43:29pregnancy and babies and have all this love to give.
- 43:34And I think one of the messages that
- 43:37I've gotten from you is that if you don't have enough love to give, you will step in and give
- 43:44the mother that love.
- 43:46Yeah, that's it.
- 43:48I mean, when you love, I mean, just, you know, I had,
- 43:54I had this, um, I mean, this is sort of, this is an example where, uh, this is sort of an extreme
- 44:01example, but there was a woman who called us, um, she grew up in foster care.
- 44:07Okay.
- 44:08And she's,
- 44:09she's not a she's not young she's in her late 20s i think she found out she was pregnant and
- 44:16the father of the baby was extremely abusive extremely okay she wasn't sure whether she
- 44:22wanted to keep the pregnancy she called us and we didn't hear from her we actually assumed that
- 44:25she'd ended the pregnancy then we find out that she didn't she actually decided to continue the
- 44:30pregnancy.
- 44:32Um, and, um, the father of the baby was so abusive.
- 44:39He punched her in the stomach
- 44:40to try to get her to miscarry when she was in her, uh, in her twenties, twenties weeks.
- 44:44Okay.
- 44:45But here's the thing.
- 44:46She went to the house, she delivered the baby.
- 44:49She went to the hospital
- 44:50every day to nurse that baby.
- 44:52Wow.
- 44:52Okay.
- 44:53She loves that baby.
- 44:54That baby has saved and changed
- 44:57her life.
- 44:57Okay.
- 44:58She is such a caring mother doing everything for that baby, you know?
- 45:03And so she did
- 45:04not start off loving that baby, but she loves that baby now.
- 45:07But what was in between that?
- 45:08Like all the chesed, all the kindness that we could do for her and a lot of other, I mean,
- 45:13there's other organizations too that were helping her be corholing, all sorts of stuff, like just
- 45:17thing after thing, meal after meal, like just one thing at a time.
- 45:21And she wasn't always able to
- 45:23even say thank you.
- 45:24Sometimes she was, sometimes she wasn't.
- 45:25She was in a lot of stress, but it
- 45:27was like all that love somehow, something shifted inside of her and she loves that baby and she's a
- 45:33great mother.
- 45:34But it was, you know, you know, she had to be loved.
- 45:38She had to be cared for.
- 45:39Sometimes people call us and like one of the core issues is they don't have a mother,
- 45:44you know, they don't have a mother to love them.
- 45:45And we gotta be the, you know, we gotta be that
- 45:47mother figure to love them because they didn't get it or they didn't, they don't have it, you know?
- 45:51I mean, there's a lot of generational trauma and a lot of people who don't have healthy relationships with mothers and then they question their own capabilities.
- 46:04So the fact that you guys are providing such a beautiful way to reframe.
- 46:11Now, that doesn't mean that you can change their history, but you can change their future.
- 46:17Yeah.
- 46:18And I think that that's such an amazing, amazing thing that you are providing.
- 46:25I want to do a few rapid fire questions with you.
- 46:27Okay, great.
- 46:30But I think before we do that, I just want to make something very abundantly clear.
- 46:36No one out there is alone.
- 46:39That the beauty of being part of the Jewish community is the emphasis on community.
- 46:45Yeah.
- 46:46That no matter the circumstance – and I think that this is – it's meaningful to me because as somebody who comes from a very normal home, thank God, but still was put in very traumatic situations and I felt so alone in those moments.
- 47:14and I think that I didn't know that there was anywhere to turn,
- 47:20which is one of the reasons why I'm a therapist now
- 47:22is because I wanted to make sure that people knew
- 47:24that there's always somewhere for you to turn.
- 47:28And the fact that there are people like you, Erica,
- 47:31who are creating organizations to help people know
- 47:35that there will always be a community.
- 47:39There will always be someone there to hold your hand no matter the circumstance.
- 47:46And I think one of the most important parts of all of this is to note that we've all been through things and we can all use our history and our perseverance to help somebody else.
- 48:07so if you're listening or watching this out there take an example from erica take an example from a
- 48:14friend you know or maybe this podcast and try to help somebody else because you don't know what a
- 48:21hello will do you don't know what a little bit of tzedakah will do or a little bit of kindness so
- 48:27i think it's really important that just like you 17 years ago saw a need and it started slow
- 48:37but you're here and that's resilience yeah you know what is one thing every jewish woman should
- 48:47know that you're precious beyond measure i agree true one myth you'd love to permanently erase
- 49:02an unwanted pregnancy means an unloved child.
- 49:06I think that that is so true
- 49:08because you cannot want something
- 49:11and not know that it's the best thing for you.
- 49:14The pregnancy is separate from the child.
- 49:17People can hate being pregnant.
- 49:18Forget wanted.
- 49:19Some people hate being pregnant.
- 49:20Yes.
- 49:21So an unwanted pregnancy has nothing to do.
- 49:23It does not mean an unloved child.
- 49:24You can absolutely love the child.
- 49:26The most meaningful moment you experienced through Shifra?
- 49:33I got a note like in the last two weeks from a woman in Florida.
- 49:39I had actually – she's a client of ours.
- 49:43She had attended a talk while pregnant.
- 49:47And while I was speaking about Shifra, the baby was kicking.
- 49:53Wow.
- 49:53And she wrote me this note just about how it's not just that we helped her through this very difficult circumstance.
- 50:01She married the father of the baby and it was going beautifully.
- 50:05We did a lot of couples counseling.
- 50:07But also it's like that kind of love is connected to Hashem also.
- 50:13That we can model the love that Hashem has for us in our relationships is pretty.
- 50:19Yeah, it's outstanding.
- 50:22One thing every rabbi or community leader should hear.
- 50:28This is happening and you need to make sure it's okay for people to ask for help.
- 50:34Yeah, I think that I have so much respect for the Rebbeim, but I think there's a lot of fear there also of making the wrong move and that there could be community backlash.
- 50:48And I think that one of the detriments is this fear of being judged.
- 50:59And it's so crazy because as Jews, we're not supposed to judge.
- 51:04And yet there's so much stigma around a lot of topics, not only this one.
- 51:12One thing every husband should hear.
- 51:17it's not a theoretical baby if she's already pregnant
- 51:21that's not for every husband that's for the husbands that are like well you should just
- 51:26get rid of it it's like it's not theoretical when it's in her body it's i mean they can be like that
- 51:32you know um it's not a theoretical pregnancy if she's already pregnant let's put it that way
- 51:36i also think they need to know that it's not only the woman's responsibility
- 51:42oh yeah that it took two to tango so it takes two to navigate a situation right yeah and and
- 51:52yeah absolutely one message to the women listening who feel completely alone right now
- 52:09clouds can cover up the sun but can't make it disappear and you can have a lot of darkness
- 52:16around you but your light is still there and it's okay to ask for help
- 52:24if someone listening today is in this situation or knows someone who is and they are
- 52:29scared to ask for help, what would you want them to hear directly from you?
- 52:43That we're here to unconditionally love and respect you in your journey.
- 52:53And we're a safe place to call.
- 52:57um i think that's i would want women to know that actually i'm going to think back to my 16
- 53:07year old self 14 year old self when i was in a scary situation and go i was alone because i
- 53:15chose to be alone because i was scared there was no one there if i knew then what i know now
- 53:26I think I would tell myself
- 53:31being alone is a choice
- 53:34suffering in silence is a choice
- 53:38and you don't have to make that choice
- 53:42and I think that that
- 53:46is one of the main takeaways I would want people to have
- 53:50is that you don't have to suffer in silence.
- 53:54And the more we talk about things
- 53:57and the more help organizations like Shiffer get,
- 54:01the better we are making the community as a whole
- 54:07because people could feel safe
- 54:10and make choices from a place of love and not fear.
- 54:15Yes.
- 54:17So thank you so much, Erica, for coming.
- 54:19I am so grateful.
- 54:20And if they want to reach Shifra?
- 54:22We will put all the information in the bio of this podcast, and we will have a link attached as well if you need any resources or need to reach Erica or Shifra as a whole.
- 54:33Awesome.
- 54:34Thank you so much.
- 54:34Thank you so much.