Latest / Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer Podcasts / On Just Terms S2 E9: Empirical insights and the case for reform with Professor Dr Vince Morabito, Monash University
Transcript
- 0:09SPEAKER_00: Thank you for joining us on On Just Terms.
- 0:12SPEAKER_00: Today we are joined by Professor Vince Moribito, one of Australia's leading empirical researchers on class actions.
- 0:19SPEAKER_00: In this episode, Professor Moribito shares insights from his data, sheds light on what it reveals about the Australian class action system, and he talks us through where he sees some areas for reform.
- 0:32SPEAKER_01: Professor Moribito, Vince, thank you so much for joining our podcast on just terms.
- 0:37SPEAKER_01: We're really grateful for you giving up your time like this.
- 0:40SPEAKER_02: Thank you for inviting me.
- 0:41SPEAKER_02: It's a pleasure to be involved in this exciting series.
- 0:44SPEAKER_01: Excellent.
- 0:44SPEAKER_01: Well, we liken this series to talk about areas of complex litigation and disputes and how the risk profile in Australia is evolving.
- 0:52SPEAKER_01: And of course, among your many career achievements, I think it's uncontroversial to say that no one has studied and certainly studied empirically the class action environment in Australia as much as you have in your detailed and learned uh scholarly contributions and other things that you've produced.
- 1:08SPEAKER_01: So we we wanted to start with some context and step back a little bit and based on your deep experience and study in this place, talk a little bit about some misconceptions that you might have identified as to how the general public and indeed the more sophisticated business community, the misapprehensions they might have about how the class action system is working in practice.
- 1:29SPEAKER_02: As far as start with the general public and the class or group members, in 2010, I think two years after I commenced my empirical work, one of the things that members of my team, uh so-called research assistants, it was basically final year law students who wanted to have three meals a day and were therefore willing to do anything to get extra money.
- 1:54SPEAKER_02: That I made them make copies or go through all the opt-out notices, all your opt-out forms that were filed by class members.
- 2:03SPEAKER_02: And I specifically asked, look for whether they actually wrote any comments, because I thought the ideal way would be to actually speak to each class member directly and said, Did you actually understand the content of the opt-out notice?
- 2:19SPEAKER_02: But of course, that would have been just not feasible.
- 2:21SPEAKER_02: I mean, I was lucky enough to receive$250,000 from the Australian Research Council to start.
- 2:27SPEAKER_02: I started looking at Victorian Class Action, actually, thanks to your firm at the beginning, which was the major sponsor.
- 2:34SPEAKER_02: Uh, and the beginning was just looking at Victorian class action.
- 2:37SPEAKER_02: Then when the Australian Research Council were nice enough to give me the large grant, uh, then it expanded to looking at federal class action.
- 2:44SPEAKER_02: In those days, it was just federal Victoria Class Action.
- 2:46SPEAKER_02: So anyway, the uh the research system made a note of all the comments that were made by class members on their opt-out notice.
- 2:53SPEAKER_02: So there was kind of a proxy of I can't interview you, but let me see who made comments.
- 2:59SPEAKER_02: And most of the comments just showed a great level of confusion on the part of class members.
- 3:05SPEAKER_02: The first one was basically I do not appreciate these lawyers that I've never dealt with commencing a legal proceeding on my behalf.
- 3:18SPEAKER_02: So the explanation of what an opt-out device entails, which of course is that you don't need to ask permission to include claimants as long as their circumstances fall within the description provided in the pleadings.
- 3:34SPEAKER_02: And they were quite resentful towards us.
- 3:37SPEAKER_02: So that was their act of rebellion or protest.
- 3:41SPEAKER_02: But the the worst one was not only did they take action on my behalf without my permission, and now I'm going to be liable for the cost.
- 3:49SPEAKER_02: So that was the other misconception by many classes.
- 3:53SPEAKER_02: I don't know whether in 2026 that there would be that level of confusion about the opt-up regime and I don't want to be liable for the millions of dollars that may be payable to cover the cost of defendants.
- 4:07SPEAKER_02: As far as misconceptions about practitioners, what I call the new kids on the block, but new kids on the block, I mean firms that are moving to class action because they're attracted by the media telling them, hey, if you're a plaintiff law firm, this is where you can make a fortune, is that they go into, and I mean that is certainly true.
- 4:30SPEAKER_02: That the major plaintiff law firms are certainly not struggling financially.
- 4:35SPEAKER_02: But what they don't realize is that making those profits needs resources, kind of an infrastructure within the firm that you can't just jump in and take on major powerful entities that have acting for them the biggest and the best law firms in Australia.
- 4:55SPEAKER_02: And I find that that is something that keeps happening.
- 4:59SPEAKER_02: That you take on the big companies, the big multinationals that have the best lawyers in town.
- 5:05SPEAKER_02: And then after six or 12 months, they realize, oh, and we'll have to discontinue or drop out of it.
- 5:10SPEAKER_02: So that's what a misconception that they they see only the profit side of it and they don't realize that some of the best plate class action plaintiff law firms, that was built on several years of victories, but also lessons learned from defeats.
- 5:28SPEAKER_02: And as far as judges are concerned, if I may respectfully say that I guess for Australia, when I see judgments say, or judges speaking uh publicly and keep saying the vast majority of class actions in Australia settle.
- 5:45SPEAKER_02: And the reality is that every few years I do publish the what I found to be the settlement rate.
- 5:52SPEAKER_02: I don't recall the settlement rate in Australia being ever more than 63, 64.
- 6:00SPEAKER_02: And in my latest article looking at just the Victorian class action, it was only in in the 50s.
- 6:06SPEAKER_02: So that's something that I find a misconception that even judges say, oh, well, you know, in the fact of making decisions which are largely influenced in the past, of judges saying, well, there's little risk of losing funders because most class actions settle, most a vast majority of class shareholder class actions settle.
- 6:27SPEAKER_02: And the reality is that my research has never shown that.
- 6:30SPEAKER_02: The only thing I remember was that in the early days, the settlement rate of class actions funded by commercial litigation funders were 100%.
- 6:39SPEAKER_02: But that was only in the first few years where they only funded shareholder class actions, and defendants would invariably settle a shareholder class action.
- 6:49SPEAKER_02: So those are sort of what I think, my understanding of what are the misconceptions among class members, practitioners, and judges.
- 6:56SPEAKER_01: It's very helpful.
- 6:58SPEAKER_01: Mel, what are your thoughts?
- 6:59SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I thought before turning to some of your more recent writings, particularly on the GCO topic, I wanted to get your thoughts on what do you think has been behind or what have been the drivers behind the real acceleration over the past decade of class action filings?
- 7:18SPEAKER_00: You know, there's been a lot of talk about, you know, one per week, and that rough trend has really been what we've been looking at at least for the last several years.
- 7:27SPEAKER_00: So, other than thinking about the main drivers, but then also, do you think that this current one-a-week trend is here to stay, or are we part of a cycle?
- 7:37SPEAKER_02: It depends whether they're going to be any legislative initiatives at the federal and state level.
- 7:44SPEAKER_02: And legislative initiatives and how that affects their profitability.
- 7:49SPEAKER_02: Look, at the end of the day, plus actions are popular because they provide significant revenue, if not profits, for plaintiff law firms.
- 8:02SPEAKER_02: And I suspect it might be the same for if I can use the terminology, defendant law firms, they defend uh powerful entities that are on the receiving end.
- 8:12SPEAKER_02: And the Australian political scene has clearly revealed, just looking at the last 10 years, that if the government is the coalition, conservative coalition, now perhaps joined by one nation, if they're in government, like the Morrison government, they will be very keen to restrict or place restrictions on the ability of class action to function.
- 8:36SPEAKER_02: I mean, they it was the the Morrison government said that it was done in the name of protecting the interests of class members, but the effect of those changes, if they had been able to be implemented fully, would have been most likely to restrict the filings of class action.
- 8:55SPEAKER_02: At least that's what the funders in the plaintiff side argued.
- 8:59SPEAKER_02: If labor is in government, the current government has shown they removed the regulation requirements which had been imposed by the Morrison government on commercial litigation funders.
- 9:13SPEAKER_02: But beyond that, the well, obviously the labor seems to be have a more favorable view of class action as being more tools to enhance access to justice, whilst the Morrison government in the Classity Coalition looks normally looks at in the business community, looks at class actions more like an opportunity for lawyers to make money funders more than the access to justice.
- 9:42SPEAKER_02: Or at least to say that that is the way the Australian system has worked.
- 9:46SPEAKER_02: So the short answer is depends what legislative changes are made and whether those legislative changes made will decrease or increase the profitability of class actions.
- 9:58SPEAKER_02: But so far, we haven't really, since the Morrison government lost the election, the biggest change has been the Victorian government introducing contingency fees only in Victorian class actions, which are called group cost orders.
- 10:14SPEAKER_02: So really, at the end of the day, it depends whether it remains profitable.
- 10:18SPEAKER_02: And then that will really depend on what regulation or what requirements state governments and the federal government will implement in the near future.
- 10:29SPEAKER_01: A good segue, I think, Lynn, to talking about group costs orders.
- 10:34SPEAKER_01: Vince, you you've written extensively about it.
- 10:37SPEAKER_01: A lot of ink's been spilt within the profession and within corporate Australia, I think there's been a lot of thinking about their implications.
- 10:44SPEAKER_01: What I found a very interesting topic is to talk briefly about what the policy imperatives were behind the introduction of group costs orders and also whether, in your view, based on your studies and otherwise, you think that broadly speaking, those policies are being met in the new regime in Victoria.
- 11:03SPEAKER_02: I guess we should go back to the origins of.
- 11:06SPEAKER_02: So in Australia, the Australia's Productivity Commission recommended contingency fee in its 2014 report on access to justice.
- 11:16SPEAKER_02: The Australian Law Reform Commission recommended contingency fees subject to a number of safeguards and restrictions with respect to federal class actions.
- 11:25SPEAKER_02: That proposal has not been implemented by either the Lawrison government or the current Albanese government.
- 11:32SPEAKER_02: In 2018, the Victorian Law Reform Commission also recommended the introduction of contingency fees for Victorian class actions, which were implemented by a Labour government.
- 11:44SPEAKER_02: And Labour is still in the government in Victorian, though there will be a Victorian election in November 2020.
- 11:52SPEAKER_02: Now, the Victorian Law Reform Commission essentially accepted the arguments of the plaintiff side of litigation by saying the average number of Victorian class actions in 2018 was five, so five per year.
- 12:06SPEAKER_02: And the Victorian Law Reform Commission said, look, it's worked well, Victorian class action regime, but five annual class actions is just not enough to fully secure the access to justice rationale.
- 12:18SPEAKER_02: And they said, we accept the arguments put forward the major plaintiff law firms that having contingency fears subject to close judicial control, close judicial scrutiny should increase the number of class actions.
- 12:35SPEAKER_02: But also what they appear to be interested in, and that was also clear from looking at the documents circulated or released by the government that actually introduced group cost orders in 2020 was reading from the second reading speech from that the attorney general responsible for GCO.
- 12:57SPEAKER_02: She said this will increase class actions for silicosis, wage theft, and corporate wrongdoing.
- 13:05SPEAKER_02: The attorney general also issued a media release saying that with the group cost orders, it will help vulnerable groups such as workers and consumers.
- 13:17SPEAKER_02: So that is the setting for sort of evaluating whether those excess of justice has been enhanced, whether the objectives of the GCOs have been enhanced.
- 13:28SPEAKER_02: Looking at the number of class actions, yeah, they've definitely increased and they've overtaken New South Wales as far as Victorian being the second most vibrant class action jurisdiction in Australia.
- 13:43SPEAKER_02: As far as the substantive claims, there've been no class actions for workers.
- 13:50SPEAKER_02: Well, there's been one since GCO, there's been one Victorian class action on behalf of workers, but it was a superannuation dispute.
- 14:00SPEAKER_02: So not exactly what you call wasn't wage theft, and it wasn't what the attorney general had in mind.
- 14:07SPEAKER_02: So that was the only one for workers.
- 14:09SPEAKER_02: Consumers, there have been 21 Victorian consumer class actions filed after GCO.
- 14:14SPEAKER_02: So definitely consumers.
- 14:16SPEAKER_02: So if we look at what the Attorney General said, she was hoping to achieve as far as substantive claims, that that goal has not been fully achieved because shareholder class actions have been the most popular form of Victorian class action since GCO.
- 14:33SPEAKER_02: And even a first-year law student will be able to tell you that if there's one category of class actions where Australia has not been left behind, are shareholder class actions.
- 14:45SPEAKER_02: And from the data that I've collected, there appears to be so shareholder class actions were definitely not what the Victorian government had in mind.
- 14:52SPEAKER_02: They were saying we want to see more class actions helping vulnerable people.
- 14:56SPEAKER_02: And they were convinced that having GCOs will allow plaintiff lawyers to bring those class actions which were not suitable to the business models, commercial litigation funders, or the solicitors to no-win, no, no fee model.
- 15:15SPEAKER_02: So we've definitely increased the number of joint classes, perhaps even beyond what the tour reform commission could possibly imagine, but this is just my speculation.
- 15:25SPEAKER_02: We haven't really fulfilled the expectation of oh, we'll have lots more class actions in favor of vulnerable workers.
- 15:36SPEAKER_02: Instead, we've seen a movement of shareholder class actions from the Supreme Court of New South Wales to the Supreme Court of Victoria.
- 15:46SPEAKER_02: Critics of the GCO would call that foreign shopping.
- 15:50SPEAKER_02: I think that would be the terminology used.
- 15:52SPEAKER_02: And Justice Nichols, at a cross-action seminar organized by Shine Lawyers in August in Sydney, revealed that when the Victorian Attorney General sought the advice of the Supreme Court as to whether they favored or they were opposed to the GCO reform, should reveal that the response was, well, as long as it's applied across Australia.
- 16:14SPEAKER_02: And also that advice wasn't followed by the Victorian government.
- 16:18SPEAKER_02: So the fear of so-called foreign shopping, there appears to be evidence of that because there's been a 53.8% decrease in the filing of New South Wales class actions.
- 16:30SPEAKER_02: If you compare the first five years of the GCO period with the five years preceding the GCO introduction in 1st of July 2020, and there's been a 222% increase in the volume of Utarian class action.
- 16:44SPEAKER_02: So, yes, we've increased the volume.
- 16:46SPEAKER_02: As far as the types of claims, not quite a lot.
- 16:52SPEAKER_02: We've missed the mark as far as what were the intentions.
- 16:55SPEAKER_02: But as a barrister, plaintiff barrister said to me, who cares whether we've complied with the wishes of the Dean Attorney General?
- 17:03SPEAKER_02: To me, that's a little bit satisfactory because when we look at whether a system works, we try and compare what was the intention and increase in the number of shares, making share of the class section the most popular category of class sections in Vitoria.
- 17:18SPEAKER_02: That was definitely not the intention of the attorney attorney general because the federal court and the Supreme Court was would do already a great job of handling a significant number of shareholders.
- 17:32SPEAKER_02: And the federal court still handles a significant number of shareholder cross sections.
- 17:38SPEAKER_00: Well, before we move from Victoria and maybe think about GCOs elsewhere and what might be in the future, I wanted to talk to you a little bit about some really interesting material coming out of your latest research, which is around the GCO rates.
- 17:54SPEAKER_00: And so you've shown that there's there's been a gradual increase in the median rate.
- 18:00SPEAKER_00: And so I suppose I've got a couple of questions for you on that, Vince, which is what do you think is leading to the rise?
- 18:07SPEAKER_00: Is there a problem with it?
- 18:09SPEAKER_00: And at least to date, you mentioned judicial scrutiny of the of the GCO rates.
- 18:14SPEAKER_00: Although that is true, what we haven't seen is really much judicial intervention into adjusting those rates on settlement.
- 18:23SPEAKER_00: So what do we think is leading to the rise?
- 18:26SPEAKER_00: And do you think that the rise is problematic?
- 18:30SPEAKER_02: If I can start with your last question, I do think, and let me set the scene.
- 18:36SPEAKER_02: So the overall median commencement GCO rate, commencement meaning the rates that are approved by the court at the initial stages of the litigation, as opposed to settlement GCO rates, which is at the time the settlement is judicial approved.
- 18:55SPEAKER_02: So the overall rate is 25%.
- 18:57SPEAKER_02: That's across the last four years.
- 18:59SPEAKER_02: But if you look at the annual rate, so with respect to the GCO orders issued in 2022, the median was 24.5.
- 19:08SPEAKER_02: 2023, the median rate for the commencement GCOs awarded in 2023 remained at 24.5.
- 19:17SPEAKER_02: 2024, there was suddenly a change right from the beginning of 2024.
- 19:23SPEAKER_02: 25% was the initial where things started from, and you had to justify why you were seeking more than 25.
- 19:32SPEAKER_02: But 2024, the approach of plaintiff lawyers changed dramatically.
- 19:38SPEAKER_02: Now they were sort of saying, forget about 2022, 2023.
- 19:44SPEAKER_02: That was a different world.
- 19:45SPEAKER_02: Things have changed, things are more expensive, things are a lot more risky.
- 19:50SPEAKER_02: 2024, it jumped to 28.75 percent.
- 19:54SPEAKER_02: 2025, the median rate for the GCOs issued in 2025 jumped to 30 percent.
- 20:02SPEAKER_02: Let me now deal with the other crucial part of your question.
- 20:07SPEAKER_02: Has there been judicial intervention?
- 20:09SPEAKER_02: Yes, the reason why I made the positive comment about GT's little scrutiny is that had Victorian judges accepted the GCO rates requested by plaintiff solicitors in 2024 and 2025, both in 2024 and 2025, the median commencement GCO rate would have been around 33 percent in each of 2024 and each of 2025.
- 20:39SPEAKER_02: So they haven't quite made the big headlines, but they have been a number of instances where both in 2022 and 23, or more importantly in 2024 and 2025, where judges have said, I'll give you the GCO, but not what you're asking for.
- 20:58SPEAKER_02: So there have been clear instances.
- 21:00SPEAKER_02: So it wasn't me just being nice, hope to Supreme Court judges, they have intervened.
- 21:05SPEAKER_02: Will this be enough?
- 21:07SPEAKER_02: There was a hearing on Friday where I think it's the Harvey Norman consolidated class action.
- 21:13SPEAKER_02: I didn't see the live streaming, but I rely on the uh reporters from Loyale who are very excellent.
- 21:21SPEAKER_02: They're they're like my Bible of class action.
- 21:24SPEAKER_02: And they've said in that report that the counsel for the class member said to the court, Justice Harris, which left me, I I was sort of shocked.
- 21:35SPEAKER_02: And I thought, I actually gotta be honest, I contacted the loyally journalists.
- 21:40SPEAKER_02: I said, Can I double check this with you?
- 21:42SPEAKER_02: They they he said forget 2022, 2023, 2024, the world has changed.
- 21:52SPEAKER_02: Look only at the median rate for 2025.
- 21:55SPEAKER_02: And guess what?
- 21:56SPEAKER_02: The median rate for 2025 is 30 percent.
- 21:58SPEAKER_02: What were they asking for?
- 22:00SPEAKER_02: 30%.
- 22:02SPEAKER_02: I'm very careful what I say because I I can't afford to pay defamation lawyers.
- 22:07SPEAKER_02: I can't.
- 22:08SPEAKER_02: Or any any form of top lawyers, because I'm just a mere public server.
- 22:15SPEAKER_02: But I just thought, I'm going to be honest, I did not find that that live argument intellectually convincing.
- 22:22SPEAKER_02: And I started thinking of Ontario.
- 22:25SPEAKER_02: My favorite class-sectional regimes in the world are Canadian.
- 22:28SPEAKER_02: I love them because I think they reach a compromise between the American regime, which is very unpredictable, and the Australian Conservative judges.
- 22:37SPEAKER_02: The Canadians are somewhere in the middle.
- 22:39SPEAKER_02: They've had contingency fees in Ontario, which is their equivalent to our federal court since 1993.
- 22:46SPEAKER_02: I have not, to my knowledge, I've not read any judgments saying the judges have said, oh, well, things are not like in 1993, Your Honor.
- 22:56SPEAKER_02: The world has changed.
- 22:57SPEAKER_02: So my fear, your other question was, am I concerned?
- 23:01SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 23:01SPEAKER_02: If they can put forward argument only in the fourth year or fifth year that we have be asking, so my fear is what's going to happen five years from now?
- 23:12SPEAKER_02: What's going to happen 10 years from now?
- 23:13SPEAKER_02: Are we going to get to 50%, 60%?
- 23:16SPEAKER_02: So it does concern me.
- 23:19SPEAKER_02: And this will require judges, Victorian judges, to be even more on guard.
- 23:25SPEAKER_02: The other problem, of course, is that all the information that the lawyers give when they ask for a GCO is confidential.
- 23:34SPEAKER_02: So and that's something that apparently Justice Harris said on Friday that apparently she spent a lot of time dealing with the confidentiality request.
- 23:42SPEAKER_02: Because apparently she said, well, if I can't see the evidence that was put before other judges in other GCO applications, this is not satisfactory.
- 23:53SPEAKER_02: So I loved that that she raised that issue of class members can't work out because it was in apparently that to close the court.
- 24:01SPEAKER_02: So that's also the second concern that they're increasing.
- 24:05SPEAKER_02: They're saying the world is changing.
- 24:08SPEAKER_02: But if we apply that logic to litigation funders, they've been funding class sections since 2001.
- 24:14SPEAKER_02: If the same logic applied to litigation funders, they started off with 40% funding commissions.
- 24:20SPEAKER_02: Would they be to 80% now if litigation funders were allowed for the federal court to say, Your Honor, 2002, it was a different world.
- 24:29SPEAKER_02: It didn't have inflation.
- 24:30SPEAKER_02: So could you put an extra 10%?
- 24:33SPEAKER_02: So that gives me concern.
- 24:35SPEAKER_02: I have complete confidence in the Supreme Court.
- 24:37SPEAKER_02: But if the Supreme Court does accept this argument, we may need to put a cap on the GCO rate.
- 24:44SPEAKER_02: Something I thought I would never ever say or think privately or publicly, but if every five years we're going to get chunks of five percentage points, like 35% and then 40%, then pull that cap immediately.
- 25:01SPEAKER_02: Now I know the argument against the cap is no wind, no fee, 25%, uplift fee, I should say.
- 25:07SPEAKER_02: Everyone asks for 25%.
- 25:09SPEAKER_02: But if you if you pitch the cap at say 27.5, 28%, I don't mind everyone saying we'll ask for the maximum, as long as we don't get to the point where there's no real difference between what class members get under contentious fee regimes and what they receive under funded class action.
- 25:29SPEAKER_02: That is class action supported by commercial litigation funders.
- 25:33SPEAKER_02: So yeah, I am very concerned.
- 25:35SPEAKER_02: I made that point at that seminary in August 2025.
- 25:39SPEAKER_02: I it wasn't received well, I must confess, but made no difference to what the what they're asking for, what they've been asking for.
- 25:48SPEAKER_02: What brought that on?
- 25:50SPEAKER_02: I think that the argument is the arguments that have been made is that the world has changed, things are more expensive.
- 25:56SPEAKER_02: Last year, one barrister said we were a little bit naive in 2022, 2023.
- 26:02SPEAKER_02: It was a different world.
- 26:03SPEAKER_02: We didn't understand the risks involved.
- 26:06SPEAKER_02: So my view is that, yeah, that may have been correct.
- 26:09SPEAKER_02: And to be fair to them, so there have been 10 settled class actions supported by GCO.
- 26:15SPEAKER_02: In two of them, the settlement approval judgment revealed that the relevant solicitors did not make profit in one.
- 26:23SPEAKER_02: In other words, that they broke even, even with the GCO.
- 26:27SPEAKER_02: And in another one, they made less than what they would have made under a no-win, no-fit regime.
- 26:33SPEAKER_02: So obviously, those circumstances increased the fear.
- 26:36SPEAKER_02: They didn't really know it was a new world in 2020, 2023.
- 26:39SPEAKER_02: And plus, I've got to be honest, again, despite the fact that I kind of thought lawyers turned for me.
- 26:45SPEAKER_02: I think part of it was that there was a natural design of the part of the plaintiff bar to show the community, but importantly, judges say, hey, you can trust us.
- 26:56SPEAKER_02: We're gonna go for the bare minimum.
- 26:59SPEAKER_02: Once the judges saw that and said, I cannot find a single negative comment by judges in judgments or public speeches about the GCO.
- 27:11SPEAKER_02: So they love it.
- 27:13SPEAKER_02: And of and so once they had the confidence support of the judges, I think 2024 was like, hey, we need to make a real profit here.
- 27:22SPEAKER_02: Let's ask what we really need.
- 27:24SPEAKER_02: So it's a to me, it's a combination of all those things.
- 27:28SPEAKER_01: That's a point well made, Vince.
- 27:29SPEAKER_01: The quote that you're referring to from the Loyley article says that attributes this to the barrister.
- 27:34SPEAKER_01: The world is very different from what it was two years ago.
- 27:36SPEAKER_01: Things certainly change, expenses, cost of capital, and the like.
- 27:40SPEAKER_01: What was maybe acceptable a few years ago is maybe not acceptable now.
- 27:44SPEAKER_01: The simple and short point is looking at all the cases over the past year, the rate being sought now, that's the 30%, is equal to the mean and median.
- 27:53SPEAKER_01: So that was the way it was put uh uh according to Loyally.
- 27:56SPEAKER_01: So there's a reference to doing worse off in some of these cases than no win, no fear indeed with a funder.
- 28:01SPEAKER_01: So it's a point well well noted.
- 28:03SPEAKER_01: And it's a nice segue into just one quick follow-up, which is you mentioned a little earlier, the relatively high rate, I think the 100% settlement rate for GCO class actions, accepting that.
- 28:17SPEAKER_01: The history of these sorts of funding arrangements isn't yet significant, but uh do you attribute anything in particular to that early incidence of high rates of settlement, something about the cases being selected or something about the way the cases are funded through the GCO that's more conducive to a settlement?
- 28:35SPEAKER_02: I've been thinking about to explain to you, listeners that so far my research has found that there's a hundred percent settlement rate with respect to those Victorian class actions supported by GCO that have been settled.
- 28:51SPEAKER_02: So, does that show that the lawyers in question have been very clever and been very good at selecting the right type of class actions for that remuneration model where they take on more of the risks?
- 29:05SPEAKER_02: I should point out though that most people think who may not be familiar with the system is that the GCO regime allows funders to be involved and provide support under a GCO model.
- 29:20SPEAKER_02: The Australian Law Reform Commission did not allow that in its recommendations, recommendations for a contingency fee model for the federal court.
- 29:30SPEAKER_02: That's the important note.
- 29:31SPEAKER_02: And I think I found that in 43% of the GCOs granted, there was some involvement by commercial litigation funders.
- 29:42SPEAKER_02: So something that I was looking back last night as I was preparing for this podcast is that at the end of the day, it may be due to the type of firms that have been awarded GCO.
- 29:53SPEAKER_02: There have only been eight.
- 29:54SPEAKER_02: It's the usual suspects.
- 29:56SPEAKER_02: And if you actually look at the 10 GCO class actions that have been settled, what was achieved there actually reflects the work done by the relevant plaintiff solicitors in non-GCO Victoria and a federal class action.
- 30:13SPEAKER_02: Let me more specific.
- 30:14SPEAKER_02: So we've got 10 settled GCO class actions.
- 30:18SPEAKER_02: None of them have been approved.
- 30:20SPEAKER_02: The last one, we're waiting for Justice Nichols' judgment in the EML payments class action.
- 30:28SPEAKER_02: Seven of those settled class actions were run by Morris Blackburn.
- 30:34SPEAKER_02: Morris Blackburn has, on a fairly regular basis, been able to secure gross settlement sums above 50 million and on occasions 100 million.
- 30:45SPEAKER_02: I'm not saying that the other major plaintiff law firms haven't achieved over 50 million or over 100 million, but the number of times where they've done that has been fairly rare compared to Morris Blackburn.
- 30:58SPEAKER_02: Now, and if we look at the seven GCO class sections, GCO supported class actions run by Morris Blackburn, what we'd look at, we look at gross settlement sum is pretty much what they are able to achieve and have achieved in non-GCO class action.
- 31:14SPEAKER_02: So the two of them were over, the gross settlement sum was over$100 million.
- 31:19SPEAKER_02: Four of them, it was between$50 and$100 million.
- 31:23SPEAKER_02: And the seventh one was around$34 million.
- 31:28SPEAKER_02: The other three, run by other major TT law firms, were below$50 million.
- 31:35SPEAKER_02: A couple of them just very close.
- 31:36SPEAKER_02: There's one, I think it's$48 million.
- 31:39SPEAKER_02: So to me, it seems that the 10 settled GCR classe actions are not really that different from other types of settled transactions run by those firms.
- 31:49SPEAKER_02: And if we look at the general characteristics, and I'm running and I'm pointing this out because one of the concerns of contingency fees, critics of contingency fees are concerned that if your payment, solicitor's payment, is dependent on getting a percentage of the total settlement process, is that they will settle earlier than they should and for less.
- 32:12SPEAKER_02: But so far, from what I've seen, we don't have that.
- 32:16SPEAKER_02: So out of the 10 settled class action, so nine were judicial approved.
- 32:20SPEAKER_02: And in one of those nine, the judge, Justice Delaney, decreased the GCO rate from around 24 to 17.3.
- 32:30SPEAKER_02: A major reason for that was that the class action was settled within 18 months.
- 32:36SPEAKER_02: And so therefore the Justice Delaney felt that the time period, he didn't make any adverse comments about, oh, this showed conflict or interest.
- 32:44SPEAKER_02: But he looked there and said, well, the risk that you ran was limited.
- 32:49SPEAKER_02: What you spent was limited.
- 32:51SPEAKER_02: Plus, there was a settlement in the US.
- 32:53SPEAKER_02: So that was the only one where the duration of the settled GCO class section was far less than what we normally expect.
- 33:01SPEAKER_02: But if we look at the other nine, they seem to be taking three, four, five years, or four and a half, which is roughly what you see in non-GCO federal class actions and if that was class actions.
- 33:13SPEAKER_02: So at the moment, even with a very small sample, it appears that what we get at the moment is replicating what happens in the non-contingency, if you will.
- 33:23SPEAKER_02: Will the 100% settlement rate remain?
- 33:26SPEAKER_02: I don't think so.
- 33:26SPEAKER_02: As we as the sample increases, we will not longer have 100%.
- 33:31SPEAKER_02: But at the moment, it doesn't look like there's anything in the 10-settled class action which may give concern to class members or politicians or judges that there is a conflict of interest created by Conteachy Fees.
- 33:45SPEAKER_02: And if there is, that that is causing problems for class members.
- 33:50SPEAKER_02: I mean, what I don't like, if I may be at liberty to say, is that my understanding of the what the Victoria Law Reform Commission intended and the government was that you just have one deduction.
- 34:02SPEAKER_02: And that that deduction should include settlement distribution costs, reimbursement payments to class members, and contradictors, cost experts.
- 34:11SPEAKER_02: But the first settlement, Justice Watson said, oh no, no, that goes on top of the GCO.
- 34:18SPEAKER_02: To me, with all due respect, that was incorrect.
- 34:21SPEAKER_02: But unfortunately, it has been followed by every other judge presiding over settlement approval.
- 34:27SPEAKER_02: And the problem, though, is that a number of opt-out and settlement notices have been sent to class members saying there would only be one deduction, and that is the GCO rate.
- 34:37SPEAKER_02: And then on top of that, and usually it's about three percentage points.
- 34:42SPEAKER_02: So even though the settlement GCO rate is 24.5, the median percentage received by class members in settled GCO is not 75.5%, it is 72.45%.
- 34:55SPEAKER_02: That reflects the settlement distribution costs that have been charged to class members.
- 35:00SPEAKER_00: That's very interesting.
- 35:02SPEAKER_00: That's all been so useful.
- 35:03SPEAKER_00: We would we do want to finish up with something forward-looking.
- 35:06SPEAKER_00: Now, given the empirical nature of your publications, it's necessarily backward looking.
- 35:12SPEAKER_00: But we would like to hear from you around what any predictions you have.
- 35:17SPEAKER_00: I mean, we've we've mentioned legislative reform, but whether it's necessarily a prediction or whether you've got some things on your wish list for reform for the for the class action regime, that might be where we'd like to end our discussion with you today.
- 35:31SPEAKER_02: I had a long list, but I will try to only mention the essential ones.
- 35:36SPEAKER_02: Based on the Australian experience, there will be a number of provisions that I would suggest adding or brand new provisions or changing the existing ones.
- 35:45SPEAKER_02: The simple ones, section 33T of the federal legislation says that the ability of the courts to replace inadequate class representatives can only be initiated by dissatisfied class members.
- 36:00SPEAKER_02: To me, I think it's agreed by all commentators or majority of them, including my distinguished colleagues in other universities, that the court should have the ability to initiate that process on its own motion.
- 36:13SPEAKER_02: Very quickly, second one, competing class actions.
- 36:16SPEAKER_02: This is going to be very controversial.
- 36:18SPEAKER_02: We'll add to the long list of enemies that I have the privilege of creating for myself competing class action.
- 36:27SPEAKER_02: So this will really upset a number of people who I think like me normally.
- 36:31SPEAKER_02: I think there should be provisions saying when there are competing class actions, the court must choose one class action, one law firm, one litigation funder.
- 36:42SPEAKER_02: Hopefully, I think Justice O'Brien of the federal court is the one who would be smiling at hearing me say that.
- 36:50SPEAKER_02: I don't base it on technical or legal reasons.
- 36:52SPEAKER_02: I'm not a judge.
- 36:54SPEAKER_02: I'm not interested in what I think is the best, not what is legal.
- 36:57SPEAKER_02: If I was 10 years younger, my next empirical project would be to prove then when two firms go to the court and say, we've had nice discussions, we're going to consolidate and we're going to be, we're going to be even better for the class members, and there will be no duplication of costs.
- 37:13SPEAKER_02: I said, if I was 10 years younger, I would spend my time if I'd receive funding for it, proving that that is not correct, that no matter how beautifully the two firms go above, no matter how many cost assessors you have, it must increase the cost of running the class action.
- 37:30SPEAKER_02: Now, from a Victorian point of view, having that rule in the Victorian legislation would force them to have a carriage motion.
- 37:38SPEAKER_02: And my stats have shown that where the court has to adjudicate on a GCO application and it's done in the carriage motion, magically, the two dueling law firms, or three or four, there was one that was four.
- 37:53SPEAKER_02: The outcome was Slater and Gordon won the carriage and said we would only take 14%.
- 37:58SPEAKER_02: So that there would be one advantage in the touring sitting where in that situation they lower their demands in order to win the carriage march.
- 38:08SPEAKER_02: So that would make me very popular.
- 38:09SPEAKER_02: This make Justice O'Brien happy.
- 38:11SPEAKER_02: Oh, this will be even actually this will actually might upset plaintiff and defendant solicitors.
- 38:18SPEAKER_02: I would have a provision in the legislation saying class closureslash registration devices are prohibited until there is a settlement agreement or a positive post-trial judgment.
- 38:37SPEAKER_02: The number of vulnerable class members in Australian class action who have missed out on getting a share of settlement proceeds.
- 38:45SPEAKER_02: Again, if I was 10 years younger, I would go and spend seven days a week collecting this data, but I can do it quickly and I hope to do it over the next few months, is extraordinary.
- 38:54SPEAKER_02: So on the legislation, we have an opt-out regime.
- 38:57SPEAKER_02: In practice, we have a mix of an opt-out optic.
- 39:02SPEAKER_02: Now, I know all the arguments, which of course are beautifully contained in Jason's book and Damien and Ken Adams and all the Melissa and all the other members of your firm.
- 39:12SPEAKER_02: I know all the arguments in favor of those disclosures, but in American empirical studies shows that the timing of imposing those types of optic devices is crucial.
- 39:24SPEAKER_02: What I mean by that is that normally those are implemented before the lawyers go and have mediation.
- 39:30SPEAKER_02: I'm saying that that should not be done, that the closed closure should happen only after there's an announcement.
- 39:36SPEAKER_02: It facilitates a settlement because it gives greater information to the defendant solicitors.
- 39:43SPEAKER_02: My argument is that American empirical studies confirm common sense, which is if there's money on the table, very sorry, very vulgar expression, American empirical studies show that the percentage of class members who take the step are far greater than when they're asked to take a positive step, and all they're told is, well, the litigation is going on, they're going to have settlement discussion.
- 40:10SPEAKER_02: But at the moment, we've got nothing for you.
- 40:12SPEAKER_02: We have no federal judgment, we have no multi-million dollar settlement.
- 40:16SPEAKER_02: So that's very controversial.
- 40:19SPEAKER_02: Peter Cashman will love me for that.
- 40:21SPEAKER_02: There should be a public fund class section.
- 40:24SPEAKER_02: Ontario, which has the best regime in Canada, they've got a public fund which funds pretty much only class sections, social justice class actions, vulnerable people.
- 40:36SPEAKER_02: And unfortunately, GCO haven there haven't been any really GC orders filed on behalf of vulnerable people.
- 40:43SPEAKER_02: So public fund, I agree with Peter Cashman.
- 40:46SPEAKER_02: Australian Law Reform Commission recommended that in 1988.
- 40:49SPEAKER_02: So, and that would take pressure off that would have me stopping annoying plaintiff lawyers and say decrease your shareholder class action, bring more social justice class section.
- 41:01SPEAKER_02: And another Peter Cashman, the pioneer of Australian class action, has been strongly arguing for this since 1988.
- 41:08SPEAKER_01: You won't be surprised that there's an episode in which we interviewed Peter and he he expressed those exact views.
- 41:14SPEAKER_01: So you've predicted that accurately.
- 41:18SPEAKER_01: He again looked favorably on Canada as you have.
- 41:21SPEAKER_01: And there is we discussed in that episode, and I'm sure you'd agree there there is an issue with the way funds are being directed at the moment to perhaps areas that aren't short of supply, away from areas where there is a bit of a need in this, what I'll call broadly the social justice areas.
- 41:36SPEAKER_02: Okay, can I just one more aggregate damages is another area where Peter and I agree.
- 41:41SPEAKER_02: In fact, so the last 20 years, Australian judges have developed a very persuasive and good jurisprudence on settlements.
- 41:50SPEAKER_02: What we don't have at the moment is because we've usually haven't had many successful trials in class action.
- 41:57SPEAKER_02: Now we're beginning to have more trials, which means more possibilities of successful trials on the substantive claims of class members.
- 42:07SPEAKER_02: What has happened is those successful ones, if the parties cannot reach an agreement, a settlement agreement, they're going on for years and years arguing how do we work out the compensation to class members?
- 42:21SPEAKER_02: The Australian judges do not appear to be like aggregate damages.
- 42:25SPEAKER_02: They seem to be saying that that only applies in exceptional circumstances.
- 42:29SPEAKER_02: So I think that that's another area that we have to look at again and say, how do we deal with the post-successful verdict where the parties cannot agree on a settlement?
- 42:40SPEAKER_02: What do we do?
- 42:40SPEAKER_02: If you don't apply aggregate damages or think aggregate damages are not relevant or applicable, what do we do?
- 42:46SPEAKER_02: We have a number of class sections which have been gone for six, five or six years since the class won the trial.
- 42:54SPEAKER_02: So that's, I think, that's the other big area, which again, if I were 10 years younger, I would look into it.
- 42:59SPEAKER_02: But it's up to my younger colleagues to do that.
- 43:02SPEAKER_00: Well, that's you've you've maybe left that one so that your uh plaintiff friends can look more favorably on you again, as I know that that's an area that they uh recovered throughout have changed their views.
- 43:15SPEAKER_00: Not on I agree that it damages, but we do support many of the things that you were saying about obviously multiplicity.
- 43:21SPEAKER_00: And it's been quite interesting that you know we've been involved in some cases where you know a number of steps have had to be taken before the proceedings have been regularised, including having to put on a defense and then having to effectively reset and start again after that carriage debate has been resolved.
- 43:38SPEAKER_00: So thank you so much, Vince, for joining us today.
- 43:45SPEAKER_00: Thank you for joining us for our discussion with Professor Vince Moribito.
- 43:49SPEAKER_00: The professor's research is broad and gives us insights ranging from class members misunderstanding the class action opt-out regime to some incorrect assumptions about settlement rates and to the procedural burdens created by competing class actions.
- 44:05SPEAKER_00: Professor Moribito's work is an interesting empirical starting point for discussions regarding the class action system, what it does well, and where there are possible areas for reform.
- 44:16SPEAKER_00: Thank you for listening to On Just Terms.