Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Classical vs Operant vs Observational Learning: How They Work Together
Transcript
- 0:00Imagine a kid growing up in an environment that's
- 0:03just steeped in prejudice. Like, are they born
- 0:06with this biological switch for hate? Or is that
- 0:09worldview constructed, you know, piece by piece
- 0:12the exact same way they learn to tie their shoes?
- 0:14Right, or like, how they learn to solve a math
- 0:16problem. Exactly. Welcome to The Psychology Undergrad.
- 0:20We are sitting down with you today to review
- 0:22our notes for Chapter 9, which is titled, Complementary
- 0:25Not Competing. before the big assignment hits.
- 0:29Yeah, and this is such a crucial deep dive into
- 0:31the source material because, I mean, all semester
- 0:34we've been looking at these isolated theories,
- 0:36right? Right, like totally separate boxes. Exactly,
- 0:38like how a dog salivates to a bell or how a pigeon
- 0:41presses a lever. Yeah. But module nine forces
- 0:45us to look at the unified architecture. Our mission
- 0:48today is to figure out how these different ways
- 0:50of learning don't actually fight each other,
- 0:53but team up to shape our behaviors. And we're
- 0:56not just talking about learning to run a cash
- 0:59register, we're getting into our deepest moral
- 1:01values. Definitely. And to ground this, we really
- 1:04should look back at the Module 8 recap first,
- 1:06because that's our entry point. Oh, for sure.
- 1:08Module 8 was all about observational learning,
- 1:11mostly Bandura's work. Right, Albert Bandura.
- 1:13His whole thing is that if we acquire behaviors
- 1:16by watching others, like literally downloading
- 1:19a behavioral template just by observing a model,
- 1:22then we can alter those behaviors the exact same
- 1:25way. Right, which has massive clinical applications.
- 1:28Right, like think about someone completely paralyzed
- 1:31by a phobia of dogs. Oh yeah. A therapist wouldn't
- 1:33just sit there and talk to them about dogs. They'd
- 1:36have the patient watch a model. usually someone
- 1:39they trust, interacting safely with a dog. And
- 1:42the observer's brain is just processing all of
- 1:44that. They see the dog being pet, they see there's
- 1:46no threat, and their amygdala actually starts
- 1:48to down -regulate the fear response. Yeah, without
- 1:51the patient ever even touching the dog. The brain
- 1:53just simulates the safety. Oh wow, that's wild.
- 1:56But I want to push back on the notes a little
- 1:57here, because let's think about a child learning
- 2:00right from wrong. Is observation really enough?
- 2:03What do you mean? Well, I've watched professors
- 2:05solve complex stats problems perfectly. The model
- 2:08was flawless. But then I look at my blank paper
- 2:11and my mind is a total void. Like, what happens
- 2:15when someone struggles to learn just by watching?
- 2:17Oh, right, the prompt delay. The text uses that
- 2:20exact math problem example. Watching is just
- 2:23the first phase. Yeah, the instructor steps back
- 2:26and makes you try it. Right, because if they
- 2:27just keep doing it for you, your brain never
- 2:30bridges that synaptic gap. But if you fail after
- 2:33the prompt delay, they don't just leave you there.
- 2:35Right, they step in. Exactly. They use this structured
- 2:38prompt system. Verbal, gestural, modeling, and
- 2:42physical. Yes. Okay, so to help you guys remember
- 2:44these four types of prompts for the exam, I came
- 2:47up with a little chunking trick. Oh, let's hear
- 2:48it. Since we're tying this to morality like learning
- 2:51good behavior, just remember V -G -M -P as...
- 2:55Very good moral people. Very good moral people.
- 2:58I like that. Verbal, gestural, modeling, physical.
- 3:01It gives your brain an emotional anchor, you
- 3:02know? And college instructors use this exact
- 3:05system. Corporate trainers use it, too. Like,
- 3:08think about learning a new point of sale system
- 3:10at a job. The trainer models it, then gives you
- 3:13a prompt delay to try ringing up a customer.
- 3:16And if you freeze, they give a verbal prompt
- 3:19like, hit the tender button. Right. And if that
- 3:21fails, they move to gestural, which is just pointing
- 3:23at the screen. If you're still stuck, they model
- 3:26it again. And finally, if you just can't get
- 3:28it, they use a physical prompt. Yeah, like literally
- 3:30putting their hand over yours to guide the mouse.
- 3:33But the key is what happens after you finally
- 3:36do it right. The trainer gives you that social
- 3:38support, like, great job. Which changes everything,
- 3:41because once we introduce praise and rewards,
- 3:44we are totally leaving Bendura behind. Oh, yeah.
- 3:47We are firmly in operant conditioning territory
- 3:49now. Which naturally transitions us into Part
- 3:52V of Module 9 complementary, not competing. Because
- 3:55observing doesn't explain why a behavior sticks
- 3:58around forever. Exactly. The core concept here
- 4:01is that respondent conditioning, operant conditioning,
- 4:03and observational learning are not competing.
- 4:06They work together in three distinct phases.
- 4:08Right. Acquisition, maintenance, and extinguishing.
- 4:11Or limiting, yeah. But OK, it's easy to see how
- 4:14learning a cash register uses all three. But
- 4:16what about the heavy, dark stuff? Like, the assignment
- 4:20specifically lists hate, racism, prejudice, and
- 4:24discrimination. Yeah, the syllabus calls that
- 4:25a package of sorts. Right, a package. So hate
- 4:29isn't just a switch. It's acquired. Maybe through
- 4:32observational learning, like a kid watching prejudiced
- 4:35adults. And then it gets maintained. Exactly,
- 4:38through operant conditioning. Like maybe they
- 4:40make a prejudice joke and their friend group
- 4:42laughs. That social approval is a massive reinforcer.
- 4:45It really is. Dopamine just floods the system.
- 4:48But this is actually where the moral implications
- 4:50get really profound. Wait, how so? Because if
- 4:53hate is mechanically acquired and mechanically
- 4:55maintained, then theoretically, It can be systematically
- 4:59extinguished. Oh, wow. Yeah, if it's learned,
- 5:02it can be unlearned. You just have to dismantle
- 5:03the machinery, you know, alter the reinforcement
- 5:06so the behavior gets a social cost instead of
- 5:08a reward. Exactly. Introduce counter models.
- 5:11It's incredibly hopeful, honestly. It really
- 5:13is. But OK, speaking of things we have to tackle,
- 5:16let's pivot to how you actually have to prove.
- 5:20you know, the stuff for the upcoming assignment.
- 5:22Right. Exercise four at WSU, the complementary
- 5:25not competing exercise. We need to go over the
- 5:27details so you guys are ready. It's a two to
- 5:29three page APA format paper. Yeah. And make sure
- 5:32it's an MS word or converted to a PDF, guys.
- 5:35Don't lose points on formatting. Seriously. The
- 5:38goal is to pick a specific behavior and explain
- 5:40how it's acquired, maintained, and reduced using
- 5:44those learning models. And there's a specific
- 5:46list of approved choices. Right. You can do drug,
- 5:49alcohol, or nicotine addiction. You can do phobias,
- 5:52either general or specific. You can do the hate
- 5:55and racism package we just talked about. Or you
- 5:57can do tantrums and disruptive behavior in children.
- 6:00But here is the massive warning label, guys.
- 6:02Listen to this part. Yes, huge red flag. The
- 6:04assignment has an other behavior option. If you
- 6:07want to pick something off list, you must email
- 6:10the instructor for prior approval. Literally,
- 6:13if you just go rogue and pick a behavior that
- 6:15doesn't fit the framework perfectly. You get
- 6:17a zero. You just get a flat zero. Do not gamble
- 6:21your grade on this. Yeah, human behavior is messy.
- 6:24The instructor is just trying to protect you
- 6:26from picking a topic that falls apart halfway
- 6:28through the analysis. So true. And to help you
- 6:31structure the paper, I've got another mnemonic
- 6:33for you. Just... AME at the target behavior.
- 6:38AME. Oh, Acquisition Maintenance Extinguishing.
- 6:40Yep. AME. Just aim at it. Use those three phases
- 6:45as your actual headings in the paper to make
- 6:47sure you hit the rubric. That's a really solid
- 6:49way to organize it. But there's a specific peer
- 6:52review process for submitting this. Yeah. Do
- 6:54not just email this to the professor. You have
- 6:56to complete it by Wednesday, but you post it
- 6:58as a reply to the discussion question prompt.
- 7:01The DQ prompt. And this is actually super meta
- 7:03if you think about it. Do you know what I mean?
- 7:05Well, the peer review process tests your ability
- 7:08to read another student's paper, give them feedback,
- 7:12evaluate their critique of your work, and then
- 7:14synthesize it all into a final response. Oh,
- 7:16wow. Yeah, we are actively using observational
- 7:19learning and operant conditioning on each other.
- 7:21Exactly. We're observing models, providing verbal
- 7:24prompts, getting social reinforcement. It's a
- 7:26live laboratory of the exact concepts we're writing
- 7:29about. That is pretty mind blowing, actually.
- 7:31Right. So let's just recap really quick. Whether
- 7:33it's a cash register, a phobia, or a deep moral
- 7:37failing like prejudice. Learning is this continuous
- 7:40loop, right? Observing, associating, and reinforcing.
- 7:44Yeah. Spot on. Which leaves us with one final
- 7:47kind of provocative thought before you start
- 7:49writing your AME papers. Yeah, think about this.
- 7:51If all behaviors, even deeply rooted moral packages
- 7:55like hate, are just learned and maintained through
- 7:58these complementary models. What happens if society
- 8:01intentionally redesigns our social reinforcements?
- 8:04Exactly. What if we redesign the models to extinguish
- 8:07prejudice on a global scale? Are we really just
- 8:10one perfectly structured prompt delay away from
- 8:13a better world? It's something to think about,
- 8:15for sure. Definitely. Well, good luck on your
- 8:17Wednesday DQ posts, guys. Keep studying, and
- 8:20we'll catch you next time on The Psychology Undergrad.