Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Substance Abuse in Family Court: Legal Tools and Practical Realities with Hon. Harry L. Powazek (Ret.)
Transcript
- 0:02Welcome to Substance Abuse and Family Law Court
- 0:05Legal Tools and Practical Realities. I'm Dan
- 0:10Bemel and along with April Zanis, I'm co -chair
- 0:12of the Beverly Hills Bar Association Family Law
- 0:14Section. Before we get started today, please
- 0:17check your calendars and make sure you're ready
- 0:19and excited for all of our great upcoming programming.
- 0:23Nuts and bolts of business valuation and family
- 0:26law on October 1st. When bankruptcy is filed
- 0:29during divorce, what happens next? Also on October
- 0:331st, the doubleheader. Fireside chat with new
- 0:38judicial officers featuring Judge Shelley Kaufman
- 0:41on October 3rd. All you need to know about PPAs
- 0:44on October 14th, also with Judge Kaufman. And
- 0:47then our two flagship events, the symposium on
- 0:50November 1st called Order in the Court, Tactics
- 0:53for Addressing Bad Faith and Incivility, and
- 0:56State of Department 2. on November 5th in person.
- 1:00It's going to be a blast. The family law section
- 1:03is sponsored by White, Zuckerman, Morsovsky,
- 1:05Luna & Hunt. White, Zuckerman, Morsovsky, Luna
- 1:08& Hunt provides a wide variety of resources to
- 1:11complete almost any project, large or small.
- 1:13They also provide additional accounting and tax
- 1:16practice services. We invite you to contact them
- 1:19to discuss your specific accounting needs and
- 1:21learn how they can be of service to you. Today's
- 1:24program is sponsored by SoberLink. SoberLink
- 1:27is a trusted leader in alcohol monitoring, providing
- 1:30innovative technology that delivers reliable,
- 1:34discreet, and user -friendly solutions to support
- 1:36recovery, treatment, and peace of mind. Here's
- 1:39a brief message from today's sponsor. Real or
- 1:50false claims of alcohol use can further complicate
- 1:52divorces by impacting child safety and trust
- 1:54between parents. As a family law attorney, you
- 1:57understand the difficulty of proving or disproving
- 1:59these claims in court and need reliable evidence
- 2:02to support your case. The problem is, traditional
- 2:05lab testing just doesn't cut it for family law
- 2:07cases. Lab tests take time, sometimes days, so
- 2:11by the time you get the results, the parenting
- 2:13time has already come and gone. Any delays in
- 2:15alcohol monitoring can cause uncertainty and
- 2:18impact child safety, leaving room for doubt and
- 2:20making it harder to present a strong case in
- 2:22court. You need something faster, more efficient,
- 2:26and reliable. A solution that gives you real
- 2:28-time, court -admissible evidence so you can
- 2:30protect your client's interests and move cases
- 2:32forward with confidence. SoberLink offers proof
- 2:36of sobriety at your fingertips so you can navigate
- 2:38custody cases confidently. With a push of a button
- 2:42and a single breath, SoberLink confirms the tester's
- 2:44identity and sends an instant notification of
- 2:47whether or not they've been drinking. It's compact
- 2:49and discreet enough to be used multiple times
- 2:51a day and has built -in sensors that detect if
- 2:53someone's trying to cheat. Most importantly,
- 2:56it's easy to read the court -admissible evidence
- 2:58of a parent's entire monthly testing history.
- 3:01For nearly 15 years, our expert in -house support
- 3:04team and best -in -class technology have been
- 3:06helping make safe and fair decisions for children
- 3:08and parents alike. That's what makes SoberLink
- 3:10the number one alcohol monitoring solution in
- 3:13family law. SoberLink, proving sobriety, improving
- 3:17lives. Okay, thank you, SoberLink. And now on
- 3:21to the program. I'm delighted to introduce today's
- 3:25speakers. And thank you both in advance for joining
- 3:28us today. The Honorable Harry Pawczyk and Ashley
- 3:32Girdow. Judge Poazic is a mediator, arbitrator,
- 3:36and private judge with signature resolution,
- 3:38bringing nearly three decades of experience on
- 3:41the San Diego Superior Court branch. A former
- 3:44certified family law specialist and mediator,
- 3:47he is known for his expertise in complex custody
- 3:49disputes, including cases involving substance
- 3:52abuse, supervised visitation, and high conflict
- 3:55parenting matters. He has served on numerous
- 3:58court committees focused on domestic violence
- 4:00and family court policy, and has been recognized
- 4:03with multiple judicial honors, including the
- 4:06Distinguished Family Law Jurist Award. Ashley
- 4:09Gerdo is a Rising Scholars Network Regional Coordinator
- 4:13for the Foundation for California Community Colleges.
- 4:16Before stepping into this role in 2025, she co
- 4:20-founded and served as the Student Support Specialist
- 4:22for the Transition Scholars Program at Mira Costa
- 4:26College, where she worked to expand equitable
- 4:28access to higher education for justice impacted
- 4:32students. Drawing on her personal experiences
- 4:35and her background in sociology, actually brings
- 4:37a deep commitment to dismantling systemic barriers
- 4:40and advocating for policies that restore dignity
- 4:43and opportunity to individuals impacted by incarceration.
- 4:48We're excited to hear what they have to share
- 4:50with us today. Thank you so much for your preparation
- 4:53and spending this time with our bar. Your honor,
- 4:57the floor is yours. Well, thank you. I'd like
- 5:00the introduction. It makes me seem important.
- 5:03I wanna thank the Beverly Hills Bar Association
- 5:07for the honor of presenting today. I've been
- 5:09a quiet visitor for the past year watching the
- 5:14seminars. They are excellent. They provide a
- 5:19great deal of information, especially regarding
- 5:21family law, which is an important area for me.
- 5:25If you need to... get a hold of me and email
- 5:29me. My email address is H. Powasek, P -O -W -A
- 5:34-Z -E -K at Signature Resolution. I'd be happy
- 5:38to respond to any questions regarding this seminar.
- 5:44We have a lot to cover between family law and
- 5:47substance abuse. There's a lot of things to deal
- 5:50with. And I'm not sure we have enough time. I'm
- 5:54going to try to get to it as quickly as I can
- 5:57and get through as much as we can. Ashley will
- 6:02tell you, I'm old school. I can barely figure
- 6:05out how to use my computer. So rather than having
- 6:09a PowerPoint. I've given you a couple of outlines
- 6:12that I thought would be beneficial. I want to
- 6:15be talking today. There's an article I wrote
- 6:18for the LA Daily Journal recently about this
- 6:21particular issue, and I did not know they were
- 6:24going to be a sponsor. There's some handouts
- 6:26for Soberlink. And that's a program I'll talk
- 6:30to you in a little bit. A couple of disclaimers.
- 6:35I've been retired about 18 months. Sometimes
- 6:37I fall back in the position of thinking I'm a
- 6:41judge still on the judge's bench and I say this
- 6:44is the order I'm going to make and that I'm retired.
- 6:49So excuse that. I also need to tell you this
- 6:53is My own opinion. I'm going to give you a bench
- 6:57perspective. I have no formal training in substance
- 7:01abuse. My career began as a public defender in
- 7:05the early 80s, and that's when it was glue sniffing
- 7:09and marijuana was not even close to what it is
- 7:12today. And they did not have vaping. It was just
- 7:15rolling a joint. Things have changed dramatically
- 7:19about that, and I'll talk to you about that in
- 7:21a little bit. I became a certified family law
- 7:25specialist. Family law became my vocation. And
- 7:30then I got on the bench in 1995, and I was on
- 7:34the bench for almost 30 years, primarily in family
- 7:38law. And I retired about 18 months ago. During
- 7:42the same time, I fell in love with my drug court
- 7:46program. Drug court, if you don't know, is a
- 7:50diversionary drug court. They're taken out of
- 7:54the criminal justice system and given an opportunity
- 7:57to get sober, straighten out their life, and
- 8:00move forward. It's a difficult, intensive program.
- 8:05It's supposed to last 18 months. It'd last more
- 8:08than 18 months. We had one lady in there for
- 8:10eight years. I didn't want to let her go because
- 8:12I knew she would relapse as soon as she got out.
- 8:16And she did. The program requires, and it's usually
- 8:19a felony. It's changed a little bit now, but
- 8:22they had to see me once a week, depending what
- 8:25phase they're in. They had to go to counseling
- 8:27on a regular basis. All my counselors were phenomenal.
- 8:31They were ex -addicts, and so you couldn't really
- 8:35mess with them. They had to be tested regularly.
- 8:39They had to go to school or get a job, and they
- 8:43had to behave themselves. What was really important
- 8:49is the group dynamic. And I'm going to talk to
- 8:53you a little bit about that in a little bit.
- 8:58The group dynamic helped people get sober. They
- 9:03joined the drug court family. It became a safe
- 9:08place for them to deal with their issues. And
- 9:13although their motivation when they first came
- 9:15in was just to get out of jail. You know, drug
- 9:19court's easy, we'll just get out of jail. And
- 9:22that wasn't the case. It took them a while to
- 9:25be comfortable to get into the drug court family.
- 9:30But it was a very successful program. The reason
- 9:33I'm telling you about this, because there's different
- 9:35means of addressing sobriety. Mine mainly was
- 9:40drug court. This is where I learned about substance
- 9:45abuse and the people and how to deal with it,
- 9:48how to hear things that were non -verbal. Most
- 9:53importantly, I got to see people get out of Kenyans
- 9:58that they were living in and began to get their
- 10:02families back together, to get jobs, to become
- 10:06tax -paying people. And if it completed the program,
- 10:10I had the honor of terminating their probation,
- 10:13restoring their Fourth Amendment rights, and
- 10:16sending them on their way, although they kept
- 10:19on showing up at our graduations, so I could
- 10:22see how they were doing. As you know, substance
- 10:27abuse has changed tremendously within a very
- 10:31short period of time, and it continues to change
- 10:34tremendously. The delivery systems, the vaping
- 10:38right now to the various substances, the substance
- 10:43abuse issues right now can cause death easily.
- 10:47You know, you have your fentanyl, you have marijuana.
- 10:50That is not what it was when I was in high school.
- 10:56The potency is tremendous. You have the designer
- 11:00drugs. You have drugs they can't even test for
- 11:03now. The bath salts, the creatine seems to be
- 11:05coming back. And this is no longer a barrio issue.
- 11:11These are issues that are affecting affluent
- 11:14areas of town. Young kids are getting into the
- 11:19pills. And unfortunately, if they take one pill
- 11:21of fentanyl, God bless what's going to happen.
- 11:27And family law. The substance abuse allegations
- 11:31is very common, as you know. When people break
- 11:34up, they grab onto things to try to get an upper
- 11:38hand. They want to try to keep what they have,
- 11:42including their kids. And this provides a very
- 11:47difficult decision for the court for a variety
- 11:52of reasons. From the court side, there's a lack
- 11:55of court resources to deal with this particular
- 11:58issue. There's a lack of family court services
- 12:03resources to deal with this issue. More importantly,
- 12:07the parties generally don't have the money to
- 12:10pay for the tools that I'm about to give you
- 12:13that we utilize. They barely could afford the
- 12:16attorneys and then you... ask them to pay for
- 12:19a substance abuse assessment or an evaluation
- 12:22or testing. It's a very difficult situation.
- 12:27The major problem is when they don't come to
- 12:30an understanding after all this testing, it gets
- 12:33sent to a long -cause matter. And in San Diego,
- 12:36when I was in a long -cause department, it would
- 12:39take 18 months or two years to get to me. And
- 12:42God knows what happens in family law in 18 months
- 12:45to two years. So that is some problems within
- 12:48the system itself. I assume everybody understands
- 12:53the main issue is not the use of a substance.
- 12:57It is its effect on the party's ability and skills
- 13:01to take care of their kids. And then balancing
- 13:06that with the safety of the kids. as well as
- 13:10their parental rights. It tends to be a moving
- 13:13target. The cases usually show up on my calendar,
- 13:19my old calendar, I'm sorry, I thought I was a
- 13:21judge again, on an ex -party basis with no notice
- 13:25to the accused party. They're asking for substantial
- 13:29orders as the custody visitation usually with
- 13:32a domestic violence matter or through an RFO.
- 13:35And it would be great if they provided supporting
- 13:39information to support their requests, police
- 13:42reports, videos, pictures. I don't get that.
- 13:46Or normally I didn't get that. What I got was
- 13:48just a declaration basically saying the other
- 13:52part is using drugs, alcohol. The kids are in
- 13:55a bad place. You need to limit access to the
- 13:59kids. And then I sat in an order shortening time
- 14:06so we could deal with the matter quickly. It
- 14:09was always nice for me when the accused party
- 14:11never showed up. And as long as there was service,
- 14:16I made appropriate orders that I felt were appropriate,
- 14:19and the case moved on. The hard part is when
- 14:23everybody showed up. It was always nice if they
- 14:26had lawyers. Most of the time, they did not.
- 14:32And then what I wanted to do is try to keep the
- 14:36case in a stable place, safe place for the kids
- 14:42until we were able to get credible information.
- 14:45And that was difficult to do. I felt like I was
- 14:48shooting in the dark. You know, it's hard to
- 14:52deal with credibility with people from paperwork
- 14:55because it was usually on a motion calendar.
- 15:00And all I wanted to do was create stability and
- 15:04use the following tools. Now, the tools that
- 15:08I would use are mainly in the handout. Hopefully
- 15:11you have them. I think you should be able to
- 15:14download it. And I'm going to go over them just
- 15:16a little bit because they're important. This
- 15:19is what I would basically use to get through
- 15:24this substance abuse issue. hopefully on a quick
- 15:29and timely basis. There's the California Standards
- 15:32of Judicial Administration 5 .20. If you would
- 15:37like to, it's 18 pages long. It's difficult to
- 15:42read through. It's not an easy read. This is
- 15:44regarding the standards regarding supervised
- 15:47visitation, which I use on a regular basis. It
- 15:52applied to professional supervisors and non -professionals.
- 15:57It provided frankly what I thought was minimal
- 15:59education regarding substance abuse, child abuse,
- 16:03sexual abuse, domestic violence, who was also
- 16:06a component to learn basic family law. And again,
- 16:10I would use this and be creative with it. to
- 16:16try to get some stability, to get access, whether
- 16:20if it's really bad it could be through the FaceTime,
- 16:25that type of thing. But you could get to be creative
- 16:27with it. The problem with professional supervisors,
- 16:33I don't know around here, but in San Diego, the
- 16:37quality varies tremendously. I would get people
- 16:42who would provide reports to me that were out
- 16:45of their lane for lack of a legal term. They
- 16:48would tell me what to do regarding custody visitation,
- 16:51and that's not what I wanted. I just wanted to
- 16:54know how the visitation went, how the parties
- 16:57behave, whether they showed up in time, that
- 16:59type of thing. It was also a problem when they
- 17:04began to be personally involved with the case,
- 17:06especially for the nonprofessional supervisors.
- 17:11And then there's the cost of it. It could vary
- 17:14tremendously depending on whether you're using
- 17:16a professional supervisor and each of the professional
- 17:19supervisors. There's California Standard Judicial
- 17:23Administration 5 .30. This is for the new judges.
- 17:29I don't know in the various jurisdictions you're
- 17:31in, but being in family law for almost 30 years
- 17:35is... not happening. They're putting brand new
- 17:39judges in family law. And they're trying to learn
- 17:42the law. And they're trying to learn how to be
- 17:44a judge at the same time. Trying to deal with
- 17:47these type of cases with a little education they're
- 17:53getting is difficult. And you need to be aware
- 17:56of that. I'm assuming you are. I'm going to talk
- 17:59a little bit about that. Judges in a little bit.
- 18:06I'm going to say this a lot. This is going to
- 18:10cost a lot for the parties. There's very little
- 18:15resources for them to get the evaluations and
- 18:19so forth. And again, most of them take a lot
- 18:21of time. I've had them take up to a year, depending
- 18:25on the cooperation of the parties. We have court
- 18:29order custody evaluations. 5 .220 of the California
- 18:34Rules of Court. It's 19 pages long and it's supported
- 18:40by Family Code Section 211 and 3117. The evaluators
- 18:46must consider the history of child abuse, domestic
- 18:50violence, substance abuse, mental illness, and
- 18:53so forth. And usually, when you get these reports,
- 18:59they can vary tremendously, depending on the
- 19:03evaluator. Hopefully, you're going to get someone
- 19:05who has experience in this area of substance
- 19:09abuse. Some don't. There are some programs that
- 19:12aren't bad that have interns do everything, and
- 19:15they're reviewed by a psychologist. That's usually
- 19:20through the clinics, through the various colleges.
- 19:24I read the reports. I never took anything at
- 19:27face value, whether it was a CUSY evaluation
- 19:29or whatever. I needed to make sure it was based
- 19:33on more than testing, that they were able to
- 19:35get decent information from all sources, from
- 19:40the parties, the grandparents, family members,
- 19:43teachers, friends, and I'll use that in quotations.
- 19:51That was important for me. There's California
- 19:54Rules of Court 5 .225, 19 pages long. It provides
- 19:59what is necessary educational wise for the evaluators,
- 20:05the effects of divorce, separation, domestic
- 20:07violence, child's sexual abuse, children's physical,
- 20:13emotional abuse, neglect, sex abuse, and so forth.
- 20:16Everything that you think would be necessary.
- 20:19But again, If you're going to select a evaluator,
- 20:23make sure they have some experience. I understand
- 20:25the cost, but to get me someone who has no experience
- 20:30and the report is minimal at best is not really
- 20:33helpful. Now my favorite thing for a variety
- 20:38of reasons. It's the appointment of minors council
- 20:41based on California rules of court 5 .242. It
- 20:47tells you what the qualifications are. It's 16
- 20:50pages long. It's recognizing and evaluating and
- 20:54understanding evidence of child abuse, neglect,
- 20:56family violence, everything that we talked about.
- 21:01Miners' Council, from my perspective, would give
- 21:04me, the court, quick information as to what's
- 21:09going on. Usually, I don't really give a whole
- 21:13lot of credibility for the what the parties are
- 21:15telling me because they're so different. They
- 21:19are able to give me quick, hopefully objective
- 21:23information and it provides a safety net until
- 21:27I get the evaluation or substance abuse assessment
- 21:30or so forth. The best part of it is I'm no longer
- 21:36a target by the parties. I am no longer Satan.
- 21:39I am not making decisions. The Miners' Council
- 21:43becomes the target. And sometimes it gets pretty
- 21:47intense. They want to get off of the case. There's
- 21:51not a lot of money for them to get paid. There
- 21:54is a county rate that is abysmal, but at least
- 21:58it's something. There's times that they do have
- 22:00resources. I've made orders for payment, and
- 22:03they never comply. And Miners' Council doesn't
- 22:07file any type of collection action. But I love
- 22:10Miners' Council. The problem is sometimes they
- 22:13get personally involved after they've been attacked
- 22:16personally by one or both of the parties, calling
- 22:19them Satan or incompetent or so forth. It's not
- 22:24an easy job, but frankly, it has helped me until
- 22:28I'm able to make a final order. There's family
- 22:32code section 3041. And by the way, this is all
- 22:35preponderance of the evidence, which makes it
- 22:39less of a burden. 3041 is regarding testing,
- 22:44and we're generally talking about drug testing,
- 22:48urine, or blood testing. There's many types of
- 22:54orders that can be made as to the various labs,
- 22:57various times, various costs, various methods.
- 23:01You should know that I cannot consider, I cannot
- 23:06consider In the past, when I was on the bench,
- 23:10I could not consider hair follicle testing. I
- 23:15loved hair follicle testing. It could provide
- 23:17a great deal of information as to what substances
- 23:20were used, when they were used. The problem is
- 23:24it's not passed the Kelly Fry test. So it's not
- 23:29admissible unless the parties stipulate to it.
- 23:32As a story, I had one litigant. that the party
- 23:36stipulated to the hair follicle testing, which
- 23:40was great. And I set it for a review hearing.
- 23:42And then I got a notice that they couldn't complete
- 23:46the testing because the father decided to shave
- 23:50every hair on his body. And I questioned whether
- 23:54it was every hair on his body and it was. I had
- 23:59to make a test in order he couldn't shave so
- 24:02they could do the hair follicle testing. And
- 24:05frankly, when they did something like that regarding
- 24:07the noncompliance, it was like strike one. You
- 24:10know, you just don't do that unless there's a
- 24:13reason to do that. There's very creative ways
- 24:17of getting around the testing. I'll talk about
- 24:19that a little bit. There's family code section
- 24:233118 where custody evaluation is mandatory. This
- 24:28is 17 pages long. It is ordered when there's
- 24:34serious credible allegations of child abuse.
- 24:37And it can be sexual, it could be neglect and
- 24:41so forth. There is the ability for the court
- 24:45to order personal counseling. And I found this
- 24:48helpful at times depending where the parties
- 24:51were. And I could also order for the kid. I could
- 24:55order family counseling, which I never did, because
- 24:57putting them in a room together was just not
- 25:00going to be a good idea. It's pursuant to family
- 25:03code section 3192. Again, it's court -ordered
- 25:09counseling is to the best interest of the child
- 25:12or children. It required a licensed mental health
- 25:16professional. I kept on having people come in
- 25:20with church counselors. you know, they would
- 25:22go to the church and get information and get
- 25:25a counselor. That would be wonderful. They were
- 25:28never licensed by the state, and I could not
- 25:32really consider their information. It was well
- 25:36-meaning, may have been good, but it was not
- 25:40admissible into evidence. They needed to look
- 25:45at the experience of the mental health provider.
- 25:49There are a number of them that have experience
- 25:52either personally or professionally with substance
- 25:57abuse. The ones that have personal experience
- 26:00I always love because they can read between the
- 26:03lines what the parties were telling and could
- 26:05get the nonverbal communication that I've learned
- 26:09to pick up on. It gave me a decent report as
- 26:15to where the parties were in their lives and
- 26:19their substance abuse. There is Family Code Section
- 26:233011. Again, it just tells the court it must
- 26:29consider a history of abuse in child custody
- 26:32visitation matters. It was sexual abuse, substance
- 26:36abuse, and so forth. With the really bad cases,
- 26:40And in 30 years, close to 30 years, I had a number
- 26:43of them in which both parties were horrible.
- 26:48I couldn't find a third party to place the kids.
- 26:52Most of the time, the kids were using two, and
- 26:55they were problematic. And the family court,
- 26:59from my perspective, didn't have the capacity
- 27:01with its limited resources to help the parties.
- 27:06So under the 300 petition of the Welfare and
- 27:09Institution Code, I would make a referral to
- 27:13Juvenile Court. And I did this three times in
- 27:16my career. Juvenile Court would do an investigation,
- 27:20do a report, and they never took the case. They
- 27:26basically said the Family Court had the resources
- 27:28and the ability. I think they were overestimating
- 27:31my capabilities to handle the case. and I was
- 27:36livid because I would not send it to them if
- 27:38I thought I had the ability to do it. But that
- 27:42is an option that the courts have. I'm not sure
- 27:48how viable it is in your jurisdiction, but in
- 27:51mine, it was not. I need to remind people, it'd
- 27:56be wonderful as substance abuse could be shown
- 27:59on an X -ray or MRI. So we didn't have to do
- 28:03this dance. It's not. And it doesn't show up
- 28:07on one particular test with everything at the
- 28:11time of an evidentiary hearing. We'll talk about
- 28:13that. It becomes you throw everything in a bucket
- 28:16and you have your evidentiary hearing if it goes
- 28:18there and you make the best decision you can.
- 28:22There are drug assessments that can be done.
- 28:25They're relatively inexpensive. They can be done
- 28:28in 30 days. I didn't find them to be really helpful.
- 28:35Some were okay because they would just generally
- 28:37do testing and contact a few people and tell
- 28:41me if there was some issue. They would also tell
- 28:43me what I should do with casiovisitation, which
- 28:46is outside their lane, and I basically ignore
- 28:49that. But that is an option. I didn't find it
- 28:52that helpful. Regarding the testing, I mentioned
- 28:57it to you in a little bit. It's urine, blood
- 29:02by a licensed lab. You got to be creative with
- 29:06who could do it, what drugs could be tested for,
- 29:09by the way, to limit the cost. There's a problem
- 29:14though. The parties would go and actually could
- 29:17tell you about this. They will go on the internet.
- 29:20And how do I get around a test? And the old days,
- 29:24it was a whizinator. I'm not gonna tell you what
- 29:26that was. You could look it up, but there's...
- 29:32constant internet input on how to get around
- 29:35the test, whether it's blood or urine, it became
- 29:41problematic. Most of the time, quite frankly,
- 29:44it didn't work. But when you have substance issue,
- 29:48you would try anything, quite frankly. Prior
- 29:53to the evidence you're hearing, we would talk
- 29:55about that. I began to know the parties on a
- 29:58regular and consistent basis because they would
- 30:00see me on an ex -party basis saying there's not
- 30:03compliance with the test, or there was a positive
- 30:05test, they're not complying with the assessment
- 30:07or the evaluation. You know, it's like I was,
- 30:10let's go see Judge Pawasek. There's nothing better
- 30:13to do to try to deal with us on a regular and
- 30:17consistent basis. With Minor's Counsel, I want
- 30:22to go over it a little bit again. It really helped.
- 30:25But the cost was a problem and the quality was
- 30:30a problem. Every once in a while, I would have
- 30:33minor counsel come in on an ex -party basis and
- 30:36give me credible information that child welfare
- 30:39services was involved. There's a police investigation
- 30:44and so forth. As to the counseling of the parties,
- 30:49I talked to you a little bit already about it.
- 30:51Licensed, not a church counselor. It could be
- 30:55the parties, it could be the kids, it could be
- 30:58family counseling. Some of it, according to the
- 31:01code, could only be up to a year. But counseling
- 31:07was sort of helpful. Now the one thing I love,
- 31:12and this is only for alcohol, and I did not know
- 31:16they were gonna be a sponsor. In the old days,
- 31:19they would have the ankle bracelets to detect
- 31:22alcohol, and there were ways of getting around
- 31:25it. Now there's Soberlink, and I've given you
- 31:29a handout. If it's just alcohol, the cheapest
- 31:33way, and I'll get into the costs a little bit
- 31:36in a little bit, is the Soberlink. They blow
- 31:40into something. It's hooked up to their cell
- 31:42phones. There are test results that are easily
- 31:46downloaded. The information I always got for
- 31:51SoberLink were credible, helpful, and I don't
- 31:54think I ever ignored it. They would use the breathalyzer
- 31:58again. It would be linked to their cell phones.
- 32:01I didn't know this, but it has facial recognition
- 32:04now. It didn't in the past. So if they had someone
- 32:07blow in for them with the facial recognition,
- 32:12that's not gonna go anywhere. And that happened
- 32:14in the past when I was on the bench. It's really
- 32:19impossible to cheat. The documentation is quick
- 32:22and easy, and it has modified testing. The costs
- 32:29are between 135 to $235 a month. which given
- 32:34what an evaluation would cost and so forth, I
- 32:39found that highly appropriate. But again, it's
- 32:43just for alcohol. If they're polysubstance abusers,
- 32:47then I'm not sure how helpful it will be. There's
- 32:52a new thing going on and Ashley may tell you
- 32:54about it because we got creative in my drug court.
- 32:57We brought down medically assisted treatment.
- 33:01And there's various types of it. There is Vivitrol
- 33:05that we brought down to the drug court, which
- 33:08is an injectable, which blocked the opiate receptors.
- 33:13Did some other things too, but it's not a cure
- 33:18-all. I was watching TV the other day. There's
- 33:21some TV commercial now about a shot that could
- 33:25help with alcohol. I have no idea what that is,
- 33:28but it's advertising. What you should be aware
- 33:32of that these are just tools. Using something
- 33:37like this without an appropriate program is worthless.
- 33:41It really is. It has to be part of the treatment
- 33:44program. But it was it was very interesting when
- 33:49I was talking to the people who started to take
- 33:52the Bifidrol shot Which was good for 30 days
- 33:54I asked them how they were doing and they said
- 33:57they were doing fine except the needle was very
- 34:00long and That was the bad thing the good thing.
- 34:05It was they weren't dreaming about the substances
- 34:08at night gave them some peace of mind where they
- 34:14could be amenable to treatment. And I thought
- 34:17that was very helpful. The last thing I could
- 34:21do, which was more or less a threat, was placing
- 34:28the child with a third party. If both parties
- 34:31were just horrible, I couldn't get them to cooperate.
- 34:35I thought they were detrimental. to the children
- 34:39and I'd have to make that finding. I threatened
- 34:42to place them with a third party. That's the
- 34:45good news. The bad news, there was nobody. I
- 34:48couldn't find a third party. At best, there will
- 34:51be elderly grandparents who were in their 70s
- 34:55who could not take care of these teenagers usually.
- 35:01That was more or less an empty threat, but that
- 35:04was an option I had. The goal I had, the reality
- 35:08of the situation was to get reliable, decent
- 35:14evidence or information that could support a
- 35:18finding or not support a finding that the party
- 35:21substance abuse affected the parents and they
- 35:26were a danger to the kids. Usually when they
- 35:30got all this information, the evidentiary, the
- 35:34the evaluation and the reports and so forth.
- 35:37Everybody wanted an evidentiary hearing. Well,
- 35:40not everybody. Sometimes they looked at it and
- 35:42said, we've been through this stuff. And they
- 35:45reached a stipulation at a review hearing that
- 35:48I sat. I said, God bless you. We'll see you later.
- 35:52Have a good time. Of course, they came back in
- 35:54about 60 days with an ex -party basis that something
- 35:57happened. That was the reality that I was seeing.
- 36:01But most of the time I had to set it for an evidentiary
- 36:04hearing. And the time frame to get one in San
- 36:09Diego was 18 months to two years. And again,
- 36:15God knows what could happen during that time
- 36:18frame. What I had to be aware of is that no cases
- 36:26were the same. There was not a pattern. One party
- 36:31was using, both parties were using, and one party
- 36:34decided to get sober. The ages the kids were
- 36:39important to me, half the time the kids were
- 36:42using. It was not unusual for them to be using
- 36:46with the parents. The grandparents became involved.
- 36:51A lot of times they placed the kids with the
- 36:54grandparents and now the grandparents wanted
- 36:57to join in and the substance issues came up.
- 37:01I had CPS involvement that would come up because
- 37:04a mandatory reporter, whether it was a doctor,
- 37:08a teacher, somebody made a report and they became
- 37:11involved. I had involvement of the other family
- 37:15members, brothers, sisters. And then there were
- 37:20their friends. And I put that on quotation. Sometimes
- 37:23the friends were people that the parties used
- 37:26to it. They became problematic and they wanted
- 37:32to be heard. This caused me to learn the use
- 37:37of phrase until the evidentiary hearing came
- 37:40up. I had to learn how to dance, you know, because
- 37:44the music changed, the fact patterns changed.
- 37:48on a weekly basis. You know, they would come
- 37:51in with information and all I wanted to do was
- 37:54keep everything stable. But that was a problem.
- 37:59I had to learn how to dance for a lack of a legal
- 38:03term. It also applies to your judges. You got
- 38:09to know your judge. It's extremely important.
- 38:12You're not going to have somebody like me, 30
- 38:14years with drug court experience or some history.
- 38:19You're going to get a judge, at least in San
- 38:21Diego, who's just been appointed to the bench.
- 38:24Brand new. You know, learning how to be a judge,
- 38:28learning the law, being able to deal with what's
- 38:33on our RFO with multiple issues as child custody
- 38:36visitation, support, interim orders. and the
- 38:40substance issues jump up on them, it's going
- 38:43to be a problem. Check their history. Maybe they
- 38:46were a public defender who dealt with substance
- 38:50abusers. Well, maybe they were a DA, you know,
- 38:55something who had some experience to deal with
- 38:59this particular issue. If they were civil litigator,
- 39:03you're going to have to learn how to spoon feed
- 39:05them because there's a lot of nuances in this
- 39:08particular area. that are important. So you have
- 39:16your hearing. You have your evidence here. Great
- 39:19time. It's two weeks long. Everybody came in
- 39:23and testified. Most of them gave you the stink
- 39:26eye because they didn't think you knew what you
- 39:29were doing. And if I made a finding that the
- 39:34allegations were false, which happened, not often,
- 39:38but happened. there would be severe consequences.
- 39:41I strongly would consider removing that child
- 39:44and placing it in a third party or do something
- 39:47and limit the accuser's access to the child to
- 39:52make appropriate what I call probationary orders,
- 39:55although this is not a criminal matter. If I
- 39:59made a finding that there is a danger to the
- 40:03children as a result of substance abuse, I'm
- 40:08going to make certain orders, and I'm going to
- 40:12move slowly. I don't want to make any quick orders
- 40:18or orders that I think are not appropriate given
- 40:23the circumstances of the parties, the kids, and
- 40:26so forth. If you haven't seen the kid in a long
- 40:29time, I'm not going to order on supervisivistation.
- 40:33We're going to talk about that in a little bit.
- 40:39I'm going to move cautiously. And frankly, and
- 40:42I think that judges feel this way, there's something
- 40:45in the back of our minds where we don't want
- 40:47to see our names on a newspaper article in which
- 40:50a child was hurt because we made orders and they
- 40:53became injured. You know, fortunately that never
- 40:56happened to me. I was very lucky about that,
- 41:01but I would move cautiously. I would... set regular
- 41:08review hearings. Most judges won't do that. I
- 41:12wanted to provide them a path to a normalization
- 41:17of her relationship with the kids. And I would
- 41:22make orders depending on the case and very, very
- 41:27tremendously. I would order substance abuse program
- 41:31that either inpatient or outpatient, whatever
- 41:35the attorneys were able to provide to me. And
- 41:39it would be, I want information as to the program.
- 41:42I don't like video. There's a group dynamic that
- 41:47is really important. So I think the in -person
- 41:51programs are the best. I had one person came
- 41:55in at an evidentiary hearing and provided me
- 41:59documentation of the program, which I thought
- 42:01was really good, even put her counselor on it.
- 42:04As soon as the counselor, I asked the counselor,
- 42:07what is the goal of the program? She said, it
- 42:11is to reduce or have reduction of this substance
- 42:15abuse. I go, really? No sobriety? No, we're not
- 42:19going to do that. Well, how do you do your testing?
- 42:22Well, we send them a kit and they provide a urine
- 42:26sample and then they come back to the camera
- 42:28and show us the sample. because there's a temperature
- 42:32gauge and there's various testing on the container
- 42:39itself. I go, well, how do you know it's her
- 42:41urine? Well, we don't, we just assume. She's
- 42:44telling me, I mean, this is a substance abuser
- 42:47that I've been dealing with for years and I found
- 42:51that the program was not sufficient. So provide
- 42:56information for your client as to a decent program.
- 42:59I may continue supervised visitation of some
- 43:02type. If things are decent, I may just order
- 43:06supervised exchanges in a public place. For some
- 43:10reason, I kept on picking McDonald's. And depending
- 43:14on the age of the kids, I would not have them
- 43:16leave the car. So it was just an exchange, a
- 43:21quick exchange, but it would depend on the case.
- 43:25It's hard to do that with young kids. I would
- 43:30order AA meetings or some type of substance abuse
- 43:34group meeting. It's important. It gives the parties
- 43:38a safe place to talk, to see what they're going
- 43:43through, what the people around them have recommended.
- 43:47The group dynamic is just such an important part
- 43:50of getting sober and addressing the situation.
- 43:55The meetings are all over the place. They're
- 43:58free. and easy to get to, generally speaking.
- 44:03That would be an important part of what I call
- 44:06my probationary terms. I may continue the counseling,
- 44:09it just depends what shakes out from the hearings.
- 44:17At the review hearings, by then they're probably
- 44:22representing themselves. Usually, They're showing
- 44:28me documentation of what I've ordered. I need
- 44:31to make sure it's credible. It's detailed. It
- 44:35gives me some information as to where they are
- 44:39in their program, either their counseling or
- 44:42substance abuse program. If they give me something
- 44:44that checks the box, I send another review hearing
- 44:48and... have them come back with something decent.
- 44:54I need to make sure that they're making concerted
- 44:57efforts to change the people to hang around,
- 45:01where they lived, and various things. I love
- 45:04when they tell me, we moved, I'm in a different
- 45:07area, here's my new job, I'm doing really well.
- 45:14I tended, as Ashley will tell you, is to talk
- 45:17to people. Maybe that's not a good thing or not,
- 45:24but because I was dealing with them on a regular
- 45:27basis, usually you could see a substantial change
- 45:31in their behavior. I'm not Satan anymore. They're
- 45:36not looking at me with the desk there. They look
- 45:39good. Their physical appearance has changed.
- 45:44When I ask questions, so got any tokens and they
- 45:48respond quickly and concisely, Tell me about
- 45:52your job, how the kids are doing. You can see
- 45:56a visible change. And that is helpful. Especially
- 46:01when there's a modification motion being made.
- 46:04After a full -blown evidentiary hearing, I usually
- 46:07make Montenegro orders. Montenegro versus Diaz.
- 46:12For me to change the orders that I made at the
- 46:14evidentiary hearing. I need a significant change
- 46:18of circumstances. Otherwise, it's still best
- 46:20interest. I don't think of a time that I did
- 46:24not make a Montenegro order after a substantial
- 46:27hearing. Then we deal with the modifications
- 46:31because they're going to come back. As I said,
- 46:36I see them on my calendar that I pre -read ago.
- 46:39Here we go. Hopefully, they're doing okay. I'd
- 46:43look at this information. And if it's credible
- 46:46that I've seen a change, then I am inclined to
- 46:52modify the order based on the information. It's
- 46:56going to go slowly, like I told them. But whether
- 47:00it's lifting the supervision, increasing the
- 47:03time for unsupervised solicitation, maybe supervision
- 47:06not overnight. It just depends on the case. Sometimes,
- 47:15believe it or not, and it happened rarely, but
- 47:17the parties would call me up and said they've
- 47:19reached a stipulation. They don't need me anymore,
- 47:23which made me a very happy judge because trying
- 47:26to make these decisions, you know, I didn't want
- 47:28to wake up at night in the middle of the night
- 47:30wondering whether I did okay with these kids,
- 47:33you know, whether it's going to be in the newspaper
- 47:35the next day. For the attorneys, if you're still
- 47:41on the case, You've heard what I said, providing
- 47:45credible information as to where your clients
- 47:48are. Keep their expectations reasonable. It's
- 47:54hard for me because I'm gonna make orders that
- 47:57they did not anticipate based on what you've
- 48:01told them and then they're gonna look at me as
- 48:03Satan or they're gonna look at you and say, how?
- 48:06Good on you. Why didn't you anticipate? Judge
- 48:09Pawasik, we know, you know, this was easily anticipated.
- 48:15And the best thing, after the evidence hearing,
- 48:19I don't want to hear the following. Well, I hear
- 48:22it, but I'm not going to give it a whole lot
- 48:24of credibility and you're going to get the death
- 48:26stare from me. If I'm still on the bench, I forgot.
- 48:31Do not say that's not fair. I had to make a call
- 48:36on what I was given. And if you disagree, there's
- 48:41the appellate process, there's motions for reconsiderations,
- 48:45but if I put a lot of time in it, so that was
- 48:49not something I was happy to hear. The reason
- 48:55I asked Ashley here, because I think she could
- 48:58provide a human perspective on the substance
- 49:02abuse on the programs, where she was, where she
- 49:06came from, where she is now. She will hopefully
- 49:11tell you about the stink eye she used to give
- 49:13me in the beginning when she got in drug court.
- 49:16But Ashley, why don't you talk to everybody?
- 49:22Thank you. I want to thank the Beverly Hills
- 49:25Bar Association for the opportunity and thank
- 49:27you, Your Honor, for allowing me to come and
- 49:30present. Thank you to everybody in attendance.
- 49:33As the Honorable Harry Pawlasek mentioned, I
- 49:37was in drug court. So I can't speak to the family
- 49:40law side of things, but I can speak to the substance
- 49:42abuse disorder and drug court. And in true drug
- 49:46court fashion, I'd like to say that I have 5
- 49:48,012 days clean and sober today. So that's a
- 49:52little under 14 years. My name is Ashley Gerto,
- 49:57and as you can imagine, being a participant of
- 50:00drug court, I had a substance abuse disorder.
- 50:02I think it, through my years of education and
- 50:06coming to know myself and digging deep and learning
- 50:09about why I chose some of the things that I chose,
- 50:13it stems from familial issues. And so I was abused
- 50:16as a child. My parents were teenage addicts when
- 50:19they had me. They went in and out of the criminal
- 50:21justice system themselves. You know, I moved
- 50:25around a lot. I was in poverty my whole life.
- 50:28And at the age of 15, I thought that I was old
- 50:31enough and grown enough to run away to escape
- 50:33some of that abuse. And that quickly fast forwarded
- 50:37my substance abuse disorder, my introduction
- 50:40to the criminal justice system. And that was
- 50:44a good 10 years of my life. I'm probably an anonymous,
- 50:49what do you call it? Anonymous? I can't say it.
- 50:51I'm probably like one of the only people who
- 50:53asked for drug court. Usually you're mandated
- 50:57to drug court, but I had had a glimpse of sobriety
- 51:00in my life in the past when I was a teenager.
- 51:03And so I knew that there was a better way of
- 51:04life. I had heard of drug court before and I
- 51:07was at the point of desperation where I wanted
- 51:11to do something. differently, but it was really
- 51:14hard for me to get away from the lifestyle. It
- 51:16was hard for me because I had never been taught
- 51:18emotional intelligence or emotional regulation,
- 51:21how to identify my feelings, how to unpack the
- 51:25trauma that I had experienced. And so the best
- 51:28that I knew to do was to numb it with drugs and
- 51:30alcohol. I still see my face on the screen. So
- 51:34I much rather look at. Harry, because I feel
- 51:37like I'm talking to somebody and not just myself,
- 51:40but I don't know how the webinar host wanted
- 51:42to be. So yeah, so I asked for drug court. I
- 51:47would like to say that he said it's a minimum
- 51:5018 -month program. I did complete it in 19 months.
- 51:53However, the first few months were really hard
- 51:56for me. I'm taking away the substances, taking
- 52:00away the the people that I used to surround myself
- 52:03with, I still had a lot of the criminogenic thinking
- 52:07errors. And that's kind of why drug court was
- 52:10able to help me learn how to process, how to
- 52:13make better judgment in decisions, how to not
- 52:18always be thinking about how I can manipulate
- 52:20myself out of a situation. I did. I was sanctioned
- 52:25and so in drug court if you're not obeying the
- 52:28rules you have to do a weekend in jail and so
- 52:31that's why I would give the Stank Eye because
- 52:33I did do three sanctions and You know, it was
- 52:37not until the third one that I was able to identify
- 52:40it was my own actions and my own inability to
- 52:43take responsibility for those actions that was
- 52:45causing me to have to go turn myself into jail
- 52:47every weekend. And so on that third sanction
- 52:50is when I made the decision that I was truly
- 52:52gonna give my life a second chance and I was
- 52:55gonna do all of the program requirements without
- 52:58cheating or manipulating the system. I did not
- 53:00relapse. but I was just making four decisions.
- 53:06But drug court literally changed my life and
- 53:07I'm forever grateful. They forced me to get a
- 53:11job and so I found a job and I quickly advanced.
- 53:15I was promoted three times in my first 90 days
- 53:18probation period. But all of that attributing
- 53:21to learning how to hold myself accountable, learning
- 53:23how to be dependable, how to show up on time,
- 53:25how to do a good job, I had never been exposed
- 53:29to those things before. um I did graduate drug
- 53:34court in 19 months and you know when when the
- 53:37Honorable Judge Harry Kwasik was talking about
- 53:39the counselors all of the counselors had personal
- 53:41lived experience going through recovery themselves
- 53:44and so being able to see myself within um the
- 53:48people who were help guiding me through learning
- 53:52how to change my life was paramount um my counselor
- 53:55was a female and she was the first female that
- 53:57I ever learned how to trust because everybody
- 53:59else in my life had harmed me in one way and
- 54:01therefore I learned how to be a trustworthy person.
- 54:08I did go to NA meetings. I was a part of our
- 54:12program requirements was to attend meetings and
- 54:14that also changed my life. I'm still active in
- 54:17Narcotics Anonymous. Almost 14 years later, I
- 54:19still work steps. I don't currently sponsor women,
- 54:22but I have. I'm still very close to my sponsor
- 54:24and my sponsor sisters. And going back to that
- 54:28community was vital for me, because there's a
- 54:32cliche saying that says, you know, that we have
- 54:34to get rid of old people, places and things.
- 54:36And that was so true for me. When I held on to
- 54:39a couple people who were still living, you know,
- 54:42a dirty lifestyle, I would still be caught up
- 54:45in those, like I said, those thinking errors.
- 54:50So it's a little bit about my journey. I know
- 54:53I want to be mindful of So I'll kind of tell
- 54:56you where I'm at today and how I got there. Again,
- 54:59I attribute so much of my success to drug court,
- 55:02to you Judge P, you know, for not just looking
- 55:06at me as a number on a file that's on your desk,
- 55:08but I'm going to get emotional. But for humanizing
- 55:11me, you know, and for seeing the potential and
- 55:14the worth. I am grateful and privileged to say
- 55:19that I had three children in recovery and so
- 55:22they have not had to experience me on drugs or
- 55:25on alcohol. Hopefully they never have to go through
- 55:29family law court. The job that I had mentioned
- 55:33before that I quickly advanced through it taught
- 55:36me so much but it wasn't enough as a family of
- 55:38five in Southern California so I put myself school.
- 55:43I dropped out in 10th grade. I don't remember
- 55:45attending 10th grade so really I had like an
- 55:47eighth or a ninth grade education. I currently
- 55:50have a master's degree in sociology and on October
- 55:541st I'm applying for a doctoral degree. While
- 55:57I was going to school, I had such a passion for
- 56:01learning and I wanted to help everyone around
- 56:05me get an education because it's really hard
- 56:08when you come from this population to have an
- 56:10affordable living wage with really no education.
- 56:15And so I started the program that they mentioned
- 56:17in my bio. I started a program at Maracosta College
- 56:19in Oceanside, California that supports justice
- 56:21impacted individuals, creating equitable access
- 56:25for higher education. And from that has just
- 56:28opened a whole new world of possibilities for
- 56:30me because I've been able to help hundreds of
- 56:32people who come from similar backgrounds that
- 56:34I do, struggling with substance abuse disorder,
- 56:37with homelessness, multiple incarcerations, criminal
- 56:40backgrounds that make it really hard to get into
- 56:42the workforce to help them obtain degrees and
- 56:45make livable wages. It not only changes their
- 56:48lives, but it changes their family's lives, future
- 56:50generations, their communities. And so it's really,
- 56:53really important work for me. I did run that
- 56:56program for four years. I helped many of my former
- 57:00drug court participants go through it as well,
- 57:03getting AA degrees, bachelor's degrees, master's
- 57:05degrees. And currently I have been promoted.
- 57:11And so instead of working for one campus, I now
- 57:13work for the statewide initiative where I'm working
- 57:16to support the practitioners that are helping
- 57:18the students who are either currently incarcerated
- 57:20incarcerated or formerly incarcerated, helping
- 57:23them to obtain a higher education as well. But
- 57:27I really do, you know, It's a little bit redundant,
- 57:30but I do attribute this to what I learned in
- 57:32drug court. Having to go through those groups,
- 57:36having to go to court. We didn't just show up
- 57:39to court. We had to dress up for court. We went
- 57:41there weekly. And then as we phased up, we would
- 57:43go monthly or biweekly. I forget what it was.
- 57:46But often, we had to meet. And the team worked
- 57:49as a team. So I had never experienced. I was
- 57:52always a defendant in court. And it was the judge
- 57:55and the DA and then me. And it's like, were against
- 57:58each other, but in drug court, it was a team.
- 58:02And really looking at what's in the best interest
- 58:05of the client and what's going to propel them
- 58:07in their future. And there were, unfortunately
- 58:10in my case, there were consequences for my actions,
- 58:13but I learned from them. Like Judge P had said,
- 58:20I'm sorry, I'm really informal, but that's Judge
- 58:22P to me. Like he had said before, you know, when
- 58:26a person as clean and doing well, there usually
- 58:30are patterns. I'm sure that can't be used as
- 58:32like evidence in court or whatnot, but there
- 58:34are usually patterns. People usually start showing
- 58:36up on time. They usually start holding themselves
- 58:38accountable and they, you know, whatever things
- 58:41that are mandated of them, they're getting done.
- 58:43And like he had mentioned, they're starting to
- 58:45present better. They look healthy, you know?
- 58:47So there are things that, you know, for a person
- 58:51like me, boosted my self -esteem and made me
- 58:53feel valuable and worthy in life. I'm not sure,
- 58:58I know it's 1 .30, so I'm not sure how much more
- 59:01time we have. Or if there's questions particularly,
- 59:04I know that I think most of you are in family
- 59:07court and so I can't really speak to that aspect
- 59:10of it, but 10 years substance abuse disorder
- 59:14and 14 years clean, I've got a lot of lived experience
- 59:16and I'm happy to answer any questions. I'm again,
- 59:19just really grateful for the opportunity to come
- 59:21and share a little bit about my story and thank
- 59:24you again. What I just want to point out other
- 59:29than I'm really proud of Ashley and most of my
- 59:34graduates is the community. The sober community
- 59:38is probably the biggest thing that helps them.
- 59:43You got the counseling, but if they don't feel
- 59:45safe and a place to talk and a place to go to
- 59:49and people they could go to the beach with, you
- 59:52know, you're talking about changing an entire
- 59:54lifestyle and trying to get some of the family
- 59:58court people who come before me to, or who came
- 1:00:02before me, there I go again, to understand that
- 1:00:05without preaching to them, which I cannot do
- 1:00:09from the bench. It is a difficult thing. That's
- 1:00:11what you have to do as attorneys to get them
- 1:00:15into these programs that provide this type of
- 1:00:19support so they feel comfortable and are able
- 1:00:22to. reunite with their families, their kids,
- 1:00:26and not worry about a police car behind them
- 1:00:29because they got pulled over. Daniel, is there
- 1:00:33anything else, Suzanne? We did actually have
- 1:00:38two questions, primarily for you, Judge Pawasek.
- 1:00:45One of the questions is from... Nikki Brown asking,
- 1:00:50what kind of evidence would you look for that
- 1:00:52a parent has a substance abuse problem that can
- 1:00:55or does affect their ability to care for the
- 1:00:57children to support an order to drug counseling,
- 1:01:00assessment, supervision, et cetera? Great question.
- 1:01:04And it's a variety of things, whether they've
- 1:01:07lost their job, you know, whether they're living
- 1:01:10with their parents now, something that shows
- 1:01:15a substantial concern regarding their behavior
- 1:01:18and their ability to parent. Like I said, it's
- 1:01:23always nice to get a police report, that type
- 1:01:27of thing, pictures of them utilizing the illegal
- 1:01:32drugs, that type of thing. But it's not an x
- 1:01:35-ray. It's hard to tell. That's what the evaluation
- 1:01:38and the substance abuse assessment can provide,
- 1:01:41some type of credible information. But I would
- 1:01:44look for some real documentation showing that
- 1:01:49the persons people place in things is not good
- 1:01:52and they're going downhill. All right. Thank
- 1:01:58you. And then it looks like we have another from
- 1:02:00Alexander. Verducci, what process do you use
- 1:02:05in trying to match the appointment of Minors
- 1:02:08Council to a difficult case where neither party
- 1:02:12is represented by council? Yeah, Mr. Verducci
- 1:02:16should know this because he was Minors Council
- 1:02:19in front of me. What I'm supposed to do is sort
- 1:02:22of list and pick the next person on the list.
- 1:02:26Not that I'm off the bench. I could tell the
- 1:02:28truth. There were certain minors councils that
- 1:02:31were incredibly effective, incredibly dedicated,
- 1:02:35and somehow they got appointed to certain cases.
- 1:02:43Mr. Reducci was one of them. Okay, and then Rachel
- 1:02:50James asks, how do you deal with cases where
- 1:02:53one party denies substance abuse when you don't
- 1:02:55have a DUI or any criminal involvement? Great
- 1:03:01question. I don't know. That's why when they
- 1:03:05come in on an ex -party basis, I am looking for
- 1:03:09some credible information. If it's just a declaration
- 1:03:13and says something, well, I fear for my kid's
- 1:03:16safety because I think he's using or that type
- 1:03:20of thing, it's a problem. I could order some
- 1:03:24quick drug testing, maybe even hair follicle
- 1:03:29testing if the parties agree. But other than
- 1:03:32that, it becomes what I feel is appropriate or
- 1:03:37not, if that makes sense. I would need some credible
- 1:03:41information, hopefully contained in the declaration
- 1:03:44or some pictures, videos, police reports, something,
- 1:03:48family members. or friends who say, I was at
- 1:03:52this restaurant, he was blasted, and he drove
- 1:03:57away that type of thing. Any information that
- 1:04:01could be produced that shows that the children
- 1:04:05are at risk. All right. It looks like we have
- 1:04:11one last question from Robin Wood. Does a client
- 1:04:14need to have a criminal case in order to get
- 1:04:17into drug court? Yes. Oh, no, it needs to be
- 1:04:22a criminal case. Yeah, yeah. And drug court,
- 1:04:27so everybody understands, has changed tremendously
- 1:04:30since I was there. There are a number of legislative
- 1:04:35changes that I won't get into because I'll turn
- 1:04:38into a cranky old man because I had problems
- 1:04:41with him. But there are other programs around
- 1:04:46that through various charitable institutions.
- 1:04:52You got Brother Benos, depending how it is, you
- 1:04:55have a number of charities out there that will
- 1:05:00help. Salvation Army is a decent program. We
- 1:05:04used to send people there initially so they could
- 1:05:08remain in the program. People understand also,
- 1:05:14and Ashley mentioned that. If you because she
- 1:05:17went to jail a couple of times we I did not like
- 1:05:20terminating people from our program. Ashley will
- 1:05:23tell you we took in all sorts of people. There's
- 1:05:27limitations regarding violence and so forth that
- 1:05:30I would not take in the program. But they remained
- 1:05:34in the program unless they did something really
- 1:05:37dangerous. and hurt the program. I had one person
- 1:05:41who didn't have a license, drove, got drunk,
- 1:05:44went through a police, almost killed him. He
- 1:05:47was out of the program. But that was very rare.
- 1:05:51We kept people in our program as much as possible.
- 1:05:55But check the various Salvation Army, Brother
- 1:05:58Benos, if you're in San Diego. They provide a
- 1:06:02decent place to stay and a program. Great, thank
- 1:06:10you. So that's it for questions today. Yeah,
- 1:06:13so it looks like that's it for questions today.
- 1:06:15Thank you so much, Judge Pawlasek and Ashley
- 1:06:18Gerdo for your time. And thank you so much to
- 1:06:21our audience for joining us today. Have a great
- 1:06:23afternoon, everybody. Ashley, stay well. Thank
- 1:06:29you. You as well. Thank you all for your time
- 1:06:32and the opportunity. I appreciate you. Bye bye.