Latest / The FVS Valuation Podcast / Building More Defensible Valuation Reports
Transcript
- 0:03Alicia Ross: While your valuation reports
- 0:05may contain all the required sections,
- 0:08how well are you
- 0:10connecting the analysis to the conclusion?
- 0:14Welcome to the FVS Valuation podcast.
- 0:17I'm Alicia Ross with
- 0:19the AICPA's Forensic and Valuation Services Team.
- 0:23In this episode, Bethany Hearne and
- 0:26Dr. Victor Jarosiewicz
- 0:28examine what makes evaluation report
- 0:31clear, defensible, and effective.
- 0:35You'll gain practical ways to strengthen reports,
- 0:38clarify analysis, and make
- 0:41your conclusions more useful to their intended readers.
- 0:45I'm also excited to share that our podcast is meeting
- 0:49a need growing by over 200% last month.
- 0:53Thanks for joining us and have a great listen.
- 0:58Nene Gianfala: Thank you, Alicia,
- 0:59for that introduction. Hi, everyone.
- 1:01My name is Nene Glenn Gianfala,
- 1:03and I'm a member of the FVS Pod Squad,
- 1:06and I work with Chaffe and Associates in New Orleans.
- 1:08I'm glad to be back today with two great guests.
- 1:11We have Dr. J and Bethany,
- 1:13who will be talking us today about beyond the numbers,
- 1:16writing better valuation reports.
- 1:18I always like to let my guests introduce themselves.
- 1:21Ladies first, Bethany, why
- 1:23don't you tell our listeners
- 1:24a little bit about yourself?
- 1:25I know you're no stranger to the AICPA podcasts.
- 1:28Bethany Hearne: Thank you, Nene.
- 1:30Victor "Dr. J": As Nene said, I'm Bethany Hearne.
- 1:33Bethany Hearne: I'm a partner at MH CPA,
- 1:35which is a small firm located in Central Illinois.
- 1:39I've been working in
- 1:40the valuation space for over 25 years,
- 1:44I really love teaching others about valuations,
- 1:48and I have the privilege of getting to teach
- 1:50the AICPA Business Valuation School,
- 1:53which is coming up soon.
- 1:55Nene Gianfala: Dr. J is a long-time listener
- 1:57but first time participant, is that right?
- 1:59Victor "Dr. J": That's right.
- 2:00I'm a visiting assistant professor
- 2:02at Georgia State University,
- 2:03have been for the past couple of years.
- 2:05My full name is Victor Jarosiewicz, but of course,
- 2:09my students can't say that or spell that very well,
- 2:11so I just tell them, call me Dr. J,
- 2:13and I've taken a liking to it.
- 2:15I've been a professor at several universities.
- 2:17But I've been in business valuations since late 2000.
- 2:21Twenty-six years in accounting now.
- 2:24I've taught business valuations for ASA,
- 2:28and I have been a long-time listener, as you say,
- 2:33and so I actually teach, I've created,
- 2:36and I teach a business valuation class
- 2:38at Georgia State University.
- 2:39I emphasize valuation standards and what's expected.
- 2:44Then I focus on several things,
- 2:46including how should they create their reports.
- 2:50Nene Gianfala: Today's podcast is
- 2:51really designed for beginners,
- 2:53and also, longtime people in our profession.
- 2:56We're going to have some good tips for you
- 2:57as well, so still keep listening.
- 2:59Don't hang up. To start off,
- 3:02I think it's really important to
- 3:03start with the foundations.
- 3:04Bethany, why don't you tell me a little bit about
- 3:07what are the relevant standards
- 3:09or best practices that people
- 3:11should take into consideration
- 3:12when they're either writing
- 3:14evaluation report or if
- 3:15they're trying to review a peer's report.
- 3:18Bethany Hearne: Absolutely. All of
- 3:21our evaluation work needs to
- 3:22comply with relevant standards.
- 3:24For me, being a CPA ABV,
- 3:27I need to comply with the standards issued by the AICPA.
- 3:31Now, we always think about that.
- 3:33It's SSVS.
- 3:35But it's not just SSVS.
- 3:38We also have to comply with all of
- 3:40the other rules and requirements issued by the AICPA,
- 3:43including the Code of Professional Conduct.
- 3:45I just don't want people to think that,
- 3:48well, I just need to look at SSVS and I'm good.
- 3:51You really need to look at all of
- 3:53the requirements under the AICPA,
- 3:55make sure you're following those.
- 3:57Now, in addition to SSVS,
- 4:01valuator should also comply with
- 4:04uniform standards of professional appraisal practice,
- 4:08even if your credential doesn't specifically require it.
- 4:11The Appraisal Standards Board promulgates
- 4:16USPAP for appraisers and users of appraisal services.
- 4:21The Ethics rule in USPAP states,
- 4:25an individual should comply anytime that individual
- 4:29represents that he or she
- 4:31is performing the service as an appraiser.
- 4:35Even if you're not an ASA,
- 4:38you still should be looking
- 4:40at USPAP and making sure your reports
- 4:43are compliant with USPAP
- 4:45as well as any other standards you should use.
- 4:48Nene Gianfala: If we have listeners who are not in the US,
- 4:51but international,
- 4:52what standard should they be reviewing?
- 4:54Bethany Hearne: Well, they should be looking at
- 4:55the international valuation standards.
- 4:58The international business valuation standards.
- 5:02Victor "Dr. J": I'll jump in on that. Yeah,
- 5:04so IVSC, they promote international valuation standards.
- 5:09That's what Bethany is talking about
- 5:11and then yeah, USPAP,
- 5:13it's interesting because USPAP
- 5:15is from the Appraisal Foundation,
- 5:17and it is required of sponsoring organizations,
- 5:22it's strongly recommended for everybody.
- 5:25For federal transactions, it's considered a requirement.
- 5:28If you do gift and estate valuations,
- 5:32for example, then for IRS purposes, it's expected.
- 5:36Nene Gianfala: I know also the standards can
- 5:38change based on the purpose of the valuation,
- 5:40whether or not, Dr. J Is tending
- 5:42that sating gift versus litigation.
- 5:44There might be some different standards for that.
- 5:46Again, just be aware of
- 5:48all the various standards out there and make
- 5:50sure you're adhering to the proper ones for
- 5:51your assignment based on its scope and purpose.
- 5:53Bethany Hearne: Nene, you mentioned litigation.
- 5:55Just want to throw it out there
- 5:57for those that are in that space
- 5:59that are the forensic standards by the AICPA.
- 6:04You want to make sure that
- 6:05you're looking at those as well.
- 6:06Nene Gianfala: Great point.
- 6:07There's lots of resources that highlight
- 6:09the various standards under
- 6:11each purpose on the AICPA's website,
- 6:13and we'll have a link to those tools for
- 6:15you and show notes.
- 6:17With that, let's get into the nitty gritty for
- 6:20valuation reports and talk about
- 6:22our biggest pet peeves that
- 6:23you see in valuation reports.
- 6:25This time, I'll start off with you, Dr. J.
- 6:28Victor "Dr. J": Pet peeves. Oh, my gosh.
- 6:30Bethany and I, we've talked about this a few times now.
- 6:33I joke about valuation reports
- 6:36where there's the two halves.
- 6:38There's the front part of the report,
- 6:40and then all of the magic happens in the last 3-5 pages.
- 6:44That's what it feels like that
- 6:46because folks tend to
- 6:49be slavish about following standards,
- 6:51they will check all the boxes,
- 6:52the description of the company,
- 6:54its history and the economy and the industry,
- 6:56and you name it, and it's all of this content upfront.
- 7:00Then in the last 3-5 pages,
- 7:02by the way, here's how I did my income approach,
- 7:04whether I capitalized or I did DCF,
- 7:06here's of my market approach, and,
- 7:08of course, I'm not going to use public companies
- 7:10they're too big and whatever excuses you want to use.
- 7:12Here's some transactions. No,
- 7:14those aren't very good either. Bam, there you go.
- 7:16I like to joke that it's like The Frugal Gourmet,
- 7:20which was this TV show on PBS when I was a kid,
- 7:23where the chef would talk about
- 7:25all the ingredients that have to go into this dish,
- 7:28and then he would just take the tray and put it down
- 7:30underneath into one oven and out of the other oven,
- 7:32pull out the finished product and go, "See?
- 7:34Here's what it looks like."
- 7:35You go, wait, I missed something there.
- 7:37That is one of my biggest pet peeves is the disconnect.
- 7:41We're not supposed to just put things in
- 7:43reports because the checklist tells us to do so.
- 7:45The standards have a checklist
- 7:47of things that we need to put in there.
- 7:48They have a bearing on the valuation indications,
- 7:53and the conclusion, make it clear so that they connect.
- 7:57Don't put your brain on yourself.
- 7:58Don't just go, I've talked about the industry,
- 8:01and I've talked about competitors, and I'm done.
- 8:03Now, let me just go on and do
- 8:04Cap of earnings or whatever
- 8:06it is that you're going to do.
- 8:07Explain to the reader,
- 8:09the intended users how those matter.
- 8:14If they don't matter, why are you
- 8:16wasting 10, 20 pages on them?
- 8:17That's one of my biggest pet peeves.
- 8:19How about you, Bethany?
- 8:21Bethany Hearne: Well, you talked about connection
- 8:23and I call it the missing link.
- 8:26That's my biggest pet peeve.
- 8:28The missing link is where you have
- 8:31this beautiful write up of the company and it's
- 8:34just wonderful and then you have your analysis.
- 8:37But the reader gets to the analysis and they're like,
- 8:39"Wait a second. That doesn't make sense."
- 8:42The best example is I was valuing a company,
- 8:45it was a manufacturing company and
- 8:48they've been growing very quickly.
- 8:51They had pretty high growth for the last five years.
- 8:55Reading the report, I would have
- 8:58expected a discounted cash flow methodology to be used,
- 9:02but a capitalized cash flow methodology was used.
- 9:05The question is why?
- 9:07Well, what wasn't in the report,
- 9:09that missing link was
- 9:11that the company had reached capacity.
- 9:14They couldn't grow anymore unless they built
- 9:18a new plant or bought a new plant
- 9:20and although they'd talked about that,
- 9:22it was cost prohibitive and
- 9:24Nene Gianfala: they were not going to do it.
- 9:26Bethany Hearne: In that case, a capitalized cash flow made sense.
- 9:31It's just that link needed to be there
- 9:34between what the company was doing and had been doing,
- 9:37and what the future expectations
- 9:39were that they were at capacity,
- 9:41wouldn't be growing at that high rate anymore.
- 9:44Then it makes sense.
- 9:46That's my biggest pet peeve, missing links.
- 9:49Nene Gianfala: I have to admit, I feel
- 9:50like that's a common mistake you see,
- 9:51especially people starting out, where they copy and
- 9:54paste the economy and
- 9:55the industry, and the economy is great.
- 9:57The industry is doing great and it's growing.
- 9:59They write up on the company
- 10:01and make the company sound great.
- 10:02But then you get to the valuation and sales are
- 10:04declining and the values
- 10:05low, and there's a high discount rate.
- 10:07You're like, Wait, what happened?
- 10:08Again, your report needs to mirror your worksheets.
- 10:12Definitely a big pet peeve.
- 10:14Any other pet peeves?
- 10:15Victor "Dr. J": I absolutely agree with Bethany that
- 10:18it's not just what needs to be in the report,
- 10:20but also, what you left out. I agree.
- 10:24I didn't think of it, because I focused so much on
- 10:26the dozens and dozens of pages
- 10:29where clearly you just took a canned report from
- 10:33whatever provider you use for your data,
- 10:36and you put it in because it sounds great.
- 10:39But there's no so what.
- 10:41Actually, when I was managing analysts before the PhD,
- 10:44I would say, "Look, this is great work, but so what?"
- 10:48One, it's got to be in our workpaper so that
- 10:51if we just have a call with a client, there's no report.
- 10:54We're just talking to the client.
- 10:56We've got to be able to say, and
- 10:57here's what that means for you.
- 10:59That's huge. The so what needs to be in there,
- 11:03but also, what you left out.
- 11:06Maybe save some time from all those pages of
- 11:10replicating the background and
- 11:14instead distill it and don't leave out that connection.
- 11:17Definitely, I love that you said that.
- 11:19That is truly an important thing.
- 11:21I go, "Wait, I'm missing something. Where is that?"
- 11:24Nene Gianfala: I feel like another
- 11:27good piece of advice for people,
- 11:30especially starting out, is it get someone who
- 11:32hasn't had their head
- 11:33stuck in the weeds to read their report,
- 11:35because sometimes you know everything.
- 11:37It makes sense to you when you're reading it,
- 11:39but the whole point of evaluation report
- 11:41is so a third party can read it,
- 11:43understand what you did, and get to the same conclusion.
- 11:46Sometimes even to this day,
- 11:48I'll give a report if it's important to appear and say,
- 11:50read this and tell me what you think
- 11:52to make sure you're not missing that because again,
- 11:54sometimes you're so boggled down
- 11:56the assignment to you, it makes sense.
- 11:58But again, if Bethany was to read
- 11:59my report, she'd be like, What's she thinking?
- 12:00It is helpful to use your peers.
- 12:03I think that's a good transition
- 12:06because I feel like some of that work
- 12:07instead of going to your
- 12:08peers is now being filled by AI.
- 12:12How are all seeing AI impact evaluation report?
- 12:17With that, I'll hand it back to Dr. J.
- 12:19Victor "Dr. J": Thanks, Nene. I'm going to bring in
- 12:22my class that I teach again because I've
- 12:24actually flipped it to be AI centric.
- 12:26I want the students
- 12:29who will be future analysts and interns at
- 12:32valuation firms to be thinking about it this
- 12:35way that use this resource as your digital intern,
- 12:39but it's another entity,
- 12:41another thing that mimics human thinking.
- 12:46I say, run your reports through there,
- 12:50run your work papers through there and ask it,
- 12:53What's wrong? What's missing?
- 12:56Because I agree and when we're neck deep in a project,
- 13:00we've got all of the facts and
- 13:02figures floating in our head.
- 13:03Of course, we know them.
- 13:06When we read what we write,
- 13:07we have all of that already there,
- 13:09and so we don't see the gaps in
- 13:12our writing and giving that to a third party,
- 13:16whether it's a peer
- 13:19or whether it's to an AI digital assistant,
- 13:22just say, "Look, pretend you don't know this company.
- 13:25Pretend you don't know this project.
- 13:27What's missing here?"
- 13:29I haven't actually said those words
- 13:32quite that way, but I have said,
- 13:34use it to check to check your work,
- 13:37check your assertions, your assumptions,
- 13:40and your conclusions.
- 13:42That's one way that AI helps.
- 13:45Nene Gianfala: I do feel I need to put
- 13:47a disclaimer here for our listeners.
- 13:48He is not saying upload your valuation report to
- 13:51public ChatGPT or whatever you use.
- 13:56Please be sure to only use
- 13:58your internal closed AI program
- 14:02so that information is protected.
- 14:04Now, I can't promise your clients won't
- 14:06upload their report to AI.
- 14:09Definitely have protections for that, but do not,
- 14:11again, use any public resource for evaluation reports.
- 14:15Use only closed sources for that.
- 14:17Victor "Dr. J": That's perfect.
- 14:19I want to hand it over to Bethany,
- 14:21but I will say perfect example of
- 14:23what's in my head versus what is disclosed.
- 14:26In my class, we talk about confidentiality
- 14:30that we clients don't
- 14:33want any of their information out there,
- 14:35so you have to make sure that
- 14:36whatever system you use doesn't train,
- 14:39doesn't share, all of
- 14:40the privacy settings are set to maximum.
- 14:43You're absolutely right. No, that
- 14:48would be a career ending mistake.
- 14:50But Bethany I'm curious your perspective.
- 14:53Bethany Hearne: Yeah, when asked about using AI,
- 14:55my response is, absolutely, we should be using AI.
- 14:59Now, what using AI with the report can do is it helps
- 15:03the analyst and the reviewer or
- 15:06signer focus at a higher level,
- 15:09the higher-level analysis,
- 15:11the higher-level documentation in the report,
- 15:13and not always the little nitty gritty.
- 15:16What I mean by the nitty gritty,
- 15:17that's on Exhibit B,
- 15:21Footnote 3 references, Exhibit 7 or Exhibit G,
- 15:27it should be Exhibit I.
- 15:29Those little things, AI can catch that.
- 15:32Don't stress about those little, tiny things
- 15:35that you can let AI focus on in a review.
- 15:39But focus makes on your analysis on
- 15:42your bridging gaps in the discussion and how you
- 15:47write about the company so that the reader understands
- 15:50the whole flow of the report and
- 15:53agrees with your conclusion
- 15:54by the time they get to the end.
- 15:55But the other thing I do with AI is I have agent setup,
- 16:00and it's a standards analyzer.
- 16:03I have all the standards in there,
- 16:06I have USPAP, SSVS,
- 16:09I have the forensic standard,
- 16:10I have other standards in there,
- 16:12so that the AI is going to review
- 16:15the report based on
- 16:17those standards, and occasionally, it finds something.
- 16:20It's like, "Hey, you referenced
- 16:23the summary evaluation report,
- 16:25but not a restricted appraisal report."
- 16:28It's like, "Oh, shoot. I forgot the restricted part."
- 16:31It really helps you to identify if
- 16:33you're missing something from a standards perspective.
- 16:36Nene Gianfala: Now, I agree. I think that's great.
- 16:38Our firm has something similar.
- 16:39We have an agent that's developed
- 16:41using standards, and it's great.
- 16:42Again, agents are being developed with
- 16:45different firms as quality control layers,
- 16:48which I think is great, and it's really going to help
- 16:50improve the quality of evaluation reports going forward.
- 16:53The other one I'd
- 16:55mentioned that I've heard from other guests of how
- 16:57they're using AI on their reports is as rebuttal.
- 17:01They ask the AI to read the report and help prepare them
- 17:05a rebuttal report to help prepare them
- 17:08before they go up against someone in litigation.
- 17:10That's another great use that I've heard
- 17:12people use for AI on their valuation reports.
- 17:15Victor "Dr. J": I will say that is actually
- 17:18a really useful thing
- 17:21to turn it into an adversarial reviewer.
- 17:24As an academic, I also do research
- 17:27that's meant to go into peer reviewed academic journals,
- 17:30and I use AI that way to
- 17:32go kick the [inaudible] out of this thing.
- 17:34Tell me what the reviewers are
- 17:37going to throw back at me of your work is bad,
- 17:39this way, this way, this way, this way,
- 17:40and this is why we don't want to publish
- 17:42it so that we can fix it.
- 17:43The same thing, all valuation work
- 17:47has a counterparty that has an adverse interest.
- 17:51It's typically not hostile unless it's truly litigation.
- 17:55But there's always somebody who's
- 17:56going to have a different point of view.
- 17:58Ask your AI, I say,
- 18:01"Hey, what are the weak spots? What are the objections?
- 18:05What do I need to address so
- 18:07that I don't have a blind spot,
- 18:09and I don't get caught blindsided later."
- 18:12Nene Gianfala: I always check them.
- 18:13Victor "Dr. J": Yeah, it makes mistakes all the time.
- 18:15Misses things because it's
- 18:17probabilistic, not deterministic.
- 18:19You, the human are still
- 18:21responsible for that work product for that report,
- 18:23so make sure you're not embarrassed by what you put out.
- 18:27Alicia Ross: Pardon the interruption.
- 18:29If this episode is making you think that you
- 18:32could benefit from hands on training for report writing,
- 18:36please join us at the
- 18:37AICPA's forensic evaluation Services Conference
- 18:42in the DC area on November 4th-6th.
- 18:46The two-hour report writing
- 18:48workshop kicks off the conference,
- 18:51along with two other workshop options,
- 18:54and it is included in the price of attendance.
- 18:57Check out the show notes for more information,
- 19:00and now back to the conversation. Thanks.
- 19:04Nene Gianfala: Going back to our main top
- 19:06of evaluation reports,
- 19:07we've heard a couple of different types
- 19:09of reports while you all have been talking today.
- 19:11Calculation, restricted use, summary, detail.
- 19:14There's a lot of different report layouts out there.
- 19:17Bethany, can you explain to
- 19:19our listeners what they should know about reports
- 19:21when the purposes change
- 19:23when certain reports are appropriate
- 19:25for different purposes like
- 19:26litigation, tax, financial reporting?
- 19:29Bethany Hearne: Absolutely.
- 19:31We'll start with the tax purposes.
- 19:33For estate and gift tax purposes,
- 19:36it's a detailed valuation report is what's required.
- 19:39That's actually in the AICPA
- 19:42Estate and Gift Tax valuation Practice Aid.
- 19:45It says right in
- 19:47there that a detailed report should be used.
- 19:50If you're departing from
- 19:51that and issuing a summary report,
- 19:53you have to be aware that you're not complying
- 19:56with the following what
- 19:58the advice of the practice aid is.
- 20:00In addition, the IRS,
- 20:02they're looking for a comprehensive
- 20:04complete detailed evaluation report,
- 20:07consistent with uniform standards of
- 20:10professional appraisal practice as
- 20:11well as other standards.
- 20:13Make sure that you're providing that detailed report.
- 20:17Now, litigation and financial reporting
- 20:20is a little bit different.
- 20:22Litigation, you have some
- 20:24flexibility on what you can do.
- 20:26Some states, in some jurisdictions,
- 20:29you actually do not have to issue a report.
- 20:31My preference is to
- 20:34issue a report because it
- 20:36helps me in testifying because I
- 20:38have that report there to reference,
- 20:41and it helps makes testifying easier with the report.
- 20:45But I use a summary restricted report
- 20:50because I want to be able
- 20:52to limit some of the information that I put in there.
- 20:57For example, in an estate valuation,
- 20:59I'm going to attach as an appendix,
- 21:02the industry report, the complete industry report,
- 21:05and the complete economic report.
- 21:07Now, those are like, super long,
- 21:09so I don't want to sit there
- 21:12on the witness stand and be cross examined on
- 21:14every single thing in
- 21:16that industry report or economic report.
- 21:21I can respond to all those things.
- 21:23It's a waste of time, and so I don't put it in there.
- 21:27What Dr. J said earlier that so what,
- 21:31what basically do you need?
- 21:34If it's a so what, it doesn't matter,
- 21:36then don't put it in there for litigation because you
- 21:39don't want to cause issues with your cross examination.
- 21:43For the financial reporting,
- 21:47I see even shorter reports.
- 21:51I don't do a lot of financial reporting,
- 21:54but the reports I see are pretty short.
- 21:58They're the summary restricted appraisal reports.
- 22:03I like a little more detail in my litigation reports,
- 22:06but it's really up to the preparer
- 22:08or the signer on what they
- 22:10want in those types of reports.
- 22:12So you just have to make sure that you're following
- 22:15the minimum requirements for
- 22:17whatever type of report you're issuing,
- 22:20and Nene, you mentioned calculation.
- 22:23There is a calculation report in
- 22:26SSVS and there's minimum requirements
- 22:28for that calculation report,
- 22:30and the only time you can issue
- 22:32a calculation report is for calculation engagement.
- 22:35You can't issue a calculation report
- 22:38if it's a full valuation engagement.
- 22:41The distinction is a calculation engagement
- 22:45is like an agreed upon procedure.
- 22:48You agree with the client
- 22:51upfront what you're going to
- 22:53do and what you're not going to do,
- 22:55and that's in your engagement letter,
- 22:57and that's one thing I see missed
- 23:00a lot it's a calculation engagement,
- 23:04but there's nothing defined in the engagement letter.
- 23:06So you have to be very careful.
- 23:08If it's a calculation engagement,
- 23:10you need to document what you agreed upon to do,
- 23:14and then you need to do it and don't do anything else.
- 23:18But yeah, the calculation report
- 23:21is only for a calculation engagement.
- 23:23Nene Gianfala: Then that standards
- 23:25AI agent that Bethany mentioned
- 23:27earlier would be great for this manifest to make
- 23:29sure you have the right thing
- 23:30and the right type of report.
- 23:32So you mentioned you're seeing
- 23:33some shorter reports on the financial reporting side.
- 23:36Victor, what are some trends that you're
- 23:37seeing in reports nowadays?
- 23:40Victor "Dr. J": So actually, I want to touch on
- 23:42the fair value for financial reporting,
- 23:45we have fair value
- 23:46but we have fair value in litigation,
- 23:48which is the state level definitions
- 23:50of does it have discounts or not.
- 23:52Totally different animal from
- 23:54fair value for financial reporting,
- 23:56and what I have been hearing in
- 23:59the fair value for financial reporting space is that
- 24:04ultimately, what's desired is just get
- 24:08to the answer and show
- 24:10me the exhibits that directly support the answer.
- 24:13Everything else is extra,
- 24:14and so it's hard for those to even comply with any
- 24:18of the standards across the valuation organization.
- 24:22So I know that there's talk about that.
- 24:24Where it's going, I don't know.
- 24:26I need to hear more about it.
- 24:29But I do hear that what's
- 24:31practice now is here's a set of slides,
- 24:36a slide deck, and here's some exhibits,
- 24:38and here's what you needed.
- 24:40Here's what you asked,
- 24:41and here's what answers that
- 24:43direct and a lot of things are being left off.
- 24:46They're kept in the work papers,
- 24:47presumably, but those financial reporting,
- 24:50and I think that should line up, Bethany,
- 24:53with what you've been saying that
- 24:54it's really skinning down,
- 24:56and so that's what I've been saying.
- 24:58As far as more traditional gift and estate stuff,
- 25:02I don't have a ton of detail to add there
- 25:06because the standards haven't changed.
- 25:10What I see is a lot of people still leaning on,
- 25:13well, 59 60, which is Revenue Ruling 59 60.
- 25:17It tells me I need to do this,
- 25:19and that's why I need to do it, and the reality is
- 25:22all valuation standards have incorporated those factors,
- 25:26and so we need to put things in our reports
- 25:29because our professional standards require them,
- 25:31and it's a good thing that they line up with 59 60,
- 25:34but 59 60 is not the reason why it has to be there.
- 25:39So I think people are still
- 25:41giving too much weight to 59 60.
- 25:44In fact, I've seen 59 60 use
- 25:46as the reason for reports being the way they are.
- 25:48In every setting, not even gift and estate.
- 25:52So I've seen things for litigation talk
- 25:53about 59 60 and I just shrug at it.
- 25:55I go, "It's got no relevance.
- 25:58What are the state requirements?
- 26:00What are your own professional requirements?"
- 26:03So I think, if anything,
- 26:04that's not necessarily a trend,
- 26:07but a continuation of old practices.
- 26:10This is the way it's always been done,
- 26:12where I would hope by power
- 26:14of suggestion that people go,
- 26:16"No, really the right reason to
- 26:19do this is because we have standards,
- 26:21professional standards that require it,
- 26:23and those dictate what should be in there."
- 26:27Nene Gianfala: And I think that's a good point
- 26:29that you're seeing a lot of people getting thinner
- 26:31on the reports and the moving a bunch
- 26:32of the standard kind of
- 26:33language to an appendix or in the back on the exhibits,
- 26:36and so, Bethany, why don't you tell us a little bit
- 26:38about what at a minimum,
- 26:40needs to be in the report versus the exhibits.
- 26:42You can't just throw
- 26:43everything into the exhibits, right?
- 26:45Bethany Hearne: Well, you have actually
- 26:47really three sections.
- 26:48You have the body of the report,
- 26:50the exhibits, and the appendices.
- 26:53As long as the whole from A to Z,
- 26:57all of that is considered the valuation report,
- 27:01and so you have to look at the
- 27:02standards to make sure you
- 27:03are complying with those
- 27:05and including what needs to be in there.
- 27:07But basically, you're going to
- 27:08include the background of the company,
- 27:10a financial analysis of the company.
- 27:12You're going to include a discussion of
- 27:15the different valuation methods that you
- 27:18considered and why you did one over the other.
- 27:21So if you're excluding a method,
- 27:23you need to explain why you're excluding it.
- 27:25I think Dr. J earlier mentioned the market approach,
- 27:28the transactions, and
- 27:30here's transactions, but we didn't use them.
- 27:32Well, you really need to
- 27:34be able to explain why you didn't
- 27:35use them and support that.
- 27:38So the body of the report,
- 27:41I like to keep clean, and I do like to put
- 27:45the additional details in appendices.
- 27:48For example, cost of capital.
- 27:50I like to put a detailed discussion
- 27:52of what the cost of capital is,
- 27:54what are the inputs to the cost of capital,
- 27:57the definitions, and why they're important.
- 28:00But that's in every report, the same thing.
- 28:05I put that in appendix.
- 28:07What I keep in the body of the report is
- 28:09specific and unique to that company.
- 28:12Anything that's general, I try to put in an appendix.
- 28:17The exhibits to me, are the analysis,
- 28:20but I do want to make sure the footnotes are detailed
- 28:24and so that if somebody
- 28:26pulls an exhibit and they're looking at it,
- 28:29they can understand it,
- 28:31just looking at the exhibit and they don't
- 28:33have to dig through the report to
- 28:35find all of the discussion of normalizing adjustments.
- 28:40I want those in footnotes on the exhibit.
- 28:42I also include them in the report.
- 28:44Now, one thing I've seen is there is
- 28:48differences of opinion on how to
- 28:51incorporate the exhibits in your report,
- 28:53and so you might see
- 28:55a report that here's some information about the company,
- 28:59and then there's an exhibit right there in the report
- 29:02and then more discussion and
- 29:03an exhibit and more discussion and an exhibit,
- 29:06and that's not my preference,
- 29:09just because it's just my style.
- 29:13I put information from the exhibits
- 29:15in the report because it flows,
- 29:17but too much detail in the body of the report I feel can
- 29:21detract from what the analyst is saying in the report.
- 29:25But that's just my opinion.
- 29:26I see a lot of differences.
- 29:28Victor "Dr. J": I'll take it's not necessarily
- 29:31the opposite because I've done it both ways,
- 29:32but I know exactly what you mean that I've seen reports,
- 29:35and I have written and signed reports where it
- 29:38is narrative almost like chapters in a book.
- 29:42Here's the narrative,
- 29:43all the way through the conclusion,
- 29:45and then a separator or divider,
- 29:46and then here are the exhibits, and then after that,
- 29:49limiting conditions assumptions and CB and all
- 29:51of and I've changed blame the PhD,
- 29:56but in academic writing,
- 29:58the exhibits are right in the body
- 29:59because we talk about them in the narrative,
- 30:02and so I've shifted over to that.
- 30:03But I think both work, and in fact,
- 30:07draft manuscripts of academic work
- 30:09tend to say insert Exhibit 1 here,
- 30:12but it ends up in the back of
- 30:13the manuscript until it's published,
- 30:15and when it's published, the exhibit
- 30:16actually gets placed there.
- 30:17Either way, you should be able to track it.
- 30:19So long as the narrative,
- 30:21as you say, ties to the exhibit.
- 30:24That's where AI can help you because as we do this work,
- 30:28we tend to go through at least one draft,
- 30:29sometimes more than one draft,
- 30:31and you'll change the exhibit because we work on
- 30:33the Excel file or whatever tool you're
- 30:35using for the analysis,
- 30:36and then we do the report later,
- 30:38and sometimes we forget to
- 30:40cross check and make sure everything ties,
- 30:41and so if you don't give it to
- 30:44somebody else to look it over and make sure that,
- 30:46"Hey, you said three in Exhibit one,
- 30:48and over here, it's 30 or 35.
- 30:51You want to clean that up
- 30:52or you're AI digital assistant."
- 30:54Either way, make sure that connects one to the other.
- 30:59Nene Gianfala: I always like to ask our guests to give
- 31:01tips and resources for our listeners on
- 31:04how they can improve
- 31:06their business writing skills
- 31:07or improve their valuations reports,
- 31:10and with that, doctor can you talk through resources
- 31:12that you would recommend that our listeners look at?
- 31:15Victor "Dr. J": Sure. So I'll give you two.
- 31:17One is what you're going to
- 31:19see in credentialing classes.
- 31:21So whether it's BB University with
- 31:23Bethany as your instructor or our working session,
- 31:26we're going to talk about the resources
- 31:29that are typically used there.
- 31:31If you come in through a different door,
- 31:33if you have multiple credentials,
- 31:35then you know about ASA's resources.
- 31:38I know that NACAS put out their own resources,
- 31:40but there's going to be example reports,
- 31:42and example language of
- 31:44how to do it right. Definitely read that.
- 31:47The other perspective is,
- 31:49see what's been put out there.
- 31:50By and large, our reports are not in the public domain,
- 31:54except when they become exhibits to SEC filings.
- 31:59So in the class in the valuation class that I teach,
- 32:02I actually have my students read
- 32:05valuation reports that are attached to
- 32:07public SEC filings because those are public domain,
- 32:10and we do the pros and cons.
- 32:12Look at this one.
- 32:13What do you like about it and what's wrong?
- 32:15Feed it into your AI and have your AI point
- 32:18out the flaws and the strengths of each one,
- 32:21and one of the things that we tend to
- 32:24see is that people put in, again, it's too much of
- 32:27the wrong thing and not enough of the right thing.
- 32:30So folks will put in too much of explaining things like,
- 32:33here's the income approach and
- 32:35what are the basic theories of the income approach?
- 32:38And then they'll just jump past,
- 32:40"Oh, by the way, here's my discount rate."
- 32:41Wait, slow down. How did you get there?
- 32:44Walk me through your thinking.
- 32:46You even see that in public reports,
- 32:51and so I will definitely bring those,
- 32:54and we will bring those up in our working session
- 32:56at the conference of Here's free resources.
- 33:00You can look at it and learn from
- 33:02their best practices and learn what not to do,
- 33:05where you look at them and you say,
- 33:06"Hey, there's some limitations, some
- 33:09gaps in here worth looking at."
- 33:11So that's a preview of what's to come at the conference.
- 33:14Bethany Hearne: What I used to do when
- 33:15I first started valuation is
- 33:17I asked the folks I worked with at the firm,
- 33:20what valuation reports can I read?
- 33:21I read a lot of them,
- 33:23and what that helped me
- 33:24to do is it helped me to see take
- 33:27the writing style of others and
- 33:29incorporate that so that when I'm writing,
- 33:32I can mimic the style of pretty much anybody.
- 33:36So if I'm working with Dr. J
- 33:38and he's written part of the report,
- 33:40I know what he wants if
- 33:42I've seen another one of his reports.
- 33:43So I can then mirror
- 33:46that writing style so that when Dr. J gets my report,
- 33:49he's not having to change all of it to fit his style.
- 33:54If you needs to add a paragraph,
- 33:56it's going to fit right in because
- 33:57that writing style was mimicked.
- 34:00But reading valuation reports is really
- 34:02a great way to learn how to write,
- 34:05and the more you read,
- 34:07the better writer you'll be,
- 34:09and you can also read other business publications,
- 34:13the Journal of Accounting,
- 34:14your state CPA Society publication, Wall Street Journal.
- 34:19All of those are going to help you to
- 34:22broaden your knowledge base of writing.
- 34:26One other trick I'm going to throw in there
- 34:29on helping to improve
- 34:31the quality of your valuation report.
- 34:34Dr. J mentioned you have
- 34:36your word report and you have your exhibits,
- 34:38and you have different iterations
- 34:40and you may make changes to
- 34:41your exhibits while you've
- 34:43already written part of the report.
- 34:46I use a program.
- 34:48It's called Macabacus and what it does is it enables
- 34:52you to link your Excel file right to your report,
- 34:55and all you have to do is hit
- 34:57Refresh and all the numbers update.
- 34:59It's just beautiful.
- 35:00Nene Gianfala: That sounds wonderful,
- 35:02and I just want to reiterate.
- 35:03You're so true about
- 35:05reading as many evaluation reports as you can,
- 35:07so you can really understand the writing style.
- 35:09I feel like a lot of people who started
- 35:10on this field struggle with that.
- 35:11Business writing is not the same as creative writing.
- 35:14It's more factual writing,
- 35:16and you should not use adjectives to
- 35:18explain a company's financial statements.
- 35:20They had a beautiful year and they're flourishing,
- 35:23and it's really hard to train people to,
- 35:26like, don't use adjectives.
- 35:27It's only facts. So again,
- 35:28read as many reports as you can,
- 35:30so you can learn that style.
- 35:32Victor "Dr. J": No, look, Nene, actually,
- 35:33what you just said is huge.
- 35:36We should have come to it earlier.
- 35:38Yes, we are hired to give our professional opinion,
- 35:42not our personal opinion,
- 35:43and so, no, don't use adjectives.
- 35:47What a great year or what a terrible year it was.
- 35:51Never mind that you would never think of doing that in
- 35:53litigation because you've been crucified on the stand.
- 35:58But even in a non-direct litigation setting,
- 36:03whether it's ESOP or Fair Value or Gift and Estate, no,
- 36:07that will come from reading
- 36:08other reports that have actually been
- 36:09published or been issued.
- 36:12You'll see that people focus on,
- 36:14here's what is better than the industry,
- 36:17worse than the industry, higher, lower.
- 36:19So comparatives, yes, but adjectives that
- 36:23convey your personal emotions
- 36:25do not belong in any report.
- 36:27Nene Gianfala: That is an excellent point, Dr. J.
- 36:29Again, for our listeners, we have lots of
- 36:31great resources for you in the show notes,
- 36:32so please be sure to check those out.
- 36:34We will have a link for you to BV School,
- 36:36which will involve Bethany coming up and also a link to
- 36:39register for Bethany and Dr. J's upcoming session,
- 36:41which will be on a similar topic to today's podcast,
- 36:45but much longer and more in depth,
- 36:46so definitely check that out as well.
- 36:48Again, huge thank you to Bethany and
- 36:50Dr. J for being on today's episode,
- 36:52please be sure to check out again,
- 36:54the show notes for All those additional resources,
- 36:57and with that, back to you, Alicia.
- 36:59Alicia Ross: It's Alicia with an important
- 37:02announcement for
- 37:03our podcast loving valuation folks who want to
- 37:06keep the discussion going
- 37:07with us once the episodes over.
- 37:10The AICPA has created FVS Engage 365,
- 37:15a community designed for continuing the conversation.
- 37:19Get started at connect.aicpa-cima.com.
- 37:26Members can log in and jump right into the
- 37:29peer-to-peer discussions in the FVS community.
- 37:33Non-members can check out
- 37:35your options on that same page.
- 37:38We'd love to see you there, and as OEs,
- 37:40the details are in the show
- 37:42notes along with links to other great resources.
- 37:46Finally, please click on our survey link and
- 37:49share your thoughts on the podcast. Have a great day.
- 37:58MALE_1: This content is designed to
- 38:00provide illustrative information with respect to
- 38:02the subject matter covered and does not represent
- 38:04an official opinion or position of the AICPA,
- 38:07The Association, or CIMA.
- 38:09It is provided with the understanding that they are not
- 38:12engaged in offering legal accounting
- 38:13or other professional services.
- 38:15If such advice or expert assistance is required,
- 38:18the services of a competent,
- 38:19professional person should be sought.
- 38:21The AICPA, The Association,
- 38:23and CIMA make no representations,
- 38:25warranties, or guarantees as to,
- 38:27and assume no responsibility for
- 38:29the content or application of the material
- 38:32contained herein and especially
- 38:33disclaim all liability for
- 38:35any damages arising out of the use of
- 38:37reference to or reliance on such material.