Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / Why Software IPOs Are Pivoting to Direct Listings
Transcript
- Lucas: So, we talk a lot on this show about the mechanics of going public — the roadshow, the pricing, the pop on day one. But there's this quiet but meaningful shift happening: a growing number of software companies are skipping the traditional IPO entirely and choosing direct listings instead. Luna: And it's not just the high-profile ones like Spotify or Palantir. I'm seeing more mid-cap SaaS companies take that route too. What's driving it? Lucas: A big part is economics. A traditional IPO typically costs a company around 7 percent of the money raised in underwriting fees. For a deal that raises $100 million, that's $7 million going to investment banks. With a direct listing, you skip the underwriters almost entirely — you just need a few advisors and a listing fee. Luna: Right, but the trade-off has always been that without underwriters, there's no price stabilization. Isn't that risky? Lucas: It was, historically. But the data is shifting that perception. A study from the University of Florida looked at all direct listings and traditional IPOs from 2020 through 2025 and found that direct-listed companies traded about 12 percent higher after six months, on average, compared to traditional IPOs. The reason: direct listings avoid the deliberate underpricing that banks use to ensure a first-day pop. Luna: So the 'pop' is essentially money left on the table — money that could have gone to the company instead of first-day buyers. Lucas: Exactly. And it's a lot of money. When Arm Holdings went public in 2023, it raised $4.87 billion, but the banks charged 4.5 percent — that's over $200 million in fees. Then the stock popped 25 percent on day one, meaning the company effectively left another $1.2 billion on the table. Contrast that with Palantir's direct listing in 2020: zero underwriting fees, and no first-day pop because the price was set by the market from the open. Luna: Palantir is an interesting case because it was controversial at the time. People said it wouldn't work for a company with that kind of complexity. But here we are — Palantir's stock is trading at around $136.88 today, up 1.3 percent for this week alone according to our live data. So the market seems fine with it. Lucas: And that's the broader trend. The New York Stock Exchange and Nasdaq have both updated their rules to make direct listings more accommodating. In 2020, the SEC allowed companies to raise primary capital in a direct listing — not just let existing shareholders sell, but actually issue new shares. That removed the biggest objection: that you couldn't raise new money. Luna: So now you can have your cake and eat it too: raise capital, avoid underwriter fees, and let the market set the price transparently. Lucas: Right. And the numbers bear out the demand. The average tech IPO in 2025 raised just $85 million, down from $220 million in 2021. Smaller deals mean the fixed costs of an IPO — the roadshow, the legal work, the SEC filing — become a larger burden. Direct listings are cheaper to execute, so they make sense for smaller companies. Luna: Is there a catch? I mean, what about the institutional investors who provide the research coverage and long-term support? In a traditional IPO, the banks assign analysts who cover the stock. With a direct listing, you don't get that automatic coverage. Lucas: That's a real trade-off. But the market has adapted. Firms like Citadel and Two Sigma have started offering independent research to direct-listed companies. And you're seeing more buy-side analysts cover these stocks because they're trading with full liquidity from day one. The information asymmetry argument is fading. Luna: I also wonder about the retail angle. In a traditional IPO, retail investors often can't get shares at the offering price — they have to buy after the pop. With a direct listing, everyone gets the same opening price. That democratization is a big deal for the average listener who might want to invest in a company they use. Lucas: It's a huge deal. And it's one reason the narrative around direct listings is so positive. The next big test will be Stripe. There's been chatter about Stripe pursuing a direct listing as soon as later this year, potentially at a valuation around $85 billion. If that happens, it would be the largest direct listing ever, and it would cement the model as a mainstream option. Luna: An $85 billion direct listing would be a statement. It would tell every late-stage startup that this is a viable path. Lucas: And it might force the investment banks to rethink their fee structures. If a company like Stripe can save hundreds of millions by going direct, the traditional 7 percent model starts to look pretty fragile. Luna: Quick honest thing — a handful of listeners chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, and that's literally what funds making this many of these episodes. If these conversations are useful for what you're building or running, that link is there. No pressure, just appreciate having the option. Lucas: Yeah, and it keeps us ad-free, which we love. So anyway, back to Stripe — if they do go direct, it will be fascinating to see how the market prices them without a traditional book-building process. Luna: It will also test whether the market can absorb that much supply in a single day. But given the liquidity in tech stocks right now, I think it can. Lucas: Agreed. And that's the story we'll be watching. The direct listing isn't just an alternative anymore — it's becoming the default for a new generation of software companies. Luna: And for investors, it means a fairer shot at getting in on day one. Lucas: Right. So next time you hear about a company going public, ask yourself: are they listing directly, or are they paying the traditional toll? The answer might tell you a lot about their priorities.